Figure 1.1 Active and Stable Landslide Regions Upper Hoult Creek Area (Superimposed on Figure A-119 Enbridge Potential Full-Bore Ruptures, Etc…)

Home , Bulk carrier, Chatham Sound, Dean Channel, Douglas Channel, Fisher Channel, Lama Passage

In the Matter of

Enbridge Northern Gateway Project Joint Review Panel

OH-4-2011

Northern Gateway Pipelines Inc.

Enbridge Northern Gateway Project

Written Evidence of Intervenor

David John Shannon

1. Once exiting the western Hoult Portal, the proposed twinned pipelines will be traversing some very active landslide areas of Hoult Creek and the upper Kitimat River (See Figures 1.1 and 1.2 below). The source of these evaluations is from Airphotos at scale 1:15,000 scale shown in Figures 1.3-1.10, following. (Figures 1.3 to 1.10 are best viewed in sequential pairs through a Stereo viewer, i.e. Figs 1.3 and 1.4; 1.5 and 1.6;, etc…)

Figure 1.1 Active and Stable Landslide Regions Upper Hoult Creek area (superimposed on Figure A-119 Enbridge Potential Full-Bore Ruptures, etc…).

Figure 1.2 Active and Stable Landslide Regions Upper Hoult Creek area (superimposed on Figure A-120 Enbridge Potential Full-Bore Ruptures, etc…).

Figure 1.3 Photo 200 Hoult Tunnel (East ½)

Figure 1.4 Photo 199 Hoult Tunnel (West ½)

Figure 1.5 Photo 198 East of Waypoint #8 (East ½)

Figure 1.6 Photo 198 East of Waypoint #8 (West ½)

Figure 1.7 Photo 196 Waypoint #8N (East ½)

Figure 1.8 Photo 195 Waypoint #8N (West ½)

Figure 1.9 Photo 86 Waypoint #8S (East ½)

Figure 1.10 Photo 87 Waypoint #8S (West ½)

2. Enbridge has made estimates of full bore ruptures at selected points along the pipeline. A selection of segment A-120 (shown below) will be discussed in more detail:

Figure 2.1 Pipeline Route through the Upper Kitimat.

The estimated rupture amounts from segment A-120 are shown in Figure 2.2 below: Figure 2.2 Potential Full-bore releases in upper Kitimat (Enbridge NGP information A- 120)

In this region the estimates vary from approximately 5,000 to 14,000 barrels of oil.

A Google Earth photo shown below puts the last slide into perspective: Figure 2.3 Google Earth photo of Upper Kitimat.

Three proposed boom locations are shown on the map above (Fig 2.3) along the pipeline route. My concern, having walked the route, is the inaccessibility of access to this portion of the river especially during winter.

The slide below (Fig. 2.4) shows a series of GPS waypoints (Waypoints #8- #18) at which photographs were taken of recent boulder and debris slides which cause me grave concern for the pipeline route.

Figure 2.4 Google Earth photo showing GPS waypoints of several photographs of landslide evidence

A photograph at waypoint #18 (Hoult “Monolith” photo) is shown below (Fig. 2.5), just about at the location the pipeline would exit Mount Nimbus, between Enbridge KP 1091 and KP 1092. The potential for this kind of geological activity in the region of a pipeline is most concerning. Figure 2.5 Huge boulder at the Hoult Portal location

Another sizeable boulder in a region estimated to be ‘Active’ is shown in the next figure (Fig 2.6) at GPS waypoint #8. Waypoint #8 is also identified in Figures 1.8 and 1.9.

Figure 2.6 Boulder at waypoint #8 along the pipeline route.

A portion of an Information Request from the BC Government is shown in Figure 2.7 below, highlighting the concern that even larger releases than those from full-bore ruptures are possible with slow leaks:

Figure 2.7 Leak Detection Systems Capabilities

I share the same concerns as the BC Government (Fig. 2.8 below) Figure 2.8 Leak detection was also a problem in the Kalamazoo and Kitimat’s isolation is a further concern

In a region known for its valuable salmon habitat, I am very concerned with a crude oil pipeline to Kitimat and the destructive cleanup methods which would be required after a spill. See Fig 2.9: Figure 2.9 Concerns for the Kitimat River guided by Kalamazoo experience

In the Matter of

Enbridge Northern Gateway Project Joint Review Panel

OH-4-2011

Northern Gateway Pipelines Inc.

Enbridge Northern Gateway Project

Written Evidence of Intervenor

David John Shannon

1. The tanker route proposed by Enbridge Northern Gateway Pipelines would be one of the longest most challenging routes for VLCC tankers in the world. Supporting evidence is given in Appendix A (World Tanker Routes). 2. The passage has been compared by some to the Strait of Magellan, in which the Chilean Government experienced a very large spill of crude oil (Metula incident of 1974) in their fourth and final attempt to traverse the Strait with VLCC crude oil tankers. Evidence is given in Metula Grounding Incident USCG Final Report shown in the link: http://www.fas.org/ota/reports/7508.pdf . The location of the grounding is identified in the last figure in attachment 1., above. The route now requires the presence of two “well-rested” pilots for the entire journey through the Straits. 3. Difficulty in dealing with the spill and its aftermath are shown in “Metula Oil spill Medeiros and Kjerfve” in the link http://geotest.tamu.edu/userfiles/167/77.pdf and “The Metula Oil Spill 21 Years Later” found in the link http://www.iosc.org/papers_posters/00323.pdf.

Dated this 20th day of December, 2011.

Dave Shannon,

Appendix A: World Tanker Routes Page 1/5

Figure A 1 Sullom Voe, Shetlands (20 miles) Appendix A World Tanker Routes Page 2/5

Figure A 2 Mongstad Norway (20 miles) Appendix A World Tanker Routes Page 3/5

Figure A 3 Brofjorden, Sweden (20 miles) Appendix A World Tanker Routes Page 3/5

Figure A 3 Valdez, Alaska (90 miles) Appendix A World Tanker Routes Page 4/5

Figure A 4 Kitimat Enbridge Northern Gateway Northern Route (190 miles) Appendix A World Tanker Routes Page 5/5

Figure A 5 Strait of Magellan (350 miles) Showing location of Metula Oil Spill In the Matter of

Enbridge Northern Gateway Project Joint Review Panel

OH-4-2011

Northern Gateway Pipelines Inc.

Enbridge Northern Gateway Project

Written Evidence of Intervenor

David John Shannon

1. This passage was taken from a “History of HSC Tug Escort Guideline and Regulation Development” for the port of Los Angeles/ Long Beach harbor found in this June 30, 2007 link: http://www.mxsocal.org/pdffiles/App%20C3%20History%20HSC%20Tug%20Escort%20Reg.pdf

“Analysis of marine casualties for vessels operating in the LA/LB port area revealed that an average of 1 in 100 commercial vessels (1 per week) sustained some type of steering or propulsion failure during the inbound or outbound transit. The mechanical problem rate and the ever-decreasing amount of navigable water inside the breakwaters threaten safe transit of vessels through the “relatively” confined breakwater entrances. If a significant allision or collision causes a major oil or chemical release, the environmental and economic costs could be devastating.”

2. With these figures applied to the combined LNG and Enbridge Northern Gateway crude oil traffic in the Kitimat harbor potentially to exceed 300 major tankers per year, the occurrence of steering or power failures could well exceed three events per year. The same occurrence rate would no doubt also pertain to the tugboats intended to perform escort and towing functions in the harbor and its approaches. The potential for a major crude oil or fuel oil release for the very sensitive north coast waters is alarming.

3. Tug boats are not immune to the combined human error and other risk factors, as the following Figures 1.1 and 1.2 (below) illustrate.

Figure 1.1 Sea Voyager and Pathfinder Tugs service the tanker fleet in Prince William Sound

Figure 1.2 Pathfinder Tug aground on Bligh Reef in Prince William Sound

4. An earlier incident also involving the Sea Voyager Tug in Prince William Sound is summarized in Figure 1.3, below:

Figure 1.3 Incident Involving Sea Voyager Tug and Escort Response Vehicle in prince William Sound

Dated this 19th Day of December 2011.

David John Shannon,

In the Matter of

Enbridge Northern Gateway Project Joint Review Panel

OH-4-2011

Northern Gateway Pipelines Inc.

Enbridge Northern Gateway Project

Written Evidence of Intervenor

David John Shannon

1. Figure 1.1, below shows TSB Reported Marine Incidents on the Inside Passage for the 6 years ending January 2009. The western boundary of the summary area is the vertical red line:

Figure 1.1 TSB Reportable Marine Accidents/ Incidents for the 6 years ending January 2009

The table from which this view was taken is shown in “TSB Marine Incidents Inside Passage.pdf” attached separately.

Dated this 19th day of December, 2011 David John Shannon

Accidents and Reportable Marine Incidents where Latitutde between 51 00 00 and 54 15 00 N and Longitude between 127 50 00 W and 130 30 00 W (Inner Passage - Prince Rupert to Port Hardy )

Obs OCC_NO OCC_CLAS ACC_TYPE_ID OCC_DATE VESSEL_NAME VESSEL_TYPE_ID INC_TYPE_I REGION_ID OCC_LOC AREA_TYPE_ID OCC_LATIT LAT_IDENTI OCC_LONG LONG_IDEN S_ID D UDE FIER ITUDE TIFIER 1 M03W0007 CLASS 5 CAPSIZING 07-Jan-03 POWELL BARGE - CARGO . WESTERN RODERICK ISLAND, BAY 524010 N 1282200 W CARRIER REGION WATSON BAY, B.C. 2 M03W0008 CLASS 5 FLOODING 08-Jan-03 MANSON TUG - OTHER . WESTERN FOG ROCKS, CHANNEL / 515800 N 1275500 W REGION FITZHUGH SOUND, STRAIT / SOUND B.C. 3 M03W0013 CLASS 5 STRIKING 18-Jan-03 SEA RAKE FISHING - . WESTERN MOORE ISLAND, B.C. BAY 524030 N 1292440 W UNSPECIFIED REGION 4 M03W0019 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 28-Jan-03 NANA BARGE - CARGO . WESTERN DUMAS POINT, CHANNEL / 521200 N 1280600 W PROVIDER REGION SEAFORTH STRAIT / SOUND CHANNEL, B.C. 5 M03W0027 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 28-Jan-03 NORMAN S TUG - OTHER . WESTERN SEAFORTH CHANNEL / 521200 N 1280600 W REGION CHANNEL, DUMAS STRAIT / SOUND POINT, B.C. 6 M03W0033 CLASS 5 STRIKING 05-Mar-03 NORSUL BULK CARRIER . WESTERN KITIMAT, EUROCAN HARBOUR - 540000 N 1294100 W AMERICA REGION TERMINALS, BERTH WITHIN I.E. #1 IMMEDIATE AREA 7 M03W0048 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 26-Mar-03 RIP TIDE FISHING - . WESTERN KENNEDY ISLAND, CHANNEL / 540500 N 1301000 W (CFV99153) UNSPECIFIED REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 8 M03W0053 CLASS 5 PROPELLER/R 01-Apr-03 VICTORY FISHING - . WESTERN KINGCOME POINT, CHANNEL / 531757 N 1285423 W UDDER/STRUC UNSPECIFIED REGION FRASER REACH, BC STRAIT / SOUND TURAL DAMAGE 9 M03W0057 CLASS 5 OTHER 14-Apr-03 G STAR DIVING GROUND WESTERN PRINCIPE CHANNEL, CHANNEL - 531800 N 1294800 W TENDER/SUPPOR ING - REGION B.C. APPROACH T NEAR (GENERAL) 10 M03W0060 CLASS 5 FIRE/EXPLOSIO 18-Apr-03 ROYAL FISHING - . WESTERN PRINCIPE CHANNEL, CHANNEL / 533359 N 1293922 W N FISHER TRAWLER/DRAG REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND GER 11 M03W0068 CLASS 5 OTHER 03-May-03 ROYAL FISHING - ENGINE WESTERN SAFETY COVE, CHANNEL / 512600 N 1275300 W PACIFIC UNSPECIFIED FAILURE REGION CALVERT ISLAND, STRAIT / SOUND B.C. 12 M03W0071 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 08-May-03 SAFARI YACHT . WESTERN KISAMEET BAY, BAY 515750 N 1275320 W SPIRIT REGION FISHER CHANNEL, B.C. 13 M03W0074 CLASS 5 OTHER 12-May-03 STYX TUG - OTHER . WESTERN CLIFFORD BAY, BAY 524000 N 1291000 W REGION ARISTAZABAL ISLAND, B.C.

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 1 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls 14 M03W0092 CLASS 5 OTHER 06-Jun-03 ABERDONIA FISHING - . WESTERN MALACCA PASSAGE, AT SEA 540806 N 1301640 W N UNSPECIFIED REGION B.C. (GENERAL) 15 M03W0093 CLASS 5 OTHER 13-Jun-03 MISS LYNA FISHING - PROPELL WESTERN PORCHER INLET, CHANNEL / 535800 N 1302700 W UNSPECIFIED ER - REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND FOULED BY ROPE

16 M03W0104 CLASS 5 OTHER 18-Jun-03 SAILA FISHING - MACHINE WESTERN HECATE STR., NEAR CHANNEL / 531410 N 1302500 W UNSPECIFIED RY REGION WALLER BAY, BANKS STRAIT / SOUND FAILURE - ISLAND, B.C. GENERA L

17 M03W0131 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 10-Jul-03 VITAMIN FISHING - . WESTERN BARRETT ROCK, HARBOUR AREA - 541447 N 1302000 W SEA IV UNSPECIFIED REGION PRINCE RUPERT GENERAL HARBOUR, B.C. 18 M03W0145 CLASS 5 OTHER 21-Jul-03 DELTA FISHING - . WESTERN BELLA BELLA FUEL HARBOUR - 521000 N 1280800 W SPIRIT(13K9 UNSPECIFIED REGION DOCK, B.C. WITHIN I.E. 6032) IMMEDIATE AREA 19 M03W0156 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 30-Jul-03 GO CONG FISHING - . WESTERN WEST SIDE OF CHANNEL / 520606 N 1280656 W (CFV 30587) TRAWLER/DRAG REGION WALKER ISLAND, STRAIT / SOUND GER B.C. 20 M03W0159 CLASS 5 OTHER 31-Jul-03 EASY FISHING - MACHINE WESTERN BUTEDALE, GRAHAM CHANNEL / 530900 N 1283630 W PASSAGE TROLLER RY REGION REACH, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND FAILURE - GENERA L

21 M03W0189 CLASS 5 OTHER 15-Aug-03 MISS NOEL FISHING - PROPELL WESTERN COSTE ISLAND, B.C. CHANNEL / 534800 N 1284700 W GILLNET ER - REGION STRAIT / SOUND FOULED BY ROPE

22 M03W0190 CLASS 5 OTHER 21-Aug-03 SILVER FISHING - . WESTERN FISHER CHANNEL, CHANNEL / 515700 N 1275800 W VIKING UNSPECIFIED REGION LAGOON BAY, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 23 M03W0208 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 28-Sep-03 GORDON LIFEBOAT/SEARC . WESTERN CARTWRIGHT CHANNEL / 530158 N 1292758 W REID H AND RESCUE REGION SHOAL, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 24 M03W0223 CLASS 5 STRIKING 26-Oct-03 QUEEN OF FERRY - . WESTERN MCLOUGHLIN BAY, BAY 520800 N 1280550 W PRINCE PASSENGER/VEH REGION B.C. RUPERT ICLE

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 2 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls 25 M03W0244 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 22-Nov-03 TALLY IV FISHING - . WESTERN SPIDER HARBOUR AREA - 514911 N 1281306 W UNSPECIFIED REGION ANCHORAGE, GENERAL QUEENS SOUND, B.C. 26 M03W0249 CLASS 5 OTHER 16-Nov-03 GENERAL TUG - OTHER CARGO WESTERN IDOL POINT, B.C. CHANNEL / 521400 N 1281600 W JACKSON SHIFTED REGION STRAIT / SOUND 27 M03W0255 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 09-Dec-03 THETIS FISHING - . WESTERN MATHIESON CHANNEL / 522359 N 1282031 W QUEEN UNSPECIFIED REGION CHANNEL, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 28 M03W0260 CLASS 5 STRIKING 12-Dec-03 COAST PATROL BOAT . WESTERN NEWCOMBE CHANNEL / 534142 N 1300621 W RANGER REGION HARBOUR, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 29 M03W0266 CLASS 5 OTHER 22-Dec-03 UNK/INC FISHING - COLLISIO WESTERN NORTH OF BAKER CHANNEL / 532200 N 1291900 W FISHING UNSPECIFIED N - NEAR REGION INLET, GRENVILLE STRAIT / SOUND VESSEL 1 CHANNEL, B.C. CLOSE QUARTERS 30 M04W0004 CLASS 5 OTHER 03-Jan-04 FURY BAY FISHING - BEACHIN WESTERN BELLA BELLA, B.C. HARBOUR - 521013 N 1280831 W UNSPECIFIED G REGION WITHIN I.E. IMMEDIATE AREA 31 M04W0018 CLASS 5 CAPSIZING 27-Jan-04 LARISSA FISHING - LINE- . WESTERN GRENVILLE CHANNEL / 532531 N 1292545 W FISHING & REGION CHANNEL, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND SEINER 32 M04W0023 CLASS 5 OTHER 10-Feb-04 HENRY BAY FISHING - OTHER - WESTERN NEPEAN SOUND, CHANNEL / 531200 N 1293600 W UNSPECIFIED MISC. REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 33 M04W0034 CLASS 3 CAPSIZING 26-Feb-04 HOPE BAY FISHING - . WESTERN QUEEN CHARLOTTE AT SEA 512322 N 1290841 W TROLLER REGION SOUND, B.C. (GENERAL) 34 M04W0051 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 22-Mar-04 ALLAVERDY FISHING - SEINER . WESTERN WALKER ISLAND, CHANNEL / 520600 N 1280700 W REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 35 M04W0053 CLASS 5 OTHER 25-Mar-04 EMIL K FISHING - SEINER PROPELL WESTERN FERRIE ISLAND, CHANNEL / 521440 N 1281336 W ER - REGION SEAFORTH STRAIT / SOUND FOULED CHANNEL, B.C. BY ROPE

36 M04W0060 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 09-Apr-04 PATRIATE FISHING - . WESTERN SOUTH OF CHANNEL / 530906 N 1283800 W UNSPECIFIED REGION BUTEDALE IN STRAIT / SOUND GRAHAM REACH, B.C. 37 M04W0068 CLASS 5 OTHER 26-Apr-04 PACIFIC FISHING - MACHINE WESTERN FITZHUGH SOUND, CHANNEL / 514855 N 1275458 W QUEST UNSPECIFIED RY REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND FAILURE - GENERA L

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 3 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls 38 M04W0084 CLASS 5 OTHER 02-Jun-04 LISA MARIE FISHING - ENGINE WESTERN HARMSTON ISLAND, CHANNEL / 521200 N 1280600 W UNSPECIFIED ROOM REGION SEAWORTH STRAIT / SOUND PROBLE CHANNEL, B.C. MS - GENERA L 39 M04W0089 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 04-Jun-04 LION HEART FISHING - . WESTERN NAMU HARBOUR, IN HARBOUR - 515158 N 1275336 W 2 GILLNET REGION FITZHUGH SOUND, WITHIN I.E. B.C. IMMEDIATE AREA 40 M04W0097 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 10-Jun-04 BRITTANY FISHING - . WESTERN SOUTH OF PRINCE HARBOUR AREA - 541150 N 1301400 W BAY UNSPECIFIED REGION RUPERT HARBOUR, GENERAL B.C. 41 M04W0098 CLASS 5 OTHER 12-Jun-04 SEA SONG FISHING - OTHER - WESTERN GRENVILLE CHANNEL / 534326 N 1295011 W NO. 1 GILLNET MISC. REGION CHANNEL, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 42 M04W0100 CLASS 5 STRIKING 16-Jun-04 MLT HWY BARGE - . WESTERN NEW WESTMINSTER, RIVER 541100 N 1300200 W UNSPECIFIED REGION B.C.

43 M04W0114 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 24-Jun-04 LILY M FISHING - . WESTERN NORTH END OF CHANNEL / 522200 N 1282500 W UNSPECIFIED REGION MOSS PASS, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 44 M04W0118 CLASS 5 OTHER 29-Jun-04 ALHENA FISHING - . WESTERN WEST OF GOOSE CHANNEL / 515300 N 1285100 W UNSPECIFIED REGION ISLANDS, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 45 M04W0125 CLASS 5 FLOODING 30-Jun-04 SEASPAN BARGE - CARGO . WESTERN SURF INLET, BAY 525300 N 1290600 W FORESTER REGION CAMPANIA SOUND, B.C. 46 M04W0128 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 08-Jul-04 CHERYL C. FISHING - . WESTERN SKEENA RIVER BAY 540706 N 1300601 W UNSPECIFIED REGION MOUTH, B.C. 47 M04W0136 CLASS 5 OTHER 23-Jul-04 WESTERN FISHING - . WESTERN NAMU HARBOUR, HARBOUR AREA - 515200 N 1275400 W ROVER UNSPECIFIED REGION FITZHUGH SOUND, GENERAL B.C. 48 M04W0137 CLASS 5 OTHER 24-Jul-04 QUEEN OF FERRY - COLLISIO WESTERN ABEAM POINTER CHANNEL / 520600 N 1275600 W THE NORTH PASSENGER/VEH N - NEAR REGION ISLAND, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND ICLE 49 M04W0140 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 19-Jul-04 OPAL T FISHING - . WESTERN KENNEDY ISLAND, CHANNEL / 535916 N 1301057 W (13K99958) UNSPECIFIED REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 50 M04W0163 CLASS 5 FIRE/EXPLOSIO 06-Aug-04 SATSUMA FISHING - . WESTERN LAGOON BAY, CHANNEL / 520147 N 1275446 W N GILLNET REGION FITZHUGH SOUND, STRAIT / SOUND B.C. 51 M04W0164 CLASS 5 OTHER 09-Aug-04 TANNER'S FISHING - PROPELL WESTERN DEHORSLEY ISLAND, CHANNEL / 540743 N 1300508 W QUEST GILLNET ER - REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND FOULED BY NET 52 M04W0168 CLASS 5 STRIKING 16-Aug-04 HAIDA TUG - OTHER . WESTERN PRINCESS ROYAL CHANNEL / 531050 N 1284206 W CHIEFTAIN REGION CHANNEL, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 4 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls 53 M04W0176 CLASS 5 FIRE/EXPLOSIO 22-Aug-04 GOLD FISHING - . WESTERN CLIFF BLUFF, LAMA CHANNEL - 520454 N 1280254 W N GILLNET REGION PASSAGE, B.C. APPROACH (GENERAL) 54 M04W0187 CLASS 5 OTHER 02-Sep-04 QUEEN OF FERRY - COLLISIO WESTERN GENN ISLANDS, B.C. CHANNEL / 540600 N 1301700 W THE NORTH PASSENGER/VEH N - NEAR REGION STRAIT / SOUND ICLE 55 M04W0190 CLASS 5 OTHER 03-Sep-04 LESLIE LISA FISHING - ENGINE WESTERN BELLA BELLA, CHANNEL / 520400 N 1280700 W UNSPECIFIED FAILURE REGION GERMAN POINT, BC STRAIT / SOUND 56 M04W0209 CLASS 5 FLOODING 08-Oct-04 PUBNICO FISHING - . WESTERN LAREDO SOUND, BC CHANNEL / 521943 N 1284700 W GEMINI PACKER/BAIT/TR REGION STRAIT / SOUND ANSFER 57 M04W0215 CLASS 5 STRIKING 13-Oct-04 SANKO GENERAL CARGO . WESTERN KITIMAT HARBOUR, HARBOUR - 534900 N 1285200 W SPRING REGION BC WITHIN I.E. IMMEDIATE AREA 58 M04W0218 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 17-Oct-04 SANDERLIN FISHING - . WESTERN LAMA PASSAGE, B.C. CHANNEL / 520401 N 1280159 W G NO. 1 LONGLINER REGION STRAIT / SOUND 59 M04W0243 CLASS 5 SINKING 18-Nov-04 WORKBOAT WORKBOAT/TEN . WESTERN CHATHAM SOUND, CHANNEL / 540700 N 1303000 W NO. 6 DER TUG REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 60 M05W0001 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 03-Jan-05 ROBERT FISHING - . WESTERN COAST ISLAND, B.C. CHANNEL / 541244 N 1301955 W ALLEN UNSPECIFIED REGION STRAIT / SOUND 61 M05W0019 CLASS 5 OTHER 18-Feb-05 WESTERN TUG - OTHER COLLISIO WESTERN TOLMIE CHANNEL, CHANNEL / 524100 N 1283300 W NAVIGATOR N - NEAR REGION SPLIT HEAD, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND

62 M05W0028 CLASS 5 OTHER 05-Mar-05 DEBRA MAR FISHING - MACHINE WESTERN PETREL CHANNEL, CHANNEL / 534839 N 1301641 W UNSPECIFIED RY REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND FAILURE - GENERA L

63 M05W0035 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 13-Mar-05 GREAT FISHING - . WESTERN WALKER ISLAND, CHANNEL / 520400 N 1280700 W NORTHERN UNSPECIFIED REGION SOUTH OF BELLA STRAIT / SOUND 6 BELLA, B.C. 64 M05W0036 CLASS 5 OTHER 16-Mar-05 MIKE TUG - OTHER MACHINE WESTERN MILBANKE SOUND, CHANNEL / 522157 N 1283146 W O'LEARY RY REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND FAILURE - GENERA L

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 5 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls 65 M05W0041 CLASS 5 OTHER 10-Mar-05 QUEEN OF FERRY - MACHINE WESTERN LAMA PASSAGE, B.C. CHANNEL / 520850 N 1280815 W PRINCE PASSENGER/VEH RY REGION STRAIT / SOUND RUPERT ICLE FAILURE - GENERA L

66 M05W0064 CLASS 5 OTHER 27-Apr-05 NORGATE FISHING - ENGINE WESTERN HASTINGS ISLAND, CHANNEL / 523755 N 1285015 W UNSPECIFIED FAILURE REGION LAREDO SOUND, STRAIT / SOUND B.C. 67 M05W0077 CLASS 5 OTHER 17-May-05 BONANZA IV FISHING - ENGINE WESTERN DOUGLAS CHANNEL, CHANNEL / 535000 N 1285000 W LONGLINER FAILURE REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 68 M05W0089 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 05-Jun-05 SHERRY FISHING - . WESTERN INVERNESS CHANNEL / 541144 N 1301425 W JAY I UNSPECIFIED REGION CHANNEL, CHATHAM STRAIT / SOUND SOUND, B.C.

69 M05W0100 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 14-May-05 NORA C FISHING - . WESTERN DALLAS ISLAND, B.C. CHANNEL / 522115 N 1282855 W UNSPECIFIED REGION STRAIT / SOUND 70 M05W0119 CLASS 5 OTHER 07-Jul-05 G.C. 27 BARGE - CRANE / FUEL - WESTERN IVORY ISLAND, B.C. CHANNEL / 521654 N 1282754 W DERRICK BLOCKA REGION STRAIT / SOUND GE 71 M05W0120 CLASS 5 OTHER 09-Jul-05 MAJESTIC FISHING - FUEL - WESTERN GOOSE BANK, CHANNEL / 513418 N 1292712 W BELLE II TROLLER BLOCKA REGION QUEEN CHARLOTTE STRAIT / SOUND GE SOUND, B.C. 72 M05W0124 CLASS 5 OTHER 13-Jul-05 ISLAND TUG - OTHER MACHINE WESTERN ORMISTON POINT, CHANNEL / 533230 N 1293630 W PROVIDOUR RY REGION GRENVILLE STRAIT / SOUND I FAILURE - CHANNEL, B.C. GENERA L

73 M05W0137 CLASS 5 OTHER 21-Jul-05 QUEEN OF FERRY - MACHINE WESTERN SEAFORTH CHANNEL / 521318 N 1280942 W THE NORTH PASSENGER/VEH RY REGION CHANNEL, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND ICLE FAILURE - GENERA L

74 M05W0138 CLASS 5 PROPELLER/R 24-Jul-05 MOON FISHING - . WESTERN EGG ISLAND, QUEEN CHANNEL / 511200 N 1275100 W UDDER/STRUC BEAM TROLLER REGION CHARLOTTE SOUND, STRAIT / SOUND TURAL B.C. DAMAGE 75 M05W0146 CLASS 5 COLLISION 30-Jul-05 ROYAL FISHING - . WESTERN PRINCE RUPERT CHANNEL - 541134 N 1302052 W PRIDE UNSPECIFIED REGION HARBOUR, B.C. APPROACH (GENERAL)

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 6 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls 76 M05W0151 CLASS 5 OTHER 09-Aug-05 JOEL A FISHING - ENGINE WESTERN LOWE INLET, CHANNEL / 533300 N 1293700 W GILLNET FAILURE REGION GRENVILLE STRAIT / SOUND CHANNEL, B.C. 77 M05W0166 CLASS 5 OTHER 03-Sep-05 KITIMAT II FISHING . WESTERN HARTLEY BAY, B.C. CHANNEL / 532500 N 1291500 W PROTECTION REGION STRAIT / SOUND 78 M05W0178 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 25-Sep-05 LADY FISHING - . WESTERN HANMER ISLAND, BC CHANNEL / 540326 N 1301512 W DEBBIE UNSPECIFIED REGION STRAIT / SOUND 79 M05W0187 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 11-Oct-05 DANNY & FISHING - . WESTERN PRINCESS ROYAL CHANNEL / 531057 N 1284352 W DAVID UNSPECIFIED REGION CHANNEL, STRAIT / SOUND BUTEDALE, BC 80 M05W0209 CLASS 5 OTHER 29-Oct-05 ANCHORAG BARGE - RAIL . WESTERN BELLA BELLA, BC CHANNEL / 521000 N 1280800 W E PROVIDER REGION STRAIT / SOUND

81 M05W0223 CLASS 5 FIRE/EXPLOSIO 02-Dec-05 SEA FISHING - . WESTERN CHATHAM SOUND, CHANNEL / 541030 N 1302400 W N HARVEST LONGLINER REGION BC. STRAIT / SOUND 82 M05W0229 CLASS 5 PROPELLER/R 09-Dec-05 CAPTAIN FISHING - . WESTERN DRYAD POINT AT SEA 521000 N 1281200 W UDDER/STRUC LOWLINER UNSPECIFIED REGION LIGHTSTATION (GENERAL) TURAL DOCK, BC DAMAGE 83 M06W0001 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 05-Jan-06 SEA BAR FISHING - . WESTERN PRUTH BAY, BC BAY 513927 N 1280741 W UNSPECIFIED REGION 84 M06W0009 CLASS 5 OTHER 15-Jan-06 SILVER BAY TUG - OTHER CARGO - WESTERN GREENVILLE CHANNEL / 535000 N 1300100 W VIII LOST REGION CHANNEL, BC STRAIT / SOUND OVERBO ARD 85 M06W0020 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 02-Feb-06 WESTERN FISHING - SEINER . WESTERN OGDEN CHANNEL, CHANNEL - 535441 N 1301233 W MONARCH REGION BC APPROACH (GENERAL) 86 M06W0022 CLASS 5 OTHER 06-Feb-06 OSCAR RESEARCH CONTAC WESTERN JANE ISLAND, CHANNEL - 523802 N 1283101 W DYSON GENERAL/PATRO T WITH REGION FINLAYSON APPROACH L THE CHANNEL, BC (GENERAL) BOTTOM 87 M06W0042 CLASS 5 OTHER 14-Mar-06 PACHENA FISHING - SEINER MACHINE WESTERN HIGGINS PASSAGE, CHANNEL / 522800 N 1283900 W NO. 1 RY REGION BC STRAIT / SOUND FAILURE - GENERA L

88 M06W0052 CLASS 2 GROUNDING 22-Mar-06 QUEEN OF FERRY - . WESTERN JUAN POINT, GILL CHANNEL / 531900 N 1291330 W THE NORTH PASSENGER/VEH REGION ISLAND, BC STRAIT / SOUND ICLE 89 M06W0053 CLASS 5 OTHER 21-Mar-06 OCEAN FISHING - . WESTERN CALVERT ISLAND, BC CHANNEL / 513100 N 1275400 W PRINCE II GILLNET REGION STRAIT / SOUND

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 7 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls 90 M06W0055 CLASS 5 FLOODING 24-Mar-06 PACIFIC FISHING - SEINER . WESTERN PORT EDWARD, BC HARBOUR - 541200 N 1301900 W HORIZON REGION WITHIN I.E. IMMEDIATE AREA 91 M06W0068 CLASS 5 FLOODING 07-May-06 ALASKA FISHING - SEINER . WESTERN RIPPON POINT, CHANNEL / 535355 N 1301041 W QUEEN II REGION NORTH END OF PITT STRAIT / SOUND ISLAND, BC 92 M06W0073 CLASS 5 OTHER 16-May-06 INDIAN FISHING - ENGINE WESTERN FOUL BAY, BANKS BAY 532103 N 1301047 W GIVER UNSPECIFIED FAILURE REGION ISLAND, BC 93 M06W0084 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 12-Jun-06 JOY FISHING - . WESTERN IVORY ISLAND, BC CHANNEL / 521628 N 1282207 W TROLLER REGION STRAIT / SOUND 94 M06W0088 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 22-Jun-06 COPPER FISHING - . WESTERN HUNTER ISLAND, CHANNEL / 515508 N 1275810 W SUNRISE GILLNET REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 95 M06W0093 CLASS 5 OTHER 28-Jun-06 VICTOR FISHING - CONTAC WESTERN ELEANOR PASS, B.C. CHANNEL / 540850 N 1300740 W GILLNET T WITH REGION STRAIT / SOUND THE BOTTOM 96 M06W0104 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 20-Jul-06 CAPE FISHING - . WESTERN CHASSEPOT ROCK, HARBOUR AREA - 541200 N 1302400 W STEPHEN UNSPECIFIED REGION PRINCE RUPERT GENERAL HARBOUR, BC 97 M06W0113 CLASS 5 FIRE/EXPLOSIO 20-Jul-06 BARRIER FISHING - . WESTERN PORPOISE HARBOUR AREA - 541107 N 1301850 W N ROCK GILLNET REGION CHANNEL, PRINCE GENERAL RUPERT, B.C. 98 M06W0118 CLASS 5 STRIKING 27-Jul-06 PARRY PASSENGER . WESTERN PORT JOHN, BC CHANNEL / 520730 N 1275042 W REGION STRAIT / SOUND 99 M06W0125 CLASS 5 FLOODING 01-Aug-06 DIANE X FISHING - . WESTERN KITIMAT, BC HARBOUR AREA - 534800 N 1285200 W UNSPECIFIED REGION GENERAL 100 M06W0126 CLASS 5 FLOODING 01-Aug-06 BONANZA IV FISHING - . WESTERN KITKIATA INLET, CHANNEL / 533800 N 1291400 W LONGLINER REGION DOUGLAS CHANNEL, STRAIT / SOUND BC 101 M06W0130 CLASS 5 OTHER 04-Aug-06 PACIFIC FISHING - SEINER . WESTERN PRINCE RUPERT HARBOUR AREA - 540800 N 1301700 W HORIZON REGION HARBOUR, B.C. GENERAL 102 M06W0131 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 07-Aug-06 BLUE FISHING - . WESTERN POINT CUMMINGS, CHANNEL / 531700 N 1290600 W PACIFIC NO. UNSPECIFIED REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 1 103 M06W0134 CLASS 5 OTHER 09-Aug-06 NORDIC FISHING - . WESTERN QUEEN CHARLOTTE CHANNEL / 513449 N 1294259 W SPIRIT UNSPECIFIED REGION SOUND, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 104 M06W0146 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 28-Aug-06 SEA FISHING - . WESTERN SQUALLY CHANNEL, CHANNEL / 533339 N 1293833 W HUNTER UNSPECIFIED REGION BC STRAIT / SOUND 105 M06W0161 CLASS 5 OTHER 13-Sep-06 SEA WAY 2 FISHING - ENGINE WESTERN TSUM TSADI INLET, CHANNEL / 541024 N 1301700 W GILLNET FAILURE REGION SMITH ISLAND, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 106 M06W0163 CLASS 5 OTHER 19-Sep-06 MISS TAKEN FISHING - ENGINE WESTERN PRINCE RUPERT, BC CHANNEL / 540800 N 1302900 W UNSPECIFIED FAILURE REGION STRAIT / SOUND

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 8 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls 107 M06W0164 CLASS 5 OTHER 20-Sep-06 HAIDA TUG - OTHER BROKE WESTERN SEAFORTH CHANNEL / 521954 N 1283018 W CHIEFTAIN TOW REGION CHANNEL, BC STRAIT / SOUND AND LEFT ADRIFT 108 M06W0165 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 20-Sep-06 P.E. 232 FISHING - . WESTERN BEAVER PASSAGE, CHANNEL / 534513 N 1302148 W UNSPECIFIED REGION SOUTH SPICER STRAIT / SOUND ISLAND, BC 109 M06W0171 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 04-Oct-06 JACK TUG - OTHER . WESTERN NORTH GRENVILLE CHANNEL / 535307 N 1300403 W BRUSCO REGION CHANNEL, PITT STRAIT / SOUND POINT, B.C. 110 M06W0181 CLASS 5 OTHER 12-Oct-06 QUEEN OF FERRY - COLLISIO WESTERN PRINCE RUPERT HARBOUR - 541100 N 1302000 W PRINCE PASSENGER/VEH N - NEAR REGION HARBOUR, B.C. WITHIN I.E. RUPERT ICLE IMMEDIATE AREA 111 M06W0182 CLASS 5 OTHER 23-Sep-06 KYNOCH PASSENGER . WESTERN LAREDO INLET, B.C. CHANNEL / 523800 N 1284540 W QUEENS REGION STRAIT / SOUND 112 M06W0187 CLASS 5 OTHER 23-Oct-06 BECKY JO FISHING - MACHINE WESTERN ARTHUR PASSAGE, CHANNEL / 535431 N 1300836 W UNSPECIFIED RY REGION BANKS ISLAND, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND FAILURE - GENERA L

113 M06W0192 CLASS 5 FIRE/EXPLOSIO 04-Nov-06 QUEEN OF FERRY - . WESTERN SEAFORTH CHANNEL / 521200 N 1280600 W N PRINCE PASSENGER/VEH REGION CHANNEL, BC STRAIT / SOUND RUPERT ICLE 114 M06W0213 CLASS 5 STRIKING 03-Dec-06 STAR GENERAL CARGO . WESTERN KITIMAT EUROCAN HARBOUR - 535942 N 1284048 W INDIANA REGION TERMINAL, BC WITHIN I.E. IMMEDIATE AREA 115 M06W0222 CLASS 5 OTHER 24-Dec-06 MALOLA SMALL CRAFT MACHINE WESTERN IDOL POINT, CHANNEL / 521440 N 1281600 W (UNLICENSED & RY REGION SEAFORTH STRAIT / SOUND UNREGISTERED) FAILURE - CHANNEL, B.C. GENERA L

116 M07W0025 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 09-Mar-07 JUDI B FISHING - . WESTERN GRENVILLE CHANNEL / 532600 N 1292610 W UNSPECIFIED REGION CHANNEL, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 117 M07W0027 CLASS 5 FIRE/EXPLOSIO 09-Mar-07 ISLAND TUG - OTHER . WESTERN LORETTA ISLAND, CHANNEL / 534308 N 1284902 W N CHAMPION REGION DEVASTATION STRAIT / SOUND CHANNEL, B.C. 118 M07W0030 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 19-Mar-07 SEA TUG - OTHER . WESTERN OFF SERPENT CHANNEL / 520406 N 1275907 W VOYAGER REGION POINT, LAMA PASS, STRAIT / SOUND B.C.

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 9 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls 119 M07W0045 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 13-Apr-07 GULF TUG - OTHER . WESTERN GARDNER CANAL, CHANNEL / 533145 N 1284418 W PRINCE REGION NORTH RIX ISLAND, STRAIT / SOUND B.C. 120 M07W0050 CLASS 5 OTHER 22-Apr-07 NORTHERN PASSENGER MACHINE WESTERN MCLOUGHLIN BAY, CHANNEL / 520823 N 1280850 W ADVENTURE RY REGION LAMA PASS, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND FAILURE - GENERA L

121 M07W0070 CLASS 5 COLLISION 30-May-07 GULF FISHING - . WESTERN FRASER REACH, B.C. RIVER 531100 N 1284200 W MAIDEN LONGLINER REGION 122 M07W0076 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 09-Jun-07 SEATOW TUG - OTHER . WESTERN MILLBANK SOUND, CHANNEL / 522118 N 1282000 W REGION MOSS PASSAGE, BC STRAIT / SOUND

123 M07W0080 CLASS 5 STRIKING 14-Jun-07 PENDER TUG - OTHER . WESTERN CHARLES CHANNEL / 523024 N 1282506 W CHIEF REGION NARROWS, STRAIT / SOUND FINLAYSON CHANNEL, BC 124 M07W0100 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 25-Jul-07 PROGRESS FISHING - SEINER . WESTERN GRENVILLE CHANNEL / 532200 N 1291900 W OR REGION CHANNEL, BC STRAIT / SOUND 125 M07W0106 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 31-Jul-07 B.C. FISHING - . WESTERN PORPOISE HARBOUR AREA - 541120 N 1302002 W VALOUR GILLNET REGION HARBOUR, B.C. GENERAL 126 M07W0118 CLASS 5 OTHER 28-Aug-07 GEROI FISHING - FISH . WESTERN WEST OF CALVERT CHANNEL / 513800 N 1282600 W SHIRONINTS FACTORY REGION ISLAND, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND Y 127 M07W0124 CLASS 5 OTHER 07-Sep-07 REID PASS FISHING - . WESTERN CHISMORE CHANNEL / 540205 N 1301810 W UNSPECIFIED REGION PASSAGE, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 128 M07W0127 CLASS 5 STRIKING 15-Sep-07 QUEEN OF FERRY - . WESTERN MCLOUGHLIN BAY, BAY 520830 N 1280800 W PRINCE PASSENGER/VEH REGION BC RUPERT ICLE 129 M07W0132 CLASS 5 OTHER 25-Sep-07 SOUTHERN FISHING - COLLISIO WESTERN MARY ANNE POINT, CHANNEL / 514805 N 1281805 W RIDGE UNSPECIFIED N - NEAR REGION ACTIVE PASS, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND

130 M07W0143 CLASS 5 OTHER 03-Feb-07 NEW BULK CARRIER GROUND WESTERN PRINCE RUPERT HARBOUR - 541107 N 1302303 W LEADER ING - REGION ANCHORAGE "X", WITHIN I.E. NEAR B.C. IMMEDIATE AREA 131 M07W0145 CLASS 5 OTHER 02-Mar-07 CAPITANO BULK CARRIER GROUND WESTERN PRINCE RUPERT, HARBOUR AREA - 541200 N 1302210 W GIOVANNI ING - REGION ANCHORAGE "X", GENERAL NEAR B.C.

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 10 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls 132 M07W0156 CLASS 5 OTHER 04-Nov-07 YUCATA TUG - OTHER MACHINE WESTERN WRIGHT SOUND, BC CHANNEL / 532042 N 1291536 W SPIRIT RY REGION STRAIT / SOUND FAILURE - GENERA L

133 M07W0166 CLASS 5 FLOODING 20-Nov-07 BANKS FISHING - . WESTERN MATHIESON CHANNEL / 522857 N 1281635 W ISLAND UNSPECIFIED REGION CHANNEL, BC STRAIT / SOUND 134 M07W0167 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 21-Nov-07 SHARI GALE FISHING - . WESTERN FITZHUGH SOUND, CHANNEL / 515839 N 1275451 W UNSPECIFIED REGION FOGROCKS, BC STRAIT / SOUND 135 M07W0174 CLASS 5 OTHER 10-Dec-07 PATTAYA FISHING - BEACHIN WESTERN BANKS ISLAND, B.C. CHANNEL / 531000 N 1295500 W UNSPECIFIED G REGION STRAIT / SOUND 136 M07W0177 CLASS 5 OTHER 12-Dec-07 LAST CALL CREW-BOAT ENGINE WESTERN SEPARATION HEAD, CHANNEL / 524100 N 1283300 W FAILURE REGION SEYMOUR STRAIT / SOUND NARROWS, BC 137 M07W0181 CLASS 5 OTHER 17-Dec-07 INLET TUG - OTHER ENGINE WESTERN IDOL POINT, CHANNEL / 521400 N 1281600 W CHALLENGE TROUBL REGION SEAFORTH STRAIT / SOUND R E CHANNEL, B.C. 138 M07W0182 CLASS 5 STRIKING 19-Dec-07 THUNDERST FISHING - . WESTERN GRAHAM REACH, CHANNEL / 530242 N 1283200 W RUCK UNSPECIFIED REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 139 M08W0001 CLASS 5 OTHER 02-Jan-08 NORTHERN PASSENGER ENGINE WESTERN LAMA PASS, CHANNEL / 520835 N 1280803 W ADVENTURE FAILURE REGION MCLOUGHLIN BAY, STRAIT / SOUND BC 140 M08W0007 CLASS 5 OTHER 08-Jan-08 SAGA BULK CARRIER . WESTERN HECATE STRAIT, BC CHANNEL / 515900 N 1295454 W HORIZON REGION STRAIT / SOUND 141 M08W0009 CLASS 5 OTHER 09-Jan-08 STAR GENERAL CARGO CARGO WESTERN QUEEN CHARLOTTE CHANNEL / 513000 N 1300000 W IKEBANA SHIFTED REGION SOUND, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 142 M08W0013 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 10-Jan-08 44G1 PATROL BOAT . WESTERN JACKSON PASS CHANNEL / 523124 N 1281754 W REGION NARROWS. B.C STRAIT / SOUND 143 M08W0019 CLASS 5 FLOODING 24-Jan-08 CAPE ANN FISHING - . WESTERN SWANSON BAY, B.C BAY 530005 N 1280954 W TROLLER REGION 144 M08W0022 CLASS 5 PROPELLER/R 02-Feb-08 WESTSHOR BARGE - . WESTERN TOM BAY, DON BAY 522342 N 1281200 W UDDER/STRUC E NUMBER 1 ACCOMMODATIO REGION PENINSULA, BC TURAL N DAMAGE 145 M08W0039 CLASS 5 OTHER 26-Feb-08 ENERGY BULK CARRIER OTHER - WESTERN PRINCE RUPERT, BC HARBOUR AREA - 511924 N 1302024 W TRADE MISC. REGION GENERAL 146 M08W0048 CLASS 5 OTHER 08-Mar-08 GYPSY FISHING - . WESTERN FITZ HUGH SOUND, CHANNEL / 514348 N 1275548 W SOUL UNSPECIFIED REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 147 M08W0051 CLASS 5 STRIKING 11-Mar-08 SOUTH BULK CARRIER . WESTERN PRINCE RUPERT, HARBOUR AREA - 541336 N 1302030 W FORTUNE REGION B.C. GENERAL

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 11 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls 148 M08W0076 CLASS 5 OTHER 01-May-08 NORTHISLE FISHING - SEINER COLLISIO WESTERN QUEEN CHARLOTTE CHANNEL / 510100 N 1282100 W & TRAWLER N - NEAR REGION SOUND, BC STRAIT / SOUND

149 M08W0077 CLASS 5 OTHER 01-May-08 CORY J FISHING - . WESTERN BISHOP COVE, BC CHANNEL / 532555 N 1284336 W UNSPECIFIED REGION STRAIT / SOUND 150 M08W0083 CLASS 5 OTHER 12-May-08 LISA GALE FISHING - MACHINE WESTERN ARTHUR PASSAGE, CHANNEL / 540340 N 1301542 W UNSPECIFIED RY REGION BC STRAIT / SOUND FAILURE - GENERA L

151 M08W0087 CLASS 5 OTHER 14-May-08 EDGE FISHING - ENGINE WESTERN QUEEN CHARLOTTE CHANNEL / 511100 N 1293600 W TROLLER FAILURE REGION SOUND STRAIT / SOUND 152 M08W0092 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 26-May-08 GRIZZLY 1 TUG - OTHER . WESTERN SOUTH OF DE CHANNEL / 540700 N 1301042 W REGION HORSEY ISLAND, BC STRAIT / SOUND

153 M08W0094 CLASS 5 SINKING 30-May-08 KRAFT TUG - OTHER . WESTERN MISTKATLA, CHANNEL / 534858 N 1285557 W MASTER REGION DOUGLAS CHANNEL, STRAIT / SOUND BC 154 M08W0098 CLASS 5 FLOODING 02-Jun-08 ERMELINA FISHING - . WESTERN REID PASS, BC CHANNEL / 521836 N 1282154 W PACKER/BAIT/TR REGION STRAIT / SOUND ANSFER 155 M08W0111 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 18-Jun-08 LA-FLEUR FISHING - . WESTERN LOWE INLET, CHANNEL / 533300 N 1293500 W UNSPECIFIED REGION GRENVILLE STRAIT / SOUND CHANNEL, B.C. 156 M08W0112 CLASS 5 OTHER 18-Jun-08 SILVER FISHING - MACHINE WESTERN PEARSE CANAL, B.C. CANAL - 540444 N 1301215 W SPRAY IV UNSPECIFIED RY REGION INCLUDING FAILURE - SEAWAY GENERA L

157 M08W0114 CLASS 5 OTHER 20-Jun-08 STAR GENERAL CARGO OTHER - WESTERN KITIMAT, B.C. HARBOUR - 535900 N 1284100 W OSAKANA MISC. REGION WITHIN I.E. IMMEDIATE AREA 158 M08W0116 CLASS 5 OTHER 21-Jun-08 SUSAN G FISHING - ENGINE WESTERN QUEEN CHARLOTTE CHANNEL / 511645 N 1285812 W TROLLER FAILURE REGION SOUND, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 159 M08W0120 CLASS 5 OTHER 24-Jun-08 KRISTY RAE FISHING - ENGINE WESTERN BERNIE ISLAND, BC BAY 533640 N 1302650 W GILLNET FAILURE REGION 160 M08W0136 CLASS 5 FLOODING 08-Jul-08 SKEENA FISHING - . WESTERN SKEENA RIVER, B.C. RIVER 540930 N 1300548 W PRINCESS UNSPECIFIED REGION 161 M08W0141 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 15-Jul-08 FREE SPIRIT FISHING - . WESTERN PRINCIPE CHANNEL, CHANNEL / 532223 N 1294653 W UNSPECIFIED REGION BC STRAIT / SOUND

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 12 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls 162 M08W0151 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 21-Jul-08 HELENA FISHING - . WESTERN PORPOISE CHANNEL / 541142 N 1301918 W (13K57197) GILLNET REGION CHANNEL, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND 163 M08W0156 CLASS 5 OTHER 24-Jul-08 NORTHERN PASSENGER OTHER - WESTERN GRENVILLE CHANNEL / 535212 N 1300412 W ADVENTURE MISC. REGION CHANNEL, B.C. STRAIT / SOUND

164 M08W0157 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 03-Aug-08 TSIMSHIAN PASSENGER . WESTERN MARRICK ISLAND, CHANNEL / 535612 N 1300824 W STORM REGION BC STRAIT / SOUND 165 M08W0158 CLASS 5 GROUNDING 24-Jul-08 QUEEN FISHING - . WESTERN INVERNESS RIVER 541136 N 1301430 W MARY TROLLER REGION PASSAGE, BC 166 M08W0169 CLASS 5 OTHER 07-Aug-08 CLIPPER PASSENGER COLLISIO WESTERN MILLBANK SOUND, CHANNEL / 522600 N 1282930 W ODYSSEY N - NEAR REGION B.C. STRAIT / SOUND

167 M08W0188 CLASS 5 SINKING 29-Aug-08 STYX TUG - OTHER . WESTERN PORPOISE HARBOUR - 541340 N 1301748 W REGION HARBOUR, BC WITHIN I.E. IMMEDIATE AREA 168 M08W0202 CLASS 5 OTHER 23-Sep-08 MCLAUGHLI DIVING ENGINE WESTERN LAREDO CHANNEL, CHANNEL / 524833 N 1290936 W N BAY TENDER/SUPPOR FAILURE REGION BC STRAIT / SOUND T 169 M08W0203 CLASS 5 OTHER 24-Sep-08 ITB 38 BARGE - OIL CONTAC WESTERN SERPENT POINT, BC CHANNEL / 520440 N 1275930 W TANK T WITH REGION STRAIT / SOUND THE BOTTOM 170 M08W0206 CLASS 5 OTHER 28-Sep-08 ITB 38 BARGE - OIL CARGO - WESTERN MCINNES ISLAND. CHANNEL / 521600 N 1284300 W TANK LOST REGION BC STRAIT / SOUND OVERBO ARD 171 M08W0210 CLASS 5 OTHER 03-Oct-08 GULF TUG - OTHER ENGINE WESTERN KEMANO INLET, BC CHANNEL / 533000 N 1284200 W PRINCE FAILURE REGION STRAIT / SOUND 172 M08W0232 CLASS 5 OTHER 25-Oct-08 SEATAC 300 BARGE - CARGO CARGO WESTERN INSIDE PASSAGE, BC CHANNEL / 535000 N 1301900 W SHIFTED REGION STRAIT / SOUND 173 M08W0245 CLASS 5 OTHER 18-Nov-08 DEANNA FISHING - SKIFF RUDDER WESTERN KAKUSHDISH HARBOUR AREA - 520809 N 1280008 W GALE INOPERA REGION HARBOUR, BC GENERAL TIVE 174 M08W0260 CLASS 5 OTHER 11-Dec-08 STORM TUG - OTHER ENGINE WESTERN REGATTA ROCKS,BC CHANNEL / 521304 N 1280831 W WINDS #1 FAILURE REGION STRAIT / SOUND 175 M08W0267 CLASS 5 OTHER 20-Dec-08 QUEEN OF FERRY - MACHINE WESTERN BOSCOWITZ PT, BAY 520755 N 1280756 W PRINCE PASSENGER/VEH RY REGION DEAN CHANNEL, B.C RUPERT ICLE FAILURE - GENERA L

Source data : Transportation Safety Board's Marsis Prepared by Macro Analysis Division As at cob 27 October 2009 13 / 13 file :111219 Dave Shanon - TSB Incidents 2003-2008 M09-125(1) (2).xls