Nzskeptic-73.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
“Documentary” Gets Bent Spoon Skeptical Teens Newspaper Survey Credence – Beyond Belief number 7273 -- winterspring 20042004 content editorial Not Rare – Just Another Medium 3 Getting a Word In The Media Creates a Miracle 4 Five Tips for Assessing ’M ASHAMED to say we put up a fight. The head of the local Mediums or Psychics 7 I community radio station wanted to know if we were interested in Skeptical Teenage Boys: putting together a skeptic show. A skeptic of many years’ standing himself, Hope for the Future 6 Phil Grey had taken on the job recently at Community Radio Hamilton Newsfront 10 and was wanting to get some balance into the airwaves. Forum 14 We thought about our lives at present – running daughter to various activities, working, trying to pound an acre of garden into submission, Hokum Locum 16 cleaning up after the cat – all those little things that pass for existence Credence is Beyond these days. There was also the fear factor. A radio show? As in, public Belief 18 speaking? The thought was ghastly. After almost two decades in print Loose Talk from an media, the concept of having to think on one’s feet for a radio show was Old Smoothie 19 daunting. But Phil would not be put off. He was up to his ears in spiritual and alternative health shows, one could hear his teeth gnash over the emails he sent. And Lord knows there are countless subjects out there that one could poke a stick at. We’ve recorded four shows now, and, after a bit of skilful editing by Phil, they sound almost like real ones—and I’m sure we’ll improve. So for those who can pick it up, Contributions Through the Fog (an ap- Contributions are welcome and propriate name we thought, should be sent to: given the Waikato climate) can be heard Fridays at Annette Taylor 12.30pm on 1206AM. 122 Woodlands Rd RD1 Hamilton It is in fact, a rare luxury Email: [email protected] to have someone in the Deadline for next issue: media enthusiastically seek- January 10, 2005 (my birthday) ing such input from skeptics; Letters for the Forum may be ed- SPOON BENDERS: Through the Fog not many opportunities ited as space requires - up to 250 presenters, from left, David Riddell, Phil Grey present themselves. At the and Annette Taylor words is preferred. Please indicate recent conference journalist the publication and date of all clip- David McLoughlin gave a presentation on how the media take a generally pings for the Newsfront. sympathetic view of paranormal and pseudoscientific claims. For those, Material supplied by email or IBM- like us, who couldn’t get to Christchurch, his talk is reproduced in this compatible disk is appreciated. issue (page 8). Permission is given to other non- A classic example was the winner of this year’s Bent Spoon Award: profit skeptical organisations to re- print material from this publication Melanie Reid’s 20/20 item on Taranaki medium Jeanette Wilson (see provided the author and NZ Skeptic page 3). Wilson has continued to have a dream run in the media – chair- are acknowledged. entity Vicki Hyde was asked to be on Newstalk ZB with Wilson recently, but in the end didn’t even get a sound bite. More on that next issue. Opinions expressed in the New Zealand Skeptic are those of the We need more reporters who truly keep an open mind. individual authors and do not necessarily represent the views of • www.communityradio.co.nz NZSCICOP or its officers. number 73 - spring 2004 bent spoon Not Rare – Just Another Medium Vicki Hyde A new star on the psychic circuit impressed the makers of TV3’s 20/20, but not the NZ Skeptics gushy piece of infotainment any meaning for them”. Asking While 20/20 did include some A on what is claimed to be leading questions designed to elicit footage of the critique in the first New Zealand’s premier showcase information or agreement is a part of the programme, I was for investigative reporting has won common tactic aimed at building disappointed that the programme 20/20 the 2004 Bent Spoon confidence in the performer, and chose to focus extensively on one Award. Melanie Reid’s August 22 making it appear as if they are very emotional, but content-free segment “Back from the Dead”, revealing hidden knowledge. Telling reading in what they called a “test” profiling Taranaki medium Jeanette a middle-aged audience member of the medium’s ability. Real tests Wilson, was judged by the NZ that their parent or grandparent is of such skills have to be carefully Skeptics to be the year’s most watching over them is playing simple planned to avoid naïve or mis- outstanding example of gullible or demographics, as it is more than leading interpretations. It’s not so naive reporting in the paranormal likely that such people will have much the testing as the marking or pseudoscience area. older relatives who have died. that’s important. Take away the histrionics and it was a very poor We were looking forward to performance as far as a demon- seeing a solid journalistic treatment stration of mediumship goes. of this growing industry, in much the same manner that 20/20 in the US Of course these very powerful exposed the dubious practices of images were selected by 20/20 medium James van Praagh. It was precisely because they make great very disappointing to hear 20/20 entertainment. They didn’t screen describe similar techniques per- very much of the unimpressive formed here in New Zealand as readings, the one where Wilson “astonishing”. asked a lady twice if her father had died, the ones where she used the 20/20 asked me to comment on same names and stock phrases Wilson’s performance, citing how over and over again. impressed they had been with both Wilson’s presentation – they said If, indeed, the medium had she looked just like Lady Di – and definitive proof of the after-life, this her accuracy – they said she was Chair-entity Vicki Hyde: “It’s not so should have been world-shattering coming up with specific names and much the testing as the marking news. After all, with this sort of that’s important.” relationships. capability, it means there should be no unsolved murders, no missing What I saw was the same col- New Zealand Skeptics are children, no arguments over in- lection of staple techniques used always prepared to check such heritance. There should be no throughout the industry and well- performers out, in case someone innocent people in prison, no documented in many books such really is doing something as- unidentified child molesters. The as Peter Huston’s “Scams from the tonishing, which would be very world would certainly be a better Great Beyond”. One example is exciting, but that certainly wasn’t the place, and that’s something about that of fishing for names, where the case here, despite 20/20’s en- which there could be no doubt. medium will ask a client if a thusiastic endorsement. common name, such as John, “has page 3 bent spoon The Media Creates a Miracle The reading by Jeanette Wilson which featured most prominently on the 20/20 programme awarded the 2004 Bent Spoon (see page 3) was of a woman named Maria. It transpired after the reading that Maria’s mother had, two years previously, haemorrhaged to death from a perforated duodenal ulcer. It was Maria who found her, and Maria interpreted Jeanette Wilson’s very dramatic performance as relating to that event. But as can be seen from the following transcript, stripped of the histrionics, Wilson appeared to be talking about something quite different—the murder of two small boys. Melanie Reid: We are running there longer to me, OK? M: Um, it would be another boy this mediumship reading unedited. that I know... It is intense. Some people may find M: That would be correct. JW: Yeah... it disturbing to watch. JW: Was she in a coma or some- Jeanette Wilson (JW) is handed thing then? M: ...but not to do with my family. a ring from Maria (M), to help M: No, but I understand what you JW: No. establish a connection. say... M: That would... JW: Now I’ve got a lady coming JW: OK. in on your mum’s side first, quite JW: But a similar age, do you strongly. OK. I’ve also got a M: About her feeling she was... understand? gentleman with her and I’m just JW: Yeah because she’s coming M: Yeah I do. trying to work out who’s who. through as a spirit that’s used to Alright. communicating. Alright. Now JW: Because I’m being shown a similar age and a similar situation M sits opposite, says nothing. she’s bringing with her a small boy. Do you understand who in the that happened? Alright? Under- JW: The lady I’ve got on your family that is? stand? mum’s side of the family, she’s M: Mm. coming through with a lot of M: Yeah I do. affection to you, she’s like, wanting JW: OK. And she’s showing me JW: (emotional) Oh goodness, to put her arms around you? It lots and lots of tears about this I’ve got blood on my hands. And feels like she’s being passed over young boy’s passing because there I don’t understand why I’ve got several years now, somewhere was a tragedy... blood on my hands..