Resettlement Planning Document
Short Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan Document Stage: Final Project Number: 37192 July 2009
PAK: Multitranche Financing Facility Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program, Tranche 1
Sub Project No. 20 220 kV Dera Ghazi Khan - Loralai Double Circuit
Transmission Line Subproject
Prepared by National Transmission and Despatch Company for the Asian Development Bank (ADB).
The resettlement plan is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB’s Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature.
ASIAN DEVELOPMENT BANK
ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF PAKISTAN
Pakistan: Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program (ADB Loan No. 2289-PAK)
TRANCHE 1
Subproject No. 20
Dera Ghazi Khan to Loralai 220kV Double Circuit Transmission Line
Short Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan
December 2008
NATIONAL TRANSMISSION AND DESPACH COMPANY (NTDC)
GOVERNMENT OF PAKISTAN
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table of Contents Abbreviations Definition of Terms Executive Summary 1. INTRODUCTION...... 10 1.1 BACKGROUND ...... 10 1.2 DESCRIPTION OF THE SUBPROJECT ...... 11 2. PROJECT COMPENSATION AND REHABILITATION FRAMEWORK ...... 13 2.1 PAKISTAN’S LAW AND REGULATIONS ON LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT ...... 13 2.2 ADB’S INVOLUNTARY RESETTLEMENT POLICY...... 14 2.3 COMPARISON OF PAKISTAN LAND ACQUISITION ACT AND ADB RESETTLEMENT POLICY...... 14 2.4 REMEDIAL MEASURES TO BRIDGE THE GAP...... 15 2.5 LEGISLATION RELEVANT TO LAND CLASSIFICATION ...... 15 2.6 COMPENSATION ELIGIBILITY AND ENTITLEMENTS FOR THE PROJECT ...... 15 2.7 ELIGIBILITY ...... 17 2.8 STRATEGY FOR COMPENSATION OF LAND AFFECTED BY TOWERS ...... 17 2.9 COMPENSATION ENTITLEMENTS...... 18 2.10 ASSESSMENT OF COMPENSATION UNIT VALUES ...... 18 2.11 REHABILITATION OF DAMAGED INFRASTRUCTURE AND FARMLANDS...... 19 3. ASSESSMENT OF IMPACTS ...... 20 3.1.1 Resettlement Field Surveys ...... 20 3.1.2 Minimization of Impacts ...... 20 3.2 IMPACTS OF THE TRANSMISSION LINE ...... 21 3.3 IMPACTS ON AFFECTED HOUSEHOLDS...... 29 3.3.1 General ...... 29 4. SOCIO-ECONOMIC PROFILE OF AFFECTED PEOPLE ...... 31 4.1 CENSUS OF AFFECTED HOUSEHOLDS...... 31 4.2 DATA ON HEADS OF AFFECTED HOUSEHOLDS...... 32 4.3 DATA ON AFFECTED HOUSEHOLDS AND POPULATION...... 32 5. INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS ...... 36 5.1 NATIONAL TRANSMISSION AND DISPATCH COMPANY...... 36 5.2 ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY ...... 38 5.3 FEDERAL AND PROVINCIAL GOVERNMENTS...... 38 5.5 GRIEVANCE REDRESS COMMITTEE...... 39 6. CONSULTATION AND DISCLOSURE ...... 40 6.1 CONSULTATION UNDERTAKEN FOR THE LARP ...... 40 6.2 COMPENSATION OPTIONS DISCUSSED ...... 41 6.3 LARP DISCLOSURE ...... 42 7. GRIEVANCE REDRESS PROCESS...... 43 8. BUDGET FOR LAND AND ASSET ACQUISITION ...... 44 8.1 BASIS FOR COMPENSATION ...... 44 8.2 DETERMINING THE RATES FOR COMPENSATION ...... 44 8.3 BUDGET FOR LAND AND ASSET ACQUISITION ...... 48 9. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE...... 50 10. MONITORING AND EVALUATION...... 52
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 3
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
10.1 INTERNAL MONITORING ...... 52 10.2 EXTERNAL MONITORING...... 53 10.3 INDICATORS FOR MONITORING AND EVALUATION ...... 53 10.4 RESETTLEMENT DATABASE...... 53
Appendices
APPENDIX 1 – SUMMARY OF RESETTLEMENT FIELD SURVEY (WORKING TABLES) 52
APPENDIX 2 – LIST OF PEOPLE CONSULTED 104
APPENDIX 3 – DRAFT PUBLIC INFORMATION BROCHURE 108
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 4
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Abbreviations
ADB Asian Development Bank AHs Affected households AM Angular Marker (Angular Tower) APs Affected people DCO District Coordination Officer DOR District Officer (Revenue) EDO-R Executive District Officer (Revenue) EIA Environmental Impact Assessment (Report) EMA External Monitoring Agency EHV Extra High-Tension Voltage (a division of NTDC) ESIC Environmental and Social Impact Cell (NTDC) GM General Manager GRC Grievance Redress Committee GSC Grid System Construction (a division of NTDC) GSO Grid System Operation (a division of NTDC) IEE Initial Environmental Assessment (Report) IPDF Indigenous Peoples Development Framework IPDP Indigenous Peoples Development Plan kanal unit of land measurement: 1 kanal = 50.54 m2 (or, 1 ha = 19.786 kanals) kV kilo-Volt (Unit of Power) LAA Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (amended) LAC Land Acquisition Collector LARF Land Acquisition and Resettlement Framework LARP Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan MOWP Ministry of Water and Power MRM Management Review Meeting NGO Non-Governmental Organization NTDC National Transmission and Dispatch Company PD Project Director, NTDC PIB Public Information Booklet PIU Project Implementation Unit (NTDC) PMU Project Management Unit (NTDC) PPTA Project Preparatory Technical Assistance RFS Resettlement Field Surveys ROW Right-of-way Rs. Pakistani Rupees (Currency): Rs. 67.40 = US$1.00 (in this LARP) SLARP Short Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan TL Transmission Line TOR Terms of Reference WAPDA Water and Power Development Authority
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 5
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Definition of Terms Affected persons/households (APs/AHs) mean all the people affected by land acquisition, relocation, or loss of incomes and include any person, household (referred to as project affected family or affected household [AH]), firms, or public or private institutions. APs therefore include; i) persons affected directly by the safety corridor, right-of-way, tower or pole foundations or construction work area; (ii) persons whose agricultural land or other productive assets such as trees or crops are affected; (iii) persons whose businesses are affected and who might experience loss of income due to the project impact; (iv) persons who lose work/employment as a result of project impact; and (v) people who lose access to community resources/property as a result of the project. Compensation means payment in cash or kind for an asset to be acquired or affected by a project at replacement cost at current market value. Cut-off-date means the date after which people will NOT be considered eligible for compensation i.e. they are not included in the list of APs/AHs as defined by the census. Normally, the cut-off date is the date of the detailed measurement survey. Encroachers mean those people who move into the project area after the cut-off date and are therefore not eligible for compensation or other rehabilitation measures provided by the project. Entitlement means the range of measures comprising cash or in-kind compensation, relocation cost, income rehabilitation assistance, transfer assistance, income/livelihood restoration which are due to AHs, depending on the type and degree nature of their losses to restore their social and economic base. Inventory of losses means the pre-appraisal inventory of assets as a preliminary record of affected or lost assets. Land acquisition means the process whereby a person is compelled by a public agency to alienate all or part of the land s/he owns or possesses, to the ownership and possession of the agency for public purposes, in return for fair compensation. The land acquisition and resettlement plan is known as a LARP. Non-titled means those who have no recognizable rights or claims to the land that they are occupying and includes people using private or state land without permission, permit or grant i.e. those people without legal title to land and/or structures occupied or used by them. ADB’s policy explicitly states that such people cannot be denied compensation. Poor means those falling below the official national poverty line (equivalent to 2,350 calories per day) of Rs 848.79 per person per month (2004). Replacement cost means the method of valuing assets to replace the loss at current market value, or its nearest equivalent, and is the amount of cash or kind needed to replace an asset in its existing condition, without deduction of transaction costs or for any material salvaged. Resettlement Field Survey means the detailed inventory of losses that is completed after detailed design and marking of project boundaries on the ground, socioeconomic data on the affected households/families, and stakeholder consultations. Sharecropper means the same as tenant cultivator or tenant farmer, and is a person who cultivates land they do not own for an agreed proportion of crop or harvest. Significant impact means 200 people or more will experience major impacts, which are defined as; (i) being physically displaced from housing, or (ii) losing ten per cent or more of their productive assets (income generating). Vulnerable means any people who might suffer disproportionately or face the risk of being marginalized from the effects of resettlement and includes; (i) female-headed households with dependents; (ii) disabled household heads; (iii) poor households (within the meaning given previously); (iv) landless; (v) elderly households with no means of support; (vi) households without security of tenure; (vii) ethnic minorities; and (viii) marginal farmers (with landholdings of five acres or less).
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 6
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Executive Summary
1. The Subproject. The new Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Subproject (No. 20 of Tranche 1 - orginaly a part of Tranche 3 but shifted to Tranche 1 in order to utilize the unspent amount of funds) is an extension of the New D. G. Khan 500kV Grid Station to the New Loralai 220kV Grid Station (Subproject Nos. 5 and 6, respectively, of Tranche 2), to provide the north- eastern part of Baluchistan province with another means of extra high-tension (220kV) power supply. This subproject will be implemented under Tranche 1 of the ADB-funded Power Transmission Enhancement Program of NTDC, through a multi-tranche financing facility (MFF). It includes the construction of a new 245.01 km long 220kV double circuit transmission line, traversing four districts, including D. G. Khan district in the Punjab province; and Bar Khan, Musa Khel and Loralai districts in the Baluchistan province. The alignment of this new 220kV double circuit transmission line has deliberately been designed to traverse mostly the unproductive hilly to rough lands, to possibly avoid the compact villages and Almond orchards. As a result, only about 10.43 km (4.26%) of its length will traverse the private farmlands, with agricultural crops and fruit and wood trees being affected. 2. Resettlement Impacts. This transmission line subproject will affect a total of 126 households (AHs) with a total population of 1,232 affected persons (APs), who are all landowner farmers. The new 245.01 km transmission line will traverse lands of some 21 villages, in the above identified four districts. It may partially affect or damage some seven stone-mud built houses and one boundary (which will not require demolition/relocation), and affect crops of a total 126 households and trees of 88 households (1,232 APs). Of the total 755 towers, only 723 towers will be constructed on barren hilly and rough lands, while only 32 towers (4.24%) will be constructed in privately owned farmlands. The majority of the towers are straight towers and in some cases, to avoid and/or minimize resettlement impacts, some 118 angular towers (Angle Markers) will be constructed. Moreover, 4-6 m leg extensions will be provided to the corresponding towers, to maintain 7-8 m vertical clearance to the tops of the likely affected eight structures (7 houses and 1 boundary wall), falling partially within the 30m wide corridor. Besides affecting agricultural crops on 31.28 ha of farmlands, some 356 trees (152 fruit trees and 204 wood trees) will need to be removed from the 30m wide corridor of impact. The overall resettlement impacts are temporary and minor (i.e. no AHs will be displaced and no AHs will lose > 10% of their income). In accordance with this minor impact this Short LARP has been prepared. Compensation and rehabilitation assistance for the subproject impacts will be provided in accordance with the following Compensation Eligibility and Entitlements (see Table 1). Table 1: Summary Compensation Eligibility and Entitlements Matrix No. Asset Specification Category Compensation Entitlements AHs Arable Access is not Farmer/Titlehol 126 No land compensation provided that land is Land restricted, and der rehabilitated /restored to former quality following (Temporaril existing/current land completion of works. Cash compensation for affected y Affected) use will remain crops and trees.as per item below unchanged Houses Partial damage to All relevant 8 Cash compensation at replacement rate for affected and privately built-up AHs, incl. structure/other fixed assets free of salvaged materials, Structures structures (houses, squatters depreciation or transaction costs. For partial impacts boundary walls, etc.) full cash assistance to restore remaining structure will be paid. Crops Crops affected All AHs, incl. 126 Crop compensation in cash at full market rate for one squatters harvest by default for impacts caused by tower bases and perimeter, stringing and access. All other crop losses will be compensated at market rates based on
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 7
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
No. Asset Specification Category Compensation Entitlements AHs actual losses. Trees Trees affected All AHs 88 Cash compensation shall reflect income replacement Community Community All damaged 126 Rehabilitation of damaged community Assets Infrastructure community AHs / infrastructure/utilities and/or individual infrastructure 21 farmlands/watercourses will be carried out by the Civil villages Works Contractors out of the Subproject funds.
3. Significance of Impact. As there is no restriction on access to, or use of, land, the impacts will be temporary. The impact on crops and trees is such that AHs will not experience a loss of 10% or more of their productive assets (income generating). There are only 8 stone-mud built structures which are likely to be partially damaged, but not demolished or relocated, as the corresponding towers will be provided with 6 m leg extension to insure sufficient clearance. Besides, no other built-up structures, whether private or community owned, will be affected. Thus, none of the 126 AHs will experience any significant impacts. Therefore the overall resettlement impact of this Subproject is considered minor and non-significant. 4. Indigenous People Issues. All the AHs are Muslim and ethnically Baloch, Khetran and Pushtoons. There are neither tribal nor minority people amongst the AHs, and all affected farmlands are held in private ownership (i.e. not tribally owned or communally held land). Thus, the ADB’s Policy on Indigenous People, as specified in the Indigenous Peoples Development Framework (IPDF) prepared for the program is not triggered, and therefore neither an IPDP nor special action is required for this subproject. 5. Participatory Land Acquisition Process. The program’s LARF has been translated into Urdu and disclosed according to ADB’s public communications policy, and it has also been uploaded to ADB’s website. Consultation has been undertaken through a series of meetings with local government agencies, AHs, as well as wider community group meetings of both men and women at all affected villages. The RFS was a participatory process, with the head of household assisting in the identification and calculation of losses and incomes. Further consultations will be required during the LARP implementation. 6. Grievance Redress Mechanism. The NTDC has also established a process to deal with any issues or concerns raised by the affected households/communities on any aspect of the LARP or compensation process. The verbal or written grievances of AHs will be heard by the district level Grievance Redress Committees (GRCs), to be constituted to assist NTDC implement the LARP. 7. Cost of Plan. Tables 2 below presents a summary of the total estimated resettlement cost for this D. G. Khan – Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Subproject is estimated at Rs. 11.23 million (US$ 165,428), which the NTDC will set aside out of its counterpart funding, and use it in complete implementation of this LARP prior to awarding of civil works contracts under this subproject.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 8
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table 2: Estimated Resettlement Cost of D.G. Khan –Loralai 220kV Transmission Lines Subproject No. Resettlement Activity Total Rs. A. Asset Compensation (8 Structures, Crops & Trees Compensation) 6,401, 248 B. Technical Assistance (Training, M&E – Internal/External) 2,850,000 C. Administration Costs (15% of A: Asset Compensation) 960,187 D. Subtotal (A+B+C): 10,211,435 E. Contingency (10% of D: Sub-Total) 1,021,144 Total Amount (Pak. Rupees): 11,232,579 Total Amount (US Dollars*): 165,428 * Exchange Rate: US$ 1.00 = Rs. 67.90.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 9
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
1. The Government of Pakistan has requested financing from the Asian Development Bank (ADB) for implementing the Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program (the Program) to be executed through a Multi-tranche Financial Facility (MFF) divided into four tranches. The Ministry of Water and Power and the National Transmission and Dispatch Company (NTDC) are the Executing Agency (EA) and the Implementing Agency (IA), respectively. Each tranche will constitute a project which, in turn, will be divided into several sub- projects involving the construction/up gradation of the sub-stations and transmission lines. 2. The Dera Ghazi Khan – Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Subproject (formerly a Subproject of Tranche 3, has been now been shifted to Tranche 1 as Subproject 20, to utilize the unspent funds) involves the construction of a total length of 245.01 km of 220kV double circuit transmission line, to connect the New Dera Ghazi Khan 500kV Grid Station to the New Loralai 220kV Grid Station (both the grid station are planned to be constructed as Subproject No. 5 & 6, respectively under tranche 2 of this ADB MFF). 3. This Short Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan (SLARP) has been prepared for the D. G. Khan – Loralai 220kV transmission line subproject by NTDC to fit the Land Acquisition and Resettlement Framework (LARF) prepared for the program as a whole. As such, the Subproject will fit the following LAR-related implementation conditions: • Signing of contracts awards for the Subproject’s civil works will be contingent to the preparation of a LARP fitting the LARF and ADB relevant polices; and • ADB issuance of notice to proceed for the implementation of the subproject’s civil works will be contingent to the full implementation of the compensation and rehabilitation programs detailed in this LARP. 4. This LARP is based on final line alignments and tower positions and fully fits the provisions of the LARF already prepared. Thus, this Short LARP is ready for implementation, except updation of prices of the affected assets. As required by the LAR-related conditionalities for the program, the LARF has been reviewed but it was not modified as the subprojects under tranche 3 require the same LAR approach as in the subprojects under tranche 1 and 2. 5. As noted in the LARF and based on ADB’s OM section F2/OP & BP (2003) impacts are considered severe when >200 APs are resettled or suffer >10% loss of productive assets (income generating) and a subproject is classified as category “A” for which a full LARP is to be prepared. Conversely, when losses are minor or non-significant i.e. <200 APs are to be resettled or lose <10% of productive assets, a subproject is classified as category “B” and only a short LARP is to be prepared. Although the number of APs is more than 200, none are to be resettled and the impact on each AH is minor, therefore this sub-project is classified as category ‘’B’’ and this document has been prepared following the short LARP format. 6. The following sections of this Short LARP detail: (i) the principles and eligibility/entitlement criteria for compensation or rehabilitation of AHs and APs; (ii) the LARP institutional organization; (iii) the various LARP implementation mechanisms (AH information disclosure, participation & consultation, grievance redress and monitoring); and, (iv) time schedules and budgets.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 10
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
1.2 Description of the Subproject 7. The D. G. Khan – Loralai 220kV transmission line subproject (Subproject No. 2.1; Tranche 3) will be constructed to provide another double circuit transmission line of extra high- tension voltage of power from the New D. G. Khan 500kV Grid Station (Subproject No. 5, Tranche 2). This transmission line, as shown in the following Figure 1.1 and Table 1.1, will traverse four districts, namely D. G. Khan district in Punjab province, and Bar Khan, Musa Khel and Loralai districts in Baluchistan province. Figure 1.1: Image of D. G. Khan – Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Subproject
The total length of this new transmission line is 245 km. As shown in Table 1.1 below, it traverses four districts, namely, the D. G. Khan district in Punjab province (62.5 km), and the remaining 182.5 km of it falls in three districts of Baluchistan province (42.8 km in Bar Khan, 24.0 km in Musa Khel and 115.4 km in Loralai district). The next Table 1.2 shows that of the total length of 245.0 km of this transmission line, only 10.4 km (4.3%) will traverse the productive lands, including fruit orchards and wheat-cum-maize farmlands with scattered wood trees belonging to a total of 126 farming households from 21 villages. Thus, the Subproject’s overall resettlement impacts on the affected communities will be quite insignificant.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 11
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table 1.1: Size of New Loralai 220kV Transmission Line by Provinces and Districts
Section of Transmission Line Total Length Total Area Number of No. Name of District (Province) (km) Traversed (ha) Towers 1 Punjab Province (sub-total-a): 62.51 187.52 198 1.1 D. G. Khan District 62.51 187.52 198 2 Baluchistan Province (sub-total-b): 182.51 547.44 557 2.1 Bar Khan District 42.78 128.27 129 2.2 Musa Khel District 23.98 71.95 73 2.3 Loralai District 115.74 347.22 355 Total (Subproject): 245.01 734.96 755 Table 1.2: Length of Transmission Line by Type of Land Traversed (Loralai 220kV TL) Section of TL Length of Traversed Land by Type (m) No. Name of District (Province) Productive Unproductive Total Land 1 Punjab Province (sub-total-a): 405.00 62,100.91 62,505.91 1.1 D. G. Khan District 405.00 62,100.91 62,505.91 2 Baluchistan Province (sub-total-b): 10,023.00 172,484.17 182,507.17 2.1 Bar Khan District 5,058.00 37,725.57 42,783.57 2.2 Musa Khel District 439.00 23,543.00 23,982.00 2.3 Loralai District 4,526.00 111,215.60 115,741.60 Total (Subproject): 10,428.00 234,585.08 245,013.08 Percentages: 4.26 95.74 100.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 12
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
2. PROJECT COMPENSATION AND REHABILITATION FRAMEWORK
9. This section compares the Pakistani laws and regulations on land acquisition and resettlement with the requirements of the ADB Policy on Involuntary Resettlement and details summarizes the main components of the policy framework prepared specifically for the project to ensure that ADB’s policy on involuntary resettlement is complied with (refer to Section 2.4). 10. The land acquisition and resettlement framework (LARF, 2006) prepared outset of this Power Transmission Enhancement MFF Project provides an exhaustive coverage of all possible land acquisition and resettlement impacts of the inclusive Subprojects, including permanent and temporary land acquisition for the grid station and transmission line, and the associated losses of assets. Depending on the type of land acquisition and the associated losses, only the applicable portions of LARF are included in this section for each Subproject. 11. This Subproject does not require any permanent land acquisition. It requires only temporary land acquisition with losses of agricultural crops, trees and likely damages to any built-up structures (like residential-cum-farm houses, boundary walls, water tanks, etc.). Therefore, only the relevant portions of LARF, and accordingly the entitlements, are included in following sub-sections.
2.1 Pakistan’s Law and Regulations on Land Acquisition and Resettlement
12. The 1894 Land Acquisition Act (LAA) with its successive amendments is the main law regulating land acquisition for public purpose. The LAA has been variously interpreted by local governments, and some province has augmented the LAA by issuing provincial legislations. The LAA and its Implementation Rules require that following an impacts assessment/valuation effort, land and crops are compensated in cash at market rate to titled landowners and registered land tenants/users, respectively. The LAA mandates that land valuation is to be based on the latest 5-3 years average registered land sale rates, though, in several recent cases the median rate over the past year, or even the current rates, have been applied. Due to widespread land under- valuation by the Revenue Department, current market rates are now frequently used with an added 15 per cent Compulsory Acquisition Surcharge as provided in the LAA. 13. Based on the LAA, only legal owners and tenants registered with the Land Revenue Department or possessing formal lease agreements, are eligible for compensation or livelihood support. The rights of the non-titled, are however addressed under the 1986 Punjab Jinnah Abadis for Non-proprietors in Rural Areas Act which recognize to squatters the right to receive rehabilitation in form of a replacement plot. It is to be noted that this right has been sometimes extended in practice to include some form of rehabilitation in cash or in forms different from land. Projects such as Chotiari Dam, Ghazi Barotha Hydropower, and National Highways Improvement, have awarded compensation and assistance to unregistered tenants and other forms of AH (sharecroppers/squatters). 14. It must also be noted that LAA does not automatically mandate for specific rehabilitation and/or assistance provisions benefiting the poor, vulnerable groups, or severely affected AHs, nor does it automatically provide for rehabilitation of income/livelihood losses or resettlement costs. This however is often done in many projects in the form of ad hoc arrangements based on negotiations between a specific EA and the AHs. 15. As noted above, exceptions to the rule are intrinsic to the fact that the law is both elastic and broadly interpreted at provincial level depending on operational requirements, local needs,
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 13
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
and socio-economic circumstances. Recourse is often taken to ad hoc arrangements, agreements and understandings for resettlement in difficult situations. The above is also influenced by the fact that an amendment of the LAA has been considered necessary by the Ministry of Environment. Accordingly, a National Resettlement Policy (NRP) and a Resettlement Ordinance have been drafted to broaden LAA provisions and current practices so as to widen the scope of eligibility and tightening up loopholes (i.e. regarding definitions of malpractices, cut- off dates, political influence on routing, etc.). But both these documents are still awaiting government’s approval for implementation. 2.2 ADB’s Involuntary Resettlement Policy 16. The ADB Policy on Involuntary Resettlement is based on the following principles: • Involuntary resettlement is to be avoided or at least minimized. • Compensation must ensure the maintenance of the AHs’ pre-project living standards. • Compensation is required for any AH who as a result of a project has their access to, or use of, land restricted. • AHs should be fully informed and consulted on LAR compensation options. • AHs’ socio-cultural institutions should be supported/used as much as possible. • Compensation will be carried out with equal consideration of women and men. • Lack of formal legal land title should not be a hindrance to rehabilitation. • Particular attention should be paid to households headed by women and other vulnerable groups, such as indigenous people and ethnic minorities, and appropriate assistance should be provided to help them improve their status. • LAR should be conceived and executed as a part of the project, and the full costs of compensation should be included in project costs and benefits. • Compensation/rehabilitation assistance to be paid prior to and demolition.
2.3 Comparison of Pakistan Land Acquisition Act and ADB Resettlement Policy
17. Table 2.1 below outlines the differences between Pakistani Law and ADB policy. Table 2.1 Pakistan and ADB Land Acquisition Policies Pakistan’s Land Acquisition Act ADB Involuntary Resettlement Policy
Crop losses compensation provided only to Crop compensation are provided to landowners registered landowners and lease/sharecrop tenants and sharecrop/lease tenants according to their (Non-registered are often deprived). shares whether they are registered or not
Tree losses are compensated o the basis of Tree losses are compensated according to actual officially fixed rates by the Forest and Horticulture worth of affected trees based on market rates. departments
Structures valuation based on official rates, with Valuation of built-up structures is based on current depreciation deducted from the structure gross market value/cost of new construction of the value. structure
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 14
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Pakistan’s Land Acquisition Act ADB Involuntary Resettlement Policy
Land Acquisition Collector (LAC) is the only pre- Complaints and grievances are resolved informally litigation final authority to decide disputes and through community participation in the Grievance address complaints regarding quantification and Redress Committees (GRC), local governments, assessment of compensation for the affected lands NGO and/or local-level community based and other assets organizations
2.4 Remedial Measures to Bridge the Gap
18. In principle, Pakistan Law and ADB Policy adhere not only to the objective of AH compensation, but also to the objective of rehabilitation. However, Pakistan law is unclear on how rehabilitation is to be achieved and in practice the provision of rehabilitation is left to ad hoc arrangements taken by local governments and specific project proponents. To clarify these issues and reconcile eventual gaps between Pakistan Law and ADB Policy, the EA prepared the LARF for the program1, ensuring compensation at replacement cost of all items, the rehabilitation of informal settlers, and the provision of subsidies or allowances for AHs that may be relocated, suffer business losses, or may be severely affected.
2.5 Legislation Relevant to Land Classification
19. In terms of application of the LARF prepared for the program, identifying the type of land affected is an important step in determining eligibility for compensation for land. Jurisdiction rather than use classifies land. Rural land includes irrigated land and un-irrigated land and is governed by the Land Revenue Act (1967) which must be read in conjunction with the LAA and other legislation that may also apply, including for example the Punjab Alienation of Land Act (1900), Colonization of Government Lands Act (1912) and the various Land Reform Regulations. Rural land falls under the jurisdiction of revenue districts. 20. Land, other than rural land, is urban and including all permutations there-under such as residential, commercial, built upon and buildable, and is governed by various regulations and ordinances including the People’s Local Government Ordinance (1972) for each province, Cantonments Act (1924), and Land Control Act (1952). Urban land falls under the jurisdiction of municipal and local government authorities. 21. While there are broad definitions of rural and urban land in the People’s Local Government Ordinances, such classifications are not immutable and have been, and are, changed by the Collector of Revenues and provincial governments over time. In general it is either the People’s Local Government Ordinances or the Land Revenue Act that determines the classification of land, however there are some cases where both applies and other cases where different legislation altogether can dictate jurisdiction and classification over land. Hence there is neither a universal classification nor legislation pertaining to the land that will be potentially affected under the program. 2.6 Compensation Eligibility and Entitlements for the Project 22. Land acquisition tasks under the program, and for this D.G. khan – Loralai subproject, will be implemented according to a compensation eligibility and entitlements framework in line with both Pakistan’s law/ regulation and ADB Policy. 23. A summary entitlements matrix is provided in Table 2.2 below.
1 The program’s LARF has been endorsed by NTDC and has been uploaded on ADB’s website.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 15
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table 2.2: Compensation and Entitlement Matrix Asset Specification Affected People Compensation Entitlements No Land compensation provided that land is rehabilitated/restored Farmer/Titleholder to former quality following completion of works. Compensation, in cash, for all damaged crops and trees as per item below No Land compensation provided that the land is Access is not Leaseholder rehabilitated/restored to former quality following completion of restricted and (registered or not) works. Compensation, in cash, for all damaged crops and trees as Arable existing or per item below Land current land use Sharecroppers Compensation, in cash or kind, for all damaged crops/trees as per will remain item below unchanged (registered or not) Agricultural Compensation, in cash or kind, for all damaged crops/trees as per workers item below Compensation, in cash, for all damaged crops/trees as per item Squatters below Land for land compensation with plots of equal value and productivity to the plots lost; or cash for affected land at Farmer/Titleholder replacement cost based on market value plus 15% compulsory acquisition surcharge and free of taxes, registration, and transfer costs All adverse Renewal of lease in plots of equal value/productivity of plots lost, Arable effects on land Leaseholder or Cash equivalent to market value of gross yield of affected land Land use (registered or not) for the remaining lease years (up to a maximum of 3 years). where independent of access is severity of Sharecroppers Cash compensation equal to market value of lost harvest share restricted impact (registered or not) once (temporary impact) or twice (permanent impact) and/or Agricultural Cash indemnity equal to salary (including portions in kind) for land use workers remaining part of agricultural year. will be 1 rehabilitation allowance equal to market value of 1 gross harvest Squatters affected (additional to crop compensation) for land use loss. 1 severe impact allowance equal to market value of gross harvest Farmer/Titleholder Additional for of affected land for 1 year (inclusive of winter and summer crop and Leaseholder severe impacts additional to standard crop compensation) (>10% of land Sharecroppers loss) 1 severe impact allowance equal to market value of harvest share (registered or not) (additional to standard crop compensation) 1 severe impact allowance equal to market value of gross harvest Squatters of the affected land for 1 year (inclusive of winter and summer crop and additional to standard crop compensation) Land x land through provision of plots comparable in value/location to plot lost; or cash for affected land at full replacement cost free of Residenti Titleholder al/ taxes, registration, transfer costs plus 15% compulsory acquisition Commer surcharge. cial Renter, Lesee 1-3 months allowance Land Accommodation in a government resettlement area or a self- Squatters relocation allowance Houses All relevant AHs, Cash compensation at replacement rate for affected structure/other and incl squatters fixed assets free of salvaged materials, depreciation or transaction Structure costs. Partial impacts full cash assistance to restore structure. s Crop compensation in cash at full market rate for one harvest All AHs, incl (either winter or summer) by default for impacts caused by tower Crops Crops affected squatters bases and perimeter, stringing and access. All other crop losses will be compensated at market rates based on actual losses. All AHs, incl Trees Trees affected Cash compensation shall reflect income replacement squatters Business owner: (i) Cash compensation equal to 1 year income, if Business Loss of business All AHs, incl loss permanent; (ii) cash compensation for the period of business Employm or employment squatters interruption, if loss temporary. Worker/employee: lost wages
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 16
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
ent indemnity for the business interruption period up to a max. of 3 months Relocatio Transport, Provision of sufficient allowance to cover transport expenses and All AHs so affected n transition costs livelihood expenses for one month. Communi Affected Rehabilitation/substitution of affected community/public Rehabilitation ty Community structures/utilities. Vulnerabl AH below Fin. Assistance Employment priority in project-related jobs. e povertyline
2.7 Eligibility
24. AHs entitled for compensation or rehabilitation provisions under the program are: • All AHs affected by restricted access to, or use of, land whether they have legal title/traditional land rights or not; • Owners of buildings, crops, trees, or other objects attached to the land; and • AHs losing business, income, and salaries. 25. Compensation eligibility will be limited by a cut-off date to be set for each subproject on the last date of the Resettlement Field Surveys (RFS). AHs who settle in the affected areas after the cut-off date will not be eligible for compensation. They will, however, be given sufficient advance notice, requested to vacate premises and dismantle affected structures prior to project implementation. Their dismantled structures will not be confiscated and they will not pay any fine or sanction. Forced eviction will only be considered after all other efforts are exhausted. 26. Cut-off Date: Compensation eligibility will be limited by a cut-off date fixed at 22nd April, 2008 for this D.G. Khan – Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Subproject, which was the last day of the RFS. During the RFS Consultations, the affected people/communities were informed of the cut-off-date. The participants were clearly told that any subsequent changes in the land use pattern would not entertained, and those AHs would not be eligible for any compensation or financial assistance. However, they would be given sufficient advance notice requesting them to vacate the TL’s corridor and dismantle all such affected structures and other establishments (if any) prior to subproject implementation. They will be allowed to reuse their salvaged material for free and they will not be asked to pay any fine for making those change. Forced eviction will only be considered after all other efforts are exhausted. The same information has also been included in PIB (Appendix 3: Public Information Brochure), to be translated into Urdu and distributed among the AHs after the finalization and approval of this LARP.
2.8 Strategy for Compensation of Land Affected by Towers
27. Besides the amended LAA, the NTDC has adopted the Telegraph Act (1885) (as amended) for the construction and maintenance of power transmission lines. The latter Act was originally framed for the construction of telegraphic poles during the British Era and later inherited by Pakistan upon independence. This Act was subsequently adopted by WAPDA for electric poles and supply lines, and eventually passed to NTDC. However, telegraphic or electric poles cover a much smaller area of land compared with transmission towers which have the potential to affect crops and grazing shrubs. The NTDC makes utmost efforts to minimize resettlement impacts, alternatively NTDC compensates affected farmers for their crop losses. 28. Thus, based on current Pakistani Law and NTDC’s practice, the land under the towers is not acquired permanently and therefore compensation is not required for land. For this Program, however, it was agreed between NTDC and ADB that the land under the tower will be acquired but would only require compensation in the case where (i) in rural areas, the tower hinders
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 17
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
access to the land under the tower for cultivation; and/or, (ii) in urban/residential areas, the tower restricts use of the land for housing development. Based on this principle it was established that the strategy for compensation of land affected by tower construction will be different for urban/residential land (and its potential for housing development) and agricultural land. In the case of urban/residential areas, the land under towers will be considered as being permanently affected and therefore it will be acquired and compensated in full. In the case of rural areas and agricultural land, as long as the towers provide sufficient clearance to allow the continuation of crop cultivation, the land will be considered to be temporarily affected (for the duration of tower installation and stringing of the lines) and therefore will not be acquired nor compensated. However, for towers with low-bars which would restrict the farmer’s access for cultivation activities, the land will be acquired permanently and compensated accordingly. 29. The construction of towers on agricultural land however will still require the provision of compensation for crops and loss of trees, for the area under the tower plus a small perimeter surrounding it (an access and working area). The area included in the perimeter has been assessed as 900 m2 for 220 kV towers. Furthermore, as the construction of towers involves a 3- tier process, namely: (i) preparation of the foundation; (ii) erection of the tower; and, (iii) stringing of the power cables, having potential of affecting three crops. Thus, compensation for a maximum of three crops will be paid to the affected farmers.
2.9 Compensation Entitlements
30. Entitlement provisions for AHs cover such impacts as land losses, house and buildings losses, crops and trees losses, a relocation subsidy, rehabilitation measures, and a business losses allowance based on tax declarations and/or lump sums. These entitlements are detailed below: • Agricultural land impacts will be compensated based on whether an AH’s access to, or use of, their land is restricted. For AHs whose access to, and use of, agricultural land is not restricted i.e. they can continue to cultivate the land, compensation will be for paid for the removed trees and damaged crops and built-up structures. Market rates will be assessed through a survey of prevalent land prices, carried out by local government financing institutions. • Houses, buildings, structures will be compensated in cash at replacement cost free of depreciation, salvaged materials, and transaction costs deductions. The compensation for houses/buildings will include the cost of lost water and electricity connections. • Crops: Cash compensation at current market rates for the net harvest actually lost being as it may the winter, the summer crop, or both. Crop compensation will be paid both to landowners and tenants based on their specific sharecropping agreements. • Trees: Cash compensation shall reflect income replacement (Section 2.10). • Community structures and public utilities: Will be fully replaced or rehabilitated so as to satisfy their pre-project functions.
2.10 Assessment of Compensation Unit Values
31. The methodology for assessing unit compensation values of different items is as illustrated as follows:
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 18
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
• Houses/buildings will be valued at replacement value based on cost of materials, type of construction, labor, transport and other construction costs. No deductions will be applied for depreciation, salvaged materials and transaction costs. • Agricultural crops will be valued at net market rates at the farm gate for the first year crop. In the eventuality that more than one-year compensation is due to the AHs the crops after the first will be compensated at gross market value. • Fruit trees will be valued based on age category (a. seedling; b. not yet productive; c. productive). Productive trees will be valued at gross market value of 1 year income for the number of years needed to grow a new tree with productive potential of lost tree. • Wood trees will be valued based on the market value of its wood, including hard timber, branches that may be used as firewood, etc.
2.11 Rehabilitation of Damaged Infrastructure and Farmlands
32. As included in the NTDC’s Contract Document (Annexure ‘C’), the construction Contractor will be required to fully safeguard all the public and private properties during the construction and stringing works, and if any damages occur during the works, fully rehabilitate the damaged infrastructure and restore the farmlands to their previous conditions. Normally, the Contractors themselves prefer to hire semi-skilled and unskilled local labour to economize on the cost of boarding, lodging and transportation, and for the security reasons. Moreover, NTDC will advise the Contractors to preferably hire local labour but that will not be a contractual obligation.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 19
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
3. ASSESSMENT OF IMPACTS
3.1 Introduction
3.1.1 Resettlement Field Surveys
33. The NTDC usually make sure that the pre-requisite of technical drawing showing line profile with on-ground tower spotting for carrying out the resettlement field surveys (RFS) of a Subproject. The resettlement surveys included detailed impact assessment by quantifying and costing the affected assets (structures, crops, trees, etc.) through a participatory approach, collection of socioeconomic data on AHs, and consultation with the men and women of AHs and the affected communities. 34. The RFS were carried out team on this Subproject by a 3-member team, consisting of one resettlement expert, and one male and one female field surveyor, accompanied by NTDC Engineers and technical survey team. To start with, the team conducted a preliminary field reconnaissance survey in the Subproject area from 18th to 21st March 2008, wherein some problem areas were identified and the technical survey team was advised to further avoid/minimize the likely resettlement impacts. After a thorough field review of the line profile by the Engineers, the Resettlement Team carried out detailed resettlement field surveys from 15th to 22nd of April 2008. Thus, NTDC has been fixed at 22nd April, 2008 as the cut-off-date for this Subproject. This means, no subsequent changes made in land use pattern or construction of any structure will be entertained for any compensation or assistance under this Subproject.
3.1.2 Minimization of Impacts
35. The NTDC usually takes all possible measures to safeguard against and/or minimize the likely adverse impacts on the local communities in the design and implementation of its power transmission enhancement subprojects. Accordingly, the following specific actions were taken to avoid/minimize the likely resettlement impacts of this D. G. Khan – Loralai 220kV transmission line subproject: * To avoid impacts of land acquisition and resettlement on the local farming community, the NTDC has located the new D. G. Khan – Loralai 220kV transmission line mostly on the barren lands, and only partly on the privately owned and cultivated farmlands, with minimum possible effect on seasonal agricultural crops and fruit and wood trees. and ; * The alignment of the transmission line was altered slightly at a number of places, by providing 118 Angle Markers (Angular Towers) in the design to avoid both compact village housing areas and most fruit (Almond) orchards. 36. As a result the new 220kV transmission line will traverse mostly the unproductive barren hilly lands (95.74%) and only minimally the private farmlands (4.26%), successfully avoiding all compact housing areas, and most almond orchards; only eight scattered stone-mud built structures and six small almond orchards will partially be affected. All the partially affected mud- built structures are presently used by the AHs for both residential and livestock keeping purposes. NTDC will avoid complete removal or damaging those structures (mud-stone houses) by raising the height of corresponding towers to provide sufficient clearance. But if any of those structures get partially damaged during the construction/stringing works, the AHs will be paid full compensation (Please, see also Paragraph Nos. 46 & 58, below). 3.1.3 Packaging of Subproject Construction
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 20
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
37. The construction of this relatively long (245 km) 220kV double circuit transmission line will be split into two Contract Packages. Both the Contractors will be expected work simultaneously in their respective reaches, and complete the construction, erection and stringing of towers, and rehabilitate damages to infrastructure and farmlands. As shown in the following Table 3.1, the first package will consist of initial 94.1 km length of transmission line, i.e., from D. G. Khan 500/220kV grid station to AM No. 66 (294 towers). The second package will consist of the remaining 150.9 km length of it beyond AM 66 up to Loralai 220kV grid station, including 52 Angle Markers (461 towers). Table 3.1: Construction Packages of Loralai 220kV Transmission Line
Number of Angle Length of Transmission Line Package No. Number of Towers Markers Meters Km
1 66 294 94,137.48 94.14 2 52 461 150,875.60 150.88 Total: 118 755 245,013.08 245.01
38. The first package includes a shorter line lenght for relatively harder works in crossing the Fort Monroe mountains, while the second package includes the longer line length because the terrain is of relatively lower elevation and includes small hills and plain lands, including the clustered farmland areas. Each package will be awarded for about two years (i.e., October 2009 to September 2011. The construction works will be initiated in barren hilly/rough reaches of the TL and carried out subsequently in the farmland areas, to further avoid/minimize its resettlement impacts.
3.2 Impacts of the Transmission Line
3.2.1 General Description
39. The new D. G. Khan – Loralai 220kV double circuit transmission line will be 245 km long, traversing four administrative districts in the Punjab and Baluchistan provinces. They are: D. G. Khan district in Punjab province; and Bar Khan, Musa Khel and Loralai districts in Baluchistan province. Table 3.2 below provides a break down of its length by the districts and provinces. Further detailed information on its temporary resettlement impacts are provided in Appendix 1: Working Tables.
Table 3.2: Size of New Loralai 220kV Transmission Line by Districts and Provinces Section of TL Total Length Area Traversed Number of No Name of District (Province) . (km) (ha) Towers 1 Punjab Province (sub-total-a): 62.51 187.52 198 1.1 D. G. Khan District 62.51 187.52 198 2 Baluchistan Province (sub-total-b): 182.51 547.44 557 2.1 Bar Khan District 42.78 128.27 129 2.2 Musa Khel District 23.98 71.95 73 2.3 Loralai District 115.74 347.22 355 Total (Subproject): 245.01 734.96 755
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 21
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
40. As said earlier, it will traverse mostly barren hilly and rough lands (95.74%), and minimally the tube-well irrigated farmlands (4.26%), as shown in Tables 3.3 and 3.4 below. No land will be acquired permanently. Nevertheless, the construction and installation works will partially affect eight private built-up structures, six almond orchards, seasonal agricultural crops, and fruit and wood trees. 41. This 245 km long 220kV transmission line Subproject will involve the construction of a total of 755 towers, of which there are 118 angle markers or angular towers (15.63%). Only 32 towers will be constructed in farmlands (4.24%), of which two angle markers will be constructed in almond orchards intercropped by wheat and maize crops. None of the 755 towers will be constructed in an urban or compact village housing areas, nor any of these towers will have a low-bar to restrict the future use of farmlands under the towers. Therefore, no tower land will be affected and acquired permanently. Table 3.3: Length of Transmission Line by Type of Land Traversed and Districts (Loralai TL) Section of TL Length of Traversed Land by Type (km) No. Name of District (Province) Productive Unproductive Total Land 1 Punjab Province (sub-total-a): 0.41 62.10 62.51 1.1 D. G. Khan District 0.41 62.10 62.51 Baluchistan Province (sub-total- 2 b): 10.02 172.48 182.51 2.1 Bar Khan District 5.06 37.73 42.78 2.2 Musa Khel District 0.44 23.54 23.98 2.3 Loralai District 4.53 111.22 115.74 Total (Subproject): 10.43 234.59 245.01
Percentages: 4.26 95.74 100.00
Table 3.4: Total Area of Land Traversed by Construction of New Loralai 220kV TL Section of TL Temporarily Affected Area of Land by Type (ha) No Name of District (Province) . Productive Unproductive Total Land 1 Punjab Province (sub-total-a): 1.22 186.30 187.52 1.1 D. G. Khan District 1.22 186.30 187.52 2 Baluchistan Province (sub-total-b): 30.07 517.37 547.44 2.1 Bar Khan District 15.17 113.10 128.27 2.2 Musa Khel District 1.32 70.63 71.95 2.3 Loralai District 13.58 333.65 3,47.22 Total (Subproject): 31.28 703.68 734.96 Percentages: 4.26 95.74 100.00
42. The construction of towers will affect agricultural farmlands only temporarily, and thus, require compensation for crops and trees lost from the area under the tower, and also in a small perimeter surrounding it. The area included in this perimeter has been assessed to be 900 m2 for a 220kV tower where up to a maximum of three crops are expected to be lost. Crops and trees will also be affected in the 30m wide TL Corridor (in-between the towers) during the stringing of power cables (Table 3.5). Crop cultivation under the towers and within the TL Corridor can
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 22
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
continue after the stringing of lines has taken place. During the stringing operations it is expected that one crop harvest will be lost. 43. Major crops grown in the subproject area are wheat in the rabi season (winter-spring), and maize in the kharif season (summer-autumn). This dominant cropping pattern of wheat- maize rotation covers almost all the affected farmland area (99.5%), while fodder and vegetables are grown on the remaining lands. Thus, the subproject’s impact assessment has been made on the basis of wheat and maize losses. The total farmland area to be temporarily affected by this subproject, in terms of crop losses, will be 31.28 ha. Table 3.6 below provides further details on affected crops. 44. The survey team was able to successfully avoid sixteen almond orchards and twelve villages by providing additional angle markers (angular towers) in the transmission line. However, six almond orchards could not be avoided, and thus, will be affected partially. The affected fruit tree species are almonds and berri (zizyphus), and wood tree species are, kikar (acacia), shisham (sisso), poplar/eucalyptus and willow are common. As shown in Table 3.7 below, a total of 356 trees will be affected; 152 are fruit trees (42.7%), and 204 trees are wood trees (57.3%). Table 3.5: Total Area of Temporarily Affected Farmlands by New Loralai 220kV TL Section of TL Temporarily Affected Farmland Area (m2) No. Name of District (Province) Towers TL Corridor Total Area 1 Punjab Province (sub-total-a): 1,800 10,350 12,150 1.1 D. G. Khan District 1,800 10,350 12,150 2 Baluchistan Prov. (sub-total-b): 27,000 273,690 300,690 2.1 Bar Khan District 15,300 136,440 151,740 2.2 Musa Khel District 900 12,270 13,170 2.3 Loralai District 10,800 124,980 135,780 Total (Subproject): 28,800 284,040 312,840 Table 3.6: Temporarily Affected Farmlands Area by Crops by Provinces/Districts (Loralai TL) Name of Province/District Total Affected Rabi Season Kharif Season No Name of Province/District Area (ha) Wheat (ha) Maize (ha) . 1 Punjab Province (sub-total-a): 1.22 1.22 1.22 1.1 D. G. Khan District 1.22 1.22 1.22 Baluchistan Province (sub-total- 2 b): 30.07 30.07 30.07 2.1 Bar Khan District 15.17 15.17 15.17 2.2 Musa Khel District 1.32 1.32 1.32 2.3 Loralai District 13.58 13.58 13.58 Total Farmland Area (ha): 31.28 31.28 31.28
Table 3.7: Number of Affected Fruit and Wood Trees by the Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Number of Affected Trees Percentages Type Fruit / Wood Trees Baluchist Fruit/Woo Punjab an Total d Overall A: Fruit Trees: (1) Almond Trees - 97 97 63.82 27.25
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 23
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Number of Affected Trees Percentages Type Fruit / Wood Trees Baluchist Fruit/Woo Punjab an Total d Overall (2) Berri (Zizyphus) 24 31 55 36.18 15.45 Sub-total (a): Fruit Trees: 24 128 152 100.00 42.70 B: Wood Trees: (1) Kikar (Acacia) 10 59 69 33.82 19.38 (2) Shisham (Sisso) 3 31 34 16.67 9.55 (3) Poplar/Eucalyptus - 65 65 31.86 18.26 (4) Willow / Other - 36 36 17.65 10.11 Sub-total (b): Wood Trees: 13 191 204 100.00 57.30 Total (Fruit+Wood): 37 319 356 - 100.00
45. Table 3.8 below shows that of the 152 affected fruit trees, there are 97 almond trees (63.8%) and 55 berri trees (36.2%). Of the 97 almond trees, 88 trees (90.7%) are found in the six partially affected compact orchards, remaining nine almond trees are found scattered. The 55 berri trees are all found scattered in and around the affected farmland areas. The 204 affected wood trees are found scattered in and around the affected farmland areas. Table 3.9 above shows that 191 wood trees will be affected in Baluchistan province, while only 13 wood trees will be affected in Punjab province. Among those, each of Kikar (acacia) and Poplar/Eucalypts trees account for one-third (33.8% and 31.9%, respectively), while each of the Shisham and Willow/Other tree species are about one-sixth (16.7% and 17.7% respectively).
Table 3.8: Number of Affected Fruit and Wood Trees by Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Number of Affected Trees Percentages Type Fruit / Wood Trees Baluchista Punjab n Total Fruit/Wood Overall A: Fruit Trees: (1) Almond Trees - 97 97 63.82 27.25 (2) Berri (Zizyphus) 24 31 55 36.18 15.45 Sub-total (a): Fruit Trees: 24 128 152 100.00 42.70 B: Wood Trees: (1) Kikar (Acacia) 10 59 69 33.82 19.38 (2) Shisham (Sisso) 3 31 34 16.67 9.55 (3) Poplar/Eucalyptus - 65 65 31.86 18.26 (4) Willow / Other - 36 36 17.65 10.11 Sub-total (b): Wood Trees: 13 191 204 100.00 57.30 Total (Fruit+Wood): 37 319 356 - 100.00
Table 3.9: Affected Sizes of Compact and Scattered Almond Orchards (Loralai 220kV TL) Tower Nos. No. of Affected Fruit Trees Intercropped No. Type of Baluchista with (Crops) (From – To) Orchard Punjab n Total
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 24
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Tower Nos. No. of Affected Fruit Trees Intercropped No. Type of Baluchista with (Crops) (From – To) Orchard Punjab n Total 1 286 – 289 Compact - 12 12 Wheat, Maize 2 487 – 490 Compact - 11 11 Wheat, Maize 3 501 – 504 Compact - 9 9 Wheat, Maize 4 508 – 511 Compact - 13 13 Wheat, Maize 5 694 – 698 Compact - 22 22 Wheat, Maize 6 708 – 713 Compact - 21 21 Wheat, Maize
Total (Subproject): - 88 88 -
46. In addition, a total of eight structures are likely to be affected (Table 3.10 below), seven structures are stone-mud built (six houses and a boundary wall), and one concreted water tank. All those structures fall partially within 30m wide corridor of the transmission line, and thus, are considered to be partially affected. But none of these structures are planned to be demolished, rather avoided by raising tower heights by 4-6m leg and body extensions to the corresponding towers. However, sufficient provisions have been made in the Budget (Section 8) to compensate the affected households for any unintended damages occurring to their likely affected built-up structures (Please, see also Paragraph No. 36 & 58 in this Section 3).
Table 3.9: Partially Affected Built-Up Structures by Loralai 220kV TL Subproject Tower Nos. Partially Affected Structure Affected Part (Dimensions/Area) (From - To) No. Type Built Length (m) Width (m) Area (m2) Boundary 011 – 012 1 Wall Stone-Mud 16.00 1.00 16.00 048 - 049 2 Mud-House Stone-Mud 10.00 6.00 60.00 048 - 049 3 Mud-House Stone-Mud 9.00 5.00 45.00 049 - 050 4 Mud-House Stone-Mud 20.00 15.00 300.00 049 - 050 5 Water Tank Concrete 5.00 4.00 20.00 051 - 052 6 Mud-House Stone-Mud 10.00 8.00 80.00 067 - 068 7 Mud-House Stone-Mud 20.00 16.00 320.00 Tube well 100 - 101 8 Room Stone-Mud 3.00 3.00 9.00 011 - 101 8 Total Structures: - - 850.00
47. As a result of the above discussed resettlement impacts, a total of 126 farming households (the self-cultivating landowners) will be affected by this Loralai 220kV transmission line Subproject. The following Table 3.10 shows breakdown of 126 affected households and population by the affected provinces and districts. Among them, no lease tenants, sharecroppers or female-headed households have been found affected. And, none of the 126 affected households (AHs) will lose 10% or more of their farm incomes. Thus, the overall resettlement impacts of this Subproject will be insignificant (further socioeconomic details on AHs are provided in the next Chapter 4).
Table 3.10: Affected Households and Populations by Provinces and Districts (Loralai TL)
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 25
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Affected Households Affected Average Province District Number Percentage Population HH Size Punjab sub-total-a: 10 7.94 101 10.10 D. G. Khan 10 7.94 101 10.10 Baluchistan sub-total-b: 116 92.06 1,131 9.75 Bar Khan 43 34.13 423 9.84 Musa Khel 7 5.56 70 10.00 Loralai 66 52.38 638 9.67
Total (Subproject): 126 100.00 1,232 9.78
3.2.2 Impacts of the Towers
48. The new 220kV transmission line will require the construction of a total 755 towers. No private or public land will be acquired permanently, as none of the new towers will be constructed in an established urban or a developing housing area, and sufficient clearance between the lowest tower bars and the ground will be provided to ensure access by tractors and allow affected farmers continued and unencumbered use of their land. 49. The farmlands under and around the towers will, however, be affected temporarily by the loss of crops and trees during a 3-tier process of tower construction, namely: (i) the excavation construction of foundations, (ii) erection of towers, and (iii) stringing of power cables. According to the Time Schedule (Section 9), this whole process is expected to be completed in a period of 18 to 20 months, thereby causing crop losses for up to three cropping seasons. Cash compensation will be paid to the affected farmers for the loss of their crops for three seasons, two rabi season (wheat crop) and one kharif seasons (maize crop). 50. The construction of the total 245 km length of the transmission line will involve the construction 755 towers. Of those, 723 towers (95.76%) will be located on unproductive hilly/rough lands, and only 32 towers (4.24%) will be located on private farmlands. No towers will affect any built-up structure. As explained in Section 2.8, for tower installation, crops and trees in an area not only under the tower, but also in a small perimeter surrounding it as the access, working and storage areas, will be affected during the construction works, which is assessed at an average size of 900 m2 per tower. 51. According to the following three tables (Table 3.11, 3.12 and 3.13), the 32 towers will temporarily affect 28,800 m2 (2.88 ha) of farmlands in terms of crop and tree losses. The construction of all these towers will affect seasonal agricultural crops (2 maize and 1 wheat crop) and fruit and wood trees, belonging to 32 AHs (i.e., one tower per AH). The construction of 723 towers on unproductive hilly/rough lands will affect no people, and thus, there will AHs/APs.
Table 3.11: Number of Towers by Type of Land Affected by Loralai 220kV TL Number of Towers of by Type of Land Section of TL Affected No Name of District (Province) . Productive Unproductive Total Land 1 Punjab Province (sub-total-a): 2 196 198 1.1 D. G. Khan District 2 196 198 Baluchistan Province (sub-total- 2 b): 30 527 557 2.1 Bar Khan District 17 112 129
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 26
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
2.2 Musa Khel District 1 72 73 2.3 Loralai District 12 343 355 Total (Subproject): 32 723 755 Percentages: 4.24 95.76 100.00
Table 3.12: Area of Land Traversed by Construction of New Towers (Loralai TL) Section of TL Area of Land under Towers by Type of Land No. Name of District (Province) Productive Unproductive Total Land
Punjab Province (sub-total-a): 1 1,800 176,400 178,200 1.1 D. G. Khan District 1,800 176,400 178,200 Baluchistan Province (sub-total- 2 b): 27,000 474,300 501,300 2.1 Bar Khan District 15,300 100,800 116,100 2.2 Musa Khel District 900 64,800 65,700 2.3 Loralai District 10,800 308,700 319,500 Total (Subproject): 28,800 650,700 679,500
Percentages: 4.24 95.76 100.00
Table 3.13: Temporarily Affected Farmlands by New 220kV Towers (Loralai TL)
Section of TL Number of Affected Area (900 m2/Tower) No. Name of District (Province) Towers in m2 Ha
Punjab Province (sub-total-a): 1 2 1,800 0.18 1.1 D. G. Khan District 2 1,800 0.18 Baluchistan Province (sub-total- 2 b): 30 27,000 2.7
2.1 Bar Khan District 17 15,300 1.53
2.2 Musa Khel District 1 900 0.09 2.3 Loralai District 12 10,800 1.08 Total (Subproject): 32 28,800 2.88
3.2.3 Impacts of the Lines
52. The 30m wide sections of the transmission line falling in-between the towers have been termed as TL Corridor, which will cause loss of crops and trees in affected farmlands only by the stringing of power cables. This final activity is usually carried out rapidly at one stretch of time and completed in one cropping season, for which one-time crop compensation will be paid to the affected farmers. The stringing of this relatively long transmission line will, however, take longer period than usual. That is, it will cover two consecutive cropping seasons, yet it will affect one crop of any of the two cropping seasons in different reaches.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 27
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
53. The Time Schedule (Section 9) and Resettlement Budget (Section 8), indicate that about 40% of stringing activity will be carried in kharif season of 2010, and the remaining 60% of it will be carried out in rabi season of 2010-11. Accordingly, the affected farmers will be paid compensation for their respective one crop (maize or wheat) to be affected. 54. Of the total 245.01 km length of the new transmission lines, a total 222.36 km length comes out to be as the TL Corridor (excluding the lands under towers, totaling at about 22.65 km). Of the 222.36 km length of TL Corridor, as Table 3.14 below show that only 9.47 km length of it traverses the productive farmlands. It will temporarily affect a total area 28.4 ha of the farmlands during the stringing activity. The crops and trees of a total of 126 AHs (all landowners) will be affected.
Table 3.14: Temporarily Affected Farmlands by TL Corridor (Loralai 220kV TL) Section of TL Length of Affected Area (30m Corridor) No. Name of District (Province) TL Corridor (m) m2 ha 1 Punjab Province (sub-total-a): 345.00 10,350.00 1.04 1.1 D. G. Khan District 345.00 10,350.00 1.04 Baluchistan Province (sub-total- 2 b): 9,123.00 273,690.00 27.37 2.1 Bar Khan District 4,548.00 136,440.00 13.64 2.2 Musa Khel District 409.00 12,270.00 1.23 2.3 Loralai District 4,166.00 124,980.00 12.50 Total (Subproject): 9,468.00 284,040.00 28.40
3.2.4 Other Impacts and Impacts Summary
55. As described above, the new Loralai 220kV transmission line will traverse mostly barren government owned lands (95.74%), and only partly privately owned irrigated farmlands totaling to 31.28 ha (4.26%). No land will be acquired permanently for this transmission line Subproject. Nevertheless, its construction and installation works will partially affect seasonal agricultural crops (wheat and maize), six small almond orchards, scattered fruit and wood trees, and eight stone-mud built structure (including six houses, one boundary wall and a concrete water tank). As a result, a total 126 landowner farmers will be affected (AHs); no tenants or sharecroppers will be affected. 56. A total 356 trees will require removal from the 30m wide corridor of the new transmission line. Of the 356 affected trees, there are 152 fruit trees (42.7%) and 204 (57.3%) are wood trees. Six Almond orchards will be affected only partially. Among the 152 affected fruit trees, 88 Almond trees (57.9%) are found in six compact Almond orchards, while 64 affected fruit trees (42.1%) are found scattered within the 30m wide corridor of the transmission line. Of the 64 scattered fruit trees, there are 40 Almond trees and 24 Berri (zizyphus) trees. Among the 204 affected wood trees, kikar (acacia) shisham (sisso), poplar/eucalyptus, willow, etc. are found scattered in the subproject area. 57. Compensation for the affected trees will be paid once, on initial removal. The compensation for fruit trees is assessed on the basis current market prices of average fruit production for the number of years required for fruiting maturity of the respective fruit trees. Each of the affected Almond and Berri trees has an average of 10 years long maturity period, and accordingly, the compensation will be assessed and paid to the Ahs. Compensation amount
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 28
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
for affected wood trees is based on current market rate of the wood. Further information on compensation is provided in Section 8 (Budget). 58. The eight built-up structures are likely to be partially affected in terms of unintended damages occurring during the construction and/or stringing works. In fact, these structures will not be demolished nor relocated, rather protected by providing sufficient vertical clearance from the live power cables by adding 4-6 m leg extensions to the corresponding towers. Nevertheless, sufficient budgetary provision has been made to compensate the affected households for any unintended partial damages occurring to those structures. 59. Moreover, the new transmission line will cross over the Fort Monroe National Park in D. G. Khan district of Punjab province, and (2) Multan – D. G. Khan – Loralai National Highway, at a number places in the Punjab and Baluchistan provinces. The NTDC will obtain No-Objection Certificates (NOCs), respectively, from the Punjab Forest Department and the National Highways Authority (NHA), prior to commencing civil works on this Subproject. 60. Besides, no community property resources (land, structures, etc.) or any business activities will be affected by the construction of the towers and/or stringing of transmission line cables. Moreover, there are no vulnerable or poor people among the total 126 AHs, as they are all found above the national poverty line, and they mostly live in joint/extended families to mutually share in the responsibilities and benefits which serve as a cushion against external economic shocks. 61. The overall impacts on the local communities will not be severe by any recognized standards, as the loss to incomes of the 126 AHs averages at 8.46%, and none will suffer a loss of 10% or more. To sum up, the overall resettlement impact of this D. G. Khan – Loralai 220kV transmission line Subproject comes out to be insignificant, and thus this Short LARP has been prepared.
3.3 Impacts on Affected Households
3.3.1 General
62. Construction of the new 245.01 km long 220kV double circuit transmission line will traverse mostly unproductive barren government lands (234.6 km) and partially tube-well irrigated farmlands (10.43 km) in the Punjab and Baluchistan provinces. The new transmission line will temporarily affect a total of 126 AHs with a total population of 1,232 persons (APs). They are all landowners, and no tenant or sharecropper will affected. Of the total 126 AHs, 124 AHs will suffer from loss of agricultural crops (2 AHs have no farmlands but with only trees affected), while 120 AHs will suffer from the loss of crops and trees both, and 8 AHs may also suffer from partial damage to stone-mud built structures.
3.3.2 Significance of Impacts
63. The overall impact of loss of crops and trees will be insignificant on all 126 AHs. All of them are relatively small to medium farmers with highly tube-well irrigated farmlands, and none of them will lose >10% of his total crop income. The 30m wide strip of land will be acquired temporarily as a working corridor for installation of the new towers and stringing of the power cables. 64. The transmission line will affect agricultural crops and trees, while only eight structures are partially affected. The affected households (AHs) will not be impacted by restricted access to, or use of their farmlands. Wheat and maize crops, and fruit and wood will be affected on a total of 31.28 ha of private lands and 356 trees (152 fruit trees and 204 wood trees) will be
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 29
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
removed from a 30m wide corridor of the new transmission line. The overall crop loss impact is insignificant as it averages at 8.46 per cent, ranges from 6.01 per cent to 9.64 per cent, and remains consistently below 10 per cent. 65. Moreover, as explained in the following Section 4, none of the 126 AHs are vulnerable (or include individually vulnerable people), as their incomes are such that they are above the national poverty line, and they live predominantly in a joint/extended family system which serves as a safety net against external economic shocks. None of the 126 AHs were found to be headed by a widow or a disabled person. Finally, the overall community impact (i.e. village level) will be negligible to just minor, as only a 30m wide strip of their productive/unproductive lands will be affected temporarily and mostly out of the compact village housing areas.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 30
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
4. SOCIO-ECONOMIC PROFILE OF AFFECTED PEOPLE
4.1 Census of Affected Households
4.1.1 Field Methodology 66. The field methodology included carrying out Resettlement Field Surveys, including a 100% Census of AHs, accompanied by community consultation (refer to Section 6). The field survey was carried out from 15th to 22nd April 2008. The survey included questions about the socio-economic characteristics of AHs in order to obtain necessary information about their livelihoods and conditions. The findings are presented in this section. 4.1.2 General Information on Affected Households 67. The new 220kV double circuit transmission lines will affect 126 households by crops and tree losses, and 8 of them are likely to suffer also from partial damages to their stone built mud- houses. The transmission lines traverse mostly barren lands and partially (4%) productive farmlands of two provinces, in Punjab, D.G. Khan District 10 households are affected. In Punjab Province, the affected households are: Bar Khan District 43; Musa Khel District 7 ; and Loralai District 66. All the AHs are landowners. Of the total 126 AHs, 7.94% belong to Punjab Province and 92.6% belong to Baluchistan Province.
Table 4.1: Location and Number of Affected Households Affected Households Province District Landowners Tenants Number Percentage Punjab sub-total-a 10 7.94 10 0 D. G. Khan 10 7.94 10 0 Baluchistan sub-total-b 116 92.06 116 0 Bar Khan 43 34.13 43 0 Musa Khel 7 5.56 7 0 Loralai 66 52.38 66 0 Total (Subproject): 126 100.00 126 0
68. Moreover, as shown in Table 4.2 below, the 126 AHs have a total population of 1,232 persons (APs). All AHs are landowners and self-cultivators, having no sharecroppers or tenants.
Table 4.2: Affected Households and Population by Tenurial Status (Loralai TL Subproject) Affected Households Affected Province District Landlords Tenants Population Punjab sub-total-a 10 - 101 D. G. Khan 10 - 101 Baluchistan sub-total-b 116 - 1,131 Bar Khan 43 - 423 Musa Khel 7 - 70 Loralai 66 - 638 Total (Subproject): 126 - 1,232
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 31
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
69. Almost all the participants in the fielkd survey were the heads of household. All the 88 AHs are Muslim and ethnically and linguistically Baloochi/Pukthuns. In terms of social groups, there are six major clans of original Baloch/Pukthun, as described in the following Table 4.3.
Table 4.3: Distribution of Affected Households by Social Groups (Loralai TL Subproject) Punjab Baluchistan Province Overall D.G. Khan Bar Khan Musa Khel Loralai No. Clan District District District District Total % 1 Baloch 10 4 7 21 16.67 2 Hasni 11 11 8.73 3 Kakar 47 47 37.30 4 Khethran 27 27 21.43 5 Nasir 19 19 15.08 6 Syed 1 1 0.79 Total: 10 43 7 66 126 100.00
4.1.3 Indigenous People
70. None of the AHs are tribal or minority members and all affected land is held in private ownership (i.e. no tribal or communal ownership). Similarly, none of AHs were found to be vulnerable (headed by either females, disabled/aged persons or poor). 71. Therefore the standard provisions of the LARF and this LARP are sufficient to ensure an effective compensation process and the requirements of ADB Policy on Indigenous People are complied with. The ADB’s policy, as specified in the Indigenous Peoples Development Framework (IPDF) prepared for this project is not triggered, and therefore neither an IPDP nor special action is required for this subproject.
4.2 Data on Heads of Affected Households
72. All heads of household are male, 95 % are headed by married men while 5% are widowed men, and only one AH was headed by an unmarried man, in all married cases the spouse lives in the same household (i.e. none are separated). 73. Most of the household heads are between 41 and 60 years old and those of the remaining 4 AHs are between 61 and 75 years old, while none among them is a younger than 40 years. There are no elderly AHs (older than 75 years). 74. In terms of literacy and education,32 out of 101 participants in Punjab Province claimed to be literate i.e. 31.7% of participants were literate. This ratio amongst men was 46.2% whilst only 16.6% women were literate. In Baluchistan Province 252 out of 1131 participant claimed to be literate. This ratio amongst men was 30.3% whilst only 14.2% women were literate.
4.3 Data on Affected Households and Population
4.3.1 Households 75. Households in the subproject area are large. Household size in the Punjab Province was 10.1, the maximum was 14 whereas the minimum was 7. In Baluchistan Province, the household size was 9.75, the maximum being 21 whereas the minimum was 5. Average household size in different districts of Baluchistan was: Loralai 9.67; Bar khan 9.00; and Musa Khel 10.00. Household size in Pakistan is positively correlated to income in Pakistan. (refer to Table 4.4).
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 32
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table 4.4: Affected Households and Population by Province (Loralai TL Subproject) Number of Persons per Household (Household Size)
No. of Minimum Maximum Average Affected Province AHs Population (A) Punjab 10 7 14 10.1 101 (B) Baluchistan 116 5 21 9.75 1131 Total 126 5 21 9.78 1,232
76. Table 4.5 provides details on household size and their gender composition by Province. Overall, the male population accounts for 50.3% the total affected population of 1,232 persons.
Table 4.5: Gender Composition of Affected Households (Loralai TL Subproject) Household Size (No. of Persons) Affected Province Gender Minimum Maximum Average Populatio n (A) Punjab Male 3 8 5.2 52 (10 AHs) Female 3 8 4.9 49 (B) Baluchistan Male 2 12 4.9 568 (116 AHs) Female 1 9 4.9 563 Male 2 12 4.9 620 Overall (126 AHs): Female 1 9 4.9 612 77. As seen in Table 4.6, adults account for two-fifths of the AP population (41%) and older adults account for 12.3%, and together these 53.3% APs take care of the household economy. The children and youth account for the remaining 36.7% of APs. Table 4.4: Age and Gender Composition of AHs Age Age Group (Years) Percentage Children Up to 15 19.7 Youth 16 – 25 27.0 Adults 26 – 60 41.0 Older Adults Above 60 12.3 Total All Ages 100.0
4.3.2 Housing 78. None of the AHs live in simple dwellings (constructed of thatch, sack, bamboo, clay or earth). All respondents stated that they live in houses constructed of brick and concrete. 4.3.3 Livelihood and Incomes 79. As all AHs rely on farming most, if not all of their income, the tenure of agricultural land is an important factor in terms of security and sustainability of livelihood. Among the AHs, all the land owners in the RFS stated they are the registered land owners; there are no sharecroppers amongst the AHs. There are no AHs that rent or lease agricultural land, no households that claim ownership, and no squatters. All the AHs are landowner farmers. Table 4.6 shows that the
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 33
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
total farm size of almost all the affected households is relatively large, as its overall average stands at 2.94 Ha and ranges from 0.76 Ha to 10.32 Ha. Table 4.6: Farm Size of Affected Households
No. AHs Total Farm Size (ha) Province (Actual: 126) Minimum Maximum Average (A)Punjab 10 1.24 2.02 1.34 (B)Baluchistan 116 0.76 10.32 3.07 Sum-Total: 126 0.76 10.32 2.94
80. As shown in Tables 4.7 agriculture is the sector that accounts for 79% and 97% of APs engaged in livelihood in Punjab and Baluchistan respectively .Men comprise 97% and 100% of the agricultural activity in Pi=Punjab and Baluchistan. Females contribute about 4.5% of the household income in Punjab whereas in Baluchistan no women were reported to be activity involved in any commercial activity Table 4.7: Sector-Wise Average Incomes by Gender of Affected Households
Involvement of APs by Gender Income Punjab (000 Rs..) Sector Sector Men Women Total (%) Agriculture 1541 41 1582 79 Business 87 0 87 4 Employment 156 0 156 8 Misc. 120 50 170 9 Total 1904 91 1995 100 Involvement of APs by Gender Income Baluchistan (000 Rs..) Sector Sector Men Women (%) Agriculture 43586 0 43586 97 Business 315 0 315 1 Employment 528 0 528 1 Misc. 550 0 550 1 Total 44979 0 44979 100
4.3.4 Poverty Level 81. The national poverty line is estimated to be Rs. 849 per person per month. Based on the data provided in the RFS, there are no AHs that fall on or below the poverty line. Average per capita monthly incomes are Rs 2,375 and 4,085 in Punjab and Baluchistan respectively. With minimum incomes of Rs 1,238 and 1,125 in Punjab and Baluchistan respectively. Figure 4.8 presents the summary of the monthly income by province. Table 4.8: Monthly per Capita Income of Affected Households
No. of Monthly Per Capita Income (Rs) Province AHs Minimum Maximum Average Punjab 10 1,238 2,923 2,375 Baluchistan 116 1,125 6,712 4,085 Total 126 1,238 6,712 3,926
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 34
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
4.3.5 Literacy
82. Table 4.9 shows an overall literacy rate of APs of 31.68% and 22.58% in Punjab and Baluchistan respectively. Male literacy rates are 46.15% and 30.28% in Punjab and respectively, whilst female literacy rates are much lower at 16.23% and 14.21% in Punjab and Baluchistan respectively Table 4.9: Literacy by Age and Gender of APs
Total No. of APs Punjab-Literacy Level Male Female Overall Total No. of APs 52 49 101 Literate APs (No.) 24 8 32 Illiterate APs (No.) 28 41 69 Literacy Rate (%) 46.15 16.33 31.68 Total No. of APs Baluchistan-Literacy Level Male Female Overall Total No. of APs 568 563 1,131 Literate APs (No.) 172 80 252 Illiterate APs (No.) 396 483 879 Literacy Rate (%) 30.28 14.21 22.28
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 35
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
5. INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS
83. The compensation and rehabilitation program described in this LARP involves a number of agencies including, NTDC as the implementing agencies, the Environmental Protection Agencies of Punjab and Baluchistan, Provincial Governments of Punjab and Baluchistan, and district governments of D.G.Khan in Punjab, and Bar Khan, Musa Khel and Loralai in Baluchistan, as detailed below.
5.1 National Transmission and Dispatch Company
84. NTDC as the prime executing agency (EA), bears the overall responsibility for the preparation, implementation and financing of all tasks set out in this LARP, as well as, inter- agency coordination, and monitoring and evaluation activities required the LARP preparation, implementation, and monitoring and evaluation. Institutionally, as shown in Figure 5.1 overleaf, NTDC has three functional divisions, namely the Planning, Projects and Grid Station Construction divisions. 85. The Planning Division is responsible for planning and preparation of subprojects and keeping liaison with the Government of Pakistan and Asian Development Bank (ADB), as the donor of this Project. This division is currently being assisted by the PPTA Consultants2, including a Resettlement Expert responsible for LARP preparation), in preparing the identified subprojects in line with the ADB Policies and obtaining approval from the donor ADB. 86, The Projects Division is responsible for the overall management and coordination of the subprojects. Its major functions include, keeping regular liaison with ADB and relevant departments of the federal and provincial governments, updation of LARP and its monitoring and evaluation activities. In addition, the Project Management Unit takes care of the overall coordination and liaison with the Government of Pakistan and ADB. It will be assisted by the Project Management Consultants team, including a Resettlement Specialist, to be hired shortly3. Secondly, the Environmental and Social Impact Cell is responsible for the updation and internal monitoring of LARPs of approved Subprojects. It will be assisted by the Resettlement Specialist in the external Monitoring and Evaluation Consultants team to be hired shortly4. 87. The Grid Station Construction Division is responsible for implementing the Subprojects, including LARP preparation/updation and implementation. GM GSC is the final approving authority for the compensation to be paid to the AHs for their affected assets. This large division is divided into two geographical regions, each headed by a Chief Engineer. They are EHV – I (Northern Region, Lahore) and EHV – II (Southern Region, Hyderabad). The D. G. Khan to Loralai 220kV Tranmission Line Subproject falls under the jurisdiction of EHV – II (Hyderabad), where a Project Director as head of the Project Implementation Unit (PIU), along with an Executive Engineer and Sub-Divisional Officers (Junior Engineers) will be managing the construction works. 88. Besides, each regional EHV has an in-house Land Acquisition Collector (LAC), who along with his field staff, an Assistant Land Acquisition Officer (Tehsildar) and Patwaris will take care of the updation (if required) and implemtation of the LARP. The NTDC LAC normally works as an independent entity, but in case of local needs like price updation, grievance redressal, etc., involves the respective District Government, especially the District Coordination Officer
2 British Power International (BPI), a UK Based firm. 3 The hiring Projectv Management Consultants team is under process of selection (proposals are being evaluated). 4 The hiring of Monitoring and Evaluation Consultants team is under process of selection (proposals are being evaluated).
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 36
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
(DCO / District LAC), Union Council Nazims, and other local leaders, and/or the Provincial Revenue Boards, for addressing broader matters and resolving permanent Land Acquisition issues (not applicable to this Subproject). In addition, the NTDC LAC will be obtaining technical assistance from the Resttlement Specialists in both the Project Management Consultants and external Monitoring and Evaluation Consultants teams.
Figure 5.1: NTDC Organization for LARP Planning, Implementation and Monitoring
Chief Executive, NTDC
General Manager, General Manager, Projects General Manager, Grid Station Planning (GM Planning) (GM Projects) Construction (GM, GSC)
Project Chief Engineer, Project Chief Engineer, Director, EHV-II, Preparation EHV-I, Lahore Project Hyderabad Consultants Preparation (PPTA/BPI) (PD PPTA)
Project Project Director Manager, Project Project Director Management Unit Management Project Project (PMU) Consultants Implementation Implementation Unit (PIU) Unit (PIU)
Environmental and Environmental and Social Impacts Social Monitoring XEN & SDOs XEN & SDOs Cell (ESIC) Consultants
Land Land Acquisition Provincial Boards of Revenue Acquisition Collector (For Land Acquisition) Collector (LAC) (LAC)
District LACs, Tehsildars/Patwaris Assistant Land Assistant Land (For Land Acquisition) Acquisition Acquisition Officer (ALAO) Affected Officer (ALAO) Households / Tehsildar/Patwari Communities Tehsildar/Patwari
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 37
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
5.2 Environmental Protection Agency
89. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), based in Islamabad, is a subsidiary organization of the Ministry of Environment; represented by the regional EPAs in all the four provinces. Two of the regional EPAs, the Punjab EPA based in Lahore and Baluchistan EPA based in Quetta, will be involved in this TL Subproject. 90. Obtaining formal approval the IEE/EIAs along LARPs from the respective regional EPAs has been mandatory under the Environmental Protection Law, 1997 for all the infrastructure development projects/subprojects. The same rule applies to the NTDC’s Power Tranmission Enhancement Project, and its inclusive Subprojects. Thus, approval of the IEE report along with this LARP for this TL Subproject will be required from EPAs Punjab and Baluchistan. The NTDC’s Environmental and Social Impacts Cell (ESIC) has the additional responsibility to this.
5.3 Federal and Provincial Governments
90.. The NTDC usually approaches and ijnvolves the respective provincial governments and the federal government involved in the Subprojects requiring permanent land acquisition and/or for obtaining No-Objection Certificates (NOCs) from the respective departments for traversing or affecting major government infrastructure and resources, like major roads, railway lines, canals, forests, rangelands, wildlife sanctuaries/protected areas, etc. The respective Provincial Boards of Revenue (PBR) are involved by NTDC when it needs to acquire land on permanent basis for the construction of a new grid station. This is not the case in this TL Subproject, involving the construction of a 220kV transmission line5, requiring no land acquisition but compensation for the partially affected crops, trees and structures. Thus, it is assumed that the NTDC LAC will take care of the LARP implementation, and will not require any major involvement of the provincial government in doing. 5.4 District Governments and Union Councils 91. The respective District Governments have jurisdiction for land administration, valuation and acquisition. At the provincial level these functions rest with the Board of Revenue while at district level they rest with the District Coordination Office (DCO) and the Land Acquisition Collector (LAC) within the DCO office. The Tehsildars and a number of minor agents, most notably the Qanungos (land Surveyors) and Patwari, (land records clerk), carry out specific roles such as titles identification and verification (see Figure 5.2). Their major involvement is usually sought by NTDC for permanent land acquisition for constructing new grid stations and other similar facilities. Functions pertaining to compensation of assets different from land (i.e. buildings, crops and trees) or income rehabilitation also may fall on local governments, more specifically the respective district departments. 92. The NTDC LAC and PIU Engineers usually resolve the issues and redress grievances related to clearing of TL ROW and compensation for affected assets through dialogue and negotiations with AHs and local community leaders. But where they can not succeed, they will approach the respective District Governments, Union Councils and community leaders for seeking their assistance in getting such land and asset related disputes and issues resolved, assessing/revising the compensation costs, and redressing outstanding grievances of the affected households/communities. In short, NTDC will make all out efforts to resolve all the issues and redress grievances in an informal pre-litigation manner, to avoid delays and ensure smooth execution of the Subproject works.
5 The New Grid Station (D. G. Khan 500kV and Loralai 220kV) have been included as separate Subprojects in Tranche 2 of this MFF.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 38
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Figure 5.2: Organization of District Land Acquisition Collector Office
DCO & Nazim District Coordination Officers and District Nazim (Elected)
EDO-R / LAC Executive District Officer (Revenue) (Land Acquisition Collector)
Tesildar / Naib Tehsildar Land Acquisition Officers (LAO)
Qanungo and Patwari Land Surveyor and Land Records Clerk
5.5 Grievance Redress Committee
93. To get the outstanding disputes resolved and grievances redressed effectively, NTDC will request the respective District Governments and Union Councils for assistance by forming a formal grievance redressal committee (GRC) at each district of the Subproject’s affected area. NTDC’s PIU and LAC will inform all the affected communities of the formation of the same and advise them to file their complaints with the GRC to be established at their respective district headquarters. The GRC’s structure is shown in Figure 5.3 below, and its scope and functions are described in Chapter 7 (Grievance Redress Process).
Figure 5.3: Structure of a Grievance Redressal Committee at Each District
DCO / Nazim
(Chairman)
District LAC / Union Council XEN / SDO, LAC / ALAO, Tehsildar Nazim PIU, NTDC NTDC (Member 1) (Member 2) (Member 3) (Member 4)
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 39
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
6. CONSULTATION AND DISCLOSURE
6.1 Consultation Undertaken for the LARP
94. The consultative process undertaken for the preparation of the LARP has included not only AHs, but also representatives of local governments in the subproject area. Special attention was paid to identify the needs of vulnerable groups (such as the poor, women, and elderly), to ensure that their views have been considered in the formulation of the LARP. 95. Consultation with stakeholders at the different stages of the subproject is required by ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement and as provided for in the LARF. To start with, consultations with the AHs were conducted as part of the RFS. The communities’ and especially the AHs’ responses to the proposed subproject were found to be positive. 96. Along with the participatory RFS and interviewing of AHs, semi-structured discussions aiming at community awareness and consultations regarding the project’s likely impacts were also held with the small groups of men and women, including AHs, other stake holders and notables of the area along the proposed transmission line. Forty group discussions and consultations were held (20 men and 20 women groups) in three villages in Punjab Province and seventeen villages in Baluchistan Province. The total number of participants was 208; including 129 men and 113 women, as shown in the table 6.1 overleaf and as set out in Appendix 2.
97. The concerns raised during the consultation sessions, namely, the adequacy and timeliness of the compensation payments, safety measures, etc., have been addressed by NTDC in this LARP, by making payment of crop and tree compensations to all the AHs at least one month (30 days) prior to the temporary use of their farmlands (before starting the civil works), and instructing the Contractor/s to take all possible safety measures during the entire the Subproject execution period, especially during the construction and stringing activities. 98. The local communities’ responses (awareness, perceptions and preferences) to the subproject and resettlement related matters are summarized as follows: • This subproject is necessary under the current local conditions. • Crop and tree compensation should be fair and timely • Skill and unskilled labor should be used locally. • Electricity should be provided to the affected villages which are still without electricity.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 40
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table 6.1: Participants in Group Discussions and Consultations
Province No. of Groups No. of Participants District/Village Men Women Total Men Women Total Punjab 3 3 6 15 13 28 D.G.Khan District 3 3 6 15 13 28 Basti Shikar Khan 11244 8 Rajhani Village 11244 8 Village Gamuli 11275 12 Baluchistan 17 17 34 114 100 214 Bar Khan District 6 6 12 41 37 78 Pailia Thal 11288 16 Mir Hamadani Killi 11244 8 Basti Khaprani 11243 7 Basti Kaurri 1 1 2 12 11 23 Deh Bhebani 11243 7 Rarkan Village 11298 17 Musa Khel District 2 2 4 11 10 21 Village Rarrasham 11255 10 Gidar Daag 11265 11 Loralai District 9 9 18 62 53 115 Mekhtar Village 1 1 2 12 10 22 Ashberg Village 1 1 2 9 8 17 Indah Village 1 1 2 9 8 17 Sehan Gharra Village 11265 11 Shabozai Village 11265 11 Masood Killi 11263 9 Sagor Village 11254 9 Bala Killi Tattai 11265 11 Naway Bawar Killi 11235 8 Total 20 20 40 129 113 242
6.2 Compensation Options Discussed
99. In addition to the focus group discussions and consultative meetings described above, the RFS included a questionnaire with several questions regarding AHs’ preferences for compensation and rehabilitation options. This information has been and will be used to assist in determining the support measures required by AHs. 100. The first compensation priority of all AHs is for cash, rather than land or a combination of cash and land. When asked why they preferred cash compensation, half of all AHs stated the reason was to assist with daily living expenses as they will loose their livelihood in the shape of crops. 101. In summary, the compensation and resettlement options discussed and agreed upon during the consultation meetings included:
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 41
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
• Relocation - not applicable; • Assistance - not applicable; • Compensation – the majority of AH representatives look forward to receiving a “fair” and “timely” compensation for their lost/affected crops and trees. By “fair”, they meant the application of prevalent open market rates, or “replacement value” for their affected crops and trees. By “timely”, they meant prior to the temporary use of their lands and sustaining any damage to or removal of their crops and trees, as provided for in the LARF; • Job opportunities - the more disadvantaged people in the villages requested that NTDC assist them with job opportunities with the contractors, on a priority basis, during project implementation.
6.3 LARP Disclosure
102. An English version of the program’s LARF has already been uploaded to ADB’s website and an Urdu version has been made available through NTDC’s headquarters and PIUs in Subproject areas (second tranche). 103. In line with ADB’s public communications policy, this LARP in English will also be posted on the ADB website, while its translation in Urdu will be disclosed to the AHs at the Dera Ghazi Khan/Loralai PIU office and posted on the ADB website. 104. In addition, a public information booklet in Urdu, summarizing compensation provisions will be sent to all AHs (a draft booklet in English has been prepared as provided in Appendix 3).
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 42
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
7. GRIEVANCE REDRESS PROCESS
105. A grievance mechanism will be available to allow an AH appealing any disagreeable decision, practice or activity arising from land or other assets compensation. AHs will be fully informed of their rights and of the procedures for addressing complaints whether verbally or in writing during consultation, survey, and time of compensation. 106. Care will always be taken to prevent grievances rather than going through a redress process. This can be obtained through careful LAR design and implementation, by ensuring full participation and consultation with the AHs, and by establishing extensive communication and coordination between the community and the PMU. 107. As there is no land acquisition involved, the Office of LAC will not be involved, rather funds will move directly from NTDC to the AHs. The complaint and grievances will be addressed through two different processes as described in Table 7.1. Table 7.1: Grievance Resolution Process Land & Crop Compensation Issues Other Compensation or Project Issues 1. First, complaints resolution will be attempted at 1. First, complaints resolution will be attempted village level through the involvement of the LARU, NGO at village level through the involvement of the LARU, and informal mediators. NGO and informal mediators.
2. If still unsettled, a grievance can then be 2. If still unsettled, a grievance can be lodged to lodged to LAC who has 30 days to decide the case. the PIU/LARU, which will have 30 days to respond.
3. If no solution was reached a grievance can be 3. If no solution was reached a grievance can be lodged with support of the LCC to the PMU. The AH lodged with support of the LCC to the PMU. The AH must lodge the complaint within 1 month of lodging the must lodge the complaint within 1 month of lodging the original complaint with the LAC and must produce original complaint with the LAC and must produce documents supporting his/her claim. The PMU will documents supporting his/her claim. The PMU will provide the decision within 21 days of registering the provide the decision within 21 days of registering the complaint. The PMU decision must be in compliance complaint. The PMU decision must be in compliance with this LARF provisions. with this LARF provisions.
4. Should the grievance redress system fail to 4. Should the grievance redress system fail to satisfy the AH, they can further submit their case to the satisfy the AH, they can further submit their case to the appropriate court of law as per the process set out in appropriate court of law as per the process set out in Sections 18 to 22 of the LAA (1894). Sections 18 to 22 of the LAA (1894).
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 43
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
8. BUDGET FOR LAND AND ASSET ACQUISITION
8.1 Basis for Compensation
108. Compensation for projects affecting people’s assets can often differ between the borrower and ADB (and other providers of official development assistance). To comply with ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement, rates used to compensate for lost land and assets must be replacement cost at current market value, in order to meet the policy objective of “at least” restoring people’s livelihoods and ensuring that people affected by a project are not left worse off. 109. According to the project’s LARF, replacement cost is the amount of cash or kind needed to replace an asset in its existing or better condition, and is the value determined as compensation for the current market price without depreciation or deduction of the costs of any transaction or for any material salvaged. The processes for establishing the rates used for the D. G. Khan – Loralai 220kV double circuit transmission line subproject followed the methodology of LARF.
8.2 Determining the Rates for Compensation
110. Based on the foregoing requirements of ADB resettlement policy and the LARF provisions, the methodology for assessing unit compensation values of different items affected by the subproject is described as follows: • The eight built-up structures likely to be partially affected will be compensated for the actual loss of the structures, at the local costs of reconstruction (material plus labor). The AHs will be allowed to keep salvaged material without any deductions from the compensation amount. • Basic annual crop compensation was valued at net farm-gate market rates. If additional crops compensation is due it will be calculated at market value minus inputs. As noted earlier, compensation for crops affected by tower bases and perimeters is three-crop and for stringing of the lines is for one-crop; and • Productive fruit trees were valued at gross market value of one year’s income multiplied by the number of years needed to grow a new tree with the productive potential of the lost tree. Wood trees were valued based on type, size, and age (dimensions/volume). The AHs are entitled to keep the wood (as salvaged material) without any deductions. 111. The valuation survey registered recent current construction costs of the likely partially affected built-up structures through local masons and house-owners, and current market sale rates of the crops, fruits and wood, together with the AHs and community consultation (including relevant local government agencies). The results of valuation survey are provided in the tables below. 112. A total of eight built-up structures, including six stone-mud built houses and one boundary wall, and a concrete water tank, are likely to be partially affected by the TL construction and stringing activities. Though none of these structures are planned to be demolished or relocated, and the corresponding towers will be raised by 4-6 m leg/body extensions to provide sufficient vertical clearance between the live 220kV cables and the roof- tops of these structures. Yet the compensation costs are assessed in case the structures get affected during the subproject implementation activities. The reconstruction costs were collected
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 44
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
from local masons and landowners who have recently constructed similar structures in the subproject area. The following Table 8.1 provides the extent of likely damaged covered area, and the maximum amount of compensation to the AHs.
Table 8.1: Maximum Compensation Cost for Partially Affected Structures (Loralai 220kV TL)
Tower Nos. Affected Structure Affected Compensation Assessed Area (From - To) No. Type Built (m2) Rate (Rs./m2) Amount (Rs.) 011 - 012 1 Boundary Wall Stone-Mud 16.00 425 6,800 048 - 049 2 Mud-House Stone-Mud 60.00 425 25,500 048 - 049 3 Mud-House Stone-Mud 45.00 425 19,125 049 - 050 4 Mud-House Stone-Mud 300.00 425 127,500 049 - 050 5 Water Tank Concrete 20.00 675 13,500 051 - 052 6 Mud-House Stone-Mud 80.00 425 34,000 067 - 068 7 Mud-House Stone-Mud 320.00 425 136,000 Tube well 100 - 101 8 Room Stone-Mud 9.00 425 3,825 011 – 101 8 Total Structures: 850.00 - 366,250 * The new transmission line will pass over this single-storey mud-house, where 8m vertical clearance between the power cable and roof-top will be maintained by providing leg extension to the corresponding two towers.
113. Major agriculture crops cultivated in the area are wheat crop in the rabi season (winter- spring), and maize crop in the kharif season (summer-autumn). According to the LARP Time Schedule, the construction of towers (including stringing activity) will affect crops in three consecutive cropping seasons (Rabi-Kharif-Rabi), while the cable stringing activity in the TL Corridor will be carried in the last kharif and rabi cropping seasons (40% and 60% respectively). Current market rates of each crop (wheat and maize) were collected from the AHs and local markets in D. G. Khan and Loralai towns, and based on the crop incomes rates (as shown in Table 8.2 below), crop compensations were assessed for the affected crops (see Tables 8.3 and 8.4 below). Table 8.2: Average Crop Income per Unit Area of Farmland (Loralai 220kV TL) Affected Crop Average Crop Income per Unit Area (Rs.) Cropping Season No . Name Kanal (basis) Hectare Square Meter Rabi (Autumn-Winter) 1 Wheat 3,650.00 72,153.20 7.22 Kharif (Spring-Summer) 2 Maize 3,825.00 75,612.60 7.56 Sum Total: 7,475.00 147,765.80 14.78 Average (Wheat/Maize): 3,737.50 73,882.90 7.39 * A kanal is a local land measuring unit which is one-eighth of an Acre (1.00 ha = 19.768 kanals)
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 45
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table 8.3: Assessment of Compensation for Crops Affected by New Towers
Cropping Affected No. of Cropped Area Compensation Assessed Season Crops Towers Affected (m2) * Rate (Rs./m2) Amount (Rs.) Rabi 2009-10 Wheat-1 32 28,800 7.22 207,936.00 Kharif 2011 Maize-1 32 28,800 7.56 217,728.00 Rabi 2010-11 Wheat-2 32 28,800 7.22 207,936.00 Total: 32 28,800 (Mean: 7.39) 633,600.00 * Cropped area to be affected the construction of One Tower is estimated at 900 m2 ((30mx30m).
Table 8.4: Assessment of Compensation for Crops Affected by TL Corridor Cropping Affected TL Corridor* Cropped Area Compensation Assessed Season Crops Length (m)** Affected (m2) Rate (Rs./m2) Amount (Rs.) Kharif 2010 Maize-1 3,787.20 113,616 7.56 858,936.96 Rabi 2010-11 Wheat-2 5,680.80 170,424 7.22 1,230,461.28 Total: 9,468.00 284,040 (Mean: 7.39) 2,089,398.24 * The transmission line's right-of-way falling in-between any two towers has been termed as TL Corridor. ** The Stringing activity will be carried out in the last two cropping seasons (Kharif-1: 40%, and Rabi-2: 60%)
114. The affected fruit trees (Almonds and Berri) were valued based on age and productivity category of maturity (a. immature -not yet productive; b. mature-1 – the period of gaining full productivity level; and c. mature-2 - fully productive). Compensation assessment for fruit tree is shown in Tables 8.5 and 8.6.
Table 8.5: Categorization and Income Replacement Values of Affected Fruit Trees (Loralai TL)
Categorization Loss of Income per Fruit Tree Type of Rate of No. Affected Fruit Compensation Maturity Age of Tree Period Annual Tree Level (Years) (Years) Income (Rs) Assessed (Rs.) Immature up to 10 10 800 8,000 Almond Trees Mature-1 11 - 40 10 2,100 21,000 1 Mature-2 Above 40 10 2,000 20,000 Immature up to 15 10 700 7,000 Berri (Zizyphus) Mature-1 16 - 30 10 1,200 12,000 2 Mature-2 above 30 10 1,500 15,000
Table 8.6: Number and Compensation of Affected Fruit Trees (Loralai 220kV TL) Type of Maturity Affected Fruit Trees (No.) Rate Compensation No. Affected Fruit Level (Rs./Tree) Amount (Rs.) Tree Punjab Baluchn. Total 1 Almond Trees Immature 0 28 28 8,000 224,000 Mature-1 0 57 57 21,000 1,197,000 Mature-2 0 12 12 20,000 240,000
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 46
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Type of Maturity Affected Fruit Trees (No.) Rate Compensation No. Affected Fruit Level (Rs./Tree) Amount (Rs.) Tree Punjab Baluchn. Total Sub-total (a): Almond Trees 0 97 97 - 1,661,000 2 Berri (Zizyphus) Immature 5 8 13 7,000 91,000 Mature-1 11 17 28 12,000 336,000 Mature-2 8 6 14 15,000 210,000 Sub-total (b):Berri (Zizyphus) 24 31 55 - 637,000
TOTAL: 24 128 152 - 2,298,000
115. The affected wood trees were valued based on type, size, and age (dimensions and volume of wood rather than productivity). Compensation assessment for affected wood trees is shown in Tables 8.7, 8.8 and 8.9, below. The AHs will be entitled to keep the wood (as salvaged material) without any deductions from the amount of compensation. Table 8.7: Relative Size of Affected Wood Trees by Height and Girth in Meters (Loralai TL)
Name of Small Tree Medium Tree Large Tree Wood Tree No. Height (m) Girth (m) Height (m) Girth (m) Height (m) Girth (m) 6.1 & 1.0 & 1 Kikar (acasia) up to 3.0 up to 0.5 3.1 - 6.1 0.5 - 0.9 above above 7.7 & 1.0 & 2 Shisham (sisso) up to 3.8 up to 0.5 3.9 - 7.6 0.5 - 0.9 above above 9.1 & 0.5 & 3 Poplar/Eucalypts up to 4.6 up to 0.3 4.6 - 9.1 0.4 - 0.5 above above 4.1 & 0.9 & 4 Willow / Other up to 2.5 up to 0.4 2.6 - 4.1 0.5 - 0.8 above above
Table 8.8: Current Market Values of Affected Wood Trees (Loralai 220kV TL) Name of Affected Average Market Rates by Size of Wood Tree (Rs.) No. Wood Tree Small Medium Large Mean 1 Kikar (Acasia) 3,500 5,500 7,500 5,500 2 Shisham (Sisso) 4,500 6,000 9,000 6,500 3 Poplar/Eucalypts 4,000 6,000 8,000 6,000 4 Willow / Other 1,200 2,000 4,000 2,400
Table 8.9: Number and Compensation of Affected Wood Trees (Loralai 220kV TL) Market Rate Compensation Type of Affected Relative Affected Wood Trees (No.) No. Wood Tree Size (Rs.) Amount (Rs.) Punjab Baluchn Total 1 Kikar (Acasia) Small 3 21 24 3,500 84,000 Medium 6 22 28 5,500 154,000 Large 1 16 17 7,500 127,500 Sub-total (a): Kikar 10 59 69 - 365,500 2 Shisham (Sisso) Small 1 10 11 4,500 49,500 Medium 2 12 14 6,000 84,000 Large 0 9 9 9,000 81,000
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 47
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Market Rate Compensation Type of Affected Relative Affected Wood Trees (No.) No. Wood Tree Size (Rs.) Amount (Rs.) Punjab Baluchn Total Sub-total (b): Shisham 3 31 34 - 214,500 3 Poplar/Eucalypts Small 0 34 34 4,000 136,000 Medium 0 21 21 6,000 126,000 Large 0 10 10 8,000 80,000 Sub-total (c): Poplar/Eucalypts 0 65 65 - 342,000 4 Willow / Other Small 0 4 10 1,200 12,000 Medium 0 20 12 2,000 24,000 Large 0 12 14 4,000 56,000 Sub-total (d): Willow / Other 0 36 36 - 92,000 TOTAL: 13 191 204 - 1,014,000
8.3 Budget for Land and Asset Acquisition
116. This LARP includes the cost of compensation, rehabilitation and other restoration/assistance entitlements of the 126 private AHs, with a breakdown by likely partially affected houses, seasonal agricultural crops, fruit and wood trees, and other associated costs. The cost estimate has been based on the rates derived through consultation and survey as described in Section 8.2. The rates for compensation and cash entitlements for rehabilitation as well as allowances payable to the AHs will be adjusted annually, based on the actual annual inflation rate. The NTDC, through LAC/GSC will determine the annual inflation rates and adjust all cash entitlements. Total compensation for the affected assets, namely houses, crops and trees is Rs. 6.4 million (see Table 8.10, overleaf). 117. The administrative charges have been estimated as 15 per cent of the total of compensation for houses, crops and trees. These charges are to cover the costs of implementing the LARP, in terms of producing and distributing the PIB, holding individual and group consultations and public meetings as required, verifying the RFS, revising the LARP if required (to reflect any minor changes), organizing and arranging for the compensation payments through LAC/GSC, and internal monitoring of the plan and its implementation. 118. A contingency of 10 per cent of the subtotal of the compensation and administrative charges has been included in the cost estimate. Funds for compensation and implementation of the LARP will be from the Government (counterpart funds) via NTDC, budgetary requirements for economic restoration, as part of resettlement budget will also come from the counterpart funds and shall be identified as allowances. The EMA will be financed as a project loan cost as a component of the project support fund. The total cost of LARP implementation, as shown in Table 8.10 below, is estimated at Rs. 11.48 million (US$ 0.17 million).
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 48
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table 8.10: Estimated Resettlement Cost of Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Subproject
No. Resettlement Activity No. Unit Rs./Unit Total Rs. A. Asset Compensation: - - - 6,401,248 A.1 Partial Damage to 8 Mud-Houses 850 m2 430.88 366,250 A.2 Trees: 356 tree - 3,312,000 A.2.1 Fruit Trees: 152 tree - 2,298,000 Almond Orchard Trees 97 tree 17,124 1,661,000 Berri (Zizyphus) 55 tree 11,582 637,000 A.2.2 Wood Trees: 204 tree - 1,014,000 Kikar (acasia nicolta) 69 tree 5,297 365,500 Shisham (sisso) 34 tree 6,309 214,500 Poplar/Eucalypts 65 tree 5,262 342,000 Willow / Other 36 tree 2,556 92,000 A.3 Crops: - - - 2,722,998 A.3.1 Towers: - - - 633,600 32 Towers (2 Crops): Wheat-1&2 28,800 m2 7.22 415,872 32 Towers (1 Crop): Maize-1 28,800 m2 7.56 217,728 A.3.2 TL Corridor: - - - 2,089,398 40% TL Corridor (1 Crop): Maize-1 113,616 m2 7.56 858,937 60% TL Corridor (1 Crop): Wheat-2 170,424 m2 7.22 1,230,461 B. Rehabilitation Works: - - - 220,704 B.1 Rehabilitation of Affected Farmlands 312,840 m2 0.60 187,704 B.2 Rehabilitation of Affected Watercourses 528 m 62.50 33,000 C. Technical Assistance: - - - 2,850,000 C.1 Resettlement Specialist (implementation) 6.00 pers/mo 300,000 1,800,000 C.2 External Monitoring (LARP activities) 3.00 pers/mo 300,000 900,000 C.3 Training of NTDC staff (incl. materials) 1 lumpsum 150,000 150,000 D. Administration Costs (15% of A) 0.15 lumpsum 6,401,248 960,187 E. Sub-total (A+B+C+D): - - - 10,432,139 F. Contingency (10% of E) 0.10 lumpsum 10,432,139 1,043,214 Total Amount (Pak. Rupees): - - - 11,475,353 Total Amount (US Dollars*): - - - 169,004 * US$ 1.00 = Rs. 67.90
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 49
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
9. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE
119. The overall program will be implemented over a five to six year period with the first tranche of subprojects scheduled to commence upon loan approval. Implementation of resettlement and related activities will take place after the project supervision consultant has mobilized, who will work closely with, and assist, the NTDC in all resettlement and related activities. 120. Civil works contractors will not be issued a notice of possession of site for any section of construction works unless NTDC has (i) satisfactorily completed, in accordance with the approved LARP and all compensation payments have been made, and (ii) ensured that the rehabilitation assistance is in place and the area required for civil works is free of all encumbrances. 121. The LARP implementation schedule, shown below, envisages the following sequence of activities; some of these steps will overlap in their timing and some will be repeated throughout the project schedule.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 50
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table 9.1: Implementation Schedule for D. G. Khan – Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Subproject
Responsibility Year 2008 Year 2009 Year 2010 Year 2011 Secondar I I I I LARP Activity/Task Primary y I I III IV I I III IV I I III IV I I III IV
Technical Survey and Design of the TL NTDC NESPAK
Site Demarcation of Affected Lands PMU LARU/RS Consultant Resettlement Surveys and LARP preparation NTDC s
Preparation Consultant Preparation of LARP (First Draft) NTDC s NTDC- LARP disclosure - Brochure in Urdu PMU ADB
Mobilize project supervision consultant Govt NTDC NTDC- LARP revision (if necessary) PMU LARU/RS NTDC- Information dissemination regarding compensation payment & evacuation dates PMU LARU/RS Submit revised LARP to EPA/ADB. LARP approval prior to NTDC- Award of Contract for civil works Govt/ADB PMU NTDC- Implementation Adjust compensation rates & rehabilitation costs for inflation (if necessary) PMU LARU/RS NTDC- Delivery of compensation. Payments to be made prior to the start of Civil Works PMU LARU/RS NTDC- Grievance Redress Process PMU LARU/RS
NTDC- LARP monitoring (internal, and mobilization of EMA & baseline survey) PMU EMA PMU/LAR Possession of land for starting works U Contractor
Final payment of crop compensation PMU LARU/RS Contractor mobilized, civil works commenced (Two Packages: 94.1 km + 150.9 km = 245.0 km) Contractor PMU Construction Rehabilitation of Damaged Land/Infrastructure Contractor PMU NTDC/AD LARP monitoring; post-evaluation report EMA B
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 51
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
10. MONITORING AND EVALUATION
122. Monitoring and evaluation (M&E) are critical activities in involuntary resettlement caused by various infrastructure development projects, like this power transmission enhancement project. Monitoring involves periodic checking to ascertain whether activities are progressing as per schedule while evaluation is essentially a summing up, at the end of the project, assessment of actual achievement in comparison to those aimed at during the implementation. RP implementation will be monitored both internally as well as externally. 123. The NTDC/PMU through LARU will be responsible for internal monitoring through its field office. The Resettlement Specialist will provide necessary technical assistance in implementing and monitoring the resettlement activities. In addition, a part-time Consultant will be responsible for independent external monitoring and evaluation of the resettlement activities.
10.1 Internal Monitoring
124. The Short LARP includes indicators and benchmarks for achievement of the objectives under the resettlement program, which can be categorized as follows: • Process indicators, which include project inputs, expenditures, staff deployment; • Output indicators are results in terms of numbers of affected persons compensated for their affected assets (land, crops and/or trees), and, • Impact indicators related to the long-term effect of the project on people’s lives in the project-affected area. 125. The first two types of indicators, related to process and immediate outputs and results, will be monitored internally by LARU. This information will be collected from the project site and assimilated in the form of a monthly progress report to assess the progress and results of LARP implementation, and adjust the work program, where necessary, in case of any delays, disputes and/or other problems. Specific activities under LARP implementation that will be monitored are the following: • Information campaign and consultation with AHs on a continued basis; • Status of land acquisition/purchase and payment of crop/tree compensations; • Status of restoration of damaged community infrastructure (water pipelines, irrigation channels / watercourses, drains, roads, streets, etc.) • Grievances redress activities 126. The LARU will be responsible for monitoring the day-to-day resettlement activities of the subproject. The socio-economic census and land acquisition data will provide the necessary benchmark for field level monitoring, to be carried out through: • Review of IOL/Census information for all AHs; • Consultation and informal interviews with AHs; • In-depth case studies; • Informal sample survey of AHs; • Key informant interviews; and
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 52
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
• Community public meetings. 127. A performance data sheet will be developed to monitor the project at the field level. Quarterly reports will be received from the field offices and LAC/GSC will be responsible for overall project level monitoring.
10.2 External Monitoring
128. As mentioned earlier, an Individual Consultant, a Consulting firm, or an NGO will be engaged on part-time basis to carry out independent monitoring and evaluation of the LARP implementation (see TORs in Appendix 4). Independent evaluation will be undertaken on a bi- annual basis till the end of the Project. The Consultant will be selected by the NTDC/PMU, with advice and concurrence of ADB. S/he will review the status of the resettlement implementation in light of the targets, budget and duration that had been laid down in this short LARP. The key tasks during external monitoring include: • Review and verify internal monitoring reports prepared by LARU; • Identification and selection of impact indicators; • Impact assessment through formal & informal surveys with the affected persons; • Consultations with AHs, officials, community leaders for review report; and • Assessment of the resettlement efficiency, impact and sustainability, and drawing lessons for future resettlement policy formulation and planning.
10.3 Indicators for Monitoring and Evaluation
129. The following will be considered as the basis for indicators in monitoring and evaluation of the subproject’s LARP: • Socio-economic conditions of the AHs in the post-resettlement period; • Communications and reactions from AHs on entitlements, compensation, options, alternative developments and relocation timetables etc.; • Changes in housing and income levels; • Valuation of property; • Grievance procedures; • Disbursement of compensation; and • Level of satisfaction of AHs in the post resettlement period.
10.4 Resettlement Database
130. All information concerning resettlement issues related to land acquisition, socio- economic information of the acquired land; inventory of crop and tree losses by individual AHs, compensation and entitlements and payments will be collected by LARU and the Consultants through their concerned field offices and computerized by the LARU, at EHV-GSC office in Lahore. This database will form the basis of information for implementation, monitoring and reporting purposes and facilitate efficient resettlement management.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 53
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
10.5 Reporting Requirements 131. The LARU responsible for supervision and implementation of LARP will prepare monthly progress reports on resettlement activities and submit them to the ADB for review. The Resettlement Specialist will also monitor LARP implementation independently and submit quarterly reports to PMU, NTDC and ADB. These quarterly reports will also highlight the bottlenecks and recommend ways and means to improve such problematic situations. The external Consultant will submit bi-annual review reports directly to ADB and determine whether or not resettlement goals have been achieved, more importantly whether livelihoods and living standards have been restored/enhanced and suggest suitable recommendations for improvement. S/he will also provide a copy of the same report to NTDC Headquarters for information and successive action.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 54
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Annex A: Working Tables for D. G. Khan - Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Subproject
Table A-1: Type of Land Traversed by the Construction of D. G. Khan - Loralai 220kV Transmission Line
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Section - A: Punjab Province - Sub-section A.1: Dera Ghazi Khan District (DGK):
GS - LP GS/DGK LP (start) 4 820.00 24,600.00 - - - 4 820.00 24,600.00
LP T# 1 1 420.00 12,600.00 - - - 1 420.00 12,600.00
1 2 1 200.00 6,000.00 - - - 1 200.00 6,000.00
AM 001 2 3 1 329.98 9,899.40 - - - 1 329.98 9,899.40
3 4 1 265.45 7,963.50 - - - 1 265.45 7,963.50
AM 002 4 5 1 320.55 9,616.50 - - - 1 320.55 9,616.50
5 6 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
6 7 1 366.00 10,980.00 - - - 1 366.00 10,980.00
7 8 1 350.37 10,511.10 - - - 1 350.37 10,511.10
AM 003 8 9 1 305.63 9,168.90 - - - 1 305.63 9,168.90
9 10 1 318.00 9,540.00 - - - 1 318.00 9,540.00
10 11 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 1 328.00 9,840.00
11 12 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 1 314.00 9,420.00
12 13 1 300.00 9,000.00 - - - 1 300.00 9,000.00 13 14 1 319.48 9,584.40 - - - 319.48 9,584.40
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 55
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
AM 004 14 15 1 100.52 3,015.60 - - - 1 100.52 3,015.60
15 16 1 240.00 7,200.00 - - - 1 240.00 7,200.00
16 17 1 294.21 8,826.30 - - - 1 294.21 8,826.30
AM 005 17 18 1 337.79 10,133.70 - - - 1 337.79 10,133.70
18 19 1 361.66 10,849.80 - - - 1 361.66 10,849.80
AM 006 19 20 1 346.34 10,390.20 - - - 1 346.34 10,390.20
20 21 1 373.00 11,190.00 - - - 1 373.00 11,190.00
21 22 1 345.00 10,350.00 - - - 1 345.00 10,350.00
22 23 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
23 24 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
24 25 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00
25 26 1 336.00 10,080.00 - - - 1 336.00 10,080.00
26 27 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00
27 28 1 350.00 10,500.00 - - - 1 350.00 10,500.00
28 29 1 350.16 10,504.80 - - - 1 350.16 10,504.80
AM 007 29 30 1 343.84 10,315.20 - - - 1 343.84 10,315.20
30 31 1 362.00 10,860.00 - - - 1 362.00 10,860.00 31 32 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 360.00 10,800.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 56
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
32 33 1 372.00 11,160.00 - - - 1 372.00 11,160.00
33 34 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
34 35 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
35 36 1 370.00 11,100.00 - - - 1 370.00 11,100.00
36 37 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
37 38 1 366.00 10,980.00 - - - 1 366.00 10,980.00
38 39 1 354.00 10,620.00 - - - 1 354.00 10,620.00
39 40 1 361.21 10,836.30 - - - 1 361.21 10,836.30
AM 008 40 41 1 340.79 10,223.70 - - - 1 340.79 10,223.70
41 42 1 330.00 9,900.00 - - - 1 330.00 9,900.00
42 43 1 338.00 10,140.00 - - - 1 338.00 10,140.00
43 44 1 360.61 10,818.30 - - - 1 360.61 10,818.30 AM 008A 44 45 1 333.39 10,001.70 - - - 1 333.39 10,001.70
45 46 1 312.00 9,360.00 - - - 1 312.00 9,360.00
46 47 1 336.00 10,080.00 - - - 1 336.00 10,080.00
47 48 1 261.98 7,859.40 - - - 1 261.98 7,859.40
AM 009 48 49 1 305.79 9,173.70 - - - 1 305.79 9,173.70 49 50 1 302.00 9,060.00 - - - 302.00 9,060.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 57
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
50 51 1 324.00 9,720.00 - - - 1 324.00 9,720.00
51 52 1 316.00 9,480.00 - - - 1 316.00 9,480.00
52 53 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 1 328.00 9,840.00
53 54 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 1 328.00 9,840.00
54 55 1 303.65 9,109.50 - 33.00 990.00 1 270.65 8,119.50
AM 010 55 56 1 376.35 11,290.50 - 64.00 1,920.00 1 312.35 9,370.50
56 57 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
57 58 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00
58 59 1 376.00 11,280.00 - - - 1 376.00 11,280.00
59 60 1 354.00 10,620.00 - - - 1 354.00 10,620.00
60 61 1 376.17 11,285.10 - - - 1 376.17 11,285.10
AM 011 61 62 1 393.83 11,814.90 - - - 1 393.83 11,814.90
62 63 1 280.00 8,400.00 - 86.00 2,580.00 1 194.00 5,820.00
63 64 1 290.00 8,700.00 1 192.00 5,760.00 - 98.00 2,940.00
64 65 1 287.51 8,625.30 1 30.00 900.00 - 257.51 7,725.30
AM 012 65 66 1 312.49 9,374.70 - - - 1 312.49 9,374.70
66 67 1 310.00 9,300.00 - - - 1 310.00 9,300.00 67 68 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 320.00 9,600.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 58
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
68 69 1 263.14 7,894.20 - - - 1 263.14 7,894.20
AM 013 69 70 1 288.86 8,665.80 - - - 1 288.86 8,665.80
70 71 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 1 328.00 9,840.00
71 72 1 326.00 9,780.00 - - - 1 326.00 9,780.00
72 73 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00
73 74 1 332.00 9,960.00 - - - 1 332.00 9,960.00
74 75 1 320.84 9,625.20 - - - 1 320.84 9,625.20
AM 014 75 76 1 331.16 9,934.80 - - - 1 331.16 9,934.80
76 77 1 300.00 9,000.00 - - - 1 300.00 9,000.00
77 78 1 270.00 8,100.00 - - - 1 270.00 8,100.00
78 79 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 1 320.00 9,600.00
79 80 1 316.00 9,480.00 - - - 1 316.00 9,480.00
80 81 1 301.93 9,057.90 - - - 1 301.93 9,057.90
AM 015 81 82 1 306.07 9,182.10 - - - 1 306.07 9,182.10
82 83 1 342.00 10,260.00 - - - 1 342.00 10,260.00
83 84 1 354.00 10,620.00 - - - 1 354.00 10,620.00
84 85 1 370.95 11,128.50 - - - 1 370.95 11,128.50 AM 016 85 86 1 189.05 5,671.50 - - - 189.05 5,671.50
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 59
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
86 87 1 140.00 4,200.00 - - - 1 140.00 4,200.00
87 88 1 197.78 5,933.40 - - - 1 197.78 5,933.40
AM 017 88 89 1 292.22 8,766.60 - - - 1 292.22 8,766.60
89 90 1 504.73 15,141.90 - - - 1 504.73 15,141.90
AM 018 90 91 1 339.27 10,178.10 - - - 1 339.27 10,178.10
91 92 1 256.00 7,680.00 - - - 1 256.00 7,680.00
92 93 1 388.00 11,640.00 - - - 1 388.00 11,640.00
93 94 1 372.00 11,160.00 - - - 1 372.00 11,160.00
94 95 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
95 96 1 368.91 11,067.30 - - - 1 368.91 11,067.30
AM 019 96 97 1 443.09 13,292.70 - - - 1 443.09 13,292.70
97 98 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00
98 99 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 1 320.00 9,600.00
99 100 1 333.23 9,996.90 - - - 1 333.23 9,996.90
AM 020 100 101 1 370.77 11,123.10 - - - 1 370.77 11,123.10
101 102 1 260.00 7,800.00 - - - 1 260.00 7,800.00
102 103 1 256.00 7,680.00 - - - 1 256.00 7,680.00 103 104 1 260.00 7,800.00 - - - 260.00 7,800.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 60
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
104 105 1 354.00 10,620.00 - - - 1 354.00 10,620.00
105 106 1 336.00 10,080.00 - - - 1 336.00 10,080.00
106 107 1 380.00 11,400.00 - - - 1 380.00 11,400.00
107 108 1 171.84 5,155.20 - - - 1 171.84 5,155.20
AM 021 108 109 1 156.67 4,700.10 - - - 1 156.67 4,700.10
AM 022 109 110 1 377.49 11,324.70 - - - 1 377.49 11,324.70
110 111 1 361.02 10,830.60 - - - 1 361.02 10,830.60
AM 023 111 112 1 312.98 9,389.40 - - - 1 312.98 9,389.40
112 113 1 281.06 8,431.80 - - - 1 281.06 8,431.80
AM 024 113 114 1 348.94 10,468.20 - - - 1 348.94 10,468.20
114 115 1 315.00 9,450.00 - - - 1 315.00 9,450.00
115 116 1 355.00 10,650.00 - - - 1 355.00 10,650.00
116 117 1 364.00 10,920.00 - - - 1 364.00 10,920.00
117 118 1 416.00 12,480.00 - - - 1 416.00 12,480.00
118 119 1 168.00 5,040.00 - - - 1 168.00 5,040.00
119 120 1 253.45 7,603.50 - - - 1 253.45 7,603.50
AM 025 120 121 1 286.55 8,596.50 - - - 1 286.55 8,596.50 121 122 1 227.52 6,825.60 - - - 227.52 6,825.60
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 61
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
AM 026 122 123 1 291.48 8,744.40 - - - 1 291.48 8,744.40
123 124 1 355.00 10,650.00 - - - 1 355.00 10,650.00
124 125 1 308.00 9,240.00 - - - 1 308.00 9,240.00
125 126 1 338.00 10,140.00 - - - 1 338.00 10,140.00
126 127 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
127 128 1 333.39 10,001.70 - - - 1 333.39 10,001.70
AM 027 128 129 1 279.77 8,393.10 - - - 1 279.77 8,393.10
129 130 1 350.00 10,500.00 - - - 1 350.00 10,500.00
130 131 1 368.00 11,040.00 - - - 1 368.00 11,040.00
131 132 1 362.00 10,860.00 - - - 1 362.00 10,860.00
132 133 1 522.00 15,660.00 - - - 1 522.00 15,660.00
133 134 1 232.51 6,975.30 - - - 1 232.51 6,975.30
AM 028 134 135 1 65.49 1,964.70 - - - 1 65.49 1,964.70
135 136 1 240.40 7,212.00 - - - 1 240.40 7,212.00
AM 029 136 137 1 375.65 11,269.50 - - - 1 375.65 11,269.50
AM 030 137 138 1 337.23 10,116.90 - - - 1 337.23 10,116.90
AM 031 138 139 1 384.64 11,539.20 - - - 1 384.64 11,539.20 AM 032 139 140 1 283.08 8,492.40 - - - 283.08 8,492.40
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 62
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
AM 033 140 141 1 215.66 6,469.80 - - - 1 215.66 6,469.80
AM 034 141 142 1 394.34 11,830.20 - - - 1 394.34 11,830.20
AM 035 142 143 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 1 320.00 9,600.00
AM 036 143 144 1 254.00 7,620.00 - - - 1 254.00 7,620.00
144 145 1 206.00 6,180.00 - - - 1 206.00 6,180.00
145 146 1 300.00 9,000.00 - - - 1 300.00 9,000.00
AM 037 146 147 1 200.00 6,000.00 - - - 1 200.00 6,000.00
147 148 1 340.00 10,200.00 - - - 1 340.00 10,200.00
148 149 1 136.00 4,080.00 - - - 1 136.00 4,080.00
149 150 1 164.00 4,920.00 - - - 1 164.00 4,920.00
150 151 1 374.00 11,220.00 - - - 1 374.00 11,220.00
151 152 1 405.91 12,177.30 - - - 1 405.91 12,177.30
AM 038 152 153 1 184.09 5,522.70 - - - 1 184.09 5,522.70
153 154 1 449.42 13,482.60 - - - 1 449.42 13,482.60
AM 039 154 155 1 270.58 8,117.40 - - - 1 270.58 8,117.40
155 156 1 257.69 7,730.70 - - - 1 257.69 7,730.70
AM 040 156 157 1 448.31 13,449.30 - - - 1 448.31 13,449.30 157 158 1 278.30 8,349.00 - - - 278.30 8,349.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 63
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
AM 041 158 159 1 107.70 3,231.00 - - - 1 107.70 3,231.00
159 160 1 464.00 13,920.00 - - - 1 464.00 13,920.00
160 161 1 461.15 13,834.50 - - - 1 461.15 13,834.50
AM 042 161 162 1 134.85 4,045.50 - - - 1 134.85 4,045.50
162 163 1 276.00 8,280.00 - - - 1 276.00 8,280.00
163 164 1 458.00 13,740.00 - - - 1 458.00 13,740.00
AM 043 164 165 1 150.00 4,500.00 - - - 1 150.00 4,500.00
165 166 1 310.00 9,300.00 - - - 1 310.00 9,300.00
166 167 1 265.87 7,976.10 - - - 1 265.87 7,976.10
AM 044 167 168 1 492.13 14,763.90 - - - 1 492.13 14,763.90
168 169 1 438.00 13,140.00 - - - 1 438.00 13,140.00
169 170 1 384.34 11,530.20 - - - 1 384.34 11,530.20
AM 045 170 171 1 389.66 11,689.80 - - - 1 389.66 11,689.80
171 172 1 260.00 7,800.00 - - - 1 260.00 7,800.00
172 173 1 343.94 10,318.20 - - - 1 343.94 10,318.20
AM 046 173 174 1 252.06 7,561.80 - - - 1 252.06 7,561.80
174 175 1 404.00 12,120.00 - - - 1 404.00 12,120.00 175 176 1 250.00 7,500.00 - - - 250.00 7,500.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 64
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
176 177 1 302.00 9,060.00 - - - 1 302.00 9,060.00
177 178 1 456.12 13,683.60 - - - 1 456.12 13,683.60
AM 047 178 179 1 191.88 5,756.40 - - - 1 191.88 5,756.40
179 180 1 288.00 8,640.00 - - - 1 288.00 8,640.00
180 181 1 312.00 9,360.00 - - - 1 312.00 9,360.00
181 182 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 1 314.00 9,420.00
182 183 1 395.02 11,850.60 - - - 1 395.02 11,850.60
AM 048 183 184 1 78.98 2,369.40 - - - 1 78.98 2,369.40
184 185 1 426.00 12,780.00 - - - 1 426.00 12,780.00
185 186 1 290.00 8,700.00 - - - 1 290.00 8,700.00
186 187 1 276.00 8,280.00 - - - 1 276.00 8,280.00
187 188 1 378.00 11,340.00 - - - 1 378.00 11,340.00
188 189 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
189 190 1 374.00 11,220.00 - - - 1 374.00 11,220.00
190 191 1 210.00 6,300.00 - - - 1 210.00 6,300.00
191 192 1 294.00 8,820.00 - - - 1 294.00 8,820.00
192 193 1 362.00 10,860.00 - - - 1 362.00 10,860.00 193 194 1 150.00 4,500.00 - - - 150.00 4,500.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 65
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
Sub-total (a): Punjab - DGK: 198 62,505.91 1,875,177.30 2 405.00 12,150.00 196 62,100.91 1,863,027.30 Section - B: Baluchistan Province: Sub-section - B.1: Bar Khan District (Baluchistan):
194 195 1 297.01 8,910.30 - - - 1 297.01 8,910.30
AM 049 195 196 1 262.99 7,889.70 - - - 1 262.99 7,889.70
196 197 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 1 320.00 9,600.00
197 198 1 326.00 9,780.00 - 173.00 5,190 1 153.00 4,590.00
198 199 1 328.00 9,840.00 1 190.00 5,700 - 138.00 4,140.00
199 200 1 346.00 10,380.00 1 146.00 4,380 - 200.00 6,000.00
200 201 1 362.14 10,864.20 1 106.00 3,180 - 256.14 7,684.20
AM 050 201 202 1 351.86 10,555.80 - 87.00 2,610 1 264.86 7,945.80
202 203 1 366.00 10,980.00 - 64.00 1,920 1 302.00 9,060.00
203 204 1 362.00 10,860.00 - 58.00 1,740 1 304.00 9,120.00
204 205 1 364.00 10,920.00 - 42.00 1,260 1 322.00 9,660.00
205 206 1 358.00 10,740.00 - 158.00 4,740 1 200.00 6,000.00
206 207 1 378.00 11,340.00 - 163.00 4,890 1 215.00 6,450.00
207 208 1 356.00 10,680.00 1 126.00 3,780 - 230.00 6,900.00
208 209 1 370.33 11,109.90 1 215.00 6,450 - 155.33 4,659.90 AM 051 209 210 1 365.67 10,970.10 1 9,420 - 51.67 1,550.10 Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 66
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 314.00
210 211 1 366.00 10,980.00 - 325.00 9,750 1 41.00 1,230.00
211 212 1 356.00 10,680.00 1 306.00 9,180 - 50.00 1,500.00
212 213 1 352.25 10,567.50 1 296.00 8,880 - 56.25 1,687.50
AM 052 213 214 1 367.10 11,013.00 1 272.00 8,160 - 95.10 2,853.00
AM 053 214 215 1 338.65 10,159.50 1 270.00 8,100 - 68.65 2,059.50
215 216 1 288.00 8,640.00 1 242.00 7,260 - 46.00 1,380.00
216 217 1 330.00 9,900.00 1 253.00 7,590 - 77.00 2,310.00
217 218 1 270.00 8,100.00 1 250.00 7,500 - 20.00 600.00
218 219 1 294.01 8,820.30 - 76.00 2,280 1 218.01 6,540.30
AM 054 219 220 1 299.99 8,999.70 - - - 1 299.99 8,999.70
220 221 1 354.00 10,620.00 - - - 1 354.00 10,620.00
221 222 1 362.00 10,860.00 - - - 1 362.00 10,860.00
222 223 1 330.00 9,900.00 - - - 1 330.00 9,900.00
223 224 1 338.00 10,140.00 - - - 1 338.00 10,140.00
224 225 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
225 226 1 374.00 11,220.00 - - - 1 374.00 11,220.00
226 227 1 296.00 8,880.00 - - - 1 296.00 8,880.00 227 228 1 364.00 10,920.00 - - - 364.00 10,920.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 67
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
228 229 1 366.00 10,980.00 - - - 1 366.00 10,980.00
229 230 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
230 231 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00
231 232 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00
232 233 1 286.00 8,580.00 - - - 1 286.00 8,580.00
233 234 1 342.00 10,260.00 - - - 1 342.00 10,260.00
234 235 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00
235 236 1 338.00 10,140.00 - - - 1 338.00 10,140.00
236 237 1 356.80 10,704.00 - - - 1 356.80 10,704.00
AM 055 237 238 1 349.03 10,470.90 - - - 1 349.03 10,470.90
238 239 1 356.00 10,680.00 - 72.00 2,160.00 1 284.00 8,520.00
239 240 1 366.00 10,320.00 - 63.00 1,890.00 1 303.00 8,430.00
240 241 1 344.00 10,320.00 - - - 1 344.00 10,320.00
241 242 1 344.00 9,594.90 - - - 1 344.00 9,594.90
242 243 1 319.83 9,063.60 - - - 1 319.83 9,063.60
AM 056 243 244 1 302.12 9,702.60 - - - 1 302.12 9,702.60
244 245 1 323.42 8,477.40 - - - 1 323.42 8,477.40 AM 057 245 246 1 282.58 10,200.00 - - - 282.58 10,200.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 68
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
246 247 1 340.00 10,200.00 - - - 1 340.00 10,200.00
247 248 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 1 314.00 9,420.00
248 249 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 1 320.00 9,600.00
249 250 1 310.00 9,300.00 - - - 1 310.00 9,300.00
250 251 1 378.00 11,340.00 - - - 1 378.00 11,340.00
251 252 1 332.00 9,960.00 - - - 1 332.00 9,960.00
252 253 1 390.00 11,700.00 - - - 1 390.00 11,700.00
253 254 1 247.27 7,418.10 - - - 1 247.27 7,418.10
AM 058 254 255 1 351.74 10,552.20 - - - 1 351.74 10,552.20
AM 059 255 256 1 374.99 11,249.70 - - - 1 374.99 11,249.70
256 257 1 340.00 10,200.00 - - - 1 340.00 10,200.00
257 258 1 190.00 5,700.00 - - - 1 190.00 5,700.00
258 259 1 462.00 13,860.00 - - - 1 462.00 13,860.00
259 260 1 236.00 7,080.00 - - - 1 236.00 7,080.00
260 261 1 338.80 10,164.00 - - - 1 338.80 10,164.00
AM 060 261 262 1 416.20 12,486.00 - - - 1 416.20 12,486.00
262 263 1 240.00 7,200.00 - - - 1 240.00 7,200.00 263 264 1 258.00 7,740.00 - - - 258.00 7,740.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 69
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
264 265 1 247.94 7,438.20 - - - 1 247.94 7,438.20
AM 061 265 266 1 346.06 10,381.80 - - - 1 346.06 10,381.80
266 267 1 334.00 10,020.00 - - - 1 334.00 10,020.00
267 268 1 354.00 10,620.00 - - - 1 354.00 10,620.00
268 269 1 272.00 8,160.00 - - - 1 272.00 8,160.00
269 270 1 228.21 6,846.30 - - - 1 228.21 6,846.30
AM 062 270 271 1 371.79 11,153.70 - - - 1 371.79 11,153.70
271 272 1 260.00 7,800.00 - - - 1 260.00 7,800.00
272 273 1 226.34 6,790.20 - - - 1 226.34 6,790.20
AM 063 273 274 1 397.66 11,929.80 - - - 1 397.66 11,929.80
274 275 1 322.00 9,660.00 - - - 1 322.00 9,660.00
275 276 1 316.00 9,480.00 - - - 1 316.00 9,480.00
276 277 1 268.00 8,040.00 - - - 1 268.00 8,040.00
277 278 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
278 279 1 362.00 10,860.00 - - - 1 362.00 10,860.00
279 280 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00
280 281 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00 281 282 1 264.00 7,920.00 - - - 264.00 7,920.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 70
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
282 283 1 330.64 9,919.20 - - - 1 330.64 9,919.20
AM 064 283 284 1 253.36 7,600.80 - - - 1 253.36 7,600.80
284 285 1 292.00 8,760.00 - - - 1 292.00 8,760.00
285 286 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 1 328.00 9,840.00
286 287 1 374.89 11,246.70 - 21.00 630.00 1 353.89 10,616.70
AM 065 287 288 1 371.11 11,133.30 1 203.00 6,090.00 - 168.11 5,043.30
288 289 1 248.00 7,440.00 - 93.00 2,790.00 1 155.00 4,650.00
289 290 1 350.79 10,523.70 - - - 1 350.79 10,523.70
AM 066 290 291 1 300.00 9,000.00 - 18.00 540.00 1 282.00 8,460.00
291 292 1 324.00 9,720.00 - - - 1 324.00 9,720.00
292 293 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
293 294 1 346.00 10,380.00 - 25.00 750.00 1 321.00 9,630.00
294 295 1 360.00 10,800.00 1 112.00 3,360.00 - 248.00 7,440.00
295 296 1 366.00 10,980.00 1 132.00 3,960.00 - 234.00 7,020.00
296 297 1 300.00 9,000.00 - - - 1 300.00 9,000.00
297 298 1 344.00 10,320.00 - - - 1 344.00 10,320.00
298 299 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00 299 300 1 316.00 9,480.00 - - - 316.00 9,480.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 71
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
300 301 1 364.00 10,920.00 - 27.00 810.00 1 337.00 10,110.00
301 302 1 368.00 11,040.00 1 160.00 4,800.00 - 208.00 6,240.00
302 303 1 332.00 9,960.00 - - - 1 332.00 9,960.00
303 304 1 308.00 9,240.00 - - - 1 308.00 9,240.00
304 305 1 402.00 12,060.00 - - - 1 402.00 12,060.00
305 306 1 329.24 9,877.20 - - - 1 329.24 9,877.20
AM 067 306 307 1 386.76 11,602.80 - - - 1 386.76 11,602.80
307 308 1 344.00 10,320.00 - - - 1 344.00 10,320.00
308 309 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 1 320.00 9,600.00
309 310 1 362.00 10,860.00 - - - 1 362.00 10,860.00
310 311 1 368.00 11,040.00 - - - 1 368.00 11,040.00
311 312 1 330.00 9,900.00 - - - 1 330.00 9,900.00
312 313 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
313 314 1 332.00 9,960.00 - - - 1 332.00 9,960.00
314 315 1 354.00 10,620.00 - - - 1 354.00 10,620.00
315 316 1 266.00 7,980.00 - - - 1 266.00 7,980.00
316 317 1 400.00 12,000.00 - - - 1 400.00 12,000.00 317 318 1 332.00 9,960.00 - - - 332.00 9,960.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 72
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
318 319 1 276.00 8,280.00 - - - 1 276.00 8,280.00
319 320 1 330.00 9,900.00 - - - 1 330.00 9,900.00
320 321 1 280.00 8,400.00 - - - 1 280.00 8,400.00
321 322 1 324.00 9,720.00 - - - 1 324.00 9,720.00
322 323 1 336.00 10,080.00 - - - 1 336.00 10,080.00 Sub-total (b.1): Bar Khan (Baln.): 129 42,783.57 1,282,727.10 17 5,058.00 151,740.00 112 37,725.57 1,130,987.10 Sub-section B.2: Musakhal District (Baluchistan):
323 324 1 346.00 10,380.00 - 28.00 840.00 1 318.00 9,540.00
324 325 1 310.11 9,303.30 - 64.00 1,920.00 1 246.11 7,383.30
AM 068 325 326 1 417.89 12,536.70 - - - 1 417.89 12,536.70
326 327 1 224.00 6,720.00 - - - 1 224.00 6,720.00
327 328 1 254.00 7,620.00 - - - 1 254.00 7,620.00
328 329 1 396.00 11,880.00 - - - 1 396.00 11,880.00
329 330 1 332.00 9,960.00 - - - 1 332.00 9,960.00
330 331 1 338.00 10,140.00 - - - 1 338.00 10,140.00
331 332 1 378.00 11,340.00 - - - 1 378.00 11,340.00
332 333 1 342.00 10,260.00 - - - 1 342.00 10,260.00
333 334 1 364.00 10,920.00 - - - 1 364.00 10,920.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 73
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m)
334 335 1 340.00 10,200.00 - - - 1 340.00 10,200.00
335 336 1 390.00 11,700.00 - - - 1 390.00 11,700.00
336 337 1 148.00 4,440.00 - - - 1 148.00 4,440.00
337 338 1 412.00 12,360.00 - - - 1 412.00 12,360.00
338 339 1 273.03 8,190.90 - - - 1 273.03 8,190.90
AM 069 339 340 1 170.97 5,129.10 - - - 1 170.97 5,129.10
340 341 1 258.00 7,740.00 - - - 1 258.00 7,740.00
341 342 1 309.75 9,292.50 - - - 1 309.75 9,292.50
AM 070 342 343 1 414.25 12,427.50 - - - 1 414.25 12,427.50
343 344 1 304.00 9,120.00 - - - 1 304.00 9,120.00
344 345 1 278.00 8,340.00 - - - 1 278.00 8,340.00
345 346 1 308.00 9,240.00 - - - 1 308.00 9,240.00
346 347 1 302.00 9,060.00 - 82.00 2,460.00 1 220.00 6,600.00
347 348 1 386.00 11,580.00 - 227.00 6,810.00 1 159.00 4,770.00
348 349 1 260.00 7,800.00 1 38.00 1,140.00 - 222.00 6,660.00
349 350 1 202.00 6,060.00 - - - 1 202.00 6,060.00
350 351 1 390.21 11,706.30 - - - 1 390.21 11,706.30
AM 071 351 352 1 331.79 9,953.70 - - - 1 331.79 9,953.70
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 74
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m)
352 353 1 388.00 11,640.00 - - - 1 388.00 11,640.00
353 354 1 266.00 7,980.00 - - - 1 266.00 7,980.00
354 355 1 284.75 8,542.50 - - - 1 284.75 8,542.50
AM 072 355 356 1 311.25 9,337.50 - - - 1 311.25 9,337.50
356 357 1 392.00 11,760.00 - - - 1 392.00 11,760.00
357 358 1 220.00 6,600.00 - - - 1 220.00 6,600.00
358 359 1 422.00 12,660.00 - - - 1 422.00 12,660.00
359 360 1 418.00 12,540.00 - - - 1 418.00 12,540.00
360 361 1 242.00 7,260.00 - - - 1 242.00 7,260.00
361 362 1 444.00 13,320.00 - - - 1 444.00 13,320.00
362 363 1 286.00 8,580.00 - - - 1 286.00 8,580.00
363 364 1 350.00 10,500.00 - - - 1 350.00 10,500.00
364 365 1 432.00 12,960.00 - - - 1 432.00 12,960.00
365 366 1 422.00 12,660.00 - - - 1 422.00 12,660.00
366 367 1 240.00 7,200.00 - - - 1 240.00 7,200.00
367 368 1 173.35 5,200.50 - - - 1 173.35 5,200.50
AM 073 368 369 1 362.65 10,879.50 - - - 1 362.65 10,879.50
369 370 1 288.00 8,640.00 - - - 1 288.00 8,640.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 75
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m)
370 371 1 319.41 9,582.30 - - - 1 319.41 9,582.30
Am 074 371 372 1 336.59 10,097.70 - - - 1 336.59 10,097.70
372 373 1 330.00 9,900.00 - - - 1 330.00 9,900.00
373 374 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
374 375 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
375 376 1 486.00 14,580.00 - - - 1 486.00 14,580.00
376 377 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
377 378 1 266.77 8,003.10 - - - 1 266.77 8,003.10
AM 075 378 379 1 333.48 10,004.40 - - - 1 333.48 10,004.40
AM 076 379 380 1 439.75 13,192.50 - - - 1 439.75 13,192.50
380 381 1 232.00 6,960.00 - - - 1 232.00 6,960.00
381 382 1 256.00 7,680.00 - - - 1 256.00 7,680.00
382 383 1 342.00 10,260.00 - - - 1 342.00 10,260.00
383 384 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
384 385 1 340.00 10,200.00 - - - 1 340.00 10,200.00
385 386 1 434.00 13,020.00 - - - 1 434.00 13,020.00
386 387 1 250.00 7,500.00 - - - 1 250.00 7,500.00
387 388 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 1 328.00 9,840.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 76
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m)
388 389 1 218.00 6,540.00 - - - 1 218.00 6,540.00
389 390 1 404.00 12,120.00 - - - 1 404.00 12,120.00
390 391 1 326.00 9,780.00 - - - 1 326.00 9,780.00
391 392 1 404.00 12,120.00 - - - 1 404.00 12,120.00
392 393 1 326.00 9,780.00 - - - 1 326.00 9,780.00
393 394 1 350.00 10,500.00 - - - 1 350.00 10,500.00
394 395 1 380.00 11,400.00 - - - 1 380.00 11,400.00
395 396 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00 Sub-total (b.2): Musa Khel (Baln.): 73 23,982.00 719,460.00 1 439.00 13,170.00 72 23,543.00 706,290.00 Sub-section B.3: Loralai District (Baluchistan):
396 397 1 408.11 12,243.30 - - - 1 408.11 12,243.30
AM 077 397 398 1 259.89 7,796.70 - - - 1 259.89 7,796.70
398 399 1 300.00 9,000.00 - - - 1 300.00 9,000.00
399 400 1 414.18 12,425.40 - - - 1 414.18 12,425.40
AM 078 400 401 1 145.82 4,374.60 - - - 1 145.82 4,374.60
401 402 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
402 403 1 372.00 11,160.00 - - - 1 372.00 11,160.00
403 404 1 308.00 9,240.00 - - - 1 308.00 9,240.00 404 405 1 294.00 8,820.00 - - - 294.00 8,820.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 77
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
405 406 1 364.00 10,920.00 - - - 1 364.00 10,920.00
406 407 1 370.00 11,100.00 - - - 1 370.00 11,100.00
407 408 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00
408 409 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
409 410 1 372.00 11,160.00 - - - 1 372.00 11,160.00
410 411 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
411 412 1 372.00 11,160.00 - - - 1 372.00 11,160.00
412 413 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
413 414 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 1 314.00 9,420.00
414 415 1 344.00 10,320.00 - - - 1 344.00 10,320.00
415 416 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
416 417 1 258.00 7,740.00 - - - 1 258.00 7,740.00
417 418 1 376.00 11,280.00 - - - 1 376.00 11,280.00
418 419 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
419 420 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
420 421 1 370.00 11,100.00 - - - 1 370.00 11,100.00
421 422 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 1 314.00 9,420.00 422 423 1 410.00 12,300.00 - - - 410.00 12,300.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 78
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
423 424 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 1 314.00 9,420.00
424 425 1 336.00 10,080.00 - - - 1 336.00 10,080.00
425 426 1 260.00 7,800.00 - - - 1 260.00 7,800.00
426 427 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 1 314.00 9,420.00
427 428 1 324.00 9,720.00 - - - 1 324.00 9,720.00
428 429 1 244.00 7,320.00 - - - 1 244.00 7,320.00
429 430 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00
430 431 1 354.69 10,640.70 - - - 1 354.69 10,640.70
AM 079 431 432 1 367.31 11,019.30 - - - 1 367.31 11,019.30
432 433 1 334.00 10,020.00 - - - 1 334.00 10,020.00
433 434 1 398.42 11,952.60 - - - 1 398.42 11,952.60
AM 080 434 435 1 377.58 11,327.40 - - - 1 377.58 11,327.40
435 436 1 260.00 7,800.00 - - - 1 260.00 7,800.00
436 437 1 254.00 7,620.00 - - - 1 254.00 7,620.00
437 438 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 1 314.00 9,420.00
438 439 1 420.00 12,600.00 - - - 1 420.00 12,600.00
439 440 1 280.00 8,400.00 - - - 1 280.00 8,400.00 440 441 1 330.00 9,900.00 - - - 330.00 9,900.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 79
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
441 442 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
442 443 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
443 444 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
444 445 1 304.88 9,146.40 - - - 1 304.88 9,146.40
AM 081 445 446 1 279.12 8,373.60 - - - 1 279.12 8,373.60
446 447 1 312.00 9,360.00 - - - 1 312.00 9,360.00
447 448 1 304.00 9,120.00 - - - 1 304.00 9,120.00
448 449 1 390.00 11,700.00 - - - 1 390.00 11,700.00
449 450 1 274.00 8,220.00 - - - 1 274.00 8,220.00
450 451 1 304.00 9,120.00 - - - 1 304.00 9,120.00
451 452 1 370.00 11,100.00 - - - 1 370.00 11,100.00
452 453 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 1 320.00 9,600.00
453 454 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 1 314.00 9,420.00
454 455 1 374.00 11,220.00 - - - 1 374.00 11,220.00
455 456 1 326.00 9,780.00 - - - 1 326.00 9,780.00
456 457 1 330.00 9,900.00 - - - 1 330.00 9,900.00
457 458 1 392.00 11,760.00 - - - 1 392.00 11,760.00 458 459 1 272.00 8,160.00 - - - 272.00 8,160.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 80
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
459 460 1 291.71 8,751.30 - - - 1 291.71 8,751.30
AM 082 460 461 1 342.29 10,268.70 - - - 1 342.29 10,268.70
461 462 1 336.00 10,080.00 - - - 1 336.00 10,080.00
462 463 1 366.00 10,980.00 - - - 1 366.00 10,980.00
463 464 1 270.00 8,100.00 - - - 1 270.00 8,100.00
464 465 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00
465 466 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
466 467 1 368.00 11,040.00 - - - 1 368.00 11,040.00
467 468 1 362.00 10,860.00 - - - 1 362.00 10,860.00
468 469 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00
469 470 1 366.00 10,980.00 - - - 1 366.00 10,980.00
470 471 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
471 472 1 228.00 6,840.00 - - - 1 228.00 6,840.00
472 473 1 464.00 13,920.00 - - - 1 464.00 13,920.00
473 474 1 334.00 10,020.00 - - - 1 334.00 10,020.00
474 475 1 308.00 9,240.00 - - - 1 308.00 9,240.00
475 476 1 382.37 11,471.10 - - - 1 382.37 11,471.10 AM 083 476 477 1 233.23 6,996.90 - - - 233.23 6,996.90
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 81
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
477 478 1 324.00 9,720.00 - - - 1 324.00 9,720.00
478 479 1 404.00 12,120.00 - - - 1 404.00 12,120.00
479 480 1 107.98 3,239.40 - - - 1 107.98 3,239.40
AM 084 480 481 1 368.02 11,040.60 - - - 1 368.02 11,040.60
481 482 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 1 314.00 9,420.00
482 483 1 253.40 7,602.00 - - - 1 253.40 7,602.00
AM 085 483 484 1 278.60 8,358.00 - - - 1 278.60 8,358.00
484 485 1 324.00 9,720.00 - - - 1 324.00 9,720.00
485 486 1 340.00 10,200.00 - - - 1 340.00 10,200.00
486 487 1 270.00 8,100.00 - 82.00 2,460.00 1 188.00 5,640.00
487 488 1 330.00 9,900.00 1 203.00 6,090.00 - 127.00 3,810.00
488 489 1 364.00 10,920.00 - 218.00 6,540.00 1 146.00 4,380.00
489 490 1 354.00 10,620.00 - 153.00 4,590.00 1 201.00 6,030.00
490 491 1 340.00 10,200.00 1 177.00 5,310.00 - 163.00 4,890.00
491 492 1 266.00 7,980.00 - - - 1 266.00 7,980.00
492 493 1 278.54 8,356.20 - - - 1 278.54 8,356.20
AM 086 493 494 1 299.46 8,983.80 - - - 1 299.46 8,983.80 494 495 1 310.00 9,300.00 - - - 310.00 9,300.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 82
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
495 496 1 268.00 8,040.00 - - - 1 268.00 8,040.00
496 497 1 350.00 10,500.00 - - - 1 350.00 10,500.00
497 498 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00
498 499 1 291.16 8,734.80 - - - 1 291.16 8,734.80
AM 087 499 500 1 320.84 9,625.20 - - - 1 320.84 9,625.20
500 501 1 366.00 10,980.00 - - - 1 366.00 10,980.00
501 502 1 336.00 10,080.00 - 23.00 690.00 1 313.00 9,390.00
502 503 1 338.00 10,140.00 - 72.00 2,160.00 1 266.00 7,980.00
503 504 1 366.76 11,002.80 - 34.00 1,020.00 1 332.76 9,982.80
AM 088 504 505 1 359.24 10,777.20 - - - 1 359.24 10,777.20
505 506 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 1 320.00 9,600.00
506 507 1 300.00 9,000.00 - - - 1 300.00 9,000.00
507 508 1 300.00 9,000.00 - - - 1 300.00 9,000.00
508 509 1 340.00 10,200.00 - 75.00 2,250.00 1 265.00 7,950.00
509 510 1 350.00 10,500.00 1 126.00 3,780.00 - 224.00 6,720.00
510 511 1 348.00 10,440.00 - 84.00 2,520.00 1 264.00 7,920.00
511 512 1 382.00 11,460.00 - - - 1 382.00 11,460.00 512 513 1 314.04 9,421.20 - - - 314.04 9,421.20
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 83
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
AM 089 513 514 1 295.96 8,878.80 - - - 1 295.96 8,878.80
514 515 1 327.73 9,831.90 - - - 1 327.73 9,831.90
AM 090 515 516 1 316.27 9,488.10 - - - 1 316.27 9,488.10
516 517 1 380.00 11,400.00 - - - 1 380.00 11,400.00
517 518 1 306.00 9,180.00 - - - 1 306.00 9,180.00
518 519 1 244.00 7,320.00 - - - 1 244.00 7,320.00
519 520 1 277.67 8,330.10 - - - 1 277.67 8,330.10
AM 091 520 521 1 372.36 11,170.80 - - - 1 372.36 11,170.80
521 522 1 340.00 10,200.00 - - - 1 340.00 10,200.00
522 523 1 300.00 9,000.00 - - - 1 300.00 9,000.00
523 524 1 310.00 9,300.00 - - - 1 310.00 9,300.00
524 525 1 290.00 8,700.00 - - - 1 290.00 8,700.00
525 526 1 330.00 9,900.00 - - - 1 330.00 9,900.00
526 527 1 316.00 9,480.00 - - - 1 316.00 9,480.00
527 528 1 334.00 10,020.00 - - - 1 334.00 10,020.00
528 529 1 300.00 9,000.00 - - - 1 300.00 9,000.00
529 530 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 1 320.00 9,600.00 530 531 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 346.00 10,380.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 84
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
531 532 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
532 533 1 372.00 11,160.00 - - - 1 372.00 11,160.00
533 534 1 315.15 9,454.50 - - - 1 315.15 9,454.50
AM 092 534 535 1 336.85 10,105.50 - - - 1 336.85 10,105.50
535 536 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
536 537 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 1 328.00 9,840.00
537 538 1 318.00 9,540.00 - - - 1 318.00 9,540.00
538 539 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 1 320.00 9,600.00
539 540 1 202.11 6,063.30 - - - 1 202.11 6,063.30
AM 093 540 541 1 217.89 6,536.70 - - - 1 217.89 6,536.70
541 542 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00
542 543 1 364.00 10,920.00 - - - 1 364.00 10,920.00
543 544 1 320.00 9,600.00 - 138.00 4,140.00 1 182.00 5,460.00
544 545 1 328.00 9,840.00 1 210.00 6,300.00 - 118.00 3,540.00
545 546 1 306.00 9,180.00 - 84.00 2,520.00 1 222.00 6,660.00
546 547 1 277.58 8,327.40 - - - 1 277.58 8,327.40
AM 094 547 548 1 262.42 7,872.60 - - - 1 262.42 7,872.60 548 549 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 314.00 9,420.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 85
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
549 550 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 1 314.00 9,420.00
550 551 1 314.00 9,420.00 - - - 1 314.00 9,420.00
551 552 1 315.99 9,479.70 - - - 1 315.99 9,479.70
AM 095 552 553 1 284.01 8,520.30 - - - 1 284.01 8,520.30
553 554 1 300.00 9,000.00 - - - 1 300.00 9,000.00
554 555 1 292.00 8,760.00 - - - 1 292.00 8,760.00
555 556 1 318.00 9,540.00 - - - 1 318.00 9,540.00
556 557 1 277.45 8,323.50 - - - 1 277.45 8,323.50
AM 096 557 558 1 224.55 6,736.50 - - - 1 224.55 6,736.50
558 559 1 342.00 10,260.00 - - - 1 342.00 10,260.00
559 560 1 266.00 7,980.00 - - - 1 266.00 7,980.00
560 561 1 234.00 7,020.00 - - - 1 234.00 7,020.00
561 562 1 246.00 7,380.00 - - - 1 246.00 7,380.00
562 563 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
563 564 1 281.72 8,451.60 - - - 1 281.72 8,451.60
AM 097 564 565 1 298.28 8,948.40 - - - 1 298.28 8,948.40
565 566 1 326.00 9,780.00 - - - 1 326.00 9,780.00 566 567 1 342.00 10,260.00 - - - 342.00 10,260.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 86
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
567 568 1 344.00 10,320.00 - - - 1 344.00 10,320.00
568 569 1 276.00 8,280.00 - - - 1 276.00 8,280.00
569 570 1 316.00 9,480.00 - - - 1 316.00 9,480.00
570 571 1 336.00 10,080.00 - - - 1 336.00 10,080.00
571 572 1 326.00 9,780.00 - - - 1 326.00 9,780.00
572 573 1 302.00 9,060.00 - - - 1 302.00 9,060.00
573 574 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 1 328.00 9,840.00
574 575 1 312.00 9,360.00 - - - 1 312.00 9,360.00
575 576 1 310.00 9,300.00 - - - 1 310.00 9,300.00
576 577 1 350.00 10,500.00 - - - 1 350.00 10,500.00
577 578 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00
578 579 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00
579 580 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00
580 581 1 318.00 9,540.00 - - - 1 318.00 9,540.00
581 582 1 338.00 10,140.00 - - - 1 338.00 10,140.00
582 583 1 306.00 9,180.00 - - - 1 306.00 9,180.00
583 584 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00 584 585 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 360.00 10,800.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 87
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
585 586 1 340.00 10,200.00 - - - 1 340.00 10,200.00
586 587 1 364.00 10,920.00 - - - 1 364.00 10,920.00
587 588 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
588 589 1 292.00 8,760.00 - - - 1 292.00 8,760.00
589 590 1 350.00 10,500.00 - - - 1 350.00 10,500.00
590 591 1 347.39 10,421.70 - - - 1 347.39 10,421.70
AM 098 591 592 1 268.61 8,058.30 - - - 1 268.61 8,058.30
592 593 1 344.00 10,320.00 - - - 1 344.00 10,320.00
593 594 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
594 595 1 344.00 10,320.00 - - - 1 344.00 10,320.00
595 596 1 354.00 10,620.00 - - - 1 354.00 10,620.00
596 597 1 364.00 10,920.00 - - - 1 364.00 10,920.00
597 598 1 336.00 10,080.00 - - - 1 336.00 10,080.00
598 599 1 368.00 11,040.00 - - - 1 368.00 11,040.00
599 600 1 362.00 10,860.00 - - - 1 362.00 10,860.00
600 601 1 336.00 10,080.00 - - - 1 336.00 10,080.00
601 602 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00 602 603 1 306.00 9,180.00 - - - 306.00 9,180.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 88
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
603 604 1 322.00 9,660.00 - - - 1 322.00 9,660.00
604 605 1 321.81 9,654.30 - - - 1 321.81 9,654.30
AM 099 605 606 1 340.19 10,205.70 - - - 1 340.19 10,205.70
606 607 1 364.00 10,920.00 - - - 1 364.00 10,920.00
607 608 1 364.00 10,920.00 - - - 1 364.00 10,920.00
608 609 1 354.00 10,620.00 - - - 1 354.00 10,620.00
609 610 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
610 611 1 364.00 10,920.00 - - - 1 364.00 10,920.00
611 612 1 353.48 10,604.40 - - - 1 353.48 10,604.40
AM 100 612 613 1 266.52 7,995.60 - - - 1 266.52 7,995.60
613 614 1 338.00 10,140.00 - - - 1 338.00 10,140.00
614 615 1 338.00 10,140.00 - - - 1 338.00 10,140.00
615 616 1 262.00 7,860.00 - - - 1 262.00 7,860.00
616 617 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 1 328.00 9,840.00
617 618 1 268.00 8,040.00 - - - 1 268.00 8,040.00
618 619 1 370.00 11,100.00 - - - 1 370.00 11,100.00
619 620 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00 620 621 1 342.00 10,260.00 - - - 342.00 10,260.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 89
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
621 622 1 318.00 9,540.00 - - - 1 318.00 9,540.00
622 623 1 300.00 9,000.00 - - - 1 300.00 9,000.00
623 624 1 366.00 10,980.00 - - - 1 366.00 10,980.00
624 625 1 340.00 10,200.00 - - - 1 340.00 10,200.00
625 626 1 384.00 11,520.00 - - - 1 384.00 11,520.00
626 627 1 344.00 10,320.00 - - - 1 344.00 10,320.00
627 628 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
628 629 1 370.00 11,100.00 - - - 1 370.00 11,100.00
629 630 1 334.00 10,020.00 - - - 1 334.00 10,020.00
630 631 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
631 632 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
632 633 1 292.00 8,760.00 - - - 1 292.00 8,760.00
633 634 1 310.00 9,300.00 - - - 1 310.00 9,300.00
634 635 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 1 320.00 9,600.00
635 636 1 324.00 9,720.00 - - - 1 324.00 9,720.00
636 637 1 286.00 8,580.00 - - - 1 286.00 8,580.00
637 638 1 254.00 7,620.00 - - - 1 254.00 7,620.00 638 639 1 332.00 9,960.00 - - - 332.00 9,960.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 90
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
639 640 1 298.00 8,940.00 - - - 1 298.00 8,940.00
640 641 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
641 642 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
642 643 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00
643 644 1 372.00 11,160.00 - - - 1 372.00 11,160.00
644 645 1 358.00 10,740.00 - - - 1 358.00 10,740.00
645 646 1 368.00 11,040.00 - - - 1 368.00 11,040.00
646 647 1 362.00 10,860.00 - - - 1 362.00 10,860.00
647 648 1 340.00 10,200.00 - - - 1 340.00 10,200.00
648 649 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00
649 650 1 318.00 9,540.00 - - - 1 318.00 9,540.00
650 651 1 318.68 9,560.40 - - - 1 318.68 9,560.40
AM 101 651 652 1 309.32 9,279.60 - - - 1 309.32 9,279.60
652 653 1 257.71 7,731.30 - - - 1 257.71 7,731.30 AM 101A 653 654 1 244.29 7,328.70 - - - 1 244.29 7,328.70
654 655 1 250.00 7,500.00 - - - 1 250.00 7,500.00
655 656 1 334.71 10,041.30 - - - 1 334.71 10,041.30 AM 102 656 657 1 291.96 8,758.80 - - - 291.96 8,758.80
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 91
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
657 658 1 326.00 9,780.00 - - - 1 326.00 9,780.00
658 659 1 266.00 7,980.00 - - - 1 266.00 7,980.00
659 660 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
660 661 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
661 662 1 366.00 10,980.00 - - - 1 366.00 10,980.00
662 663 1 334.00 10,020.00 - - - 1 334.00 10,020.00
663 664 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 1 328.00 9,840.00
664 665 1 338.00 10,140.00 - - - 1 338.00 10,140.00
665 666 1 352.47 10,574.10 - - - 1 352.47 10,574.10
AM 103 666 667 1 347.54 10,426.20 - - - 1 347.54 10,426.20
667 668 1 362.00 10,860.00 - - - 1 362.00 10,860.00
668 669 1 316.00 9,480.00 - - - 1 316.00 9,480.00
669 670 1 366.00 10,980.00 - - - 1 366.00 10,980.00
670 671 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00
671 672 1 368.00 11,040.00 - - - 1 368.00 11,040.00
672 673 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
673 674 1 354.00 10,620.00 - - - 1 354.00 10,620.00 674 675 1 344.00 10,320.00 - - - 344.00 10,320.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 92
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
675 676 1 337.96 10,138.80 - - - 1 337.96 10,138.80
AM 104 676 677 1 344.04 10,321.20 - - - 1 344.04 10,321.20
677 678 1 362.00 10,860.00 - - - 1 362.00 10,860.00
678 679 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
679 680 1 338.00 10,140.00 - - - 1 338.00 10,140.00
680 681 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
681 682 1 332.00 9,960.00 - - - 1 332.00 9,960.00
682 683 1 344.00 10,320.00 - - - 1 344.00 10,320.00
683 684 1 354.00 10,620.00 - - - 1 354.00 10,620.00
684 685 1 374.00 11,220.00 - - - 1 374.00 11,220.00
685 686 1 348.00 10,440.00 - - - 1 348.00 10,440.00
686 687 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
687 688 1 374.00 11,220.00 - - - 1 374.00 11,220.00
688 689 1 342.00 10,260.00 - - - 1 342.00 10,260.00
689 690 1 322.00 9,660.00 - - - 1 322.00 9,660.00
690 691 1 324.00 9,720.00 - - - 1 324.00 9,720.00
691 692 1 340.00 10,200.00 - - - 1 340.00 10,200.00 692 693 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 328.00 9,840.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 93
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
693 694 1 334.15 10,024.50 - - - 1 334.15 10,024.50
AM 105 694 695 1 323.00 9,690.00 - 110.00 3,300.00 1 213.00 6,390.00
AM 106 695 696 1 290.85 8,725.50 1.00 286.50 8,595.00 - 4.35 130.50
696 697 1 319.93 9,597.90 1.00 302.50 9,075.00 - 17.43 522.90
AM 107 697 698 1 346.07 10,382.10 - 63.00 1,890.00 1 283.07 8,492.10
698 699 1 352.00 10,560.00 - - - 1 352.00 10,560.00
699 700 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
700 701 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 1 328.00 9,840.00
701 702 1 332.00 9,960.00 - - - 1 332.00 9,960.00
702 703 1 337.14 10,114.20 - - - 1 337.14 10,114.20
AM 108 703 704 1 350.86 10,525.80 - - - 1 350.86 10,525.80
704 705 1 346.00 10,380.00 - - - 1 346.00 10,380.00
705 706 1 356.00 10,680.00 - - - 1 356.00 10,680.00
706 707 1 342.00 10,260.00 - - - 1 342.00 10,260.00
707 708 1 332.00 9,960.00 - - - 1 332.00 9,960.00
708 709 1 332.00 9,960.00 - 108.00 3,240.00 1 224.00 6,720.00
709 710 1 357.98 10,739.40 - - - 1 357.98 10,739.40 AM 109 710 711 1 262.07 7,862.10 - 186.07 5,582.10
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 94
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 76.00 2,280.00 1
711 712 1 213.84 6,415.20 1 117.00 3,510.00 - 96.84 2,905.20
AM 110 712 713 1 382.16 11,464.80 1 118.00 3,540.00 - 264.16 7,924.80
713 714 1 334.32 10,029.60 - 63.00 1,890.00 1 271.32 8,139.60
AM 111 714 715 1 324.51 9,735.30 - - - 1 324.51 9,735.30
AM 112 715 716 1 345.12 10,353.60 - - - 1 345.12 10,353.60
716 717 1 370.00 11,100.00 - - - 1 370.00 11,100.00
717 718 1 340.00 10,200.00 - - - 1 340.00 10,200.00
718 719 1 338.05 10,141.50 - - - 1 338.05 10,141.50
AM 113 719 720 1 369.96 11,098.80 - - - 1 369.96 11,098.80
720 721 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00
721 722 1 370.00 11,100.00 - 176.00 5,280.00 1 194.00 5,820.00
722 723 1 336.00 10,080.00 - 104.00 3,120.00 1 232.00 6,960.00
723 724 1 360.00 10,800.00 - - - 1 360.00 10,800.00
724 725 1 306.00 9,180.00 - 87.00 2,610.00 1 219.00 6,570.00
725 726 1 360.00 10,800.00 - 92.00 2,760.00 1 268.00 8,040.00
726 727 1 344.00 10,320.00 - - - 1 344.00 10,320.00
727 728 1 320.00 9,600.00 - - - 1 320.00 9,600.00 728 729 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 328.00 9,840.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 95
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 1
729 730 1 350.00 10,500.00 - - - 1 350.00 10,500.00
730 731 1 350.00 10,500.00 - - - 1 350.00 10,500.00
731 732 1 310.25 9,307.50 - - - 1 310.25 9,307.50
AM 114 732 733 1 303.75 9,112.50 - - - 1 303.75 9,112.50
733 734 1 332.00 9,960.00 - - - 1 332.00 9,960.00
734 735 1 328.00 9,840.00 - - - 1 328.00 9,840.00
735 736 1 300.20 9,006.00 - - - 1 300.20 9,006.00
AM 115 736 737 1 317.80 9,534.00 - - - 1 317.80 9,534.00
737 738 1 288.00 8,640.00 - - - 1 288.00 8,640.00
738 739 1 285.53 8,565.90 - - - 1 285.53 8,565.90
AM 116 739 740 1 314.47 9,434.10 - - - 1 314.47 9,434.10
740 741 1 326.00 9,780.00 - 43.00 1,290.00 1 283.00 8,490.00
741 742 1 324.00 9,720.00 1 284.00 8,520.00 - 40.00 1,200.00
742 743 1 270.00 8,100.00 1 182.00 5,460.00 - 88.00 2,640.00
743 LP 1 359.28 10,778.40 - 57.00 1,710.00 1 302.28 9,068.40
LP - GS LP (end) GS/Loralai 7 1,420.00 42,600.00 2 578.00 17,340.00 5 842.00 25,260.00
Sub-total (b.3): Loralai: 355 115,741.60 3,472,248.00 12 4,526.00 135,780.00 343 111,215.60 3,336,468.00 Sub-total (b): Balochistan: 557 182,507.17 5,474,435.10 30 172,484.17 5,173,745.10
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 96
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Reach of the New Total Land Area Traversed (30m wide) Affected Productive Land (30m wide) Traversed Unproductive Land (30m) Angle Transmission Line Number Twr-Twr Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Number Length Area of Land Marker (Angular (Tower Nos.) of Distance Traversed of of TL Affected of of TL Traversed Tower) From To Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) Towers (m) (sq. m) 10,023.00 300,690.00 527
Total (Subproject): 755 245,013.08 7,349,612.40 32 10,428.00 312,840.00 723 234,585.08 7,036,772.40
Overall Percentage 100.00 100.00 100.00 4.24 4.26 4.26 95.76 95.74 95.74
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 97
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table A-2: Temporarily Affected Farmlands and Affected Crops in Loralai 220kV TL Subproject (ROW: 30m)
Affected Farmland Affected Farmlands by Towers Affected Farmland by TL Corridor Reach of the New Cropped Area Area of Affected Transmission Line Length Affected No. of Affected (m2) Length Affected Crop Angle Marker (Tower Nos.) of TL Area Towers Area Wheat Maize of TL Area Wheat Maize AM No. From To (m) (sq. m) (No.) (sq.m ) (Rabi) (Kharif) (m) (sq. m) (Rabi) (Kharif) Section - A: Punjab Province - Sub-section A.1: Dera Ghazi Khan District (DGK): 28 29 Desert/No Cultivation of Crops; only Trees are affected (see Table of Trees) 007 29 30 Desert/No Cultivation of Crops; only Trees are affected (see Table of Trees)
54 55 33 990 - - - - 33 990 990 990
010 55 56 64 1,920 - - - - 64 1,920 1,920 1,920
(011) 62 63 86 2,580 - - - - 86 2,580 2,580 2,580
63 64 192 5,760 1 900 900 900 162 4,860 4,860 4,860
(012) 64 65 30 900 1 900 900 900 - - - -
Sub-total (a): Punjab - DGK: 405 12,150 2 1,800 1,800 1800 345 10,350 10,350 10,350 Section - B: Baluchistan Province: Sub-section - B.1: Bar Khan District (Baluchistan):
197 198 173.00 5,190 - - - - 173 5,190 5,190 5,190
198 199 190.00 5,700 1 900 900 900 160 4,800 4,800 4,800
199 200 146.00 4,380 1 900 900 900 116 3,480 3,480 3,480
200 201 106.00 3,180 1 900 900 900 76 2,280 2,280 2,280
050 201 202 87.00 2,610 - - - - 87 2,610 2,610 2,610
202 203 64.00 1,920 - - - - 64 1,920 1,920 1,920
203 204 58.00 1,740 - - - - 58 1,740 1,740 1,740 204 205 - - - -
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 98
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Affected Farmland Affected Farmlands by Towers Affected Farmland by TL Corridor Reach of the New Cropped Area Area of Affected Transmission Line Length Affected No. of Affected (m2) Length Affected Crop Angle Marker (Tower Nos.) of TL Area Towers Area Wheat Maize of TL Area Wheat Maize AM No. From To (m) (sq. m) (No.) (sq.m ) (Rabi) (Kharif) (m) (sq. m) (Rabi) (Kharif) 42.00 1,260 42 1,260 1,260 1,260
205 206 158.00 4,740 - - - - 158 4,740 4,740 4,740
206 207 163.00 4,890 - - - - 163 4,890 4,890 4,890
051 207 208 126.00 3,780 1 900 900 900 96 2,880 2,880 2,880
208 209 215.00 6,450 1 900 900 900 185 5,550 5,550 5,550
209 210 314.00 9,420 1 900 900 900 284 8,520 8,520 8,520
210 211 325.00 9,750 - - - - 325 9,750 9,750 9,750
052 211 212 306.00 9,180 1 900 900 900 276 8,280 8,280 8,280
053 212 213 296.00 8,880 1 900 900 900 266 7,980 7,980 7,980
213 214 272.00 8,160 1 900 900 900 242 7,260 8,220 8,220
214 215 270.00 8,100 1 900 900 900 240 7,200 8,730 8,730
215 216 242.00 7,260 1 900 900 900 212 6,360 6,360 6,360
216 217 253.00 7,590 1 900 900 900 223 6,690 8,220 8,220
217 218 250.00 7,500 1 900 900 900 220 6,600 6,630 6,630
054 218 219 76.00 2,280 - - - - 76 2,280 2,280 2,280
(055) 238 239 72.00 2,160 - - - - 72 2,160 2,160 2,160
239 240 63.00 1,890 - - - - 63 1,890 1,890 1,890
286 287 21.00 630 - - - - 21 630 630 630 Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 99
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Affected Farmland Affected Farmlands by Towers Affected Farmland by TL Corridor Reach of the New Cropped Area Area of Affected Transmission Line Length Affected No. of Affected (m2) Length Affected Crop Angle Marker (Tower Nos.) of TL Area Towers Area Wheat Maize of TL Area Wheat Maize AM No. From To (m) (sq. m) (No.) (sq.m ) (Rabi) (Kharif) (m) (sq. m) (Rabi) (Kharif)
065 287 288 203.00 6,090 1 900 900 900 173 5,190 5,190 5,190
288 289 93.00 2,790 - - - - 93 2,790 2,790 2,790
066 290 291 18.00 540 - - - - 18 540 540 540
293 294 25.00 750 - - - - 25 750 750 750
294 295 112.00 3,360 1 900 900 900 82 2,460 2,460 2,460
295 296 132.00 3,960 1 900 900 900 102 3,060 3,060 3,060
300 301 27.00 810 - - - - 27 810 810 810
301 302 160.00 4,800 1 900 900 900 130 3,900 3,900 3,900
Sub-total (b.1): Bar Khan (Bal.): 5,058 151,740 17 15,300 15,300 15,300 4,548 136,440 140,490 140,490 Sub-section B.2: Musakhal District (Baluchistan):
323 324 28 840 - - - - 28 840 840 840
(068) 324 325 64 1,920 - - - - 64 1,920 1,920 1,920
(070) 346 347 82 2,460 - - - - 82 2,460 2,460 2,460
347 348 227 6,810 - - - - 227 6,810 6,810 6,810
(071) 348 349 38 1,140 1 900 900 900 8 240 240 240 Sub-total (b.2): Musa Khel (Bal.): 439 13,170 1 900 900 900 409 12,270 12,270 12,270 Sub-section B.3: Loralai District (Baluchistan):
(085) 486 487 82 2,460 - - - - 82 2,460 2,460 2,460
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 100
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Affected Farmland Affected Farmlands by Towers Affected Farmland by TL Corridor Reach of the New Cropped Area Area of Affected Transmission Line Length Affected No. of Affected (m2) Length Affected Crop Angle Marker (Tower Nos.) of TL Area Towers Area Wheat Maize of TL Area Wheat Maize AM No. From To (m) (sq. m) (No.) (sq.m ) (Rabi) (Kharif) (m) (sq. m) (Rabi) (Kharif)
487 488 203 6,090 1 900 900 900 173 5,190 5,190 5,190
488 489 218 6,540 - - - - 218 6,540 6,540 6,540
489 490 153 4,590 - - - - 153 4,590 4,590 4,590
(086) 490 491 177 5,310 1 900 900 900 147 4,410 4,410 4,410
(087) 501 502 23 690 - - - - 23 690 690 690
502 503 72 2,160 - - - - 72 2,160 2,160 2,160
(088) 503 504 34 1,020 - - - - 34 1,020 1,020 1,020
508 509 75 2,250 - - - - 75 2,250 2,250 2,250
509 510 126 3,780 1 900 900 900 96 2,880 2,880 2,880
(089) 510 511 84 2,520 - - - - 84 2,520 2,520 2,520
(093) 543 544 138 4,140 - - - - 138 4,140 4,140 4,140
544 545 210 6,300 1 900 900 900 180 5,400 5,400 5,400
(094) 545 546 84 2,520 - - - - 84 2,520 2,520 2,520
105 694 695 110 3,300 - - - - 110 3,300 3,300 3,300
106 695 696 287 8,595 1 900 900 900 257 7,695 7,695 7,695
696 697 303 9,075 1 900 900 900 273 8,175 8,175 8,175
107 697 698 63 1,890 - - - - 63 1,890 1,890 1,890 708 709 - - - - Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 101
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Affected Farmland Affected Farmlands by Towers Affected Farmland by TL Corridor Reach of the New Cropped Area Area of Affected Transmission Line Length Affected No. of Affected (m2) Length Affected Crop Angle Marker (Tower Nos.) of TL Area Towers Area Wheat Maize of TL Area Wheat Maize AM No. From To (m) (sq. m) (No.) (sq.m ) (Rabi) (Kharif) (m) (sq. m) (Rabi) (Kharif) 108 3,240 108 3,240 3,240 3,240
109 710 711 76 2,280 - - - - 76 2,280 2,280 2,280
711 712 117 3,510 1 900 900 900 87 2,610 2,610 2,610
110 712 713 118 3,540 1 900 900 900 88 2,640 2,640 2,640
713 714 63 1,890 - - - - 63 1,890 1,890 1,890
(113) 721 722 176 5,280 - - - - 176 5,280 5,280 5,280
722 723 104 3,120 - - - - 104 3,120 3,120 3,120
724 725 87 2,610 - - - - 87 2,610 2,610 2,610
725 726 92 2,760 - - - - 92 2,760 2,760 2,760
(116) 740 741 43 1,290 - - - - 43 1,290 1,290 1,290
741 742 284 8,520 1 900 900 900 254 7,620 7,620 7,620
742 743 182 5,460 1 900 900 900 152 4,560 4,560 4,560
743 LP 57 1,710 - - - - 57 1,710 1,710 1,710 LP LP - GS (end) GS/Loralai 578 17,340 2 1,800 1,800 1,800 518 15,540 15,540 15,540
Sub-total (b.3): Loralai (Bal.): 4,526 135,780 12 10,800 10,800 10,800 4,166 124,980 124,980 124,980
Sub-total (b): Balochistan: 10,023 300,690 30 27,000 27,000 27,000 9,123 273,690 277,740 277,740
Total (Subproject): 10,428 312,840 32 28,800 28,800 28,800 9,468 284,040 288,090 288,090
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 102
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table A-3: Fruit and Wood Trees Affected by the Construction of Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Subproject Angle TL Reach Affected Fruit Trees (No.) Affected Wood Trees (No.) Total Almon Affecte Marker (Tower Nos.) Name of Village / Berri Total Shisha Poplar / Willo Total d Kikar d Hamlet (Zizphu (Fruit m Eucallyp w / (Woo AM (Trees / Toot Trees From To s) ) (Sisso) ts Other d) No. ) (No.) Section - A: Punjab Province - Sub-section A.1: Dera Ghazi Khan District (DGK):
Basti Shikar Khan 1 28 29 - 2 2 - - - 1 3
Basti Shikar Khan 2 007 29 30 - 2 2 - - - 2 4
3 54 55 Rajhani Village - 3 3 - - - 3 6
1 010 55 56 Rajhani Village - 3 3 - - - 1 4 Gamuli (Choti Bala 2 (011) 62 63 Road) - 7 7 - - - 2 9 Gamuli (Choti Bala 2 63 64 Road) - 3 3 - - - 2 5 Gamuli (Choti Bala 1 1 (012) 64 65 Road) - 4 4 - - 2 6 Sub-total (a): Punjab - DGK: 0 24 24 10 3 0 0 13 37 Section - B: Baluchistan Province: Sub-section - B.1: Bar Khan District (Baluchistan):
197 198 Basti Kamdan (Bawata) - 1 1 1 1 - 1 3 4
198 199 Basti Kamdan (Bawata) - - 0 1 - - - 1 1
199 200 Pailia Thal (Bawata) - 1 1 - - - - 0 1
200 201 Pailia Thal (Bawata) - 1 1 2 1 - 1 4 5
050 201 202 Pailia Thal (Bawata) - - 0 1 1 - - 2 2
202 203 Sarpa Village - - 0 1 1 - - 2 2
1 204 205 Mir Hamadani Village - - 0 2 - - 3 3 205 206 Mir Hamadani Village - 1 1 1 3 4 5
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 103
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Angle TL Reach Affected Fruit Trees (No.) Affected Wood Trees (No.) Total Almon Affecte Marker (Tower Nos.) Name of Village / Berri Total Shisha Poplar / Willo Total d Kikar d Hamlet (Zizphu (Fruit m Eucallyp w / (Woo AM (Trees / Toot Trees From To s) ) (Sisso) ts Other d) No. ) (No.) - -
206 207 Mir Hamadani Village - 2 2 - - - - 0 2
051 207 208 Basti Kaurri (Rakni) - - 0 - - 2 - 2 2
208 209 Basti Kaurri (Rakni) - - 0 2 1 4 - 7 7
209 210 Basti Kaurri (Rakni) - - 0 1 2 3 - 6 6
210 211 Basti Kaurri (Rakni) - - 0 3 1 - - 4 4
052 211 212 Basti Kaurri (Rakni) - - 0 4 - - - 4 4
053 212 213 Basti Kaurri (Rakni) - - 0 2 1 4 - 7 7
213 214 Basti Kaurri (Rakni) - - 0 3 - - 5 8 8
214 215 Basti Kaurri (Rakni) - - 0 2 - 5 - 7 7
215 216 Basti Kaurri (Rakni) - - 0 2 - - - 2 2
216 217 Basti Kaurri (Rakni) - - 0 3 - - - 3 3
054 217 218 Basti Kaurri (Rakni) - - 0 1 - 4 - 5 5
218 219 Basti Kaurri (Rakni) - - 0 1 2 - - 3 3
(055) 238 239 Deh Bhebani 1 - 1 2 - 3 - 5 6
239 240 Deh Bhebani 2 - 2 1 - 2 - 3 5
1 286 287 Rarkan Village 3 - 3 0 1 - 2 5
065 287 288 Rarkan Village 4 - 4 0 2 - - 2 6
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 104
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Angle TL Reach Affected Fruit Trees (No.) Affected Wood Trees (No.) Total Almon Affecte Marker (Tower Nos.) Name of Village / Berri Total Shisha Poplar / Willo Total d Kikar d Hamlet (Zizphu (Fruit m Eucallyp w / (Woo AM (Trees / Toot Trees From To s) ) (Sisso) ts Other d) No. ) (No.)
288 289 Rarkan Village 5 - 5 1 - - - 1 6
066 290 291 Rarkan Village - - 0 0 - - - 0 0
293 294 Rarkan Village - - 0 1 - - - 1 1
294 295 Rarkan Village - - 0 0 - - - 0 0
295 296 Rarkan Village - - 0 1 - - - 1 1
300 301 Rarkan Village - - 0 0 - - - 0 0
301 302 Rarkan Village - - 0 0 - - - 0 0
Sub-total (b.1): Bar Khan (Bal.): 15 6 21 38 15 32 7 92 113 Sub-section B.2: Musakhal District (Baluchistan):
323 324 Rarrasham - - 0 - - - - 0 0
(068) 324 325 Rarrasham - - 0 1 - - - 1 1
(070) 346 347 Gidar Daag - 4 4 - 1 - 4 5 9
347 348 Gidar Daag - 7 7 - - - 1 1 8
(071) 348 349 Gidar Daag - 5 5 1 - - 1 2 7 Sub-total (b.2): Musa Khel (Bal.): 016162 106925 Sub-section B.3: Loralai District (Baluchistan): (085) 486 487 Mekhtar Village - - 0 1 - 2 6 9 9
487 488 Mekhtar Village 4 - 4 - - - 2 2 6
488 489 Mekhtar Village 5 - 5 - - - - 0 5 489 490 Mekhtar Village 2 - 2 2 - 2 4 Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 105
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Angle TL Reach Affected Fruit Trees (No.) Affected Wood Trees (No.) Total Almon Affecte Marker (Tower Nos.) Name of Village / Berri Total Shisha Poplar / Willo Total d Kikar d Hamlet (Zizphu (Fruit m Eucallyp w / (Woo AM (Trees / Toot Trees From To s) ) (Sisso) ts Other d) No. ) (No.) - -
(086) 490 491 Mekhtar Village - - 0 - - - - 0 0
(087) 501 502 Indah Village 2 3 5 - - - - 0 5
502 503 Indah Village 4 - 4 - - - - 0 4
(088) 503 504 Indah Village 3 - 3 - - - - 0 3
508 509 Torat Thana Village 4 1 5 - - - - 0 5
509 510 Torat Thana Village 4 2 6 - - 3 3 6 12
(089) 510 511 Torat Thana Village 5 1 6 - - 4 2 6 12
(093) 543 544 Gharra Village (Sehan) - 2 2 2 1 3 - 6 8
544 545 Gharra Village (Sehan) 2 - 2 3 - 2 - 5 7
(094) 545 546 Gharra Village (Sehan) 4 - 4 - 26- 8 12
105 694 695 Shabozai Village 2 - 2 1 3 - - 4 6
106 695 696 Shabozai Village 6 - 6 - - 2 - 2 8
696 697 Shabozai Village 8 - 8 2 2 - - 4 12
107 697 698 Shabozai Village 6 - 6 - 1 - 2 3 9 708 709 Masood Killi 5 - 5 3 - - 1 4 9
109 710 711 Masood Killi 6 - 6 1 - - - 1 7
711 712 Masood Killi 6 - 6 - - 1 - 1 7 110 712 713 Masood Killi 4 - 4 - - 1 1 5
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 106
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Angle TL Reach Affected Fruit Trees (No.) Affected Wood Trees (No.) Total Almon Affecte Marker (Tower Nos.) Name of Village / Berri Total Shisha Poplar / Willo Total d Kikar d Hamlet (Zizphu (Fruit m Eucallyp w / (Woo AM (Trees / Toot Trees From To s) ) (Sisso) ts Other d) No. ) (No.) -
713 714 Masood Killi - - 0 1 - - - 1 1
(113) 721 722 Tattai Bala Killi - - 0 2 - 1 - 3 3
722 723 Tattai Bala Killi - - 0 1 2 - - 3 3
724 725 Tattai Bala Killi - - 0 2 - - - 2 2
725 726 Tattai Bala Killi - - 0 - - 2 2 4 4
(116) 740 741 Naway Bawar Killi - - 0 - 1 1 - 2 2
741 742 Naway Bawar Killi - - 0 - - - 2 2 2
742 743 Naway Bawar Killi - - 0 - - 2 1 3 3
743 LP Naway Bawar Killi - - 0 - 1 3 - 4 4 LP - LP GS/Loral GS (end) ai Naway Bawar Killi - - 0 - - 1 1 2 2 Sub-total (b.3): Loralai (Bal.): 82 9 91 19 15 33 23 90 181 Sub-total (b): Balochistan: 97 31 128 59 31 65 36 191 319 Total (Subproject): 97 55 152 69 34 65 36 204 356
Percentages - Fruit & Wood Trees: 100.0 100.0 63.82 36.18 0 33.82 16.67 31.86 17.65 0 -
Percentages - Fruit Trees Versus Wood Trees: 42.70 57.30 100.00
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 107
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table A.4: List of Farming Households Affected by the Construction of Loralai 220kV Transmission Lines Subproject
No. of Affected Farmlands Affected by AffectedTree Name of Name of Affected TL Reach Farmlands Towers & TL Corridor s No Tenurial Affected Farmer (Head of Towe Tower . Status Hamlet / Household) AM r Length Area (30x30m) TL Corridor (30m) Fruit Woo Village No Area Length Area Tree d No. Nos. (m) (m2) . (m2) (m) (m2) s Trees Section - A: Punjab Province - Sub-section A.1: Dera Ghazi Khan District (DGK): Landowne Basti Shikar 1 Shikar Khan Khosa r Khan 28-29 Desert Land. No Cropping. Only Scattered Trees. 2 1 Landowne Basti Shikar 2 Khuda Bukhsh Khosa r Khan 7 29-30 Desert Land. No Cropping. Only Scattered Trees. 2 2 Landowne 3 Musallim Master r Rajhani Village 54-55 33 990 - - 33 990 2 1 Landowne 4 Razi Khan r Rajhani Village 10 55-56 64 1,920 - - 64 1,920 3 2 Landowne 5 Nabli Ramba Mujawir r Gamuli 11 62-63 52 1,560 - - 52 1,560 4 - Landowne 6 Chimru Khan Mujawir r Gamuli 62-63 34 1,020 - - 34 1,020 3 2 Landowne 7 Fazlur Rahman Mujawir r Gamuli 12 63-64 62 1,860 - - 62 1,860 2 1 Landowne 8 Bhagoo Khan Mujawir r Gamuli 63-65 65 1,950 1 900 35 1,050 3 - Landowne 9 Kaurra Mekrri r Gamuli 64-65 47 1,410 - - 47 1,410 - 4 Landowne 10 Afzal Alyani r Gamuli 64-65 48 1,440 1 900 18 540 3 -
Sub-total (a): Punjab - DGK (10 AHs): 405 12,150 2 1,800 345 10,350 24 13 Section - B: Baluchistan Province: Sub-section - B.1: Bar Khan District (Baluchistan): Landowne 197- 11 Spar Khan Leghari r Pailia Thal 198 173 5,190 - - 173 5,190 1 3 Landowne 198- 12 Jan Mohammad Leghari r Pailia Thal 199 190 5,700 1 900 160 4,800 - 1 Landowne 199- 13 Shahab Din Khetran r Pailia Thal 200 146 4,380 1 900 116 3,480 1 2 Landowne 200- 14 Haji Sain Dad Leghari r Pailia Thal 201 106 3,180 1 900 76 2,280 1 4 15 Pahada Khan Khetran Landowne Sarpa Village 50 201- -
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 108
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
No. of Affected Farmlands Affected by AffectedTree Name of Name of Affected TL Reach Farmlands Towers & TL Corridor s No Tenurial Affected Farmer (Head of Towe Tower . Status Hamlet / Household) AM r Length Area (30x30m) TL Corridor (30m) Fruit Woo Village No Area Length Area Tree d No. Nos. (m) (m2) . (m2) (m) (m2) s Trees r 202 87.00 2,610 - - 87 2,610 2 Landowne 202- 16 Kalu Khan Khetran r Sarpa Village 203 64.00 1,920 - - 64 1,920 - - Landowne Mir Hamadani 203- 17 Mir Hamadani r Kili 204 58.00 1,740 - - 58 1,740 - 3 Landowne Mir Hamadani 204- 18 Badha Khetran r Kili 205 42.00 1,260 - - 42 1,260 - 1 Landowne Mir Hamadani 205- 19 Balakh Khetran r Kili 206 62.00 1,860 - - 62 1,860 1 1 Landowne Mir Hamadani 20 Haibat Saryam r Kili 96.00 2,880 - - 96 2,880 - - Landowne 206- 21 Haji Gul Moahmmad r Basti Khaprani 207 71.00 2,130 - - 71 2,130 1 1 Landowne 22 Binda Khan Khetran r Basti Khaprani 92.00 2,760 - - 92 2,760 1 1 Landowne 207- 23 Ahmad Khan Khetran r Basti Kaurri 51 208 126.00 3,780 1 900 96 2,880 - 2 Landowne 208- 24 Kamal Khan Khetran r Basti Kaurri 209 82.00 2,460 - - 82 2,460 - 2 Landowne 208- 25 Lal Khan Khetran r Basti Kaurri 210 133.00 3,990 1 900 103 3,090 - 5 Landowne 209- 26 Sahib Khan Khetran r Basti Kaurri 210 128.00 3,840 - - 128 3,840 - 6 Landowne 27 Allah Dad Khetran r Basti Kaurri 186.00 5580 1 900 156 4,680 - 1 Landowne 210- 28 Khamees Khan Khetran r Basti Kaurri 211 142.00 4,260 - - 142 4,260 - 3 Landowne 210- 29 Gul Khan Khetran r Basti Kaurri 212 183.00 5,490 1 900 153 4,590 - 2 Landowne 211- 30 Sadaram Khan Khetran r Basti Kaurri 52 212 124.00 3,720 - - 124 3,720 - 2 Wadera Mohammad Landowne 31 Jan r Basti Kaurri 182.00 5,460 - - 182 5,460 - 7 Landowne 212- 32 Ismail Shah Sheikh r Basti Kaurri 53 213 296.00 8,880 1 900 266 7,980 - 8 Khan Mohamad Landowne 213- 33 Khamees r Basti Kaurri 214 272.00 8,160 1 900 242 7,260 - 7 34 Abdul Karim (Son of Landowne Basti Kaurri 214- 1 -
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 109
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
No. of Affected Farmlands Affected by AffectedTree Name of Name of Affected TL Reach Farmlands Towers & TL Corridor s No Tenurial Affected Farmer (Head of Towe Tower . Status Hamlet / Household) AM r Length Area (30x30m) TL Corridor (30m) Fruit Woo Village No Area Length Area Tree d No. Nos. (m) (m2) . (m2) (m) (m2) s Trees #33) r 215 270.00 8,100 900 240 7,200 2 Abdul Rahim (Son of Landowne 215- 35 #33) r Basti Kaurri 216 242.00 7,260 1 900 212 6,360 - 3 Landowne 216- 36 Mehmood Khan r Basti Kaurri 217 253.00 7,590 1 900 223 6,690 - 5 Landowne 217- 37 Sher Jan Fatyani r Basti Kaurri 218 250.00 7,500 1 900 220 6,600 - 2 Landowne 218- 38 Haji Rahmatan r Basti Kaurri 54 219 76.00 2,280 - - 76 2,280 - 1 Landowne 238- 39 Sher Khan r Deh Bhebani {55} 239 38.00 1,140 - - 38 1,140 - 4 Landowne 40 Gamman Khan r Deh Bhebani 34.00 1,020 - - 34 1,020 1 1 Landowne 239- 41 Rahim Khan r Deh Bhebani 240 26.00 780 - - 26 780 1 2 Landowne 42 Khuda Bukhsh r Deh Bhebani 37.00 1,110 - - 37 1,110 1 1 Landowne 286- 43 Khairullah Hasni r Rarkan Village 287 21.00 630 - - 21 630 - 2 Landowne 44 Rahimullah Hasni r Rarkan Village 63.00 1,890 - - 63 1,890 3 - Landowne 45 Gul Beg Hasni r Rarkan Village 140.00 4,200 - - 140 4,200 4 - Landowne 287- 46 Nabi Jan Hasni r Rarkan Village 65 288 38.00 1,140 1 900 8 240 3 2 Landowne 47 Sohrab Khan Hasni r Rarkan Village 55.00 1,650 - - 55 1,650 2 Landowne 290- 48 Nabi Bukhsh Hasni r Rarkan Village 66 291 18.00 540 - - 18 540 - 1 Habeeb ur Rehman Landowne 293- 49 Hasni r Rarkan Village 294 25.00 750 - - 25 750 - 1 Landowne 294- 50 Ubaidullah Hasni r Rarkan Village 295 112.00 3,360 1 900 82 2,460 - - Landowne 295- 51 Gul Jan Hasni r Rarkan Village 296 132.00 3,960 1 900 102 3,060 - 1 Landowne 300- 52 Ahmad Deen Hasni r Rarkan Village 301 27.00 810 - - 27 810 - - 53 Mohammad Deen Hasni Landowne Rarkan Village 301- 1 -
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 110
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
No. of Affected Farmlands Affected by AffectedTree Name of Name of Affected TL Reach Farmlands Towers & TL Corridor s No Tenurial Affected Farmer (Head of Towe Tower . Status Hamlet / Household) AM r Length Area (30x30m) TL Corridor (30m) Fruit Woo Village No Area Length Area Tree d No. Nos. (m) (m2) . (m2) (m) (m2) s Trees r 302 160.00 4,800 900 130 3,900 -
Sub-Total (b.1): Bar Khan (Balochistan) - 43 AHs: 5,058 151,740 17 15,300 4,548 136,440 21 92 Sub-section - B.2: Musa Khel District (Baluchistan): Landowne 323- 54 Bakhshal Khan Baloch r Rarrasham 324 28.00 840 - - 28 840 - 1 Deen Mohammad Landowne 324- {68} 55 Baloch r Rarrasham 325 64.00 1,920 - - 64 1,920 - 1 Fazal ur Rehman Landowne 346- {70} 56 Baloch r Gidar Daag 347 82.00 2,460 - - 82 2,460 5 2 Landowne 347- 57 Mujtaba Khan Baloch r Gidar Daag 348 72.00 2,160 - - 72 2,160 5 1 Landowne 58 Murtaza Khan Baloch r Gidar Daag 88.00 2,640 - - 88 2,640 4 1 Landowne 59 Bukhsh Ali Baloch r Gidar Daag 67.00 2,010 - - 67 2,010 2 1 Landowne 348- {71} 60 Hameed Khan Baloch r Gidar Daag 349 38 1,140 1 900 8 240 - 2
Sub-total (b.2): Musa Khel (Balochistan) - 7 AHs: 439 13,170 1 900 409 12,270 16 9 Sub-section B.3: Loralai District (Baluchistan): Sardar Abdul Manan Landowne Mekhtar 486- 61 85 Nasir r Village 487 35.00 1,050 - - 35 1,050 - 4 Landowne Mekhtar 62 Majak Haji r Village 47.00 1,410 - - 47 1,410 - 5 Landowne Mekhtar 487- 63 Dinnak Jallozai r Village 488 54.00 1,620 1 900 24 720 1 - Landowne Mekhtar 64 Abdul Malik Adezai r Village 48.00 1,440 - - 48 1,440 - 1 Landowne Mekhtar 65 Palay Haji Adezai r Village 42.00 1,260 - - 42 1,260 2 - Landowne Mekhtar 66 Khula Khan Adezai r Village 27.00 810 - - 27 810 1 - Landowne Mekhtar 67 Aurak Haji Jallozai r Village 32.00 960 - - 32 960 - 1 Landowne Mekhtar 488- 68 Gul Mohammad Khan r Village 489 18.00 540 - - 18 540 1 -
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 111
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
No. of Affected Farmlands Affected by AffectedTree Name of Name of Affected TL Reach Farmlands Towers & TL Corridor s No Tenurial Affected Farmer (Head of Towe Tower . Status Hamlet / Household) AM r Length Area (30x30m) TL Corridor (30m) Fruit Woo Village No Area Length Area Tree d No. Nos. (m) (m2) . (m2) (m) (m2) s Trees Landowne Mekhtar 69 Sherak Talakzai r Village 37.00 1,110 - - 37 1,110 - - Landowne Mekhtar 70 Tore Khan Palezai r Village 23.00 690 - - 23 690 1 - Landowne Mekhtar 71 Haji Bazik Palezai r Village 44.00 1,320 - - 44 1,320 - - Landowne Mekhtar 72 Mallay Khan Palezai r Village 51.00 1,530 - - 51 1,530 2 - Landowne Mekhtar 73 Shaebo Khan Palezai r Village 24.00 720 - - 24 720 1 - Landowne Mekhtar 74 Haji Rehmat Khan r Village 21.00 630 - - 21 630 - - Landowne Mekhtar 489- 75 Mira Khan Palezai r Village 490 67.00 2,010 - - 67 2,010 1 - Landowne Mekhtar 76 Fida ur Rehman Nasir r Village 86.00 2,580 - - 86 2,580 1 2 Mohammad Umar Landowne Mekhtar 490- 77 {86} Nasir r Village 491 31.00 930 - - 31 930 - - Landowne Mekhtar 78 Abdul Malik Nasir r Village 62.00 1,860 - - 62 1,860 - - Mohammad Zaman Landowne Mekhtar 79 Nasir r Village 84.00 2,520 1 900 54 1,620 - - Landowne Ashberg 501- 80 Jamal Khan {87} r Village 502 23.00 690 - - 23 690 5 - Landowne Ashberg 502- 81 Hidayatullah Khan r Village 503 22.00 660 - - 22 660 4 - Mohammad Saleem Landowne Ashberg 82 Khan r Village 27.00 810 - - 27 810 - - Mohammad Aslam Landowne 83 Indah Village Kakar r 23.00 690 - - 23 690 - - Mohammad Hayat Landowne 503- 84 Indah Village (88} Kakar r 504 18.00 540 - - 18 540 1 - Fazal ur Rehman Landowne 85 Indah Village Kakar r 16.00 480 1 900 (14) (420) 2 - Landowne 508- 86 Atta Mohammad Kakar Indah Village r 509 75.00 2,250 - - 75 2,250 5 - Landowne 509- 87 Raz Mohammad Kakar Indah Village r 510 54.00 1,620 - - 54 1,620 4 3
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 112
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
No. of Affected Farmlands Affected by AffectedTree Name of Name of Affected TL Reach Farmlands Towers & TL Corridor s No Tenurial Affected Farmer (Head of Towe Tower . Status Hamlet / Household) AM r Length Area (30x30m) TL Corridor (30m) Fruit Woo Village No Area Length Area Tree d No. Nos. (m) (m2) . (m2) (m) (m2) s Trees Dost Mohammad Landowne 88 Indah Village Kakar r 72.00 2,160 1 900 42 1,260 2 3 Landowne 510- 89 Malak Gul Mohammad Indah Village {89} r 511 84.00 2,520 - - 84 2,520 6 6 Jamon Khan Landowne 543- 90 Sehan Gharra {93} Hamzazai r 544 17.00 510 - - 17 510 - 2 Landowne 91 Mir Khan Hamzazai Sehan Gharra r 30.00 900 - - 30 900 1 1 Landowne 92 Baath Khan Hamzazai Sehan Gharra r 38.00 1,140 - - 38 1,140 1 2 Landowne 93 Sehan Gharra Balos Khan Hamzazai r 53.00 1,590 - - 53 1,590 - 1 Khair Mohamad Landowne 544- 94 Sehan Gharra Hamzazai r 545 62.00 1,860 1 900 32 960 1 - Khan Mohamad Landowne 95 Sehan Gharra Hamzazai r 30.00 900 - - 30 900 - 1 Landowne 96 Sehan Gharra Haji Mirajan r 21.00 630 - - 21 630 - - Landowne 97 Sehan Gharra Mullah Jamal r 14.00 420 - - 14 420 - 2 Landowne 98 Sehan Gharra Shadi Khan r 35.00 1,050 - - 35 1,050 - - Landowne 99 Sehan Gharra Baijak Khan r 27.00 810 - - 27 810 - 2 Landowne 100 Sehan Gharra Dostak Khan r 21.00 630 - - 21 630 1 - Landowne 545- 101 Sehan Gharra {94} Malak Ghulam r 546 38.00 1,140 - - 38 1,140 3 4 Landowne 102 Sehan Gharra Zantoo Khan r 46.00 1,380 - - 46 1,380 1 4 Mohamad Yaqoob Landowne 694- 103 105 Kudozai r Shabozai 695 110.00 3,300 - - 110 3,300 2 4 Mohamad Salman Landowne 695- 104 106 Kudozai r Shabozai 696 164.50 4,935 - - 165 4,935 5 - Mohammad Sultan Landowne 105 Kudozai r Shabozai 122.00 3,660 - - 122 3,660 1 2 Landowne 696- 106 Hayat Khan Kudozai r Shabozai 697 134.00 4,020 - - 134 4,020 3 2
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 113
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
No. of Affected Farmlands Affected by AffectedTree Name of Name of Affected TL Reach Farmlands Towers & TL Corridor s No Tenurial Affected Farmer (Head of Towe Tower . Status Hamlet / Household) AM r Length Area (30x30m) TL Corridor (30m) Fruit Woo Village No Area Length Area Tree d No. Nos. (m) (m2) . (m2) (m) (m2) s Trees Landowne 107 Afta Khan Kudozai r Shabozai 168.50 5,055 1 900 139 4,155 5 2 Laal Mohammad Landowne 697- 108 107 Kudozai r Shabozai 698 63.00 1,890 - - 63 1,890 6 3 Landowne 708- 109 Alauddin Khan r Masood Killi 709 108.00 3,240 - - 108 3,240 5 4 Landowne 710- 110 109 Ajamir Temarkhel r Masood Killi 711 76.00 2,280 - - 76 2,280 6 1 Landowne 711- 111 Bakhtiar Temarkhel r Masood Killi 712 117.00 3,510 1 900 87 2,610 6 1 Landowne 712- 112 110 Mukhtiar Temarkhel r Masood Killi 713 66.00 1,980 1 900 36 1,080 3 1 Mumtaz Khan Landowne 113 Temarkhel r Masood Killi 52.00 1,560 - - 52 1,560 1 - Landowne 713- 114 Haji Feroz Khan r Masood Killi 714 63.00 1,890 - - 63 1,890 - 1 Mohammad Arshad Landowne {113 721- 115 Khan r Sagor Village } 722 176.00 5,280 - - 176 5,280 - 3 Landowne 722- 116 Banaras Khan r Sagor Village 723 104.00 3,120 - - 104 3,120 - 3 Landowne 724- 117 Bawar Khan r Sagor Village 725 87.00 2,610 - - 87 2,610 - 2 Landowne 725- 118 Haji Khan Mohammad r Sagor Village 726 92.00 2,760 - - 92 2,760 - 4 Landowne {116 740- 119 Haji Saleem Utamkhel r Bala Killi Tattai } 741 43.00 1,290 - - 43 1,290 - 2 Landowne 741- 120 Haji Kareem Utamkhel r Bala Killi Tattai 742 160.00 4,800 1 900 130 3,900 - 1 Landowne 121 Barat Khan r Bala Killi Tattai 124.00 3,720 - - 124 3,720 - 1 Landowne 742- 122 Abdul Hakeem r Bala Killi Tattai 743 182.00 5,460 1 900 152 4,560 - 3 Landowne 743- 123 Mohammad Zakariya r Bala Killi Tattai LP 57.00 1,710 - - 57 1,710 - 4 Landowne Naway Bawar LP- 124 LP Abdul Rafique r Killi GS 182.00 5,460 - - 182 5,460 - - Landowne Naway Bawar 125 Master Amanullah r Killi 202.00 6,060 1 900 172 5,160 - 2
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 114
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
No. of Affected Farmlands Affected by AffectedTree Name of Name of Affected TL Reach Farmlands Towers & TL Corridor s No Tenurial Affected Farmer (Head of Towe Tower . Status Hamlet / Household) AM r Length Area (30x30m) TL Corridor (30m) Fruit Woo Village No Area Length Area Tree d No. Nos. (m) (m2) . (m2) (m) (m2) s Trees Landowne Naway Bawar 126 Haji Faiz Mohd Nasir r Killi 194.00 5,820 1 900 164 4,920 - -
Sub-total (b.3): Loralai (Baluchistan.) - 66 AHs: 4,526 135,780 12 10,800 4,166 124,980 91 90
Sub-total (b): Baluchistan (116 AHs): 10,023 300,690 30 27,000 9,123 273,690 128 191
Total (Subproject) - 126 AHs: 10,428 312,840 32 28,800 9,468 284,040 152 204
Table A-5: Percentage of Temporarily Affected Farmland by Type of Line in Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Subproject
Share Total Farmland Holding Affected Farmland of AH Name of Affected Farmer Name of Tenurial Crop No. (Head of Household) Hamlet/Village Status (%) Kanals Hectares Sq. Meters Area (m2) Percentage Section - A: Punjab Province - Sub-section A.1: Dera Ghazi Khan District (DGK): 1 Shikar Khan Khosa Basti Shikar Khan Landowner 100 No Farmlands; only Trees - - 2 Khuda Bukhsh Khosa Basti Shikar Khan Landowner 100 No Farmlands; only Trees - -
3 Musallim Master Rajhani Village Landowner 100 25.00 1.26 12,646.70 990 7.83
4 Razi Khan Rajhani Village Landowner 100 40.00 2.02 20,234.72 1,920 9.49
5 Nabli Ramba Mujawir Gamuli (Choti Bala) Landowner 100 36.00 1.82 18,211.25 1,560 8.57
6 Chimru Khan Mujawir Gamuli (Choti Bala) Landowner 100 24.50 1.24 12,393.77 1,020 8.23
7 Fazlur Rahman Mujawir Gamuli (Choti Bala) Landowner 100 39.50 2.00 19,981.79 1,860 9.31
8 Bhagoo Khan Mujawir Gamuli (Choti Bala) Landowner 100 40.00 2.02 20,234.72 1,950 9.64 9 Kaurra Mekrri Gamuli (Choti Bala) Landowner 100 30.00 1.52 9.29 Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 115
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Share Total Farmland Holding Affected Farmland of AH Name of Affected Farmer Name of Tenurial Crop No. (Head of Household) Hamlet/Village Status (%) Kanals Hectares Sq. Meters Area (m2) Percentage 15,176.04 1,410
10 Afzal Alyani Gamuli (Choti Bala) Landowner 100 30.00 1.52 15,176.04 1,440 9.49
Sub-total (a): Punjab - DGK (10 AHs): - - 265.00 13.41 134,055.04 12,150 9.06 Section - B: Baluchistan Province: Sub-section - B.1: Bar Khan District (Baluchistan):
11 Spar Khan Leghari Pailia Thal (Bawata) Landowner 100 120.00 6.07 60,704.17 5,190 8.55
12 Jan Mohammad Leghari Pailia Thal (Bawata) Landowner 100 127.00 6.42 64,245.24 5,700 8.87
13 Shahab Din Khetran Pailia Thal (Bawata) Landowner 100 96.00 4.86 48,563.33 4,380 9.02
14 Haji Sain Dad Leghari Pailia Thal (Bawata) Landowner 100 70.00 3.54 35,410.76 3,180 8.98
15 Pahada Khan Khetran Sarpa Village Landowner 100 56.00 2.83 28,328.61 2,610 9.21
16 Kalu Khan Khetran Sarpa Village Landowner 100 42.00 2.12 21,246.46 1,920 9.04
17 Mir Hamadani Mir Hamadani Kili Landowner 100 40.00 2.02 20,234.72 1,740 8.60
18 Badha Khetran Mir Hamadani Kili Landowner 100 30.00 1.52 15,176.04 1,260 8.30
19 Balakh Khetran Mir Hamadani Kili Landowner 100 44.00 2.23 22,258.20 1,860 8.36
20 Haibat Saryam Mir Hamadani Kili Landowner 100 64.00 3.24 32,375.56 2,880 8.90
21 Haji Gul Moahmmad Basti Khaprani Landowner 100 50.00 2.53 25,293.40 2,130 8.42
22 Binda Khan Khetran Basti Khaprani Landowner 100 66.00 3.34 33,387.29 2,760 8.27
23 Ahmad Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 84.00 4.25 42,492.92 3,780 8.90
24 Kamal Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 55.00 2.78 27,822.74 2,460 8.84 25 Lal Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 90.00 4.55 8.76
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 116
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Share Total Farmland Holding Affected Farmland of AH Name of Affected Farmer Name of Tenurial Crop No. (Head of Household) Hamlet/Village Status (%) Kanals Hectares Sq. Meters Area (m2) Percentage 45,528.13 3,990
26 Sahib Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 84.50 4.27 42,745.85 3,840 8.98
27 Allah Dad Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 112.00 5.67 56,657.22 5,580 9.85
28 Khamees Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 87.50 4.43 44,263.46 4,260 9.62
29 Gul Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 132.00 6.68 66,774.59 5,490 8.22
30 Sadaram Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 80.00 4.05 40,469.45 3,720 9.19
31 Wadera Mohammad Jan Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 122.50 6.20 61,968.84 5,460 8.81
32 Ismail Shah Sheikh Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 180.00 9.11 91,056.25 8,880 9.75
33 Khan Mohamad Khamees Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 172.00 8.70 87,009.31 8,160 9.38
34 Abdul Karim (Son of #33) Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 204.00 10.32 103,197.09 8,100 7.85
35 Abdul Rahim (Son of #33) Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 182.00 9.21 92,067.99 7,260 7.89
36 Mehmood Khan Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 200.00 10.12 101,173.61 7,590 7.50
37 Sher Jan Fatyani Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 192.50 9.74 97,379.60 7,500 7.70
38 Haji Rahmatan Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Landowner 100 62.50 3.16 31,616.75 2,280 7.21
39 Sher Khan Deh Bhebani Landowner 100 27.50 1.39 13,911.37 1,140 8.19
40 Gamman Khan Deh Bhebani Landowner 100 24.50 1.24 12,393.77 1,020 8.23
41 Rahim Khan Deh Bhebani Landowner 100 16.00 0.81 8,093.89 780 9.64
42 Khuda Bukhsh Deh Bhebani Landowner 100 27.50 1.39 13,911.37 1,110 7.98
43 Khairullah Hasni Rarkan Village Landowner 100 15.00 0.76 7588.02 630 8.30 Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 117
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Share Total Farmland Holding Affected Farmland of AH Name of Affected Farmer Name of Tenurial Crop No. (Head of Household) Hamlet/Village Status (%) Kanals Hectares Sq. Meters Area (m2) Percentage
44 Rahimullah Hasni Rarkan Village Landowner 100 44.00 2.23 22258.20 1,890 8.49
45 Gul Beg Hasni Rarkan Village Landowner 100 92.00 4.65 46539.86 4,200 9.02
46 Nabi Jan Hasni Rarkan Village Landowner 100 32.50 1.64 16440.71 1,140 6.93
47 Sohrab Khan Hasni Rarkan Village Landowner 100 35.00 1.77 17705.38 1,650 9.32
48 Nabi Bukhsh Hasni Rarkan Village Landowner 100 17.50 0.89 8852.69 540 6.10
49 Habeeb ur Rehman Hasni Rarkan Village Landowner 100 16.00 0.81 8093.89 750 9.27
50 Ubaidullah Hasni Rarkan Village Landowner 100 72.00 3.64 36422.50 3,360 9.23
51 Gul Jan Hasni Rarkan Village Landowner 100 87.00 4.40 44010.52 3,960 9.00
52 Ahmad Deen Hasni Rarkan Village Landowner 100 18.00 0.91 9105.63 810 8.90
53 Mohammad Deen Hasni Rarkan Village Landowner 100 102.00 5.16 51598.54 4,800 9.30
Sub-Total (b.1): Bar Khan (Baluchistan): - - 3,472.00 175.64 1,756,374 151,740 8.64 Sub-section - B.2: Musa Khel District (Baluchistan):
54 Bakhshal Khan Baloch Rarrasham Village Landowner 100 23.00 1.16 11634.97 840 7.22
55 Deen Mohammad Baloch Rarrasham Village Landowner 100 44.00 2.23 22258.20 1,920 8.63
56 Fazal ur Rehman Baloch Gidar Daag Village Landowner 100 60.00 3.04 30352.08 2,460 8.10
57 Mujtaba Khan Baloch Gidar Daag Village Landowner 100 50.00 2.53 25293.40 2,160 8.54
58 Murtaza Khan Baloch Gidar Daag Village Landowner 100 64.00 3.24 32375.56 2,640 8.15
59 Bukhsh Ali Baloch Gidar Daag Village Landowner 100 56.00 2.83 28328.61 2,010 7.10
60 Hameed Khan Baloch Gidar Daag Village Landowner 100 30.00 1.52 15176.04 1,140 7.51 Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 118
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Share Total Farmland Holding Affected Farmland of AH Name of Affected Farmer Name of Tenurial Crop No. (Head of Household) Hamlet/Village Status (%) Kanals Hectares Sq. Meters Area (m2) Percentage
Sub-total (b.2): Musa Khel (Balûchistân): - - 327.00 16.54 165419 13,170 7.96 Sub-section B.3: Loralai District (Baluchistan):
61 Sardar Abdul Mannan Nasir Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 24.00 1.21 12140.83 1,050 8.65
62 Mekhtar Village Landowner Majak Haji 100 32.00 1.62 16187.78 1,410 8.71
63 Dinnak Jallozai Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 34.50 1.75 17452.45 1,620 9.28
64 Abdul Malik Adezai Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 30.00 1.52 15176.04 1,440 9.49
65 Palay Haji Adezai Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 30.00 1.52 15176.04 1,260 8.30
66 Khula Khan Adezai Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 20.00 1.01 10117.36 810 8.01
67 Aurak Haji Jallozai Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 20.00 1.01 10117.36 960 9.49
68 Gul Mohammad Khan Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 12.50 0.63 6323.35 540 8.54
69 Sherak Talakzai Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 27.50 1.39 13911.37 1,110 7.98
70 Tore Khan Palezai Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 16.00 0.81 8093.89 690 8.52
71 Haji Bazik Palezai Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 28.00 1.42 14164.31 1,320 9.32
72 Mallay Khan Palezai Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 34.50 1.75 17452.45 1,530 8.77
73 Shaebo Khan Palezai Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 14.50 0.73 7335.09 720 9.82
74 Haji Rehmat Khan Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 15.00 0.76 7588.02 630 8.30
75 Mira Khan Palezai Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 42.50 2.15 21499.39 2,010 9.35
76 Fida ur Rehman Nasir Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 56.00 2.83 28328.61 2,580 9.11
77 Mohammad Umar Nasir Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 20.00 1.01 10117.36 930 9.19 Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 119
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Share Total Farmland Holding Affected Farmland of AH Name of Affected Farmer Name of Tenurial Crop No. (Head of Household) Hamlet/Village Status (%) Kanals Hectares Sq. Meters Area (m2) Percentage
78 Abdul Malik Nasir Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 48.00 2.43 24281.67 1,860 7.66
79 Mohammad Zaman Nasir Mekhtar Village Landowner 100 78.00 3.95 39457.71 2,520 6.39
80 Jamal Khan Ashberg Village Landowner 100 17.50 0.89 8852.69 690 7.79
81 Hidayatullah Khan Ashberg Village Landowner 100 17.50 0.89 8852.69 660 7.46
82 Mohammad Saleem Khan Ashberg Village Landowner 100 18.00 0.91 9105.63 810 8.90
83 Mohammad Aslam Kakar Indah Village Landowner 100 18.00 0.91 9105.63 690 7.58
84 Mohammad Hayat Kakar Indah Village Landowner 100 15.00 0.76 7588.02 540 7.12
85 Fazal ur Rehman Kakar Indah Village Landowner 100 15.00 0.76 7588.02 480 6.33
86 Atta Mohammad Kakar Indah Village Landowner 100 60.00 3.04 30352.08 2,250 7.41
87 Raz Mohammad Kakar Indah Village Landowner 100 43.00 2.18 21752.33 1,620 7.45
88 Dost Mohammad Kakar Indah Village Landowner 100 60.00 3.04 30352.08 2,160 7.12
89 Malak Gul Mohammad Indah Village Landowner 100 58.00 2.93 29340.35 2,520 8.59
90 Jamon Khan Hamzazai Sehan Gharra Landowner 100 12.00 0.61 6070.42 510 8.40
91 Mir Khan Hamzazai Sehan Gharra Landowner 100 18.00 0.91 9105.63 900 9.88
92 Baath Khan Hamzazai Sehan Gharra Landowner 100 37.50 1.90 18970.05 1,140 6.01
93 Sehan Gharra Landowner Balos Khan Hamzazai 100 37.00 1.87 18717.12 1,590 8.49
94 Sehan Gharra Landowner Khair Mohamad Hamzazai 100 37.50 1.90 18970.05 1,860 9.80
95 Sehan Gharra Landowner Khan Mohamad Hamzazai 100 18.00 0.91 9105.63 900 9.88 96 Haji Mirajan Sehan Gharra Landowner 100 14.50 0.73 7335.09 8.59 Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 120
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Share Total Farmland Holding Affected Farmland of AH Name of Affected Farmer Name of Tenurial Crop No. (Head of Household) Hamlet/Village Status (%) Kanals Hectares Sq. Meters Area (m2) Percentage 630
97 Sehan Gharra Landowner Mullah Jamal 100 10.00 0.51 5058.68 420 8.30
98 Sehan Gharra Landowner Shadi Khan 100 28.00 1.42 14164.31 1,050 7.41
99 Sehan Gharra Landowner Baijak Khan 100 21.00 1.06 10623.23 810 7.62
100 Sehan Gharra Landowner Dostak Khan 100 16.00 0.81 8093.89 630 7.78
101 Sehan Gharra Landowner Malak Ghulam 100 27.50 1.39 13911.37 1,140 8.19
102 Sehan Gharra Landowner Zantoo Khan 100 32.50 1.64 16440.71 1,380 8.39
103 Landowner Mohamad Yaqoob Kudozai Shabozai Village 100 87.50 4.43 44263.46 3,300 7.46
104 Landowner Mohamad Salman Kudozai Shabozai Village 100 112.00 5.67 56657.22 4,935 8.71
105 Landowner Mohammad Sultan Kudozai Shabozai Village 100 80.00 4.05 40469.45 3,660 9.04
106 Landowner Hayat Khan Kudozai Shabozai Village 100 97.50 4.93 49322.14 4,020 8.15
107 Landowner Afta Khan Kudozai Shabozai Village 100 118.00 5.97 59692.43 5,055 8.47
108 Landowner Laal Mohammad Kudozai Shabozai Village 100 44.00 2.23 22258.20 1,890 8.49
109 Landowner Alauddin Khan Masood Killi 100 75.00 3.79 37940.11 3,240 8.54
110 Landowner Ajamir Temarkhel Masood Killi 100 64.00 3.24 32375.56 2,280 7.04
111 Landowner Bakhtiar Temarkhel Masood Killi 100 72.50 3.67 36675.44 3,510 9.57
112 Landowner Mukhtiar Temarkhel Masood Killi 100 45.00 2.28 22764.06 1,980 8.70
113 Landowner Mumtaz Khan Temarkhel Masood Killi 100 36.00 1.82 18211.25 1,560 8.57
114 Landowner Haji Feroz Khan Masood Killi 100 40.00 2.02 20234.72 1,890 9.34 Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 121
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Share Total Farmland Holding Affected Farmland of AH Name of Affected Farmer Name of Tenurial Crop No. (Head of Household) Hamlet/Village Status (%) Kanals Hectares Sq. Meters Area (m2) Percentage
115 Mohammad Arshad Khan Sagor Village Landowner 100 127.00 6.42 64245.24 5,280 8.22
116 Banaras Khan Sagor Village Landowner 100 82.50 4.17 41734.12 3,120 7.48
117 Bawar Khan Sagor Village Landowner 100 60.00 3.04 30352.08 2,610 8.60
118 Haji Khan Mohammad Sagor Village Landowner 100 60.00 3.04 30352.08 2,760 9.09
119 Haji Saleem Utamkhel Bala Killi Tattai Landowner 100 30.00 1.52 15176.04 1,290 8.50
120 Haji Kareem Utamkhel Bala Killi Tattai Landowner 100 124.00 6.27 62727.64 4,800 7.65
121 Barat Khan Bala Killi Tattai Landowner 100 103.00 5.21 52104.41 3,720 7.14
122 Abdul Hakeem Bala Killi Tattai Landowner 100 125.00 6.32 63233.51 5,460 8.63
123 Mohammad Zakariya Bala Killi Tattai Landowner 100 47.50 2.40 24028.73 1,710 7.12
124 Abdul Rafique Naway Bawar Killi Landowner 100 128.00 6.48 64751.11 5,460 8.43
125 Master Amanullah Naway Bawar Killi Landowner 100 142.00 7.18 71833.27 6,060 8.44
126 Haji Faiz Mohamad Nasir Naway Bawar Killi Landowner 100 132.00 6.68 66774.59 5,820 8.72
Sub-total (b.3): Loralai (Balûchistân): - - 3,247 164.26 1,642,554 135,780 8.27
Sub-total (b): Baluchistan: - - 7,046 356 3,564,346 300,690 8.44
Total (Subproject): - - 7,311 370 3,698,401 312,840 8.46
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 122
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table A-6: Socioeconomic Indicators of Affected Households of Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Subproject Affected Household Size Literacy Rate (No. of AH Affected Farming Household Caste/Tribe Language (No) Persons) No. (Name of Head of Name of Affected Household) Hamlet / Village Men Women Total Men Women Total Section - A: Punjab Province - Sub-section A.1: Dera Ghazi Khan District (DGK):
1 Shikar Khan Khosa Basti Shikar Khan Baloch Siraiki 4 3 7 1 - 1
2 Khuda Bukhsh Khosa Basti Shikar Khan Baloch Siraiki 3 4 7 2 - 1
3 Musallim Master Rajhani Village Baloch Siraiki 4 4 8 2 1 3
4 Razi Khan Rajhani Village Baloch Siraiki 4 6 10 2 1 4
5 Nabli Ramba Mujawir Gamuli (Choti Bala) Baloch Siraiki 5 3 8 2 - 2
6 Chimru Khan Mujawir Gamuli (Choti Bala) Baloch Siraiki 6 8 14 3 2 5
7 Fazlur Rahman Mujawir Gamuli (Choti Bala) Baloch Siraiki 7 4 11 4 1 3
8 Bhagoo Khan Mujawir Gamuli (Choti Bala) Baloch Siraiki 6 3 9 2 - 4
9 Kaurra Mekrri Gamuli (Choti Bala) Baloch Siraiki 5 8 13 2 1 4
10 Afzal Alyani Gamuli (Choti Bala) Baloch Siraiki 8 6 14 4 2 7 Sub-total (a): Punjab - DGK: 52 49 101 24 8 32
Percentage (a): Punjab - DGK: 51.5 48.5 100.0 46.2 16.3 31.7 Section - B: Baluchistan Province: Sub-section - B.1: Bar Khan District (Baluchistan):
11 Spar Khan Leghari Pailia Thal (Bawata) Baloch Siraiki 6 5 11 2 1 3
12 Jan Mohammad Leghari Pailia Thal (Bawata) Baloch Siraiki 3 7 10 1 2 3 13 Shahab Din Khetran Pailia Thal (Bawata) Baloch Siraiki 2 6 8 - - -
14 Haji Sain Dad Leghari Pailia Thal (Bawata) Baloch Siraiki 5 5 10 1 1 2
15 Pahada Khan Khetran Sarpa Village Khetran Siraiki 7 8 15 4 3 7
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 123
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Affected Household Size Literacy Rate (No. of AH Affected Farming Household Caste/Tribe Language (No) Persons) No. (Name of Head of Name of Affected Household) Hamlet / Village Men Women Total Men Women Total
16 Kalu Khan Khetran Sarpa Village Khetran Siraiki 4 5 9 2 1 3
17 Mir Hamadani Mir Hamadani Kili Khetran Siraiki 6 7 13 2 2 4
18 Badha Khetran Mir Hamadani Kili Khetran Siraiki 3 5 8 1 - 1 19 Balakh Khetran Mir Hamadani Kili Khetran Siraiki 6 3 9 - - -
20 Haibat Saryam Mir Hamadani Kili Khetran Siraiki 3 4 7 1 - 1
21 Haji Gul Moahmmad Basti Khaprani Khetran Siraiki 9 7 16 3 2 5
22 Binda Khan Khetran Basti Khaprani Khetran Siraiki 5 4 9 1 - 1
23 Ahmad Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 3 7 10 - 2 2
24 Kamal Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 7 4 11 2 1 3
25 Lal Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 4 5 9 - 2 2
26 Sahib Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 6 5 11 3 - 3
27 Allah Dad Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 8 4 12 - 1 1
28 Khamees Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 5 8 13 2 2 4
29 Gul Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 5 6 11 2 1 3
30 Sadaram Khan Khetran Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 7 5 12 4 2 6
31 Wadera Mohammad Jan Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 4 6 10 1 - 1
32 Ismail Shah Sheikh Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Syed Siraiki 5 4 9 3 - 3
33 Khan Mohamad Khamees Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 2 3 5 1 1 2
34 Abdul Karim (Son of #33) Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 5 3 8 2 - 2 35 Abdul Rahim (Son of #33) Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 4 4 8 - - - Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 124
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Affected Household Size Literacy Rate (No. of AH Affected Farming Household Caste/Tribe Language (No) Persons) No. (Name of Head of Name of Affected Household) Hamlet / Village Men Women Total Men Women Total
36 Mehmood Khan Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 5 4 9 3 1 4
37 Sher Jan Fatyani Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 6 6 12 3 2 5 38 Haji Rahmatan Basti Kaurri (Rakni) Khetran Siraiki 4 2 6 - - -
39 Sher Khan Deh Bhebani Khetran Siraiki 3 4 7 1 2 3
40 Gamman Khan Deh Bhebani Khetran Siraiki 4 5 9 2 1 3
41 Rahim Khan Deh Bhebani Khetran Siraiki 4 4 8 3 1 4
42 Khuda Bukhsh Deh Bhebani Khetran Siraiki 3 4 7 - 1 1
43 Khairullah Hasni Rarkan Village Hasni Siraiki 5 6 11 2 1 3 44 Rahimullah Hasni Rarkan Village Hasni Siraiki 6 4 10 - - - 45 Gul Beg Hasni Rarkan Village Hasni Siraiki 3 3 6 - - -
46 Nabi Jan Hasni Rarkan Village Hasni Siraiki 7 4 11 2 - 2 47 Sohrab Khan Hasni Rarkan Village Hasni Siraiki 2 4 6 - - -
48 Nabi Bukhsh Hasni Rarkan Village Hasni Siraiki 5 3 8 2 - 2
49 Habeeb ur Rehman Hasni Rarkan Village Hasni Siraiki 3 6 9 1 2 3
50 Ubaidullah Hasni Rarkan Village Hasni Siraiki 5 6 11 3 1 4
51 Gul Jan Hasni Rarkan Village Hasni Siraiki 7 5 12 4 1 5
52 Ahmad Deen Hasni Rarkan Village Hasni Siraiki 10 6 16 5 2 7
53 Mohammad Deen Hasni Rarkan Village Hasni Siraiki 4 7 11 1 1 2 Sub-Total (b.1): Bar Khan (Baluchistan): 210 213 423 70 40 110
Percentage (b.1): Bar Khan (Baluchistan): 49.6 50.4 100.0 33.3 18.8 26.0 Sub-section - B.2: Musa Khel District (Baluchistan): 54 Bakhshal Khan Baloch Rarrasham Village Baloch Siraiki 8 5 13 -
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 125
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Affected Household Size Literacy Rate (No. of AH Affected Farming Household Caste/Tribe Language (No) Persons) No. (Name of Head of Name of Affected Household) Hamlet / Village Men Women Total Men Women Total 2 2
55 Deen Mohammad Baloch Rarrasham Village Baloch Siraiki 6 4 10 1 - 1 56 Fazal ur Rehman Baloch Gidar Daag Village Baloch Siraiki 4 5 9 - - -
57 Mujtaba Khan Baloch Gidar Daag Village Baloch Siraiki 6 4 10 1 1 2 58 Murtaza Khan Baloch Gidar Daag Village Baloch Siraiki 3 5 8 - - -
59 Bukhsh Ali Baloch Gidar Daag Village Baloch Siraiki 5 4 9 1 - 1
60 Hameed Khan Baloch Gidar Daag Village Baloch Siraiki 6 5 11 2 1 3
Sub-total (b.2): Musa Khel (Balûchistân): 38 32 70 7 2 9
Percentage (b.2): Musa Khel (Balûchistân): 54.3 45.7 100.0 18.4 6.3 12.9 Sub-section B.3: Loralai District (Baluchistan):
61 Sardar Abdul Mannan Nasir Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 4 6 10 2 2 4
62 Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto Majak Haji 6 3 9 2 - 2 63 Dinnak Jallozai Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 2 5 7 - - - 64 Abdul Malik Adezai Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 3 6 9 - - -
65 Palay Haji Adezai Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 4 5 9 1 - 1
66 Khula Khan Adezai Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 5 3 8 1 - 1
67 Aurak Haji Jallozai Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 8 6 14 3 1 4 68 Gul Mohammad Khan Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 5 6 11 - - -
69 Sherak Talakzai Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 6 4 10 2 - 2
70 Tore Khan Palezai Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 6 6 12 3 2 5 71 Haji Bazik Palezai Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 2 3 5 - - - 72 Mallay Khan Palezai Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 3 4 7 - - -
73 Shaebo Khan Palezai Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 6 5 11 1 - 1 Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 126
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Affected Household Size Literacy Rate (No. of AH Affected Farming Household Caste/Tribe Language (No) Persons) No. (Name of Head of Name of Affected Household) Hamlet / Village Men Women Total Men Women Total 74 Haji Rehmat Khan Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 6 4 10 - - -
75 Mira Khan Palezai Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 4 8 12 2 3 5 76 Fida ur Rehman Nasir Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 3 4 7 - - - 77 Mohammad Umar Nasir Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 2 6 8 - - -
78 Abdul Malik Nasir Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 6 7 13 2 1 3 79 Mohammad Zaman Nasir Mekhtar Village Nasir Pushto 6 3 9 - - -
80 Jamal Khan Ashberg Village Kakar Pushto 5 5 10 2 - 2
81 Hidayatullah Khan Ashberg Village Kakar Pushto 4 3 7 1 - 1
82 Mohammad Saleem Khan Ashberg Village Kakar Pushto 7 3 10 4 1 5 83 Mohammad Aslam Kakar Indah Village Kakar Pushto 5 4 9 - - - 84 Mohammad Hayat Kakar Indah Village Kakar Pushto 4 4 8 - - - 85 Fazal ur Rehman Kakar Indah Village Kakar Pushto 6 5 11 - - - 86 Atta Mohammad Kakar Indah Village Kakar Pushto 5 2 7 - - -
87 Raz Mohammad Kakar Indah Village Kakar Pushto 4 6 10 2 2 4 88 Dost Mohammad Kakar Indah Village Kakar Pushto 8 5 13 - - - 89 Malak Gul Mohammad Indah Village Kakar Pushto 4 7 11 - - -
90 Jamon Khan Hamzazai Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto 6 8 14 3 2 5
91 Mir Khan Hamzazai Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto 9 7 16 2 - 2
92 Baath Khan Hamzazai Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto 8 5 13 1 - 1
93 Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto Balos Khan Hamzazai 6 4 10 2 - 2
94 Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto Khair Mohamad Hamzazai 3 5 8 1 1 2 95 Khan Mohamad Hamzazai Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto 2 5 7 - - - 96 Haji Mirajan Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto 2 3 5 - - - 97 Mullah Jamal Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto 3 3 6 - - - 98 Shadi Khan Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto 2 6 8 - - -
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 127
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Affected Household Size Literacy Rate (No. of AH Affected Farming Household Caste/Tribe Language (No) Persons) No. (Name of Head of Name of Affected Household) Hamlet / Village Men Women Total Men Women Total
99 Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto Baijak Khan 5 4 9 1 - 1 100 Dostak Khan Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto 2 4 6 - - - 101 Malak Ghulam Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto 3 2 5 - - -
102 Sehan Gharra Kakar Pushto Zantoo Khan 3 6 9 2 3 5
103 Kakar Pushto Mohamad Yaqoob Kudozai Shabozai Village 5 6 11 1 1 2
104 Kakar Pushto Mohamad Salman Kudozai Shabozai Village 6 3 9 4 2 6 105 Mohammad Sultan Kudozai Shabozai Village Kakar Pushto 2 5 7 - - - 106 Hayat Khan Kudozai Shabozai Village Kakar Pushto 3 4 7 - - -
107 Kakar Pushto Afta Khan Kudozai Shabozai Village 5 1 6 2 - 2 108 Laal Mohammad Kudozai Shabozai Village Kakar Pushto 4 3 7 - - -
109 Kakar Pushto Alauddin Khan Masood Killi 5 4 9 3 - 3
110 Kakar Pushto Ajamir Temarkhel Masood Killi 4 6 10 2 2 4 111 Bakhtiar Temarkhel Masood Killi Kakar Pushto 2 8 10 - - -
112 Kakar Pushto Mukhtiar Temarkhel Masood Killi 4 4 8 2 - 2
113 Kakar Pushto Mumtaz Khan Temarkhel Masood Killi 4 5 9 1 - 1
114 Kakar Pushto Haji Feroz Khan Masood Killi 5 3 8 2 1 3 115 Mohammad Arshad Khan Sagor Village Kakar Pushto 2 4 6 - - - 116 Banaras Khan Sagor Village Kakar Pushto 3 4 7 - - -
117 Kakar Pushto Bawar Khan Sagor Village 5 4 9 2 1 3
118 Kakar Pushto Haji Khan Mohammad Sagor Village 8 7 15 5 3 8
119 Kakar Pushto Haji Saleem Utamkhel Bala Killi Tattai 10 6 16 6 1 7
120 Kakar Pushto Haji Kareem Utamkhel Bala Killi Tattai 12 9 21 5 2 7 121 Barat Khan Bala Killi Tattai Kakar Pushto 9 5 14 1 Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 128
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Affected Household Size Literacy Rate (No. of AH Affected Farming Household Caste/Tribe Language (No) Persons) No. (Name of Head of Name of Affected Household) Hamlet / Village Men Women Total Men Women Total 4 5
122 Kakar Pushto Abdul Hakeem Bala Killi Tattai 6 5 11 3 - 3
123 Kakar Pushto Mohammad Zakariya Bala Killi Tattai 8 4 12 5 2 7
124 Kakar Pushto Abdul Rafique Naway Bawar Killi 4 5 9 1 - 1
125 Kakar Pushto Master Amanullah Naway Bawar Killi 3 6 9 1 1 2
126 Pushto Haji Faiz Mohamad Nasir Naway Bawar Killi Nasir 8 7 15 6 3 9
Sub-total (b.3): Loralai (Balûchistân): 320 318 638 95 38 133
Percentage (b.3): Loralai (Baluchistan): 50.2 49.8 100.0 29.7 11.9 20.8
Sub-total (b): Baluchistan: 568 563 1,131 172 80 252
Percentage (b): Baluchistan: 50.2 49.8 100.0 30.3 14.2 22.3
Total Number (Subproject): 620 612 1,232 196 88 284
Overall Percentage (Subproject): 50.3 49.7 100.0 31.6 14.4 23.1
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 129
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Appendix 2: List of Participants of Community Consultation Sessions (Loralai TL)
Men's Groups Women's Groups No. Name Status AHNo. Name Status AH Punjab Province - D. G. Khan District Village 1: Basti Shikar Khan (Tower Nos. 28-30) 1 Shikar Khan Khosa Landowner AH 1 Salima Mai House-Wife AH 2 Khuda Bukhsh Khosa Landowner AH 2 Shabnam Bibi House Girl AH 3 Sabzal Khan Khosa Landowner - 3 Norina Kulsoom House Girl AH 4 Mehr Bakhsh Khosa Shepherd - 4 Maryam Bibi House-Wife AH Village 2: Rajhani Village (Tower Nos. 54-56) 5 Musallim Master Landowner AH 5 Shamman Mai House-Wife AH 6 Razi Khan Landowner AH 6 Bakhtawar Mai House-Wife AH 7 Mithu Khan Mujawar Sharecropper - 7 Haleema Mai House-Wife - 8 Wahid Bakhsh Mujawir Landowner - 8 Lali Mai House-Wife AH 9 Ghulam Sarwar Teacher - Village 3: Village Gamuli, Choti Bala Road (Tower Nos. 62-65) 10 Nabli Ramba Mujawir Landowner AH 9 Nasima Mai House-Wife - 11 Fazlur Rahman Mujawir Landowner AH 10 Madho Mai House-Wife AH 12 Bhagoo Khan Mujawir Landowner AH 11 Amir Bibi House Girl - 13 Chimru Khan Mujawir Landowner AH 12 Shamim House-Wife AH 14 Mohammad Rasheed Sharecropper - 13 Hayati Mai House-Wife - 15 Afzal Alyani Landowner AH 16 Kaurra Mekrri Landowner AH Baluchistan Province - Bar Khan District Village 4: Pailia Thal, Bawata (Tower Nos. 197-201) 17 Jan Mohammad Leghari Landowner AH 14 Rehmat Mai House-Wife AH 18 Haji Sain Dad Leghari Landowner AH 15 Mira Mai House Girl AH 19 Spar Khan Leghari Landowner AH 16 Lali Mai House-Wife - 20 Shahab Din Khetran Landowner AH 17 Gulshan House Girl AH 21 Manzoor Hussain Khetran Landowner - 18 Mukhtar Mai House-Wife - Village 5: Sarpa Village, Bawata (Tower Nos. 201-203) 22 Pahada Khan Khetran Landowner AH 19 Bakhi Mai House-Wife AH 23 Kalu Khan Khetran Landowner AH 20 Humaira Mai House-Wife - 24 Karim Khan Khetran Sharecropper - 21 Saira Bibi House Girl AH 25 Mohammad Afzal Khetran Labour - 22 Munira Mai House-Wife AH 23 Hijran Mai House Girl - Village 6: Mir Hamadani Killi (Tower Nos. 203-206) 26 Mir Hamadani Landowner AH 24 Sanab Mai House-Wife AH 27 Balakh Khetran Landowner AH 25 Shamim House Girl AH 28 Haibat Saryam Landowner AH 26 Hava Mai Mid Wife - 29 Badha Khetran Landowner AH 27 Kanara Bibi House-Wife AH Village 7: Basti Khaprani (Tower Nos. 206-207) 30 Haji Gul Moahmmad Landowner AH 28 Wazifa Mai House Girl AH 31 Binda Khan Khetran Landowner AH 29 Wazira Bibi House-Wife -
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 130
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Men's Groups Women's Groups No. Name Status AHNo. Name Status AH 32 Khan Mohammad Teacher - 30 Tajan Mai House-Wife AH 33 Mohammad Aslam Khetran Shopkeeper - Village 8: Basti Kaurri, Rakni (Tower Nos. 207-219) 34 Ahmad Khan Khetran Landowner AH 31 Gul Bibi House Girl AH 35 Kamal Khan Khetran Landowner AH 32 Amna Mai House-Wife AH 36 Lal Khan Khetran Landowner AH 33 Asmat Mai House-Wife AH 37 Sahib Khan Khetran Landowner AH 34 Murada Mai House Girl AH 38 Wadera Mohammad Jan Landowner AH 35 Maryam Bibi House-Wife - 39 Gul Khan Khetran Landowner AH 36 Halima Mai House-Wife - 40 Bilal Khan Khetran Transporter - 37 Shehla Bibi House-Wife AH 41 Sadaram Khan Khetran Landowner AH 38 Ahmad Mai House-Wife AH 42 Allah Dad Khetran Landowner AH 39 Chand Bibi House Girl AH 43 Khamees Khan Khetran Landowner AH 40 Saleema Mai House-Wife - 44 Ismail Shah Sheikh Landowner AH 41 Sitara Mai House-Wife - 45 Khadim Husain Shekh Teacher - Village 9: Deh Bhebani, Rakni (Tower Nos. 238-240) 46 Khuda Bukhsh Landowner AH 42 Batool Mai House-Wife AH 47 Gamman Khan Landowner AH 43 Amina Mai House-Wife - 48 Sher Khan Landowner AH 44 Irsa Bibi House-Wife AH 49 Amin Khan Landowner - Village 10: Rarkan Village (Tower Nos. 286-302) 50 Khairullah Hasni Landowner AH 45 Phool Bibi House-Wife AH 51 Rahimullah Hasni Landowner AH 46 Tasleem Bibi House-Wife AH 52 Sohrab Khan Hasni Landowner AH 47 Karima Mai House-Wife - 53 Nabi Bukhsh Hasni Landowner AH 48 Meena Mai House-Wife AH 54 Mohammad Deen Hasni Landowner AH 49 Ameer Begum House-Wife - 55 Ahmad Deen Hasni Landowner AH 50 Shakira Bibi House Girl AH 56 Habeeb ur Rehman Hasni Landowner AH 51 Shakila Bibi House Girl AH 57 Ubaidullah Hasni Landowner AH 52 Nahida Mai House-Wife - 58 Amanullah Hasni Landowner - Balûchistân Province - Musa Khel District Village 11: Village Rarrasham (Tower Nos. 323-325) 59 Amir Khan Baloch Landowner - 53 Zinat Mai House-Wife AH 60 Bakhshal Khan Baloch Landowner AH 54 Ashra Mai House-Wife AH 61 Deen Mohammad Baloch Landowner AH 55 Puran Mai House Girl - 62 Ayaz Khan Baloch Shopkeeper - 56 Jannat Bibi House Girl AH 57 Miran Mai House-Wife - Village 12: Gidar Daag (Tower Nos. 346-349) 63 Fazal Karim Khan Landowner - 58 Nasiba Mai House Girl - 64 Fazal ur Rehman Baloch Landowner AH 59 Hasina Bibi House-Wife AH 65 Bukhsh Ali Baloch Landowner AH 60 Bilqees Akhtar House-Wife AH 66 Hameed Khan Baloch Landowner AH 61 Farzana Jamal House-Wife -
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 131
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Men's Groups Women's Groups No. Name Status AHNo. Name Status AH 67 Mujtaba Khan Baloch Landowner AH 62 Bina Mai House Girl AH 68 Murtaza Khan Baloch Landowner AH Baluchistan Province - Loralai District Village 13: Mekhtar Village (Tower Nos. 486-491) 69 Gul Mohammad Khan Landowner AH 63 Zarina Bibi House-Wife AH 70 Sherak Talakzai Landowner AH 64 Mehnaz Bibi House-Wife AH 71 Majak Haji Landowner AH 65 Hameedah House-Wife AH 72 Mohammad Zaman Nasir Landowner AH 66 Haleema Bibi House-Wife AH 73 Tore Khan Palezai Landowner AH 67 Zalacha Old Women AH 74 Sardar Abdul Mannan Nasir Landowner AH 68 Zartaja House-Wife - 75 Dinnak Jallozai Landowner AH 69 Malika Gul House Girl AH 76 Khula Khan Adezai Landowner AH 70 Mahnaz Gul House Girl AH 77 Aurak Haji Jallozai Landowner AH 71 Malaika House-Wife AH 78 Haji Rehmat Khan Landowner AH 72 Farsheen House Girl - 79 Abdul Malik Nasir Landowner AH 80 Haji Bazik Palezai Landowner AH Village 14: Ashberg Village (Tower Nos. 501-503) 81 Hidayatullah Khan Landowner AH 73 Noor Nisa House-Wife AH 82 Mohammad Saleem Khan Landowner AH 74 Najiba Bibi House-Wife - 83 Jamal Khan Landowner AH 75 Arsha Khatoon House Girl AH 84 Faiz ur Rehman Landowner - 76 Zarsanga House-Wife AH Village 15: Indah Village (Tower Nos. 503-511) 85 Abdul Hameed Kakar Landowner - 77 Aasia Bibi House-Wife AH 86 Raz Mohammad Kakar Landowner AH 78 Akalmanda House-Wife AH 87 Dost Mohammad Kakar Landowner AH 79 Gull Bibi House-Wife - 88 Fazal ur Rehman Kakar Landowner AH 80 Gulnaz House Girl AH 89 Atta Mohammad Kakar Landowner AH 81 Rehana House Girl AH 90 Mohammad Aslam Kakar Landowner AH 82 Zarfaka House Girl AH 91 Mohammad Hayat Kakar Landowner AH 83 Samina House Girl - 92 Mohammad Iqbal Kakar Teacher - 84 Qayamat Bibi House-Wife AH 93 Jumma Khan Kakar Shopkeeper - Village 16: Sehan Gharra Village (Tower Nos. 543-546) 94 Haji Mirajan Landowner AH 85 Gul Pari House-Wife AH 95 Mullah Jamal Landowner AH 86 Bakhtiara House-Wife - 96 Shadi Khan Landowner AH 87 Shekhato Bibi House Girl AH 97 Malak Ghulam Landowner AH 88 Sanam Khatoon Student AH 98 Zantoo Khan Landowner AH 89 Afzal Nisa House-Wife - 99 Mir Khan Hamzazai Landowner AH 90 Naimat Jan House Girl - 100 Baath Khan Hamzazai Landowner AH 101 Khan Mohamad Hamzazai Landowner AH 102 Khair Mohamad Hamzazai Landowner AH Village 17: Shabozai Village (Tower Nos. 694-698)
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 132
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Men's Groups Women's Groups No. Name Status AHNo. Name Status AH 103 Mohamad Salman Kudozai Landowner AH 91 Aslama Student AH 104 Mohammad Sultan Kudozai Landowner AH 92 Akhtar Jana House-Wife AH 105 Hayat Khan Kudozai Landowner AH 93 Hajira House Girl AH 106 Afta Khan Kudozai Landowner AH 94 Saira House-Wife - 107 Laal Mohammad Kudozai Landowner AH 95 Mirana House-Wife AH 108 Arsalan Khan Student - Village 18: Masood Killi (Tower Nos. 708-714) 109 Alauddin Khan Landowner AH 96 Khairat Bibi House-Wife AH 110 Haji Feroz Khan Landowner AH 97 Amir-us-Nisa House-Wife AH 111 Bakhtiar Temarkhel Landowner AH 98 Mehnaz House Girl AH 112 Ajamir Temarkhel Landowner AH 113 Sultan Khan Temarkhel Landowner - 114 Ajamir Khan Temarkhel Landowner - Village 19: Sagor Village (Tower Nos. 721-726) 115 Banaras Khan Landowner AH 99 Rafiqah Khanam Teacher - 116 Bawar Khan Landowner AH 100 Ameena Gul House-Wife AH 117 Arshad Khan Landowner AH 101 Hanifa House-Wife AH 118 Amir Sultan Govt. Service - 102 Mirana House-Wife AH 119 Huzoor Bakhsh Policeman - Village 20: Bala Killi Tattai (Tower Nos. 740-743) 120 Haji Kareem Utamkhel Landowner AH 103 Sehrish Student AH 121 Haji Khan Mohammad Landowner AH 104 Ajeeba Khatoon House-Wife AH 122 Barat Khan Landowner AH 105 Murada Bibi House-Wife - 123 Haji Saleem Utamkhel Landowner AH 106 Marina Gul House-Wife AH 124 Hasan Nawaz Transporter - 107 Hasina Gul House Girl AH 125 Israr Khan Utmankhel Landowner - Village 21: Naway Bawar Killi (Tower Nos. 743/LP-GS) 126 Haji Faiz Mohamad Nasir Landowner AH 108 Banafsha Gul House-Wife 127 Abdul Rafique Landowner AH 109 Hakima Khatoon House-Wife 128 Master Amanullah Landowner AH 110 Noor Nisa House-Wife 111 Gulshana House Girl 112 Arbaza House-Wife
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 133
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Appendix 3 – Draft Public Information Brochure
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Program D. G. Khan – Loralai 220kV Transmission Line Subproject
National Transmission and Dispatch Company Government of Pakistan
December 2008
Land Acquisition and Resettlement Impacts Compensation/Rehabilitation: Information Booklet
A. GENERAL 1. The National Transmission and Dispatch Company (NTDC) is intending to take a loan from the Asian Development Bank (ADB) to implement the Power Transmission Enhancement Program (PTEP) aiming at upgrading and extending the transmission network to expanding the capacity and coverage of the network. The project will be implemented over five to six years, and will include a number of tranches or groups of subprojects. 2. D.G.Khan –Loralai Transmission line is one of the subprojects in tranche three. This is one of the tranche three subprojects which have some type of affect on the local community. This subproject requires temporary crop and tree losses during the construction (Foundation and erection of towers and stringing of power cables) of the associated transmission line. 3. The D.G.Khan - Loralai 220kV Transmission Lines Subproject (Subproject No. 2.1 in Tranche 3 of this MFF) involves the construction of a total length of 245 km of 220kV double circuit transmission line. The line connects the proposed D.G.Khan (Punjab) 500/220 kV grid station with proposed 220 kV Loralai (Baluchistan) grid station. 4. The subproject will be implemented in the area where you live starting later in 2009 and will affect crops and trees in your communities. To compensate and/or rehabilitate these losses the provisions of relevant Pakistan laws and of the ADB Policy on Involuntary Resettlement will be adopted. This has included the preparation of a Land Acquisition and Resettlement Framework (LARF) setting out the basic compensation/rehabilitation provisions for the PTEP and a Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan (LARP) providing data on impacts and affected families and indicating in detail how the impacts will be compensated or rehabilitated has been prepared for each subproject that requires temporary disturbance to land and subsequent compensation for crops and trees. 5. Both the LARF and the LARP in Urdu language will be available for perusal to anyone interested at the Project Implementation Unit in D.G Khan, Bar Khan, Musa Khel and Loralai districts. This booklet summarizing the provisions of the LARF and the LARP for
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 134
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
the D.G Khan –Loralai 220 kV Transmission Line Subproject is given to all the families whose land, trees and crops and incomes are affected by this subproject. The objective of this booklet is to inform them of the essential compensation and rehabilitation policy for the New D.G khan – Loralai 220 kV Transmission Line Subproject and of a number of basic issues relative to the implementation of the compensation and rehabilitation program.
B. PRINCIPLES FOR COMPENSATION AND/OR REHABILITATION OF AFFECTED FAMILIES Principles for the compensation/rehabilitation of affected people (AHs) by the New D.G.Khan – Loralai 220 kV Transmission Line Subproject are: 1. Land acquisition will be avoided and acquisition will only occur where access to, or use of, an AH’s land is affected; 2. Compensation will guarantee the maintenance of the AHs pre-project living standards; 3. AHs will be fully informed/consulted on compensation options; 4. AHs’ socio-cultural institutions will be supported and used; 5. Land acquisition provisions will equally apply to women and men; 6. Lack of formal title will not impede rehabilitation of families losing land; 7. Particular attention will be paid to women-headed households and vulnerable groups; 8. Land acquisition budgets will be included in project costs; and 9. Compensation will be fully provided prior to ground leveling and demolition.
C. COMPENSATION AND REHABILITATION ELIGIBILITY AND ENTITLEMENTS All families residing in affected areas and holding affected assets or incomes before the eligibility cut-off date for the subproject 22nd April 2008 (the date of the end of the impact survey) will be entitled to compensation and/or rehabilitation for their losses. Table 1 - Eligibility and Entitlements Matrix Affected Asset Specification Compensation Entitlements People Arable Land Access is not restricted and Farmer/Titleholder No land compensation provided that land is rehabilitated (Temporarily existing or current land use /restored to former quality following completion of works. Cash Affected) will remain unchanged compensation for affected crops and trees as per item below All relevant AHs, Cash compensation at replacement rate for affected Partial damage to privately Houses and incl. squatters structure/other fixed assets free of salvaged materials, built-up structures (houses, Structures depreciation or transaction costs. For partial impacts full cash boundary walls, etc.) assistance to restore remaining structure will be paid. All AHs, incl. Crop compensation in cash at full market rate for one harvest squatters by default for impacts caused by tower bases and perimeter, Crops Crops affected stringing and access. All other crop losses will be compensated at market rates based on actual losses. Trees Trees affected All Ahs Cash compensation shall reflect income replacement Rehabilitation/substitution of affected structures/utilities, i.e. All damaged Community bridges, roads/streets, watercourses, farmlands, etc. (will be Community Infrastructure community Assets part of Civil Works Contract, and accordingly carried out infrastructure satisfactorily by the Contractor out of the Subproject funds)
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 135
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
D. Compensation Assessment for Affected Crops and Trees The following four tables (Tables A-2 to A-5) provide the bases for assessment of compensations for the affected agricultural crops and fruit and wood trees.
Table A-2: Categorization and Income Replacement of Affected Fruit Trees Type of Categorization Loss of Income per Fruit Tree No. Affected Maturity Age of Tree Period Rate of Annual Compensation Fruit Tree Level (Years) (Years) Income (Rs) Assessed (Rs.) Immature up to 10 10 800 8,000 Almond Mature-1 11 - 40 10 2,100 21,000 Trees 1 Mature-2 Above 40 10 2,000 20,000 Immature up to 15 10 700 7,000 Berri Mature-1 16 - 30 10 1,200 12,000 (Zizyphus) 2 Mature-2 above 30 10 1,500 15,000
Table A-3: Number and Compensation of Affected Fruit Trees Type of Maturity Affected Fruit Trees (No.) Rate Compensation No. Affected Fruit Baluchn Level (Rs./Tree) Amount (Rs.) Tree Punjab . Total 1 Almond Trees Immature 0 28 28 8,000 224,000 Mature-1 0 57 57 21,000 1,197,000 Mature-2 0 12 12 20,000 240,000 Sub-total (a): Almond Trees 0 97 97 - 1,661,000 Berri 2 (Zizyphus) Immature 5 8 13 7,000 91,000 Mature-1 11 17 28 12,000 336,000 Mature-2 8 6 14 15,000 210,000 Sub-total (b):Berri (Zizyphus) 24 31 55 - 637,000
TOTAL: 24 128 152 - 2,298,000
Table A-4: Relative Sizes of Affected Wood Trees by Maximum Heights and Girths Name of Small Tree Medium Tree Large Tree No Height Height Height Wood Tree . (m) Girth (m) (m) Girth (m) (m) Girth (m) 6.1 & 1.0 & 1 Kikar (acasia) up to 3.0 up to 0.5 3.1 - 6.1 0.5 - 0.9 above above Shisham 7.7 & 1.0 & 2 (sisso) up to 3.8 up to 0.5 3.9 - 7.6 0.5 - 0.9 above above Poplar/Eucalyp 9.1 & 0.5 & 3 ts up to 4.6 up to 0.3 4.6 - 9.1 0.4 - 0.5 above above 4.1 & 0.9 & 4 Willow / Other up to 2.5 up to 0.4 2.6 - 4.1 0.5 - 0.8 above above
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 136
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Table A-5: Number and Compensation of Affected Wood Trees Affected Wood Trees (No.) Market Rate Compensation Type of Affected Relative No. Wood Tree Size (Rs.) Amount (Rs.) Punjab Baluchn Total 1 Kikar (Acasia) Small 3 21 24 3,500 84,000 Medium 6 22 28 5,500 154,000 Large 1 16 17 7,500 127,500 Sub-total (a): Kikar 10 59 69 - 365,500 2 Shisham (Sisso) Small 1 10 11 4,500 49,500 Medium 2 12 14 6,000 84,000 Large 0 9 9 9,000 81,000 Sub-total (b): Shisham 3 31 34 - 214,500 3 Poplar/Eucalypts Small 0 34 34 4,000 136,000 Medium 0 21 21 6,000 126,000 Large 0 10 10 8,000 80,000 Sub-total (c): Poplar/Eucalypts 0 65 65 - 342,000 4 Willow / Other Small 0 4 10 1,200 12,000 Medium 0 20 12 2,000 24,000 Large 0 12 14 4,000 56,000 Sub-total (d): Willow / Other 0 36 36 - 92,000 TOTAL: 13 191 204 - 1,014,000
E. SOME BASIC QUESTIONS RELATED TO THE IMPACTS COMPENSATION AND REHABILITATION PROGRAM FOR THE PROJECT
Question 1 - Do we need to have a land title in order to be compensated or rehabilitated? Answer: No. Lack of formal legal rights (title) to land does not prevent AHs from receiving at least rehabilitation assistance. All AHs who were occupying or using the affected land at the time of the cut-off date (see above) will be entitled to compensation or at least rehabilitation under the project. Users of land with title or traditional rights (or who can prove they are legally using the land) who are affected by restricted access to, or use if, the land will be entitled to compensation for land and any assets on the land affected. Users of land who do not have title or traditional rights to land will be provided full compensation for any structures, crops or trees on land affected by the project and if their access to, or use of, the land is affected, will receive rehabilitation for land losses either in form of replacement land (if available) or in form of a cash allowance for land-use loss.
Question 2 - Does compensation apply to my house or structures? Answer: Yes. Houses and any other structures (small shops, animal sheds, etc) that will be affected by the project shall be compensated at replacement cost so that owners can build another structure of the same size and standard.
Question 3 - What about my crops and trees? Answer: Your affected crops and trees will also be compensated at current market value. Compensation for crops will be based on the anticipated harvest at market value, while compensation for trees will be based on the type, age and productivity of each tree affected.
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 137
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program
Question 4 - Does the above mean that anybody in your community can claim compensation or rehabilitation? Answer: No. The entitled affected families are only those who where residing in project affected areas and had affected assets at the time the impacts assessment and the affected people census was carried out. The cut-off-date for eligibility for this subproject is 22nd April 2008 when the impact survey and the affected people census was completed. Anybody who encroaches into the area after the cut-off-date will not be entitled to compensation or any other form of resettlement assistance.
Question 5 - Do we need to vacate and clear the affected properties immediately after they have been identified as needed by the project? Answer: No. Clearing the affected areas will only take place AFTER the compensation or rehabilitation for affected land or other lost assets and the appropriate subsidies have been provided to you. After the day in which compensation and rehabilitation was delivered to you, you will then have 1 month to clear the land. If you have not done so after a month the project will be allowed to enter your ex-property and clear the land for you.
Question 6 - If there is any disagreement regarding the way the compensation policy set up in the LARP has been implemented or any other issues relative to the compensation and rehabilitation program for the project do we have the right to complain, and if so how and where? Answer: Yes. Any AH may file a complaint or grievance. AHs will first lodge a complaint with the land acquisition collector and the project implementation unit in Loralai district. If unanswered within 15 days, the complaint can then be lodged to NTDC’s project management unit in Lahore. Finally if the grievance is still not settled within 1 month, the AH can seek redress at the appropriate court. The village administrations and the Land Acquisition Coordination Committee (LACC) composed by senior members of the AH communities and by their elected representatives will assist the AH in these cases. The concerned land acquisition coordination committees will properly document all complaints and resolutions. AHs will be exempted from all taxes, administrative and legal fees associated with resolving the dispute.
Question 7 - Who can we contact for more information about the project? Answer: For further information about the project as a whole, and/or the LARP for D.G.Khan – Lotalai Transmission Line Subproject, or if you would like to receive a full copy of the Land Acquisition and Resettlement Framework (2006) for the project, please contact as the follows:
NATIONAL TRANSMISSION AND DISPATCH COMPANY Address: Room No. 140, WAPDA House, Lahore. Phone/Fax Number: +92-42-9202414 Contact person: Khalid Hasan (Manager PMU / PPTA)
Revised LARP Loralai 220kV TL Subproject_ May 2009 Page 138