Comprehensive Review of JICA's Assistance in Mindanao
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Comprehensive Review of JICA’s Assistance in Mindanao February 2021 Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) Oriental Consultants Global Co.,Ltd. IC Net Limited 1R JR 21-006 Comprehensive Review of JICA’s Assistance in Mindanao Contents APPENDIXES .....................................................................................................................3 FIGURES & TABLES ..........................................................................................................4 MAP ....................................................................................................................................6 ABBREVIATIONS ...............................................................................................................7 FOREWARD........................................................................................................................8 CHAPTER 1. SURVEY OVERVIEW..................................................................................10 1.1 Background and Purpose ............................................................................................................ 10 1.2 Study Method ................................................................................................................................ 11 1.3 Limitation of the Study ................................................................................................................. 17 CHAPTER 2. OVERVIEW OF THE MINDANAO PEACE PROCESS ..............................18 2.1 Background to and factors behind the Mindanao conflict ......................................................... 18 2.2 Transition of the peace process (Marcos administration - Duterte administration) .................. 20 2.3 Legislative Process over a Bangsamoro Basic Law and its implication under the Duterte administration .......................................................................................................................................... 40 CHAPTER 3. JAPAN’S MINDANAO ASSISTANCE POLICY...........................................46 3.1 Country Assistance Program for the Philippines and Mindanao ............................................... 46 3.2 Support for the Mindanao peace process ................................................................................... 48 CHAPTER 4. JICA’S MINDANAO ASSISTANCE TO DATE ............................................53 4.1 Overview of JICA’s Assistance for Mindanao ............................................................................. 53 4.2 Developments in the Peace Process and Results of Assistance ............................................... 56 4.3 JICA’s Assistance by Sector ........................................................................................................ 62 4.4 JICA’s Assistance by Geographic Area ....................................................................................... 65 CHAPTER 5. REVIEW OF JICA’S ASSISTANCE TO MINDANAO ..................................69 2 Comprehensive Review of JICA’s Assistance in Mindanao 5.1 Outcome Analysis ........................................................................................................................ 69 Economic Development (Infrastructure Development) ............................................................. 69 Economic Development (Agricultural Development)................................................................. 76 Economic Development (Industrial Development) .................................................................... 87 Enhancing Good Governance.................................................................................................. 93 Community Development ...................................................................................................... 106 5.2 Other Assistance which Generated Synergy with JICA’s Assistance for Mindanao ............... 122 Assistance of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) of Japan ............................................... 122 Security Activities .................................................................................................................. 125 Promotion for Dialogue in Mediating Peace (Consolidation for Peace) ................................... 127 Intensive Implementation of the “Grant Assistance for Grassroots Human Security” ............... 130 Japanese Grant Aid for Human Resource Development Scholarships.................................... 132 Synergies between Other Assistance and JICA’s Assistance for Mindanao ............................ 133 5.3 Facilitating and Inhibiting Factors for Achieving the Outcomes .............................................. 136 Facilitating Factors ................................................................................................................ 136 Inhibiting Factors ................................................................................................................... 139 CHAPTER 6. JICA’S CONTRIBUTION TO PEACE AND DEVELOPMENT IN MINDANAO ..................................................................................................................... 146 6.1 Economic Development ............................................................................................................. 146 6.2 Enhancing Good Governance .................................................................................................... 148 6.3 Community Development ........................................................................................................... 149 6.4 Synergies between JICA’s Assistance and Other Assistance .................................................. 151 CHAPTER 7. CONCLUSION AND LESSONS LEARNED ............................................. 153 7.1 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................. 153 7.2 Lessons Learned ........................................................................................................................ 156 Appendixes Appendix 1: Mindanao assistance by other development partners Appendix 2: Project narrative summaries 3 Comprehensive Review of JICA’s Assistance in Mindanao Figures & Tables Figure 1-1 Overview of Mindanao Support ................................................................................... 12 Figure 4-1 Number of Projects by Scheme and Implementing Agency (1990 - 2019) ................. 55 Figure 4-2 Number of Projects by Japanese Fiscal Year and Scheme (1990 - 2019) ................. 55 Figure 4-3 Number of Projects by Japanese Fiscal Year and Implementing Agency (1990 - 2019) ................................................................................................................................................... 55 Figure 4-4 Number of Projects by Year and Sector (1990-2019) ................................................. 65 Figure 4-5 Geographic Areas where JICA Operated the Projects (Except those for community development) ............................................................................................................................. 67 Figure 4-6 Geographic Areas where JICA Operated the Projects for Community Development 68 Figure 6-1 JICA’s Contribution to Economic Development ........................................................ 147 Figure 6-2 JICA's Contributions to Enhancing Good Governance ............................................. 149 Figure 6-3 JICA’s Contributions to Community Development .................................................... 150 Figure 6-4 Relationship between JICA's Assistance and Other Assistance Leading to “Peace and Development in Mindanao” ..................................................................................................... 152 Table 1-1 Analytical framework for each project ........................................................................... 13 Table 1-2 Target projects ................................................................................................................ 16 Table 2-1 Outline of the 1996 Final Pease Agreement (FPA)....................................................... 23 Table 2-2 Main contents of Bangsamoro Framework Agreement and Annexes (changes from Republic Act No. 9054) .............................................................................................................. 32 Table 2-3 Key differences in authority between the ARMM and the BARMM .............................. 43 Table 3-1 Japan’s ODA to the Philippines: Priority support areas ................................................ 48 Table 3-2 Support for Mindanao through the J-BIRD initiative ..................................................... 50 Table 4-1 List of Projects in JICA’s Assistance for Mindanao....................................................... 53 Table 4-2 Projects Launched between 1990 and 2002 ................................................................ 56 Table 4-3 Projects Launched between 2002 and 2006 ................................................................ 58 Table 4-4 Projects Launched between 2006 and 2011 ................................................................ 59 Table 4-5 Projects Launched after 2011 ....................................................................................... 61 Table 4-6 List of All of the Projects by Sector ............................................................................... 63 Table 5-1 Planning and Approaches at Project Level in Economic Development