Requiem for China's One-Child Policy
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TOM FLYNN: Requiem for China’s One-Child Policy CELEBRATING REASON AND HUMANITY February/March 2016 Vol. 36 No.2 ATHEODICY AND THE IMPOSSIBILITY OF GOD Does the Existence of Evil Show That God Can’t Exist? SUSAN JACOBY | STEPHEN LAW | DAVID KOEPSELL JAMES A. METZGER | EDWARD TABASH | SHADIA B. DRURY ANTHONY PINN | JUDY WALKER & TOM FLYNN Greta Christina | Faisal Saeed Al Mutar | Ed Buckner and Mandisa Thomas 80% 1.5 BWR PD F/M 08 Robert M. Price | Edd Doerr | Stephanie Savage 03 Published by the Center for Inquiry in association 7725274 74957 with the Council for Secular Humanism CENTERS FOR INQUIRY | www.centerforinquiry.net/about/branches CFI–SAN FRANCISCO CFI IN PAKISTAN United States Coordinator: Leonard Tramiel Ex. Dir.: Emanuel Enoch CFI EXECUTIVE OFFICES Tel.: (415) 335-4618 [email protected] 1020 19th St. NW, Suite 425 Email: [email protected] CFI IN POLAND (WARSAW) Washington, DC 20036 CFI–TALLAHASSEE Ex. Dir.: Andrzej Dominiczak Tel.: (202) 629-2403 Coordinator: Gary Whittenberger 01-867 Warszawa Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] ul. Broniewskieg 99/47 CFI–TRANSNATIONAL CFI–TAMPA BAY Poland President and CEO: Ronald A. Lindsay Coordinator: Rick O’Keefe CFI IN ROMANIA (BUCHAREST) PO Box 741 Tel.: (813) 443-2729 Ex. Dir.: Gabriel Andreescu Amherst, NY 14226 Email: [email protected] CFI IN RUSSIA (MOSCOW STATE UNIVERSITY) Tel.: (716) 636-4869 CFI–WASHINGTON, DC Ex. Dir.: Dr. Valerii A. Kuvakin Email: [email protected] Ex. Dir.: Ed Beck Moscow, Russia CFI–AUSTIN 1020 19th St. NW CFI IN SPAIN (BILBOA) Coordinator: Steve Bratteng Washington, DC 20036 Ex. Dir.: Luis Alfonso Gámez Email: [email protected] Tel.: (202) 629-2403 CFI IN UGANDA (KAMPALA) CFI–FORT LAUDERDALE Email: [email protected] Ex. Dir.: Deogratiasi Ssekitooleko Coordinator: Jeanette Madea Tel.: (954) 345-1181 CFI IN ZAMBIA (LUSAKA) Email: [email protected] Transnational Ex. Dir.: Wilfred Makayi PO Box 310383 CFI–HARLEM CFI IN BEIJING (CHINA) Chelston, Lusaka Tel.: (646) 820-2344 Ex. Dir.: Ren Fujun Zambia Email: [email protected] China Research Inst. for Science Popularization Beijing, China CFI IN CANADA CFI–INDIANA Ex. Dir.: Eric Adriaans CFI IN BUENOS AIRES (ARGENTINA) Ex. Dir.: Reba Boyd Wooden 55 Eglinton Avenue East, Suite 307 Ex. Dir.: Alejandro Borgo 350 Canal Walk, Suite A Toronto, Ontario M4P 1G8 Buenos Aires, Argentina Indianapolis, IN 46202 Canada Tel.: (317) 423-0710 CFI IN CAIRO (EGYPT) Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Chairs: Prof. Mona Abousenna CFI–CALGARY (CANADA) and Prof. Mourad Wahba CFI–LONG ISLAND Email: [email protected] Coordinator: Amy Frushour Kelly 44 Gol Gamal St., Agouza, Giza, Egypt CFI–EDMONTON (CANADA) Tel.: (631) 793-9382 CFI IN FRANCE (NICE) Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Ex. Dir.: Dr. Henri Broch CFI–HALIFAX (CANADA) CFI–LOS ANGELES Universite of Nice, Faculté des Sciences Email: [email protected] Ex. Dir.: James Underdown Nice, France 4773 Hollywood Blvd. CFI IN GERMANY (ROSSDORF) CFI–KELOWNA (CANADA) Hollywood, CA 90027 Ex. Dir.: Amardeo Sarma Email: [email protected] Tel.: (323) 666-9797 Kirchgasse 4, 64380 CFI–MONTREAL (CANADA) Email: [email protected] Rossdorf, Germany Email: [email protected] CFI–MICHIGAN CFI IN INDIA (HYDERABAD) CFI–OKANAGAN (CANADA) Ex. Dir.: Jeff Seaver Ex. Dir.: Dr. Jugal Kishore Email: [email protected] 3777 44th Street SE 46 Masih Garh, New Friends Colony CFI–OTTAWA (CANADA) Grand Rapids, MI 49512 New Delhi, India 110025 Email: [email protected] Tel.: (616) 698-2342 CFI IN JAPAN (TOKYO) CFI–SASKATOON and REGINA (CANADA) Email: [email protected] Ex. Dir.: Erick Eck Email: [email protected] CFI–NEW YORK CITY CFI IN KENYA (NAIROBI) CFI–TORONTO (CANADA) Email: [email protected] Ex. Dir.: George Ongere 55 Eglinton Avenue East, Suite 307 CFI–NORTHEAST OHIO PO Box 4205-40103 Toronto, Ontario M4P 1G8 Coordinator: Monette Richards Kisumu, Kenya Canada PO Box 2379, Akron, OH 44309 CFI IN LONDON (U.K.) Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Provost: Dr. Stephen Law CFI–VANCOUVER (CANADA) CFI–ORANGE COUNTY Conway Hall, 25 Red Lion Square, Email: [email protected] 4773 Hollywood Blvd., Hollywood, CA 90027 London WC1R 4RL, England CFI–WEST KOOTENAYS (CANADA) Tel.: (323) 666-9797 CFI IN THE LOW COUNTRIES Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Ex. Dir.: Bert Gasenbeek CFI–PITTSBURGH Universitiet, voor Humanistiek PO Box 19003, Pittsburgh, PA 15213 Postbus 797 3500 AT Email: [email protected] Utrecht, The Netherlands CFI–PORTLAND (OREGON) CFI IN PERÚ (LIMA) Ex. Dir.: Ryan Harvey Ex. Dir.: Manuel A. Paz y Miño Tel.: (503) 877-2347 Lima, Peru Email: [email protected] The mission of the Center for Inquiry is to foster a secular society based on science, reason, freedom of inquiry, and humanist values. The Center for Inquiry is a supporting organization of the Council for Secular Humanism, publisher of FREE INQUIRY. February/March 2016 Vol. 36 No.2 CELEBRATING REASON AND HUMANITY ATHEODICY AND THE IMPOSSIBILITY OF GOD 28 Auschwitz and Evil: My Experience 13 Introduction Growing Up as the Son of a Survivor Tom Flynn Edward Tabash 14 Who’s Afraid of the 32 Why John Hick’s Solution to the Problem of Big Bad Theodicy Riddle? Evil Makes God Monstrous Susan Jacoby Shadia B. Drury 18 Evil God and Mirror Theodicies 36 Is One Person’s Theodicy Another’s Stephen Law Anthropodicy? Preliminary Considerations 21 Evil Gods and Evil Men: Anthony B. Pinn Some Limits in the Debate 40 Epilogue David Koepsell Judy Walker and Tom Flynn 25 Is It Wrong to Accept God’s Gift of Salvation? James A. Metzger EDITORIAL DEPARTMENTS REVIEWS 4 China’s One-Child Policy: A Requiem 49 Doerr's Way 64 Move Upstream: A Call to Tom Flynn Public Education under Siege, Part 2 Solve Overpopulation Edd Doerr by Karen I. Shragg Reviewed by Tom Flynn OP-EDS 51 Great Minds 7 A Response to an Almost Good H. L. Mencken: but Limited and Very Troubling Scourge of the Booboisie POEM Argument against Trigger Warnings Dale DeBakcsy 63 An Abandoned Church Greta Christina 55 High Heresy by Stephen Van Eck 8 The Syrian Refugee Crisis and the Trojan Horde Need for Political Solutions Robert Price Faisal Saeed Al Mutar 57 The Humanist Soapbox 9 Should Atheist and Humanist Religion: Private Matter Organizations Broaden Their Purpose? or Public Policy? Ed Buckner and Mandisa Thomas Steve Davidson LOOKING BACK 59 Living Without Religion 11 Sympathy for the Devil-Believers Stephanie Savage LETTERS 61 The Faith I Left Behind 12 A Life of Love, Religion, and Science Gordon E. Hunter Editor Thomas W. Flynn Managing Editor Andrea Szalanski Tom Flynn Editorial Columnists Ophelia Benson, Russell Blackford, Greta Christina, Edd Doerr, Shadia B. Drury, Nat Hentoff, Faisal Saeed Al Mutar, Mark Rubinstein Senior Editors Bill Cooke, Richard Dawkins, Edd Doerr, James A. Haught, Jim Herrick, Ronald A. Lindsay, Taslima Nasrin Contributing Editors Roy P. Fairfield, Charles Faulkner, Levi Fragell, Adolf Grünbaum, China’s One-Child Policy: Marvin Kohl, Lee Nisbet Assistant Editors Julia Lavarnway A Requiem Nicole Scott Literary Editor Cheryl Quimba Permissions Editor Julia Lavarnway Art Director Christopher S. Fix Production Paul E. Loynes Sr. Center for Inquiry Inc. n October 29, 2015, the that the one-child policy prevented 400 Chair Edward Tabash Chinese Communist Party million births. R. Elisabeth Cornwell Board of Directors ended its one-child policy. FREE INQUIRY Senior Editor Vern L. Brian Engler For thirty-six years that pol- Kendrick Frazier O Bullough and his wife, FI Contributing Barry A. Kosmin icy had been the planet’s most aggres- Editor Bonnie Bullough, toured China Leonard Tramiel sive, longest-running campaign against in 1983, just four years after the one- Honorary: Rebecca Newberger overpopulation. It was also a human- child policy began. “We have to admire Goldstein rights nightmare, marked by forced the Chinese for their determination Susan Jacoby to bring their growth rate under con- Lawrence Krauss sterilizations and compulsory abor- tions. Especially in rural areas, women trol,” they wrote in FREE INQUIRY (Winter Chief Executive Officer Ronald A. Lindsay 1983/84). The Bulloughs frankly dis- Director, Campus and Community Programs Debbie Goddard cussed the policy’s dark side but also Director, African Americans recognized the existential danger if for Humanism Debbie Goddard “I mourn the one-child policy’s China did nothing to limit population Director of passing—not because I’m con- growth. “We wish that some of the Development Martina Fern more drastic forms of persuasion did fident it worked but because Director of Libraries Timothy Binga not have to be used,” they concluded, Communications Director Paul Fidalgo of the reasons why China’s “but we have no viable alternatives to Database Manager Jacalyn Mohr Communist leadership appar- recommend.” Reactions to the policy’s suspen- Webmaster Matthew Licata ently abandoned it.” sion have been varied. Joe Bish of the Staff Pat Beauchamp, Ed Beck, Melissa Braun, Shirley Population Media Center commented, Brown, Eric Chinchón, “I imagine many who are concerned Lauren Foster, Roe Giambrone, Nora Hurley, about human overshoot feel this is the Paul Paulin, Michael Rupp, faced immense social pressures and final nail in the global demographic Anthony Santa Lucia, devastating fines if they had a for- Diane Tobin, Vance Vigrass coffin.” Count me among that group. I bidden second or third child. Finally, mourn the one-child policy’s passing— Council for Secular Humanism strong cultural preference for male chil- not because I’m confident it worked Executive Director Thomas W. Flynn dren led to a troubling sex imbalance, but because of the reasons why China’s with as few as 85 girls born per 100 Communist leadership apparently aban- males. That said, China has claimed doned it. I’ll get back to that.