The Identity of African Christians
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Bengt Sundkler, Christopher Steed. The History of the Church in Africa. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000. xviii + 1232 pp. $140.00, cloth, ISBN 978-0-521-58342-8. Reviewed by Isabel Mukonyora Published on H-SAfrica (May, 2001) 'THE IDENTITY OF AFRICAN CHRISTIANS' 8-9), is used to make a strong point about the Readers will like this book a lot because its claim that Christianity is as traditional to Africa as aim is to challenge westerners to think about it is to the western world. Christianity as a religion of Africa in which As I found when teaching a course on Chris‐ African have always taken part in the spread tianity in Africa at the University of Zimbabwe, thereof. As far as Sundkler is concerned it is prob‐ Donatists are a lot easier to accept as Africans lematic to think that European missionaries were than the Early Church Fathers of North Africa. Do‐ vital to the spread of Christianity in Africa. This is natists were not as cosmopolitan in outlook as the partially true, but extremely important to grasp. master of hellenization, Origen at the School of In today's world, this voluminous book makes Alexandria in the second century, or the well-trav‐ good reading for anyone serious about knowing eled intellectual St Augustine who was baptized African history. into Christianity in a far away Rome before he NORTH AFRICAN INTELLECTUALS AND came back to Africa to settle in Hippo. As a move‐ KINGS ment of Berber origin, Donatists distinguished themselves in North African Church history by The most interesting aspect of this book lies staging a rebellion against the imperial state in in the effort made to challenge Europeans into re‐ the name of Christian orthodoxy understood by thinking their role in spreading Christianity in them to separate the Church as a community for Africa. From the outset, Sundkler and Steed focus the Holy from the institutions of the imperial gov‐ on the role of African Christians in shaping their ernment that were considered corrupt, oppres‐ understanding of the belief system in North sive and certainly not worth giving honor through Africa from the frst century onwards. The exis‐ the worship of the Emperor (pp. 22-41). African tence of a Coptic Church that is indigenous to students living in neo-colonial societies can prob‐ North Africa and claims to be founded on the ably identify with the Donatists as African Chris‐ teaching of St. Mark, one of the gospel writers (pp. H-Net Reviews tians in the face of an imperial power responsible is unmistakable. Sundkler observes that St. Augus‐ for their persecution. tine considered Punic "an honorable part of his Among the other wonders of this book that native heritage" and chose it 'to explain biblical are widely known among Africanists but never‐ words' (p. 26). The news that St Augustine of Hip‐ theless important to mention in a book aimed at po had a high regard for Punic as his mother persuading us to think of Christianity as an tongue is bound to raise eyebrows among western African phenomenon is the discussion on the roy‐ theologians already fnding it hard to accept that alty of Ethiopia. Christianity was introduced to Augustine, Tertullian, and Cyprian were African the royal courts of Aksum through the consecra‐ (pp. 22-41). tion of Frumentius as Bishop of Aksum. This was Sundkler even tries his hand at theology by done by Bishop Athanasius as head of the Church pointing to what he calls the 'Unionite' doctrine of in Alexandria between AD328 and 378 (pp. 12, 35). Christ, otherwise known as monophytisism. This, This led King Ezana of Aksum to embrace Chris‐ Sundkler maintains, is a distinct African view of tianity and declare it a state religion to mark the Christ as a divine being. Since the statement of beginning of a long legacy of dynasties of confess‐ Chalcedon in AD 329, Christian orthodoxy insists ing Christians (pp. 150-168). Readers who are not on affirming the full humanity and full divinity of familiar with early Christianity in Africa might Christ. But, the African Christians in the Coptic find it an amazing testimony to the permanence Church of Egypt and Ethiopia reason about Christ of Christianity in Africa to hear of an African King their own way. For them Jesus Christ could only in Ethiopia making Christianity a state religion at have been of one nature and that was a divine na‐ the same time as Constantine in the fourth centu‐ ture ftting of the only Son of God (p. 16). The ry Roman Empire (pp. 35-38). So it seems to be the Ethiopian delegation withdrew from Chalcedon case for Sundkler that from early Christianity in and left western Christian orthodoxy with the Africa, when royalty fnds for itself a family reli‐ perennial problem of having to try and explain gion, it expects the subjects to follow (passim). how someone who shares fully in our humanity The matters for discussion go deeper. Sund‐ has also a perfect divine nature from eternity. It kler claims for Africa the theologians of North does not matter to Sundkler that the Christologi‐ Africa such as, Tertullian, Augustine, Athanasius cal formula that the Ethiopian Christians uphold and others. These are widely known theologians to this day was dismissed as a heresy. The impor‐ providing us with enough material to read for tant point is that Africans had their own way of weeks. Sundkler claims them for Africa without reflecting on the identity of Christ as the focus of necessarily getting us lost in the deep theological their faith. arguments that usually go with the mention of African theologians Kwame Bediako, John these reputable men. As for the Hellenism, well, it Mbiti and others would welcome the detailed way appears to be taken for granted as a phenomenon in which Sundkler writes about Christianity with that was pervasive in the Greco-Roman world African agency as a main theme. Over ffty years wherever it extended. Alexandria and Carthage ago, Mbiti became well known among African in‐ happened to be important areas of trade and with tellectuals for questioning the European assump‐ it came many Greek influences upon the indige‐ tion that Africans were ignorant of God before Eu‐ nous people who reflect this in their literary ropeans brought the Gospel. Mbiti claimed that works. Despite this, St. Augustine, widely known Christianity in North Africa during the Greco-Ro‐ as the patron of western orthodox theology, is man Empire is part of African history and the tra‐ portrayed in such a way that his African identity ditional African culture beyond the borders of the 2 H-Net Reviews Empire shows many continuities of belief with The latter are anxious to have their tradition‐ Christianity. Since then, Pobee, Kwesi Dickson, al cultures given the respect they have always de‐ Nyamiti, Sanneh and others have gone to great served by drawing out the areas of continuity be‐ lengths to show that African religious idioms can tween past and present religions. In Sundkler's be used to explain key doctrines of the Christian case, more attention is paid instead to the fact faith to an African audience. Names of high gods, that Europeans did in fact contribute in a signifi‐ images of chiefs and ancestors have been used to cant way to the spread of the new religion of characterize the modern subject of African Theol‐ Christianity in Africa beyond the Sahara desert ogy. Bediako followed the footsteps of Mbiti and through a missionary enterprise that recognize maintained that the Church Fathers from early the importance of African evangelism. Plagued by Christianity such as, St. Augustine, Cyril of Alexan‐ diseases leading to a high death rate, European dria, Tertullian, and Origen etc. are patrons of missionaries soldiered on to ensure that Africans African theology (Bediako, 1992). where touched by the gospels (passim). The re‐ As indicated above, Sundkler would agree peated references to missionary bodies from Eu‐ with this to some extent. At least, the detailed rope and America such as Methodists, Presbyteri‐ notes about Christian witness throughout North ans from Scotland, Anglicans, Catholics, Baptists, Africa, down the Nile leading to Ethiopia by the Salvation Army and so on make it difficult to Africans suggest the emergence of African theo‐ appreciate the indigenous character of Christiani‐ logical thought to go with the history of the ty that Sundkler is trying to help us to understand. spread of Christianity on the continent. What the THE CONQUEST OF WEST, CENTRAL, EAST African theologians do, and Sundkler avoids, is to AFRICA AND BEYOND go further to show the extent to which the pre- Sundkler tries very hard, nevertheless, to Christian African religions found in areas remote show the active participation of Africans in the to North Africa in Sub-Sahara Africa are prepara‐ conversion of fellow Africans. Even in giving an tio evangelica. For Mbiti, it is very important to account of the ways in which Europeans spread recognize that even though Christianity was pre‐ Christianity among Africans as subjects of con‐ sented to many Africans in European dress, it was quista (pp. 44-45), he is quick to identify Africans not new insofar as the concepts that missionaries who took up positions of leadership in the church, believed themselves to be introducing anew were especially authority fgures such as Kings and found in the African religions. Hence, the names chiefs. He also makes a point of drawing attention for the Judaeo-Christian God have today been tak‐ to any evidence suggesting that Europeans some‐ en from names of the high god in the various times encountered African people who were in‐ African religions.