Enhancing Local Level Emergency Management: the Influence of Disaster Experience and the Role of Households and Neighbourhoods

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Enhancing Local Level Emergency Management: the Influence of Disaster Experience and the Role of Households and Neighbourhoods Enhancing Local Level Emergency Management: The Influence of Disaster Experience and the Role of Households and Neighbourhoods Brenda Murphya (principal investigator), Leanna Falkinerb, Gordon McBeanc, Holly Doland and Paul Kovacse a. Wilfrid Laurier University, Brantford Campus, Brantford ON., N3H 4R7, [email protected] b. Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction, Toronto ON, [email protected] c. Departments of Geography and Political Science, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, N6A 5B9, [email protected] d. Department of Geography, University of Victoria, Victoria, BC V8W , [email protected] e. Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction, Toronto ON, [email protected] July 2005 ICLR Research Paper Series – No. 43 ISBN # 0-9733795-9-6 Abstract: This report summarizes the research findings of a two-year project funded by the Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction (ICLR). In July 2000 the Pine Lake, Alberta area was severely affected by an F3 tornado – 12 people were killed and over 140 seriously injured. Following an extensive review of the available literature, the study compares emergency preparedness levels and perceptions between two communities: Pine Lake and North Dumfries, Ontario, of which only the former has experienced a serious natural disaster. It also assesses the role that gender plays in risk perception and preparedness. Emergency preparedness and attitudes were measured using a variety of indicators including household safety activities, economic and insurance factors, views and knowledge of the tornado warning system, levels of community social capital, community knowledge of local vulnerability and perceptions of government emergency management activity. The study also summarizes information about tornadoes, forecasting and early warning systems and assesses the impact of the tornado on the residents of Pine Lake. Methodologically, the two communities were matched across several characteristics to isolate the effect of the disaster experience. Both qualitative interview and document information as well as quantitative survey data was collected and assessed. Devastation at Green Acres, Pine Lake, Alberta Source: http://www.redcross.ca/ TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................................1 1.1 Purpose and Objectives ...............................................................................................................1 2 EXTREME WEATHER AND TORNADOES ........................................................................................4 2.1 Natural Disasters .........................................................................................................................4 2.2 Warnings......................................................................................................................................5 2.3 Tornadoes ....................................................................................................................................7 2.4 Observing Systems for Detection of Tornadoes..........................................................................8 2.4.1 Warning Communication and the Media............................................................................9 2.5 Pine Lake Tornado ....................................................................................................................11 3 EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS.........................................................................................................13 3.1 Hazard Response Cycle.............................................................................................................13 3.2 Emergency Preparedness and Insurance....................................................................................15 3.3 Household-Level Preparedness .................................................................................................15 3.4 Neighbourhood-Level Preparedness..........................................................................................18 3.5 Municipal-Level Emergency Preparedness ...............................................................................19 4 RISK PERCEPTION ..............................................................................................................................21 4.1 Risk Perception and Economics ................................................................................................22 4.2 Risk Perception, Preparedness and Education...........................................................................22 5 VULNERABILITY AND CAPACITY..................................................................................................23 5.1 Vulnerability..............................................................................................................................23 5.2 Capacity and Social Capital.......................................................................................................25 6 METHODOLOGY .................................................................................................................................27 6.1 Research Proposal .....................................................................................................................27 6.2 Community Selection ................................................................................................................28 6.3 Sample Size...............................................................................................................................30 6.4 Research Instrument Design......................................................................................................31 6.5 Data Collection and Processing.................................................................................................32 7 EMPIRICAL RESULTS.........................................................................................................................33 7.1 Socio-Demographic Statistics....................................................................................................33 7.2 Perception of Risk .....................................................................................................................34 7.3 Household-Level Emergency Preparedness ..............................................................................37 7.3.1 General Preparedness........................................................................................................37 7.3.2 Economic Aspects of Preparedness ..................................................................................40 7.3.3 Information and Emergency Preparedness .......................................................................44 7.3.4 Emergency Preparedness and Level of Tornado Knowledge ...........................................46 7.4 Perception of Disaster Science and Warnings...........................................................................47 7.5 Perceptions of Government-Level Emergency Management....................................................48 7.6 Perceptions of Vulnerability......................................................................................................52 7.7 Community Networks and Relationships ..................................................................................55 7.8 Impact of the Tornado on Pine Lake Residents.........................................................................57 7.8.1 Impact ...............................................................................................................................57 7.8.2 Local Capacity..................................................................................................................59 8 DISCUSSION/RECOMMENDATIONS ...............................................................................................64 9 REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................................67 LIST OF TABLES Table 3.1: Categories of Incentives .............................................................................................. 16 Table 6.1: Community Characteristics ......................................................................................... 29 Table 7.1: Survey Sample Demographic Characteristics ............................................................. 34 Table 7.2: Index, Perception of Natural Disasters and Associated Damage ................................ 35 Table 7.3: Seriousness of Most Recent Disaster........................................................................... 36 Table 7.4a: Perception of Disaster versus Experience.................................................................. 37 Table 7.4b: Perception of Disaster versus Gender........................................................................ 37 Table 7.5: Nexus of Household Level Responsibility .................................................................. 39 Table 7.6: Why Would you be Willing to Invest in Home Improvements?................................. 43 Table 7.7: Why Wouldn't you be Willing to Invest? .................................................................... 43 Table 7.8a: Sources of Emergency Preparedness Information ..................................................... 44 Table 7.8b: Sources of Emergency Preparedness Information - Gender...................................... 45 Table 7.9: How Accurate do you Think the Science
Recommended publications
  • The First Twenty Five Years Peace Hills Insurance Building, Edmonton, AB Introduction
    The First Twenty Five Years Peace Hills Insurance Building, Edmonton, AB Introduction It’s a story that begins 25 years ago. Pierre Trudeau was Prime Minister of Canada and Peter Lougheed was Alberta’s Premier. Terry Fox succumbed to cancer after capturing the admiration and support of Canadians across the country. “Bette Davis Eyes” topped the charts and “Raiders of the Lost Ark” took theatres across Canada by storm. The Edmonton Oilers drafted Paul Coffey, Jari Kurri and Andy Moog to support Wayne Gretzky and build a Stanley Cup contending team. It was a time of romance: Lady Diana Spencer and Prince Charles were married, as millions of people across the world watched on television. And it was a time of tragedy: AIDS was identified and diagnosed for the first time, and the New York Islanders won the Stanley Cup. It was a time of vision: in Hobbema, Alberta, the Samson Cree Nation – led by Chief Jim Omeasoo and later his successor Chief Victor Buffalo – decided it was time to invest the Nation’s oil and gas royalties and diversify their holdings. In 1981, the dream that would become Peace Hills General Insurance Company was born. Original letter of formation and objectives The Eighties 1981 Dream Catchers – Investing Wisely The path the Samson Cree Nation took in establishing Peace Hills Insurance was not a straight one. In 1981, Chief Jim Omeasoo lead them in a new direction, with the goal of investing their oil and gas revenues in new ventures. They persuaded David Nicholson to leave his job with the federal government and become the Chief Jim Omeasoo General Manager of Samson Management Limited, which handled the management of their investments.
    [Show full text]
  • University of Alberta
    University of Alberta Library Release Form Name of Author: Lesley Margaret Hill Title of Thesis: Drylines observed in Alberta during A-GAME Degree: Master of Science Year this Degree Granted: 2006 Permission is hereby granted to the University of Alberta Library to reproduce single copies of this thesis and to lend or sell such copies for private, scholarly or scientific research purposes only. The author reserves all other publication and other rights in association with the copyright in the thesis, and except as herein before provided, neither the thesis nor any substantial portion thereof may be printed or otherwise reproduced in any material form whatsoever without the author's prior written permission. Signature 3906 Upper Dwyer Hill Rd. R.R. #1 Kinburn, Ontario, K0A2H0 University of Alberta Drylines observed in Alberta during A-GAME by Lesley Margaret Hill A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences Edmonton, Alberta Spring, 2006 Abstract This thesis investigates drylines (or moisture fronts) in south-central Alberta during A-GAME (July-August 2003 and July-August 2004). Surface meteorological data were collected every 30 minutes at 4 sites along the FOPEX transect (from Caroline westward). In addition, mobile transects were performed allowing for even finer 1 minute resolution data. GPS-derived precipitable water estimates were also examined. The major findings of this investigation were: 1) During the 4 summer months, 7 dryline events occurred in the project area. 2) Five of these dryline events were associated with convective activity, including one severe thunderstorm with 2 cm diameter hail.
    [Show full text]
  • Unfolding a Little History
    SARDAA History Page 1 of 25 Unfolding Our 25-Year History by Michelle Limoges, secretary, founding member and dog handler Overarching themes in SARDAA’s history include our tenacity, our willingness to reach out to other SAR groups both at home and away, our never-ending search for new/different/improved training methods, our goal of improving our organization and its processes, and our dedication to providing the best darn SAR dog teams around! Furthermore, there have been many people over our history who have believed in us, used our services and stood by us through thick and thin – we won’t list your names for fear of missing someone, but you know who you are! Thank you for honouring us with your support and confidence. Very early days Prior to SARDAA’s official formation under the Alberta Societies Act in November of 1989, the original six dogs and people had been training in obedience, protection and tracking together for some time at a local Edmonton dog school run by Kevin George. We hadn’t even begun to think about SAR work at that point! Original Objectives It’s important for newcomers to SARDAA to be aware of the organization’s history. SARDAA is much more than individual members and their dogs; we are a team dedicated to training and deploying the best SAR dogs we are capable of producing. We take this mandate very seriously. 12/30/17 SARDAA History Page 2 of 25 1989 Objectives of the Society a) To encourage and promote the use of SAR dogs throughout the province of Alberta b) To establish performance standards for SAR dog teams c) To educate both the community and government in the training and deployment of SAR dogs d) To establish a resource library of SAR dog subjects e) To train dog and handler teams for mission-ready SAR work in wilderness and disaster duty.
    [Show full text]
  • A Tornado Scenario for Barrie, Ontario
    A Tornado Scenario for Barrie, Ontario by: David A. Etkin (corresponding author) Adaptation and Impacts Research Group, Environment Canada Institute for Environmental Studies, University of Toronto 33 Willcocks St., Toronto, Ontario, M5S 3E8 [email protected] Soren E. Brun North Carolina Dep’t. of Transport GIS Unit Solomon Chrom Faculty of Environmental Studies, York University Pooja Dogra Institute for Environment Studies, U. of T. July 2002 ICLR Research Paper Series – No. 20 (A contribution to the Canadian Natural Hazards Assessment Project) INTRODUCTION A natural disaster occurs when an environmental extreme triggers social vulnerabilities. The magnitude of the resulting impact is then a function of the intensity of the environmental extreme coupled with a society’s perception and adaptation to the hazard (Blaike et al., 1994). An examination of risk should therefore be composed of two parts: one part relating to the probability of a natural hazard occurring, while the second relates to the magnitude of the resulting impact (which depends upon the vulnerability of the exposed infrastructure and population). Various studies such as Hague (1987), Paul (1995a,b), Etkin et al. (1995; 2001), Paruk and Blackwell (1994) and Newark (1983), have explored the probability of tornado occurrence in Canada; while other (Lawrynuik et al, 1985; Allen, 1986, Carter et al., 1989; Charlton,et al., 1998) have discussed the impacts of individual Canadian tornadoes. Globally, Canada ranks second, after the United States, in tornado risk. The purpose of this paper is to focus on the second part of the problem - that is, the impact/vulnerability aspect. In order to accomplish this, this paper will briefly review historical tornado impacts, consider one tornado disaster in more detail (the May 31, 1985 Barrie Tornado), and consider a hypothetical scenario of how it might have been worse, had events transpired somewhat differently (ie.
    [Show full text]
  • Adventist Awareness
    LBERT~ DVENTIST SEPTEMBER- OCTOBER, 1987 Two Ministers Ordained ADVENTIST Reo Ganson Inaugurated AWARENESS as President of CUC '88 During 1988 a province-wide media advertising campaign is being planned in order to make the average Albertan much more aware of who Seventh-day Adventists are and of how our unique message can benefit them. During the July 18 Sabbath service this past camp meeting, an offering of $7,235.79 was received. Several sample radio spots were played to give our membership an idea of the direction of this program. We have heard nothing but good comments regarding this. We need another $17,800 in order to help finance the Elder and Mrs. Lawrence Branch (left) and Elder and anticipated expenses. Please Mrs. Dennis Nickel. mark your Tithe & Offering Elder Jim Wilson, President of Canadian Union Conference, envelope, "Adventist Aware­ presenting a large Bible to Dr. Reo Ganson, President of ness" and pass it on to your Canadian Union College on the day of inauguration. July 18, 1987 was a very Mrs. Beth Reimche gave a local church treasurer. meaningful day in the Jives of special charge to the two Thank you for s~pporting Dr. Reo Ganson was offi­ of Education and Vice­ two ~lberta pastors and their wives, Eunice Branch and Jenny this program tv Leo 1 Alberta coally onstated as President President for Academic Affairs families. On the last Sabbath Nickel. Elder AI Reimche, who Adventists are and how we of Canadian Union College at till his appointment as the of Foothills Camp Meeting Ministerial Director of Alber­ can benefit them.
    [Show full text]
  • Data Collection Report
    Edmonton Japanese Community Association History Project – Data Collection Report Edmonton Picnic 1949 June 30, 2014 1 Publisher: Edmonton Japanese Community Association (EJCA) - History Project Phase 1 and Phase 2 Committees Date: June 30, 2014 Contact Address: EJCA, c/o EJCA/Argyll Community Centre, 6750 - 88 Street, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada T6E 5H6, E-mail: [email protected] Committee members: Phase 1 - Rick Hirata (Chair), Cathy Tennant, David Sulz, Jim Hoyano, Sanae Ohki Phase 2 – Cathy Tennant (Chair), Daiyo Sawada, David Sulz, Jim Hoyano, Sanae Ohki Editor: Sanae Ohki Copyright: Edmonton Japanese Community Association and/or individual creators of various sections. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form whatsoever without prior written permission from the EJCA or individual section creators except in the case of brief quotations or insubstantial portions which must be properly credited. Important note: Due to the nature of historical data collection, there are undoubtedly many gaps, missing information, and the accuracy of some facts may be disputed. The committee members and interviewees disclaim any responsibility for errors, omissions and incomplete information but are pleased to receive corrections, suggestions, additions, etc. that may be used (or not) at the committee's discretion. Any additional information or historical sources received after June 2014 will be added to a separate document called Edmonton Japanese Community Association History Project Data Collection Report Addendum. Each time
    [Show full text]
  • Presentation
    3A.6 A CASE STUDY OF THREE SEVERE TORNADIC STORMS IN ALBERTA, CANADA Max L. Dupilka University of Alberta, T6G2E3 Edmonton, AB Canada and Gerhard W. Reuter* 1. INTRODUCTION was the only case of an F4 tornado in Alberta during recorded history. The Holden and the Pine The Rocky Mountains are an impressive north- Lake tornados were both F3 cases. There were no south mountain barrier extending 2400 km from other recorded F3 tornadoes in Alberta during the Yukon to Texas. The impact on of the mountains is period 1983-2003. particularly evident in Alberta, whose boundaries We made a synoptic analysis of the three extend from 49° to 60° N and 120° to 110° W, with tornadic storms with an emphasis on the surface the southwestern border following the Continental moisture and storm tracks. The development of Divide (Fig.1). Central Alberta is highly susceptible these storms was compared to the conceptual to severe convection, having on average 52 days model for severe convection suggested by Smith with hail fall each summer (Smith et al. 1998). and Yau (1993a,b). They identified two stages Alberta thunderstorms that spawn tornadoes occur leading to the formation of severe convective far less frequently (Newark 1984; Bullas and storms. Stage 1 is characterized by clear skies in Wallace 1988). Hage (1994, 2003) compiled an subsiding air ahead of an approaching upper-level extensive tornado climatology starting from 1879. He ridge. A strong inversion in the lower troposphere found that on average 10 tornadoes occur over inhibits or “caps” any deep convection. Upper level Alberta each summer.
    [Show full text]
  • Physical Features
    Physical Features Chapter 2 Prepared by J. Brad Stelfox, John Godfrey, Mike Flannigan, Bob Wynes, and Greg Tink Summary Points • The geological landscape of northwest Alberta reflects the dynamic erosional and depositional history of the region. Advancing and retreating glaciers during the Pleistocene modified the pre-glacial topography, smoothing the highlands and depositing materials in topographic depressions. • Today, morainal deposits blanket most of the lowland regions. Glacial deposits on upland areas are more shallow and consequently these regions have some Cretaceous and Tertiary sediments exposed. • Soil conditions in northwest Alberta vary significantly depending on glacial history, local parent materials, climate, vegetation, and topography, with finer-textured clay-dominated soils occurring in glacial lake basins, and clay/loams with some stoniness occurring in highland regions where glacial till prevails. • Permafrost is present throughout much of the northern portions of the study area and is generally found beneath bog complexes. Permafrost is common in more northerly latitudes but yields to degraded permafrost further south. Degraded permafrost areas are those sites that provide clear evidence of permafrost in recent geologic times, but has been degraded because of changes in climate or landform. • The overall climate for northwest Alberta is continental, with warm summers and cold winters. Large contrasts in temperature between day and night, and between winter and summer are typical. For seven to eight months of the year, the air transport in northwest Alberta is from the west, which might be expected to bring moist air from the Pacific. However, most of the moisture is lost when the air passes over the Coastal Mountain Range and the Rocky Mountains, thereby giving the region its continental climate.
    [Show full text]
  • Simulating Rural Emergency Medical Services During Mass Casualty Disasters
    SIMULATING RURAL EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES DURING MASS CASUALTY DISASTERS by KENDRA SULLIVAN B.S., Kansas State University, 2008 A THESIS submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree MASTER OF SCIENCE Department of Industrial and Manufacturing Systems Engineering College of Engineering KANSAS STATE UNIVERSITY Manhattan, Kansas 2008 Approved by: Major Professor Dr. Malgorzata Rys Copyright KENDRA SULLIVAN 2008 Abstract Emergency Medical Systems (EMS) are designed to handle emergencies. Fortunately, most emergencies faced have only one patient. The every day system is not designed to respond to emergencies in which there are many casualties. Due to natural disasters and terrorist attacks that have occurred over the past decade, mass-casualty disaster response plans have become a priority for many organizations, including EMS. The resources available for constructing such plans are limited. Physical simulations or practices of the plan are often performed; however, it is not until a disaster strikes that the capabilities of the plan are truly realized. In this paper, it is proposed that discrete-event simulations are used as part of the planning process. A computer simulation can test the capability of the plan under different settings and help planners in their decision making. This paper looks at the creation of a discrete-event simulation using ARENA software. The simulation was found to accurately simulate the response to the Greensburg tornado that occurred May of 2008. A sensitivity analysis found that the simulation results are dependent upon the values assumed for Volunteer Injury Rate, Injury Level, Information Dissemination Rate and Transportation Decision variables. When a disaster occurs, the local resources are overwhelmed and outside aide must be called in.
    [Show full text]
  • The Weather of the Canadian Prairies
    PRAIRIE-E05 11/12/05 9:09 PM Page 3 TheThe WeWeatherather ofof TheThe CCanaanadiandian PrairiesPrairies GraphicGraphic AreaArea ForecastForecast 3232 PRAIRIE-E05 11/12/05 9:09 PM Page i TheThe WWeeatherather ofof TheThe Canadiananadian PrairiesPrairies GraphicGraphic AreaArea ForecastForecast 3322 by Glenn Vickers Sandra Buzza Dave Schmidt John Mullock PRAIRIE-E05 11/12/05 9:09 PM Page ii Copyright Copyright © 2001 NAV CANADA. All rights reserved. No part of this document may be reproduced in any form, including photocopying or transmission electronically to any computer, without prior written consent of NAV CANADA. The information contained in this document is confidential and proprietary to NAV CANADA and may not be used or disclosed except as expressly authorized in writing by NAV CANADA. Trademarks Product names mentioned in this document may be trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective companies and are hereby acknowledged. Relief Maps Copyright © 2000. Government of Canada with permission from Natural Resources Canada Design and illustration by Ideas in Motion Kelowna, British Columbia ph: (250) 717-5937 [email protected] PRAIRIE-E05 11/12/05 9:09 PM Page iii LAKP-Prairies iii The Weather of the Prairies Graphic Area Forecast 32 Prairie Region Preface For NAV CANADA’s Flight Service Specialists (FSS), providing weather briefings to help pilots navigate through the day-to-day fluctuations in the weather is a critical role. While available weather products are becoming increasingly more sophisticated and, at the same time more easily understood, an understanding of local and region- al climatological patterns is essential to the effective performance of this role.
    [Show full text]
  • Wild Words: Essays on Alberta Literature/Edited by Donna Coates and George Melnyk
    ESSAYS ON ALBERTA LITERATURE Edited by Donna Coates and George Melnyk 061494_Book.indb i 2/9/09 2:47:51 PM 061494_Book.indb ii 2/9/09 2:47:52 PM ESSAYS ON ALBERTA LITERATURE Edited by Donna Coates and George Melnyk 061494_Book.indb iii 2/9/09 2:47:53 PM © 2009 Donna Coates and George Melnyk Published by AU Press, Athabasca University 1200, 10011 – 109 Street Edmonton, AB T5J 3S8 Library and Archives Canada Cataloguing in Publication Wild words: essays on Alberta literature/edited by Donna Coates and George Melnyk. Includes bibliographical references and index. Issued also in electronic format (ISBN 978-1-897425-31-2). ISBN 978-1-897425-30-5 1. Canadian literature – Alberta – History and criticism. I. Coates, Donna, 1944- II. Melnyk, George III. Title. PS8131.A43W54 2009 C810.9’97123 C2008-908001-7 Cover design by Kris Twyman Cover painting by Marion Twyman Book layout and design by Infoscan Collette, Québec Printed and bound in Canada by Marquis Book Printing This publication is licensed under a Creative Commons License, see www.creativecommons.org. The text may be reproduced for non-commercial purposes, provided that credit is given to the original author(s). Please contact AU Press, Athabasca University at [email protected] for permission beyond the usage outlined in the Creative Commons license. This book was funded in part by the Alberta Historical Resources Foundation. TABLE OF CONTENTS PREFACE: The Struggle for an Alberta Literature Donna Coates and George Melnyk . vii INTRODUCTION: Wrestling Impossibilities: Wild Words in Alberta Aritha van Herk . 1 PART ONE: Poetry 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Disaster Forum to TAKE ACTION!
    Disaster Mitigate Prepare Respond Recover PLAN TO TAKE ACTION! Forum May 11-14, 2009 | Banff, Alberta | www.disasterforum.ca 2009 Presented by Platinum Sponsors Silver Sponsors Practical perspectives on emergency Bronze Sponsors management Thank you to all our sponsors: Contents Platinum 03 Welcome 03 Who Should Attend 03 About Banff 04 Disaster Forum Agenda 08 Conference Session and Speakers 08 Pre-Conference Workshops Silver 09 Keynote Speakers 10 Concurrent Session A 12 Concurrent Session B 13 Concurrent Session C 14 Concurrent Session D 15 Demonstration EOC Exercise 15 The Conference After Hours 16 General Information 17 Conference Policies Bronze 18 Travel and Accommodations 19 Discover Banff 20 Conference at a Glance 21 Concurrent Sessions at a Glance 22 Map of Banff Centre 23 Delegate Registration Form 25 Session Selection Form 26 Guest Registration Form Disaster Forum 2009 is presented by Disaster Conferences Inc. 13127-156 Street Edmonton, AB T5V 1V2 Phone: (780) 483-4004 or 1-800-718-3762 Fax: (780) 444-6167 e-mail: [email protected] www.disasterforum.ca 2 Get Away to the Rockies! This spring, management and emergency preparedness practitioners from across Canada will gather in beautiful Banff, Alberta for the ninth-annual Disaster Disaster Forum. Join them for four days of professional development sessions and social activities – with a distinctively western Forum Canadian flavour. Your conference organizers have brought together a world- 2009 class group of speakers – ranging from experts in preventing and responding to emergencies and attacks on critical infrastructure, to seasoned professionals who have been involved in responding to some of the most significant disasters in recent history.
    [Show full text]