Lawyering at the Speed of Change

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Lawyering at the Speed of Change FALL 2019 LAWYERING AT THE SPEED OF CHANGE How Technology Is Changing Business Law plus Losing Labels, Reaching Potential Northwestern Mutual’s Ray Manista, L’90, on shifting course in order to grow ALSO INSIDE Lee Rosenthal on Holmes— and Ambition and Aspiration Today Denno and Triggiano on How Courts Handle Childhood Trauma From Z(iegler) to A(brahamson), with Twerski, Sykes, Sherry, Rofes, McChrystal, Klitzke, Geske, Evers—and Even Some Yeats and Dwyane Wade—in Between 1 MARQUETTE LAWYER FALL 2019 FROM THE DEAN The Company We Keep Someone once remarked to me that you cannot have too many friends. I entirely agree with that sentiment. Marquette University Law School provides powerful evidence of this. Some of our friends you can meet in this issue of the Marquette Lawyer. One is Ray Manista, L’90, a leader at Northwestern Mutual, longtime member of the Law School’s advisory board, and now a trustee of Marquette University; a profile (pp. 14–17) of Ray and his wife, Dawne, complements the cover story. And that story, “Practicing Business Law at the Speed of Change,” draws on the insights and experience of leaders in the practice, many of them longtime friends of the Law School (pp. 4–13). Often, the influence of our friends on us is not publicly visible. For example, the cover story itself was inspired by a strategic planning session led by a great friend of the Law School: Donald W. Layden, Jr., L’82. As chair of the advisory board, Don has encouraged the Law School’s attention to the trajectory and pace of change in the profession, including that prompted by technology. I am grateful for his leadership and friendship. We welcome new friends. Lee H. Rosenthal was already a prominent federal judge but new to us in her visit here last spring. She engaged and animated the Marquette Law School community, and her Hallows Lecture attracted new friends to us, as you can see among the reactions to the lecture (pp. 18–37). Judge Rosenthal had been warmly recommended to us by old friends—past lecturers here. Deborah W. Denno of Fordham University School of Law is also someone new to us who enriched our community this past academic year, as is evident in this issue (pp. 44–49). We enjoy a special friendship with our alumni. Whether in the class notes or profiles Marquette Lawyer (pp. 58–61) or in the alumni awards (pp. 38–43), Spring | Summer 2008 Marquette University Law Alumni Magazine you, too, can get to know some of them. We are so grateful for their contributions through the profession, their service in the community, their examples to our students and those of us engaged in the daily life of the Law School. Marquette Law School has had no more generous friend than Ray Eckstein, L’49, and his wife, Kay, herself a Marquette alumna (Speech ’49). Kay passed away in June 2017, as noted in a previous issue of this magazine, and so now also has Ray, this past April. The Ecksteins provided the lead gift for our new home, opened in 2010, and Ray and Kay Eckstein Hall continues to shape Marquette University Law School. The building is extraordinary in so many ways—including its Ray and Kay Eckstein ability to foster a rich and expanding network on the Site of the Future Law School Also Inside: of friendships and collaboration. We remain • Fifth Circuit Judge Carolyn Dineen King on Judicial Independence grateful and will continue to remember and • Princeton University’s Robert P. George on Faith and Reason honor Ray and Kay Eckstein. Front cover of the Spring l Summer 2008 issue of the Marquette Lawyer Joseph D. Kearney Dean and Professor of Law 2 MARQUETTE LAWYER FALL 2019 FALL 2019 Contents COVER STORY 4 Practicing Business Law at the Speed of Change How technology is changing the practice of business law. by Alan J. Borsuk and David A. Strifling 14 Losing Labels, Reaching Potential Northwestern Mutual’s Ray Manista knows how to shift course in order to grow. 2 38 58 From the Dean Four Models of What It Means Class Notes to Be a Marquette Lawyer Reaching a Defining Moment 18 The annual Marquette Law 58 Family, schools, and Ambition and Aspiration: School alumni awards colleagues lead Katie Living Greatly in the Law ceremony, honoring Annette Perhach to the federal bench. Lee Rosenthal, Chief Judge Ziegler, Aaron Twerski, Lisette 50 of the U.S. District Court Khalil, and Aaron Hernandez, FROM THE PODIUM A Super “Thank You” for the Southern District provides glimpses into the lives Tony Evers to a Superstar and careers of four exemplars of T exas, looks back at Oliver Remarks at the May 2019 Tamara Johnson expresses of the school’s mission. Wendell Holmes, Jr., in order Hooding Ceremony her gratitude to Dwyane to look around and look Wade, benefactor. forward. Reactions come Joseph D. Kearney from Diane Sykes, Darren 44 Remarks upon receiving Trauma: Can the Criminal Bush, Suzanna Sherry, Chad the American Inns of Court Justice System Stay Up-to- 62 Oldfather, Nancy Joseph, Professionalism Award Date with Its Impact? Reflecting upon an Anna Fodor, Anne Berleman for the Seventh Circuit Extraordinary Career on the Kearney, and Peter Rofes. Deborah Denno and Mary Wisconsin Supreme Court Triggiano discuss the impact Celebrating Professor of childhood trauma on Michael McChrystal Janine Geske and the courts, plus an excerpt Ramon A. Klitzke II Diane Sykes help honor from Denno’s Barrock Shirley Abrahamson Recalling his father, Lecture on Criminal Law. in the state capitol. Professor Ramon Klitzke Marquette University EDITOR: COVER: photo by Copyright 2019 Law School Alan J. Borsuk John Nienhuis, Marquette University. Eckstein Hall illustration by DESIGN: All rights reserved. P.O. Box 1881 Stephanie Dalton Cowan Douglas Frohmader Milwaukee, WI 53201-1881 Andy Haas Schneider PHOTOGRAPHY: Phone: (414) 288-7090 Mike Gryniewicz Fax: (414) 288-6403 COPY EDITOR: John Nienhuis law.marquette.edu Amy Bauman FALL 2019 MARQUETTE LAWYER 3 4 MARQUETTE LAWYER FALL 2019 PRACTICING BUSINESS LAW AT THE SPEED OF CHANGE How technology is changing the practice of business law. BY ALAN J. BORSUK AND DAVID A. STRIFLING Justin P. Webb, L’14, began the continuing legal education Do lawyers need to understand the technical details of session with a question: “How many of you think you blockchain, artificial intelligence, and data analytics? Maybe understand what blockchain is?” About 75 people had gathered not. But are they wise to have some grasp of how technology in the classroom at Marquette Law School for the one-hour, and other forces are changing or will change daily life for lunchtime program on June 6, 2019. attorneys who provide counsel to businesses, either through No hands went up. law practices or on an in-house basis? That spoke to the reason the people had come. They shared Yes, in many cases. As is true in so many other economic a strong sense of the need to understand—or at least have and social sectors, automation is reshaping the practice of some grasp of—the rapidly changing world of technology as it business law. It is changing the way clients and attorneys affects legal practice. And the attorneys present knew that they communicate, what clients want or need from attorneys, what weren’t at that point, especially when it came to matters such as is most valued by clients when it comes to legal services—and the often-heard but challenging term blockchain. it is changing businesses themselves, which lawyers also need Webb, of Godfrey & Kahn in Milwaukee, explained in to understand. broad terms that blockchain is a sort of cyber spreadsheet Smart lawyers and firms know that they need to stay on or business ledger that many parties can access at the same top of all of this because tech-driven change keeps coming, time. As applied to the cryptocurrency market (Bitcoin and so and coming fast. on), it means that there is no central clearinghouse or bank. What is now the state of high tech’s impact on the practice Blockchain technology has many other potential applications, of law, and what lies ahead? In what other important respects or “use cases,” as Webb called them: “smart contracts” that are is legal work for businesses changing? How have the daily fulfilled in real time as transactions occur, real estate dealings, routines of serving clients changed in a world so filled with even tamper-proof records of financial transactions, just to computerized tools? name a few. But blockchain is in an early stage. “I’m still waiting to see really good implementation of it,” Webb said. Illustrations by Stephanie Dalton Cowan FALL 2019 MARQUETTE LAWYER 5 We asked questions such as these of the heads of several large where developments are headed and to anticipate legal issues. firms, in-house lawyers for major corporations, lawyers who are “The clients may not know when to call you,” Manista says. “As tech-savvy and at earlier stages of their careers, and some general an advisor, you can’t wait for the client to call.” experts. While it is impossible in these early days to draw any Instead, today’s lawyers must anticipate problems and firm conclusions about the future of the practice, here are a few offer potential solutions to clients rather than adhere to older, observations about what has changed and some perspectives on process-driven models, when clients and lawyers might not lessons already gleaned from lawyering at the speed of change. connect until an issue was ripe or a dispute was in full bloom.
Recommended publications
  • Iron County Heads to Polls Today
    Mostly cloudy High: 49 | Low: 32 | Details, page 2 DAILY GLOBE yourdailyglobe.com Tuesday, April 4, 2017 75 cents Iron County TURKEY STRUT heads to polls today By RICHARD JENKINS sor, three candidates — incum- [email protected] bent Jeff Stenberg, Tom Thomp- HURLEY — Iron County vot- son Jr. and James Schmidt — ers head to the polls today in a will be vying for two town super- series of state and local races. visor seats. Mercer Clerk Chris- At the state level, voters will tan Brandt and Treasurer Lin decide between incumbent Tony Miller are running unopposed. Evers and Lowell Holtz to see There is also a seat open on who will be the state’s next the Mercer Sanitary Board, how- superintendent of public instruc- ever no one has filed papers to tion. Annette Ziegler is running appear on the ballot. unopposed for another term as a The city of Montreal also has justice on the Wisconsin two seats up for election. In Supreme Court. Ward 1, Joan Levra is running Iron County Circuit Court unopposed to replace Brian Liv- Judge Patrick Madden is also ingston on the council, while running unopposed for another Leola Maslanka is being chal- term on the bench. lenged by Bill Stutz for her seat Iron County’s local municipal- representing Ward 2. ities also have races on the ballot The other town races, all of — including contested races in which feature unopposed candi- Kimball, Mercer and Montreal. dates, are as follows: In Kimball, Town Chairman —Anderson: Edward Brandis Ron Ahonen is being challenged is running for chairman, while by Joe Simonich.
    [Show full text]
  • SENATE JUD COMMITTEE -1- January 25, 2012 POSITION STATEMENT: Delivered a Presentation to the Crime Summit
    ALASKA STATE LEGISLATURE SENATE JUDICIARY STANDING COMMITTEE January 25, 2012 8:37 a.m. MEMBERS PRESENT Senator Hollis French, Chair Senator Bill Wielechowski, Vice Chair Senator Joe Paskvan Senator Lesil McGuire Senator John Coghill MEMBERS ABSENT All members present OTHER LEGISLATORS PRESENT Senator Gary Stevens Senator Johnny Ellis Senator Fred Dyson Representative Pete Petersen COMMITTEE CALENDAR CRIME SUMMIT - HEARD PREVIOUS COMMITTEE ACTION No previous action to record WITNESS REGISTER ERIN PATTERSON-SEXSON, Lead Advocate Direct Services Coordinator Standing Together Against Rape Anchorage, AK POSITION STATEMENT: Delivered a presentation to the Crime Summit. NANCY MEADE, General Counsel Alaska Court System Anchorage, AK SENATE JUD COMMITTEE -1- January 25, 2012 POSITION STATEMENT: Delivered a presentation to the Crime Summit. DIANE SCHENKER, Project Coordinator Fairbanks Electronic Bail Conditions Project Alaska Court System Anchorage, AK POSITION STATEMENT: Delivered a presentation to the Crime Summit. HELEN SHARRATT, Integrated Justice Coordinator Alaska Court System and Coordinator for MAJIC Anchorage, AK POSITION STATEMENT: Delivered a presentation to the Crime Summit. QUINLAN STEINER, Director Public Defender Agency Department of Administration Anchorage, AK POSITION STATEMENT: Delivered a presentation to the Crime Summit. RICHARD ALLEN, Director Office of Public Advocacy Department of Administration Anchorage, AK POSITION STATEMENT: Delivered a presentation to the Crime Summit. WALT MONEGAN, President and CEO Alaska Native Justice Center Anchorage, AK POSITION STATEMENT: Delivered a presentation to the Crime Summit. JAKE METCALFE, Executive Director Public Safety Employee Association Anchorage, AK POSITION STATEMENT: Delivered a presentation to the Crime Summit. TERRENCE SHANIGAN, Trooper Alaska State Troopers Department of Public Safety Talkeetna, AK SENATE JUD COMMITTEE -2- January 25, 2012 POSITION STATEMENT: Delivered a presentation to the Crime Summit.
    [Show full text]
  • Accessibility, Quality, and Profitability for Personal Plight Law Firms: Hitting the Sweet Spot
    ACCESSIBILITY, QUALITY, AND PROFITABILITY FOR PERSONAL PLIGHT LAW FIRMS: HITTING THE SWEET SPOT By Noel Semple Prepared for the Canadian Bar Association Futures Initiative ACCESSIBILITY, QUALITY, AND PROFITABILITY FOR PERSONAL PLIGHT LAW FIRMS: HITTING THE SWEET SPOT August 2017 © Canadian Bar Association. 865 Carling Avenue, Suite 500, Ottawa, ON K1S 5S8 Tel.: (613) 237-2925 / (800) 267-8860 / Fax: (613) 237-0185 E-mail: [email protected] Home page: www.cba.org Website: cbafutures.org ALL RIGHTS RESERVED No portion of this paper may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the written permission of the publisher. Printed in Canada Sommaire disponible en français The views expressed in this report are those of the author only and do not necessarily reflect those of the Canadian Bar Association. ISBN: 978-1-927014-41-7 2 ACCESSIBILITY, QUALITY, AND PROFITABILITY FOR PERSONAL PLIGHT LAW FIRMS: HITTING THE SWEET SPOT ACCESSIBILITY, QUALITY, AND PROFITABILITY FOR PERSONAL PLIGHT LAW FIRMS: HITTING THE SWEET SPOT By Noel Semple1 Prepared for the Canadian Bar Association Futures Initiative. ABSTRACT Personal plight legal practice includes all legal work for individual clients whose needs arise from disputes. This is the site of our worst access to justice problems. The goal of this project is to identify sustainable innovations that can make the services of personal plight law firms more accessible to all Canadians. Accessibility is vitally important, but it is not the only thing that matters in personal plight legal practice. Thus, this book seeks out innovations that not only improve accessibility, but also preserve or enhance service quality as well as law firms’ profitability.
    [Show full text]
  • National Association of Women Judges Counterbalance Spring 2012 Volume 31 Issue 3
    national association of women judges counterbalance Spring 2012 Volume 31 Issue 3 INSIDE THIS ISSUE Poverty’s Impact on the Administration of Justice / 1 President’s Message / 2 Executive Director’s Message / 3 Cambridge 2012 Midyear Meeting and Leadership Conference / 6 MEET ME IN MIAMI: NAWJ 2012 Annual Conference / 8 District News / 10 Immigration Programs News / 20 Membership Moments / 20 Women in Prison Report / 21 Louisiana Women in Prison / 21 Maryland Women in Prison / 23 NAWJ District 14 Director Judge Diana Becton and Contra Costa County native Christopher Darden with local high school youth New York Women in Prison / 24 participants in their November, 2011 Color of Justice program. Read more on their program in District 14 News. Learn about Color of Justice in creator Judge Brenda Loftin’s account on page 33. Educating the Courts and Others About Sexual Violence in Unexpected Areas / 28 NAWJ Judicial Selection Committee Supports Gender Equity in Selection of Judges / 29 POVERTY’S IMPACT ON THE ADMINISTRATION Newark Conference Perspective / 30 OF JUSTICE 1 Ten Years of the Color of Justice / 33 By the Honorable Anna Blackburne-Rigsby and Ashley Thomas Jeffrey Groton Remembered / 34 “The opposite of poverty is justice.”2 These words have stayed with me since I first heard them Program Spotlight: MentorJet / 35 during journalist Bill Moyers’ interview with civil rights attorney Bryan Stevenson. In observance News from the ABA: Addressing Language of the anniversary of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.’s assassination, they were discussing what Dr. Access / 38 King would think of the United States today in the fight against inequality and injustice.
    [Show full text]
  • Language and Jury Decision-Making in Texas Death Penalty Trials
    The author(s) shown below used Federal funds provided by the U.S. Department of Justice and prepared the following final report: Document Title: Doing Death in Texas: Language and Jury Decision-Making in Texas Death Penalty Trials Author: Robin Helene Conley Document No.: 236354 Date Received: November 2011 Award Number: 2009-IJ-CX-0005 This report has not been published by the U.S. Department of Justice. To provide better customer service, NCJRS has made this Federally- funded grant final report available electronically in addition to traditional paper copies. Opinions or points of view expressed are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official position or policies of the U.S. Department of Justice. This document is a research report submitted to the U.S. Department of Justice. This report has not been published by the Department. Opinions or points of view expressed are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official position or policies of the U.S. Department of Justice. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA Los Angeles Doing Death in Texas: Language and Jury Decision-Making in Texas Death Penalty Trials A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in Anthropology by Robin Helene Conley 2011 This document is a research report submitted to the U.S. Department of Justice. This report has not been published by the Department. Opinions or points of view expressed are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official position or policies of the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • 2010 April Montana Lawyer
    April 2010 THE MONTANA Volume 35, No. 6 awyerTHE STATE BAR OF MONTANA SpecialL issue on Montana courts Tweeting Supreme Court docket is now a major viewable to all on the web trial Developments in the 2 biggest UM’s discipline cases student The trouble Grace Case with money in Project changes judicial elections the landscape for media coverage Chopping down the backlog Changes in procedures at the Supreme Court cuts the deficit Ethics opinion on the new in the caseload notary rule THE MONTANA LAWYER APRIL INDEX Published every month except January and July by the State Bar of Montana, 7 W. Sixth Ave., Suite 2B, P.O. Box 577, Helena MT 59624. Phone (406) 442-7660; Fax (406) 442-7763. Cover Story E-mail: [email protected] UM’s Grace Case Project: trial coverage via Internet 6 STATE BAR OFFICERS President Cynthia K. Smith, Missoula President-Elect Features Joseph Sullivan, Great Falls Secretary-Treasurer Ethics Opinion: notary-rule compliance 12 K. Paul Stahl, Helena Immediate Past President Money floods campaigns for judgeships 22 Chris Tweeten, Helena Chair of the Board Shane Vannatta, Missoula Commentary Board of Trustees Pam Bailey, Billings President’s Message: Unsung heroes 4 Pamela Bucy, Helena Darcy Crum, Great Falls Op-Ed: A nation of do-it-yourself lawyers 25 Vicki W. Dunaway, Billings Jason Holden, Great Falls Thomas Keegan, Helena Jane Mersen, Bozeman State Bar News Olivia Norlin, Glendive Mark D. Parker, Billings Ryan Rusche, Wolf Point Lawyers needed to aid military personnel 14 Ann Shea, Butte Randall Snyder, Bigfork Local attorneys and Law Day events 15 Bruce Spencer, Helena Matthew Thiel, Missoula State Bar Calendar 15 Shane Vannatta, Missoula Lynda White, Bozeman Tammy Wyatt-Shaw, Missoula Courts ABA Delegate Damon L.
    [Show full text]
  • Hard Justice Free
    FREE HARD JUSTICE PDF Lori Foster | 384 pages | 21 Mar 2017 | Harlequin Books | 9780373799329 | English | United States Hard Justice | Halo Machinima | Fandom Its promotional trailer was released Hard Justice YouTube on September 20, Hard Justice Bernard Brown is the starring character, an ex-cop Hard Justice resigns from the Hard Justice department of Regent City after deciding Hard Justice doesn't want to be a part of or contribute to the fact that Regent City is slowly becoming a fascist police state. Unfortunately for him, Esoteria is not much of a difference. After Hard Justice to get a Hard Justice, Bernard finds a job at E. Despite having a dark theme, Hard Justice still contains plenty Hard Justice DigitalPh33r's trademark humor. Max tells Eddie to steel himself for the coming task. Eddie decides to open the door, but Max tells him "Don't split hairs with me. Why go around something when you can go through it", and blasts open the door with his rocket launcher. Entering the house, Max discovers that the occupant of the house has downloaded three tracks of music, causing Eddie to puke violently. Just then, the occupant of the Hard Justice returns, and he is placed under arrest by Max, who tells him that downloading three tracks is equivalent to killing three Hard Justice. Eddie then fires at the "offender", who flees. Max blows up his car. After failing to catch him, they taser him twice and restrain him. In the Hard Justice, Bernard arrives at Esoteria airport, and after clearing the numerous security checkpoints, getting stopped at each of them Hard Justice being nervous.
    [Show full text]
  • March 2019 / Issue No
    “I am hugely honoured “Guilty, I am - radicalised, “Being free doesn’t solve by the opportunity to I was. Yet I still find my your problems it just gives the National Newspaper for Prisoners & Detainees lead HMPPS at such an entire situation incredibly you the space to deal with important time.” Jo Farrar surreal.” Zakaria Amara them.” Melanie Myers a voice for prisoners since Newsround // page 10 Comment // page 31 Comment // page 27 March 2019 / Issue No. 237 / www.insidetime.org / A ‘not for profit’ publication/ ISSN 1743-7342 WORLD BOOK DAY 11 // MOTHER’S DAY 46 // INTERNATIONAL WOMEN’S DAY 54 An average of 60,000 copies distributed monthly Independently verified by the Audit Bureau of Circulations PAROLE REVOLUTION Justice Secretary David Gauke’s ‘landmark reform’ l Prisoners and victims l Process to be more l Victims still have no to have right of appeal transparent to counter veto on decisions to against decisions. ‘profound deficiencies’. release. Inside Time report whether there could have The judge would be able to been serious mistakes or legal either ask the original panel 14 flaws in the ruling. If the Jus- to review its decision or order Credit: HMP Hydebank Wood Under the new plans, victims tice Secretary decides that a fresh hearing by a new who want to challenge a deci- there is a case for the decision panel. The new system will sion to release a particular to be reviewed he will refer apply from this summer to New kids on the block! prisoner would be able to the appeal to a judge at the those with the most serious apply to the Justice Secretary, Parole Board.
    [Show full text]
  • Rebel Without a Pause Rising GOP Star Paul Ryan by Christian Schneider Editor > Charles J
    WI 2010 JULY WISCONSIN INTEREST Our Divided, Dysfunctional Supreme Court AN INVESTIGATIVE REPORT BY MIKE NICHOLS UW’s Real Diversity Problem BY DAVID BLASKA The Great Train Robbery BY PATRICK MCILHERAN Rebel without a pause Rising GOP star Paul Ryan BY CHRISTIAN SCHNEIDER Editor > CHARLES J. SYKES Hard choices WI WISCONSIN INTEREST For a rising political star, Paul Ryan remains a nation’s foremost celebrity wonk, asking: remarkably lonely political figure. For years, “What’s so damn special about Paul Ryan?” under both Democrats and Republicans, he More than his matinee-idol looks. has warned about the need to avert a fiscal “Ryan is a throwback,” writes Schneider, Publisher: meltdown, but even though his detailed “he could easily have been a conservative Wisconsin Policy Research Institute, Inc. “Roadmap” for restraining government politician in the era before cable news. He spending was widely praised, it was embraced has risen to national stardom by taking the Editor: Charles J. Sykes by very few. path least traveled by modern politicians: He Despite lip-service praise from President knows a lot of stuff.” Managing Editor: Marc Eisen Obama, Democrats have launched serial Also in this issue, Mike Nichols examines Art Direction: attacks against the plan, while GOP leaders Wisconsin’s dysfunctional, divided Supreme Stephan & Brady, Inc. have made themselves scarce, avoiding being Court and the implications for law in the state. Contributors: yoked to the specificity of Ryan’s hard choices. Patrick McIlheran deconstructs the state’s David Blaska But Ryan’s warnings have taken on new signature boondoggle, the billion-dollar not- Richard Esenberg urgency as Europe’s debt crisis unfolds, and so-fast train from Milwaukee to somewhere Patrick McIlheran the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Retributive Hatred As a Reactive Moral Attitude
    Retributive Hatred as a Reactive Moral Attitude Jeramy S. Gee A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Washington 2014 Reading Committee: Jean Roberts (Chair) Stephen Gardiner Ingra Schellenberg Cass Weller Program Authorized to Offer Degree: Department of Philosophy ©Copyright 2014 Jeramy S. Gee University of Washington Abstract Retributive Hatred as a Reactive Moral Attitude Jeramy S. Gee Chair of the Supervisory Committee: Professor Jean Roberts Department of Philosophy Philosophers’ attention to negative attitudes has grown in recent decades. However, whereas philosophers have offered a number of descriptions of, and justifications for, attitudes like resentment and contempt, hatred is usually met with antipathy even when we might be inclined to be sympathetic to the hater. In this dissertation I offer a sustained examination of hatred I and make a rather startling claim: There are cases of hatred that are morally justifiable. The kind of hatred I defend is what some philosophers have called retributive hatred. This is hatred adopted in response to wrongdoing and in which hostility is driven by a retributive notion of moral desert. To make my case I argue that retributive hatred is distinguishable from such attitudes as prejudicial hatred, malice, and spite—attitudes with which it is often confused—and that it is not liable to the kinds of criticisms that can be levied against these types of hatred. I then show that retributive hatred should be classified among the reactive attitudes. Thus there are conditions governing when retributive haters can be understood as properly representing their targets as hateful and I argue that these conditions can be met.
    [Show full text]
  • Honorable Nathan L. Hecht Chief Justice of Texas PRESIDENT-ELECT
    Last Revised June 2021 PRESIDENT: Honorable Nathan L. Hecht Chief Justice of Texas PRESIDENT-ELECT: Honorable Paul A. Suttell Chief Justice of Rhode Island ALABAMA ARKANSAS Honorable Tom Parker Honorable John Dan Kemp Chief Justice Chief Justice Alabama Supreme Court Supreme Court of Arkansas 300 Dexter Avenue Justice Building Montgomery, AL 36104-3741 625 Marshall St. (334) 229-0600 FAX (334) 229-0535 Little Rock, AR 72201 (501) 682-6873 FAX (501) 683-4006 ALASKA CALIFORNIA Honorable Joel H. Bolger Chief Justice Honorable Tani G. Cantil-Sakauye Alaska Supreme Court Chief Justice 303 K Street, 5th Floor Supreme Court of California Anchorage, AK 99501 350 McAllister Street (907) 264-0633 FAX (907) 264-0632 San Francisco, CA 94102 (415) 865-7060 FAX (415) 865-7181 AMERICAN SAMOA COLORADO Honorable F. Michael Kruse Chief Justice Honorable Brian D. Boatright The High Court of American Samoa Chief Justice Courthouse, P.O. Box 309 Colorado Supreme Court Pago Pago, AS 96799 2 East 14th Avenue 011 (684) 633-1410 FAX 011 (684) 633-1318 Denver, CO 80203-2116 (720) 625-5410 FAX (720) 271-6124 ARIZONA CONNECTICUT Honorable Robert M. Brutinel Chief Justice Honorable Richard A. Robinson Arizona Supreme Court Chief Justice 1501 W. Washington Street, Suite 433 State of Connecticut Supreme Court Phoenix, AZ 85007-3222 231 Capitol Avenue (602) 452-3531 FAX (602) 452-3917 Hartford, CT 06106 (860) 757-2113 FAX (860) 757-2214 1 Last Revised June 2021 DELAWARE HAWAII Honorable Collins J. Seitz, Jr. Honorable Mark E. Recktenwald Chief Justice Chief Justice Supreme Court of Delaware Supreme Court of Hawaii The Renaissance Centre 417 South King Street 405 N.
    [Show full text]
  • Guide to the Wisconsin Supreme Court
    2011 Guide to the Wisconsin Supreme Court Prepared by: WISCONSIN CIVIL JUSTICE COUNCIL, INC. JANUARY 2011 2011 Guide to the Wisconsin Supreme Court By Andrew Cook and Jim Hough The Hamilton Consulting Group, LLC January 2011 The Wisconsin Civil Justice Council, Inc. (WCJC) was formed in early 2009 to represent Wisconsin business interests on civil litigation issues before the Legislature and courts. Our goal is to achieve fairness and equity, reduce costs, and enhance Wisconsin‘s image as a place to live and work. The Wisconsin Civil Justice Council Board is proud to present its first biennial Judicial Evaluation of the Wisconsin Supreme Court. The purpose of the Judicial Evaluation is to educate WCJC‘s members and the public by providing a summary of the most important decisions issued by the Court which have had an effect on Wisconsin business interests. Officers and Board Members President - Bill Smith Vice President - James Buchen National Federation of Independent Business Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce Treasurer-Andy Franken Secretary - Pat Stevens Wisconsin Insurance Alliance Wisconsin Builders Association John Mielke James Boullion Associated Builder & Contractors Associated General Contractors of Wisconsin Michael Crooks Beata Kalies Wisconsin Defense Counsel Electric Cooperatives Gary Manke Nickolas George Midwest Equipment Dealers Association Midwest Food Processors Association Mary Ann Gerrard Peter Thillman Wisconsin Automobile & Truck Dealers Assn. Wisconsin Economic Development Assn. Eric Borgerding Mark Grapentine
    [Show full text]