claimet\he got the idea for his h ''" from wntching a gas flame bum. John Ambrose Flen#ng thought that story ·~just so much hot air.

lreJess telegraphy held excit­ m WIng promise at the beginning of the twentieth century. Peo­ ~With Imagination could seethe po.. tentlal thot 'the rematkoble new offered forworlct1Nk:le com­ munfcotion. However, no one could hove predicted the impact that the soon-to-be-developed "osdllotlon volve" ond "oudlon" Wireless-telegra­ phy & wauid have on elec­ tronics technology.

Backpouncl. Shortly before 1900, · Guglielmo Morconl had formed his own company to develop wireless­ telegraphy technology. He demon­ strated that wireless set-ups on ships eot~ld~messageswlth nearby stations on other ships or on land. t The hOd also j transmitted messages across the EhQ­ Jish Channel. By the end of 1901. Mar­ coni extended the range of his equipmenttospantheAtlan1tcOcean. It was obvlgus. 1hot ~raph ~MeS with subrhatlrie cables and ihelr lnber­ ent flmltations woUld soon disappear, Ships· at sea would no longer be iso­ la1ed. No locatlon on Eorth would. be too remote to send and receive mes­ sages. Clear1y; the opportunity existed tor enormous tiOOnciql gain once Jelio­ ble equlprrient was avoltable. To that end, 1Uned electrical circuits were developed to reduce the band­ width of the signals produced by ,the spark transrnlf'tirs. The resonont clfcults were also used in a receiver to select one signal from omong several trans­ missions. Slm~deslgn principles for resonont ontennas were also being explored and applied, However, the senstflvlty and reUabltlty of the devices used to ctetectthe Wireless signals were still hln­ cterlng the development of commer­ () cial wireless-telegraph nefWorks. Inadequate Detectors. The detector most commoniV UWd at the rum of the century was theCOherer. developed by Edouord Branly In 1890. Basico~ the consis1ed of a hollow non-con­ ducting tube .filled with metallic filings. Normally. ·the coherer acted as .an open circuit. However, when a Ual6 ... Way. Thomas IWa produced by a spark dlschdrge was EdisOn cOntributed substantially to the applied, the coherer became con­ ~of the thermionic ductive and remained that way until ft:lrPugh his 'YOrk with the incandescent the filings were shaken loose by tap­ lamp. In 1fJ79, he had produced a ping the tube. procflcallathp with a carbon filament ·The coherer was not a very sensitiVe that operated on DC. or reliable detector and the tapping After each lamp hdd operated for a required be1ween each telegraphic WhHe. Edison noticed that a black de­ dot or dash meant that messages posit of carbon formed on the Inside of could not be transmitted very rapidly. the gloss envelope. The carbon Despite its limitations, the coherer was ~to be corning from the nega­ the best detector of wireless signals -side ot the filament, sinOe that was available at that tlme. the Side that

43 II

He merely used the incandescent lamp D. Edison had modified and patented in b 1883 for a new purpose-the detection of wireless signals. Edison's prior patent, I together with some very broad claims

:vI in Fleming's patent application con­ I cerning the rectifying capabilities of M the oscillation valve, made Fleming's 2 legal position questionable. As the markets for both Fleming's 4 valve and de Forest's audion were ini­ c tially relatively small, no resolution of the - ,,,, + legal questions was pursued. The Lee de Forest Radio Telephone Company A sold wireless equipment that incorpo­ rated grid-audion detectors to the U.S. Navy. It also sold the spherically shaped grid audions for commercial use. The Fig. 5. Lee de Forest's grid audion was the first grid-containing low-vacuum tube. Marconi Company used the Fleming Multiple-electrode tubes were soon to follow. valve, modified to include a grid similar to that in de Forest's triode audion, in its were more reliable. simpler to operate. considered to be a relay), Fleming's de­ own network of wireless stations. and virtually indestructible. vice could do nothing to increase the In his 1906 patent application, de effective energy of the signals. and Oscillators. In 1911. Forest called the original triode audion The explanation de Forest provided de Forest was hired by the Federal Tele­ a "device for amplifying feeble electric concerning how his detector func­ graph Company. The company's goal currents." The techniques necessary for tioned differently· from Fleming's was of recording high-speed telegraph sig­ using it as a true , however. wrong. Both Fleming's and de Forest's nals for later decoding created the would not be developed for almost six devices were , virtually identi­ need to increase the energy of the re­ years. cal in appearance and operation. The ceived signals. Lee de Forest now battery de Forest used in the plate cir­ worked to get the triode audion to am­ Patent Problems. Other problems ex­ cuit of his audion put a positive bias on plify at audio frequencies. isted for de Forest. too. The Marconi the plate. but was not necessary for its Lee de Forest and his co-workers Company of America owned the pat­ operation as a rectifier. Lee de Forest's achieved amplification in 1912 by using ent on Fleming's valve and maintained device was not, in any sense of the audio-frequency to cou­ that de Forest's two-element (diode) word, a relay. ple the signal to and from the audion. audion infringed on that patent. Fur­ While the legal position of the de For­ They also found it extremely beneficial ther. Lee de Forest's triode audion con­ est diode and triode audions was not to reduce even further the already low cept was based on his diode audion. very clear, that of the also pressure inside the audion ·envelope. In Consequently, de·Foresfs right to man­ was in question: Strictly speaking, Flem­ time. the audion's spherical shape ufacture and sell the triode audions ing did not "invent'' the oscillation valve. would become tubular and the gener­ was not without dispute. ic name for this and similar devices. Lee de Forest maintained that the very appropriately, would become the idea for his diode audion came from his Books and Articles. "vacuum tube." earlier flame audion, not from Fleming's In the course of developing the am­ valve. The records show. however. that "Lee de Forest and the Triode Detector;" By plifier, de Forest found that his circuit de Forest knew about the Fleming valve Robert A Chipman, Scientific Americon. oscillated, a phenomenon commonly and had some copies of it made for his March 1965, pp. 92- 100. encountered by amplifier builders own experiments late in 1905. In fact, Saga of the. vacuum Tube; By Gerald F.J. even today. The discovery that the tri­ one of de Forest's patent applications Tyne, Indianapolis. Howard W. Sams & Co.. ode also could be used as an amplifier (for what he called a "static valve"), 1987. or as an oscillator established it as a filed on December 9. 1905, refers to 76 ~rs ofRadio Tubes dnd Valves; By John truly important electronic device. Fleming's valve by name. That patent W. Stokes, Vestal. N.Y., The Vestal Press ltd., application was filed several months 1982. Lawsuits and Stalemate. The Mar­ before he applied for patents on his The : Technology and coni Wireless Telegraph Company of (f) own diode audion. American Radio; By Hugh G.J. Aitken, America sued Lee de Forest and the S:2 A further claim by de Forest was that Princeton, N.J.. Princeton University Press, z 1985. Lee de Forest Radiotelephone and 0a: the use of a battery in the plate circuit Telegraph Company in 1914 for in­ 1- "The First Tube"; By George Shlers. () of his diode audion distinguished it from fringement of its Fleming-valve patent. UJ Scientific American. March 1969, pp. _J Fleming's valve. He also argued that Lee de Forest a.nd his company filed a UJ 104-112. Fleming's valve was only a device for countersuit for infringement of their tri­ a: "The life and Work of lee de Forest'; On 14 :5 rectifying high-frequency wireless sig­ ode-audion patents by the Marconi ::::> Parts), Edited by W.B. Arvin. Radio News, Oc2 a.. nals. Lee de Forest maintained that. un­ tober 1924-November 1925. Company. lr like his own audion (which he still (Continued on page 85)

44 SLOT VACUUM TUBES (Continued from page 39) (Continued from page 44) diameter of the fiber-optic cable for a The Marconi Company admitted its snug fit, and the other holes should fit guilt and was prohibited from further the hardware you're using. infringement. On September 20, 1916, a Attach a U-shaped mounting brack­ U.S. District Court ruled that de Forest et to the coin slot as shown in Fig . 8. Fit and his company similarly had violated the emitter assemblies on one side of the Fleming patent. In short. neither the EARN YOUR the coin slot and the detectors on the Lee de Forest Company nor the Mar­ other. Now simply twist and solder them coni Company could manufacture tri­ B.S.E.E. to the leads coming from the circuit ode audions without infringing on the board. Follow the polarity indications other's patent. DEGREE supplied with the exact parts you use in This legal impasse was not resolved THROUGH HOME STUDY your circuit. until after World War I. During the war, Our New and Highly Effective Advanced-Place­ Make sure that the circuit is counting however, de Forest was granted legal ment Program for experienced Electronic Tech­ nicians grants credit for previous Schooling and change properly before installing it in­ immunity to manufacture grid audions Professional Experience, and can greatly re­ side a cabinet. Since this article is really for the United States Government. duce the time required to complete Program and reach graduation. No residence schooling re­ about the , we will not go quired for qualified Electronic Technicians. into the details on how the cabinet was Legacy of the Audion. Once the tri­ Through this Special Program you can pull all of the loose ends of your electronics background assembled, but the basic measure­ ode audion's capabilities for amplifying together and earn your B.S. E. E. Degree. Up­ ments are shown in Fig. 9. The elec­ and oscillating were discovered, the grade your status and pay to the Level. Advance Rapidly! Many lin ish in 1 2 tronic circuitry and the slot assembly development of regenerative and su­ months or less. Students and graduates in all 50 mounts inside the top of the unit. The pefheterodyne receivers quickly fol­ States and throughout the World. Established Over 40 Years! Write for free Descriptive Lit­ top and bottom half of the bank are lowed. Commercial radio broadcast­ erature. attached with hinges to allow empty­ ing began shortly thereafter. In just a ing of the change compartment and few years, the triode vacuum tube was access to the reset button. The top half joined by its more sophisticated of the bank has a fairly large cutout in its and relatives to make possi­ base to allow .the coins fall through into ble even more sophisticated electronic the bottom compartment. • circuits. •

This publication is LASER (Continued from page 66) available in microform from University lot more things than I need or want. I Microfilms make use of the wordprocessor be­ cause of the convenience in writing International. when and where I feel in the mood, as opposed to being captive at a desktop location. The documentation is clear, the programs are largely intuitive, and file transfer is fast and easy. A privately produced quarterly news­ letter devoted to the PC4 is available from Michael Posner, LUGNuts (Laser THE MONEY MAKING OPPORTUNITY User Group Nuts), 4200 Community OF THE 1990'S IF you are able to work with common small hand Drive #1514, West Palm Beach, FL tools, and are familiar with basic electronics (i.e. able 33409, for $10 a year. You can request a 0 Please send information about these titles: to use voltmeter, understand DC electronics) ... . free sample copy. IF you possess average mechanical ability, and have a VCR on which to practice and learn ....then we can The Laser PC4 is available directly teach YOU VCR maintenance and repair! from Laser Computer, Inc. (800 North FACT: up to 90% of ALL VCR malfunctions are due to Name ______simple MECHANICAL or ELECTRO-MECHANICAL Church St., Lake Zurich, IL 60047-1596), breakdowns! for $249.95 plus shipping. The order Company/lnstitution ------FACT: over 77 million VCRs in use today nationwide! Average VCR needs service or repai r every t2 to 18 phone number is 800-LASER43, or you months! can call Laser at 708-540-8911 for your Address ------Viejo 's 400 PAGE TRAINING MANUAL (over 500 pho­ tos and illustrations) and AWARD-WINNING VIDEO local dealer. If you get a PC4 and need City ------TRAINING TAPE reveals the SECRETS of VCR mainte­ technical support. call Laser at Sta te ______ZiP·------nance and repair-"real world" information that is NOT available elsewhere! 800-551-5742 or 708-540-5022. For Phone ,_(---'------­ Also includes all the info you'll need regarding the more information contact the man­ Call toll-free 800-521-3044. In Michigan, BUSINESS-SIDE of running a successful service op- Alaska and Hawaii call collect 313-761-4700. Or ufacturer or circle No. 119 on the Free mail inquiry to: University Microfilms International, eration! FREE INFORMATION 300 North Zeeb Road, Ann Arbor, MI 48106. CALL TOLL-FREE 1-800-537-0589 Information Card. • Or write to : Viejo Publications Inc. 5329 Fountain Ave . Lo s Angeles , CA 90029 Dept. PE 85 CIRC LE 20 ON FREE INFORMATION CARD II