Music and the Politics of Participation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Title Page AUDIBLE PUBLICS: POPULAR MUSIC AND THE POLITICS OF PARTICIPATION IN POSTCOLONIAL UGANDA by Charles Lwanga BA (Music), Makerere University, 2003 MA (Composition/Theory), Makerere University, 2006 Post-graduate Diploma in Education, Kyambogo University, 2006 Diploma in Law, Law Development Center, Kampala, Uganda, 2007 Doctor of Philosophy (Composition/Theory), University of Pittsburgh, 2012 Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of the Dietrich School of Arts and Sciences in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Pittsburgh 2020 Committee Page UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH DIETRICH SCHOOL OF ARTS AND SCIENCES This dissertation was presented by Charles Lwanga It was defended on March 2, 2020 and approved by Committee Member: Dr. Kofi Agawu, Ph. D, Professor of Music Committee Member: Dr. Shalini Ayyagari, Ph. D, Assistant Professor of Music Committee Member: Dr. Adriana Helbig, Ph. D, Associate Professor of Music Committee Member: Dr. Gavin Steingo, Ph. D, Associate Professor of Music Dissertation Advisor: Dr. Andrew Weintraub, Professor of Music ii Copyright © by Charles Lwanga 2020 iii Abstract AUDIBLE PUBLICS: POPULAR MUSIC AND THE POLITICS OF PARTICIPATION IN POSTCOLONIAL UGANDA Charles Lwanga, Ph. D University of Pittsburgh, 2020 This dissertation project is a historical and analytical examination of how popular music has participated in the transformation of Uganda’s public sphere into a more participatory space since the early 1990s. Popular music has rendered previously marginalized publics audible and visible. By marginalized, I refer to the trivialization of the social aspirations of collectivities by the state or the dominant public. By publics, I refer to collectivities that exchange information, debate ideas, and advocate for change in physical and virtual spaces. “Marginalized publics” are thus, collectivities identified by processes of sharing information, debating ideas, and advocating for social change. When president Yoweri Museveni and his National Resistance Army/Movement (NRA/M) took over power from General Tito Okello Lutwa in 1986, he promised fundamental change. Although Museveni has tried his best, most of his promises about change have not yet been delivered. Moreover, Museveni’s ruling National Resistance Movement (NRM) party has since the early 1990s, increasingly been hostile to the basic rights of assemblage, association and the freedom of expression. Ironically, the hostility of Museveni’s government has promoted rather than prevented the rise of multiple publics that are advocating for social change in the country. iv Drawing on fieldwork in Uganda’s capital, Kampala, this dissertation project examines the rise of popular music in rendering five marginalized publics audible: Buganda kingdom, the LGBT collectivity, the Kampala street laborers, Besigye’s “peoples’ government,” and Bobi Wine’s “people-power” public. I argue that the rise of marginalized publics was simultaneously enhanced by the return to relative (but precarious) peace in the early 1990s, the establishment of democratic organs such as the Uganda Human Rights Commission (UHRC) to act as a watch dog against human rights violations, as well as the liberalization (and privatization) of media in the country, which promoted more public avenues of participation (such as privately-owned radio and television stations, and the internet/social media). Through a music-cultural analytical lens, my dissertation project contributes to an understanding of power and representation among emergent democracies. It enriches the growing body of regional studies about music and its dynamic creation of cultural and historical meanings within particular social-cultural contexts. v TABLE OF CONTENTS PREFACE ................................................................................................................................. XIII 1.0 INTRODUCTION................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Theoretical Framework ................................................................................................. 8 1.1.1 Publics ...................................................................................................................9 1.1.2 Theorizing the Public Sphere in Postcolonial Africa ......................................16 1.1.3 Mediation and Heterogenous Actors ................................................................20 1.2 Audibility: “Epistemologies of Sonic Purification and Transculturation” ............. 22 1.3 A Brief History of Uganda Since Independence ........................................................ 23 1.3.1 Popular Music as an Arena of Participation ...................................................25 1.3.2 Defining Popular Music as a Political Tool in Uganda ...................................30 1.4 Rationale and Purpose of the Study ............................................................................ 35 1.5 Research Questions ...................................................................................................... 37 1.6 Scope of the Study ........................................................................................................ 38 1.7 Methodology .................................................................................................................. 39 2.0 SINGING THE REIGN: RECOLLECTING THE PAST, NEGOTIATING AN AUTONOMOUS BUGANDA ................................................................................... 49 2.1 The Politics and Philosophy of Autonomy in Buganda ............................................. 53 2.2 Buganda as an Audible Public ..................................................................................... 59 2.3 Paul Ssaaka and His Musical Career.......................................................................... 63 2.4 The Musical Anatomy of “Omulembe Omutebi” ...................................................... 65 2.4.1 The Plot and Its Construction of a Buganda Public .......................................76 vi 2.4.2 Multiple Interpretations of “Omulembe Omutebi” ........................................85 2.4.3 Visual Symbols in “Omulembe Omutebi” .......................................................89 2.5 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................... 92 3.0 “HANG THEM!” POPULAR MUSIC AND THE POLITICS OF BELONGING IN HOMOPHOBICUGANDA ....................................................................................... 95 3.1 Contestations Over Same-Sexuality in Postcolonial Uganda ................................... 99 3.2 The Emergent LGBT Public in Uganda ................................................................... 100 3.3 Queer Terminologies and Their Usage ..................................................................... 105 3.4 Living “Bare Lives?” .................................................................................................. 107 3.5 Belonging and the Politics of Belonging in Postcolonial Uganda ........................... 108 3.6 Into the Reality of ‘Bare Lives’ in Uganda .............................................................. 109 3.7 Stories of Same-sex Loving Individuals in Uganda ................................................. 110 3.7.1 Telling Their Stories ........................................................................................112 3.8 Jackie Chandiru .......................................................................................................... 116 3.9 The Schema of “Ikumabo” ........................................................................................ 117 3.9.1 The Verses of “Ikumabo” ................................................................................121 3.10 Levels of Inclusion in “Ikumabo” ........................................................................... 127 3.11 Conclusion ................................................................................................................. 130 4.0 “TELL JENNIFER ON OUR BEHALF”: VOICING THE STREET VENDORS, NEGOTIATING PARTICIPATORY SPACE IN KAMPALA………………….132 4.1 Bobi Wine, The “Ghetto President” ......................................................................... 133 4.2 An Emergent Public of Street Vendors in Kampala ............................................... 137 4.3 The Kampala Street Vendors and Their Social Struggles ...................................... 140 vii 4.4 Text and Music of “Tugambire ku Jennifer” .......................................................... 143 4.4.1 The Intro ...........................................................................................................147 4.4.2 The Refrain .......................................................................................................148 4.4.3 The Outro ..........................................................................................................150 4.4.4 The Audiovisual Assemblage of “Tugambire ku Jennifer” .........................151 4.5 Hearing Ears: Visible Change, Ongoing Negotiations ............................................ 154 4.6 Conclusion ................................................................................................................... 157 5.0 ‘TOKA KWA BARABARA” (CLEAR THE WAY): SINGING FOR CHANGE DURING UGANDA’S 2016 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTIONS ............................. 160 5.1 Music and Politics During