Personal Touches, Public Legacies: an Ethnography of Lgbt Libraries and Archives
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PERSONAL TOUCHES, PUBLIC LEGACIES: AN ETHNOGRAPHY OF LGBT LIBRARIES AND ARCHIVES DANIELLE COOPER A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY GRADUATE PROGRAM IN GENDER, FEMINIST AND WOMEN’S STUDIES YORK UNIVERSITY TORONTO, ONTARIO NOVEMBER 2016 © DANIELLE COOPER, 2016 ii ABSTRACT Personal touches, Public legacies: An ethnography of LGBT libraries and archives examines lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) information organizations in Vancouver, Canada and surrounding areas. In order to develop a deeper understanding of the diversity in, changes to and challenges for LGBT information organizations, a multi-sited ethnography was conducted between June and September 2014. Organizations featured in the study include: two autonomous LGBT information organizations (the BC Lesbian and Gay Archives and Out on the Shelves Library), two LGBT information organizations founded within universities (the Archives of Lesbian Oral Testimony at Simon Fraser University, the Transgender Archives at the University of Victoria), an LGBT-focused collection within Vancouver’s public municipal cultural milieu (the Ken Brock collection at the City of Vancouver Archives and the Museum of Vancouver) and, a temporary, autonomous home library with a queer mandate (the STAG Library). This study puts feminist, LGBT and queer studies in dialogue with archival studies and library and information studies (LIS). The chapters are organized by overarching themes associated with information organizations and address specific theoretical discussions that accompany those themes: location (Chapter 2), collection development (Chapter 3), organization and dissemination (Chapter 4) and mandate (Chapter 5). The findings not only explore how LGBT information collections and organizations interrogate and reimagine the definitional boundaries of what constitutes an information collection and information organizations more broadly but also examine how concepts of gender, sexuality and queerness are understood in the realm of the information organizations under study. The divide between normative and non-normative information collection and organizational practice is not simple or stable, but, like the concept of queer, is ever shifting. The findings demonstrate that queer information organizing persists in LGBT information organizational contexts, but not in ways necessarily anticipated by existing literature on the topic. This study also highlights how the relationship between the LGBT communities and the public is in great flux as some LGBT communities become increasingly considered a part of the mainstream public. It is precisely this oscillation and tension between concepts of the personal and the public that define LGBT information organizing activities in this current moment. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Ethnography is in essence a collective endeavor and I am thankful for all of those who took part in its co-creation, formally and informally. The THEN/HiER (The History Education Network/Histoire et Éducation en Réseau) Visiting Doctoral Student Award funded an inaugural visit to Vancouver and Victoria that laid the groundwork for my dissertation proposal. The Ontario Graduate Scholarship and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council Doctoral Fellowship generously funded this research. York University’s fieldwork cost fund and Susan Mann Dissertation Scholarship also supported my research and writing. Over the course of conducting my research, I had the opportunity to learn from so many different people working within the context of LGBT information organizing. Ron Dutton regularly welcomed me into his home/archives, and he worked with me tirelessly throughout. I hope my work serves as a testimony to Ron’s lifelong dedication to the LGBT community. Gabriel Saloman and Aja Rose Bond welcomed me into their home/library as well, and I am so grateful for their creative energies and all the dynamic work they do. Ken Brock generously provided his time and insight into his rich personal collection and Viviane Gosselin at the Museum of Vancouver played a key role in introducing me to him. Aaron Devor and Lara Wilson at the Transgender Archives and Elise Chenier at the Archives of Lesbian Oral Testimony took the time to talk and share their important work on these groundbreaking collections. Nailisa Tanner at the Archives of Lesbian Oral Testimony not only provided key insights into that organization but also, and perhaps even more crucially, showed me the point where friendship and ethnography can productively meet. I am also thankful to the patrons and volunteers at the BC Gay and Lesbian Archives, the STAG Library, and Out on the Shelves Library for sharing their unique perspectives and experiences. A group of incredible scholars guided this project. My supervisor, David Murray, provided that perfect mixture of support and critical input at every juncture that ensured that my project could flourish. David showed me how to be the kind of ethnographer I aspire to be: one who carefully and thoughtfully balances one’s own perspectives with those being studied. Allyson Mitchell brought a creative perspective as a scholar and artist that this project truly needed and her artistic practice has been hugely informative in how I think about the intersection of cultural production, politics and space. Jacinthe Michaud introduced me a wealth of theories of and perspectives on feminism and social movements, and her ongoing support and enthusiasm has nurtured this project since its earliest stages. Outside of my committee, Jenna Hartel has been a significant mentor throughout my career—she is why I am an ethnographer and she taught me the power of following “the red thread of information” throughout my work. Marc Stein provided invaluable insight in this project’s earlier stages and I am also grateful to Nick Mulé, Kate Eichhorn and Shannon Bell for their generous participation in my defense. My family and friends provided endless support. Ela Przybylo and Sara Rodrigues bolstered me throughout the entire PhD process with their friendship and collegiality. Sara also provided excellent professional copyediting services. Lifelong friend Dasha Kornienko turned “the field” of Vancouver into home. This project would not exist without the unlimited patience and support of my partner Ariel Leutheusser. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT...................................................................................................................... II ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ...........................................................................................III TABLE OF CONTENTS ...............................................................................................IV LIST OF FIGURES........................................................................................................VI LIST OF ACRONYMS ................................................................................................ VII CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCING LGBT LIBRARIES AND ARCHIVES............. 1 On the Move ................................................................................................................... 1 Defining LGBT and LGBT Libraries and Archives....................................................... 7 Theorizing at the Intersection of LGBT Communities and Organizations................... 11 Methods for Examining LGBT Information Organizations ......................................... 17 Chapter Outlines ........................................................................................................... 26 CHAPTER TWO: SEMI-PUBLIC HOME LIBRARIES AND ARCHIVES........... 30 Always Take Your Books............................................................................................. 30 Public, Semi-Public ...................................................................................................... 33 A Necessity for Community Engagement .................................................................... 37 Sheltering Information and Ideas.................................................................................. 43 Fires, Floods and Death ................................................................................................ 48 House Proud.................................................................................................................. 56 Conclusion .................................................................................................................... 63 CHAPTER THREE: CONSTRUCTING THE SELF THROUGH PERSONAL COLLECTION ............................................................................................................... 67 A Gay Man’s Shoes in the Museum of Vancouver ...................................................... 67 Ken’s Collection in Vancouver..................................................................................... 71 Documentation with a Personal Touch......................................................................... 74 Documentation as Self-Healing .................................................................................... 79 Self-Documentation as Legacy..................................................................................... 85 Conclusion .................................................................................................................... 92 CHAPTER FOUR: INFORMATION ORGANIZATION AND DISSEMINATION IN A CONTEXT OF NON-DIGITAL PERSISTENCE ............................................