Update on Brook Trout Rehabilitation in the Ontario Waters of Lake Superior, Lake Nipigon, and the Nipigon River: Public Workshop Proceedings
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Update on brook trout rehabilitation in the Ontario waters of Lake Superior, Lake Nipigon, and the Nipigon River: Public Workshop Proceedings Upper Great Lakes Management Unit – Lake Superior Technical Report 11-02 (November 2011) AUTHORS Russell Bobrowski1, Marilee Chase1*, Rob Swainson2, Albertine van Ogtrop3, Steve Bobrowicz1, Ken Cullis 1, Mark Sobchuk4 1. Upper Great Lakes Management Unit – Lake Superior, Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources (OMNR), Thunder Bay, ON 2. Nipigon District, OMNR, Nipigon, ON 3. Lake Nipigon Fisheries Assessment Unit, OMNR, Nipigon, ON 4. Northwest Region, OMNR, Thunder Bay, ON * Author to whom correspondence should be addressed: Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources, Upper Great Lakes Management Unit, Lake Superior. 435 James Street South, Suite 221e, Thunder Bay, Ontario, Canada, P7E 6S8 [email protected] Phone: (807) 475-1371 Cover photo credit: Gord Ellis CITATION: Bobrowski, R.J., M. Chase, R. Swainson, A. van Ogtrop, S. Bobrowicz, K. Cullis and M. Sobchuk. 2011. Update on brook trout rehabilitation in the Ontario waters of Lake Superior, Lake Nipigon, and the Nipigon River, Public Workshop Proceedings. Upper Great Lakes Management Unit Technical Report 11-02. Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources, Thunder Bay, ON. 31 pp. plus appendices. Table of Contents Executive Summary......................................................................................................... 1 Background..................................................................................................................... 2 Lake Nipigon Spawning Shoal Surveys ........................................................................... 5 Lake Nipigon and Nipigon River Angler Surveys............................................................ 8 Habitat use and movement patterns of brook trout in Nipigon Bay, Lake Superior .... 11 Movement of brook trout between Lake Superior and Nipigon Bay tributaries .......... 12 Co-operative Brook Trout Angler Program .................................................................. 14 Genetics of Lake Superior Brook Trout......................................................................... 19 Coaster brook trout research in Nipigon Bay and tributary streams ............................ 20 Coaster brook trout management in other jurisdictions............................................... 21 Conclusions................................................................................................................... 25 Recommendations ........................................................................................................ 26 Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................... 28 References .................................................................................................................... 28 Appendix 1 Summary fo Pre-2005 Sport Fishing Regulations...................................... 32 Appendix 2: Workshop – Participant List...................................................................... 33 Appendix 3: Workshop Agenda ................................................................................... 35 Appendix 4: Lake Nipigon Spawning Shoal Surveys .................................................... 37 Appendix 5: Lake Nipigon and Nipigon River Creel Surveys ....................................... 43 Appendix 6: Co-operative Brook Trout Angler Program.............................................. 47 Appendix 7: Estimating the age of Coaster Brook Trout ............................................. 62 Appendix 8: Workshop – Minutes of Final Discussion Period ...................................... 65 Appendix 9: Workshop – Comments received from the Ontario Federation of Anglers and Hunters .............................................................................................................. 68 List of Figures Figure 1 Location of areas within the Ontario waters of Lake Superior, Lake Nipigon and the 2 Nipigon River discussed in this review. Figure 2 Annual estimated number of brook trout spawning on shoal in West Bay and South 6 Bay of Lake Nipigon. Figure 3 Size structure of brook trout captured during spawning shoal surveys in South Bay 7 and West Bay of Lake Nipigon. Figure 4 Results from OMNR angler surveys on the Nipigon River from 1993 to 2010. 9 Figure 5 Results from OMNR angler surveys at the South Bay access point on Lake Nipigon 10 from 1993 to 2009. Figure 6 A simplified diagram of PIT antennas used to study movement of brook trout 12 between Lake Superior and Nipigon Bay tributaries. Figure 7 Time of brook trout movements recorded at PIT antennas situated near the mouth 12 of tributary streams in Nipigon Bay, Lake Superior. Figure 8 Date of brook trout movements recorded at PIT antennas situated near the mouth 13 of tributary streams in Nipigon Bay, Lake Superior. Figure 9 Size structure of brook trout captured by co-operative anglers in the Jessie Lake 15 area of the Nipigon River from 2006 to 2010. Figure 10 Co-operative angler catch rates on Lake Nipigon, the Jessie Lake area of the 17 Nipigon River, and Nipigon Bay. Figure 11 Size structure of brook trout caught by co-operative anglers in the Jessie Lake area 18 of the Nipigon River and the Nipigon Bay area of Lake Superior before and after the regulation change in 2005. Figure 12 The size of spawning brook trout captured in Minnesota tributaries before and 21 after protective sport fishing regulations were implemented in 1997. Figure 13A Before habitat was improved on the Bark River, Wisconsin. 23 Figure 13B After habitat was improved on the Bark River, Wisconsin. 23 Figure A4-1 Size structure of brook trout captured during spawning shoal surveys on South Bay 40 in 1997, 1998, 2002, 2003, 2006 and 2007. Figure A4-2 Size structure of brook trout captured during spawning shoal surveys on West Bay 41 in 2001, 2002, 2008, and 2009. Figure A6-1 Size structure of brook trout caught in the Nipigon Bay area of Lake Superior from 51 1997 to 2010. Figure A6-2 Size structure of brook trout caught by anglers in the Cameron Falls area of the 54 Nipigon River from 2003 to 2005. Figure A6-3 Size structure of brook trout caught by anglers in the Jessie Lake area of the 55 Nipigon River from 1997 to 2010. Figure A6-4 Size structure of brook trout caught by anglers in Lake Nipigon during 1998, 1999, 57 2000 and 2006. Figure A6-5 Length-weight relationship of brook trout captured within Cameron Falls, Jessie 60 Lake and Lake Nipigon from co-operative angler program. Figure A7-1 Comparison of the estimated ages of fifty Cypress River brook trout using scales 63 and fin rays. Figure A7-2 Comparison of the estimated ages of 47 brook trout from the Nipigon River 63 watershed using scales and otoliths. List of Tables Table 1 Goals for brook trout management in Lake Superior and Lake Nipigon 3 Table 2 Annual growth of brook trout in the Jessie Lake section of the Nipigon River 16 Table A1-1 Summary of sport fishing regulations for brook trout prior to 2005 in the Ontario 32 waters of Lake Nipigon, the Nipigon River, and Lake Superior including tributary streams. Table A4-1 Estimated number of eggs collected during brook trout spawn collection programs 38 from 1924 to 1984 in South Bay and West Bay of Lake Nipigon and resultant estimates of population size. Table A4-2 Survey dates and estimated number of brook trout from tagging studies in South 39 Bay and West Bay of Lake Nipigon. Table A5-1 Survey dates and estimated fishery characteristics from angler surveys on the 44 Nipigon River from 1993-2010. Table A5-2 Distribution of angler effort directed at brook trout on the Nipigon River. 44 Table A5-3 Summary of length and age information collected from brook trout, lake trout, 45 northern pike, rainbow trout and Chinook salmon harvested from the Nipigon River. Table A5-4 Survey dates and estimated fishery characteristics from angler surveys at South Bay, 46 Lake Nipigon, from 1993-2009. Table A6-1 Number of groups tagging brook trout in each region from 1997 to 2010. 48 Table A6-2 Summary of brook trout tagging and recapture information collected by co- 50 operative anglers in regions of Nipigon Bay, Lake Nipigon, and the Nipigon River. Table A6-3 Length statistics for brook trout caught by anglers on Nipigon Bay, Lake Nipigon 58 and sections of the Nipigon River before and after the sport fishing regulation was modified in 2005. Table A6-4 Annual growth of brook trout in the Jessie Lake section of the Nipigon River. 59 Executive Summary Brook trout populations have declined from historic highs in the Ontario waters of Lake Superior, Lake Nipigon, and the Nipigon River. In an effort to enhance populations, a protective sport fishing regulation was applied in 2005, allowing the possession of 1 brook trout greater than 56 cm (22 in) in length. Associated with the new regulation was a public recommendation to review the status of brook trout after a five year period. As a result, in March 2011 the Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources (OMNR) hosted a workshop to present information collected from 2005 to 2010, review the progress of brook trout rehabilitation, and to discuss future actions. Brook trout populations and fisheries in Lake Nipigon showed substantial change after the sport fishing regulation was amended. Brook trout numbers and average size increased in two Lake Nipigon spawning populations, although numbers remain at a fraction of 1930’s levels. Catch rates of the average angler have