ECONSPEAK: A Journal of Advances in Management IT & Social Sciences, Vol. 8, Issue 9, September 2018 Impact Factor 5.132 ISSN: (2231-4571) www.skirec.org Email Id: [email protected]

A CRITICAL STUDY ON NON-DUALISTIC VEDANTA TRADITION AND ITS IMPACT ON ENVIRONMENTAL ECOSYSTEM

Dr. Udit Narayan Panday Assistant Regional Transport Officer Transport Department, UP ABSTRACT: "is a non- human self the parallel division amongst dualistic arrangement of Vedanta clarified human and non human other should be risen fundamentally by Sankara. It has been and above and human being ought to understand keeps on being the most generally that nature is nevertheless constitutive piece acknowledged arrangement of thought of his self. For rise of eco self human needs to among philosophers in India". Advaita rise above his sense of self and understand Vedanta belongs to a framework which is that nature is a constitutive component of his known as ontological. This ontological self. framework is known as optimism. This stated The focal position of the Advaita Vedanta the situation of adoption of universe to be convention is that in reality there is no simply consciousness. Again the consciousness contrast amongst consciousness and the state of universe is known as . In this universe, no genuine refinement between the paper we will study about the Advaita individual, the whole universe and God, Vedanta and its positive and negative impacts Brahman. Advaita (truly signifying "not two" of Advaita Vedanta on ecology. or non-dual), proclaims that the universe is an KEYWORDS: Advaita Vedanta, Ecology, appearance of one undifferentiated reality, meditation, Brahman etc. communicated in as Brahman, fix in I. INTRODUCTION sexual orientation it actually signifies For a superior man – nature relationship, "development", "advancement", "swelling" or Deep ecologists yearn for the rise of eco self. the "Incomparable extraordinary and intrinsic They investigate the human-centric thought Reality or the One Godhead. that human creatures are the bosses over The term Advaita implies, not two, and nature and nature has yet just subservient alludes to the way that atman and Brahman position and utilitarian esteem. Adopting a are not isolated; in like manner, the made profound strategy nature, Deep ecologists universe has no reality that is separate from yearn for development of human self to suit that of the Vedantic Self. However the notions non human nature also. For development of of Advaita Vedanta is unpretentiously not the

An International Double-Blind, Peer Reviewed, Refereed Open Access Journal - Included in the International Indexing Directories Page 1

ECONSPEAK: A Journal of Advances in Management IT & Social Sciences, Vol. 8, Issue 9, September 2018 Impact Factor 5.132 ISSN: (2231-4571) www.skirec.org Email Id: [email protected]

same as a reasoning of radical unity, since the conventional perspective of their specific made universe and the Vedantic source are confidence. From various perspectives distinctive as in one constitutes the full and Advaita Vedanta is additionally an Eastern just reality, and the other, however clear to type of Idealism (think Plato, Plotinus, Kant or the faculties, appreciates just an obtained Hegel), proposing that psyche or reality. consciousness, which at its root exudes from “With me, illusions are bound to be shattered. God, is the pith or significance of the I am here to shatter all illusions. Yes, it will exceptional reality. irritate you, it will annoy you - that's my way Vedanta is neither recondite nor unfeasible. of functioning and working. I will sabotage In the event that introduced legitimately, you from your very roots! Unless you are contemplated sincerely and comprehended totally destroyed as a mind, there is no hope with an unsophisticated heart, it can be a for you.” wellspring of motivation without a moment's - Osho hesitation. The all encompassing perspective In spite of the fact that a portion of the ideas of the universe that it offers, with its weight in this vision may appear to be unusual at first on the Divine pervading or controlling each hearing, it is urgent to take note of that the viewpoint, can assist us with elevating our language and thoughts are not paradoxical brain from the microcosm to the world, from but rather clear, exact, and particular. the commonplace to the spiritualist levels. Similarly essential to hold as a top priority is Taken in their materiality, as "writing," the that Advaita Vedanta is heredity based texts and images are definitely misjudged by profound convention, supposedly go down the individuals who are not themselves in from teacher to student from Shan. karacarya journey. No matter what, the metaphysical in the eighth ninth hundreds of years CE to terms and images are the technical terms of the present day. the pursuit. They are never artistic Nondual philosophical frameworks are not decorations, and as Malinowski has so well uncommon, different types of are said in another association, "Technical emphatically non-dual and one could language, in issues of functional interest, recommend that a lot of the world's gains its significance just through individual spiritualists talk about nondual, that a support in this kind of interest." That is the nondual experience of association with God, reason, the Indian feels; the Vedantic texts regardless of whether not bolstered by the have been just verbally and linguistically and

An International Double-Blind, Peer Reviewed, Refereed Open Access Journal - Included in the International Indexing Directories Page 2

ECONSPEAK: A Journal of Advances in Management IT & Social Sciences, Vol. 8, Issue 9, September 2018 Impact Factor 5.132 ISSN: (2231-4571) www.skirec.org Email Id: [email protected]

never extremely comprehended by European outstanding conditions—is viewed as a researchers, whose strategies for think about perilous deviation from the way. are avowedly objective and noncommittal. Nor is the Vedanta a sort of psychology or The Vedanta can be known just to the degree Yoga a kind of therapeutics aside from that it has been lived. The Indian, in this coincidentally. Physical and moral healths are manner, can't confide in a teacher whose essentials to profound advance. A mental convention isn't specifically reflected in his examination is utilized just to separate our exceptionally being. Here is something affectionate faith in the solidarity and extremely far expelled from the modern superfluity of the "spirit," and with a view to a European idea of grant. superior recognizing of the soul from what isn't the soul however just a transitory psycho-physical indication of a standout amongst the most constrained of its modalities. Whoever, similar to Jung, demands deciphering the basics of Indian or Chinese mysticism into a psychology is just twisting the importance of the texts. The Supreme Swan: In the foundation is an artistic rendering of a swan, with the Sanskrit We should include, for the individuals who sentence Brahmaivasatyam - Brahman is the engage romantic thoughts of the "puzzling main Truth. The swan theme is found in the East," that the Vedanta has nothing to do with seals of numerous Advaita associations. The enchantment or with the activity of figure seen here has been adjusted from the mysterious forces. Without a doubt the official seal of the Sringeri maTha, an ancient adequacy of supernatural system and the fact and a standout amongst the most essential of mysterious forces are underestimated in focuses of Advaita Vedanta in India. The swan India. In any case, the enchantment is viewed is an extremely prevalent theme in traditional as a connected art of the basest kind; and Hindu symbolism. It can be found in oil-lights while mysterious forces, for example, that of utilized as a part of temples and at task "at a distance," are by chance gained sanctuaries in individuals' homes. over the span of pondering practice, the Advaita Vedanta and Swan have very close utilization of them—except if under the most relationship with each other. In the Sanskrit

An International Double-Blind, Peer Reviewed, Refereed Open Access Journal - Included in the International Indexing Directories Page 3

ECONSPEAK: A Journal of Advances in Management IT & Social Sciences, Vol. 8, Issue 9, September 2018 Impact Factor 5.132 ISSN: (2231-4571) www.skirec.org Email Id: [email protected]

language, the Swan is known as “Hamsa”. scholars’ consideration, and have additionally Hamsa has also a unique kind of variety which been scrutinized by agreeing schools. The belongs to Soham. It means the superior similarities have been deciphered as Buddhist relationship like “I am He”. There has been impacts on Advaita Vedanta, while others seen that advaitin and Swan has not similar deny such impacts, or consider them to be which means they have differently equivalent variation articulations. As indicated by Daniel with each other. Swan belongs to water along Ingalls, the Japanese Buddhist scholarship has with the feather which remains dry. On the contended that Adi-Shankara did not other hand advaitin keeps separated with comprehend Buddhism. Atman from the non-dual world. The Atman Some Hindu scholars condemned Advaita for that is Brahman is impending in the world, its Maya and non-mystical doctrinal much the same as milk is apparently similarities with Buddhism. Ramanuja, the indistinguishably blended with water, originator of Vishisht-advaita Vedanta, however It can never be genuinely blamed Adi-Shankara for being a acknowledged without the nitya-anitya- PrachannaBauddha, that is, a "crypto- vastuviveka - right discrimination between the Buddhist", and somebody who was endless and fleeting - that is fundamental for undermining mystical Bhakti devotionalism. the advaitin. The swan is accordingly a symbol The non-Advaita researcher Bhaskara of the for the jIvanmukta, who is freed while still Bhedabheda Vedanta tradition, alive in this world, by virtue of having correspondingly around 800 CE, blamed acknowledged Brahman [4]. Shankara'sAdvaita as "this disgusting “Feel nothing, know nothing, do nothing, have separated Mayavada that has been droned by nothing, give up all to God, and say utterly, the Buddhists", and a school that is 'Thy will be done.' We only dream this undermining the ritual duties set in Vedic bondage. Wake up and let it go.” orthodoxy [6]. - Swami Vivekananda A couple of Buddhist scholars made the II. RELATIONSHIPS WITH BUDDHISM contrary feedback in the medieval time Advaita Vedanta and Mahayana Buddhism toward their Buddhist rivals. In the 6th share similarities and have differences, their century CE, for instance, the Mahayana relationship a subject of dispute among Buddhist researcher Bhavivek are scholars. The similarities amongst Advaita and characterized Vedantic ideas to indicate how Buddhism have pulled in Indian and Western they fit into ideas, and

An International Double-Blind, Peer Reviewed, Refereed Open Access Journal - Included in the International Indexing Directories Page 4

ECONSPEAK: A Journal of Advances in Management IT & Social Sciences, Vol. 8, Issue 9, September 2018 Impact Factor 5.132 ISSN: (2231-4571) www.skirec.org Email Id: [email protected]

"equate[d] the Buddha's body with as far as how it impacts the conduct of the Brahman, a definitive reality of the two people and different cooperatives. In the ." In his instances of ecological activism and Madhyamakahṛdayakarikaḥ, Bhaviveka stages awareness as observed through the focal a () interlocutor, who points of Deep Ecology and Social Ecology, blames Mahayana Buddhists for being AdvaitaVedanta is to a great extent positive. "crypto-Vedantins". Medieval period Tibetan There are, be that as it may, a few parts of Gelugpa scholars blamed the Jonang School Advaita, which are negative with respect to for being "crypto-Vedantist." Contemporary issues of ecological concern. As the great researcher David Kalupahana called the qualities of Advaita Vedanta have just been seventh century Buddhist researcher talked about in the second and third sections, a "crypto-Vedantist", a view the spotlight here will be on those qualities dismissed by scholars of Madhayamika that are negative to issues of ecological Buddhism. concern. Boss among these qualities are sure The Advaita Vedanta tradition has verifiably religious fundamentals, which have served to dismissed allegations of crypto-Buddhism advance a propelled at monism or outrageous featuring their particular perspectives on individualism in Indian society [7]. Atman, and Brahman. A) Interpreted Literally Sacred Texts III. NEGATIVE IMPLICATIONS OF ADVAITA Sometimes Demean Nature and its Creatures VEDANTA REGARDING ECOLOGICAL The colossal religious texts of the world are ACTIVISM AND AWARENESS loaded with anecdotes and comparative Similarly as with any religious and literary gadgets, which are used by writers for philosophical system, which is a few thousand the motivations behind giving readers lessons years of age, Advaita Vedanta does not that have layered meanings. Also, the specifically address contemporary issues, for different meanings that an anecdote or example, the approaching ecological debacle comparable gadget may have are not that mankind currently faces. Rather, Advaita generally unequivocal or literal. Ordinarily the Vedanta and other such systems proffer a "deeper" layers of the lesson must be gotten world view by which the two people and a handle on through exceptional investigation whole social orders may base their everyday and dedication and the literal meanings of the lives and presence. Thus, this world view may illustrations or comparative gadgets are have both positive and negative ramifications insignificant. This is the situation with the

An International Double-Blind, Peer Reviewed, Refereed Open Access Journal - Included in the International Indexing Directories Page 5

ECONSPEAK: A Journal of Advances in Management IT & Social Sciences, Vol. 8, Issue 9, September 2018 Impact Factor 5.132 ISSN: (2231-4571) www.skirec.org Email Id: [email protected]

religious texts of Advaita Vedanta. In any case, understand that a society's activities will on the grounds that an individual just handles dependably be governed, at any rate to a the "shallowest" or literal of the different limited extent, by the dominant supernatural meanings from a given lesson does not at all belief system of that society [9]. lesson the degree to which they might be James (2000), an American Philosopher, in affected by that lesson. As to different The Theory of Human Culture, contends that consecrated texts of Advaita, this is a reason rationalities are normally effective in the for concern in issues of ecology, particularly arrangement of human societies. As per his since a considerable lot of the hallowed texts hypotheses, theoretical systems, for example, of Advaita include criticalness inside other Advaita Vedanta, shape, alongside different Hindu traditions and among non-Hindus [8]. impacts, the improvement of human society. Inside any society, Feibleman states, is an "implicit dominant ontology," which controls activity on both an individual and aggregate level. He bases his cases, as do others, on the possibility that the way in which individuals see themselves and their place inside the

IV. ADVAITA VEDANTA AND ECOLOGY world effects extraordinarily the way by which Those people and gatherings who work and individuals carry on and how they see their live in India and are focused on ending and conduct. Feibleman (1946) infers that in the turning around the ecological genocide in the midst of social change and inconvenience, it is subcontinent should seek Advaita Vedanta for the errand of the scholar to make express understanding and direction with regards to these implicit dominant ontologies for the the idea of the issue and its answer. Thusly, motivations behind feedback and they will locate a rich and huge ontological reproduction. To survive the ecological tradition, which overwhelms India simply like dangers that Indian society faces, it is the Judeo-Christian ontological tradition foremost to notice Feibleman's contention to commands the West. Without a doubt, make express the implicit dominant ontology Sankara's system of non-dualism has been in Indian society for the motivations behind dominant for over a thousand years in India reproduction and feedback. Along these lines, and is at the bleeding edge of the modern the two people and gatherings dynamic in the Hindu Renaissance (1998). It is significant to battle to invert the wild demolition of the

An International Double-Blind, Peer Reviewed, Refereed Open Access Journal - Included in the International Indexing Directories Page 6

ECONSPEAK: A Journal of Advances in Management IT & Social Sciences, Vol. 8, Issue 9, September 2018 Impact Factor 5.132 ISSN: (2231-4571) www.skirec.org Email Id: [email protected]

subcontinent's extraordinary ecosystems can Ecological Crisis. In Christopher draw upon the beliefs and customs of India's Chappie and Mary Tucker (Eds.). kin keeping in mind the end goal to teach and Hinduism and Ecology, (pp. 165-179). advance change [10]. Harvard University Press. V. CONCLUSION [2] Bookchin, M. (2005). The Ecology of Advaita Vedanta incorporates a religious Freedom: The Emergence and measurement, which is indigenous to India, to Dissolution of Hierarchy. Oakland: AK the moral goals of both Deep Ecology and Press. Social Ecology. The moral position of the [3] Chappie, C. K. (2000). Introduction. In solidarity of all life and populism between Christopher Chappie and Mary Tucker species in Deep Ecology has a firm supporting (Eds.). Hinduism and Ecology, (pp. in Advaitin supernatural quality. Social xxxiii-xlix). Harvard University Press. Ecologists can in like manner point to the [4] Clark, J. (2005). Social Ecology. In route that there is the wrong spot for the Bron Taylor (Ed.). The Encyclopedia of mentalities that provoke hierarchy of Religion and Nature. London and New leadership inside the Advaitin way of life and York: Continuum conviction framework. By perceiving and [5] Dwivedi, O. P. (2000). Dharmic drawing in the all-inclusive community's own Ecology. In Christopher Chappie and specific sentiment of place and reason in the Mary Tucker (Eds.). Hinduism and World the natural development in India can Ecology, (pp. 3-22). Harvard find accomplishment. The components of the University Press. connections that shape the participation [6] Naess, A. (2005). The Selected Works between the natural and manufactured world of Arne Naess Vols 1-10. New York: in India must be changed if the subcontinent Springer-Verlag Press is to remain a sincere space. It is basic to [7] Nelson, Lance E. (2000). Reading the these end activists, educators, and approach BhagavadgTta from an Ecological makers comprehend the advantage that Perspective. In Christopher Chappie Advaita Vedanta is in the fight to save India and Mary Tucker (Eds.). Hinduism and from natural devastation. Ecology, (pp. 127-164). Harvard REFERENCES University Press. [1] Agarwal, A. (2000). Can Hindu Beliefs [8] Robb, P. (2002). A History of India. and Values Help India Meet Its New York: Palgrave.

An International Double-Blind, Peer Reviewed, Refereed Open Access Journal - Included in the International Indexing Directories Page 7

ECONSPEAK: A Journal of Advances in Management IT & Social Sciences, Vol. 8, Issue 9, September 2018 Impact Factor 5.132 ISSN: (2231-4571) www.skirec.org Email Id: [email protected]

[9] Williams, M. (2003). Deforesting the Earth: From Prehistory to Global Crisis. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press [10] James, G. (2000). Ethical and Religious Dimensions of Chipko Resistance. In Christopher Chappie and Mary Tucker (Eds.). Hinduism and Ecology. (pp. 499-530). Harvard University Press.

An International Double-Blind, Peer Reviewed, Refereed Open Access Journal - Included in the International Indexing Directories Page 8