A Study of Educational Opportunity for Punjabi Youth. Final Report. INSTITUTION South Asian American Education Association, Stockton, CA
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DOCUMENT RESUME ED 236 276 UD 023 154 AUTHOR Gibson, Margaret A. TITLE Home-School-Community Linkages: A Study of Educational Opportunity for Punjabi Youth. Final Report. INSTITUTION South Asian American Education Association, Stockton, CA. SPONS AGENCY Department of Education, Washington, DC. PUB DATE 83 GRANT NIE-G-80-0123 NOTE 270p.; Funding was provided by the Home, Community, and Work Program. PUB TYPE Reports - Research/Technical (143) EDRS PRICE MF01/PC11 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS Academic Achievement; *Cultural Influences; Educational Opportunities; *Family School Relationship; High Schools; *Immigrants; *Indians; Minority Groups; *Parent Attitudes; Religious Cultural Groups; School Community Relationship; Student Behavior; *Success IDENTIFIERS California; *Sikhs ABSTRACT This report presents findings from ethnographic research that focused on factors which promote and impede educational opportunity for Punjabi Sikh immigrants in "Valleyside," an agricultural town in California. The report is divided into two parts. Part one considers the setting and the sociocultural context for schooling ia "Valleyside." Drawing from interviews with Punjabi and non-immigrant residents, parents' views of life in America, job opportunities, family structure, social relations, and child rearing are described. Background on Punjabis in India is provided.Their reasons for immigrating to the United States, their theory of success, and their life strategies are explored. In addition, social relations between'Punjabis and members of the mainstream majority are discussed. This section closes with a comparative analysis of child rearing, emphasizing those patterns most directly related to school performance at the secondary level. The second half of the report focuses on schooling itself by examining social, structural, and cultural factors which influence educational opportunity, home-school relations, and school response patterns. The ways in which the high school curriculum structure and various academic "tracks" create barriers to educational opportunity are explored. Social relations among students are also discussed. The study demonstrates that immigrant minorities may do well in school even when cast as subordinate by a dominant group and that cultural differences do not necessarily inhibit educational achievement. Specifically, findings indicate the importance of high self-esteem, self-reliance, and parental support. All of these aspects of Punjabi culture strongly contribute to success. (GC) HOME-SCHOOL-COMMUNITY LINKAGES: A STUDY OF EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITY FOR PUNJABI YOUTH FINAL REPORT NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION Grant Number NIE-G-80-0123 1983 U.S. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES INFORMATION CENTER (ERIC) This document has been reproduced as received from the person or organization originating it. Minor changes have been made to improve reproduction quality. Points of view or opinions stated in this docu- ment do not necessarily represent official NIE Position or policy. SOUTH ASIAN AMERICAN EDUCATION ASSOCIATION HOME-SCHOOL-COMMUNITY LINKAGES: A STUDY OF EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITY FOR PUNJABI YOUTH by Margaret A. Gibson Department of Anthropology California State University, Sacramento Sacramento, California 95819 SOUTH ASIAN AMERICAN EDUCATION ASSOCIATION POST OFFICE BOX 4294 STOCKTON, CALIFORNIA 95204 PROJECT STAFF BOARD OF DIRECTORS MARGARET A. GIBSON, Ph.D. AMARJIT S. BAL Principal Investigator President AMARJIT S. BAL, Ph.D. KARAM S. MAUGHAN CoInvestigator Vice President GURDIP K. DHILLON GURCHARN S. SANDHU Research Assistant Secretary ELIZABETH C. MCINTOSH AMARJIT S. AUJLA Research Assistant Assistant Secretary HASSAN POLADI Treasurer SOHAN S. BIRING Assistant Treasurer AMAR S. GILL Auditor BALBIR S. RAI Director TEJINDER BAL Director PROJECT ABSTRACT HOME-SCHOOL-COMMUNITY LINKAGES: A STUDY OF EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITY FOR PUNJABI YOUTH by Margaret A. Gibson This case study of educational opportunity, a collaborative ethnography, examines the interrelation among social, cultural, and structural factors which influence school performance. It focuses on an immigrant group at the high school level, Punjabi Sikhs, and treats both poor school performance and success. The research site is a large, agricultural -own in California. The research utilizes interviews, questionnaires, and direct observation of Punjabi and mainstream students, their parents, teachers, and administrators. Quantitative measures of success are drawn from school records. The research compares Punjabi and mainstream, males and females, new immigrants and second generation. It examines the cultural processes of prejudice and Americanization. Tracking and ESL are also treated. The study describes a case of educational and economic success by Asian Americans. The success of the Punjabis is all the more remarkable considering the context of their achievements. The study shows how analysis of /tan immigrants can contribute to understanding of factors affecting opportunity. Immigrant minorities may do well, in school, even when cast as subordinate by a dominant grout,. Greater barriers to equal educational opportunity were found to arise out of the structure of school programs and the prejudiced nature of majority-minority social relations than from home - school cultural differences. Findings indicate the importance of high self-esteem and parental support for education, whatever the student's background. Self-reliance is also significant, although Punjabi and mainstream definitions differ. This case suggests that while home-school discontinuity can lead to performance dysfunction in the classroom, cultural differences do not necessarily inhibit educational achieve- ment. Aspects of Punjabi culture contribute strongly to success. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The Punjabi Education Project, from its inception, has been a cooperative undertaking involving students, parents, community members, educational practitioners, and researchers. At the local level Project participants were most concerned about the improvement of education in Valleyside and the insight which research findings might provide. Toward this end the school district opened its doors to a team of outside researchers, not only permitting scrutiny within the schools for the duration of the Project, but providing guidance and assistance to the Project every step along the way. Without the support of the District Superintendent, the High School Principal, and many other administrators and teachers, we would neither have known the questions to ask nor had the ability to answer them. Our hope is that the insights gleaned will aid Valleyside educators in their ongoing efforts to strengthen educational programs and improve social relations among the different groups they serve. The views of students, parents, and educators, both Punjabi and Valleysider, provide the substance of this report. We have endeavored to represent their views accurately and know that what we have learned is the result of their willingness to share so fully their ideas and opinions. In keeping with our commitment to them, they, and all others who have participated in the Project, shall remain anonymous. The Project was administered by the South Asian American Educa tion Association, a nonprofit community organization dedicated to the goals of improving educational opportunities for South Asian American youngsters and promoting understanding and appreciation of the cultural heritage of the South Asian American people among Americans iv 6 in general. We are indebted to the Board of Directors of the Association for their support. Special thanks goes to Major Gurcharn S. Sandhu for his staunch backlag of the research and his own tireless contribution to the Project's administration. As principal investigator I wish to express my gratitude to the research team and to all those who helped carry out the work of the Project. My colleague and co-investigator Amarjit Bel sparked my initial interest in Punjabi Americans and throughout the past three years has greatly contributed to my understanding of Sikhs, Sikhism, and the Punjab. A separate, complementary report presents his analysis and findings. Gurdip Dhillon and Beth McIntosh, research assistants, who many times must have wondered if the fieldwork phase would ever end, were always willing to contribute to the Project in ways that far exceeded their job descriptions. Ms. McIntosh conducted with great skill and dedication a large share of all Valleysider parent and student interviews, as well as performing myriad other essential tasks. Ms. Dhillon ran our field office, managing ever cheerfully to keep track of seemingly endless sets of details, and translated and transcribed all the Punjabi language interviews, an enormous undertaking which she performed with great competence and good humor. Our thanks go also to Amarjit Aujla, Davinder Deol, Dorothy Roberts, and Rajinder Singh for assistance in conducting parent inter- views; to Vee Carney for transcription of interviews; Tony Wruck for computer assistance; Dorothea Theodoratus for administrative guidance; the staff of the Cross Cultural Resource Center for assistance with xeroxing; and Jack Cornelius for serving so competently as the Project's accountant. A draft copy of this report has been reviewed, chapter by chapter, by Neelam Agarwal, Martha Bunce, Darleen Dhillon, Hari Singh Everest, Andros Karperos, Bruce La Brack, John Ogbu, Bidya Pradhan, Baldev Singh, Jane Singh, ani George Zerkovich. I am