oes guas om Iias Maas aioa ak o seie ioy a io o .- — Accoig o ae Cuey o e Eiomea Iesigaio Agecy e siuaio acig aimas i Iia as ee eseae "oe ige eig oace eey ay oece aeas eig esoye y iusiaiaio ige oe a ski aes wakig ee a oes guas wiou uioms oos a oe saaies" EIAs ig-oie ige camaig as ee isumea i uiciig e ig o Iias wiie a ow e goeme is egiig o make wiie a ioiy o isace e Iia oa o Wiie wic a o me o eig yeas was ecoee y ime Miise ee Gowa wo caie a egy iiia meeig Moe cages may e i e oig as Gowa os a oe o coiece wic may ig a ew ime Miise o ee ew eecios o moe o iges see ages a 5

vr phtrph b v Crr 0 Envrnntl Invttn An

iecos Maoie Cooke lphn th At rld n Snt ea Waace ougas egisaio ieica o as yeas "oi ea Ac" was u o eeo G ewe e Amiisaio Cisie Sees as ack o assage y cogessioa a Cio oge Sees ee ae aocaes i Ai I succeee i eig use oug Aiee ai a eaig a maku i e ouse (see age a was aou o e Cyia Wiso amme oug e Seae as we u was amaicay eaye we Geeeace ue ack om e egisaio a eose a Oices comomise Seaos e Sees ( AK a o eau ( A Cisie Sees esie agiy cacee ei Ai 17 eaig eaig a e Geeeace Cyia Wiso ice esie eecio aog wi eay oosiio om 5 coseaio ei- eeo G ewe Seceay omea a aima weae gous as we as eaig seaos oge Sees easue cou scue e i Scieiic Commiee Geeeace as ee ue eay essue om is meme- Maoie Ace si wic sogy aos oi oecio a om e as Gea ea maoiy o e coseaio commuiy wic ae Geeeace ee ey M a eegae ou oe gous suo e oi ea Ac aaa Oas aoig ee ae oe ois Cee o Maie Coseaio oge aye Wo Wiie u Eiomea eese u a aioa Samue eacock M Wiie eeaio o Was M We Geeeace sumie is comomise esimoy o Sees Ieaioa Commiee a eau wo ays eoe e eaig e Cio/Goe Amiis- Aie e Aua M - Meico aio a e Meica goeme wic a oug ey a G Aikas M - Geece Geeeace i ei ocke aacke e Geeeace moe Acco- Amassao aaak usai - agaes ig o cogessioa souces Geeeace oyis Gea eae was Agea Kig - Uie Kigom agge o a emegecy meeig wi Seae sa a e ai- Simo Muciu - Keya oi gous wee e was eae a essue o wo ous Gooeo Sui - Cie o eca is esimoy a esume ackig e oi ea Ac Ms umiiko ogo - aa u a euge o egaie uiciy ke Geeeace om caig Kaus esegaa - emak i agai o e oi kies Iese uic essue icuig a Aeey Yaoko - ussia u-age a i e Anl eoucig Geeeace aee Sa is memesi a ouce o a cisis i e gou ousas o May Ee aye Associae Eio cas wee ouig aiy io Geeeace oices o oes is seou o Geie Assisa o e Oices e comomise eose y Geeeace wou se u a -3 yea iae aeso am Aima Cosua scieiic suy o eemie e eecs o ois o e ua ye uciso Wae Camaig Cooiao isig ecique wee moe a oe miio ois ae case Cay iss Eecuie ieco a ee eac yea Mos coseaio a aima weae gous Kaeie Mice eseac Assisa aog wi eaig maie ioogi§s wa a e sess a iuy e augo Mai Oe Seceay iee i isig "o oi" ae ageous o e maie Gea isso Wiie Cosua mammas a o e ea o ei ouaios wic ae sow aick oa uicaios Cooiao o sig o ecoey om e massace a as owe moe a eie ike Amiisaie Assisa see miio ois oe e as 39 yeas iko eia M I is ouu a e Amiisaio wi eose a comomise aoaoy Aima Cosua a e ai Ameica ua iusy as eouce i ecause ay Aam oes eseac Associae ick Si Maie Mamma eseac Aays cage i e oi-sae ae wou e eaye eig e scieiic suy = THE INSTITUTE QUAEY WIE 1997 OUME UME 1

PO Box 3650, Washington, DC 20007 phone: 202-337-2332 fax: 202-338-9478 email: [email protected]

AM e? Cols/444

ae i Wiie

Aou e Coe

e eseae ig o Iias iges 5

Wi 1997 e e Yea o e ea?

e Gea Eea eae Wi i Ee E?

Maie Mammas oi ea Ac eaie i Seae oi oecos Wok o a "ea Ac" Seamoe h bb lphnt ft hn n th bln f plx nd trblnt ntrntnl dbt. oess Wll th prttn tht lphnt n th th ig o e oess—a ei Iaias 1 8 vr trd bn ntn? Or ll rd nd hrthtdn brn bt r nl "usmea" imae Casuaies o Ou-o-Coo Gee lphnt lln? S r tr n p 8. o ime 1 e Wos ages Cooaio; e Wos Mos

aga esoie? 13

Aeciaio Caes icey 1

ews ouu 1

acoy ams emosaos Coem Cs Misuse o us 15 ook eiew And th Wtr rnd t ld 15

uma ouaio Mnnt frr l Sbn hld th lp So US ouaio Gow—Sae Eagee Secies 1 f ppr hn h h pd "hff" n hl dntrtn t th hdrtr f th Aimas o eeisio tnl r rdr Cnl, hh h bn d f n th fnd. S r tr "A aimas a e ime" 1 n p .

3 Dolphin Protectors Work to Halt "Death Act" Steamroller esie aia oosiio y Cogessma Geoge Mie camio o aima oecio a coseaio egisaio ( CA —ieica o as yeas "oi ea iouce a susiue i o maiai e iegiy o e Ac"—as ee aoe y e ouse esouces Commi- oi-sae ae a euce oi eas u e susi- ee a awais oo acio Suoes o is egisaio ae ue was uouaey eece y e sucommiee usig a o aease e Meica goeme a ai Cogessma Mie wae "I Cogess aos Ameica oyiss we ae seecig o ois a ou maie mam- was make u i e sucommiee ess a ma oecio eos o aoiae ea so a Meico ca ous ae a eaig o e i Geoge Mie a ogime se is usae ua i Ameica suemakes a eceie cosumes io eieig i is sae o ois" e eaig Senator Boxer Lambastes Bill for e Ai 9 egeee esimoy agais wic Potentially Easing Drug Shipments aoug i was isegae y e Commiee coaie e Seao aaa oe ( CA as ecome e geaes ey essece o e cooesy e auos Cisoe ie o ois a e US Seae as ee see Se Co a ioogis a o igea a aoey ae e o aems o ass as yeas oose oi eoe yeas o e oi-ua oem ea Ac wic wou ae emoe e oecio A igy sigiica secio o e esimoy is e aoe ois oug e oi-sae ae a isa eo o M Cos eeieces uig is yeas as aeas o a cas o Ameica ua a aioa Maie iseies Seice osee aoa ua Aocaes o e i wae o aac i o oe egisaio esses i e Ease oica aciic comig o e Seae oo i e as ays o e 1 My acua eeiece us coay o e Ie-Ameica Cogess u Seao oe mae i kow a se wou oica ua Commissios (IACs caim a "oi oec o ay i o wic a oi ea Ac ie was moaiy is easiy oice a ocumee sice oi cacasses oa a ae isie om a gea isace" aace us oecig ois oug aoe eious Osees aoa ua seies oe ae oe iy o iy eio squae mies o oe sea as e esses aem o scae eaus is yea Seao oe agai aesse e issue o a oce a sige scoo o ois umeig i e u- e Seae oo o Mac seakig aou "e Uie es o ousas o sumi o caue i a e Is iicu Saes emago agais Meica ua a e eos y o moio eey squae oo o sea i e iig gae o some icuig e Meica Goeme o i is em- suig owou o ai o a wey ko o geae wi ceaig a coy sea sae uig is ime ee is a ago" Se oe emeous amou o cousio a e sae o e ocea is e cue emago—wic was imose i 199 agais igy aiae cosisig o wakes om seeoas a wie a couies a o o ae eiomea oicies a cas a waes seea ee i eig Ee i mio-ike oec ois om usae ua isig acices—oi- camess eais as i aey oes i is iuay imossie o is Meica ua esses om seig ei oucs i e ieiy a ay e oies o ea o yig ois ee i Uie Saes make ey wee o emai o e suace iig e emago wou uouey ea o a icease Aemig o kee e osee om seeig ea ois i e ume o Meica esses oeaig i e ease was someimes a o a cews o esciio a I susec oica aciic I eiee a gie e cue owe a i si is eac o e ug caes i ai Ameica—aicuay I oe susece a some ea ois wee emoe Coomia a Meico—a ei eque eiace o mai- om es immeiaey ae ackow us eoe e e was ime esses o make ug simes ow is o e ime o oug cose eoug o e esse o me o see I was agey oe u a woe ew aeue o maiime ae om Meico ecause o my coce o ickey a I eue io e Caes ae usig isig oas a cago sis moe a wae a wiesse oi eageme om a iee moe oe o smugge cocaie om Coomia o Meico esecie Wa oe sees uewae is usuay o isie wee i is e sie o ucks a oe eices o om e eck o ua esses wee osees ae suose o aso acoss e oe io e Uie Saes say ue o ages om saks a oe acos I is ecause e isk o caue o ese esses is ow i a ocea so o wa I saw wie i e e a I ae ie ai i ay age A ee we e sis ae soe i is a o aw osees aiiy o eeciey moio e aciiies om e eoceme o i e ugs wic ae ie i sece eck o oas comames May isig esses ae soisicae As ois ae oigae eaes ey o ow—ey aa equime a aows em o kee aea o aw suocae Oe oes ook a e issue quie e same way o eoceme see ackow as a gea aaceme ae seeig scoos o Accoig o a aice i e auay Washington Post, ois igig o ea agais a caoy o eig ceae ou ow Coas Gua amis a e ease aciic is "oe y e cue o wae uig ackow Ae usig u o e mos iicu aces o us o ieic ug simes agais e weig o e e ui oo weak o coiue ei Is a as ocea ee ae o coke ois o aces o ie sous ae oe ooie a caiage oe oues I ae a os o aces o seac—icuig mies o coas" amos ee ue eea e caoies myse My iges So wy a is ime we acoics aickig i a oug ae sie io e mous o ois uig ei ea Meico io e Uie Saes is eaeig o uemie oes u ee eei ie Wie aemig o eease ou wo couies eaiosi wou we eieaey make ois om es I ae ee ue y eoaes (ia i ae o ig ese caes ue coo? soe ois seemigy aemig o oec ei mo- M esie I ask uaimous cose o ae ie i es e eco wo ocumes eaig o is quesio—oe e Uess osees acuay see a ea oi e ua Post aice o wic I us eee a wo a ece eo caue i a se ike Ie escie wi e so o cosumes y e umae Sociey o e Uie Saes o e eice as "oi-sae" imac o acoics aickig o iig e ua emago a e u ouse esouces Commiee aoe e o- is ime I us a we wi o ac i ay way o icease oou- i ea Ac o Ai 1 a i wi ow e cosiee y iies o ug smuggig a e u ouse o eeseaies a 4 ao A amiious a cae oec ige was auce i 1973 o u Iias aioa symo ack om e ik o eicio WW Ieaioa was i- sumea i aucig e eo aog wi e Iia goeme oec ige se u 3 ige esees a i- ece ay eee uig io ese oece aeas o coseaio a eoceme Iiiay e oec was a success—e ige eoue a WW a oec ige cogauae em- sees ow owee e siuaio is as- icay cage iges ae eig oace a e ae o oe a ay wie e o- ie oes guas ae euce o ao- Cntrtn f tr: bv, Khr nd ig o oo ame oy wi sicks r r Sbrn tr b h wee rphnd Wa we wog? Comacecy hn thr thr wee ht b phr. h r couio wase a aay ae n f n rrv. At rht, bn dtnd fr th dtrtv, lll trd n tr prdt. h Envrn gow u ike wees wii a aou ntl Invttn An rntl ndtd n oec ige—a WW ndrvr nvttn n Yr tht fnd 80% ome C coesoe Mak f An dn phr ll prdt tht n uy woe ecey i h Indpndnt tn tr prt, r l t. "It tr prrt," a WW "as aise moe a £1 d EIA v Crr. "It r t fnd tr prt iio [$15 iio] i e as 1 yeas n Yr thn t n p r jn." muc o i i e ame o e ige" I e ses amos 5 e ce o is mae moe a $99 as yea e a moey was o eig se o e icome o amiisaio uy ou woe u "cou o ao o uy ee ig oecs a moey wic cou ae ee su- a sige £7 [$1155] ao eice "e o me We ees a ie yig Iias i-equie oes guas o e eeaguee ages" uig o you say "O es ae a o eig o oec ige aia was Asok Kuma e ome ea o semia" o o you u ou e ie? I acuay ayig o "us oices sa- WW Iias AIC ogaiaio o ike WW you ow e ce o e sue ases gossy magaies oi- uy e e WW Iia ecause "e e coseaio ie e you mus ake

cia eos a semias" WW Iia e was geig aequae suo a e ce o e ame — a Advocates of Anti-Leghold Trap Law's Passage Now Struggle for its Full Implementation aaa Case a Mao Seigma—wo eie Memes o e Euoea aiame wo wee isumea i assig e Euoea Uios eguaio agais ego as—eue o e aiame i euay o ig o imemeaio o e aws u imo a wic sou e imose agais ose aios si usig ego as Moe a ie yeas ae e Euoea Uio (e aiame Couci o Miises a e Commissio asse eguaio 35/91 Case a Seigma aee o Sasoug o mee wi Memes o e aiame a e Commissio a o aess Commissioe i eega a a meeig o e Iegou o Aima Weae e aiame esoe aoig a esouio agais e oooe-ie aig ageeme eace ewee e Euoea Commissio Caaa a ussia—a o eoceme o e Euoea aw e oowig week e Couc o Miises me i usses a iscusse e ai-ego a eguaio a ieiie seciic coces wi e aig ageeme egoiae y e Commissio e Couci eaye imemeaio o e u imo a ui ue o gie e Commis- sio ime o moiy e ageeme I e meaime eey eo mus e mae o esue a e Couci a aiame o o acce ay ageeme emiig use o ego as I is oe a i ue e Couci wi isis rr Erpn rlnt Mbr Mdrn a e eguaios oiiio o imo o u om 13 secies o aimas Sln nd rbr Ctl th AWl Extv io e EU om aios wo ae o ae use o ego as o aoe rtr Cth (ntr, n rl. "ieaioay agee aig saas" wi iay come io oce 91 5 ea oecio Ac eiouce i Cogess "I, fr n, ll nt tnd b nd ll r n br ppltn t b dtd b phr."

-US SENATOR MITCH MCCONNELL UPON INTRODUCTION OF THE BEAR PROTECTION ACT

As eaes o e AW I Qrtrl kow we o Ameica ack eas ae ue icease ea om oaces smugges a eaes wo eoi ese magiice ceaues o suy e ucaie ae i ea as a oucs Seciicay ea gaaes a ie ae use i aiioa Ciese Meicie (CM o ea maaies agig om eiium o emoois a ae ow aso use i ig-ice cosmeics suc as samoo As Asiaic ack ea ouaios ae ee ecimae o e ea as ae uscuuous oiees ae se ei sigs o Ameicas iae ea ouaio eea egisa- io is soey eee o ceae a uiom ega amewok oecig Ameica eas om is ea O euay 5 1997 Seao Mic McCoe (KY iouce "e ea oecio Ac" (A i e US Seae (S 3 As o Ai 3 ee wee 31 co-sosos o is ey eiio Agais Sou Koea Sumie o iaisa i Simuaeousy Cogessma o oe Ieio Seceay ai Ardn t Sth Krn tr d, "f th 60,000 Sth Krn h (I iouce ieica egisaio ( 19 i e ouse trvld t hlnd n , pprxtl 0,000 nd br ndr o eeseaies—aso a iaisa eo wi oe co- br prt hl n th ntr.... rt p fr US$,00 t US$,000 sosos fr lv br. h br thn drnd, t llblddr rvd, nd t o esios o e i t nd p nd." • Make i iega o imo io o eo om e US ea -SIERRA CLUB LEGAL DEFENSE FUND PETITION iscea [e oy uis o iea ogas icuig e gaae] o oucs a coai o caim o coai ea e ay oowig Cogessioa ioucio o e ea iscea; oecio Ac 133 ogaiaios ougou e couy oiy • Make i iega o a eso o se ae oe o se o se a ee o Seceay o e Ieio uce ai equesig ae ucase o ossess wi ie o se o ae i a Sou Koea e ceiie ue e ey Ameme o e iesae o oeig commece ea iscea o oucs a isemas oecie Ac o 197 o is coiuig oe i e coai o caim o coai ea iscea; goa ea as ae Suc ceiicaio eaes e esie • Auoie e imosiio o cii a cimia eaies o imose ecoomic sacios agais Sou Koea muc ike as ig as $ a u o 5 yeas i iso e ioaio ose imose o aiwa o is eaig oe i e ae i as usua o e US acey Ac o 191; a a oucs o eagee iges a ios Sou Koea is • omoe ieaioa cooeaio o oec eas y cuey uemiig e eecie imemeaio o eisig isucig e Uie Saes ae eeseaie a e ea oecio ue CIES wic i oie i 1993 Seceay o e Ieio o cosu wi eeseaies o e Aoug oy a au o Asiaic ack eas (Ur eaig imoig eoig a cosumig couies i a thbtn emais i Sou Koea omesic ema o ea eo o esais a cooiae saegy o e is eime- oucs aeas isaiae ea as cosumio i Asia a ae couies—suc as Sou Koea—eaes o oy e ew oay e A wi o usu saes auoiy o emaiig iigeous Sou Koea eas u a oe ea maagig esie ea ouaios o eem sog sae secies ougou e wo icuig Ameica ack eas aws a aeay oii commeciaiaio o ea as (Ur rn, wose ga aes ae iuay iisi- e uose o e i is o esue a e Uie guisae oce emoe om e aima Saes oes o coiue o e isasous ae i ea e ey eiio ie y e Siea Cu ega eese as I oiis imoaio o oucs om ea- u Ic coais eeaios o Sou Koea auses o gee Asia eas coses e oooes ceae y e CIES eguaios iee o oec aious ea secies e cue acwok o sae aws a uos Ameicas eiio oes a "ee ae ee ee ay seiues o ieaioa eay oigaios ue e Coeio o osecuios o ea ga smuggig i Sou Koea I is Ieaioa ae i Eagee Secies o Wi aua acuum o oicia ackowegme a acio Sou Koeas a oa (CIES coiue o cosume eas a a aamig ace" is egisaio wi e maiai a eay Ameica e eiio cies may seciic iega acs ie y e ea ouaio a wi se a message o oaces ema o ga aes ie aws a mea icuig smugges a cosumes e wo oe a e US wi • "e smuggig ou o aia o iy eas o cosum- o oeae a aack o ou eas a wi o aiciae io y Sou Koea aees o e 19 Oymic Games" i is oie ack make ae As Seao McCoe • "A emoyee o Koea Aiies wo coceae a oe "Aoug we cao esoe e umes we oce asoe ea gaaes a ee woe ea cacasses a we ca isue a e emaiig eas ae o so o io Sou Koea sae a e was ae o ge e ea as io oi o e iges ie" e couy y iig cusoms oicias" 6 • "e esie o Seoyug aig Comay ase i associae wi e isua simi- Sou Koea as sae We I am sick I go o e USA o aiy o ow ea as suc as ea a wac i kie myse" e ga ae wi simia o- ee is o usiicaio o emiig a couy wose gas o oe eagee a ciies egage i suc eeae egegious cicumeios o eaee ea secies ieaioa coseaio ageemes o go uuise A Aoio o e oosa wi e ey eas ey ceiicaio y e Seceay o e Ieio a a esseia ee o oec- wi e e Sou Koea goeme a oes ougou io o e wiig oua- e wo kow a e Uie Saes akes is oigaios ios o ow eas ougou ue CIES seiousy a wi o oeae ioaio y oe Euoe Asia a e ome aios o ei ciies Sog acio y e Uie Saes Soie Uio a oeuy wi agais Sou Koea o is ouig o e Coeio wi ay e asse eeiiousy e amewok o ue acieemes i ea oecio a e ow ea age isuse- ucomig CIES Coeece o e aies is summe i me is eemey iese occu- imawe ig i sma ockes o a ougou Asia Euoe a o Ameica As uma ouaios coiue o gow ow ea ouaios ecome YEAR OF THE BEAR? iceasigy agmee a agie ue wowie eo- b Ad brt esaio eseciay ougou ukey ussia a suou- ig ageas as esice aaiae suiae aia o ea oecio o e Agea a ue CIES ow eas Meeig e ow ea is aeay eic i may Euoea "Ipt (n brn br ppltn r ll t nr hh pr couies a ouaio saus eos iicae o moe a ntn t prvd n nntv t ph br, nd t br 11 o 1 ow eas iai e Ease emisee hbtt nr." As ow ea umes ay om couy o couy so oo

-CITES LISTING PROI'OSAL SUBMITTED BY FINLAND oes e ee o oecio eac ouaio eceies Accoig o ias oosa i ace oa e Ukaie a oe oowig ue cosieaio a o e CIES Aimas couies e secies is "uy oece" wie omaia aows Commiee a Saig Commiee meeigs as yea e ea us "ue secia icese u oy i seaso" aa suec o e iega goa ae i ea as a oucs as wi a ukow u "iceasigy isoae su-ouaio" o ee oiciay ise o e agea o e ucomig e ow eas maiais miima ega oecio a emis CIES Coeece o e aies (see "CIES akes a Imoa ea us "o so a as a es" is Se o e eas" AW I Qrtrl, a 199 I is AWIs ias oosa oes a "oacig o ow ea a oe a e Uie Saes CIES eegaio wi oi Cia i iega ae i ea as is a is mos seee i e ussia a caig o assage o a esouio ecaig a goa moaoium Eas" a a "e ussia Maia is eaiy ioe i e o e ae i ea as o a ea secies aicuay e iega wiie ae" e Ease emiseic iega ea wiy oiae ga aes Suc acio wi ay a eme- as ae emoies a come smuggig we wee "ie- ous oe i eig e ea o e wos eas om e gay imoe uig oies om omaia eas ae commeciaiaio o ei auae as ee seie i Sai" "Gema so ues cicume Aiioa seciic aeio o e ig o ow eas omesic egisaio oiiig e imo o oies om (Ur rt as ee oug o e aeio o CIES omaia eas y assig em oug ussia is" a eegaes i seaae oosas sumie o e CIES Sece- "iega ae io Geece oies a oeig io e woe EU aia y ia wi e suo o ugaia a oa ese [Euoea Uio]" sumissios seek o aise e ee o oecio aoe a I is imoa a CIES eegaes suo oacie emaiig ouaios o ow eas (ecuig o Ameica measues i accoace wi e "ecauioay icie" a om Aei II o Aei I us eeig ae i ow ecogie e age ow eas ace om ese iicae a ea as is acio is aoe eo o euce oems eesie oacig a smuggig oeaios As e oosa ackoweges "o e oace i oes o mae wic secies o ea is ue i aes ae ou wi gas om [eagee Asiaic] ack eas ey meey caim a ey ae om ow eas" A Aei I isig wi o oy iecy eei ow eas u aso igy eagee ea secies wose gaaes as meioe aoe ae isuay iisi- guisae om ose o ow eas a ae iegay auee as suc eemie measues suc as e A Sou Koea ey ceiicaio a aoiae acio y CIES aies wi oie icacuae eeis o e saiie a e oua- ios so ey ca suie o geeaios o come 1 1:

Asiaic ack ea (Ur thbtn, su ea (lrt ln, secace ea (rrt rnt, a so ea (Mlr rn. 893 7 e wo ecaes eaig u o e 199 iea- ese oosas eese a oious aem o I ioa a o commeciaiaio o eea ioy u a uge wege i e oo o uimaey oeig e e coie-wie Aica eea ouaio was u-scae esumio o e ioy ae e egaia- cu i a ow amos e yeas ae AWI a io o ieaioa commecia ae i ioy ega- oe coseaio a aima oecio ogaia- ess o is oigi a esiaio wou oie a ios ae oce o ee goa eea oecio coe o iega ae a e esumio o ay ega agais ose wo wis o eoe e ooy ioy ioy ae wou simuae cuey suesse ae a suseque eea sauge ioy makes wowie As was e case eoe e e ocus o e goa eae is wee o o ioy a make ema wou simuae a iega aies o e Coeio o Ieaioa ae i ae eee o oace eeas Eagee Secies o Wi aua a oa (CIES wi sa im agais essue om ooes o e Experts Question Controls cue a o commecia ae i Aica eea A CIES ae o Ees was coee o iesi- oucs ow is a ioa ime o eciig e gae coiios eae o eea coseaio i e eeas uue as imawe oswaa a amiia couies ioe i e owisig oosa e ae oyig a o CIES aies o euce Aica see-meme ieaioa ae se wo weeks as eea oecio we e e Coeece o e Ocoe aeig ougou oswaa amiia a aies (CO1 coees is ue i aae ima- imawe wi a suseque eceme i o aa we e oose imoig couy o e sockie ioy Aica eeas (Loxodonta africana) ae oece e 5-age eaie eo ses o umeous o ieaioay a i e US CIES iss e cocusios icuig e oowig secies o Aei I wic icues "a secies Botswana eaee wi eicio wic ae o may e aece • Coos oe ioy socks i oswaa ae iaequae I may o e ossie o eemie e oigi o muc o e y ae" Commecia ae i Aei I secies is ioy wii e sockie oiie i mos cases u oe o e cue ece- • e ae is uae o eic wa sycoogica ios is so-ue Aica eea oies wic W eec [om owisig] o oaces a iega aes i ae ega wi secia emis e US Eagee E r. ioy wi e e oswaa goeme oes o ae a Secies Ac iss e secies as "eaee" meaig cea oicy o ow o use e moey o mecaisms o Y AAM OES esuig asaecy i e way a i is use a i is ikey o ecome eagee i o oece Namibia e 19 Aica Eea Coseaio Ac esaise a moa- Prospective Poaching imos o woke ioy" • ... e maoiy o ae memes eiee a e age ume oium o imoaio io e US o ioy—agai wi eem- o coiscaios o ioy o Agoa oigi oies cicumsaia eos ou o soue a ease Aica sow oiees Egegious ioaios o e cue CIES oiiio iicae ios o so-ue oies eiece a some ioy is moig oug amiia a is iew osiioig emsees o ea eomous iacia ewas sou a iaiiy o a eas uwiigess amog some CIES aies ogee ese oecios ee saiie eea oua- is suoe y e ESU [Eagee Secies oecio Ui] o e ioy ae e eoee Oe eues eo om a Es suc as imawe o aee o e Coeio Moeoe i Sou Aica ios a ougy a a miio cause a amaic ecie i ioy Saaam i aaia oe a "oice seie 13 eea usks sows a wiie aw eoceme as we as eo a imo Zimbabwe ices a simiie aw eoceme a ai-oacig eos o e Iia Ocea isa o aia ou o aia" esicios ae oue A cea message om e CIES aies • aw Eoceme wi esec o e ioy ae as ee owee as scemig oces e wo oe wok ieessy o gossy iaequae WM [eame o aioa aks a Aoe eo om usaka amia saes a "amia oice a e ioy a is o-egoiae is esseia o eucio o oi oce moe om ea eeas oaces ae icease Wi ie Maageme] as emie e esaisme o age- i Soue oice ae smase a ogaie ioy acke oacig a smuggig eea kis i oe o "make a (iacia kiig" sou ioy scae ioy caig oeaios wic ae seig commecia quai- imouig 5 eea usks a aesig ee susecs" ies o semi-woke ioy iee o eo o Asia couies agai e so egay i e goa makeace A ews om aae imawe is a a "o Koea Zimbabwe, Botswana, & Namibia icuig aa eoes euic o Cia a aia e oigia 199 oosa o a ieaioa commecia • Iomaio om ESU iicaes a a age ooio o ioma was eig quesioe ae e ie o smugge 33 ieces iega ioy aiig i Sou Aica as asse oug imawe o eea ioy ou o imawe" ae o ioy came om aaia a coiues o e suoe • imawe as oo coo oe ae i eea oucs ese ae us a ew cases a ae ee ucoee Wo oewemigy y Aica age saes io o e 37 meeig oe a ioy kows ow may oe simes o ioy go ueece o o e CIES Saig Commiee a secia meeig was e i • e imawea goeme oes o ae a cea oicy o wiig ioy mecas? Wa is cea is a ieaioa aka Seega "o oie e Aica eea age Saes wi ow o use e moey om sae o goeme-owe ioy o a oouiy o cosu eac oe o issues eae o e mecaisms o esuig asaecy i e way a i is use moeme o iega ioy—o a eas aems a suc asoe Japan simes—as sae u agai coseaio o e secies" • e coo o eai ae is o aequae o ieeiae e imawe eae amog e soue Aica ioy ae Oe cocusio o e meeig accoig o oicia CII ES oucs o egay acquie ioy om ose o iega souces ooes as oay e ages omesic ioy caig ocumes is a "seig [ioy] oug a ega sysem o iea- iusy o e coie Accoig o a eaie eoy e ioa makes aise coces eseciay y a ume o wes Aica ase o e aes eo oe ca cocue a aoug CIES ae o Ees age Saes aou e simuaio o iega ae a e egaie eea ouaios i a ew Aica couies may e sae ee is eiece a wo eaes [ae] issue Ceiicaes o imac is mig ae o some eea ouaios" a aequae moioig may eis suicie ae coos age commecia quaiies o woke ioy esie o eo o a esie is seious coce a aig aeay aie a a eguaoy eoceme mecaisms—eseciay i ima- aiey o couies icuig aa Cia aia og Kog CIES meeigs i Kyoo a o aueae o owis Aica we—ae o i ace I e owisig is gae i is ikey e iiies Ioesia USA a Sou Aica Some o e eeas a ew soue Aica couies e y imawe a Aica eeas wi oce agai e saugee a e simes wee ey age icuig a sige sae o seas aue a wi e makig ye aoe aem a CO1 $ 919113 (aoimaey US$ 9 o a aaese cusome a oucs icuig ioy auee aog wi eisig sock- oe esie o aia aue a $ e ioy egises ogee imawe oswaa a amiia ae oosig ies Uimaey i e ioy ae is comeey eoee a o e eae ioe iicae a uig e mo o Ai 199 owisig eac o ei eea ouaios om Aei I a uue CIES meeig e eea wi agai a ey o e aoe e a so ioy seas o aaese cusomes cae om 1 o Aei II o aow eo o os o woe usks om ei oaces ig-owee ies a ouaios o is magii- usks oaig 1 oes sockies o aa oe sime i 199 a oe i 1999; o eo ce secies ougou e coie wi esume e amaic e ae cocue a "is is a mae o seious coce" ie aimas o "aoiae a acceae" esiaios; o aow ecie a iiiay e o sog ieaioa oecio o a aiey o easos icuig e acs a imawe Cusoms ieaioa ae i uig oies; a o imawe o aow oices aie o eec o oii ese simes a a e ieaioa ae i eea ies eae aices a ioy imoig aios "aea o ae aie o iece ese iega soueis continued on next page

(99 9 guaaee a moey mae om ioy saes wi ge om e goeme o oca commuiies is was o e case io o e ioy a a ee is o easo o eiee a i wi e ue ow Gie e oeia o goemea couio i imawe (see "CAMIEs ices isic Goes oke" AWI Qrtrl , Sig/Summe 199 suc iacia isuse- mes ae uikey I a eceme 199 eo e imawea aiame cocue a imawes WM is "ie y cou- io iigig a eaousy" a a ee eiss a "maage- me cisis" wii e eame is is ay a sou oe o coiece o imawes aiiy o ee iega eea kiigs a aoiaey isiue us om suc sauge o commuiies i ee o iacia assisace Accoig o eesa eecky o e umae Sociey o e Uie Saes (SUS wo as ee ea e eese o e ioy a a ieee eauao was ie y e Uie Saes Agecy o Ieaioa eeome (USAI o assess CAMIEs eecieess eecky eos e An lphnt fl rp "eauao ou a e oec is ooiousy weak i is eiomea assessme o oeia imacs esuig om ntnd fr prv p e oec; a oca goemes ke mos o e eeue Sttn Arnd th Sldrn CAMIE ae a giig i o e eoe; a a e oecs I is o oy e imawea goeme a is suo- aoac is suec o coase oce oo iacig is ig a eewe eea sauge oay e Commua Aeas wiaw" a o is "oo iacig" acuay icues Maageme ogamme o Iigeous esouces (CAM- ga moey om USAI ise eecky oe ue IE a e we-ue Aica esouces us (A ae a "CAMIE eas a ess om oy uig (aoi- oie oces wi Saai Cu Ieaioa o aciiae eea maey US$ miio e aum a i gais i oeig ai kiig a e CIES owisig om e US goeme a oe goemes (a eas Accoig o CAMIEs ow uise ieaue "i US$5 miio e aum om e US aoe" seeks o esucue e coo o imawes couysie giig eoe aeaie ways o usig ei aua esouces" USAI—Yr x llr t Wr is eig esciio eies e ac a CAMIE ees e moey a USAI ses o e CAMIE o- sog essue o eoi eeas o ei auae ioy gam wic wi aoo o amos $3 miio y 1999 is Ceaig susaiay ucioig Aica commuiies is a esumay use o u a aiey o ogams ese icue aisewoy goa I ac CAMIE ecogies some acce- omoig oy uig o Aica eeas a oyig ae wiie-ase o-cosumie iusies icuig "a- o i e ieaioa ioy a As oe aoe i is ig e ais o e wi amei iewig e icoia as ouu a is moey is eig use wisey eiciey o ekkig i wieess aeas cimig e myseious mou- i a equae mae amog isics ougou imawe ais o Cimaimai" CAMIE aso aocaes commuiy- r ase ouism wee ua commuiies os ouiss em- AICA SUO O E IOY A sees cuua ouism wee "ouiss eeiece e oca cuue oug saig aiioa oos music a iesye" "Aei I as aise oe o eea ouaios" a aiioa ecoouism iusies icuig i-wacig -MM yimo Cie aw Eoceme Oice Wiie e- a eoic wiie iewig A o ese ae auae meca- ame aaia isms o aacig a se-susaiig commuiy a oiig "oacig o eeas as a u soe e ice o ioy om aua esouces wiou esoyig em is a a a ime ow a uic aiues i suo o eea owee CAMIE ieaue saes a 9 o is coseaio ae ey ig iee" icome is eie om oy uig o eeas Make o -ica eakey ome ieco Keya Wiie Seice misake is is o oy aou aowig a au o weay "Aei I isig as geay euce coss-oe ae i Ameicas o Euoeas e oouiy o ae a Aica ioy I as aso cause e oacig o eeas o saai a ig ack a eea oy I is aou u-scae ecie" esumio o e ioy ae awoa aegwa o e -Moses Okua Cie Game Wae Ugaa CAMIE Associaio amie as muc "imawe agey o ea o CAMIE is eaig e camaig o e-oe e "e Aei I isik as coiue o e ee o ioy ae" awaeess o o goeme isiuios a e commu- e mao coeio o CAMIE a imawe is a iy wi eeis o secies eseaio" eoeig e ioy ae wou oie muc-eee e- -Maue Eoc Cie o eame o aks a esees eue o imoeise iages O couse i M aegwa Agoa is accuae i suggesig a CAMIE "as ee makig a "o ou aou i eeas ae wo a moe aie a o o moey $13 miio i 1995" oe mus woe wy ea " suc a successu ogam ees a eoee ioy ae a a -oe Muma ome ea o e amia Secies Moeoe as e ae o Ees oe ee is o oecio eame 1 0 e9 ( SUS oes a "o eey oa e US goeme us i CAM- IE eas oy 5 ces i icome O e 5 ces eae y e ogam oy 5 ae eue o iages wie e es ae eaie y e ima- wea goemes ua isic Coucis aioa a isic goe- mes" eas mos egegious oug is e ac a USAI gies a cosi- eae sum o moey Ameica a- aye oas o a ieee o- gaiaio ame Aica esouces us (A e ou yea uge o A—us om USAI—is $39 A uses e moey o uis ciicisms agais umae a coseaio ogaiaios as we as CIES ise a o i maeias omoig e esumio o e ioy ae Atlnt r. rr Mpl, ttfn n bhlf f th Afrn Elphnt Cnrv tn At, d, "In 199 I vtd t n Kn v tnl r, hr t Accoig o e ue 1995 "a dlt nd n bb lphnt r bthrd b phr. hr hd t ff o Oeaios" o e "aua e- thr f t rv thr t. I hd nvr tnd n lr t f nd." souces Maageme oec (M ase II - imawe" As "ou- us" ae o icue omoio o ieaioa makes o No Blood Money CAMIE oucs suc as ioy y eeoig "e- I aiio o ecoouism-ase aoaces suc as o- gioa a ieaioa suo ewoks o CAM- cosumie wiie ouism a cuua ouism wii IE" a o kee "key ecisio-makes meia GOs oca commuiies ee ae some oe ways o e e- a acaemic commuiies i USA seece couies o eas a imoeise Aica commuiies Euoe a Aica iome a iuece" asicay Muc o e moey eoe o CAMIE A a Saai US moey goes o A o ieaioa oyig o Cu Ieaioa o iec a iiec suo o eea omoe e ioy ae is is aicuay eeesie oy uig a omoio o e ioy ae cou e sice US oicy a e gea maoiy o US ciies o o eiece o omoig a makeig ecoouism a e suo ieaioa commecia ioy ae u a agecy susaiae coage iusies a wi eeo as iceasig o e US goeme USAI is usig miios o oas umes o oeig ouiss isi soue Aica ese o Ameica aaye moey o u ogaiaios a ugeoig ew wiie-ase eues icue suc ioa- omoe esumio o e goa ioy ae Aso a ie ieas as makig ae om eea ug Keya aie ece o eeae a o e Ameica uic a coseaiois Mike ugaa iscoee a e ug ca oose e eea goeme oiig us o ai e oie soake esse a su-ie io aw ae e oy uig o eeas a oe wiie New Scientist eos a e Keya Wiie Seice as "com- uemoe accoig o e A "Aciiies" is o e missioe im o ouce eea ug iiaio cas o e eio 1995-1999 moey wi e use o secue oices a wiie seices 5 aiesay ceeaios is yea aog ecui sa i e Uie Kigom usses Wasigo wi a secia ma o Keya o eseaio o e couys C a Sou Aica; ouce a uis CAMIE a esie" e Wiie Sociey o Maawi a ae Makig A ocues "ac sees ooks ookes a osiio Eucaio us ae coaoae o make eea ug aes"; "ieiy a iuece u o 1 key iiiuas"; ae eeoes a oe iems wi e moey goig ack a "o ieig semias i USA Euoe a Aica" io eea coseaio e mos succic ioy may ae come om ece Aiioay ioaie ogams ae ueway o mii- commes y ai aes ieco o USAIs Goa mie e uma-eea coic a someimes aises ecause Eiome Cee "o oe is igig o i e a o o a sae eea ouaio a oomig uma oua- ioy" M aes caims Ieesig e imawea io o isace e Ieaioa u o Aima Weae ewsae e Ctzn eoe o eceme 199 a as oae oe $ miio o e aioa aks oa i Sou "CAMIE as cae o e a o ioy aig o e Aica o ucase a wic ca e use o eocaio o ie" Moeoe aaeaa Maeeke o e CAM- eeas om aeas wee ei coceaio is oo gea IE associaio sai i e Ai 199 CAMIE EWS, Aiioay SUS as ueake a eesie eseac "aioa a ieaioa egisaios [] mus e su- ogam o immuocoaceio o miimie e imac o oie o ee ae i ioy a eea oucs" Maye uma/eea coic M aes a USAI sou eik ei osiio o A oe o ese may e e sige aswe o e goa CAMIE a e ioy ae eoe makig ay moe eea eae u ogee ey ca coiue o a saemes o e suec—a eas eoe makig ay moe eaceu a oseous eisece o Aicas a Aica uge iacia eeiues eeas 9 7 11 ht fr th rt—nd hr Inhbtnt y uiee Wiiams ei aioa ouaies iey e ce o e ieaioa As is eo goes o ess ew igues ae ee aouce ae is omiae y uge asaioa comaies wose y e Uie aios oo a Agicuue Ogaiaio ecoomic a oiica musce aows em iuay ue- wic sow a ou ae wiesse a e oss o 5 miio sice access io oess acoss e goe ecaes o oess ewee 199 a 1995—is is equiae Gie a o e causes a eecs o oes oss a o a aea wice e sie o Iay Eigy e ce o e wos egaaio ae equey goa i aue a ee i is o gow oess ae ow ee esoye o egae a eie a e goa oes cisis wi o e esoe uess muc o e emaie is eig eaiy = a ui goa cooeaio is aciee ogge wi caasoic esus o wiie I 1995 e Eiomea Iesigaio I e oica oes egios aoe a esi- Agecy (EIA auce a mao ew iea- mae 7 secies cou e oce io ioa camaig o a goa oess Coe- eicio y eoesaio eac a eey io o oie amog oe igs ei- yea omea eguaio o e goa ime oug e goa ime ae (ow iusy Aoug a ume o eisig aue a aou $ iio e yea is o ieaioa ageemes a U agecies e oy cause o oes oss i is e geaes ae eeace o oes issues oe as ea o aua oess (e ices i se- Aln tprt rnfrt oe eecie a geig o e oo o e cies o mee e ema o cea a oem A oess Coeio wi oces- eiu suies o ime a ae e ieaioa ae ae a cooiae assau o oes oems a a ees o iusy coiues is esucio o oess aguig a ei goeace A ew Coeio wi oie a sog ame- eaceme wi sige-secies aaios is "susaiae" wok o cosee oess a—uike e ese siuaio— Ye ese aaios ae aou as simia o a aua oes as wi esue egay-iig commimes makig goe- a ooa ie is o a owe-ic meaow mes moe accouae a ei ecisiomakig moe Acoss e goe e same ae is occuig a caa- asae; as we as ecouagig aioa oes aig ogue o easaio om Caaas o-gow oess ome a oece oes aeas I wi aso oie a esseia o ea wo a y; e oica oess o Ioesia a oum o cooiae iacia assisace ecoogy ase Maaysia ieaceae aia o oaguas; o ussias a scieiic a ecica eseac oess ome o e as emaiig 5 Sieia iges—a ae I ue 199 wo eaes me a e Ea Summi i io ue seee a immeiae ea om e ime iusy o iscuss e sae o e wos eiome a oose As e goa makeace eas i is iceasigy acios o aciee oes coseaio a susaiae ee- iicu o goemes a cosumes o iuece e ome esie is e ae o oes esucio as aciiies o comaies oeaig o wii a eyo oceee ucecke a e ime a ae iusy as ee aowe o escaae wiou esai is comig ue wo eaes wi mee agai a Ea Summi II o eiew "Bushmeat": Primate Casualties of ogess mae sice 199 i imemeig agee-uo Out-of-Control Greed for Timber acios o cosee e eiome e Summi eses a isoic oouiy o agee o a cea couse o acio As ime comaies ess ue a ue io e owas eeoig a oess Coeio Cea Aica aioess e esucio woug o e io Ea Summi esaise e U Commissio aia is o e oy amage oe o aimas A o Susaiae eeome wic a is i meeig i ouisig ae i "usmea"—usuay e smoke Mac 1995 iscusse ogess mae owas acieig oes mea o uieiiae imaes—uses oggig ucks a coseaio ecogiig e sie o e ask a e com- oggig oas as isiuio caes a as a caie eiy o e eae suouig oess e commissio make i e ime wokes sice e oggig comaies esaise a Iegoemea ae o oess (I o geeay o o ay o ee ei cews is ae is "usue cosesus a cooiae oosas o acio o comiig wi aia esucio a oe acos o suo e maageme coseaio a susaiae e- gaey eage Aicas gea aes eome o a yes o oess" aes i usmea ki goias a cimaees e aes maae was o eamie issues a aec amog oe aimas i aamig umes e Iea- oess icuig oe-cosumio o ime e imac o ioa imae oecio eague esimaes a i o- ae uo e eiome a meas o emey ese e Cogo aoe - goias ae kie auay oems icuig moiiig iacia assisace cooia- Aoe agic cosequece o is ae is e o- ig scieiic a soci eseac a ecouagig ecoogy as i ouces we moe aes ae kie o mea ase ei youg cao suie o ei ow ese ias a Oe e as wo yeas EIA as woke wii e I oo oe eie ie o ae ke as es i cuey egige o y a esue a we wo eaes mee a Ea coiios Oy a ew ca e escue a aise i Summi II i ue ey wi make a ecisio i ao o a ew sacuaies oess Coeio o moe iomaio ea e eo "Sauge o A e ou a ia I meeig euay 11-1 1997 e Aes" aaiae om e Wo Sociey o e a ume o aios ecae ei suo o a ew Goa oecio o Aimas agey ae oo SW 1 oess Coeio a uike e oaise siuaio o e Ega; oe ( 171 793 5 ∎ Ea Summi e iisios ewee oe a Soue 1 aios ae imiise susaiay oae amog a- ios a ow suo a coeio ae ussia Maaysia e iiies Ioesia Cia a aua ew Guiea Sog suo o a coeio coiues o come om Caaa a e Euoea Uio—i is oicia oicy o a EU meme aios o suo e eeome o a coeio Suisigy a e ou meeig o e I a ume 0 o o-goemea ogaiaios (GOs oose e e- eome o a oess Coeio caimig a i is "ema- ue" a wi esie a "owes commo eomiao" o 0 oes maageme is esie e ac a i 199 oe 5 ieaioa eiomea ogaiaios gae oca suo o a coeio e US Goeme aye o GO eas u soo eaiey isoae i is egessie sace o a oes coe- io aguig a e case o a coeio as ye o e oe Gie a aou couies ae i ao o a coeio a may moe ae oe o e ossiiiy e quesio aises as o wy e US as ake suc a isoae a aaey iasige osiio I 199 ice esie A Goe a suoe e egoiaio o a oes coeio—e e e US egisaos eegaio o e U Coeece o Eiome a ee- ome (Ea Summi i 199 Goe as aso see as esie o GOE Ieaioa wic i 199 ouce a a oes coeio "o oie guiace a esseia eemes o e ieaioa eae aou oess" As is esoa iee omeage ocaims "A Goes commi- Grtr ldr nt n hl hh nl bn t fr n me a eaesi o eiomea issues is uaaee tr ldr thn 20 r. Shrthtd frtr prt e as sai e oecio a eseaio o e eas dtr thr h. eiome is oe o e mos imoa issues acig is geeaio" o us e eas oess ae eig esoye a e ae o I a keyoe aess o e Commissio o Susaiae oe ooa ies wo eey seco" eeome i ue 1993 us oe yea ae io Goe oe Gie is cea ecogiio o e ie siuaio acig e a "we ae uie y a commo emise a uma wos oess a e goa eiome a e ugecy aciiies ae eeessy causig gae a eas ieaae o iig eecie og-em souios o e oes cisis amage o e goa eiome e ages ae cea o a wy oes e US aocae maieace o e saus quo i e ace o e escaaig cisis o oes oss? I e US Goeme ow asses a a oess coeio is ema- The World's Largest Corporation; ue ow may ees wi e os eoe e US ecees a e the World's Most Flagrant Despoiler? ime is ig o auc egoiaios? e US cies a ack o cosesus o ceai issues as a e igges cooae ecoomy i e wo—e aie o iiiaig egoiaios u cosesus was a ess Misuisi Cooaio—wies moe ecoomic owe aace we e egoiaios o e Coeios o a a u 1 couies Isea o usig is weig a ioogica iesiy a Cimae Cage wee iiiae u- iuece o goo owee is mammo comay is emoe egoiaios o a coeio ae i eec ee seaiy oeeoiig e wos esouces o oi ueake sice e eaaoy ocess o e Ea Sum- oggig a e way o e ak mi i 199 a ae ecey iesiie uig e Iego- Misuisi wic coos oe 9 miio ecaes o emea ae o oess ocess oes us e ages mi i e Amao aioes A e io Ea Summi oiica eaes wee uae o ows Cies ages eoe o woocis a is cosis- agee uo e esiaiiy o a ew coeio ie yeas o ey amog e ages eoes o oica ime o Ea Summi II eses a isoic oouiy o commi aa emsees o coseig e aes oess I eeses e ogee wi e Meica goeme Misuisi sige es oe o goa cooeaio io e e mie- as o esais a sa oucio aciiy i Meicos ium e aeaie is uikae—"usiess as usua" is agua Sa Igacio e as ueeoe maig gou a ioeae siuaio o e wos oess wiie a a usey o gay waes e oec wou icue eoes a cao e aowe o coiue e US mus a ie ay ockig access o e agoo e acoy cage is mi a suo e maoiy o couies ee- wou ai wae om e agoo a e ae o see a e Commissio o Susaiae eeome i gaos e seco a—aig eiomea isu o suoig a coeio a eiomea iuy—e sa ouce wou go io makig coie a ecoogicay amu ocess a ltt Wll frt pnr fr th Envrnntl ouc Invttn An. 2 ecisio sake cages a ow make e US iusy e Chrl h US isic uge o C wo eae i e oecio o ois A coeague wo soke a is memoia seice o e age uge Caes icey wi og e ememee o is magiice oy o moues a uge icey was "o o e a uge" a seies o amak ecisios o e oecio o aimas e o ackog o cases e woke coscieiousy o e e I coemig e "eomace saas" a a ee e was oewoy o "e eiciecy wi wic e ke u wie ue uess y e Seceay o Agicuue o ime- wi is caseoa" sai e Whntn t. me e Imoe Saas o aoaoy Ai- "uge icey aso soug o make goeme mas amemes o e Aima Weae Ac e oicias aie y aws e e ey wee yig o woe "A e ouse e Cou sa sae e igoe I 1993 e cause a som o ciicism we oowig is case ioes aimas a suec a e iece e Cio amiisaio o come u sou e o gea imoace o a umaki" wi a eiomea imac saeme coeig uge icey usy oece o is eguaoy o- e o Ameica ee ae Ageeme osa a so seeey weakee e oigia o- "e amiisaio was oyig eaiy o ose eguaios Seae aiicaio o e measue a e uges I aoe case (uouaey oeue uge acio was see as a osace a cou oie icey ue a e Aima Weae Ac mus coe ece-sies wi a oiicay acceae easo o e mos umeous eeimea aimas use y oosig i I e e e US Cou o Aeas scieiic isiuios—amey mice as a is acae e uges oe a e eay was asse" is uig o ois wic sae ues o ousas accoig o e t. o em om ea i ua use seies was wiey accaime O igig ugs "uge iceys cimia caea i- e uge oee e aioa Maie iseies Seice o cue e 199 ia o ayu Emo III a ooious kigi eoce e oi oecio oisios o e Maie Mamma o e isics ug ae wo was seece o ie i iso oecio Ac agais e US ua iusy e was aae wiou aoe e uge oke ew gou o ias i e ciy a e US ua ee was uwiig o imeme e mos asic we e ke e uy aoymous o oesa eisas om e coseaio measues o oec ois a a ime is ug wo" o11 C Goeo egisao Moe ig-game guie wo a ee iice osiie eeis o e Aei I is- o imi og acoies o 15 eoy cous eae o is guiig ig o e eea a aess issues aciiies "Ieesigy" wies h d suc as e eig "use" o eeas o Caoia Goeo im u o- rl Wldlf Offr, "wie some o e e oe aye y e ouism iusy ose a e sae egisaue u a eea ioaios wee commie is i eea coseaio eoceme wo-yea moaoium o ew o e- guie was ee o wok eease wie e o e ieaioa a a e ecoogi- ae og acoies Meawie sae was seig a wo-yea sae iso se- ca oe o eeas wii ei ecosys- eeseaie ica Moga is aso ece o seua ause o a mio" em e coeece wi e caie y sosoig a i imiig age og ams • WS aouce a a oia ma ee Oio ieco o Aica E- Mogas i cas o a oe-yea moao- was seece o wo yeas i iso a ea ouaio Ieaioa; oe ium o oeaios wi moe a 5 oee o ay a $5 ie o cosi- Muma omey wi e Secies o- ogs esoes oca goemes o- ig o smugge oe oe ue eu- ecio eame o amia; a ig auoiy oe iusia ams a ia e ai oa cosicos io Miami aeie Sackey wi e oice o e iceases e equie seack isaces i ioaio o e Eagee Secies Ac esie o Gaa ewee og aciiies (suc as uiigs A eay e ai oa cosico is eo- aie oeses Sike o a agoos a eigoig ies ey wo $ o e eai make akes a omes ego a a EIA oss Eea Coeece Wiie aw Eoceme ie oioe ai-u emosaos igigs e Eiomea Iesigaio Agecy aie o seeces agig om 3 ays Caiae us is osig a mao co- o see mos o aious cages we Accoig o h drl Wldlf Offr: eece o e eea o e e i o uge sikes i euay a Mac • US is & Wiie Seice (WS oaesug Sou Aica May 5-7 o eess ei oosiio o cue a- Oeaio Eie—a camaig ocusig 1997 e coeece wi coe a wie ig acices o iega akig o ae sea ucks—as secum o issues eaig o e success e sikes emae 1 a eea cumiae i seea ousaig cases a eecieess o e 199 CIES e- ia o e ego a a e US e icuig a o Gae Sek wo is a cisio o a ieaioa ae i Ai- is oosiio o e Euoea Uios we-egae aiemis a Cio ca eea oucs a o ueie ai-ego a eguaio (see age 5 oso wo is a ome ice esie e ee o maiaiig Aei I o a 3 a e Sae o ew Yok so a o Saai Cu Ieaioa Aso as a a Aica eea ouaios i a wou egaie usig aiu saes esu o Oeaio Eie a o Cao- e coeece wi oie a a- o eaes ia waeow guie was ie $1 om o e oices o Aica a Asia Accoig o ica Mais ao- a gie a yeas oss o uig ii- coseaioiss o e ea y e me- ey o wo o e oeses "o some eges a wo yeas oaio ia y ecisio-makes a e uic a easo ey wee seece ey asy • WS ages i Aaska aese a age aes esee wi coe e o oeses wic ae eaiey mio" 1 ntrtr Cndn C M f nd ues o eoe emosae ousie e oices o e aioa ok ouces Couci i Mac o oice suo o amiy ams a oosiio o acoy ams Musicia a amiy am aocae Wiie eso soke a eome a e emosaio A issue is e moe a $5 miio a yea a C eceies i e om o "cecko us" ai y ames weee AIOA OK ey se ogs C is accuse o usig ose us o iesigae o-amiy OUCES am ogaiaios A e ay amiy og ames wig Au a y COUCI McKiey cae o e umae eame o am aimas a oge Aiso o e Missoui ua Cisis Cee ecie e "useakae coiios" i wic acoy-am ogs ae ke e C caims o e imaia a o eese e ieess o o sma Sn pld b prttr n frnt f C a age og oeaios u—amog hdrtr n Mn oe isaces o acoy-am aoi ism o e a o C—e couci ai eay $5 i 199 o a cosuig im Mogoe iscoe a uci o moio gassoos ogaiaios—suc as e 3- meme aioa ames Uio a ee meme gous o e Camaig o amiy ams a e Eiome (o wic AWI is aso a meme—a eo ack o C o ei aciiies e US eame o Agicuue iesigae a i is eimiay aui sai a e suec mae o some o Mogoes eos "e ousie e geeay-ecogie imis o e use o cecko us" C wic a aciae oe wee e moey use a come om ceckos was oce o ack ow acig a som o uic oucy Wll ln a e essue o USAs iesigaio I Ai i iscoiue e cosuas seices a eue $513 i cecko us a E4144 eeu And the Waters Turned to Blood o Caoias coasa ai oue i Y OEY AKE "ow imagie a is ciy as o sewage eame Simo a Suse 1997 3 ages $ as A e wases om 15 miio eoe ae simy use io oe is a saye oo ies is is a ue soy o coe-us a uis i acaemia a sae "u ese umas io ogs a you o ae o ueaucacies cage wi oecio o ei ciies ea imagie a a Is ee" a e eiome e aesay a sige-cee ceaue e eie cuey o e as umes o sows uiomy wi e owe o cage is om a muiy wi easome esse io e smaes ossie sace uae o ee u see o o ie ise i a iy a case a sik ou o sig aou suec o aiu soes a eiaio o a a we coiios ae uaoae makes ie easuae o ese igy ieige aimas is ike a Geek go o a Gimms aiy ae caace i ca o meioe i eie is ook o e ewsae seies assume a aiey o iee oms as occasio emas is u ecause i is e uaase cuey o e og acoy ioageae ftr pd y ame ies i iusy a ueies e wae a ai ouio oue wae usig io a ouaio eosio a sickes us uma eigs is ook os we ouise suc as y oeow om e gia secia iees o eeyoe cocee wi e cessoos aace o acoy ams ouig io ies oecio o am aimas a esuaies i o Caoias oce ue wae- e ooks cea igue is e ae oais ways oA ukoe wose wok e o esais- oey ake is a is-ae iesigaie e- me o a "ee 3" ioaa aoaoy o suy oe scuuousy sickig o e acs And th o ftr pd. Wi a ocoae i oaica Wtr rnd t ld eokes e sikig eeig so imoogy a seies o ueece cicumsaces oe eeiece i ece yeas y oecos o e e o a iceasigy sockig eaiaio a aimas ace wi soewaig ueaucacies a e iy ceaue se was esie o suy was o ieicae acios y gaig agecies a seem a a a a u e eaoiay micoscoic esige o ceae o-acio wee acio is ceay cae o aima ftr pd, caae o eaig uge oes i A ie meio o ogaie ok ouces essue o ises o causig aw soes i umas a sages o a o Caoia Sae Uiesiy emis us a e uk o ga causig em o sue saig memoy osses a iei- uig o uiesiy am aima eseac comes om ius- cae ages y ois a e eseac e iusy was is geae o e ogaisms ae simuae o eouce massiey y iceasig ose ois o e cooae og acoies— ega- e ouas iscage io ies a esuaies om suc ess o e eeigs o e aimas is ook oes o ouc o souces as eiie as a og acoy ams ftr aima sueig oy o e esuig ouio o eame pd was easiy eece weee is wee see ese- i cies e uie ie wiig seies o og ams a aey umig o escae e aacks o e iy moses wo aeae i h lh nd Obrvr: wee eaig em aie ■; "Imagie a ciy as ig as ew Yok suey gae oo —Cisie Sees

0 Stop U.S. Population Growth—Save Endangered Species y Ae Eiae eae eicio i a om cosucio o eeways ome ece eaes oe e Eagee Secies Ac o- usiesses scoos a oe sucues a as esoye ece as i e wese US a e eea aia e ume o giy eas iig i e wese goemes oe i eiomea oecio wie im- US was a oe ime esimae a 1 oay ee ae oa oeook e imay cause o secies eicio ewe a 1 giies e esice o e mouaious i e Uie Saes uma ecoacme io aua aeas o Wyomig Moaa Iao a Wasigo I aia ie y icease ouaio gow Cosi- 199 siy-ie o e emaiig 3 key ee i e Uie eig a e maoiy o e esimae 3 a a Saes wee i a kie y US ies o oas a u aima secies i e Uie Saes ie ea coass wee ougou e ees aua aia Oe o e eaig moe a 5 o e uma ouaio aso esies causes o ea o e eagee maaee is eig i y massie aia esucio is ieiae A gie ou ies o eceaioa oas o accommoae gow we cue gow ae e ae o secies eicio i e ae oe a aea equa o e sae o eawae eey yea Uie Saes wi icease amaicay uess we ae ae iy ece o ou oigia weas ae ee aie o o aciee US ouaio saiiaio accommoae icease ema o agicuue a eeo- e Uie Saes gows y eay ee miio eoe a me Suc eeome is esosie o e emise o 5 yea o aou a week wi oe a o a gow o e eagee secies i e Uie Saes semmig om immigaio icuig eugees a asyees Ceay ouaio gow i e Uie Saes as a I cue es coiue e Uie Saes wi oue is a wi coiue o ae easaig eecs o ou wiie ouaio y e yea 5 wi e as maoiy (9 o aia Uess we ae successu i e camaig o US a gow aiuae o immigaio Coay o e ouaio saiiaio we wi a oe e e ie yeas coucoia oio o uimie ouy e eaiy is a e aoe 15 miio eoe o e ouaio equiae o Uie Saes aiiy o suo a ouaio wii is aoe os Agees ew Yok Ciy Cicago a ouso cayig caaciy (e ume o eoe wo ca e susaiay comie e eaiy owee is a e Uie Saes as suoe i a gie aea wii esouce imis a wiou a iie esouce ase a cao accommoae a ee- egaig e aua socia cuua a ecoomic eio- iceasig ouaio Wiou a saiie ouaio a me o ese a uue geeaios is aeay eig ou eos o oec e eiome a imoe ou quaiy caege y ou ee-iceasig ouaio o ie wi suey ai Cosie us a ew o e imicaios o ou cue ouaio sie ie ue secies ae aeay kow o Ann Elzbth l th pt rtr f pltn ae aise oee i e Uie Saes eay 7 secies Envrnnt ln. r r nfrtn rt: 2000 Strt, ae eagee o eaee a 9 secies ae a isk o St. 20, Whntn, C 2006 phn: 20200.

"A AIMAS A E IME" is e moo o Aima ae iscoeys ecey auce cae eeisio cae Accoig o is missio saeme "Aima ae is a ew ou cae a igs eoe o a ages ogee o eeaime a ceeaes ou asciaio a assio o aimas We oe o coiue o a ee uesaig o ow ogee we sae e ae" I you o aeay ae access o Aima ae coac you oca cae An comay a ask em o oe i o moe iomaio ca (31 9-1999 o isi Aima ae o e Wo Wie We a //wwwaimaiscoeycom ln Aima Weae Isiue o-oi Og os Oice o 35 US OSAGE Wasigo C 7 AI Wasigo C Aess Coecio equese emi o 3

IE O ECYCE AE 9 (c) Cv4: h fftnt thrlf bnd th fndtn f ttl hrd hv l trtr. A td b tr nd Ann nhrdt ( p 20 t tht th bnd lt fr lf ndr ntrl ndtn. r, r r hr htr ld dhtr hl rndn tn np. ht b tr nhrdt.

iecos Maoie Cooke ea Waace ougas eeo G ewe , rd t "nn r" Cisie Sees h f plntlt nd oge Sees (rtrd Knn Wldlf Aiee ai Cyia Wiso Srv hd hrd Oices p t th Sp Srvvl Cisie Sees esie tr rptn n rr, Cyia Wiso ice esie n 2. Strtn t b eeo G ewe Seceay oge Sees easue xplnn h h l pnt f lvn bb Scieiic Commiee Maoie Ace thn 8 hr f n Gea ea ntrvrl ph h ee ey M (nd tht h lvn frt aaa Oas oge aye thn n th rnn h nt Samue eacock M n t dlvr n pnd pl o Was M t nt dnlt lphnt. "I ntrl ppd t n Ieaioa Commiee rptn f n ntrntnl trd n vr," h d. "h Aie e Aua M - Meico G Aikas M - Geece prt f th trd ndr prnt rtn n bth Amassao aaak usai - agaes prdr nd nr ntr ntnbl." Agea Kig - Uie Kigom ppld t th hll pd th dlt nd brvr Simo Muciu - Keya t rbr tht th hl rn fr CIES t prtt Gooeo Sui - Cie Ms umiiko ogo - aa ndnrd p, nt nrl n ntrt: "h Kaus esegaa - emak n t b d fr trdn vr b btntl fr Aeey Yaoko - ussia ndvdl bt pttn fr vrnnt. Gvrnnt Sa a Cosuas r ppdl thr t rv th ppl nd I blv tht, f eay Comue Cosua Cey eMaio eseac Assisa th vrnnt ntd t ll rv thr ppl, th ll May Ee aye Associae Eio tnd fr nd nr tht th vr trd rn bnnd o Geie Assisa o e Oices ndfntl." iae aeso am Aima Cosua ye uciso Wae Camaig Cooiao nll, h dfntl nnnd tht h fr n nt Maya ae eseac Assisa frd t b lld "bnn hr." Whppn pn t plh Cay iss Eecuie ieco bnn t f h b pt h rdld t nt h brl rd e augo Mai Oe Seceay h nd pttd t tl n th b. Gea isso Wiie Cosua aick oa uicaios Cooiao "I d nt fl lt r nfrtbl," h d, "hn I eie ike Amiisaie Assisa d f bn n th d f ldlf: I r nd d iko eia M lln f thr ppl n vr prt f th rld. W t b aoaoy Aima Cosua Aam oes eseac Associae hrd, t tnd tll nd rbr tht p lt e Wie Wiie Iesigao fr ll t." 9/ E AIMA WEAE ISIUE QUAEY SIG/SUMME 1997 OUME UMES & 3

PO Box 3650, Washington, DC 20007 • phone: 202 3372332, fax: 202 338 9478 • email: [email protected], U: http:.nllfr.

TAM tl t44044 CIES Coeece eakey ou o e a "uy ugge" Sowow i imawe Wa aee i aae a Oeiew 5 Wa e Ioy ecisio oes—a oes—Mea 5 ai Awas ecogie Wiie aw Eoceme eoism 7 imaes i Caiiy ASA us uig om Uusiie Aiquae Mokey Eeimes Ia Mokeys Sue a ie; Ai ace a USWS Igoe umae aso aw 9 Elphnt t nd tffd zbr r n th ook eiew xt f Kn 1 rl dpl rtn dlt t th CIES n au ooe 19 frn n rr, bb ( p 4 aig Sameuy Weak aig Ageeme Is Accee y EU 1 Euoea aiame ass Commissios Caiuaio o aig ea 1 Wa Comes e? Eces om e ouse o os iscussio o "ego as EU u Imo a" 11 ia eeas is ias a Igoace o Aima Issues 1 WS is Eages Ae Kie o oi; ego as Use i ae 1 Cows a Caes eioous ies ook eiew h r bt 1 Asi ige Was o Sae e Cows 1 ee Cees o e & eys—Ai-G ae Ca e Use 17 W oic ea ug igs eay eaies 19 Opp i Ieas i Cae aise o Mea eie a ac bnnt vn Grth rn. Wiie The family farmers who supply our milk and cream pledge not to Is Aoe ua oyco Ieiae? 13 treat their cows with rB6.H. Sess Suy esus ea o a o Casig ee wi h A h d n nfnt dffrn h bn hn nd n tt n n dtnh ous o aioa us a 13 btn l fr rG trtd nd ntrtd . t ll th pplr f Mao i eae Imisoe i wi ages-Ee ie 17 r thr nrdnt n pr tht th l th fr ntrtd Oe ews . oo a ug Amiisaio "eom" May Usu Cosumes ig o Kow 15 ew aw Seamies Aoio o aw Eoceme ogs 15 AA Easio o a as ack o Caos 15 ews Uaes 1 n rr rndbrn n ntrG lbl, th easaio o oess bjt f n ntn rt bttl ( p SOWOW I IMAWE y e Wie As oe wo esumes o wok o wiie a wi aces I someimes ee ei esece eeig oe my soue o see i I am oig ue o ei coces ee ae I e is scuiy as muc as uig e wo weeks I se i aae imawe a e e Coeece o e aies (CO o e Coeio o Ieaioa ae i Eagee Secies o Wi aua a oa (CIES ee e suia o esuc- io o miios o ceaues a miios o aces o ciica aia was ecie a y a eaiey sma gou o uma eigs i oe ace eoe eaig o e meeig woee wa e aimas a as wose suia—a wo—was eig eae wou say i my ace CIES is a sysem o ageemes ewee couies a ies o sike a aace oeig ee ees o oecio Aei I as a ieaioa ae ece o uig bb nn tnl r nd Wldlf dprtnt oies a ie aimas "o o e use o imaiy com- l pt tffd ldlf n dpl fr th nfrn ttnd mecia uoses" Aei II aows some ae i e se- th n t lft prt "tnbl tlztn f ntrl r cies wii seciie imis Aei III iss secies ame y r." iiiua aios o oece saus A e aae meeig e o-goemea ogaia- a a e sogas "Ieige eoe ee Ieige oo" io (GO osees eeseig coseaio a aima a "Sae a Wae—o ie" aee aoe osae oecio wee a ouumee y "susaiae use" ao- caoo waes caes ose a aic i wiie oy ues a waes o wo weeks CIES gae ums u o ow o oosa Ee e ysica seig was auig A isio o e co- ae oosa o eie is o e is ime o uis (o eio a aace o e aae Seao a o ass y e giig geae-a ese oecio owis (emoig oe gae o may Aica aimas—suc as Cae uao some oecio o eis (emoe om e Aeices com- a Ceea—ei oies sue a moue ei sii eey o oes o secies a ae ae u eaee goe ay y ay as e is week woe o e eo o eae Oe measue ecie a e coeece was a oosa y ecame sigy moe acimoious Moe a a coic ewee aa o cicume e Ieaioa Waig Commissios couies CIES is a aegou o ieas a siig aiues a o commecia waig a esais a sysem o ae i Some say a i ou cowe wo eagee secies waemea A sece oe was equese y aa a e mus ae a moeay aue mus "ay ei ow way" i esouio was eece oe o usiy ei eseaio Some o a a oms o A seemigy isigiica cage i woig was o- ie ae esouces a a e ask a a is o ceae a way o ose y amiia o ae e eiiio o e wos "o eoe o "susaiay use" em Oes eiee a we imaiy commecia uoses" i e oecio oee y sou maage uma aais i suc a way a a eas o Aei I e cage wou ae aowe goemes o moe secies ae ie o eicio a a e aowae se o ay sockies o eagee aima o a as o ae i eagee secies sou e eo "aess" o so-cae "uisace aimas" wiou e sae Aocacy gous o eey esuasio e o om ei eig cosiee "o imaiy commecia uoses" ui- oos e O-waig ig o Aiace oee -sis sace aimas cou icue ayig om eeas i Aica o macaws i Cea Ameica; e oosa was wiaw Ou geaes eay icoies a CIES ioe waes ee iee ouaios o mike waes oe o yes (oouce uus waes a e US ouaio o Caio- ia gey waes wee oose o e owise so a ei mea cou e ieaioay ae Wae aocaes oie a coae I e e e waes wo e oe Ee oug e owegia oosa o owis e mike waes i ei eck o e woos eceie a maoiy i e we so o e /3 maoiy equie ocowis eig ugecy o e oceeigs wee e eos o ew iae waig i e o Aaic eas i aici- aio o e eaaio o ues o e seig o waemea A eas si yacs ae ecey eoe iig ea o yig sem waes wi aa make uoys aace tnt v fr th bln f Ctt I, hr GO waiig o e icke u y some ukow wae e rprnttv r bnhd hl dlt bl d fr ouguese ae esoe y seig a ao esse ou rhn dn n th rld prld ldlf ntnd n nxt p

4 9(2 What Happened in Harare: an Overview Wht th Ivr n —nd nt—Mn awksi sea ues A moe o owis Cua ouaios o e ecey accee ea o ioy was si a Aei II us oeig ae was eece cusig ow o eeas esie is ee-

Eeas oswaa amiia a imawes oosa o es osy eicios o sic coos o e ae " imie ioy ae aowig em o se ei sockies was amee Ee e mos say imie ae oes uo a aoe (see siea a ig oouiies o aueig a simuaes oac- eeiiio o imaiy commecia uoses amiias esou- ig—"secuaie oacig" ase o e oe io wou ae oee e oo o age eos o Aei a u-ow ioy ae wi ecommece Ac- I secies i coaeio o e coeio e oosa was coig o wiie cosua Ia emo wiaw "may wiie eames ae ow acig emsees o a usuge i oacig aciiies ek ow ea e esouio y ia ugaia a oa o a oice a cusoms ace a simia icease i uis a Euoea Euasia Caucasia a Asia ouaios om smuggig" Aei II o Aei I was eece I is imoa o uesa us wa e agua eeueas aem o esais a eo quoa o ecisio eais says emo "Ee oug uig oies saig i 3 yeas was wiaw e eea ouaios o oswaa amiia ek igea maogay e US a oiias aem o is igea a imawe ae ee owise om A- ei Io Aei II o CIES e moe caies M- maogay o Aei II moioig ae was eece wi i sige ecauios eoe a ega ioy Soue wie ioceos Sou Aicas oosa o aow ae ae ca commece e owisig [wic i io os a oe io oucs was eece comes io eec Seeme 1] aows oy ese M_ Iega ae e USs moe o om a CIES iega ae wokig ee couies o eo uig oies ie 11- gou o assis i eoceme eos was eece aimas a o imawe aoe eea ie Waig aas aem o ieee wi e Ieaioa a ocay cae ioy cuios" Eigee mos Waig Commissio a weake CIES oecio o waes was ae ae i ioy cou e e emie o eece o wae owisig oosas wee asse aa oie—amog umeous oe cA_ aias oosas o is e aeg a wi Asia uao o coiios—a cue eiciecies i eoce- me a ioy coo ae emeie as eiie Aei I wee o wiaw y e Saig Commiee a mecaisms ae Gee-ceeke Amao ao e eo o ase is ae i ace "o eis ae eeues io eea Meica ao o Aei I was asse coseaio" +

ntnd fr prv p cie" o is cei e Uie Saes oose o ame e om e Aoes o y o i e ouaw ie o cosie e "imac" ae a "aicaio" o eas i o ae we a CIES e oosas y ia caie eeig aciiies wic o couse wi icue e ugaia a oa o icease oecio o a ow eas eoae Ciese ea ams Cia soke ou agais e ousie o Ameica wee souy eeae esie oas sime u eeicia aguage cage a e ocume was uwaeig eese iece oosiio y ow ea age aoe wiou e US ameme saes icuig e ussia eeaio omaia a e e oosas y e US o icease oecio o 1 Cec euic mae i iicu o may couies o suo secies o ma ues a e aigao saig ue wee e secies uisig waee ow a eeae o wiaw e easo gie e esouio uimaey asse y e aies o Cose- o e eea o e US eam was iese essue om e aio o a ae i eas was oow Aoug i cas o sae is a wiie agecies—ue e ae o e Ie- aies o imoe aioa egisaio a eoceme "o aioa Associaio o is a Wiie Agecies—o eae emosay euce e iega ae i ea as" i oes o oecio u o e saes ca o a ouay susesio o e ea as ae a mea- uesay o e seco week saw e Gea Eea Sow- sue a AWI as og suoe I ac e Uie Saes ow We e smoke iay ceae ou o e 13 aouce us io o e Coeece a i wou suo couies eigie o oe a mae commes i e eae suc a moaoium i ecommee y oe aies u o eae We i aeae a e iiiua oosas om suc suggesio was oee Cia seemigy suoie oswaa amiia a imawe mig ai o eac e eaig u o e Coeece so ou e eas we i magica /3 magi o success Sou Aica iouce a coue mos Ee a moes ameme oose y Iia o ameme a mae e owisig sigy moe aaae aem o "eimiae" e iega ea as ae—ae a o some e ameme was esseiay wiow essig simy euce i—was eeae as a ueaisic goa sayig a e sae o ioy wou e imie o a oe so ea asy a esouio was aoe coceig e use o e ee couies wou oy se e amos 5 os o ioy eagee secies i aiioa Asia meicies Icue ey ow o ewee em o oe uye (aa a a is a uacceae ecommeaio a aies "cosie ee wou e o saes o eigee mos eig sigy wee aoiae a wi suicie saeguas e ai- moe esicie e Sou Aica a was see as aig e caio o aiicia oagaio a i ceai cicumsaces es cace o ass I a kucke-iig sece oe e ame- caie eeig i meeig e ees o aiioa mei- ntnd n nxt p a 5 ntnd fr prv p uge ae i wi is aie eas ay ue o e me aie y us ee oes o gai e /3 ose o us ouaiy o ackig cocaie isie aeay ea is i e igig o keeig e a o ioy i oe o so oacig oom o e siig cages Oe eicae aciis om e eae a eomous sig GO osees wee eegae o Caiea coie o me a i e as yea se as a o a acoy a ookig ow o e oo I saw Isaei eegae e ouse a e saioa esoye y ug ues agy a a wiie camio i Cak sum i is cai amos o e eecieess i eosig e ug/wiie ae ik e oo i a gesue o eie a eausio I was eece Ae e Weesay oe owisig e eeas e a aoug ae i e ay e oes wou e ake o e commiees oome oug oes o ie-o-ea oosas moe iea owisig oosas o e ee wi ie eae as i a og am a ee saes a mos ikey ey wou e e- oke a emissio o eow asie ay eae- oe wo ee aggig coces aou eagee secies u i was o o e I a aay aisa a ee ou uig y ai acke Caaia cai o Ee oug i was sogy suoe Commiee I e eae was soe Isea y o e mao imoe (US a e o oig o e oosas oce a o a e mao eoe (oiia e oosa o oee e omaio o a wokig gou icease oecio o igea maogay ue (sogy o-use oway wi e was oe ow eeae y ime i- aiciaio o e ee Aica saes eess o e i ime i a ow Aso waig owisig aog wi aa a eeae wee e uisig o sawises e Euoea Uio e e ay is maea ogs ime aesakes Kaa wokig gou ouce a "cosesus" au agais seea secies o aakees ocume amos ieica o e aie oikees a cockaoos a e co Sou Aica ameme I a saigy om wi icuas oecio was e- au mae is "comomise" e cease o e eo o eoa oies saie ig oug easiy gaiig /3 o a skis ee kagaoos ie cocoies e oes e e iiiua oosas coae eccay a e eay musse wee aoe—oswaa amiia a I e as i we i eke ou a ew iay imawe icoies A oosa om eeuea o es- We e imawe eea ow- r, ll, pd th ais a quoa o eoig aguas aie isig ceae uiaio eige aks em- lth f th prtrph hntn a e oosas o aow e sae o wie ntnnt t CIES. oyees ace a ugge eac oe io o om Sou Aica a e e- ows o scue scoocie i iis sye uioms ewe ae i awksi (sea ues om Cua aie a saw as ceee a aaue A ma soo u i "Susaiae use" ooes ague a i we uy- e ue acoy a—wiou a mumu o ieuio uggig ice couies wa wi eeas eas a om e cai—sag ou e og aioa aem i a giaes i ou wo e we sou ay o e iiege igig aioe ey ae a oi owee a is aeay aeig e coces o e couies o Aica si ue siege wi e ousas o ouiss a ack e uses o come om we ame oaces a ee igoe as we as o see e eoic aua e coce a aimas ca es e ose om Iia a agaes a a aeay see a "susaiay use" y kiig em a aig i ei usuge i e kiig o Iia eeas us i aiciaio oy as is o wiy oimisic a coay o isoy o e ossie owisig I eigee mos e ae o e "susaiae" ea use o ay wiie as ee ee ioy aoug suosey seeey esice wi esume ou sog sui e cue goa coase o iseies e Ceay we i aeae e owisig wou e e- waig iusy e acie ecimaio o eaes a eae e commiee cai ae e ocess sie geas is o as ae a eames o make ecoomies a a came u wi e esie esu eas i was aïe o ecame egies o aiiaio Oce ieiie as a e- me o assume gie e moey iig o e ecisios a we souce e wos iesiy ecomes a coi a ca e wou see a ai ig i aae se sae o coee io go Eac moig e oca ewsae h rld, was sie oeeess "susaiae use" ecame e maa o e ue eac oe oom oo a eac moig e eaie CIES coeece I we ae goig o e successu eig e geee eegaes wi o-ioy ae oagaa Eac ime oice o aimas i wou aea a we ee o caiy wa e eeisio was ue o ee wee o-ioy ews ie- a meas a way o oca eoe o make moey om e ey iews a a-ou CAMIE iomecias Aima weae eisece o wi aimas—iig wee ey ie—wi a a coseaio GOs go ou sae o ess aeio oo ee Ecouagig e make ecoomy o eagee aimas u e uiciy was o e mos a aagoisic o e Wes a as us iies ue wi e oca ecoomies o a cosieay aoae owa e eea owisig ee o e oss We ee o ik ceay ow es o so e e ua ieaioa aes i wiie a ugs ae commoiiaio o e wi A we ee o say oe a oe ecome iceasigy iewie igig o eeows a ou goa coice is o aimas esus eoe u gee io e coeece e eomousy oweu ussia maia esus commuiy was sai o e i aeace ieese amog oe igs i e uesice ow o caia (e uisig o sugeo nt tvt n Wht ( "htr n pn," AWI oucs was amee o emi a geeous aowace o Quarterly, Sprn h jnd A WI tff Wldlf Inv "esoa cosumio" May o e oosas o esic e ttr. plt rn l. 6 vn Ard nz Wldlf Enfrnt r h flln ppl rvd AWI Clr . vn Aei I isig e u Gaas eeas o CIES A- Enfrnt Ard t th Sp Srvvl tr rptn, ei III ecause o is oays ioy a coes a eea hld n 2 n rr, bb, t th CIES nfrn. ioy acquie sice 197 (ae e secies was is ise o h nfnt rhn lptr rtd b hn rr r CIES oay Gaa is a isiaio i oe aeas o prntd b th SrtrGnrl f CIES, lzrv pv, eame Gaa as a goo ouaio o Aica gey a- fr ttndn hvnt n bttn ldlf r. On os a i wic is ey oua wi e e iusy CIES d nt, n f th r rd pth—tht f emis ae i is secies u Gaa ogoes e iacia Ghn Sn Kpnnd. ewas o ae i oe o see e ige iees o e secies M OUAMA IAGAE Wi- uguses eaesi i wiie aw ie Cie o Mai as ee igig eoceme is we-ecogie ogaie oacig gags o yeas oug e yeas e as caug icuig usmea oaces Mai may oaces a u em i ai as a imoa wiie eiage e is a meme o e Ieo Su- icuig e ese-aae e- gou o Wiie Cime eas o Gouma Cie iagae E E EOG a uc as seaeae eos o oec oice oice cais e Ieo Su- ese eeas om oacig a gou o Wiie Cime Ieo is oug is Gouma eaii- cosies wiie cime a eemey aio oec e is a ogoig seious oese a is ugig a cou- osiie iuece o CIES a e ies o ies moe esouces i su- secies i seeks o oec essig suc cime M e eog SEYIA ISSA SYA aioa r lft t rht: r t, Ml Wldlf ogaie a eo a oke u a aks ieco o Seega wage a Chf AWI Ad brt nd Ghn ldlf iega makeig ig esuig i e dprtnt hd Grld n, h frt pr coiscaio o ues o ou- successu camaig agais comme- pd th Appndx I ltn fr Afrn lphnt, n cia oacig gags i iokoo Koa 6. sas o aiioa Asia meicie aioa ak We e ioy a oucs coaiig eagee se- came io eec i auay 199 cies is cooeaio as yea wi iokoo Koas aua ouaio o a eas 5 eeas a USWS ages esue i e aes o memes o a imo- ee so ow o us iiiuas A cocee camaig a eie smuggig ig wi ew saegy a acics icuig ew ages wi SECIA AGE ICA MAKS wo as ee wi aequae equime a eices su e oaces ow e US is a Wiie Seice (USWS o amos yeas SIMO KEIOMA was a couageous wiie age was e ea age i e oe ase o e case agais oy i ui aioa ak Uo eaig sos om oaces isie Sia Sia a eoic i ee a auo o umeous e ak Simo a ee oe ages gae case Simo was ooks o e suec was seece o mos i iso as uame a e kew e oaces wee ame eee- a esu o e USWS "Oeaio eegae" Sia eae ess e a a a caug u wi e oaces is e was guiy o smuggig scoes o ae eoic is io e US so oi-ak y a oace ame Moo aa e ie o may o wom ie o suocaio is wous soy eeae e e a ega wiow Moo CA MAIE Seio Secia Age USWS ega aa escae io Ioy Coas Gaia auoiies ae e- is caee wi e Seices iisio o aw Eoceme i quese e eai- 1977 e was e ea age o "Oeaio aco" a io o Moo aa o ucoee a Mie Ease o o smugge eagee sa ia o mu- acos om o Ameica e ee Sou Aica oice e u so a e e- se u ei Eagee Secies oecio Ui a aie quess ae ee ig- eoceme aiig i Ioesia Iia e iiies oe agaes ea aiwa ace a Isae e oie GEA A suo o "Oeaio Wise Guy" "Oeaio Sow Ca" UGUSE iec- "Oeaio ooks age" a "Oeaio eegae" a o o Gaas e- assise cimia iesigaios eaig o wiie i 3 cou- ame o Wi- ies ie oose way AEIE IYASEKO e ussia CIES Ma- ack i 197 uig ageme Auoiy iico is esosie o oiciay esa- e Aica e- isig eame ige Oeaio Ama as a eame ea o CIES wii e ussia Miisy o e Eiome e aso u Aei I e was ogee ussias oicia CIES ask oce i Moscow iicue a a Iyaseko a is eam ae cacke ow o e iega ime u e suck y smuggig o ae a eagee secies io ussia icu- . K. And, Ghn dpt ldlf hf, is oicy a ee ig Aica gey aos cimaees a io o Sice ptd th rd n bhlf f Sn waee We e imoes ae oe memes o ussias Maia Iyaseko Kpnnd, h lld b phr. CIES ecie e is ouiey eaee 11•

0 7 ASA ll ndn fr Unjtfd, Anttd Mn Exprnt y aie Geeeg mokeys ie i cicumsaces ueae o is sace oyage I e ie sie ewee maiseam sciece a aima igs accoig o ASA oicias Soy ae ei eu om aocaes e scieiss ae mae a sog case o eeime- sace e mokeys wee aeseie o e emoa o oe ig o aimas o aace uma weae I ac ayoe wo a musce secimes O e oowig ay as oe o em isues em is ikey o e eegae o e u ige was emegig om e aeseic e mokey we io u you o ae o e a aima-igs eao o woe caiac aes a ie esie eos a esusciaio aou ASA sikig $31 miio io a ieaioa suy o e scieiic usiicaio o ese aiquae eeimes ow mokeys wi eecoes i ei ais a wies i ei is i u a oes ee e camios o aima eei- oies eac o a wo-week sace oyage meaio om emuaig e eaaga eoic o ei e quesio was o scieiic iees i e egiig o oosies I e o ays sace eusiass iee aes o mae sace ig we uma eeiece i e ukows ag a eo comig ou o sace eseac wic ey i o weigessess was imie o a ew ays u i ece o ey ae sice gauae o moe ga oug simi- yeas uma sace aees ae emaie i oi o mos ay ogus caims seig as e suecs o couess soisicae eeimes Ameicas o Meica ogess o eame ecae o e oiy a sycoogica eecs o eo gaiy a e oec wou o oy e umas i sace u wou ASAs aima eeimees owee wo gie u aso "assis i uesaig a iig eames o ae- A ei igiiy is comoue y Ameica commimes mia oseooosis muscua aoy a immue sysem ys- o susai e imoeise ussia sace eeise wic ucio o aies o ea" as a og aiio o sooig mokeys io sace As a ecuiig oo o e aima igs moeme io us we a sace sue ig o a aco--Ameica is a eam a ca u io a igmae o egiimae eei- mokey eeime was cacee i 199 e oec cae meaio o aimas io 11 was ae oe o e ussias Aima oecio gous a iiiua scieiss isue e scieiic aue nl Grnbr, dtr nd pblhr f Sn Gvrn o e eeime nt prt, xtndd prn t rprnt th rtl fr O Cismas Ee i a casue suie y e ussias th rnl f Cr. io 11 cayig wo esus mokeys was auce io oi om a ussia cosmoome o a wo-week ig ASA vntll thdr t fndn fr th As escie i e auoiaie weeky Sp , "Wie .S. ntrvrl n xprnt. Clln th td i oi e mokeys wee esse i sace suis wic wee "hl n," Grnbr rt tht "h rtrt secue o cais ei eas wee sae a sma oes ftr bt f bd pblt fr th n wee ie io ei skus o emi sesos o ake egua p n nd ntv rprt fr n eaigs o oy emeaue A a-oe eecoes wee td rp tht ASA nd t l nt th u io e mokeys musces wi e wiig coece o prr." ecoig eices O e gou i Moscow wo oe esus "rthr n flht hv nt bn rld t b mokeys wee i e same asic osiio o emi comai- ASA," rdn t Grnbr, "bt vn th p sos o e eacio o weigessess" n fl nd bn, th n e eeime was eeme a success u e oe o e d f n ld tl dppr."

rbvr rnd Ia a oae iooamus as ou a as ie i Cow e wo ie a a ac i Sou Aica wee ey euse o e seaae om oe aoes com- ay We Ias moe was kie y a ioceos says ac maage ouis aick o oe kew ow o ake cae o e Ia euse o ea a is u ae a say i a wiie eaiiaio cee se ega o ecoe tr fd In xtr o egg yoks ay oo a ceam as se gew "ios ae socia aimas" wies aick "a ae o ae comay aou em" Se was eeoe iouce o Cow a e wo ae ee iseaae ee sice— a cuious u eig eame o e asic ee o comaiosi wic is sae y a socia secies 1

8 Infnt Mn Sffr nd Ar rn nd USWS Inr n rnprt y Siey McGea aies i e sime a a i ioae eguaios e- O May 1997 Ai ace ig 57 ae a Caes e cause eac sime was accomaie y a is o a e Gaue Aio ais e ig a sae i akaa Ioe- mokeys iy aies us ee a ou weeks o wee sia e uma asseges ae ak a wace moies ise e uckig im a ook e mokeys om Cicago Meawie ow i e cago o 55 co o Sou Caoia a o kow ee wee mokeys sa i siig caes Amog aies e eciie comay a o em wee iy aies cigig o ei kow ee wee aies ee i i i moes a 17 moes-o-e e mo- kow i aace keys a ee sie y e Ioesia ooy sai ayig A cosiacy im Iquae a wee o ei way o a o siece wou omay ae ke e comay cae AS i Sou Caoia uic om kowig wa was goig o wic aeay owe oe 75 mokeys u y a soke o goo oue some- Ae 17 ous e ae ae i oy comassioae saw e sime ais Accoig o Ai ace oe o e a e ouage a e sig o e ei- moe mokeys was ea Cigig o ie ay mokeys a eso ie e was e suckig ay e was kie o e Ieaioa imae oecio o "umaey euaie" as Ai ace eague (I says e caes i o mee ieaioa A I eeom o Iomaio siig guieies esaise y e I- Ac eques eeae a ee a ee eaioa Ai aso Associaio a a eaie sime wic eace Ci- Ai aces esoe a akaa Aio cago o Ai 1 1997 is sime o sou ee ae accee e sime 53 mokeys was aso se y Iquae Some o e eiie mokeys escae o AS I icue aies (seea iey i ais ou weeks o a 17 ega mo- ee was a wo-ay eay i ais keys a ise o e siig ose eoe e mokeys ow umeig 53 A bb nd thr n hldn e Ioesia ea ceiicae agai ook o o Cicago Wiie simes ntr n Indn aese o e goo ea o a e eacig e US ae suose o e i- mokeys sece y a US is a Wiie Seice (USWS iseco e Cicago iseco a cecke a 1 o is e uose o e isecio is o eiy a e simes sime was isece We coace e sae a e a comy wi US wiie aws icuig umae sime ee see e sime a a o iea i icue ay eguaios u o USWS iseco was a Cicago Aio mokeys o ook a e sime ese icies ae oay e i o e iceeg o ause US umae sime eguaios (5 C Sec 115 o i e aoaoy mokey ae usaig as ese agic o aow sime o ay mokeys o usig moes icies ae es ememe some wos o e ae Magae ece o uge meica aeio Mea "ee ou a a sma gou o ougu commi- A usig moe wi youg [o] a uweae mamma e ciies ca cage e wo iee i is e oy ig uaccomaie y is moe sa e asoe oy i e a ee as" We ae o wok o eoce ou aios imay uose is o eee meica eame a uo wiie aws a o esuae aiies o e moe esosie ceiicaio y e eamiig eeiaia a e eame is i aig aima simes ecessay a e aima is ae o wisa e oma igos o Acio aso Suc a uweae mamma sa o e asoe USWS as a ew ieco ease se a ee o e Uie Saes o meica eame uess i is accoma- askig e o oe e USWS iisio o aw Eoce- ie a a imes a accessie o a eeiay aea me o iesigae wy wo simes icuig ay e moes a aies wee O sick a Ioesia mokeys a eace Cicago i Ai a May 1997 wee ea ceiicae saes a a wee i goo ea So e oe ceae esie o-comiace wi eguaios a o eceio o e a o siig ay mokeys a usig esue a acio is ake agais ay ay ou eso- moes i o ay Ee i e i o ceck e caes sie eques a e oe o e Cicago iseco wo ee was aoe way o e iseco o kow ee wee ceae e Ai a May simes e iesigae Wie o amie aao Cak ieco US is a Wiie Seice Wasigo C orld Wide Web users: thanks to the Aso ease se a ee o e esie o Ai ace ( W efforts of Yale University's David Seelig, ces osage o a 1-ouce $1 o a ouce eessig the 60-slide presentation "Environmental coce oe e wo mokey simes eques e aiie o Enhancement for Caged Rhesus ," so cayig mokeys eseciay simes a icue aies a usig a ega mokeys Wie o Cisia by AWI's Laboratory Animal Consultant ac Caima Ai ace 5 ue e ais 9577 oissy Viktor Reinhardt, is available on the World CG - Cee ace 1; Wide Web at: http://www.primate.wisc.edu/pin/pef/slide/intro.html Shrl MGrl th hrn f th Intrntnl rt rttn .

9 Exrpt fr th f rd n SAMEUY WEAK AIG AGEEME IS ACCEE Y EU Wht C xt? n "hld rp: EU r Iprt n" esie a oo o ees aes a oe cas Euoes oeig miises oe i uy o acce a soy e Commissio wi ow y o eac a ageeme wi e US a is ikey o "umae aig" ageeme wi Caaa a ussia e ageeme wou aow ose couies o eo o e Couci i Ocoe o oeme e Commissio mus omay aaa Case we se was a coiue usig e eiy cue ouae ego a a se ei us wii e Euoea Uio— uis a is o couies eem om e imo a oose ue egua- meme o e Euoea a- ee oug e EU as ae suc as e oeig miises ecisio oeus a o e EUs io 35/91 a e imo a wi e iouce ee mos ae is iame auoe eguaio eiome miises wo igy eece e ageeme uicaio Caaa a ussia aog wi aou oe couies wi e 35/91 aig ego as As weak a caiuaig as Caaas a ussias ageeme was i was weak eoug o eem I e US oes o eac a ageeme wi e Commissio e imo ougou e EU Se ow Ameica ooes o ego as; aaey ay comomise was oo muc comomise o a wi e eecise agais e iee secies o u coee y e eguaio sis i iais ouse o os ego-a aees i e US Eiey ese iea eees o cue aig meos ae a e US wi uouey ie a Wo ae Ogaiaio (WO caege wee se e e oowig co- eeae e see aw ego a (wic oigiae wi aaic ciig ma-as se o oaces agais e Euoea Uio oquy uy 17 o e saus o a eigious symo ey coiue o euse o sig ay ageeme a as ay ki o Oce is caege is ie e EU wi ae o ee is eguaio agais e US oecio e EU ca use Aice o e GA eay wic aows aoess Case o acku ego a ae esicios o e imemee o gous suc as coseaio oecio aske e Maesys Goe- e EUs eguaio 35/91 asse i 1991 oiie e use o ego as i EU meme o aima o a ie o ea a "uic moas" A ese gous ca e me couies u aso as a oisio cosig o imos o u om couies a ae o ye eie ae Wa ses ey ae akig ioke y e EU i is eguaios eese i e Couci o Miises o suc as o aoe "ieaioay agee umae aig saas" is oisio as ye o ee is o aioa easo o e Uie Saes o ie a WO caege secue e imemeaio e imemee agais e EU u e eeme euices o e Ieaioa Associaio o is o EU eguaio 35/91 e ecey accee ageeme is e aes eeome i is og caae Caaa a ussia a Wiie Agecies (IAWA ca e eece o ae a oweu iuece o aig e imo o us io rn Ctl omise o a some ego as wii wo o ou yeas wie oe yes ca e use o eig yeas e Euoea Uio om ou goemes eaio I e Couci o e Euoea Uio emais ue couies wic si sacio e use o e ego a o moe as a "esig" coiues u y a age i wi e usiess as usua o aes—e o is eemiaio o isis a ay ageeme eace wi e Uie Saes aoess aigo o ieo My os e Goeme e- Ageeme emis e saus quo o coiue esseiay ucecke i ese wo couies e mus e "a eas equiae" o e Caaa-ussia Commissio ageeme e mai commie o eig e use o ego as We sa coiue o saas ae a eaya o e aima weae ieio o e oigia eguaio - US wi e oiie om eoig ay o e 13 ise us o e EU esis aoio o e amewok ageeme o umae aig sa- as ecause i oes o go a eoug i aig e use o ego as I e ageeme is eece y e Couci o Miises e week we sa ess e Commissio o ig owa e ecessay measues Erpn rlnt lt Cn Cptltn n rppn l o imeme e u imo a as soo as ossie e Euoea aiame issue a ecee ciique o e usaisacoy aima weae comomises oose i e aoess Case o acku Yes o couse I wecome a ey as maimum ime a a ae aima ca e e" a as i goes u is i o a ac a a e meeig e uesay o e Ageeme a cae o e Couci a e Commissio "o Ageeme a ea ea o a WO isue emais eeoe Ue "ego as" e eo says "I is eece Couci o oeig Miises ou ow oeig Seceay wi ae a eec e oose Ageeme as oay iaequae a ie- e Ageeme ais o i ems o is aima weae a a so-cae ae ego as wi coiue o e oouiy o oe ou a iaequae aege ageeme i eaio o ecie a o imeme e imo a wiou ue ae oecies" use o u o aoe eig yeas a eas ieiiey aegey moe umae meos o aig aimas y e eg o eay" e scoe o e Ageeme is summaie as oows i ey ca mee e saa ese as cause eeme esai a o ki em? Is e Miise o awae a e Eio- "e Ageeme seeks o esais saas o a me Couci a e Euoea aiame eiousy eece a ecogiig a "e US as o agee o eose e ai--e ac a ey cou comy wi e saa amewok ageeme ou o a? Ca we ease ask a e iis Ageeme" e eo saes "us esie e may mecaica esaiig a kiig eices use o a iicaes a i is ocuse amos eiey o iuy a o Goeme oe oy a e uesays meeig a a we isis eigee secies (icuig ose coee y e egua- sueig I is oay uacceae a e saa cou a EU eguaio 35/91 is imemee wiou ue eay? io Wie ecomassig moe a ego as e e so ow as o aow suc as o e aoe eseciay aoess aigo o ieo My os my oe ie is Ageeme is o comeesie oay o-mecai- we moe a couies ae aeay ae ei use asouey ig e weakesses i e ageeme a is o e cosi- ee a e Geea Couci e week is a a om oiiig ca as icuig suc cue a commoy use eices a ey ae coeme y eaig eeiay associaios ego as i isks giig a ieaioa sea o aoa o ae as eck-saes ae o coee esie aeay eig i o Euoe a o Ameica e EC sou o e ego as a owig ego as e Goeme eiee oiie i may couies e Ageeme coceaes ay o a ageeme wic egiimises e use o ego sogy a a ageeme mus o e accee e week I o iciay o e iuy cause o age aimas caug as I aicua ecause e oose esos a ue saisacoy ageeme is eace ue e ems o wic my i esaiig as a e ime o ucosciousess o iicaos o o kiig a esaiig as may ae oe ie eee e Goeme eiee a ee sou e a imemeaio o e a ose caug i kiig as Oe sigiica acos ee seece o eae ogoig use o ceai ego as e Ea o Couow My os wa coiece o e Goe- eea o aima weae a coseaio ae omie y i couies A a miimum e use o a oms o me ae a a Euoea Uio a wi acceeae sigiicay e ese icue a equieme o iiiua aes o e ego a o a sou e immeiaey oiie asig ou o ose as i iew o e ac a o-Euoea makes icese; a miimum age o aes; a aoiae sys- ue e Ageeme" ae aso eig eoie? em o ieiyig e owe o a a; ow aimas ae aoess Case o acku Is i o a ac a ee i e ame- Ue "Seeciiy" e eo oes "I eec a a ca wok ageeme o is aegey moe umae sysem o aig aie ae o e umaey kie; equiemes o as o e coom wi e saa ee i a maoiy o e aimas wee o e aoe i si wou o icue e Uie Saes o isece a egua ieas; a aoe a a aequae ae ae om o-age secies a sue susaiay" Ameica wic as e ages ume o sies i is ie o ay assessme o aima ai a ea" I ue oes "ee is o equieme i e geea couy? eeoe ee e ae Commissioe Si eo ia "esaiig as" ue wic caegoy ego as saa o maimum imes ewee a isecio" wou ae o gous e o eusig o oeae e imo a a saes "e asis o eciig wee suc as mee agais us comig om e Uie Saes Wi e Miise ea a I a siise i o e owes commo eomiao e i mi? e umae saa is wee ue es coiios a eas Ageeme saes "Eac ay sa ecogie e aig aoess aigo o ieo My os I sa esue a e o e es gou sow oe o e siee seciie meos o ay oe ay as equiae" coces aise y my oe ie wi e oe i mi I is e case iicaos o oo weae owee imoa iuies suc Ue "asaecy a Cosuaio" e eo asks a e USA eea Goeme ae uwiig o sig e ageeme o as aceaios o a eo o igames so issue maceaio "Wa oouiy i ay wi ee e o uic scuiy o ee io a egay-iig ageeme ecause o e cosiuioa iicuies as egas e igs o iiiua saes owee e Erpn Unn rlntrn pp th trppn Arnt a oe oes ae omie Ue es coiios e u- e es oocos couc aa a esus? Wa oisios coces aise y my oe ie ae o couse imoa a oug nd b Cnd, , nd th EU Cn. Crl nt, mae saa aows u o o e age aimas a ay ae o e mae o eae aiciaio a cosuaio wi o ay o e saes ME fr rtl (hn hr brndhn lr "pddd" ume o o-age aimas o sue ay o a o e ieee aima weae ees a GOs?" lhld trp, hrd th prdn rprt n th Ar seciie aumas e ee o iuy a sueig cause is e eo cocues "Accessio o a ageeme a e iis goeme i i ac "oe oy"—i was oe o nt. nt nl, rndl rjtn th Arnt, nd aece y e eio a aima is e i e a I is wou eeuae e use o ego as a may acuay e ee Euoea couies a sesiiy oe o eec e Agee- vrhln pprt fr th rlnt. eeoe cuciay imoa a e saa icooaes a cassiy some as umae is oay uacceae" me aog wi Ausia a egium 1 1 9/ rttn vl nd Inrn n Anl I Si eo ia ice esie o e Euoea Commissio oca sae accoo muska ise age mae emie a oweuy iase ooe o uesice ae eas e quesio is wy oes ia iscimiae agais e e aig Ageeme ecey sige y Caaa ussia a y wic is aeay eic i 17 o e saes i oce ia- e Commissio (see age 1 as a mao success o iea- ie? e secies is "seiousy imeie a ceay ea- ioa cooeaio o "umae saas" oug oy wo ee" accoig o ase Caeo o e ioiesiy ega couies ae icue a e Ageeme simy eeces ouaio "As suc ee is o usiicaio o ay a- iumae meos O uy 17 e was i- ig" e ouaio as eiioe e ie o ae e meeig o e Euoea 53 US is & Wiie Seice o is e y aiames Iegou o e Weae a a e ise ue e eea Eagee Coseaio o Aimas o eso o ques- Secies Ac "Ceay ee sou e a a

ios o e egaie imac o GA a S o ae i skis o y a ise" says WO o e oecio o aimas Caeo e ue saes a e mae ia was is aske aou e a o is i ecie wi "e umo suse- imoaio o sea es a e sae a cies o mae ceay eagee" is iecie "eeae wiou ou a As o e gey wo e secies is ise e imo a was usiie o gous o as eagee i e owe saes ece coseaio o e secies e suia o o Miesoa wee i is ise as ea- a a ooe seas" e sai was a "e- ee giimae easo o a a ue GA" A u Si eo ia caims eaee so i is o a a ooe seas ae ue secies ae ioe e ac is a iese essue a mus ae sog o- Sir Leon Brittan eey mamma ise as eagee ca a ecio agais oouisic ues wo icim o ese cue as ecause ey o cou so easiy ecimae e seas ueae aies yig o iscimiae a aes seom eo e eas o eessy o e ice owee ia oowe is u y ese "o-age" aimas Waee ceaue is uucky eoeousy saig a e i "ik e sea a was eoug o se o a ie ego as a wi e aiuy comaae wi e issue o ego as wic i o gie i is oweu aws Some aimas acuay gaw o coce eaee secies" Aaey ia is igoa o ei ow oo o escae so gea is ei eo a ai Mos e ie sais i wic a cosieae ume o e 13 secies ae o wai o e aes eu o eease em om ei ise i eguaio 35/91 i emsees agoy y kiig em A oicia "oice egaig imo o us io e EU" e so-cae "umae aig saa" agee uo ees o e eguaio a oes "Aice 3 maaes a y Caaa ussia a e EU Commissio ue ias es wee woe cu o iise om 13 secies ae eaesi ses o imi o e amou o ime aimas ca e oiie om imo io e Commuiy i e oigiaig e sueig i e as Eagee secies o is as we couy as o aoe aequae amiisaie o egisa- as mammas ae eeoe eaee wi ea om is ie oisios o oii use o e ego a" I e eaio o om eemes o emeaue agig om su- ocees o is e secies eae oe coyoe wo y eo o 1° o moe WS nd El Ar Klld fr rft hld rp Ud n rd e US is a Wiie Seice ecey ee a wo-yea o a i oe ueo uig e as yeas wie migaio uecoe iesigaio io e kiig a seig o a moe a eages wee ieioay kie eie y eig a goe eages a oe migaoy is I a aoi- so o caug i ego as aie wi es mea e maey 35 iiiuas a usiesses ae eece o e cage ages ocae a ies a wee so ea eages wi a wi seig oece migaoy i as i a igy oi- maks o ei egs a ee e Seice ecie o e is ae iega make iesigaio ue Oeaio -Coes eae Saes e- osig as aes o Iia aiacs uecoe ages mauey o ee moe eages om eig kie Some o wee ae o iiae a commecia aig ig ey wee ose eages wee oee o sae om $5-$1 eac "As e agecy esosie o oecig is aios EQUESS O AWI wiie we mus u a e o e commecia kiig o eages To all who would like to help assure the Animal Welfare a oe migaoy is We ecie o moe ow o so is Institute's future through a provision in your will, this general form sauge o oec ueae eage ouaios i e Sou- of bequest is suggested: wes y akig is acio we oec is wic ae sace o may aie Ameica cuues" sai o oges euy I give, devise and bequeath to the , located in Washington, DC, the sum of $ and/or ieco o e US is a Wiie Seice (specifically described property). Cogess as eace ee seaae eea aws wic oec e eage e a Eage oecio Ac amee o Donations to AWI, a not-for-profit corporation exempt under icue e goe eage i 19; e Migaoy i eay Ac Internal Revenue Code Section 501(c)(3), are tax deductible. We amee o oec eages i 197; a e Eagee Secies welcome any inquiries you may have. In cases where you have Ac ese saues make i iega o ayoe o ake ossess specific wishes about the disposition of your bequest, we suggest you discuss such provisions with your attorney. aso se o ucase ay eages o eage as icuig eaes wiou a secia emi 1 Clntn Sn "lphn th At" I Anthr n tt Invtbl? e ua iusys eocious usui o scoos o ois y ease oica aciic I sou e ae us as e Uie see oas a eicoes was oisioay accee y e aios ae e easaig ig-seas ies seea yeas ago Iee cosumes i e US Caaa a Euoe ae US Seae we a comomise eace ewee ooes successuy emae oy oi-sae ua i ei makes a ooes o e "oi ea Ac" S39 asse uy 3 e mao caes e y eis SaKis ae esoe esie Cio sige e i io aw Augus 15 esosiy A ese cas o ua aee "oi sae" ae si Aoug may uaoas ae ue o o- ae o wisa u i aeig scuiy u wii si i-sae isig meos oes euse o aa- o is cue acice Eac yea ese eegae mos cosumes wi ae o ook sa a e eay ees om Meico aama eeuea Coom- o eec e Meica Coomia a eeuea ua ia a auau case moe a ee miio eece o sow u i suemakes I wo e aee ois kiig a iuig may ousas i e "oi sae" a eas o ye o e Seae comomise ocess ey ae emaig access o e US make cas o a -mo goeme suy o wi ei aie ua e Cio/Goe Amiisaios caim a ee is oi ouaios eoe e Sece- "o sigiica aese imac" o ois om e ay o Commece cou gie e go- case a caue ecique is uscieiic a osesi- aea o ua caug y casig ois ca I e eea eiiio o "oi-sae" is io ua use seies o e aee "o- cage y e Amiisaio i 1999 o eose is iumae a eay i sae" Suey is wou make e isig ecique e uic wi kow Seceay guiy o Oweia "oue- wa o o oce agai oyco o- ik" i-usae ua Caig a oe ea o e Moio L)01I-SA cosoium summaie e siuaio i a Seao aaa oe aie y Seaos ose ie ee o h Yr : a o Smi oug a agais e oi ea Ac Wiou ei seuous eos S39 wi a o is mos cue e so soy om you Meico Ciy ueau oay ("Meica a auue eaues wou ow e aw e Cio-Goe iseme ai Seae oe o ua a" miseaigy escies Amiisaio a e Meica goeme wou ee e isig meo a is a e cee o e ua /oi coic cosie comomise ui oce io egoiaios y Seao e ois caug a oe kie o us "ae o e oes eoic sa ecause o e ies o ois si i e aea" wee e ai Ameica iseme ae eig ua ae a igig cace o wo os 1 oycoig oi- I is meo cae "seig o ois" e oeig ees eay ua i a we i aeas i goceies a geig uosey seac ou scoos o ois ecause yeowi ua some geuie scieiic oseaio io e goeme suy ae usuay ou swimmig eow e ois We a uaoa is ois—oe ues o e maie wic is a o e comomise egisaio is wi o e mammas—a og usui egis usig eicoes a see- easy o igea e aoey wo caie e coaiio oas o ou u e aicke aimas Ae may mies o a wo e oi-sae aeig aw i 199 sai o e case e eause ois ae suoue y a mie-og comomises suy "is is o sou sciece i oy nd use seie e e o a oom o e e ae cose ("use" l n." aig e ois as we as e ua is esucie isig meo as aeay owe moe Ieee scieiss wo ecogie e ee o uiase a see miio ois a iue couess moe i e iesigaio a aaysis mus e oug io e eo

Str Std lt d t n n Chn r th nd n tnl rt nd Oe osiie cosequece o e eae aou ois ee wo eoe o a oes aia ae es suie a ua es is a is as oug o ig ie-ecog- o sue so cases ei musces ae aae o ie acs aou e ysioogica cosequeces o sess uss o aciiy o e egy usuis ioe i e a ea o aimas oay e goueakig wok o us aeso sai a ee wo wee case o moe ysioogis Ae Myick (see "eseac Sows Eeme a 3 kiomees wee "comeey eee"—ey Sess o Case a ouu Ca Cause Ieaae am- a uey o eegy e age o ois" AWI Qrtrl, Wie 199 e Uiesiies eeaio o Aima Weae I a aicay iee miieu oesso aick aeso (UAW wies i Anl Wlfr a "As oesso o Camige Uiesiy was aske y iais aioa aeso oe i is oewo o e eo suyig us o suy e eecs o uig e ee y casig em aima weae scieiicay is si i is eay sages wi ous Sagu ooes a caime a e ee is uicaio a e aioa uss immeiae e- eoy e case a a ue ee ae wii ei aa- cisie acio eese sigiica amaks i e a- ie ice we eeig om usui icaio o is ye o aoac e oi is mae i Accoig o h Sntt, aesos suy sowe e eo a e esus wic ae ase o secies- a e ee ae "i a wose sae ysioogicay ae a seciic cosieaios o eaio ecoogy ysioogy case y ous a ae a aumaic oa accie" a eacios o sess cao e geeay aie o e aioa us—wic ows mos o e a e oe secies I seems ikey a ee wi e essue us ake ace o—ae e us o is a e ay o ue eseac o is so o iesigae weae ae e eo was eease asecs o oe uma-wi aima ieacios" •2

13 9/r gei t44 Next of Kin iosis e as aso a immese success i eig auisic uma cie eac ou a egi o commuicae oug y oge ous wi See uke Mis sig aguage Ioucio y ae Gooa ae Gooa wies i e ioucio a "a e wi- 3 ages Wiiam Moow & Comay 1997 e i i e eay eigies i wou ae ee a giig soy $5 IS --1- a a gea coiuio o scieiic kowege u e I 19 a gauae sue i sycoogy ame oge ous ieeig ecae as asome Next of Kin io someig aie o a assisasi wi Ae a eai Gae moe" a "someig moe" is a ea o e umae eseaces a e Uiesiy o eaa e Gaes suy eame o aimas use i iomeica eseac a scaig ocuse o aisig cimaees i uma omes a eacig ciique o e eseac esaismes esisace o cage em Ameica Sig aguage (AS We ous was io- a a eoque eoaio o e eics o oig eseac o uce o a amucious wo-yea-o cimaee ame aimas Wasoe a 3-yea oecoase ie ega ous i Next of We ous a Gooa oue Sema a Maya aoa- Kin, oes us e e soy o Wasoe a e eow sigig oy a saw e igmais coiios e cimaees cimaees owee e aises cucia quesios aou ie i ee ous eaie e cou o oge isuae uma aue e mi a aou ow we ea oe cea- imse om e oo o ose cimaees ess ouae ues—aicuay aoaoy aimas—a e a Wasoe ouis au a a Moa e oes eem is ow eseac om eica E of ega seakig ou o ee coiios i ao- scuiy What Chimpanzees aoies a oie wi e Aima Weae e imicaios o is soy ae eey i Have Taught Me Isiue a e Aima ega eese u i a About Who as goueakig as ae Gooas iscoey We Are' awsui agais e Uie Saes eame o o oo use i cimaees i 19 e wok o Agicuue o aiig o uo e Aima oge a eoa ous amog oes wi Weae Ac—wic equies a aimas "sy- sigig cims as cage ou coceio o coogica we-eig" e omoe I ceay aguage a commuicaio eeie ow was not omoe i a aoaoy suc as Sema we ik aou aimas a ousees a wee cimaees wee ke i sese-ei- ee o wie ou moa uiese Next of Kin ig isoees eoi o ay oys akes o— is esseia eaig o ayoe ieese i mos amagigy—socia coac aimas aguage o uma eigs ous ou a is eow scieiss e- th Stphn l Mll Accoig o ous eious eeimes Oouco Y AE GOOA gae is seakig ou as a eaya "ae I nnt . th bO hhl i yig o eac ouma aimas o "ak" MOMAI AIWA., thr f Wrn ..4nIr Gooa a I wee soo ae as eeics a ae ee amee moe y e eseaces aima igs eemiss y I sokesesos aoac a y e aimas iaiiy I some cases e Accoig o em ayoe wo wae o imoe e weae ocus was oo muc o oca seec—cimaee ocaia- o aimas was ou o aois iomeica eseac a oug o ios cooe y e imic sysem ae agey iouay e ecommuicae" e aioa Isiues o ea ega ike sayig "ouc" a ose wo ae ee aug o seak eecig a o is ga oosas u ous i o ack ow ca oy o so i a ai as ue o e sucue o ei I ac e wies is esecie a oaee ieesiy esoagus I oe cases aiioa sycoogiss eie oo "As oiic as may iomeica as wee e ueyig muc o coiioig y uisme a ewa wic i- oem was caiiy; caie eiomes iee oy y iis eaig o eaigs sake—e wos o sigs ecome egee o ei cuey" wies ous "I I wee o ae ay meaigess as o oo I si oes—mos oay e moa auoiy o e suec a wou ae o icue my case o im Cimsky a ee eace—e aima was ow eseac as we" ke i eak eessig coiios a gie ie emoioa As e cimaee as ee ou o e a oo moe o o socia coac uma AIS eseac ee is a age a gowig cimaee is as was e mos imoa oi o Wasoe a e suus ous os a e mos ieige a umae comaios om e sa oec Wasoes ouaio was souio o ose aimas ow i aoaoies is eieme io oe a amiy ous quie easoay os a sice away ouses a weee ossie sacuaies i e wi uma cie eeo aguage moe o ess soaeousy Ou geeic coseess o cimaees ei ieigece i a suoie icy socia amiy eiome e same a ei ic ies ae a we-kow ow a e imica- wou go o cimaees Wasoe ook is a se ue ios ae ecomig ee moe wiey ecogie Wie i is we se aug AS o e aoe so ouis wiou uma wog o ea cimaees we us ecause o ei iei- ieeio gece (a wou usiy eaig ess ieige aimas ess e soisicae gesua commuicaio o cims i e we ecogiig ou kisi wi cimaees is a goo is wi is o a-wie a isicie u seciic o eac se o ecogiig ou kisi wi a ie ous wies "Ou cooy a suec o oca a iiiua aiaios—i oe cue sysem o aw a moaiy is ase o a imagie ga wos ey ea i om ei amiies as we o ous ewee umas a oumas e gea aes ae e eais a e easo cimaees ae ake so we o AS ikeies caiaes o ige a ga A oce ey ae is a ey ae ime o gesua commuicaio as ou oe so we umas may e moe icie o gie u ou commo omii aceso mus ae ee Sig aguage goike oe aoe aue a assume ou igu ace as accoig o ous is a eouioay seig soe o ige a o e aua wo" i oug a a uesaig o coceua a socia ea- —aick oa 4 , d nd r Adntrtn "fr" M Urp Cnr ht t Kn y Saa Amuso eig ace o e se wo is ae ee iouce i Cogess a cou ae e ouse esio o e oose egisaio icues a make imac o aima-iey cosumes ig o oo i e "aioa uiomiy" oisio As i cuey kow aou e cosmeics we wea e ugs we ake a eas oe 1 sae aws wou e e-eme icuig e oo we ea ese oo a ug Amiisaio aeig iomaio o G coe i aiy oucs eom is— 111 a S 3—ae a iusy "wis ogaic ouce seaoo aig a ee kose aws is" o kee ia iomaio o ouc aes Cosumes ey o ouc aeig o oie ciica I S 3 cosmeics a o-esciio ugs ae iomaio A o commissioe i oeme 199 icue i a ecee-seig "aioa uiomiy o oug e Oiio eseac Cooaio o ew esey aeig" oisio wic wou e-em saes igs o esue i uy o a wome saig ey wou uy a ass aws comeig mauacues o oie moe io- cosmeic ouc ase o a ae oiig iomaio o maio o e aes o ei oucs a e imie aima esig equiemes o e oo a ug Amiisaio I a ea o sog suo o euig owe o e Caioias oosiio 5—a ouc-aeig suc- saes i is a aomay a iusy oyiss ca esuae cess soy—is e so o aw a wou e suesee a euica maoiy cogess o emace eeaism y ue e ae o "aioa uiomiy" oosiio 5 ceaiig auoiy o aeig cosmeics o-esci- o yeas a age o e cosmeics iusy equies a ae io ugs a oo wi e oo a ug Amiisa- o cosume oucs coaiig kow ois o oe io .2: mauacue as a o make a ouc wi a waig ae; isea oic igeies ae ee emoe om Sr Andn ltv rtr t th r igeai ois a oe esoa cae oucs io o Anl . Strln Adptn f Enfrnt O uy 1 a aw was eace makig i easie o ogs wo ae woke i aw eoceme o e aoe y ei aes we e ogs eie Eo Gaegy ( CA iouce e i eea aw eoceme ogs ae cosiee goeme oey a we ey eie ey ae ecae "suus" Ui ecey eie ogs a o e aucioe owig o eguaios a equie comeiio o e ucase o suus goeme oey ue sice e ogs use y e oe ao ak oice Cusoms a e Sece Seice ae seciay aie ey equie ee cae a aig omey i o aoiae aie ae came owa e og mig e cage—o euaie Gaegys aw eimiae is iumae siuaio a aso cu a gea ea o e ae us seeig e ogs way o ay omes "We a kow wa a emeous coiuio ese aimas make i oecig Ameicas a uoig ou aws—askig iuay oig i eu" sai Gaegy "oiig a oig ome a secue eiome o ei eieme is e ey eas we ca o" ;i

AA EASIO: O A AS ACK O CAOS e Wie ouse a some ig-ice oyiss o ecoomic success wic i ceay is o asaioa cooaios ae geaig u o ee iese e eame o ao as ceiie 13 wokes essue o ea e o Ameica ee ae Agee- ue oe aow ogam wo ae os ei os ecause me (AA usig e so-cae "as ack" meo o oucio sis o o imos om Meico a Caaa weey e Cogess aicaes o e Eecuie is e- Moeoe ou ueceee ae eici wi ou ogaie o eiew o i a ae eas A oe o as AA aes ($39 iio as yea emosaes ack is eece someime is a a e eame o aos ume is e i o e o AA easio is wy e amiisaio is askig oss iceeg o a es ga o as-ack ae egoiaig auoiy e ueguae easio o o Ameica ae a AA as ee a aiue a eey ee o eai a as mae a aeay oue oe egio muc iie as seeey amage US aima oecie egisaio— a moe ageous AA as use e oe eco- wiess e ua/oi cooesy (see age 13 ogy o e eakig oi o eoe a aimas aike ecause o AAs oisios esseig oe I i asses as ack wi gie e amiisaio uim- isecio a e ew oo o imos coamiae ie owe o ease is "ee ae" ies i usiess y oo a iega ugs ae ouig acoss ou soue aioaig oug Cogess mao egisaio wiou a- oe i usae uisece ucks ese ew AA equae eae o ay amemes e aoe asic emo- eas wou e acceae ee i AA was a caic accouaiiy o e eoe o is couy 1 ∎ 15 3 w The Dairy Debate, Consequences of Bovine Growth "Muc ess equime a ewe soage aciiies ae eee wi si o e mos o asue eeig a wi Hormone and Rotational Grazing Technologies yea-ou coieme o eame ey Wig so Edited by William C. Liebhardt aou $ wo o equime (sio aco wagos co- 37 ages ais CA Uiesiy o Caioia Susaiae Agicu- e owe ae a saye ae e soe gowig ue eseac a Eucaio ogam 1993 $ co a ega o ee o we-maage asue i is am Mosaos muc oue ecomia oie gow o- eeig ogam I makes us woe wo ois y ames moe (G oces cows o use u ei ow issue o ouce eeig aiy cows i yea-ou coieme" .2: 1 ece moe mik a is oma is ook ois ou a —Chrtn Stvn e "agigeeics make oeia" cou e $5 iio o $1 iio y e yea SI IGE e amous auo a make o ims o e oo a ug Amiisaio as aoe uma Acie woe a ee o Swees icia ewsae cosumio o mik om G-eae cows u a eake Exprn, Seeme 195—a si esoaes oay "saey eo" oe eaoiay use o secoay ugs may uaoe o acaig cows o ea masiis "e Asi ige Was o Sae e Cows ea-ae use o ee uaoe aiaceias—ieacii 'The last chance to save the cows now is a vigorous protest,' writes geamyci a imeoim-sua—as wo imicaios 1 Astrid Lindgren. She thinks that legislation may even be needed to save cows and calves from spending their entire lives in their stalls, and to masiis a o esoe we o aoe ugs eey protect their right to graze freely during the summer. That way, at least ceaig e ee o y uaoe ugs; a e ack o a one time they can get to see the sun, escape the roaring fans and breathe seciie wioig eio uig wic coamiae mik fresh air. is iscae ue ues sceeig mik o aiioics a augmes isk o uma ea e ae oi as ee Summe is amos oe a i as ceaiy ee oey ewee e ai sowes My aoie summe image e oe I wi ake emasie y e Geea Accouig Oice (GAO 199" wi me io e akess o auum is a ua ic goe e e uouae cows iece wi eies mos eigu aaise wi gee gass a uees G ae muc moe susceie o mas- a aisies a a o o wi saweies ee a ee A iis e aiu iecio o e ue acuay—ee oe sige iig eaig cow Se wake aou gaig ookig asoa a I oug ea essie— oesso Koe cies a ia i wic suey a mus e you ame—ow ice o see you ee you ae " o 9 ew cases o masiis uig wakig aou us oe coee Sweis cow A o oome G eame wee cuue o St o ie imisome ike so may o you sises o us aoe phl r, wic is ess ame- oucio ui i oe o ou as Maye you i kow ae o eeie measues" Stph a—e ay I us wa o say a i a e cows a caes a igs a l r is e ageous iecio cickes i is couy wo ae ee eie o ei uma wic as sea ougou uma igs cou escae om ei aima acoies a as a osias ogaie a ki o aima iua eas ig ee ue e om a ecoomic saoi e ices wa a ameaio o oo wou go o oe e a soee ie o e cow agues agais use o e gow A ameaio a wou cack e wiows o e ames Mea Makeig Associaio a wou amme e eaums o e omoe oesso Koe aws aeio o e "Icease woe Sweis eoe so a ey mig egi o woe a ie i cows cue aeagig wice e usua ae o e eace- a eas Woe i i is eay ig a ece o ea aimas e me (aou o 5 ece e yea ue o oace way ey ae eae i is couy wee we ae acuay so o ieiiy a eacoy isease" o aimas e eec o amiy ames is aso gie aeio Wi- u a aima iua we as someig a ca oy ae i soies A is suec is eay a ie eaiy I ike iam Muy oesso o Agoomy a e Uiesiy o o say a ie someig aou a eaiy emo wies "e wokoa wisoo aiy y aiy Yes iee e Swee is a oe o aimas a ecame ey ames eeig cows yea-ou i coieme is simy cea o me as I ea a e ees a oue i as sig we amaig Oe ame ey Wig (esoa commuicaio I woe a ie sie i eese o cows u eoe i geea o kow eoug o ge ioe o 19 o us a eoe swicig is cows om yea-ou seak ou a say a is is o e way is goig o e coieme eeig o cooe gaig e wou i e A ay ae oe ee wie—we ca ca e ea—kew gou uig a am a wok a ay ui e e asee eoug—moe a eoug eause a 1 m Oe ay i mi-uy Wig sai e was ea is a eeiay sugeo a a i umia meicie sweaig ue aes wie coig oage auig i o a Se as see eoug sueig igee aimas i sauge- ouses a aima acoies eoug sick aiey-ie cows a sio owig i u io e sio augeig siage ou o e caes a igs imisoe o ie A wa se ees is a ee oom o e sio a auig i o e ee uks o e cows isaoime a a equay ee uy we cooe y e aske imse Wou i e easie i e cows i is o wa se cas ou cuey o ie ise emsees? a was e egiig o e e o yea-ou Wy is suc uai eame eaig wi eey yea a coieme eeig o is am Ae Wig swice o asses? Wo o wa is i a oces aima-oig Sweis ames o coaoae i is egaie cuey o aimas? asuig is cows si mos o e yea e sai e emo o e keywo is oiaiiy oiaiiy is wa emas is am sowe ow a e was ae o eoy ie agai May suc gea saciices a was o aciee ige a ige oe ames wo ae swice om coieme eeig o eus om eey "oucio ui" A o couse Sweis gaig iesock o we-maage asue ae eeiece agicuue as o e oiae; a goes wiou sayig u simia eucios i wok oa uig e gaig seaso as i ecome a quesio o oiaiiy a as goe ma a iay ue io is oosie? Is i ime o ook o ew ey ae moe ime eegy a moey o eoy ie Is a meos? wa amig is a aou? 1 9/ Mjr rd lr Iprnd, t th rtEvr n Ao "u" ae oe o e aios ages imoes o occu i e wi Aica gey aos ae igy esie o eoic is as ee seece o a yea i iso a is wii e e ae a a age "Cogo" Aica gey ie $3 o smuggig moe a ao wi commoy comma a eai ice o aoimaey $ o $1 e i i Aica gey aos accoig o e US o▪ is & Wiie Seice (USWS ae e e Uie Saes guiy o cosiig o iegay smugge A- Moe o smuggig o eoic is e ica gey aos io e Uie Saes a oowig iems ae aae om h d o eau e USWS y iig ase imo- aio ocumes o wee iee si- rl Wldlf Offr: mes o aos i ioaio o e acey Ac • e US Cusoms Seice eise e a oe eea aws USWSs e i iesigaig a ece case aes ie is e ages sum ee i a i wic ay macaws wee smugge io eea wiie smuggig case i e Uie eas ou seie ay macaws wee e a Saes Accoig o e iicme a u- asoe o e Quaaie Cee i Sa ic ocumes is comay Gaos o Miami Ysio a a USWS age cage e e- was e aios ages imoe o Aica ea wi a CIES ioaio I ai e gey aos uig 19 199 a 199 $5 ie wi e e iges amou o moey aig imoe aoimaey o a ai o a oice o ioaio i e Wes is- suc is e Aica gey ao is ise ic o eas sice a ew sceue was aoe as a oece secies i Aei II o e • Aso i eas ose Age Saias was co- Coeio o Ieaioa ae i E- ice y a uy i owsie o smuggig agee Secies (CIES aos US isic uge imo ea ese aicua aos wee smugge imose a ai em o 7 mos e a om aie o e aueig couy o Seega A "Cn" Afrn r prrt aeay see 11 ays i ai wic wi a e eoe usig ase CIES eo cou owa is seece O euay ocumes o e Uie Saes e CIES eo ocumes 1997 USWS ages ieiewe Saias i ai a is aoeys asey sae a e aos oigiae i Guiea o e Ioy eques i a eo o ae is seece euce eas a e Coas couies wee e "Cogo" Aica gey ao oes gae e ages ae eig usue hr Chr fr n & rr—AntrG bl Cn Ud us we we eae a e age asaioa cooaios cuue a eome y eseaces a e Uiesiies o a co-oe e eea goeme a quee e sii o Wiscosi a Oego sowe a 9 ece o moe a smae comaies a ess eease om e a eys a- 19 esoes sueye aiowie aoe aeig a ie eye wo a awsui eaig em o ae ei ice wou aow cosumes o isiguis ewee mik om ceam wi e saeme "We Oose ecomia oie cows eae wi G a mik om ueae cows Oe Gow omoe e amiy ames wo suy ou mik cosume sueys suo is iig a ceam ege o o ea ei cows wi G" e A issue ieim guieies o ouay aeig U o ow is ig as goe agais e cows e amiy i euay 199 seig o ow aes cou e woe so ames a e cosumes ee sice Mosao esuae e as o e uu o miseaig a i comiace wi oo US oo & ug Amiisaio (A o aoe e a aeig aw Mos saes oowe ose guieies u a cooaios "osiac"—geeicay egieee G A au o saes icuig Iiois euse o emi ay ai- aoe i a ee euse o equie aeig o mik om G aeig cows iece wi e ug esie suies some o wic e a eys CEO sai e ees coie e ae eoe a 79 icease i masiis (iecio o e ue aoe i is seeme wi e Sae o Iiois a e esuig i geae ee o aiioics euce egacy Ciy o Cicago aesses a egiimae coces a cou e aes cysic oaies a ueie isoes igesie isoes aise y ay sae a aceaios eagemes a causes o e kee Accoig o e Ogaic aey cooeaie wic su- Accoig o e & eys CEO we A "aoe ies mik a ceam o e & eys "e amiy ames wo ouay aeig i 199 u e eguaio o aes o e make u e Ogaic aey amiy o ams ae i is usiess saes we ega coacig eac sae o ge aoa o ou ecause we oe cows We wou o kowigy suec ou ae We sue e ages o em Iiois i eea cou aimas o a ug wi sie eecs a cou cause iess ea ciig e Cosiuios is Ameme oecio o ee a ceae uue sess o e aima Uiiig ay geeicay seec We ae e ig o e ou cusomes wa is a is egieee ouc is coue o wa we eiee i" i ou ice ceam" om ow o umaiaias wi e ae o eec aiy Sice 199 Iiois as eaee o seie oucs aig oucs a o ae e ai-G ae a so e a ai-G ae eey eeciey soig suc aeig sea o ese cue iecios io eess cows ougou e couy ecause i is o easie o aioay I is a auae ecee o oe eos o ae oucs isiue aiy oucs o e aee ieey i ii- wose mauacue is iuious o aimas egisaio o iua makes A ues egaig aeig is eig i Cogess (see age A 199 o commissioe y e US eame o Agi- 15 a 17 444 444 Sie ogs e Cou iges coue wi e sock o e ai eecuio" Wii ess a • A ioaie ew suy y ussia scieiss eeae a oe miue e eie cam was suoue esoe co- WW esimaes o e ume o Sieia iges iig i e oe secuiy swees comee o a es cames a ussia a Eas ae gossy iae e New Scientist eoe eices e suecs i o ae ime o ie o o ge i A 199 suey y WW coue ewee 15 a 75 iges; o e acoic a iega wiie eiece e acua umes ae cose o a a e oem wi e WW suy accoig o Segei omie oy ue Aese Saiao o aiosoks ige oecio Sociey was a • A awa-wiig oy ue was iice o ak- ey coue acks i e sow y is meo i is ey easy ucy au i Acoage Aaska a e o Meico wee o cou e same ige moe a oce e was aese e I a IS ages wokig e case e ew suey ceey use Gema sees aie equese assisace om USWS ages o eecue a seac o isiguis ewee iee iges sces is ioee- waa a a Acoage soage aciiy e ma a ee ig ecique esees moe aeio is e eam aie ue a aias e ogs o isiguis ewee e oos o cicus iges A oa o 5 moue ig game oies om aou e ewaig coec maces Sce sames om kow wi wo wee ecoee ae e iiiua a caime a e iges wee e soe i a aoaoy; a e ogs mace oae e oies o caiae isiuios o ie e ese wi sces ou i e ie coecio om ceios e oies icue eagee secies wic e o Eagee Secies Ac a acey Ac O Coios a oaocks cages agais e iiiua—i aiio o aious wie- • Accoig o Newsweek, seea eiomea gous seek coa cime cages o isiue a 1-mie "wiie coio" uig ewee uig muc o is iesigaio e susec emaie Yeowsoe aioa ak a Caaas Yuko eioy a ugiie i Meico wee e was oeaig as a uig e coio wou aow a moe iese gee oo o e guie e was susequey aese y Meica auoiies egios aima ouaios; i wou aso oec em om wo asoe im o e oe a ue im oe o e ues as ey aee ewee e wo aeas Uie Saes auoiies • I is e ack o us suc a coio i ua Keya a is coiuig o eea-uma ieacio oems acco- aaese Ioy Coos ae o ee ig o a scieis om Oo Uiesiys Coseaio e- • e ew coos a eis o ioy ae io aa sue seac Ui o asawe wies i e VVildCRU Review a om gaig eoceme oooes a ee em ie- "Aoimaey 1 eeas ie i Sokoke eiey cu o ecie says ieo Oaa esie o e Wiie Cose- om a age wic omey eee o sao Eas aioa aio iosoy Sociey o aa ak A e ieeig a as ee see y ames" "e Miisy o ae a Iusy (MII wic is e eeas wo ae aee o is a o geeaios aas CIES Maageme Auoiy as sae o us a ae cu o om ei accusome age a ae o coice u ioaio o e Cusoms aw is eyo ei uisicio o ai cos a so ee is o mecaism o Cusoms o eo a seiues o MII ee oug i is MII wic eas wi Agecies a oaces o Amy ase CIES issues" • O Ai 7 1997 a mui-agecy ask oce couce a ai Amog oe eoceme oems Oaa wies "e o e camgou a o eoa Woo Missoui a eaies ae oo ow e ume o eaes wo ae su- see as a gaeig ace o a oose-ki gou o oaces osey eguae is ey sma a a age ume o wo equee e aea uig e ukey a ee seasos sma-scae eaies a ousie e coo sysem ao- e iesigaio ocumee ossie eeas gee" a oe 1 ioaios e aws ioae icue e Miga- "Ue ese coiios o meaigu eoceme ca oy i eay Ac acey Ac Sikes Ac; sae wiie aws e aciee" Oaa sai is is aicuay igeig gie o Missoui Iiois Iowa a Cooao e ioaios i- e imeig eoeig o ae io aa (see age 5 cue eceeig imis o oes uig oes wi ai uig ee uig cose seaso wi e ai o a aiicia ees as imay ousig o ig om a moocyce a oe imi; isig uig cose seaso; uawuy kiig a mouai io; seaig goe- ogs Ouawe y USA me oey; a usig a ossessig maiuaa e US eame o Agicuue aouce i Augus o amiisaos wee cocee aou e ioaios as a ameme o Aima Weae Ac eguaios ega- ee wee may saey issues Suecs wee uawuy soo- ig aima ousig oiiig eeig as a meas o ig game icuig ukey a ee om a moo eice imay ecosue o ogs wiou coce o wa was ei e aimas I may cases "We o eiee uig a og o a ee oies e game was oace om e ousig aeas o e o Oe aequae ousig ue ay cicumsaces" sai Micae ee was so wie e oaces wee a e ca was o e os u USAs Assisa Seceay o Makeig a eea sae a miiay aw eoceme oices a eguaoy ogams game oicias aiciae i e ai im okoy a sae "is cage i eguaios eecs coces oice coseaio age sai e a ee o a o o ais u is y e uic a aece iusies uig a seies o was e is oe e a ee o wee e goo guys ouum- uic meeigs we e i 199" u sai "As a esu ee e a guys WS age ickiso ceie e success o a iu esos ow usig ees as ousig wi o e ai o "suise see a sueioiy o esoe e i ioaio o e Aima Weae Ac"

1 91 ew 4,44 au ooe oic ea ug igs eay eaies • Ewa au e sycoogis • A eea case ioig e smuggig o ceueo—a wose cue eeimes o ai- ioey oic iega ug gie o ea caes o ouce mas ke i oi coiios ai gow—as esue i ecouagigy seee ea- cause iese cooesy i e ies o ose ioe esie oo a ug eguaios 191 "Sie Sig Mokeys" case aig is use e ug was aegey oug io e as ee gie oe o is Uie Saes om oa mie wi ee aiies a oessios mos esigious isiue y e iek Suy Cooaio a eaig ee awas e Ameica sycoogi- sueme mauacue I caes ceueo ca i- ca Sociey ame im a Wiiam cease weig as muc as 3 ece e ay wie causig ames eow a is aua meeig aemia ao a oe ea umas wo ea e oi- i Wasigo C i ue o "u- soe mea ca eeiece icease ea ae musce amea iscoeies" aou ai emos eaace iiess ausea ee a cis eogaiaio e 199 iesigaio as e o seea iicmes e sociey aie o meio age ies a e imisome o ieks esie aes a as icia iesigao a Mayas Isiue o ea- oeeg e comay was ie oe $1 miio ioa eseac e couce guesome eeimes i wic Accoig o e umae amig Associaios Gai Eisi e seee ees i mokeys ams esesiiig a aa- i is "e soges eay ee ae ow agais e yig em I eeme isess ey wou ie o ei ow ea iusy" oimi ea Cooaio—e aios iges Mokeys wee sae i esaiig eices (see ages ouce o ea—was oee o ay $3 oo aoe a suece o iese ai (wic eseaces Eisi ucoee oimis oe i e scaa eme "acue oious simui" I aus aciiy aimas ue e esie o ais Ca Mik Ic a Wis- we ays wiou eeig ie i i a wee ume i cosi ea omua comay was seece o ie mos a ucke o omaeye we ey ie i ai a ie moe o ome coieme ae eaig e case aace wiesea uiciy we eoe o guiy o cimia cosiacy o eau e US goeme e Eica eame o Aimas co-oue Ae aceco Accoig o e ga uy ais ucase 15 ocumee e cue coiios wie wokig a e aoa- ous o ceueo-ace ee om iek Oe o e oy as a ie Siee o e mokeys wee seie a au couys ages ea ams I Ic is aso imicae i was coice o oiig iaequae eeiay cae o si e case a is owes ace imisome a ies o mokeys Yeas o ega wagig esue owee a i cages o smuggig a cosiacy 19 e coicio was oeue o a ecicaiy ee is si moe o e oe owee uc usi- e mokeys wo suee a ie o aus "ua- essma Gea oogeik—owe o ico a ee mea iscoeies" wee o gie ay awa y e sociey sueme comay ase i Ouewae oa— was iice o ie eea oeses a cou e ie u o $ miio a e imisoe o u o 1 yeas Mcoas oses ace i ie ace osecuos say ico was "e icia souce o ack • e ega maao o iais oace "Mcie" ia as make ugs" o iek e mus e eaie o e come o a ackuse e o Mcoas Cooaio wic Uie Saes o sa ia "Ui ow uc auoi- se ee yeas a $15 miio o a awsui agais wo ies ae ee ey euca o usue is case" sai eiess oo aciiss wo uise a eae ciiciig e Eisi ow owee—aks o essue om A gia as-oo cai; ey couce ei ow ega eese suoes a e US goeme—is eaiio is I 19 oo Geeeace (o aiiae wi Geeeace eig cosiee y e cous i oa Ieaioa issue a ame ie "Was Wog wi Acio ease wie o e Eceecy W Sogage Mcoas?" wic ook e cooaio o ask o is ei- Miise o usice c/o oya eeas Emassy omea imac is eame o aimas a o is wokes iea Aeue W Wasigo C A oiica a e eec o uma ea o is oo Accoig o h Secio ema a Gea oogeik e eaie tn, Mcoas ie eecies o iiae e iy gou immeiaey o ace ia o smuggig iega oic ugs a sy o is memes e ie ie cages agais ie io e Uie Saes aciiss ee see ou o cou u ae Mois a ee See euse a e oges ia i Egis isoy was o Clv fr th "rt" ht iay o ue 19 h tn woe "uge oge e vl trd, n th ue a wie Mois a See a o oe a rt n hh Mcoas cause saaio i e i Wo o was th r nfnd esosie o esoyig e aioess o a kowigy fr nth. h eose cusomes o e isk o oo oisoig o a eaig nvr r lld a Mcoas eas o ea isease o cace ey a oe t trth thr a e comays as eoi cie a a i is cue o lb, vd thr aimas a ueays is wokes Mcoas a aske o n xrnt, aou $15 i amages; uge e awae ess a r hv t $1" Wie o quie a eea i is a gaig o-icoy ld fd. o e cooaio wic wou ae oe muc ee o eae is ciics aoe

. 19 rth Intrvl n Cttl d fr Mt lf nd t y iko a Aie eia a aeage 3 ays i e semi-wi cows esus 9 ays I is commoy eiee a caes mus e aiiciay weae i e maage cows so a e cow gies i a e mos eque ossie ie- e ieece o 1 ays was saisicay sigiica as We a e uique oouiy o quesio e usiica- iicaig a e eomace was eace we e caes io o is eie y comaig e eoucie eomace wee aowe o say wi ei moe ae a we ey o 1 cows wo wee aowe o aise ei caes eyo e wee aiiciay weae y eig ake away om e mae- age o aua weaig wi e eoucie eomace o a e 9 oe cows wo wee suece o e aiioa oce e ee eomace o e semi-wi cows cou o e weaig maageme sysem o caegoies o cows ie o aiue o iee cimaic o uiioa coiios I e same ac i es o aoimaey 5 aimas icuig coas o e maage cows owee e semi-wi cows wo maue us e e ie i a sae socia eiome I was oay is e caes o e "maage" cows wee ake away saiiy o e socia eiome a accoue o e ai- om ei moes a e age o aou eig mos a mas ee eoucie eomace Aiiciay eakig aise i seaae gous Soy eeae e moes o oy e o ewee moes a ei si usig wee aso emoe om e oigia e a e-goue caes u aso iesi eaiosis ewee e moes i oe es ese aiicia isuios o socia eaio- a oe e memes aaey cosiue a seee sis wee eemey isuig o e aimas a i ook sess siuaio o e maage cows wic esue i a seea ays o ee weeks ui ey came ow agai eessio o ei eoucio a esaise ew eaiosis wi e memes o e Ou oseaios caege e ieia o aiio emo- ew gous saig a eoucio o ee cae is eace ae a e caes o e "semi-wi" cows wee auay weae euce we cows ae aowe o wea ei caes a e y ei moes emae caes a e age 7-1 mos mae ioogicay eemie age Ieeig i ioogica ocesses caes a e age o 9-1 mos e weaig i o imai i may saisy mas amiio o ae coo oe em u is ay way e aecioae o ewee moe a ca I ac is ou o ae uoesee eecussios i e ioogica e moe-ca o was e ouaio o e es coesie ocess is o oey uesoo Ieeig i e aua socia sucue (see coe oo weaig ocess o cae o oy iics aoiae emoioa e eomace o cae is usuay assesse y cacuaig ai u i aso uecessaiy imiises e aimas aua e ime ase ewee wo is is so-cae caig ie- eoucie oeia vttn f rt The first meeting of the Intergovernmental Forum on Forests is scheduled to meet in New York in October, but it won't report its findings till the year 2000! Meantime, the transnational logging companies who control 80-90% of the international trade in timber are free to roam the globe seeking our untouched forests for exploitation. • e acie oess o e Uie Saes ae eay (95 goe a ese ae e oes aimas aoie euges Ee e ewoos ae eaee y e Maam Cooaio wic was o ay is cai saws o e eee eawaes oes A iesos sou oow e eame o e Caioia Sae eaces eieme Sysem a ies emsees o Maam sock • ome eo e mammo uiig suy comay uicy aouce i wo uy o gow ewoo om is suies icuig e gia oggig cooaio ouisaa aciic • US isic uge Sce ou e US oes Seices acios i eass aioa oess o e "aiay caicious a ause o isceio" e ae ime cuig o uic as ece i ae cases

Aima Weae Isiue o-oi Og os Oice o 35 US OSAGE Wasigo C 7 AI Wasigo C Aess Coecio equese emi o 3

IE O ECYCE AE

eag a aigs ooga o wo youg oaguas ca- ues e coseess a ieeeece o ese ou imae cousis owee a a wo away as oes ies ue ou o coo i Soueas Asia oagua amiies—amog may oes—wee o aa Aimas ie om ie om smoke iaaio a a e as o umas See soy o age 11

rtr Maoie Cooke ai O i eeo G ewe ppprt Cisie Sees oge Sees Cyia Wiso Clr, Offr rtr Cisie Sees esie Cyia Wiso ice esie eeo G ewe Seceay f th U.S. oge Sees easue h nd Sntf Ctt Maoie Ace Gea ea Wldlf ee ey M aaa Oas Srv oge aye Samue eacock M is a Wiie Seice ieco ppprt Clr was co- o Was M ime y e Seae as Augus Se as aeay aciee a goa soug o may yeas y ies o wiie amey e eeaio o e Seices Intrntnl Ctt ie e Aua M - Meico Cie o aw Eoceme o e ieco ee is imoa ogaia- G Aikas M - Geece ioa cage wi make ossie moe eecie eoceme o aws assao aaak usai - agaes oecig wi aimas a as om e we-ogaie smuggig igs Agea Kig - Uie Kigom a oe scoaws wose owe a eusieess as gow so isasousy Simo Muciu - Keya n ece yeas Gooeo Sui - Cie I aessig a e emoyees o e Seice ieco Cak sai "As Ms umiiko ogo - aa you kow ou ages ae a iicu a oe akess ask o eocig Kaus esegaa - emak a wie age o eea wiie aws om oacig o smuggig o wiie Aeey Yaoko - ussia I is a o a cosses iuay a ogam aeas ye i seems a iee Stffnd Cnltnt om wa oes o i e Seice I ik i is imoa a e ieco eay Comue Cosua e esoay ioe i aw eoceme issues a eeoe I am o Geie Assisa o e Oices ueakig a eaigme o make e aw Eoceme iisio accou- iae aeso am Aima Cosua ye uciso Wae Camaig Cooiao ae iecy o e iecos Oice" Cay iss Eecuie ieco Cak cie "e emakay successu Oeaio eegae" ue e augo Mai Oe Seceay wic "we go ou 3 coicio o smuggig aos" e uecoe Gea isso Wiie Cosua Oeaio eegae was sae y Ciie o aw Eoceme Cak ai aick oa uicaios Cooiao wo is memoiaie i e Cak ai Awas o e Aima Weae eie ike Amiisaie Assisa Isiue iko eia M Kei Aams wo as see o 1 yeas as a Secia Age i e aoaoyAima Cosua Seices aw Eoceme iisio was aoie Cie o e iisio eie iick Amiisaie Assisa i oeme 1997 e as emasie e ee o ui soge goa Aam oes eseac Associae aesis i comaig smuggig oacig a aic i iega wiie e Wie Wiie Iesigao oucs E AIMA WEAE ISIUE QUAEY FALL 1997 VOLUME 46 NUMBER 4

O x 60, Whntn, C 2000 • phn: 20222, fx: 202848 • l: nllfr., URL: http:.nllfr.

ttt tl 0,042444 Wiie amie aao Cak ieco o e US is a Wiie Seice US Eaes u Imo a ego a ooes Cee Eea oaces oise o Make a Kiig Maasai Gou akes Issue wi CAMIEs oyig acics Isae ass "aioae" Ioy ecisio Was e ea Soy o Missouis ie Oes? Asia ies uee y Sosigeess a Gee Cause Uo Sueig am Aimas

10 Abv: lphnt f n phn thrt. Mosaos Geeicay Egieee oucs Mee esisace eiew o The Price of Meat y ay ema 12 S tr, p 6. ew ook Sows ow Gee a Cuey ae Suee a-Wo oecio o iesock 13 Aimas i aoaoies Ae Seig Miios ew esey Aima es aoaoy os awsui 1 o Moe Aima esig o Cosmeic oucs i iai 1 eiew o From Guinea Pig to Computer Mouse 1 AWIs Aima-ousig esouce eise Uae 1 ews Uaes I Aeciaio o May Seas McGauga AWI oss ook ay ae aws a e Eiome MAI Giig e Wo Away? 15 age WOs igeig eco 15 Ieaioa Waig Commissio Abv: n l ht n lhld trp. aa a oway Use Iis Commissioe l: tr fr r European Voice dvr o owa Waig Agea 1 tnt n th lhld trp . S tr eo om Moaco 1 n p 4 nd .

O E CAUG U Y E U.S. EGO A AGEEME ... p

4, 0 C1 t 7 •1" ACIO

AGE 4 • A AWI QUAEY U.S. Evd r Iprt n, hld rp rpnnt Chr Humane Intent of European Law Does a Disappearing Act The advertisement on the facing page ran in the European Voice December, Pimenta said, "This very day, the European Union is just before the final vote on implementation of the European Union undertaking the conclusion of a new agreement, this time with the import ban on fur. AWI and the 16 major organizations whose logos ofAmerica. The understanding I got by reading the texts appear on the bottom of the ad appealed to the Council of Ministers I received privately is that this particular agreement is even weaker than to reject the U.S. proposal. But heavy lobbying fom the United the one we just analyzed with Canada and Russia. It is the worst because States, particularly the threatened World Trade Organization Chal- it gives more time to the United States to prohibit the use of leghold lenge of the EU law, overpowered the United traps with jaws. It is especially bad as regards Kingdom, Belgium and Austria—who stood observation and enforcement.... for protection of animals from the cruel jaws "I would like to ask the Commission what of leghold traps. did the American [Trade] Representative The U.S./EU Agreement is flawed be- Charlene Barshefsky write in the letter she cause: it is not legally binding; it defers sent to Minister Klaus Kinkel, where she responsibility by the federal government to stated that this derogation will be applied in the states; it contains a loophole-ridden offer case of extreme necessity, and will remain the to slowly phase out use of "conventional" same as in the agreement with Canada and leghold restraining traps—without defining Russia." which leghold traps are "conventional" and Anita Pollack, another Member of the which are not; and it embraces "best manage- European Parliament who has strongly sup- ment practices" (BMPs), an idea contrived to ported the leghold trap ban, said: "We are disguise continued use of leghold traps. here debating a very peculiar creature. It is called an agreement yet in reality it is a non- A Goas Oe Ageeme "I eaiy [e US ageeme] is agreement. I would liken it to the Cheshire The character of the U.S./European Cat because all you can see is its smile. First, Union agreement is starkly revealed by the a o-ageeme I wou ike it should be said that Parliament did not seek reaction it has inspired in the National Trap- i o e Cesie Ca ecause this agreement, we want the implementation pers Association (NTA), which is overjoyed a you ca see is is smie" of the 1991 Regulation. That was very care- that, as its president puts it, the agreement on fully put together to end the worst cruelty —European Parliament Member Anita Pollack "remains firm in the necessity and associated with the trade which allows rich humaneness of leghold traps." women to wear the furs of tortured animals. In his letter to members, a copy ofwhich In the face of threats of WTO from Canada has reached AWI, NTA President Craig and the United States, the Commission took Spoores assures trappers that "The scientific it upon itself to negotiate this non-agreement BMP process will discover that some leghold and it is fundamentally flawed.... traps will continue to be necessary and prove "TheAmericans cannot ensure implemen- best for some American species" (emphasis tation because of their federal system. The added). Canadians are happy for it to have enough Does Mr. Spoores possess some mystic loopholes for a pack ofwolves to run through, power to foretell the future or is he simply and the Russians love the self-enforcing, self- passing along to his constituency the low- evaluating system. So there is still no commit- down on a back-room deal? The existence of ment to abolish the cruel leghold traps. At the such a deal has long been suspected between end of the day this unwanted, unworkable the European Union Commission, the Clin- non-agreement will perpetuate the use of the ton Administration, and the International Association of Fish and leghold trap and is unable to improve the welfare of trapped animals. Agencies—which exerts massive influence over the state fish Even the Cheshire Cat trapped behind its smile. I urge support for the and game departments. Pimenta report." "Thanks to you," Spoores wrote to NTA members, "the animal MEP Caroline Jackson asked Sir Leon Brittan, "One point on activists have suffered another major defeat. We still have our market which I would be grateful ifihe Commissioner could reply. It seems and our tools." By "tools," Spoores undoubtedly means steel jaw that the Commission was possibly reluctant to implement the original leghold traps. Regulation because of fear ofWTO proceedings. Is this true? How does the Commission regard the original Regulation as likely to fare within Meawie i aiame the WTO?" In the European Parliament, few have been as dedicated to animal Brittan did not reply to Jackson's questions, but sidestepped them welfare as Carlos Pimenta, the Portuguese member who authored the by claiming, "we all share the same commitment," noting that "the Parliament's stern condemnation of the previous draft trapping problem is more severe in the United States and it takes longer to get agreement. Speaking during the Parliament's debate on the issue in rid of it." %,2:

AWI QUAEY A • AGE

h EU h pd lndr l nt lhld trp Wll th Clntn Adntrtn b lld t ndrn t?

Ct ht In n lhld htrph ntl . K

O E COUCI O MIISES The EU Law Against Leghold Traps —

We esecuy eques a you oose e cue aig • I 1991 e Euoea Uio aoe oosa oee y e Uie Saes e US oosa wi o eguaio 35/91 euce e uecessay sueig o aimas caug i ego as • As maae y ase I o e aw a o e EUs iee Meme Saes I is meey a use y e US - o o aoi cagig is aaic oiie use o ego as i 1995 aig acices a o aoi e EUs u imo a • O eceme 1 o is yea ase II o ee quaes o Ameicas wa ego as ae Eigy- e aw - is imo a o us om eig couies ae aeay ae em u ow e EUs isoic couies a ae o eie ae aw may e caug ewee e aws o e Cio Amiisaios e a o aoe "ieaioay wo eious saegies e eceiu oosa a e scae acic o a agee umae aig saas" - eaee Wo ae Ogaiaio (WO caege came io eec e US as aie o comy wi eie oisio e oosa sou e eece ecause

• It frdlnt e EU Commissio as caime a e US oe o ase ou coeioa see aw ego as wii si yeas is ucoiioa owee e US ae eeseaies Oice oey sae a e oose ase ou o ese ego as wi e suec o umeous eogaios

• It nt b nfrd e US as sae ceay a aig is o a eea mae a i cao oce e saes o comy

• It prt t h dl Caaa a ussia ae commie o e use o coeioa ego as ucoiioay i yeas e US oosa emis yeas - wi eogaios

• It bd n rdn f th thrt fr WO e eguaio is oay eesie ue WO o gie i o US ackmai a ak o ae sacios

Since the U.S. has not agreed to stop using leghold traps, the fur import ban should be implemented as required by law. It should only be lifted if the U.S. puts forth a geniine anti-leghold trap proposal, and the European Parliament and Council of Ministers accept it.

esie G I 1 ArI '4H KA 4 ="-m-

h dvrtnt bv rn n th br f Erpn .

AGE 6 • A AWI QUAEY

EEA OACES OISE O MAKE A KIIG by Adam M. Roberts As Ben White eloquently and sadly reported in the last Qr trl, the African elephant (xdnt ftn did not fare well at the tenth Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Interna- tional Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) held last June. Despite our indefatigable defense of the ivory ban, convention host Zimbabwe successfully won the down- listing of its own elephant population, as well as Botswana's and Namibia's, through intense lobbying schemes and an overwhelm- ing government-backed media campaign. The looming question for CITES nations is whether or not the ivory trade specifically should resume as a result ofthis downlisting and what effect the downlisting has had, and will continue to have, on African elephants across the entire continent. The decision taken by the Parties last summer reclassifies the elephant populations in Zimbabwe, Botswana and Namibia from Appendix I (no commercial trade) to Appendix II (regulated commercial Abv: phd trade allowed). Right now, these three countries can export live elephants lphnt r and trophies. The U.S. government no longer has the important dn n responsibility—nay requirement—to issue an import permit, as was Ghn Ml previously mandated. Zimbabwe has a special dispensation to export tnl r. ivory souvenirs and elephant hides as well. Thankfully, under the ht: pl f provisions of the United States African Elephant Conservation Act, lphnt bn. America will not permit any ivory across its borders, although other non- ivory elephant products now have seemingly unfettered entree. The historic decision to weaken elephant protection did not auto- mind that the ivory trade itself cannot be completely resumed until the matically enable the legal resumption of international ivory trade, how- aforementioned nine conditions are met, it is worth investigatingwhat has ever, and if it does occur, the only trading partner to receive such ivory happened in the months surrounding the downlisting decision at COP 10 is Japan. Decision 10.1 of the Parties describing "Conditions for the and whether these same prospecting profiteers are still hard at work. Has resumption of trade in African elephant ivory from populations trans- there been an "escalation of illegal hunting of elephants"? ferred to Appendix II at the 10th meeting ofthe Conference ofthe Parties" •Senior Wildlife Officer B. K. Volta-Tineh reported on August 8, outlines nine specific requirements which must be met iftrade in raw ivory 1997, from Gaa that "On 30th June 1997, eight days after my return is to resume. Unfortunately, this decision paper is incompatible with the from the CITES conference in Zimbabwe, a report was received on a text of the Convention; it is incomplete, weak, and does not give other poached elephant in Mole National Park.... On the spot investigation elephant range states appropriate participatory roles in decisions related revealed that it was a mature bull carrying only one tusk. The carcass was to ivory commercialization. Moreover, this document and the others already in an advanced stage of decomposition. The animal might have related to the elephant debate were written in secret, passed without due been shot by the poachers at a place other than where it dropped because democratic dialogue, and form an inadequate regulatory framework to the tusk and the tail were still in place. The poachers escaped arrest.... 2. examine the ivory trade and elephant conservation. Barely two weeks after the above poaching incident, another report on a However, one particular requirement is especially noteworthy: poached elephant in the park was received.... It was a young female ofabout condition G declares that the CITES Standing Committee (due to 10 years of age and this time the poachers succeeded in carrying away meet in the United Kingdom, March 1998) must agree "to a mecha- everything with the exception of the skull and bones.... 3. I may interest nism to halt trade and immediately re-transfer to Appendix I popu- you to learn that since 1988, this is the first time we have encountered lations that have been transferred to Appendix II, in the event of non- elephant poaching in the park. The repercussions of the CITES downlist- compliance with the conditions in this Decision or of the escalation ing of the species for the three southern African States on the other range of illegal hunting of elephants and/or trade in elephant products states is already showing in Ghana. The rapid succession in which these owing to the resumption oflegal trade." This is an important provision two poaching cases occurred in Mole National Park forebodes a very bleak because most other requirements pertain to actions within each of the future, not only for the Park but for the entire country, as far as the survival three downlisting proponent range states. This requirement, on the of this species is concerned." other hand, refers broadly to the "escalation of illegal hunting" •A report in TheNamibirin on July 23, 1997, notes that in Namibia without specifying where the illegal hunting occurs. AWI has always "Poaching is continuing unabated in the West Caprivi Game Park, where feared the effect a resumption of the ivory trade would have on all poachers killed at least two elephants and scores ofsmaller game in the past African elephant populations, not just those in Zimbabwe, Botswana month." and Namibia. •An October 2, 1997, Associated Press story out ofNairobi, reveals that Before Ben and I left for Zimbabwe, I wrote in the winter Qrtrl "Poachers have killed five elephants and hacked off their tusks in Keya about "Prospective Poaching" and claimed that "Reports out ofsouthern renewing fears that poaching will surge as a worldwide ban on ivory trading and eastern Africa show profiteers positioning themselves to reap enor- is eased." The story notes that this was "the first time ivory has been poached mous financial rewards should the ivory trade be reopened." Bearing in ntnd n nxt p

AWI QUAEY A • AGE M Grp I th CAMIE bbn t e Maasai Eiomea esouce Coaiio (MEC was ome targeting governments and international conservation organisations downplayed "o oec a maage e as iesiy o wiie a oe aua the risks to the African elephant. The lobby staged a play, centred around the misery and poverty of rural Africa and Zimbabwe in particular. Wildlife was esouces o ou a o e eei oe Maasai eoe ou couy a portrayed as having encroached on humans and the situation as being e wo" Oe Kamuao Ooisai eos i e cue Care for the Wild compounded by certain wildlife species, particularly the African elephant. News a aaysis o e isasous owisig o Aica The theatre group toured the world, strategically targeting major eeas a e CIES Coeece i aae imawe global, environmental and financial events, such as the IUCN General – Assembly in Canada and the annual meeting of the World Bank in CAMPFIRE, Zimbabwe's communal areas management scheme, Washington, DC. Audiences throughout the world were continu- was touted as the flagship strategy for `sustainable' natural resource ously misinformed of the views of the Maasai of Kenya and Tanzania, use in the southern African region. CAMPFIRE targets the who were portrayed as supporters of the ivory trade! The message to harnessing of wildlife resources for commercial purposes, includ- the audience is that trade in wildlife is the panacea to the economic ing the re-opening o f the international ivory trade. The ivory trade problems of rural Africa. The ivory trade received particular attention. was the focus of attention because of the potentially massive profit M Against the above background, the curtain for CITES '97 was lifted to be made. Japan had already been identified as the trading partner. Envrnntl by none other than Zimbabwe's President Mugabe.... r Secondly, and perhaps most importantly, the Organisation of Nevertheless, it is important to note that, apart from CAMPFIRE Cltn African Unity Heads ofStates held a summit in Harare, just one week Associations and their regional affiliates in southern Africa, the only before the CITES Conference began. President Mugabe of Zimbabwe was other African NGOs at the conference were those opposed to the downlisting elected Chair of this organisation. It was an opportune moment for Zimbabwe, of elephants. These included groups from Ghana, Kenya, Liberia, Uganda and Namibia and Botswana (the three countries which were proposing to resume Zambia. the ivory trade), to lobby the rest of Africa. Heads of State would have found . . . In our view, the ideals that founded CITES—namely the regulation of it difficult not to offer their support to their chairman, for purely political trade in endangered species of wi Id flora and fauna—remain some of the greatest reasons, devoid of ecological considerations. accomplishments of our time. It is the same spirit that needs to drive and guide A third factor—and perhaps one that is lost to many an observer—is the the deliberations surrounding the Convention. Our hope is that these ideals public relations campaign undertaken by the CAMPFIRE Association's will always be upheld, even under the severest of political tests. implementing agencies, which include the Africa Resources Trust and the In Harare, this vision was nearly sacrificed, thanks to the aggressive marketing Zimbabwe Trust. A carefully choreographed global information campaign tactics of the proponents of the ivory trade. 4,1,1

• • ntnd fr prv p Irl lt "lrdd" Ivr n i Keya is yea" a quoes Keya Wiie Seice eea ee A combination of blatant and underhanded dealings made the aick Omoi sayig "We ae ey ey cocee aou ou e- relaxation of the CITES ivory ban possible in June in Harare, Zimbabwe. eas We ae o sue wa wi ae o em wi e owga- Accordingly, the Israeli CITES Management Authority issued a vigorous ig o eea oecios" e UK-ase Cae o e Wi Iea- denunciation of the decision—and demonstrated that the vote was pushed ioa ae a i "as eceie e oiyig ews a i us oe through illegitimately—in a petition to the chairman ofthe CITES Standing mo 9 eeas ae ee saugee i Keya o ei ioy" Committee, parts ofwhich are excerpted below: •A eoe o Seeme 1 a imawes ewsae The Sunday Standard Mr. Chairman, full and free debate is a vital right of the democratic process. caims ecoig "a 5 ece icease i cases o If a deliberative assembly, such as CITES, is to secure intelligent and eeas oace sice e ieaioa a was eae wo mos ago responsible decisions on proposals there must be free interchange of thought Wiis Makome acig ea o e eame o aioa aks a through discussion and debate. Furthermore, parliamentary law customarily Wiie [sai] e aeage ume ooace eeas a so u om requires that every member ofa deliberative assembly have the right to know the meaning of any proposition before the assembly, and what its effect will ou e mo o e is si mos o e yea o si i uy oowig be. Such knowledge is achieved through a presentation or explanation of a e iig o e a" particular proposal by its proponent, and by the exercise of full and free debate Aiioa eos icue wee eeas oace i oe week i once the presentation or explanation has been made. e owe amei aea o amia; 95 eeas kie y Suaese Although during the previous day there had been some general debate on the African elephant issue, at no time had there been any consideration of the oaces i e Cea Aica euic; a Suaese oacig text of document Com. 10.34. There was no presentation or explanation of cams esaise i e emocaic euic o Cogo the several complex provisions of the document, nor was any debate permitted uig e eea eae a CO 1 Iia oo soke ou agais on those specific provisions, even though they were among the most e owisig oosa e eegae oe a as ega ioy ae contentious in the history of CITES. It is our conclusion that debate, crucial to an intelligent and responsible was amu o e goa eea ouaio a a ioy aes wee vote on the African elephant proposals, was improperly denied and sup- aeay egagig i e osecie oacig o Asia eeas As o pressed. It is further our conclusion that the Rules of Procedure have been oeme 15 1997 15 oace Iia eeas wee ecoe— transgressed, and as a consequence, the vote following that transgression is moe a ay oe sige yea i moe a a ecae invalid.... The abrogation of pertinent Rules of Procedure, and the consequent I is imossie o iiae e mi o a oace o eemie e deprivation of Parties of their rights of free and open debate on issues is a most moies ueyig e aaic massace omaesic eeas a isce serious matter that in itself should be enough to invalidate any decisions which wee e iig o e ioy a may e e imeus o e eewe are produced from such infringements.... sauge; wa is cea is a e message oa oeia esumio o ae It is further our conclusiohi that the entire handling of the issue lacked fairness and good faith. The timing of the elephant issue so late on the agenda, i ioy is a gaig siga o oaces a ee is oi o e a y and particularly the shocking announcement that the most critical documents eea eas e CIES aies mae a oeiay ageous ecisio would be neither explained nor debated, as well as the persistent use of secret owisig e secies oug e Saig Commiee ocess ee votes—far beyond the stated intentions of Parties who approved the new voting regime—combine to obscure the CITES process. There is a lack of is a oouiy o aies o uge e imac o e eea owis- transparency. There is a hint of trickery. Several Parties left Harare with the ig a ossiy ee e esumio o ega ieaioa ioy saes feeling that the African elephant issue had been railroaded.... Eea oaces a aaese ioy cosumes mus o e e oues If such fundamental characteristics of parliamentary procedure are under- oice ea o ia maes ogoa secies coseaio ee is ecious mined, the future of the Convention and the wild fauna and flora it seeks to protect, are jeopardized. ie oom o eo i e uue o e secies A rvr ttr thr nd hld (pht b nl . Cx

issoui se e yeas a $1 miio o eiouce ie oes oceues a assumios" sayig a e o-imi seaso is "u us- aig as ee aowe u wa so o "eucaio " is amio giig e Euoeas? e I— o e sae e asae oes eoye Missouis waeways iiae o scieiic gous" a a "ee is o usiicaio o oeig e Aima ega eese u ie—a os—a awsui gosses oe ego as eie cuey a e ac a may oe ess a ie owee i 199 a e agai i 1997 e sae a aig seaso" S ouis uic Scoos sciece cooiao aymo cagig e US is a Wiie Seice wi acig "i a aiay cue aig meos ae aaiae (eumeae i eai i AWIs eame o Coseaio (OC oee a o-imi oe aig eick sai "is ieeaio is oiousy iase" omas E a caicious mae" y aowig e oe es o e eoe (o Alternative Traps). e aso ais o oe a e u iusy as a ese seaso I aiio o eeaig e uose oe eioucio ogam Eea cae e 199 seaso "a oious oe-aes" e 15 oes kie i 199 a u wee agge o eo iees i "usiess as usua" a as o iceie o cage aig wi a ususaiae ai o ei umes (ey ae ise o CIES as yea amio esimae a e oe ouaio a icease Uouaey e cou ue (amog oe ecicaiies a sice meos o umae easos amio assee "I o ik ees a Aei II—eaee e aig suecs oes o e cuey o o 3 om e oigia 5 wo a ee eiouce io Missoui Missoui was goig o o e aig seaso i ay case e issue coic o iees ee e u iusy is e oy gou as goig ego as—a o ee a make o ei u i Cia om ouisiaa ow ae e 199 aig seaso (uig wic o wee e es wee eoe o o was a issue o come u wi moe umae as" OC scieis ai amio caims a ee ae moe a 15 oes wee kie amio as aouce a Missoui as e OC is a meme o e u Isiue oCaaa wic as ai o moe o e sa esus o suc ieeios y sokesme o eoug oes o go aou u amios ouaio esimaes ae oes-5 moe a wa e sai a yea ago amio says o ai amios asaaic aes—mae e sai ue oa "o sae is a game agecies a y e US ae eeseaie ucuae cuiousy skyockeig o a ee wic euae ioogiss e eaie esimae was wog e iae umes wee oiicay eucae [Euoea Uio] ioogiss memes o e eiome see age wee e Euoea aiames oewemig oosiio ae cae io quesio ecoogis ica Ose o e Isiue ey coeie gie aes eageess o ag as may oes as eames memes o e ae eames oiicias igiaies o e US aig ageeme is eesse i is mos ece eae; o Ecosysem Suies ook amio o ask o "scieiicay uious ossie i 1997—oy e seco yea sice 191 a ie oe a e uic aou u maageme ogams i e Uie Saes" aso see e European Voice aeiseme eouce o age 5 ; O

AGE 0 • A AWI QUAEY

After Spending Millions, New Jersey Animal Test Laboratory Drops Lawsuit Aoug uigo ie Scieces a oe o ecoe some o e awsui "ses a sog message o e coaiio o aoaoy a u 1 miio oas i esimae i a os as a esu oEAs eig-mo iusy gous wic a ie u ei uigo aious o see uecoe iesigaio o is ew esey aima esig aoaoy EAs iesigaios soe I i wok" uigo cae i quis ae aig se moe a wo miio oas EA esie Igi ewkik ceeae e icoy a e gous i ega ees a eeses o e sui e seeme i wic EA oes ook eaquaes sayig "uigo auce a eesie aack o ay uigo ay amages o coss was sige y eea isic a ackie We soug o sow e wo ow aoaoies ike cou uge ey Moga i ook igiia o eceme 15 uigo ea aimas ei e scees a we succeee; a ume Cii igs aoey ii iscko wo eesee EA o a o ig amaceuica ouses saw EAs eiece a susee o geay euce ee eiees uigos ecisio o o e eesie cacee ei coacs wi uigo a oco & Game auce a ieee iesigaio a e o is eouceme o o Moe Aima esig o Cosmeic oucs i iai uigos aima aig acices e ieo is ou ee a e use o aimas o es cosmeic oucs i iai ee i uigo ca ig i ack ay moe a i ca ecaim e eages oeme we e ee comaies icese o o suc ess agee wo as a esu o EAs acio Kim asige sae om aig ei o so Goeme miises wo a omise o ouaw e ess egs oke a eig esoye i uigos a" eoe ei eecios—a wee accuse y e uic o eakig As a o e seeme uigo agee o acae a coem ei omise—me wi e icese ims a oaie e ouay iig agais ewkik aisig om EAs eos o ee e eages a e comay emais ue iesigaio y e US eame o Cosmeic ingredients, owee ca si e ese o aimas Agicuue o ossie ioaios o eea aw aisig ou o a comai Oe measues e goeme as ecie uo icue a a i is case e comay wic as see is sock a 7 ece sice o cimaees a goias i scieiic eeimes (oug oe i came ue scuiy i e Uie Kigom oowig e eease o as ee use i iai o a ecae a a ossie a o e use uecoe ieoaes ee as aso ake isciiay acio agais o aimas aicuay eages o oacco a acoo esig a- seea ew esey emoyees wo o is sa i iai ae ee oug o iceses o o so cuey eis ► cimiay coice o cuey o aimas

MOSAOS GEEICAY EGIEEE OUCS MEE ESISACE y oie Cummis caim ey wee eaue y Mosao ue aiy cows eaig Mosao as suee a ume o ecoogica a uic eaios Mosaos "ouu eay" soyeas ae oucig mik wi ie- "gices" oe e as ewyeas icuig e massie makeace aiue e cemica caaceisics (ige a ees a cows wo ae eaig o is iio-oa agsi ouc G Ae ee yeas o e egua soyeas Ina makeace oy o Ameicas aiy cows ae eig so u wi e ug Wa See aayss o usiess Week magaie i 199 a ue nn Cn th tnl rtr f th r d o ame a cosume oosiio (a e ac a G amages e Cpn USA. r r nfrtn, rt t: r d ea o cows e ug was a oa aiue a a i ecoomic ems i Cpn, 860 h 6, ttl Mr, Mnnt 64, sou e ake o e make [Eios oe G as ee eiay r ll (800 2068. ike o ea oems a cause eeme sueig o cows icuig masiis a aiu iammaio o e ue See e Sig/Summe More on Monsanto AWI Quarterly 1997 o moe eais] A Gema aciis wo owae ciicisms o Mosao o a I scieiic a uic ea ems aa coiues o ie u a Iee maiig is ou imse e age o e gia cemica sigiicay icease ees o e uma gow omoe aco IG- cooaios awyes—a e comay os 1 i geeicay egieee mik a aiy oucs cosiue a seious as wie Wee eisege eceie a message om a gou o uma ea isk o icease eas a coo cace I aiio oesos wo wee ogaiig a ai-Mosao oes e oesos scieiic suies ae ecey ee oug o e aeio o e Wo cae Mosao "A cooaio ooisos gees a swie" eisege ea Ogaiaio a iecig mammas wi geeicay egieee asse e aouceme o o a e-mai iscussio is cae GEESIS gow omoes ey ikey iceases ei susceiiiy o eay wic coces oo ecoogy e i-skie cooaio sue icuae ai-wasig iseases suc as SE commoy kow as Ma eisege ee oug e was o e auo o e message a e Cow isease o is uma aia Ceue-ako isease Cose- iscussio is oy a memes quey e WO e Euoea Uio a e Coe Aimeaius ae "Mosao caime a I oee e comay wi e wo uikey o ee aoe G as a sae ug eaig e US as e oy swie a eagee ei ceiwoiess" eisege woe i iusiaie aio i e wo o ae aoe G Earth Island Journal. "ey gae me ee ays o sig a ecaaio Oe oues o Mosaos geeicay egieee oucs co- omisig ee agai o say Mosao e cooaio o swie iue o mou i mi-199 Mosao/Cagees igy-oue "a Eey ime I eeae is seece I would have to pay Monsanto Sa" omao was ake o e make osesiy ecause o oucio 100,000 DM ($66,666)." aiues a geeic gices; Mosaos eie Caaia geeicay Reisberger refused to sign, and a German court rejected all ofMonsanto's egieee aesee o caoa co a o e ecae eaie is yea claims and ordered the company to pay the court costs. Such hypersensitive ecause o ueaie "ecica iicuies"; a u o a miio aces litigation only serves to make giant companies look silly, as Monsanto o 5 o Mosaos Coo co i e US wee aacke y should have learned from England's McLibel trial. a owoms i 199 oiig awsuis y ouage coo gowes wo AWI QUAEY AI • AGE Asian Fires, Fueled by Shortsightedness and Greed, Cause Untold Suffering oiic ies ae swe acoss e us esey ouae isas o May oe o Soueas Asias Soueas Asia is a Smoke as ie e ai cokig is o ea aimas sueig om esiaoy Oaguas iges a eeas ae e e uig uges oy o oems a imeig amie i ey a owee o go Wa was immeiaey aae was a ae a seious coics wi u- e ies wee se ieioay mas ee ige aacks wee e- e easo? am-oi a ae comaies se ies o cea o oe i smog-ie Sumaa i coa a a oug i e egio—cause y aomaous E io e as si mos a eea weae aes—aggaae e ies ui ey ue ou o coo es ae amage i aa a is ees a isecs ae a u isaeae i some aeas u Sumaa amig aeay-scace aicuay a i wee e igy eagee oaguas oKaimaa cos ie eo as ee mae o oeo a Sumaa wo ae aeay a ei aia seeey euce Orntn r n th y e ecoacig uma ouaio a y oacig ei oua- ei i e aaios a oggig nl hrdt ht b th fr. io as ae y 5 i e as 1 yeas A esimae 1 o e coces o o o em eso 3 emaiig oaguas ae ie i e ies a moe wi ikey sie o e esucio cause y e ies oug Ioesias goe- ie o saaio aia oss o om e oss o a ae ue ami me eoke 151 ime eoiaio emis o Ocoe 3 us oo soages Ioesias ae kie oaguas o ei mea as e mos ae i a eisae 5 o em aimas ie o escae e uig uge Accoig o Wiie Smis o e geey sas-a-u acices a e o e ies ae eei- e Waaise Samoa coseaoy o e isa o oeo a eas 1 e e am-oi ouces e mos ei a as ee ceae a am- oaguas ae ee oue o kie y esies escue oaguas oi ices ae ise amaicay Meawie e mosoo is ae ue o E awai a uceai uue i escue cees a coseaoies wic ae io a ee we i comes i may o so e ies wic ae oge u o caaciy i coa seams a ea ogs a cou smoe ee o yeas Newt 14kae4 • Eko Maie Cooaio o ew Yok was seece o ay $3 miio o e US is a Wiie Seice o ioaios o e Migaoy i eay Ac esuig om a 199 oi si o e oe Isa coas I is e seco-ages ie ee imose ue is ac eceee oy y e 199 Eo ae oi si i Aaska Eko Maie a wo aiiae comaies ow e ugoa Snd a e North Cape oi age wic a agou o Mauuck oe Isa i auay 199 "kiig ues o is icuig oos waeow gees a gus" accoig o oa ameso o e US is a Wiie Seice uge May M isi o e US isic Cou i oiece iece e is a Wiie Seice o se e $3 miio o coseig weas wii oe Isa • A gou o oey owes ae suig eawaes oes owe Maam a is caima Caes uwi o "eckessy iesosie oggig" i a eiome- ay sesiie aea o acie ewoos eues eoe i eceme iy-ee esies o Sao Caioia says Maam-owe aciic In appreciation of ume was esosie o oey amage susaie i asies cause y Stearns McGaughan eoesaio "Maams ogge imeas ie ike oe eeig soes o e ascae" e sui sai "is is a case i wic a woe commuiy Sao as May McGauga was e iig oce e- ee iuay wie o e ma ue o e caous isega eiie y i eacme o e see aw ego a a [Maams] us o u ees io cas" i e Sae o oe Isa Se oue e umae Sociey o amesow 5 yeas ago a EQUESS O AWI esaise a cass i e i gae ase o umae eucaioa icies wi emasis o o ay wo wou ike o e assue e Aima Weae Isiues uue wiie a aue e cass si coiues a oug a oisio i you wi is Oea om o eques is suggese as gauae may sues oe e yeas wo I give, devise and bequeath to the AnimalWelfitre Institute, locatedin Washington, ae caie o e umae wok a message DC, the sum of $ and/or (specifically described property). Se couce issues meeigs o aima oec- io wowie a was eeig e oi oaios o AWI a o-o-oi cooaio eem ue Iea oecio Ac oy weeks eoe e uimey eeue Coe Secio 51(c(3 ae a eucie We wecome ay ea Se woke cosey wi e Aima We- iquiies you may ae I cases wee you ae seciic wises aou e ae Isiue o aace ou muua aims Se wi isosiio o you eques we sugges you iscuss suc oisios wi e soey misse %,": you aoey AGE 2 • A AWI QUAEY tt2 /+1 The Price of Meat making protests. by Danny Penman Each species of farm animal is dealt with in a separate chapter followed Victor Gollancz, 1997. 240 pages. by discussion of genetic engineering described as "Redesigning Animals" ISBN 0-575-06344-0 and covering such subheads as "Building New Chromosomes"; "Sperm Danny Penman's clear prose describes everything that people of con- Engineering"; and "The Future: the Economist and the Engineer." Some of these engineering feats have already caused severe problems. Broiler science need to know about farm animals, including the science and chickens "already grow too fast for their own legs, and are technology being loosed on these creatures whose natu- in constant pain because of it, so a further raising of the ral origins and natural behavior is disregarded by the growth rate without at least a corresponding increase in leg industry as inconsequential. Mr. Penman dedicated his strength could condemn millions more birds to agony." book "to Jill Phipps, who died while trying to stop the A further chapter entitled "Patenting Life" is followed export of calves." by a chapter entitled "Animals are Worthless: the Tradi- Jill Phipps was the young woman crushed by a truck tional View" which examines Descartes' callous philoso- during a massive protest against the export of calves and sheep to the European continent. Huge demonstrations phy and 's famous quote, succeeded in stopping exports by sea. As Penman writes "The question is not, Can they reason? nor Can they talk? but Bentham may have laid the explosives under in the Introduction: "The battle to stop live exports Can they suffer?"... Descartes' views but it was Charles Darwin who detonated them. showed the power of individuals. Welfare groups were In The Origin of Species, Darwin argued that mankind was not occasionally offered seats around the table with the fundamentally different from the rest of creation because life Government but were ignored. The people of Shoreham, evolves through a process of natural selection ... The differences Brightlingsea, and elsewhere pursued their and similarities between man and beasts are of degree not ofkind. own path through direct action. For this reason, the The Price of Meat was written shortly before adoption most effective way of bringing about change is through of the new status of animals by the European Union which individual action." now has declared them to be "sentient beings." This book The extraordinary make-up of the demonstrations, which drew their should serve as a guide for action by the European Union and to point the greatest numbers from middle-aged housewives, was quite different from way for reforms in the United States. the image industry prefers to project of jobless youths in outlandish garb —Christine Stevens

own wild birds for the pet trade. Only a dozen or so countries still have AWI t rt a commercial trade. Hypocritically, the wealthy countries still continue to A book-signing parry given by the Animal Welfare Institute and Psycholo- import from some of the countries least able to regulate a wild bird trade. gists for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PSYETA) was held October The trade is highly profitable for a few individuals precisely because they 9 to launch the two organizations' new books and introduce guests to Roger cut corners at every stage. For every rule there is an abuse, and such abuse Fouts' recently published Next of Kin (reviewed in the last AWI Quarterly). is widely practiced. AWl's hard-hitting The Animal Dealers, Evidence of Abuse of Animals "Those who still advocate maintaining the wild bird trade at a 'sustain- in the Commercial Trade, 1952-1997 begins with a televised interview able' level should look more closely at the track record. The reality is that traders with a former buyer and record keeper for a major random- are expert at avoiding any regulations, and there will never source dog dealer. Not until his own dog was stolen did he exist proper resources to police such a far-flung business. We realize what his role had been in this nefarious trade. "That need to eliminate demand for wild-caught birds as pets day," he said, "I seen them burning the dog collars. That's through education and enforceable legislation and look to the day I knew they'd stole them." captive breeding to supply any birds for the pet trade. The Inspection reports by U.S. Department of Agriculture mass trade in wild-caught birds for the pet trade will always veterinarians and technicians were obtained under the result in unacceptable cruelty and has a built-in tendency to Freedom of Information Act. They document mistreat- drive species towards extinction." ment so gross that it would be hard to believe were it not Highly critical of the trade in reptiles, Clifford Warwick for the massive series of quotations from these inspection wrote the chapter entitled "The Shelf Life of Reptiles." Just reports. Photographs illustrate these abuses and those shortly before the book was published, the U.S. Fish and encountered in the primate trade, the wild bird trade, and Wildlife Service proposed to extend transport regulations the reptile and amphibian trade, to each of which a chapter for reptiles and amphibians under the 1981 Lacey Act is dedicated. Mary Ellen Drayer edited the book and with amendments on Humane and Healthful Transport of Wild Cathy Liss collected material from USDA and from AWI's Mammals and Birds. voluminous files. "The Primate Trade," written by Jessica Speart in close collaboration Peter Knights, who went undercover with Dave Currey of the with Shirley McGreal of the International Primate Protection League, Environmental Investigation Agency in both Africa and South America, details the horrors of this lade, including all the great apes and the many wrote the chapter on commerce in wild-caught exotic birds and the monkeys. smuggling, extreme overcrowding and massive deaths involved. Enforce- Dr. Kenneth Shapiro's new book, Animal Models of Human ment of the Wild Bird Conservation Act, passed in 1992, together with Psychology, soon to be published by Hogrefe & Huber, presents a Lacey Act requirements, has eliminated the worst abuses committed by big closeley reasoned analysis of the massive use of animals in psychologi- U.S. dealers. Knights reports, in compelling style, on "Operation Ren- cal research and teaching. His understanding and sympathy with the egade," the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service sting that resulted in a series of creature most commonly—indeed, almost automatically—subjected indictments and convictions of major bird dealers. Knights ends his well- to painful and distressing procedures, the albino rat, are movingly documented chapter by stating: expressed at the beginning and end of the book when Dr. Shapiro "Europe, the United States, Australia, most of Africa and South and briefly recounts his personal experiences. Animal Models of Human Central America, and Most Asian countries have all banned export of their Pschology will be reviewed shortly in the AWI Quarterly. , AWI QUAEY $9 gi A • AGE ew ook Sows ow Gee a Cuey ae Suee a-Wo oecio o iesock y Gai A Eisi omeeus ooks 1997 311 ages IS 1-5739-1-1 Slhtrh is an intensively researched expose written by a woman who, virtually singlehanded, uncovered the de facto repeal of our country's federal Humane Slaughter Act. Gail Eisnitz's interviews with slaughterhouse workers, inspectors, and veterinarians as she pursues the shocking results of deregulation of the meat industry make compelling and completely convincing reading. The Society for Animal Protective Legislation, AWI's companion organization, was the leader in convincing Congress of the need for the Humane Slaughter Act in 1958. Support was so broad and strong from groups as disparate as the General Federation of Women's Clubs, the Butcher Workmen's Union, and newspapers nationwide, that President Eisenhower said if he went by his mail he would think Americans were interested in no other issue. The and Feed Subcommit- tee of the House Agricultural Committee visited to see for themselves the overwhelming need for legislative action. The whole country supported the legislative reform. But in recent years the industry's passion for the profits that can be made by speeding up the slaughter line wiped out consideration for humans and animals alike. According to a U.S. Department ofAgriculture veterinarian quoted in the book, "At every inspection station on the kill floor there's a stop button... if an inspector sees anything wrong, he has the authority to hit that stop button. He's the only one who can give the ll nrd lhtrln pd ( ft n company permission to turn it on again." But, these days, it hardly ever h vr thr nd hv d hn lhtr p happens. bl, Gl Entz rprt. And there are a variety of reasons, all related to intimidation, that this basic law enforcement system has been destroyed. For example, an be stunned as required by the federal Humane Slaughter Act. "We kept inspector tells the author, "How can you monitor something like that if telling them we were slaughtering conscious hogs. We asked them to set you're not allowed to leave your station to see what's going on?" the stunner voltage high enough to knock the hogs out. We said we could A beef-kill knocker tells Eisnitz, "As the foreman speeded up the line, try this, try that. The main foreman would agree to take care of the it got harder and harder to knock 'em. I have to hit 'em four or five times, problems, then just walk away. Five minutes later, when we knew he was see, and even then they sometimes still get up." Describing the air gun, in another area, we'd run upstairs to the control room and turn up the he told her, "they turned the air pressure down and didn't repair the gun voltage. What does management do? Puts a lock on the control room when gaskets broke." door." Eisnitz, questioning him further, is told, "Once they regain conscious- Taking the reader into the confidence of the men hired to do the most ness, they start bellowing. They're hanging there going 000AAHH!" menial and dangerous jobs, this incisive book manages to cover all of the She asks, "How many of them are like this?" "Twenty-five to thirty horrific abuses—including the pitiful, hideously painful deaths of little percent, easy.... Just to keep the line moving. I've seen cows hit with whips, children who ate hamburger tainted with E. coli 0157:H7, the result of chains, shovels, hoes, boards. Anything they can use to move 'em. Seen feces splattered on the meat during traumatic slaughter. Far from degen- them laid wide open across their nose and stuff." erating into a litany of horrors, however, Eisnitz's fast-moving investiga- When Eisnitz asks if he ever com- tion with each individual described and quoted from tape-recorded plained, he's emphatic: "You bet. To conversations creates a broad understanding of the whole intolerable the Foreman, the inspectors, the kill situation. floor superintendent. Even the su- A fierce sadistic spirit has taken hold ofsome of the men, together with perintendent over the beefdivision.... alcoholism and domestic violence. The lead pipes used by such slaugh- I've gotten so mad on some days I'd terhouse workers are gatherTd up before consultants hired by the packing go pound on the wall because they company visit. They don't see conscious hogs driven into the scalding won't do anything about it." tank or hear their screams. Visiting government officials are likewise Anger at the frightful suffering carefully protected against the possibility of witnessing the routine contrasts starklywith the cold-hearted cruelty documented in Slhtrh. indifference of the packing company —Chrtn Stvn h Shn U f Grd. lt. nd and the slavish following of outra- Inhn rtnt Ind th U.S Ml Indtr I-- geous policy by those in authority is o moe iomaio coac e umae amig exemplified by a sticker's account of Associaio 155 Caioia See Sa acisco CA GAI A. EISII his failed efforts at getting the hogs to 919 o isi is wesie a wwwaog

AGE 4 • AI AWI QUAEY

Edtr nt: th Mltltrl Arnt n Invtnt, r MAI, h ttn lt n ttntn n th d, thh th btr rnt r thrt t vrnt nd t vrnnt blt t rlt trnntnl rprtn. An thr l, th tht prtt nl nd th nvrnnt r thrtnd b MAI. h xllnt rtl tht fll rprntd fr Econews. MAI: Gvn th Wrld A? y Eaie Weie Couies ow may imi e aiiy o oeig cooaios o um Imagine if the U.S. wee sue y a oeig cooaio ecause i is oic wases si aua esouces o isace oca wokes a ao oca osig moey coomig o aws wic isis o oi-sae ua usiesses a omoe aioa goas suc as eegy coseaio o cea aguig a is is a ae aie ecause oe couies o imose is ai a wae owee ue e oose MAI is wou a e isoy equieme o ua Cooae iesos cou caege egiimae uic ea saey Imagie oo a is sui wou e ea y a ieaioa iua a eiomea saeguas as imeimes o e ee ow o caia om wic ee is o aea a iae iiiuas a ogaiaios Was moe oce e eay is sige aios ae ocke i o yeas wee oie om suig e oeig comay a a oca a sae Aoug eimiay egoiaios ae ee goig o sice 1995 goemes cou o ass aws coaicig e iuas ecisio e oose eay as ee soue i sececy a oy eace-uic Imagie ee ue a i e US euse o comy wi e aeio uig e ece "as-ack" eaigs i Cogess e eeae iua i wou e suec o ae sacios ike ose we imose o as-ack egisaio wou ae gie e esie auoiy o egoiae Cua o Iaq—a ee cou ace miiay oce ae ageemes wiou ay cages y Cogess wic oy cou ae Ye a is is ossie ue e Muiaea Ageeme o Iesme oe yes o o (MAI a ew ieaioa ae ac a wou aicay ae e ways e MAI eay as ee escie as a Bill of Rights for asaioa goeme ca eguae asaioa cooaios cooaios a e as ig i e wo e cooaios wa is uic Wie y e Ogaiaio o Ecoomic Cooeaio a ee- iscussio aou i ome (OEC wic cosiss o 9 iusiaie aios—wi Wa You Ca o iu om 7 o e 5 ages asaioas MAI wou substitute ak o eoe Is amaig ow may soisicae eoe kow ie an international tribunal for our court system in all matters concerning o oig aou is ea o eeom e em you o o wa MAI international trade. ecause i eaes e aiiy o e eea sae a oca goemes ae is aamou o ass a eoce eiomea aws as we as uemiig aioa soeeigy e uose is o euce ae aies amog e 9 couies y o ue iomaio coac uic Ciie 1 S equiig a a iesig comaies oeig o omesic e eae W Wasigo C 9; ( 5-1; e-mai equay y ay aio a sigs e eay [email protected]. ; nr: WO rhtnn rd

All humanitarians need to know the shockingfacts detailed here by The endanger health. The "consensus" among "scientific experts" was that Ecologist—the following are excerpts from an editorial in Vol. 27, No. 4. there was no such evidence, despite the fact that the results oMosaos ow ciica ias wic i aeme o isguise sowe a e use o y Simo eaack e omoe S [aso kow as rBGH] increases the rate of udder cell I ayoe was i ay ou as o e ue aue o e Wo ae infection y ece eaig o a se o aiu a isaig ea Ogaiaio is acios i e ee yeas sice i was ceae ai a eecs e mos imoa o ese is masiis iammaio o e eessigy cea icue As eae i eey case oug eoe i o ae mammay ga o ue wic esus in pus clots in milk, a swollen red e WO as ue i ao o cooae iees sikig ow aioa udder and, in bad cases, terminal sickness.... a su-aioa egisaio oecig e eiome a uic ea [rBST milk] is also contaminated by rBST, increased levels of thyroid a eey u human enzyme, pus, antibiotics (used to treat the mastitis) and increased We a iusy-acke goemea caege o a "isaaa- levels of IGF- 1 which has been incriminated as a risk factor in breast and geous" aioa o oca aw is oug eoe e WO e coeig colon cancer, particularly for young children.... aies ese ei case i a sece eaig eoe a ae o ee oay If the WTO has swept away laws protecting human health and the uaccouae ae ees—geeay awyes wo ae mae caees o balanced composition ofthe atmosphere, legislation designed to safeguard eeseig cooae cies o ae issues—ay e mos eua o endangered species has been given even shorter shrift. The U.S. Marine aies ee is o oisio o e eseaio o aeaie esec- Mammal [Protection] Act placed an embargo on tuna caught with ies om o-goemea ogaiaios and documents presented to dolphin-killing methods. It was denounced by Mexico as a protectionist the panel, and the identification of the panelists who supported a position trade weapon designed to close markets to foreign competitors. Rather than or conclusion, emai sece reform its practices, Mexiio sued the U.S. and succeeded in having the law I May 1997 i a moe wic oes i o e Euoea Uio aw declared illegal under GATT rules, under the pretext that the way in which equiig e aeig o a geeicay egieee oo a WO ae a product is produced may not be used as grounds for trade . ecae a e Euoea Uios a o imos o ee ouce wi The U.S. law restricting the import of shrimps for countries whose aiicia gow omoes ioae ieaioa ae ues a was cose- fishermen catch them with methods a ki eagee sea ues aeas quey iega is eeses a imoa icoy o e ago-cemica se o oow a simia ae gia Mosao wic ouces e omoes a o eAmeica cae I as ee esimae y e US cie egoiao a oe o e iusy wic uses em o make cae gow ase a ouce moe mik eaaoy meeigs o e io coeece a of America's e issue eoe e ee-meme WO ae was wee e a environmental legislation could be challenged and declared illegal before was goue o ay scieiic eiece a e use o omoes mig WTO panels. 9 AWI QUAEY"Wr A • AGE t24 ge r Gn t Cptr M eeise may couc eeimes o aimas Oy esos wo ae y Usua iko ick ukes a Coia Geicke comee uiesiy suies i eeiay meicie meicie o aua uise y Euoea ewok o Iiiuas a Camaigs o scieces may couc eeimes o eeaes" is meas a umae Eucaio (EuoICE 1997 sues mus o a eas a accaaueae egee i oe o e iomeica is ook is a auae comeium o esouces o eaces a scieces eoe eig aowe to eeime o eeae aimas o sues ieese i eacig aiioa "eucaioa" eeimes a suc aw eiss i e Uie Saes am o ki seie aimas a i comemeig eis- Iee e US is a ei Euoe i esais- ig umae eucaio EuoICE wose memes ig aeaies i eucaio a ye e oems o comie is ook is a ogaiaio esaise i 19 miseame o aimas i ioogy eucaio ae y sues a aima weae camaiges e ook ee aicuay seious ee esie may eos o oies iomaio o eacig aima eeimes eom i e US si oy a ew sae aws imi ig aiioay couce y sues wi o-aima ec- scoo issecio y makig i oioa uemoe iques Aoug i is imaiy aime a uegauae oy a au o saes ae aws a a ig scoo eeimes a ioe iicig ai A oae coege-ee a eeiay scoo eucaio eaces a Ur, n sues a oe eucaioa ees wi i i useu is Crn Gr eceio is a 1979 Massacuses aw a oiis ook esees wie isiuio eemeay a secoay scoo sues om co- Aeaie esouces ae ise wi esciios o ucig eeimes i wic eeae aimas (mam- ei use a iomaio o ow o oai em e mas is is eies a amiias ae "eei- isig icues a aiey o aeaies om moes a meay meicae o ugge i a mae o cause mecaica simuaos im a ieacie ieo com- aiu eacios o o iuce aiu o ea ao- ErICE ue simuaio a iua eaiy se-eeimeaio ogica coiios o i wic sai eeaes ae a uma suies esosie aima use i io a a eeimes iue oug ay oe ye o eame eeime o oceue a oseaioa a ie suies oiig ceaues Aoug may o u o imie o aeseiaio o eecic sock o wee e e esouces ae aaiae om Euoea souces some ae ee oma ea o sai aima is ieee wi o wee ai o isess eeoe i e Uie Saes a ae eaiy aaiae ee From Guinea is cause" Pig to Computer Mouse is isiue i e US y e umae Sociey I e USee ae o aioa oicies a imi e use o aimas oe Uie Saes (see iomaio gie eow o EuoICE a i coeges o oessioa scoos u eeiay a meica sues SUS ae esaise oa sysems o a ume o ese esouces a ae ee oca i oesig equiemes a ey am aimas as a eae eaces o same a amiiaie emsees wi aeaies o ei eucaio o isace coucig o-eaeuic sugey o EuoICE eies a "aeaie" as a eacig aoac o ogs a cas As a esu some isiuios suc as us Uiesiy eucaioa ai a oms a oa umae eucaio sysem o wic ca eeiay Scoo ae eeoe "aeaie ogams" o ei su- eace amu aima use ey oi ou a e use o aeaies is es wo oec o causig am o eay aimas Amog e may e om i some Euoea uiesiies Iee seea couies i susiues oee ae a e eeiay sues use caaes a oy Euoe (e Uie Kigom Gemay Swee emak e e- couc eaeuic sugey (o acice sugey o eay aimas eas a esewee ae aws a ey easoay equie a ceai e oea aim oEuoICE is o ceae a umae eucaio sysem ee ocomeecy oesos wo egage i aima eeimeaio o ougou Euoe ei isio is o 1 ece eaceme oamu isace e 19 Gema aw saes "Oy esos wi e equisie aima use ey oec o e aiio o amu use o aimas i eucaio i wic couess ogs is as a oe AWIs Aima-ousig esouce eise Uae aimas ae use as isosae oos a ae kie eac AWI h pblhd n, yea o eac aou e ocesses oie ey eiee a prhnv hth dtn is ioaio o e aimas iegiy a is cuue o Cfrtbl f Comfortable Quarters for ioece egaes aimas sues a e wie soci- Laboratory Animals, dtd ey Qrtr b tr nhrdt, th ese ogaiaioa oecies ae eaie y a frrd b hn Gl nd ume o aciiies aime imaiy a uiesiy su- th hptr b ldn es EuoICE oes a aeaies aisoy se- fr ntt nd vtrnrn. ice oies suo a aice o sues wo ae h b, hh prvd a coscieious oecio o amig aimas a os brtr thrttv nfrtn n vr pt f nl r, aua coeeces e ogaiaio maiais a- Anl n ndpnbl rr fr ioa coacs i oe couies a ese coacs nvttr nd vlbl icue memes wo ae e ey eoe wo ace ntrbtn t nl lfr. iicuies a uiesiies egaig eeom o co- A fr p f Comfortable sciece a e ig o o-aima o-amu ae- Quarters vlbl t ntf aie meos ntttn, br f —E Barbara Orlans Intttnl Anl Cr nd r Gn t Cptr M is aaiae om U Ctt, vtrnrn oaa acome Associae ieco o Eucaio e nd rhtt fr ll thr, t umae Sociey o e Uie Saes 1 S W vlbl fr $5 Cll r rt Wasigo C 37 e -5-11 a - AWl fr r nfrtn. 77-13 a a ice o $195 wic icues siig

AGE 6 • A AWI QUAEY pn nd r U t t rrd Whln And I ei us o eoe commecia waig aa a oway ae sceme—eas ecause ey ae uwiig o so ei Aacic yig uiousy o maiuae e Ieaioa Waig Commissios "scieiic" waig wic suies miios ooas wo owaemea ew caima—a i ooks ike eye succeeig o e aaese make Micae Cay e Iis commissioe wo ecame caima o e Acio ease wie a ee o oes o e Iis goeme askig IWC as yea is ow eig a "Iis oosa" a wou aow wy Iea omay a sog coseaiois aio is eig e wo coasa commecia waig o oy o e e secies oage waes u eegae waig couies aa a oway i ei aem o aso e ues o secies o smae waes ois a ooises oeu e goa waig a a as aeay sae es o ousas Cay—a caee ueauca wo eas Ieas aks eame— o waes om eig aooe Wie o Emassy o Iea 3 may e i oe is ea we i comes o waig issues Massacuses Aeue W Wasigo C Ii• e Iis comomise wou ca o /a o a eagic (ee-sea waig (suc as aas waig i e Aacic u auoie a coasa Other News from Monaco aios o couc waig wii ei eioia waes (wic i e om Ocoe - e Ieaioa Waig Commissio case o oway a aa eac 1 mies ou o sea Uouaey (IWC gaee i Moaco o is 9 aua meeig wi 3 o e wos waes a ois e eioia oes aog coass a couies a aou 1 oicia osees i aeace icuig aou isas coe oe wos oceas Wose si amos a wae e Aima Weae Isiue As aways e meeig was a ecuia a oi secies swim wii Cays "kiig oe" a oe ime o ace ewee e aees o wo muuay ecusie woiews aoe eey yea Coasa waig is a og-soug aaese aim waes as ki o waes as ie e Iis sceme was ouy coeme y moe a a oe IWC as yea e US goemes aem o wi a quoa o ie aios a e commissios 1997 meeig as we as y e coseaio Caioia Gay Waes yeay o e Maka Iia ie o Was- a aima weae gous eaig e Sae e Waes camaig We igo sae was wiaw I Moaco e Maka a eue Cay cae o a secia iecessioa meeig o e commissioes o ucke i wi e eisig quoa o ussias Iuis o 1 waes a ackage e oosa o e 199 meeig sog oosiio was yea eegaes wae o gie e ussias ei quoa u wee si eesse y e Uie Saes e Uie Kigom ew eaa sogy oose o e Maka oosa aguage was isee io Ausaia a ai amog oes e oosa imiig wae uig o ose aoigias "wose eeeess Cay sceue e cose-oo commissioes mee- aoigia susisece a cuua ees ae ee ecogie" ig o euay 199 i o a aces Aigua e ocaio a e ac ecause ese ees o e Maka ae seciicay not ee ecog- a o esky wae-saes wi e aowe o osee ae aise may ie y e IWC may eegaes a osees eiee e eyeows o oy is Aigua amog seea Caiea aios wo ae oosa oes o emi e Maka o u waes e US ague eaiy iuece y aa i as aso eeaey ee ike o aious e eese—uouey seig e issue io US cous o oms o couio a ogaie cime us as yea e US Sae esouio eame cae Aigua "a weak ik i eos o coma ug I oe eeomes e IWC ue e quoa o G eeas aickig a moey aueig" mike wae ake y waes a yea aa use o a cage i e aaese goeme a waig ieess ae oug massie e ues ooceue a wou aow e oio ooes eig ake iuece i Aigua a ou oe isa aios S ice S ucia y sece ao a moe a as eae susaia couio a omiica a Geaa A ie o ese couies oe saisy i ie wi CIES (Coeio o Ieaioa ae o Eagee Secies aas wises a e IWC meeigs I is mae aa is oe ae y aowig couies iuece y aa o ie ei comomise o ock wae-oecio measues equiig a ee-quaes maoiy o oes e IWC aso oe ow o e e yea i a ow aas e commissios 39 meme aios eques o a aome o 5 mike waes o ei coasa waes ue comicaig e icue aa caims o oppose e Iis ue o is cea commecia comoe

Aima Weae Isiue o-oi Og os Oice o 35 US OSAGE Wasigo C 7 AI Wasigo C Aess Coecio equese emi o 3

IE O ECYCE AE