DOCSLIB.ORG

Armenia and Democratic Control of the Armed Forces Analysis and Perspectives

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Armenia and Democratic Control of the Armed Forces Analysis and Perspectives ARMENIA AND DEMOCRATIC CONTROL OF THE ARMED FORCES ANALYSIS AND PERSPECTIVES "Views, comments and conclusions expressed in the articles do not necessarily reflect the views of the OSCE or OSCE Office in Yerevan" ISBN 978-92-9235-886-0 Printed by “Asoghik” printing house FOREWORD The thematic unity of the articles collected in this publication is the OSCE Code of Conduct on Politico-Military Aspects of Security which is one of the main OSCE`s mechanisms to address global security challenges. Negotiated in the Forum for Security Cooperation (FSC) and adopted at the 1994 Budapest Summit, it still remains a unique document aimed at regulating the role of armed forces in democratic societies. The Code reiterates and deepens the main principles of the Helsinki Final Act developing the “rule of a game” between participating States, basically concerning the non-use of force. However, the Code furthers beyond the logic of the Helsinki Final Act defining important norms and “behavioral standards” of politico-military aspects at intra-state level. From perspective of democratic control over armed forces the sections VII and VIII explicitly describe commitments by participating States to develop a comprehensive mechanism of civilian control over their armed forces, including military, paramilitary and security forces, intelligence services and the police. Without effective democratic civilian control and governance of security sector institutions, there will be no substantial progress in terms of overall security, which will also have adverse influence on economic and human dimensions of security. Therefore democratic civilian control of armed forces, which logically implies inclusion of both conventional military forces and internal security services within a clearly defined constitutional and legal framework, is currently accepted as an important tool of conflict prevention and international confidence building. The Republic of Armenia as all the OSCE member states has full commitments on implementing the Code and OSCE Office in Yerevan is providing comprehensive support to the relevant authorities in overall security sector reforms. This publication is a result of a close cooperation between our Office and the Ministry of Defense of the Republic of Armenia, particularly the National Strategic Research Centre after Drastamat Kanayan. I hope that the articles collected in this publication which are devoted to the history of the Code, Armenia’s and international experience in implementation of the Code`s provisions will raise practical interest among civil society, academicians and policy makers. Ambassador Sergey Kapinos Head of OSCE Office in Yerevan 3 FOREWORD OSCE Office in Yerevan implements its mission aimed at supporting in the establishment of democratic system of values and institutions and peace and stability in the region through multilateral cooperation with governmental and non-governmental structures. This publication is also a product of such cooperation. It became possible due to joint efforts of the OSCE Office in Yerevan and the RA MoD National Strategic Research Centre after Drastamat Kanayan. I believe that from the perspective of public administration principle and human rights priorities it is a quite valuable scientific-analytical material of public democratic control over the armed forces, which contains practical recommendations. This publication will really contribute to constructive cooperation between the OSCE Office in Yerevan and RA Ministry of Defence. H.S Kotanjan Major-General, Head of RA MoD National Strategic Research Centre after Drastamat Kanayan, Advisor to the Minister of Defence, Doctor of Political Sciences 4 Contents Negotiating the code: A Polish view(1996)....................................................................................6 Political Context of the Code: An Introduction...............................................................................6 The system of oversight and control over the defense sector management in the republic of armenia........................................................................................................................................13 1. Transparency and accountability as prerequisites for an effective control over the defense sector management, and their regulation by law.........................................................................14 1.1. Transparency and Accountability, Their Role and Significance ........................................14 1.1.1 Transparency ..............................................................................................................14 1.1.2 Accountability Before the Public ............................................................................19 1.2. Democratic Control Over the Armed Forces as a Means to Ensure Lawfulness: Stipulation by the RA Legislation ...................................................................................................22 2. Oversight bodies in the defense sector as a means to ensure lawfulness ..........................28 2.1. The RA MOD Military Police as a Means to Ensure Lawfulness .....................................28 2.2. The RA Military Prosecutor’s Office as a Means to Ensure Lawfulness..........................33 2.3. Internal System of Oversight over the Armed Forces Management.................................33 3. System of control over the defense sector management.....................................................35 3.1. The RA National Assembly as a Democratic Control Body ...............................................35 3.2. The RA Control Chamber as a Democratic Control Body..................................................39 3.3. The RA Judiciary as a Democratic Control Body ................................................................40 3.4. The Human Rights Defender as a Democratic Control Mechanism.................................41 3.5. Public Control as a Democratic Control Mechanism...........................................................43 Civil control of armed forces in US and its diffusion on post-communist region................................................................................................................................45 Civil control of armed forces in US .......................................................................................49 Introduction of civil control of armed forces in post communist region after cold war..........54 Some issues related to perfection of the ra defence sphere management system......................61 Financial control of the republic of armenia defense sector as an integral part of democratic control..........................................................................................................................................68 The republic of armenia human rights defender as an institute of civilian control over the armed forces................................................................................................................................72 Special civil service as a means of democratic control over the armed forces............................81 Issues of criminal liability for crimes against military service procedures in the republic of armenia........................................................................................................................................89 5 NEGOTIATING THE CODE: A POLISH VIEW (1996) ADAM KOBIERACKI 1 Note from the OiY: Irrespective of 15 years which have passed after publication of this article many ideas and considerations of its content are still valid in mid 90. There was ongoing process in the OSCE towards the creation of a security model for Europe for the 21st Century. It will be intellectually worth reading the content and context of this article in the framework of the ongoing discussion in the OSCE called the Corfu Process. The Office expresses its gratitude to the Author for the Copy Rights Grzegorz Michalski Politico – Military Officer 2009-2011 Political Context of the Code: An Introduction The Code of Conduct contains a set of principles, provisions, norms, and rules of responsible and cooperative behaviour in the field of security. Commitments embodied in the Code affect responsibilities of states towards each other and of governments towards their people. The very idea of the Code emerged at the Helsinki Follow-up Meeting in 1992 and was included in the mandate of the OSCE Forum for Security Cooperation established there. Depending on the perspective, there may be different explanations concerning the origins of this idea. First, the political context of the Code will be discussed. From the perspective of the EU, the Code was extremely important, representing the first comprehensive expression of a common foreign and security policy. Thus, the Code was viewed as a set of norms relating to European security and, first of all, its politico-military aspects. It was intended to reflect the EU’s role in and understanding of the European security system. These political and, to a certain extent, prestigious motives are probably the reason that the EU states felt so attached to their draft of the Code that it was almost impossible to persuade them to change any part of it. Therefore, though apparently it was not the only reason, time for compromise-oriented negotiating with the EU came only at the very last stage of the negotiations. One could add that internal mechanisms for consultation within the EU were only just being developed at that time, a fact which did
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Cabinet of Armenia, 1920
    Cabinet of Armenia, 1920 MUNUC 32 TABLE OF CONTENTS ______________________________________________________ Letter from the Crisis Director…………………………………………………3 Letter from the Chair………………………………………….………………..4 The History of Armenia…………………………………………………………6 The Geography of Armenia…………………………………………………14 Current Situation………………………………………………………………17 Character Biographies……………………………………………………....27 Bibliography…………………………………………………………………...37 2 Cabinet of Armenia, 1920 | MUNUC 32 LETTER FROM THE CRISIS DIRECTOR ______________________________________________________ Dear Delegates, We’re very happy to welcome you to MUNUC XXXII! My name is Andre Altherr and I’ll be your Crisis Director for the Cabinet of Armenia: 1920 committee. I’m from New York City and am currently a Second Year at the University of Chicago majoring in History and Political Science. Despite once having a social life, I now spend my free-time on much tamer activities like reading 800-page books on Armenian history, reading 900-page books on Central European history, and relaxing with the best of Stephen King and 20th century sci-fi anthologies. When not reading, I enjoy hiking, watching Frasier, and trying to catch up on much needed sleep. I’ve helped run and participated in numerous Model UN conferences in both college and high school, and I believe that this activity has the potential to hone public speaking, develop your creativity and critical thinking, and ignite interest in new fields. Devin and I care very deeply about making this committee an inclusive space in which all of you feel safe, comfortable, and motivated to challenge yourself to grow as a delegate, statesperson, and human. We trust that you will conduct yourselves with maturity and tact when discussing sensitive subjects.
    [Show full text]
  • Varujan Vosganian, the Book of Whispers
    Varujan Vosganian, The Book of Whispers Chapters seven and eight Translation: Alistair Ian Blyth Seven ‘Do not harm their women,’ said Armen Garo. ‘And nor the children.’ One by one, all the members of the Special Mission gathered at the offices of the Djagadamard newspaper in Constantinople. They had been selected with care. The group had been whittled down to those who had taken part in such operations before, working either alone or in ambush parties. ‘I trust only a man who has killed before,’ Armen Garo had declared. They were given photographs of those they were to seek out, wherever they were hiding. Their hiding places might be anywhere, from Berlin or Rome to the steppes of Central Asia. Broad-shouldered, bull-necked Talaat Pasha, the Minister of the Interior, was a brawny man, whose head, with its square chin and jaws that could rip asunder, was more like an extension of his powerful chest. In the lower part of the photograph, his fists, twice the size of a normal man’s, betokened pugnacity. Beside him, fragile, her features delicate, his wife wore a white dress and a lace cap in the European style, so very different from the pasha’s fez. Then there was Enver, a short man made taller by his boot heels. He had haughty eyes and slender fingers that preened the points of his moustache. He was proud of his army commander’s braids, which, cascading luxuriantly from his shoulders and covering his narrow chest, sought to disguise the humble beginnings of a son whose mother, in order to raise him, had plied one of the most despised trades in all the Empire: she had washed the bodies of the dead.
    [Show full text]
  • Ethnic Cleansing and Massacres of the Ottoman
    The Nation-Building Process in the Balkans: Ethnic Cleansing and Massacres of the Ottoman Muslim and Turkish Population (1912-1913) Le processus de construction de la nation dans les Balkans: nettoyage ethnique et massacre des musulmans ottomans et turcs (1912-1913) Conference organized by the Collège Belgique (Académie Royale de Belgique) and the University of Utah Mars-March 24-25, 2016 Bruxelles-Brussels (Belgique-Belgium) A. Argumentaire en français : Le processus de construction de la nation dans les Balkans : nettoyage ethnique et massacre des musulmans ottomans et turcs (1912-1913) Dans le contexte de la désintégration de l’Empire Ottoman et de l’émergence du nouveau système étatique balkanique, la guerre a joué un rôle dans les processus de construction des nations et des états. Le système étatique balkanique a été créé pour résoudre la question d’Orient, et les états concernés ont fini par devenir des états-nations homogènes suite à une série de guerres qui atteignirent leur apogée lors de ce que l’on a appelé les guerres balkaniques (1912-1913). Ce fut la première guerre totale dans les Balkans, si l’on considère que les frontières entre le front de bataille et le front intérieur ont été supprimées au moyen d’une attaque systématique de certains groupes identitaires. On peut d’ailleurs considérer que, pour l’état ottoman, la première guerre mondiale a commencé en 1912 car le ton était donné et le schéma établi pour la première guerre mondiale. Qui plus est, les pères fondateurs de l’actuelle république de Turquie sont tous originaires des Balkans.
    [Show full text]
  • American University of Armenia International
    AMERICAN UNIVERSITY OF ARMENIA INTERNATIONAL MILITARY COOPERATION OF THE REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA SINCE INDEPENDENCE A MASTER’S ESSAY SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE AND INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS FOR PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS BY MARINE MARGARYAN YEREVAN, ARMENIA DECEMBER 2011 1 SIGNATURE PAGE Faculty Advisor Date Dean Date American University of Armenia December 2011 2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS It is a pleasure for me to state that I am indebted to my Faculty Advisor Dr. Khatchik Der Ghougassian, first and foremost, for the knowledge and skills that he gave me during my years of study. His supervision and guidance in the process of writing this master’s essay improved the quality of my work, ensured the motivation to do my best and put all my efforts. I would like to express my special gratitude to my lovely Professor Dr. Lucig Danielian who shared her precious experience and personal qualities with her students and encouraged me in the work that I do. Throughout my study she provided me wise advices, motivation and inspiration and just an opportunity to learn from a person like her. Thank you from all my heart. This thesis would not have been possible unless all the faculty members with their sound experience, knowledge and skills were not imputing in the personal and professional development of the students. I am grateful to the efforts of all the lecturers and professors that led me to the eminence. You were a life changing experience for me. It is a pleasure to thank all my classmates who made the years of my study enjoyment and fun.
    [Show full text]
  • Carlo Alberto Il Grande
    Carlo Alberto il Grande Premessa: Fra gli elementi che fecero fallire la prima guerra d'indipendenza oltre al voltafaccia degli alleati, le incertezze caratteriali di Carlo Alberto di Savoia furono forse l'elemento fondamentele; Tale incertezze sono forse da ricercare nella prematura dipartita del padre del “Re Tentenna” Ora mettiamo che il padre di Carlo Alberto, Carlo Emanuele di Savoia-Carignano, non muoia a soli trent'anni nel 1800, ma che viva a lungo, dando stabilità al giovane Carlo Alberto. P.o.D: Carlo Emanuele di Savoia-Carignano muore nel 1830, a 60 anni; Convintamente liberale, ma più cattolico che nella nostra timeline, e di salute molto più robusta, grazie all'infanzia meno complicata, Carlo Alberto concederà lo Statuto Albertino già nel 1831 , dopo la morte dello “zio” Carlo Felice; Poi dedicherà i successivi 17 anni a convincere i sovrani italiani della necessità di concedere qualcosa per mantenere il resto; il suo motto diventa: “Non fate come Carlo X!” Facendo pressioni sulla cugina Maria Beatrice nel 1835 ottiene di ospitare a Torino Francesco, l'erede al Ducato di Modena, per alcuni anni; In questi anni il futuro Fancesco V sviluppa un legame profondo per Carlo Alberto. Il Duca rivelerà in seguito che il Re di Sardegna fu per lui un padre migliore del severo e reazionario Francesco IV. Francesco V concederà la Costituzione nel 1846, subito dopo l'incoronazione. Nel 1832 da comunque asilo al suo “esempio negativo” Carlo X, a Luigi XIX e al giovanissimo Enrico V; con quest'ultimo Carlo Alberto costruisce un rapporto positivo, che si estende al figlio di Carlo Alberto, Vittorio Emanuele II; Immediata fortuna avrà con Leopoldo II, Granduca di Toscana, mite e liberale, che grazie al sostegno del Savoia decise, con buona pace del Principe di Metternich, di concedere pure lui una costituzione, nel 1837.
    [Show full text]
  • The Evolution of Tsarist Policy on the Armenian Ques- Tion in the South Caucasus (1903-1914)
    ORBIT-OnlineRepository ofBirkbeckInstitutionalTheses Enabling Open Access to Birkbeck’s Research Degree output The evolution of Tsarist policy on the Armenian ques- tion in the South Caucasus (1903-1914) https://eprints.bbk.ac.uk/id/eprint/40100/ Version: Public Version Citation: Onol, Onur (2014) The evolution of Tsarist policy on the Ar- menian question in the South Caucasus (1903-1914). [Thesis] (Unpub- lished) c 2020 The Author(s) All material available through ORBIT is protected by intellectual property law, including copy- right law. Any use made of the contents should comply with the relevant law. Deposit Guide Contact: email The Evolution of Tsarist Policy on the Armenian Question in the South Caucasus (1903-1914) Onur Onol Department of History, Classics and Archeology Birkbeck, University of London Submitted for the degree of PhD November 2014 1 The work presented in this thesis is my own. Onur Onol 2 ABSTRACT From the Tsarist confiscation of the properties of the Armenian Church in 1903 to the outbreak of the First World War, relations between Russia and its Armenian subjects gradually changed. This thesis scrutinizes how and why this gradual change took place between 1903 and 1914 by looking at the interaction between the Russian administration and the three political pillars of the Russian Armenians (the Dashnaktsutiun, the Armenian Church, and the Armenian bourgeoisie) as well as Russian foreign policy considerations. The confiscation decree of 1903 triggered an immense reaction by the Russian Armenians against the Russian government, which became part of the revolutionary unrest in the South Caucasus in 1905. The relations began to improve with the arrival of the viceroy of the Caucasus, Illarion I.
    [Show full text]
  • General Assembly Security Council Sixty-Sixth Session Sixty-Seventh Year Agenda Items 35, 39, 67, 83 and 109
    United Nations A/66/905–S/2012/710 General Assembly Distr.: General 18 September 2012 Security Council Original: English General Assembly Security Council Sixty-sixth session Sixty-seventh year Agenda items 35, 39, 67, 83 and 109 Protracted conflicts in the GUAM area and their implications for international peace, security and development The situation in the occupied territories of Azerbaijan Elimination of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance The rule of law at the national and international levels Measures to eliminate international terrorism Letter dated 17 September 2012 from the Permanent Representative of Azerbaijan to the United Nations addressed to the Secretary-General I would like to draw your attention to a letter dated 31 August 2012 from the Permanent Representative of Armenia to the United Nations transmitting a statement by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Armenia regarding the case of Ramil Safarov, a national of Azerbaijan and officer of its armed forces sentenced to life imprisonment in Hungary in 2004 for the death of an Armenian officer in an incident that took place during a North Atlantic Treaty Organization-sponsored training course in Budapest (A/66/896-S/2012/681). In its statement, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Armenia expressed its disappointment with the decision taken by the Hungarian authorities to transfer Ramil Safarov to Azerbaijan, and with his subsequent pardon by the President of Azerbaijan. It should be made clear at the outset that the transfer of Ramil Safarov from Hungary to Azerbaijan was a purely legal matter between the two countries, addressed in full conformity with the 1983 Strasbourg Convention on the Transfer of Sentenced Persons, to which both Hungary and Azerbaijan are parties.
    [Show full text]
  • For Submission
    Between Host-Countries and Homeland: Institutions, Politics and Identities in the Post-Genocide Armenian Diaspora (1920s to 1980s) by Vahe Sahakyan A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Near Eastern Studies) in the University of Michigan 2015 Doctoral Committee: Professor Kevork B. Bardakjian, Chair Associate Professor Carol B. Bardenstein Emeritus Professor Gerard J. Libaridian Associate Professor Ara Sanjian, University of Michigan - Dearborn Professor Ronald G. Suny Professor Khachig Tölölyan, Wesleyan University ©Vahe Sahakyan 2015 To my parents ii Acknowledgments The completion of this project owes much to a large number of scholars, academics and intellectuals, friends and family members. My academic journey in diaspora studies began due to my training as a sociologist at Yerevan State University, Armenia. My sociological curiosity was quick to capture the significant differences in how Armenianness was experienced and expressed in the diaspora, when I first encountered third-fourth generation Armenian-Americans upon my arrival at the University of Michigan as a Junior Faculty Development Program visiting scholar in Fall 2004. This generous grant I was awarded by the US Department of State’s Bureau of Educational and Cultural Affairs provided me a possibility to spend a year at one of the leading American universities, where my interest in Armenian diasporic identities and institutions took shape. Frequent and often endless conversations with Kevork Bardakjian and Gerard Libaridian provided additional impetus to my curiosity. It was due to their continued encouragement and support that two years after returning to Armenia I finally decided to apply and was admitted to the Ph.D.
    [Show full text]
  • Dro and World War II Non-Partisan Website Devoted to Armenian Affairs, Human Rights and Democracy
    Keghart Dro and World War II Non-partisan Website Devoted to Armenian Affairs, Human Rights https://keghart.org/dro-and-world-war-ii/ and Democracy DRO AND WORLD WAR II Posted on December 13, 2015 by Keghart Category: Opinions Page: 1 Keghart Dro and World War II Non-partisan Website Devoted to Armenian Affairs, Human Rights https://keghart.org/dro-and-world-war-ii/ and Democracy Dr. Antranig Chalabian (1922 - 2011) Teacher, medical illustrator and public relations director, the late-Dr. Chalabian was born in Kessab and lived for many years in Beirut and in Detroit. In addition to contributing to publications in Lebanon, Dr. Chalabian wrote several books, including General Andranik and the Armenian Revolutionary Movement, Revolutionary Figures, and Armenia After the Coming of Islam. This abridged excerpt is from DRO: Armenia's First Defence Minister of the Modern Era (Indo-European Publishing, 2009)--Editor. World War II changed the course of Dro’s (Drastamat Kanayan) regardless of his will or intention, linking him to the Russian-German struggle as collaborator with Nazism. During WWI he had collaborated with the tsarist regime as commander of the 2nd Volunteer Regiment on the Caucasus front. That does not mean that Dro, Andranik, Vartan, Keri, Hamazasp or others admired the tsarist dictatorship. Dr. Antranig Chalabian (1922 - 2011) Teacher, medical illustrator and public relations director, the late-Dr. Chalabian was born in Kessab and lived for many years in Beirut and in Detroit. In addition to contributing to publications in Lebanon, Dr. Chalabian wrote several books, including General Andranik and the Armenian Revolutionary Movement, Revolutionary Figures, and Armenia After the Coming of Islam.
    [Show full text]
  • Foreign Units in the Russian Army During World War I. Formation of Armenian Vigilante Units in the Caucasian Front
    Propaganda in the World and Local Conflicts, 2019, 6(2) Copyright © 2019 by Academic Publishing House Researcher s.r.o. Published in the Slovak Republic Propaganda in the World and Local Conflicts Has been issued since 2014. E-ISSN 2500-3712 2019, 6(2): 67-76 DOI: 10.13187/pwlc.2019.2.67 www.ejournal47.com Foreign Units in the Russian Army during World War I. Formation of Armenian Vigilante Units in the Caucasian Front Mikhail N. Kirilov a , * a Military Training Scientific Center of the Navy “Naval Academy named after Admiral of the Fleet of the Soviet Union N.G. Kuznetsova”, Saint-Petersburg, Russian Federation Abstract The article analyzes the reasons and methods of forming Armenian vigilante units as part of the Russian Army in the World War I in the Caucasian Front. It is emphasized that according to the plan of the Caucasus Corps Command, Armenian vigilante units should have been not just auxiliary units of the Russian Army that were familiar with the area, providing all possible assistance to the troops, but they also had to resolve issues independently where it would have been impossible to use the Caucasus Corps Units for political or other reasons. Among other things, they were charged with maintaining order in the territory of Turkish Armenia after the victory and the transfer of Russian military units to other fronts. The article also provides detailed information about the combat training arrangements of these units. Keywords: World War I, formation, Armenian vigilantes, Caucasian Front. 1. Introduction One of the important goals in the World War I that was set by the government of Tsarist Russia was to solve the so-called Eastern question.
    [Show full text]
  • Buradan Alınması Için Yo Ğun Bir Faaliyette Bulunacaktır
    AKADEMĐK BAKIŞ DERG ĐSĐ Sayı: 51 Eylül – Ekim 2015 Uluslararası Hakemli Sosyal Bilimler E-Dergisi ISSN:1694-528X Đktisat ve Girişimcilik Üniversitesi, Türk Dünyası Kırgız – Türk Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü, Celalabat – KIRGIZĐSTAN http:// www.akademikbakis.org SÖZDE ERMEN Đ “MĐLL Đ KAHRAMANLARI”NIN OSMANLI DEVLET Đ’NDEK Đ TERÖR EYLEMLER ĐNE ETK ĐLER Đ ∗∗∗ Bülent CIRIK Öz Kökeni M.S. 5. yüzyıla kadar giden ve modern manada 17. yüzyıldan itibaren olu şmaya ba şlayan Ermeni tarih yazımı içinde dört ana unsur göze çarpmaktadır. Bunlar, Ermeni kilisesi, Ermeni mukaddes mekânları, Ermeni “milli kahramanları” ve Ermeni komiteleridir. Osmanlı Devleti içinde ço ğu zaman kiliselerde ve özel mekânlarda ele geçen evraklarda “muzırr” olarak ifade edilen bu tarih bilgileri ve nüshaları 19. yüzyıldan günümüze kadar bir evrim içinde olmu ştur. Ermenilerin tarihi iddialarını kapsayan soykırım tarihi yazımı içinde, “ma ğdur olan Ermenilerin gasp edilmi ş haklarını elde etmek için sava şan” sözde kahramanların ayrı bir yeri vardır. Milli bir tarih in şası için vazgeçilmez bir unsur olan “kahramanlık miti” Ermeni tarih yazımı içinde birçok karma şıklı ğı içermektedir. Bugün Ermeni tarih kitaplarında “milli kahraman” olarak anılan Mesrop, Mıgırdıç Hrımyan, Antranik, Dro, Hamparsum Boyacıyan, Armen Garo, Mihran Damadyan, Karekin Pastırmacıyan ve daha birçok Hınçak ve Ta şnak gibi komite mensupları 19. yüzyıldan itibaren Osmanlı Devleti içinde sivil halka yönelik terör eylemleri gerçekle ştirerek Ermeni ba ğımsızlık sava şının kahramanları olmu şlardır. Ermeniler için tarihi bir beklentiyi ortaya koyan ve do ğuda Büyük Ermenistan’ı in şa etmek için çalı şan bu liderler Osmanlı Devleti açısından birer komiteci ve yasaklanmı ş ki şiler olmu ştur. Bu ki şilerin gerçekten kahramanlık yönleri var mıydı? Masum ve silahsız sivil halka nasıl davranmışlardı? Çalı şmamızda bu liderlerin arasından seçti ğimiz örnekler çerçevesinde, bunların gerçekle ştirdikleri eylemleri ve terör olaylarındaki payları, 1890-1922 yılları arasında bu “kahramanlık mitinin” macerası ele alınmaya çalı şılacaktır.
    [Show full text]
  • Think Armenian Claims Are True? Think Again…
    THINK ARMENIAN CLAIMS ARE TRUE? THINK AGAIN…. April 2015 PAST QUOTES FROM THE FIELD DON’T LIE A COMPLEX, POLITICAL WITCH HUNT… Reports are being freely circulated in the United States that the Turks massacred thousands of Armenians in the Caucasus. Such“ VIOLENT ARMENIAN UPRISING reports are repeated so many times it makes my blood boil. The Near East Relief have the reports from Yarrow and our own � The rst claim of an “Armenian Genocide” “It is a well- known fact that even in the last war the native American people which show that such Armenian reports are absolutely false. The circulation of such false reports in the United surfaced in 1965, 50 years after the alleged Christians [mostly Armenians], despite the Turkish cautions, armed event, when Soviet Union instigated Armenia States, without refutation, is an outrage and is certainly doing the Armenians more harm than good. … Why not tell the truth about themselves and fought on the side of the Allies. In these conicts, to hurt the Republic of Turkey, a member “the Armenians in every way? they were not idle, but they were well supplied with artillery, of NATO and a staunch ally of the US during —Admiral Mark L. Bristol, U.S. Ambassador to the Rep. of Turkey 1920 – 1926, March 28, 1921 letter to the post machine guns and inicted heavy losses on their enemies….” Cold War? (1) — George Lamsa, missionary (10) � Armenian sources note that the Russian army “ forcibly relocated about 300,000 Armenians It would seem as if an Armenian insurrection to help the Russians had broken out at Van.
    [Show full text]