L:>Rs(Olf/Vof
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ORGANISATION FOR THE PROHIBITION OF CHEMICAL WEAPONS Dirutor-Ctntral OPCW The lf<lgue, 18 December 2014 ?014 OEC 2 3 Johan de \V ittl.>"n 31 1./()!)(Jill)5480/14 I q--- II 8 J--i 2517 JR The Ha)!U< !:....... ...��4._�·; i/� ..,.. !.: t l t•l;_ �� Tht' Nethnbnds o:F 'i llc ;,t.Q.l;J:.:ut)'.GE.NERAI. Tdcphone:+ 31(0)704103702/o-t ht: + 31 (o)jo 410 37 91. E-mail: ahmct.uzumcu(t!)opcw.urg Excellency, I have the honour to transmit to you the Third Report of the Organisation t()r the Prohibition of I Chemical Weapons Fact-Finding Mission in Syria. As you know the Mission was mandated to J I establish the !acts surrounding allegations of the usc of toxic chemicals, reportedly chlorine, f()r I hostile purposes in the Syrian Arab Republic. I This repoti will be circulated today in ·nlC I !ague to States Parties to the Chemical Weapons Convention. IIY. Mr Ban K i-tn0l)l1 Sccrdary-Gcncral ol"the United Nations United Nations llcadquartcrs New York l:>rs(olf/vof ORGANISATION FOR THE PROHIBITION OF CHEMICAL WEAPONS Dirutor-General OPCW The Hague, 18 December 2014 Johan de Witdaan 32 1./0DG/195480/14 2517 )R The Hague The Netherlands Telephone: + 31 ( o )70 416 37 02/04 Fax:+ 31 (0)70 416 37 92 E-mail: [email protected] Excellency, I have the honour to transmit to you the Third Report of the Organisation for the Prohibiti on of Chemical Weapons Fact-Finding Mission in Syria. As you know the Mission was mandated tc• establish the facts swTounding allegati ons of the usc of toxic chemicals, reportedly chi mine, f(>r hostile purposes in the Syrian Arab Republic. This report \vil1 be circulated today in The Hague to States Parties to the Chemical Weapons Convention. Please accept, i:�xce!lency, the assurances of my highestw consideration.�� fi� , .. .. �V/I . 11.8. Mr Ban Ki-moon ori-CJ. GI Secretary-General of the United Nations ll/� !'l 1 5 ":)'f, United Nations Headquarters --�---�-:-::::----, 14 -- � (., ;Jt2J New York . H E CEl\JED :r� ·, ·;�\-· ·� ; J .. :/� �,_,.J :lJ � OPCW Technical Secretariat Officeof the Director-General S/1230/2014 18 December 2014 Original: ENGLISH NOTE BY THE TECHNICAL SECRETARIAT THIRD REPORT OF THE OPCW FACT-FINDING MISSION IN SYRIA 1. On 29 April 2014, the Director-General announced the creation of an OPCW Fact-Finding Mission in Syria (hereinafter "the Mission"). The Mission was mandated to establish the facts surrounding allegations of the use of toxic chemicals, reportedly chlorine, for hostile purposesin the Syrian Arab Republic. 2. The Mission submitted its summary report covering the period from 3 to 31 May 2014 on 16 June 2014 (S/1 191/2014, dated 16 June 2014) and its second report on 10 September 2014 (S/1212/20 14, dated 10 September 2014). Both reports were circulated to the States Parties. 3. The third report of the Mission is hereby circulated to the States Parties. This report provides a more detailed account of the work undertaken by the Mission in the second phase and the process leading to the findings presented in its second report regarding the use of chlorine fo r hostile purposes. The Mission has presented its conclusions with a high degree of confidencethat chlorine has been used as a weapon. The work of the Mission has remained consistent with its mandate, which did not include the question of attributing responsibility fo r the alleged use. Based on the available information, the Mission has completed its work with regard to the allegations of the use of chlorine in the villages of Talmenes, Al Tamanah, and KafrZi ta. 4. The Director-General should also like to advise the States Parties that the Syrian Arab Republic, through a letter dated 15 December 2014, has informed him that some documents providing information on the allegations of use of chlorine in the Syrian Arab Republic would be delivered soon. Once these documents are received, they will be examined by the Mission and the outcome of the examination will be circulated to the States Parties. Annexes: Annex 1 : Cover Note by the Head of the OPCW Fact-Finding Mission in Syria Annex 2: Third Report of the OPCW Fact-Finding Mission in Syria CS-2014-9000(E) distributed 18/12/2014 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 ....... ' S/1230/2014 Annex 1 page 2 Annex 1 COVER NOTE BY THE HEAD OF THE OPCW FACT-FINDING MISSION IN SYRIA 17 December 2014 Director-G eneral, In continuation of the Second Report of the Fact-Finding Mission (FFM) in Syria, dated 10 September 2014, I submit herewith the third report of the FFM. Malik Ellahi Head of the FFM S/1230/2014 Annex 2 page 3 Annex 2 THIRD REPORT OF THE OPCW FACT-FINDING MISSION IN SYRIA 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 This report, while chronologically the third of the OPCW Fact-Finding Mission in Syria (hereinafter "the Mission"), is essentially an expansion of the second report issued in September 2014, presented in support of its key findings. 1.2 The first report issued in June 2014 detailed, inter alia, the genesis of the Mission, its objectives and purposes, and its mandate. That report also covered the extensive discussions with the Government of the Syrian Arab Republic in early May 2014, as well as the Government's views. Under the terms of reference agreed with the Syrian Arab Republic, for locations of interest to the Mission that were not under Government control, the Mission was to make its own arrangements fo r conducting on-site activities as part of its work. These anticipated activities included interviewing witnesses from the areas that were allegedly attacked with a toxic chemical believed to be chlorine. Subsequently, with access to any of the areas virtually ruled out as a result of the armed attack on the Mission convoy on 27 May 2014, the Mission, which despite the known challenges was asked to continue its work by general consent of the States Parties, fo llowed up its work by bringing witnesses to a safe location outside the Syrian Arab Republic. 1.3 This report details witness examinations and the accounts of incidents emerging therefrom. It also provides samples of the kind of supporting documents and data that were acquired. It highlights the serious constraints of conducting an inquiry of this nature in a conflictzo ne. 1.4 Despite these issues, the key findings presented in the second report fo llow the application of widely used and established methods of inquiry, which this third report will serve to highlight. 1.5 The witnesses from the three villages of Talmenes, Al Tamanah and KafrZita include 2 casualties, 1 family members of victims, first responders, nurses, and treating physicians. 1.6 In establishing that chlorine has been used as a weapon, the Mission was able to cross-check information available from publicly accessible sources with information that it acquired independently, including video recordings; these collections of information and data are in harmony with the descriptions and characterisations provided by the interviewed witnesses. 1.7 The signs and symptoms described and documented are typical of the chemical effects of exposure to pulmonary irritants. The severity of symptoms varied and depended on Casualty = a person who has survived an alleged exposure to a toxic chemical and may display clinical features consistent with the physiological effects of toxic chemicals. 2 Victim= a person who may have been exposed to a lethal dose of toxic chemical. S/1230/20 14 Annex 2 page 4 a number of factors, such as the concentration of the toxic gas, the duration of exposure, the age of the victim, and the time medical treatment was received. 1.8 The casualties, of which there was a large number, turned to the nearest medical points/field hospitals in their village or neighbourhood. Different means of transportation were used and other hospitals became involved, as the immediate medical points did not have the capacity to treat the number of patients showing up. The fieldhospitals in the conflict area are poorly equipped and staffe d and are unable to provide the advanced treatment required by the number of persons severely exposed. Such persons were often sent to other hospitals, including out-of-country facilities. The lack of protection, severe exposure, absence of proper treatment, and prolonged medical evacuation to higher medical echelons led to a number of fatalities. Of the 350 to 500 casualties reported by the witnesses, 13 died, either at the place of the attack or shortly thereafter, or on the way to the next hospital or a few days later, despite receiving advanced medical treatment. These victims presented acute lung injuries induced by toxic gases fo llowed by pulmonary oedema. 1.9 As the report shows, witnesses also described the fe atures of the munitions, and the unusual and striking characteristics of the damage, including environmental consequences and effects on livestock, vegetation, and household goods and materials. They also described the gas, its dissipation in the open air, and its lingering inside houses fo r days on end. 1.10 Insofar as these three villages are concerned, the Mission believes that its work has now been concluded. However, the Mission could consider supplementary information which may be obtained from other sources. Furthermore, as requested in May 2014 and as subsequently communicated by the Director-General, the Mission remains open to reflectany substantive information that the Syrian Arab Republic will provide. 2. CHALLENGES AND CONSTRAINTS 2.1 The Mission faced a number of challenges in its endeavour to collect facts relating to the allegations of use of toxic chemicals in the conflict in the Syrian Arab Republic.