MOVEMENTS of the FIRST RIB by R
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
[ 94 ] MOVEMENTS OF THE FIRST RIB By R. WHEELER HAINES, Department of Anatomy, St Thomas's Hospital Medical School INTRODUCTION though less so than those of the succeeding ribs. The most varied opinions as to the movements of Henke (1863, p. 79) described the axis as passing the first ribs have been held by various workers, and outwards and at the same time upwards and back- are still to be found in modern text-books. In the wards, but Landerer (1881) could not confirm this, cadaver the first rib undoubtedly moves with the for he found the axis directed horizontally outwards rest when the lungs are inflated or the sternum and backwards, with no upward component. drawn upwards, and Magendie (1831,. p. 378) Estimations of the degree of obliquity of the axis described this rib as moving more than other (the angle between the axis and a line drawn hori- members of the series. Sibson (1846) in a careful zontally outwards) are also inconsistent. Henke study of the dissected cadaver found that when the and Meissner gave high figures (42 and 360, tables thorax was artificially inflated the first rib moved of Fick, 1911, p. 143), Trendelenburg, Volkmann with the others, keeping parallel to them, towards (same tables), Landerer and Fick low figures (9-16'). a more horizontal position, and Thane's (1892, Later authors have followed Braune (1888) in fig. 187) figure shows the sternum rising as a whole stating that the axis of the first rib is nearly trans- and the first rib moving with the others. But verse. Further, the shortness of the first costal Haller (1758) had found that for a moderate in- cartilages seems to preclude any movement similar spiration the lower end of the sternum moved to the lateral displacement of the lower ribs, so that forwards more than the upper end, and this was even those authors who, like Weber (1936), are taken by later writers to indicate that the manu- prepared to allow the first rib a considerable range brium, and so the ribs attached to it, could move of movement usually restrict that movement to a very little under any circumstances. Reid (1852, simple lid-like raising and lowering of the thoracic p. 834), for instance, mentions Magendie's conclusion inlet as a whole. Thane's (1892, p. 161) statement only to contradict it, and Allen Thomson (1876, that 'in the first rib the axis is nearly transverse, p. 812), though he admitted that 'on the prepared and thus while a considerable degree of elevation is skeleton, by raising and depressing the sternum the permitted the eversion is but slight', and Blair's ribs may be moved upwards and downwards nearly (1943, p. 341) that 'in the upper ribs, where the parallel to one another; the first rib moving as axis is almost transverse, the lateral movement is freely as the others', suggested that 'during life slight or absent' are fair samples of anatomical several causes combine to make the first rib more opinion. fixed than those that follow: as for example, the Yet a cursory examination of a preparation of the weight of the upper extremity, and the strain of the first rib in situ is sufficient to show that the move- intercostal muscles and the ribs beneath'. ment is not lid-like and the axis is not transverse. This uncertainty as to the amount of movement Each rib is seen to move round an oblique axis, in of the first rib has persisted in spite of the demon- inspiration the lateral border moves further from stration of considerable movement of the manu- the midline, and the directions in which the surfaces brium sterni in deep inspiration by outline tracings of the rib face are remarkably altered. This paper is (Hutchinson, 1852), photographic records (Hasse, concerned with a detailed study of the mechanisms 1901), radiographs (Macklin, 1925), and kymo- involved in the cadaver and in the living subject. graphs (Weber, 1936) and figures illustrating the movement (Keith, 1909, fig. 2), and is reflected for instance in Blair's (1943, p. 341) statement that in ANATOMICAL PREPARATIONS inspiration 'the upper border of the sternum is only Axis of movement. In a wet preparation of the slightly raised and is carried forward hardly at all'. first costal ring, from a man about 60 years of age, The mechanism of the first rib is still less under- a steel knitting needle was fixed to the rib by plasti- stood. Sibson's (1846) figures, made with the aid of cine and its position adjusted till it pointed the same a drawing machine, showed it quite clearly rising way whether the rib was raised or lowered (method from a more oblique to a more horizontal position of Henke, 1863 and Landerer, 1881). The fact that during inflation of the lungs, and at the same time this was possible showed that the rib was turning turning so that its outer border came to look more about a stationary axis and the movement was a laterally and less downwards. Several authors simple rotation. The axis was found to pass through whose results have been tabulated by Fick (1911, the head, along the neck and through the tubercle, p. 143) have published measurements showing that outwards, backwards and somewhat upwards, as the axis about which the first rib moves is oblique, stated by Henke (1863). It was very far from the Movements oJf the first rib 95 simple horizontal axis so often described, and the by 9 mm., but the distance between the costo- axes of opposite ribs met in the fore part of the body chondral junctions of the two sides, 85 mm., was of the first thoracic vertebra at an angle of 1100, so unchanged. that the obliquity, as defined above, was 35'. In Comparing the first rib with the others the actual the other ribs the axes pointed downwards rather displacement of its anterior end was less, for the than upwards, except for the second where the axis anterior end of the 7th rib of the same individual, was directed nearly horizontally. for example, moved through 45 mm., but owing to Range of movement. The preparation with needles the great length of the rib this displacement was fixed in the positions of the two axes could now be brought about by an angular movement of 140 mounted in a drawing frame in convenient positions, only, so that so far as angular movement was con- and accurate orthoscopic projections made with the cerned the first rib moved more than the others, ribs raised and lowered. For purposes of measure- and Magendie's (1831) statement on this point was ment direct vertical (Fig. 2), anterior (Fig. 4) and confirmed. lateral views are the most convenient, for the Trajectory. Since the axis of movement, if we vertical, lateral and anterior displacements of the ignore small displacements, remains stationary, it ribs can be read off from them directly, while a follows that each point on the rib must describe an view taken directly along the line of the axis arc of a circle about the axis as the rib turns, and a Fig. 1. Orthoscopic tracings of the first rib in inspiration and expiration in a wet preparation, taken looking directly along the axis, showing the true angular movement of the rib about the axis. (Fig. 1) gives the total movement at the costo- view along the axis will show the anterior end chondral junction and the angular movement of the moving along such an arc (Fig. 1). Other views rib about the axis. The mechanism is however show the circular trajectory projected as an ellipse, better understood from oblique views (Fig. 3), for and it is convenient to draw in the ellipse before these bring out the peculiar movements about the considering the mechanism of the rib as a whole. two axes very clearly. A wire AB (Fig. 2) is fixed so that it lies along the In the specimen illustrated the right rib turned straight line from the costo-chondral junction B to through an angle of 240. The distance from the axis the axis OAX, and meets the axis at a right angle of movement to the centre of the costo-chondral OAB. In practice since the point A is embedded in junction was 75 mm., so that the anterior end of the bone of the first thoracic vertebra the wire the rib was displaced through 31 mm., and the cannot actually reach the axis, though it can point sternum was displaced through a corresponding in its direction. A second wire AC is fixed so as to distance. When the specimen was mounted as pass from the axis at the same point as the first, and nearly as could be judged in the position it occupied again at a right angle OAC to the axis, but in the in life, the 31 mm. of total displacement was found plane in which the drawing is being made, i.e. the to be made up of 28 mm. of vertical and 14 mm. of plane of the paper. A third wire AD stands at right anterior movement. The maximum distance be- angles both to AC and to the axis, so that AO, AC tween the lateral borders of the two ribs increased and AD might lie along adjacent margins of a cube 96 R. WHEELER HAINES Fig. 2. Orthoscopic tracings taken from below looking vertically upwards, showing movement of the first ribs round the oblique axes, the forward movement of the cartilages and sternum, and the lateral displacements of the shafts of the ribs.