NATO UNCLASSIFIED and PUBLIC
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
NATO NATO UNCLASSIFIED and Copy No. PUBLIC DISCLOSED NORTH ATLANTIC COU NCI .L ... SEVENTH S ES S. I P.3-g r> CONSEIL DE L'ATLANTIQUE NORD. SEPTIEME SESSION SECRET SUMMARY RECORD 07^2" 0R„ E1NG;. 7 16 September, 1951 Summary Record of the SocondMeetin^ held at the Parliament Buildings, Ottawai, on Saturday, 15th Septemberi, 1951 at _3 PRESENT : M. Paul van Zeeland (Belgium); Chairman BELGIUM M. Jean van Houtte (Minister of Finance) Colonel B.E.M. Etienne de C-reef (Minister of National Defence) M. Fernand van Langenhove• (Council Deputy) CANADA The Hon. L.B. Pearson (Secretary of State for External Affairs) The Hon. Brooke CIaxton, K.C. (Minister of National Defence ) The Hon. D.C. Abbott, K.C. (Minister of Finance) Mr. Dana Wilgress (Council Deputy) DENMARK ^''Mr. Ole Pjprn Kraft (Minister for Foreign Affairs) Mr. Thorkil Kristensen (Minister of Finance) Admiral E.J.C. Qvistgaard (Chief of National Defence ) Mr. V. de : Steensen-Leth (Council Deputy) FRANCE S.S. M. Robert Schuinan (Minister for Foreign Affairs) M. Rens Mayer (Minister of Finance ) M. Georges Bidault (Minister . of' National-Defence ) DECLASSIFIED - PUBLIC DISCLOSURE / DÉCLASSIFIÉ - MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE LECTURE EN - MISE / DÉCLASSIFIÉ DISCLOSURE - PUBLIC DECLASSIFIED S. E. ' M. "'Herve Alphand (Council Deputy) ICELAND Mr. Thor Thors- (Minister for Canada)- Mr, G. Petursson (Council Deputy) ITALY The Hon. Alcide De Gasperi (Prime Minister, Minister for. Foreign Affairs) ( Ttie Hon. Guiseppe Pella (Minister of Budget) The Hon. Randolfo Pacclardi (Minister of Defence) Signor Alberto Rossi Longhi (Council Deputy) U.) SUMMARY RECORD Ç7-R/2 LUXEMBOURG $¢. P • Dupong (Prime Minister and Minister of Finance ) M. A. Clasen (Council Deputyl NETHERLANDS Dr. D.U. Stikker (Minister for Foreign Affairs) Mr. C. Staf (Minister, of Defence) Prof, Dr. P. Lieftinck (Minister of Finance) Prof, pi», J.R.M, van den Brink (Minister for Economic Affairs) Jonkheer A.W.L. Tjarda van Starkenborgh Stachouwer (Council Deputy) NORWAY Mr, Halvard Lange (Foreign Minister) Mr. Jens Chr. Hâuge (Minister of Defence) ,Mr. Erik Brofoss (Minister of Trade) Mr. Dag Bryn (Council Deputy) PORTUGAL Dr. Joao Pinto da Costa Lëite (Minister for the Presidency . ' - Deputy Prime Minister) Dr. Paula Cunha (Minister for Foreign Affairs) Dr. Ruy Ennes Ulrich (Council Deputy) UNITED KINGDOM The Rt. Hon. Herbert Morrison, (Secretary of State for Foreign M.P. Affairs) The Rt. Hon. Emmanuel Shinwe11, (Minister of Defence) M.P. The Rt. Hon. Hugh Gaitskellj M.P. (Chancellor of the Exchequor) Sir Frederick Hoyer-Millar, (Council Deputy) K.C.M.G., C.V.O. UNITED STATES The Hon. Dean Acheson (Secretary of State.) The Hon. John Snyder (Secretary of Treasury) The Hon. Frank H. Pace, Jr. (Secretary of the Army) The Hon. Charles M. Spofford (Chairman, Council Deputies) ALSO PRESENT DECLASSIFIED - PUBLIC DISCLOSURE / DÉCLASSIFIÉ - MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE LECTURE EN - MISE / DÉCLASSIFIÉ DISCLOSURE - PUBLIC DECLASSIFIED General P. Ely (Standing Group) Vice Admiral Jerauld Wright (Standing Group) Air Chief Marshal Elliot (Standing Group) M. H." Janne. (Chairman, Defence Production Board) Mr. W.R, Herod (Coordinator, Defence Production Board) M. Leroy Beaulieu (Chairman, Financial & Economic Board) Mr. N.E.P. Sutton (Executive Secretary, International Staff) SECRETARIAT M. R.P. Featy Mr. P.P. Roome CONTENTS Item No. Subject I . Openining address by the Chairman II Adoption of the Agenda III Exchange of views on the World Situation DECLASSIFIED - PUBLIC DISCLOSURE / DÉCLASSIFIÉ - MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE LECTURE EN - MISE / DÉCLASSIFIÉ DISCLOSURE - PUBLIC DECLASSIFIED SECRET •SUMMARY RECORD C7-R/2 ~ I. OPENING- ADDRESS BY THE CHAIRMAN 1. THE CHAIRMAN began by paying a tribute to the work done by the Council Deputies; and in particular their Chairman, Mr. Spofford; it was they who had given the Organisation a kind bf permanent•character, a nd their day to day action was of the greatest value to NATO, Yet the Council Deputies could not fulfil the functions proper to the Atlantic Council at the fninisterial level; and therefore Governments must meet periodically to give directives and to take decisions on political problems which the Deputies or technical' experts could not be expected to solve. For that reason, among others, he hoped that • Council Meetings on the ministerial level would be held in future- more frequently and at more regular intervals:. 3 or 4 times a year, for example. At the same time, it would be desirable to strengthen the powers of the Council Deputies and to widen the frame "work within v/hieh they hod powers of'decision. Thct would help to save time, and to save time was vital, ; 2, The importance of the time factor led him to advocate empirical solutions to certain problems which had perhaps been tackled in-the past months too often from the purely theoretical point of view. The sharing of infrastructure costs was a case in point, A solution of an empirical kind in cases like these could ,sometimes be reached which, while satisfying no one completely, would at least" make further progress possible»- 5, That was the . spirit which he would' like to see applied to certain aspects, of their work, and. he was thinking in particular of the expansion of arms production in Europe, where orders had to be given In some cases as much as 2 years before the date of .delivery here the importance of the time factor could hardly be overestimated, 4, The tasks with which NATO was faced were of exceptional magnitude, but they could be overcome: the whole world was looking towards NATO with hope, and NATO need not doubt the final success pf its efforts. The great achievement of just over a week ago - the signature by 48 sovereign nations of a Peace Treaty with Japan - éhowed^what could be done when a policy inspired by the "NATO principles of respect for right, for justice and for reconciliation was pursued clearly and firmly, 5. Finally, he was sure that none of them doubted that the present session, .like'earlier sessions, would mark an important stage along the path which would in the end enable DECLASSIFIED - PUBLIC DISCLOSURE / DÉCLASSIFIÉ - MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE LECTURE EN - MISE / DÉCLASSIFIÉ DISCLOSURE - PUBLIC DECLASSIFIED the whole world to feel free from aggression. • II. ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA 6± MR., ACHESON (UNITED STATES)- said that his Government; •attached great importance to item' VI on the- Agenda (Future Pevelopment of NATO, other than in connection with defence plans). The item appeared rather late In the Agenda, and his Government feared that if it could only be discussed towards the end of a busy session, there might be a danger of hasty conclusions being reached which might afterwards be regretted. He therefore proposed that after the discussion on item III there should be a brief discussion on item VI, at which point he would suggest that a Committee bo set up to prepare recommendations for examination when item VI was discussed at greater length later in the session. 7. THE COUNCIL; Approved the Agenda, subject_to the modification suggested by Mri Acheson. III. EXCHANGE OF VIEWS ON THE WORLD SITUATION 8. MR. PEARSON (CANADA) agreed with the Chairman in his opening statement that it would be desirable, and hoped that it. would be feasible, to hold Council Meeting's more regularly and perhaps more frequently than hitherto; a minimum of 3 regular meetings annually, for example. This would have the following advantages: (a) It would make it easier to plan efficiently the- work of the Council. (b) It would avoid in the public mind the impression that the Council met only to deal with emergencies instead of being what they hoped, it was becoming, a permanent and regular institution for the ord.erIy development and defence of the Atlantic community. (c) Regular meetings would give rise to less expectation of dramatic decisions emerging'from each session, and the Council would tend to be accepted. • as the normal agency for cooperation and discussion between its members. He did not imagine that it would be possible or necessary for all the Ministers responsible for foreign affairs, defence and finance to meet three times a year. Representation Governments would depend on the nature o.f the business to be discussed and the special circumstances prevailing in each country. 9. Turning to the international situation, in the Canadian view there had been little, If any, general Improvement, and no easing of world tension since the last Council Meeting. Vfcile it was true that morale in the .North Atlantic countries was higher, in the Far East the aggressive forces of Communist imperialism remained as militant and defiant as ever, while in Vlfestern .Europe itself economic and social difficulties remained DECLASSIFIED - PUBLIC DISCLOSURE / DÉCLASSIFIÉ - MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE LECTURE EN - MISE / DÉCLASSIFIÉ DISCLOSURE - PUBLIC DECLASSIFIED ja constant threat to stability, and one which the forces of Soviet Imperialism were exploiting, and would continue to exploit to. the limit. Further,- if the strictly military picture had Improved somewhat, that, he thought, was due to the realisation by any country tempted to break the peace that the North Atlantic countries stood together in resistance to any such aggression, and that the ground on which they stood was getting firmer. " The moral to be drawn from this was that they should not slacken their efforts, but should, go forward steadily and with determination to complete the job of making themselves stronger. 10. There were, however, two types of aggression to be feared: military aggression expressing itself in armed action, and social and. economic aggression expressing itself through the subversive activities of international Communism acting as the spearhead of Soviet imperialism. The military weakness of the E • • 3 NATO countries by comparison with the strength of the -Soviet armed forces was a standing temptation to Soviet attack, and they must keep working to remove that temptation.