Die Erste Stunde Johann Rafelski Abstract I recall my “first hour” events following on my meeting in Fall 1968 in the classroom with my academic teacher and thesis mentor Prof. Dr. Dr. h.c. multi- ple Walter Greiner. My comments focus on the creation of the new “strong fields” domain of physics in Frankfurt. I argue that this was the research field closest to Walter’s heart during his lustrous academic career. I will describe the events that lead on to Greiner’s course books, Walters actions leading to the rise of Frankfurt School of Theoretical Physics, and show how a stability principle defined his sci- ence. 1 Introduction Walter Greiner arrived in Frankfurt in the mid 1960s. He came in as a reformer, pushing through many changes at the Physics Faculty (Fachbereich Physik) of the Johann Wolfgang von Goethe Universitat¨ in Frankfurt. In Fall 1968, Walter’s newly approved Theoretical Physics course was offered to physics students in their first semester and attracted many students, including the author. For me and many others in this class the meeting with Walter was a random chance. However, we stayed on because of Walter. Teaching freshman Theoretical Physics Course was an educational revolution. It was accompanied by another revolution; West Germany was in the midst of a large scale student revolt. I recall that the J.W. Goethe University could not set exams; some courses were even canceled as the zealots focused on particular ‘reactionary’ lecturers. Other courses were disrupted temporarily by sit-ins organized by idealistic Johann Rafelski Department of Physics, The University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721 arXiv:1804.09909v1 [physics.hist-ph] 26 Apr 2018 e-mail: [email protected] Presented at: FIAS International Symposium on Discoveries at the Frontiers of (Walter Greiner) Science, Frankfurt, June 26 - 30, 2017. to appear in proceedings 1 2 Johann Rafelski students responding to the crooked but active Soviet propaganda machine operating from East Germany. A reader interested in a more general characterization of life and work of Walter Greiner should consult another recent commentary [1]. This article is very differ- ent as it describes in form of personal reminiscences an important series of events that occurred mainly between 1968-1983 during which 15 year period I interacted strongly with Walter. 1.1 Frankfurt 1968-1971 In Greiner’s classroom nobody from within disrupted the lectures. Moreover, when external non-physics revolutionaries tried to stop Greiner’s Theoretical Physics freshman class, his students defended the classroom, expelling the non-course stu- dents, throwing back the stink bombs and barricading the entrance doors from within with chairs and desks. Despite numerous distractions, and the absence of formal ex- amination (for fear of external disruption), there was lots of learning going on. We had classes, regular tutorial study groups, and the teaching program proceeded well. Among the 70 or more freshman students, many made great scientific careers. I think that this shows that teaching in the challenging way Walter pioneered in Frankfurt leads to success irrespective of situation. And for those going on to academic careers the near complete lack of formal examination may have been an asset: learning was not distracted by examination. Of the 1968 crop of students, quite a few joined later Greiner research group, and several became tenured theoretical physics full professors. This concentration of talent around Walter was due to his proactive approach: Walter cared for and developed young men and women working with him. Walter was bent on keeping his talented students. When someone made a move that dis- pleased Walter’s vision, he would straighten out the situation, typically offering his assessment on who was who in theoretical physics. His decisive and convincing arguments were without doubt an important reason for the successful birth of the Frankfurt School of Theoretical Physics in the eventful months of 1968-70. I still remember how Walter reacted when I told him that I won a very coveted and competitive Studienstiftung fellowship to Oxford. Walter was upfront and direct: “... only a!#s are working there.” Also, within days of this conversation, shortly after I completed my Diploma, and despite being only 21 years old, I was appointed his Scientific Assistant, see Fig. 1. A few ‘older ˚ (as compared to me) Assistants supported Walter’s teaching and research efforts. Burkhard Fricke, and Ulrich Mosel come to my mind, Burkhard was leading my tutorial group. Ulrich was the primary pillar of classical Nuclear Science and did both his Diploma and PhD with Walter. However, I was Walter’s first hire from among the people he taught from the first semester on, beginning in Fall 1968. I in turn introduced Walter to others who became important in the strong field physics formative years, including Berndt Muller,¨ Gerhard Soff, and a year Die Erste Stunde 3 Fig. 1 Walter Greiner appoints the author as his “Scientific Assistant” in July 1971 Source: Johann Rafelski archives later Joachim Reinhardt, the future soul of Walter’s rapidly expanding strong field research group. 1.2 Theoretical physics course books It is of interest to many to understand how and why Walter Greiner’s red-book se- ries, “Theoretische Physik,” was created. Before Greiner, nobody dared to teach a Theoretical Physics course in the 1st semester; thus no appropriate textbooks were available for freshman student use in the study of theoretical physics. In order to teach material which previously would appear typically only two years later in the curriculum, Walter clearly recognized the need to simplify, to explain by example, and to offer full solutions of exercises. To create such a new series for students, Walter realized that much of it had to be co-written by students. His “Assistant,” Burkhard Fricke who set the tuto- rial exercises (Ubungen)¨ for each week, would also collect from student volunteers their class protocols of class lectures, exercises, and solved problems. These were reviewed and edited by Burkhard. Walter would make another set of edits before these notes were typed, figures drafted and all put together into a “Script” by Wal- ter’s secretarial staff, supervised by the “Assistant”. The firs class course “Scripts” of Classical Mechanics I+II and Electrodynamics were prepared by Burkhard Fricke, as can be read in Fig. 2. Scripts were printed just like a PhD thesis by an in-house printing press maintained by the Theoretical Physics Institute. These scripts were available to anyone interested and were popular 4 Johann Rafelski Fig. 2 View on introductory remarks in the W. Greiner and H. Diehl Electrodynamik (Verlag Harri Deutsch, Frankfurt 1975, ISBN 3871441856). See text for further comments Source: Johann Rafel- ski archives among students selling at 2 DM a copy, the cost of a lunch in a student Mensa restaurant. Walter would use the first edition of his script, repeating three years later the same series of classes. Doing this he caught inevitable errors, and added and expanded the material. A second edition of the script was then created following the path of the first. In the case of Electrodynamik shown in Fig. 2, the first script edition was in late 1970; the second in late 1973 and the book version was ready to go to press a year later. As the fame spread, a publisher, Verlag Harri Deutsch, located just across the street from the institute became interested. So the 2nd edition of the lecture script was published reprinted directly from the script document. In this way Greiner’s script became available beyond Greiner’s institute. This in turn opened the path for other German Universities to embark on Greiner’s teaching method. The newly de- veloped Theoretical Physics teaching model began to influence all German-speaking Universities. I selected the pages of the Electrodynamik 1st book edition in Fig. 2 to show that Walter credited everyone deserving for the help in creating the main course books: we can read the names of all involved students and Assistants, and Herbert Diehl of 2nd Script edition is coauthor. After 40 years one would think that most if not all students listed in this page are long forgotten. This is not the case: many embarked on great careers, some returned (Johannes Kirsch for example) after their retirement contributing to the academic life in the newly formed Institute for Advanced Studies. Aside of the core stream of books Walter saw the need and also an opportunity for additional texts offering specialized topics. While I was teaching Special Rel- ativity in 1981, Walter asked me if I wanted to contribute as an author to the new topical series he would publish as “Herausgeber”. I agreed and Walter was keen to see my text as soon as possible; it was to be the first in the topical series. Being a Die Erste Stunde 5 young professor I did not at first have an “Assistant” to help me and I was teaching without sources as secondary literature was inaccurate and misleading. Moreover, I had research priorities. As a result three years passed before the Spezielle Rela- tivitatstheorie¨ book was ready [2]. By that time the original publication model for the special topics series was col- ored by other projects and the question of economic success: Walter Greiner was a successful author, Johann Rafelski (and the authors of other topical projects un- derway) were not. Verlag Harri Deutsch wanted to see the special series books as Greiner’s books. To account for the fact that I did all of the author’s work, Walter proposed to give me 3/4 of author compensation, considering that editors of series in general get some fraction of the revenue.