And Dianionic Carbaborane Ligands and Their Transition Metal Complexes
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Mono- and Dianionic Carbaborane Ligands and Their Transition Metal Complexes Ewan J. M. Hamilton Thesis Presented for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Edinburgh 1990 Declaration Except where specific reference is made to other sources, the work presented in this thesis is the original work of the author. It has not been submitted, in whole or in part, for any other degree. Certain of the results have been published, or have been accepted for publication (see Appendix 2). Ewan J. M. Hamilton U Dedicated to my parents and family for their unfailing support. 'U I devoted a day to a coarse sifting of the chicken shit, and another two trying to oxidize the acid contained in it into alloxan. The virtue and patience of ancient chemists must have been superhuman, or perhaps my inexperience with organic preparations was boundless. All I got were foul vapors, boredom, humiliation, and a black and murky liquid which irremediably plugged up the filters and displayed no tendency to crystallize, as the text declared it should. The shit remained shit, and the alloxan and its resonant name remained a resonant name. That was not the way to get out of the swamps: by what path would I therefore get out, I the discouraged author of a book which seemed good to me but which nobody read? Best to return among the colorless but safe schemes of inorganic chemistry. Primo Levi, from The Periodic Table Iv Acknowledgements First and foremost, I would like to thank my supervisor, Dr. Alan Welch, without whose assistance, encouragement, enthusiasm and optimism this work could not have been done. Thanks are also due to John Millar, Heather Grant and Dr. David Reed, who obtained n.m.r. spectra, and Elaine M'Dougall, who performed the elemental analyses. The help of Dr. Ruth Sorbie and Ken Taylor was invaluable in obtaining and interpreting electrochemical and spectroelecirochemical data. Assistance and encouragement have always been readily forthcoming from those who have worked over the years in laboratories 290-293, and although space limits a full "roll of honour" here, all help and advice has been greatly appreciated. Finally, thanks are due to the University of Edinburgh for the use of facilities and to S.E.R.C. for financial support. V Abstract Chapter 1 consists of a brief overview of transition metal cyclopentadienyl chemistry and of the chemistry of carbametailaborane species derived from [7,8-nido-C2B9H11 ]2 , with specific reference to the bonding modes commonly adopted by each ligand to transition metal fragments. The forms of the it-MO's of [C5H5], [C2B9H 11]2 and of the monoanionic ligand [9-SMe2-7,8-C2B9H10} (or [carb'] ), as obtained by extended Huckel molecular orbital (EHMO) calculations, are also presented. In Chapter 2, the structure of [7,8-C2B9H 12], (1), is presented, showing an endo -H atom, rather than the commonly accepted ji-H, associated with the open ligand face.This result is supported by those of n.m.r. and theoretical studies. Isolobal replacement of the endo-terminal hydrogen atom by a fPPh 3Au) fragment leads to complex (2), [10-endo-(PPh 3Au)-7,8-nido-C2B9H 11 ], which has also been studied crystallographically. Structural trends within the series (1), (2) and [PPh3Cu(C2B9H11)] have been rationalised via the results of EHMO calculations. Chapter 3 presents the structure of [10,1 1-i-H-9-SMe 2-7,8-nido-C2B9H10], (3)1 the protonated precursor to the monoanionic ligand [carb']. The molecule possesses an asymmetric bridging H atom on its open face, a structural feature whose origin may be traced using MO calculations at the extended Huckel level. The (triphenyiphosphine) gold(I) and (triphenylphosphine)copper(I) derivatives of [carb'], (4) and(S), have been prepared, and their structures determined by X-ray methods. In all three compounds, the SMe 2 substituent appears to adopt a preferred conformation, and it is suggested that this is allied to an intramolecular electrostatic interaction. Analysis of structural patterns within (3), (4) and (5) reveals different trends to those observed for the related series in the previous chapter. These differences may be rationalised by frontier MO considerations. vi Chapter 4 comprises a comparative structural, spectral and theoretical study of the analogous complexes (carb')Mn(CO) 3 , (6), and CpMn(CO) 3 , (7). The net electronic properties of the anionic ligands in the two complexes are shown to be highly similar, by consideration of infra-red carbonyl stretching frequencies and C-O distances determined by X-ray experiments. Extended Huckel and extended Huckel/fragment MO calculations suggest that the very slightly lower v 0 observed for (6) is a result of slightly greater e-donation into (primarily) the e acceptor orbitals of the (Mn(CO) 3 } fragment by the carbaborane ligand than by Cp. This results in limitation of a-donation by the carbonyl ligands, giving the slightly lower v 0 observed. Chapter 5 details the preparation of the bis(carb') analogue of ferrocene, Fe(carb')2, (8), and its structural characterisation as the E-isomer, where both (chiral) ligands are of the same optical isomer. The isomeric nature of (8) has been shown to be dependent on its method of preparation. Electrochemical work on Fe(carb') 2 again shows the net electron-donating properties of [carb'] to be comparable to those of Cp. (8) may also be readily oxidised chemically to give the 1 monocation. [Fe(carb') 2 ] . A second product, Fe(carb')(C2B9H 10SMe), (9), has also been isolated and its structure determined as the 0-isomer (where the two ligands are of opposite handedness). This, allied to the results of electrochemical studies, allow a mechanism for the formation of (9) to be proposed, involving loss of (Me) from [Fe(carb') 2]. Chapter 6 gives details of the experimental procedures leading to the results discussed in the body of the work, and comprises four sections: 1. Synthetic Methods and Spectral Data, 2. Crystallographic Techniques, 3. Molecular Orbital Calculations, and 4. Electrochemical and Spectroelectrochemical Techniques. VII Abbreviations AO atomic orbital BTMA benzyltrimethylammonium COSY correlation speciroscopy Cp cyclopentadienyl Cp* pentamethylcyclopentadienyl dmso dimethylsulphoxide EHMO extended Huckel molecular orbital EHMO/FMO extended Huckel/fragment molecular orbital e.s.d. estimated standard deviation Et ethyl eV electron volts Fc ferrocene FMO fragment molecular orbital HOMO highest occupied molecular orbital LCAO linear combination of atomic orbitals LUMO lowest unoccupied molecular orbital Me methyl MO molecular orbital n.m.r. nuclear magnetic resonance Ph phenyl p.p.m. parts per million PSEPT polyhedral skeletal electron pair theory SEP skeletal electron pair TBA tetra(n-butyl)ammonium THF tetrahydrofuran viii Abbreviations for Specific Complexes [7,8-nido-C2B9H121- [10-endo-(PPh3Au)-7,8-nido-C 2B9H1 i] [10,1 1-JL-H-9-SMe2-7,8-nido-C2B9Hi& [10,11 -J.L-(PPh3Au)-9-SMe2-7,8-nido-C2B9H1& [3-PPh3-4-SMe2-3, 1 ,2-CuC2B9H10] [3,3,3-(CO) 3-4-SMe2-3, 1 ,2-MnC2B9H rn' [(i-05H5)Mn(CO)3] [com,no-3,3'-Fe-4,4'-(SMe2)2- 1,1 ',2,2'-(C2B9H10)2] [com,no-3,3'-Fe-4-SMe2-4'-SMe- 1,1 ',2,2'-(C2B9H10)2] ix Contents Page Chapter 1: Introduction 1 Introduction 1 Chemistry of the Cyclopentadienyl Ligand 2 Carbametallaboranes: A Brief Introduction 11 Monoanionic Carbaboranes, [C2B9H10L] 19 Comparison of the it-MO's of [C 5H5]-, [C2B9H1 and [carb'] 20 Scope of the Work Presented 23 Chapter 2: [7,8-C2B9H12] and Group lb Derivatives 25 Introduction 25 Synthesis and Characterisation of [BTMA](1) 26 Synthesis and Characterisation of [drnsoH.dmso](1) 29 Structural Study of (1) 30 Synthesis and Characterisation of [BTMA](2) 43 Structural Study of (2) 45 Structural Patterns in (1), (2) and [PPh 3Cu(C2B9H11 )] - 55 Conclusions 64 Chapter 3: carb'H and Group lb Derivatives 65 [10,1 1-I.t-H-9-SMe2-7,8-nido-C2B9H1&, (3): Introduction 65 Structural Study of (3) 67 Deprotonation of (3) 81 Synthesis and Characterisation of (4) 83 Structural Study of (4) 84 Synthesis and Characterisation of (5) 94 Structural Study of (5) 95 Structural Patterns in (3), (4) and (5) 104 Conclusions 109 Chapter 4: (carb')Mn(CO) 3 versus CpMn(CO)3: A Comparative Study 110 Introduction 110 Synthesis and Characterisation of (6) 111 Structural Study of (6) 113 x Synthesis and Characterisation of (7) 122 Structural Study of (7) -. 122 Structural and Spectral Comparison between (6) and (7) 130 Electronic Structures of (6) and (7) 131 Conclusions 140 Chapter 5: The Bis(cage) Iron System 142 Introduction 142 Synthesis and Characterisation of (8) 142 Structural Study of (8) 144 Electrochemical Study of (8) 156 Chemical Oxidation of (8) 158 Spectroelectrochemical Study of (8) 160 Introduction to (9) 162 Synthesis and Characterisation of (9) 163 Structural Study of (9) 165 Electrochemical Study of (9) 182 Reaction of (9) with [Me30]BF4 183 Spectroelectrochemical Study of (9) 186 Conclusions 188 Chapter 6: Experimental 189 Introduction 189 Section 1: Synthetic Methods and Spectral Data 190 Section 2: Crystallographic Techniques 201 Section 3: Molecular Orbital Calculations 213 Section 4: Electrochemical and Spectroelectrochemical Techniques 221 References 227 Appendices 236 Appendix 1: Lectures and Courses Attended 237 Appendix 2: Published Work 238 xi Chapter 1 Introduction Since the inception of carhametallaborane (or metallacarborane) chemistry in 1.2 the mid-1960's there has been drawn an analogy between the IC13 9 11 1 (dicarhollide) ligand and the cyclopentadienide (IC5 H 5 1 or Cp) anion. A more recent modification of this analogy suggests that 1C2B 9 H 1 j may he better compared to the pentamethyl derivative of Cp, C 5 Me5 (or Cp*_), on account of its steric requirements.