DOCSLIB.ORG

Medieval Worlds Comparative & Interdisciplinary Studies

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Medieval Worlds Comparative & Interdisciplinary Studies medieval worlds comparative & interdisciplinary studies No. 1/2015 medieval worlds comparative & interdisciplinary studies medieval worlds comparative & interdisciplinary studies Volume 2015.1 Approaches to Comparison in Medieval Studies medieval worlds comparative & interdisciplinary studies The journal is funded by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) project OAJ-52. All rights reserved ISSN [applied] Media Owner: Institute for Medieval Research Copyright © 2015 by Austrian Academy of Sciences, Vienna Cover design, layout: Anneke Gerloff Austrian Academy of Sciences Press A-1011 Wien, Postfach 471, Postgasse 7/4 Tel. +43-1-515 81/DW 3402-3406, +43-1-512 9050 Fax +43-1-515 81/DW 3400 http://hw.oeaw.ac.at, http://verlag.oeaw.ac.at Editors Walter Pohl, Austrian Academy of Sciences/University of Vienna Andre Gingrich, Austrian Academy of Sciences/University of Vienna Editorial Board Maximilian Diesenberger, Austrian Academy of Sciences Bert Fragner, Austrian Academy of Sciences Christian Gastgeber, Austrian Academy of Sciences Johann Heiß, Austrian Academy of Sciences Claudia Rapp, Austrian Academy of Sciences/University of Vienna Irene van Renswoude, Huygens Institute for the History of the Netherlands/ Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences Pavlína Rychterová, Austrian Academy of Sciences Veronika Wieser, Austrian Academy of Sciences International Advisory Board Glenn Bowman , University of Kent Sabrina Corbellini, University of Groningen Mayke de Jong, Utrecht University Nicola di Cosmo, Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton Stefan Esders, Free University of Berlin Patrick Geary, Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton John Haldon, Princeton University William C. Jordan, Princeton University Osamu Kano, Nagoya University Birgit Kellner, Heidelberg University Hugh Kennedy, SOAS, University of London Gábor Klaniczay, Central European University Lars Boje Mortensen, University of Southern Denmark Elisabeth Lambourn, De Montfort University Leicester Eduardo Manzano, Centro de Ciencias Humanas y Sociales (CSIC) Helmut Reimitz, Princeton University Marina Rustow, John Hopkins University Dittmar Schorkowitz, Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology Teresa Shawcross, Princeton University Naomi Standen, University of Birmingham John Tolan, University of Nantes Przemysław Urbańczyk, Polish Academy of Sciences Dan Varisco, Qatar University Luo Xin, Peking University Journal Management Celine Wawruschka Rutger Kramer Homepage www.medievalworlds.net Medieval Worlds, first issue: »Approaches to Comparison in Medieval Studies« Walter Pohl and Andre Gingrich Medieval Worlds: Introduction to the First Issue 2 Patrick Geary The Discourse of Herrschaft as the Practice of Herrschaft in the Fifth Century 5 Robert Moore The First Great Divergence? 16 Lars Boje Mortensen Comparing and Connecting: the Rise of Fast Historiography in Latin and Vernacular (Twelfth to Thirteenth Century) 25 Helen Siu Historical Anthropology: A View from »South China« 40 Comparative Papers: Universal Histories Ian Wood Universal Chronicles in the Early Medieval West 47 Ann Christys Universal Chronicles in Arabic before c. 900 61 Comparative History in the Making: Ongoing Major Research Projects Gwen Bennet »I Spy with my Little Eye«: GIS and Archaeological Perspectives on Eleventh Century Song Envoy Routes in the Liao Empire (Kitan-Liao Archaeological Survey and History KLASH) 71 Michael Borgolte Foundations »For the Salvation of the Soul« – an Exception in World History? (Foundations of Medieval Societies FOUNDMED) 86 Catherine Holmes and Naomi Standen Defining the Global Middle Ages (AHRC Research Network) 106 Eduardo Manzano Why Did Islamic Medieval Institutions Become So Different from Western Medieval Institutions? (Power and Institutions in Medieval Islam and Christendom PIMIC) 118 Walter Pohl and Andre Gingrich Visions of Community (VISCOM): Comparative Approaches to Ethnicity, Region and Empire in Christianity, Islam and Buddhism (400-1600 CE) 138 John Tolan The Legal Status of Religious Minorities in the Euro-Mediterranean World (RELMIN) 148 medieval worlds • No. 1 Medieval Worlds: Introduction to the First Issue Books, web-sites or university courses entitled ›The Medieval World‹ usually deal with Me- dieval Europe, sometimes only with its ›Latin‹ or Western parts. The name of the present journal, ›Medieval Worlds‹, underlines the diversity of our global past, while maintaining that common approaches are possible. ›Global History‹ often concentrates on the contem- porary and modern history of a globalized world; but global perspectives on pre-modern pe- riods are also possible before or beyond processes of globalization. Many fascinating projects explore wide horizons of the global past, both temporally and spatially. These new lines of re- search depart from many disciplines and reach out across disciplinary divides; arguably, this is one of the most dynamic fields in the heterogeneous academic landscapes of the study of the past. For those who are interested in engaging with current developments and advances in this type of research, however, it is still hard to get an overview of its progress. The present journal is intended to become one of the intellectual »hubs« in this regard: exploring new approaches, stimulating comparative research, offering methodological debates, exchanging reports across disciplines, and presenting current large-scale projects. The journal’s name, ›Medieval Worlds – Comparative and Interdisciplinary Stu- dies‹, is programmatic in several ways. Within broader debates of the Social Sciences and Humanities, the Middle Ages often are conspicuously absent, or figure as a simplified coun- terfoil against modernity. Therefore, the journal aims to help putting Medieval Studies on the map. We use ›medieval‹ as a rough chronological indication, which can be modified ac- cording to regional and disciplinary research traditions, and which should in any case in- clude late antique and early modern periods of transition. The journal does not advocate any ›strong‹ concept of ›the‹ Middle Ages as a period defined by particular characteristics, which would hardly be tenable in a global context. We do not depart from any teleological idea which would limit the field and impose a choice of one explanatory model over another. Scholars may legitimately debate when axial or post-axial ages led to fundamental transfor- mations across Eurasia, or whether or not the Middle Ages marked the beginning of a ›Great Divergence‹. The journal can host such discussions, but does not regard them as an obliga- tory starting point for research on the wide varieties of medieval forms of life. Medieval so- cieties should not simply be studied as stages in a process that only became meaningful later. There is more to the Middle Ages than merely representing a prehistory of modernity – i.e. of the modern individual, state, nation, democracy, media, economy, or globalization. »Other« socio-cultural histories first have to be studied in their own right. Only thus can they contri- bute to a more general understanding of long-term social and cultural dynamics. In this way, they also may shed additional light on the inherent mechanisms of present-day societies. Studying medieval worlds requires a critical caveat regarding Eurocentrism. Traditio- nal world histories basically recounted how Europe unified an originally multiple world, first militarily and politically and then economically and culturally. Now, finally, a global view of history is gradually replacing Eurocentric perceptions of the past, not without con- troversial debates. The problem is not only that European history was often regarded as central to world history, but that the history of other regions was approached with a con- ceptual apparatus developed with regard to Europe. Post-colonial studies and the decons- eISSN-Nr. [applied] DOI 10.1553/medievalworlds_no1_2015s2 medieval worlds • No. 1 • 2015 • 2-4 3 Walter Pohl and Andre Gingrich truction of generalized ›European‹ concepts have been useful as an antidote, but pushing them too far creates another set of problems. Certainly Europe should not serve as a ›stan- dard‹ of comparison. However, we should not simply abandon the research tools and the critical approaches that the disciplines involved have developed and refined over a long time, but strive for a carefully balanced and transparent approach. In addressing ›medieval worlds‹ (in the plural), we wanted to stress the multiplicity of the medieval universe without essen- tializing its cultural differences. The focus of the journal is on comparative studies and reflections. The challenge here is to find ways of doing comparative history that do not depart from preconceived models or units, and thus avoid essentializing cultural or other objects of comparison. Issues of compa- rison are addressed in a growing body of methodological literature, together with a number of innovative propositions and designs: these have ranged from qualitative comparison in its basic dimensions to various forms of middle-range comparison, from ›thick‹ comparison across comparing networks and comparison by ›big data‹ quantifications up to ›comparing the incomparable‹. Both the theoretical framework and, perhaps even more importantly, pragmatic methodologies of some among the more promising of these endeavours wait to be further differentiated, refined, exemplified, and developed. The first issue of ›Medieval Worlds‹ is intended to contribute to these efforts, both from theoretical and from pragmatic angles. In
Load more

Recommended publications
  • October 2019 New Releases
    October 2019 New Releases what’s inside featured exclusives PAGE 3 RUSH Releases Vinyl Available Immediately! 82 Vinyl Audio 3 CD Audio 17 FEATURED RELEASES Music Video DVD & Blu-ray 52 SPYRO GYRA - WOODSTOCK: DINOSAUR JR. - VINYL TAP 3 DAYS THAT CHANGED WHERE YOU BEEN: Non-Music Video EVERYTHING 2CD DELUXE EXPANDED DVD & Blu-ray 57 EDITION Order Form 90 Deletions and Price Changes 93 800.888.0486 RINGU COLLECTION MY SAMURAI JIRGA 203 Windsor Rd., Pottstown, PA 19464 (COLLECTOR’S EDITION) FRED SCHNEIDER & THE SPYRO GYRA - WEDDING PRESENT - www.MVDb2b.com SUPERIONS - VINYL TAP TOMMY 30 BAT BABY MVD: RAISING HELL THIS FALL! We celebrate October with a gallery of great horror films, lifting the lid off HELLRAISER and HELLBOUND: HELLRAISER II with newly restored Blurays. The original and equally terrifying sequel are restored to their crimson glory by Arrow Video! HELLRAISER and its successor overflow with new film transfers and myriad extras that will excite any Pinhead! The Ugly American comes alive in the horror dark comedy AN AMERICAN WEREWOLF IN LONDON. Another fine reboot from Arrow Video, this deluxe pack will have you howling! Arrow also hits the RINGU with a release of this iconic Japanese-Horror film that spawned The Ring film franchise. Creepy and disturbing, RINGU concerns a cursed videotape, that once watched, will kill you in seven days! Watching this Bluray will have no such effect, but please, don’t answer the phone! TWO EVIL EYES from Blue Underground is a “double dose of terror” from two renowned directors, George A. Romero and Dario Argento.
    [Show full text]
  • Early Modern Japan
    December 1995 Early Modern Japan KarenWigen) Duke University The aims of this paperare threefold: (I) to considerwhat Westernhistorians mean when they speakof Early Modern Japan,(2) to proposethat we reconceivethis period from the perspectiveof world networks history, and (3) to lay out someof the advantagesI believe this offers for thinking aboutSengoku and Tokugawasociety. The idea that Japan had an early modern period is gradually becoming common in every sector of our field, from institutional to intellectual history. Yet what that means has rarely been discussed until now, even in the minimal sense of determining its temporal boundaries: I want to thank David Howell and James Ketelaar for raising the issue in this forum, prompting what I hope will become an ongoing conversation about our periodization practices. To my knowledge, the sole attempt in English to trace the intellectual genealogy of this concept is John Hall's introduction to the fourth volume of the Cambridge History of Japan-a volume that he chose to title Early Modern Japan. Hall dates this expression to the 1960s, when "the main concern of Western scholars of the Edo period was directed toward explaining Japan's rapid modernization." Its ascendancy was heralded by the 1968 publication of Studies in the Institutional History of Early Modern Japan, which Hall co-edited with Marius Jansen. "By declaring that the Tokugawa period should be called Japan's 'early modern' age," he reflects, "this volume challenged the common practice of assuming that Japan during the Edo period was still fundamentally feudal.") Although Hall sees the modernization paradigm as having been superseded in later decades, he nonetheless reads the continuing popularity of the early modern designation as a sign that most Western historians today see the Edo era as "more modern than feudal.',4 This notion is reiterated in even more pointed terms by Wakita Osamu in the same volume.
    [Show full text]
  • Saint Severinus of Noricum Catholic.Net
    Saint Severinus of Noricum Catholic.net Roman martyrology: He labored to evangelize the region of Noricum (part of. modem Austria), establishing a number of monasteries and gaving aid and comfort to the many refugees and victims of the invasion of the region by Attila and the Huns. He was known for his preaching and prophecies, Severinus died on January 5 and enshrined in the Benedictine monastery of San Severino. SHORT BIOGRAPHY A.D. 482. We know nothing of the birth or country of this saint. From the purity of his Latin, he was generally supposed to be a Roman; and his care to conceal what he was according to the world, was taken for a proof of his humility, and a presumption that he was a person of birth. He spent the first part of his life in the deserts of the East; but inflamed with an ardent zeal for the glory of God, he left his retreat to preach the gospel in the North. At first he came to Astures, now Stokeraw, situate above Vienna; but finding the people hardened in vice, he foretold the punishment God had prepared for them, and repaired to Comagenes, now Haynburg on the Danube, eight leagues westward of Vienna. It was not long ere his prophecy was verified; for Astures was laid waste, and the inhabitants destroyed by the sword of the Huns, soon after the death of Attila. Saint Severinus’s ancient host with great danger made his escape to him at Comagenes. By the accomplishment of this prophecy, and by several miracles he wrought, the name of the saint became famous.
    [Show full text]
  • University of Florida Thesis Or Dissertation Formatting
    HIP-HOP LIFE AND LIVELIHOOD IN NAIROBI, KENYA By JOHN ERIK TIMMONS A DISSERTATION PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2018 © 2018 John Erik Timmons To my parents, John and Kathleen Timmons, my brothers, James and Chris Timmons, and my wife, Sheila Onzere ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The completion of a PhD requires the support of many people and institutions. The intellectual community at the University of Florida offered incredible support throughout my graduate education. In particular, I wish to thank my committee members, beginning with my Chair Richard Kernaghan, whose steadfast support and incisive comments on my work is most responsible for the completion of this PhD. Luise White and Brenda Chalfin have been continuous supporters of my work since my first semester at the University of Florida. Abdoulaye Kane and Larry Crook have given me valuable insights in their seminars and as readers of my dissertation. The Department of Anthropology gave me several semesters of financial support and helped fund pre-dissertation research. The Center for African Studies similarly helped fund this research through a pre-dissertation fellowship and awarding me two years’ support the Foreign Language and Area Studies Fellowship. Another generous Summer FLAS Fellowship was awarded through Yale’s MacMillan Center Council on African Studies. My language training in Kiswahili was carried out in the classrooms of several great instructors, Rose Lugano, Ann Biersteker, and Kiarie wa Njogu. The United States Department of Education generously supported this fieldwork through a Fulbright-Hays Doctoral Dissertation Research Award.
    [Show full text]
  • (No. 13)Craccum-1982-056-013.Pdf
    ★ ★ * ALTERNATIVE M U SIC RADIO B 1404 RADIO B THE BUZZ IN CAMPUS RADIO AUCKLAND Vol 56, issue 13 ® Huntly 865423 - Taihape 865423 - Oamaru 865423 - McMurdo Sound 865423 Ex 153 Tuesday, June 22, 1982 STOP PRESS ELECTION LATEST KJ m ' Wf j P- ■ * Vs * " - > , ' • GEANNE KALL1S outside Auckland's Medical School. Her undercover investigation revealed thousands of teddy bears go to their deaths, some after being suffocated by duvets, pillows and their owners’ embraces. Regular Features A rts......................................16 ANIMAL HORROR Letters....................................4 News................................ 3, 6 HOUSE EXPLODED Unclassifieds.......................19 pii'i i".. It was Julius Caesar who Jill Carhart, of Save Animals first remarked upon our from Experiments, managed this by saying she was doing an ludicrous love of animals. LLB paper on the legal aspects He could not quite believe of using animals in medical that the Anglo Saxons experiments. This was true. But Chateau kept their rabbits, cats, the paper was never written. dogs, piranhas and Instead she gave her story to Bursary ’82 hamsters as pets rather ‘T r u th '. Miss Carhart struggled for than food. some time to get her Our pets are companions, information. ‘For two months cuddles and bedwarmers. As they gave me nothing but Sparkling such they have priority over the gradually I gained their hi-fi deck in the event of a fire. confidence and dropped the white But this worship carries its own right names.’ When her notes irony. Fido claims the best view were complete ‘none of the of the television and daily walks papers but Truth would touch slime while we exploit thousands of i t .
    [Show full text]
  • A Vida De São Severino Da Nórica: Um Texto Fundamental Para a História Do Início Do Medievo
    Revista Signum, v. 21, n. 1, 2020. A VIDA DE SÃO SEVERINO DA NÓRICA: UM TEXTO FUNDAMENTAL PARA A HISTÓRIA DO INÍCIO DO MEDIEVO THE LIFE OF SAINT SEVERINUS OF NORICA: A FUNDAMENTAL TEXT FOR THE HISTORY OF THE BEGINNING OF MEDIEVAL ERA Roberto da Silva Ribeiro Claretiano Rede de Educação [email protected] Resumo: Apresentamos a tradução parcial do Abstract: We present the partial translation of Comemoratório, mais conhecido como A Vida de the Commemoratorium, better known as The São Severino (511) escrito por Eugípio Africano Life of Saint Severinus (511) written by em que são narradas as experiências dos Eugyppius Africae in which are narrated the últimos colonos romanos a se retirarem da experiences of the last Roman settlers to leave fronteira do Danúbio depois da invasão dos the border on Danube River after the Goths godos. Por economia de espaço, não vamos invasion. Due to lack of space, we cannot publicar o texto completo, porém escolhemos publish the full text, but we have chosen the os trechos mais relevantes para o historiador, most relevant passages for the historian, omitindo passagens de natureza mais religiosa omitting passages of a more religious nature como orações e narrações de milagres avulsos. such as prayers and narrations of individual Palavras-chave: Godos; Queda do Império miracles. Romano; São Severino da Nórica. Keywords: Goths; Fall of the Roman Empire; Saint Severinus of Noricum. 1. Apresentação O Comemoratório (no original latino Commemoratorium), mais conhecido como A Vida de São Severino é um texto datado provavelmente de 5111 por Eugípio Africano pouco depois da morte do biografado, Severino de Nórica, que aconteceu em 482 no convento onde ambos professavam.
    [Show full text]
  • "Weapon of Starvation": the Politics, Propaganda, and Morality of Britain's Hunger Blockade of Germany, 1914-1919
    Wilfrid Laurier University Scholars Commons @ Laurier Theses and Dissertations (Comprehensive) 2015 A "Weapon of Starvation": The Politics, Propaganda, and Morality of Britain's Hunger Blockade of Germany, 1914-1919 Alyssa Cundy Follow this and additional works at: https://scholars.wlu.ca/etd Part of the Diplomatic History Commons, European History Commons, and the Military History Commons Recommended Citation Cundy, Alyssa, "A "Weapon of Starvation": The Politics, Propaganda, and Morality of Britain's Hunger Blockade of Germany, 1914-1919" (2015). Theses and Dissertations (Comprehensive). 1763. https://scholars.wlu.ca/etd/1763 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by Scholars Commons @ Laurier. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations (Comprehensive) by an authorized administrator of Scholars Commons @ Laurier. For more information, please contact [email protected]. A “WEAPON OF STARVATION”: THE POLITICS, PROPAGANDA, AND MORALITY OF BRITAIN’S HUNGER BLOCKADE OF GERMANY, 1914-1919 By Alyssa Nicole Cundy Bachelor of Arts (Honours), University of Western Ontario, 2007 Master of Arts, University of Western Ontario, 2008 DISSERTATION Submitted to the Department of History in partial fulfillment of the requirements for Doctor of Philosophy in History Wilfrid Laurier University 2015 Alyssa N. Cundy © 2015 Abstract This dissertation examines the British naval blockade imposed on Imperial Germany between the outbreak of war in August 1914 and the ratification of the Treaty of Versailles in July 1919. The blockade has received modest attention in the historiography of the First World War, despite the assertion in the British official history that extreme privation and hunger resulted in more than 750,000 German civilian deaths.
    [Show full text]
  • Comparative Thinking Ph.D
    Comparative Thinking Ph.D. - seminar in Sociology/Anthropology 4 credits Fall 2012 Judit Bodnar [email protected] ‘Thinking without comparison is unthinkable.’ Yet the comparative method has become something distinctive, and comparative history, politics, government, literature as well as comparative-historical sociology have been institutionalized as separate fields. The course explores these explicit comparative strategies in the social sciences and the humanities. It, however, goes beyond that and handles comparison as a cultural system. The course scrutinizes the cultural embeddedness of the logic and categories of comparison, the location of ‘universal’ social theory as well as issues pertaining to hegemony, ideology and knowledge. Globalization has produced an awareness of intertwined histories and social conditions, and a new configuration of similarity and difference that challenge social research and comparative thinking. This will receive special attention in class. Readings are of two types: (1) texts on comparative strategies and (2) examples of comparative research. The purpose of the class is to enhance your critical skills and help you develop a constructive, theoretically and practically viable approach to your dissertation research. You are required --to come to class prepared, (cca. 30% of your grade) --to prepare a few critical summaries of the readings that are to initiate discussion in class (on a rotating basis), (30% of your grade) --to devise a comparative research design based on the approaches discussed in class, preferably along the lines of your dissertation research. This is the term paper to be submitted shortly after the end of classes. (40% of the grade) Week 1 Introduction Part 1 The comparative method Week 2 Macrosocial comparisons in historical studies Charles Ragin.
    [Show full text]
  • THE ETHICAL DILEMMA of SCIENCE and OTHER WRITINGS the Rockefeller Institute Press
    THE ETHICAL DILEMMA OF SCIENCE AND OTHER WRITINGS The Rockefeller Institute Press IN ASSOCIATION WITH OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS NEW YORK 1960 @ 1960 BY THE ROCKEFELLER INSTITUTE PRESS ALL RIGHTS RESERVED BY THE ROCKEFELLER INSTITUTE PRESS IN ASSOCIATION WITH OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS Library of Congress Catalogue Card Number 60-13207 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA CONTENTS CHAPTER ONE The Ethical Dilemma of Science Living mechanism 5 The present tendencies and the future compass of physiological science 7 Experiments on frogs and men 24 Scepticism and faith 39 Science, national and international, and the basis of co-operation 45 The use and misuse of science in government 57 Science in Parliament 67 The ethical dilemma of science 72 Science and witchcraft, or, the nature of a university 90 CHAPTER TWO Trailing One's Coat Enemies of knowledge 105 The University of London Council for Psychical Investigation 118 "Hypothecate" versus "Assume" 120 Pharmacy and Medicines Bill (House of Commons) 121 The social sciences 12 5 The useful guinea-pig 127 The Pure Politician 129 Mugwumps 131 The Communists' new weapon- germ warfare 132 Independence in publication 135 ~ CONTENTS CHAPTER THREE About People Bertram Hopkinson 1 39 Hartley Lupton 142 Willem Einthoven 144 The Donnan-Hill Effect (The Mystery of Life) 148 F. W. Lamb 156 Another Englishman's "Thank you" 159 Ivan P. Pavlov 160 E. D. Adrian in the Chair of Physiology at Cambridge 165 Louis Lapicque 168 E. J. Allen 171 William Hartree 173 R. H. Fowler 179 Joseph Barcroft 180 Sir Henry Dale, the Chairman of the Science Committee of the British Council 184 August Krogh 187 Otto Meyerhof 192 Hans Sloane 195 On A.
    [Show full text]
  • The Ruin of the Roman Empire
    7888888888889 u o u o u o u THE o u Ruin o u OF THE o u Roman o u o u EMPIRE o u o u o u o u jamesj . o’donnell o u o u o u o u o u o u o hjjjjjjjjjjjk This is Ann’s book contents Preface iv Overture 1 part i s theoderic’s world 1. Rome in 500: Looking Backward 47 2. The World That Might Have Been 107 part ii s justinian’s world 3. Being Justinian 177 4. Opportunities Lost 229 5. Wars Worse Than Civil 247 part iii s gregory’s world 6. Learning to Live Again 303 7. Constantinople Deflated: The Debris of Empire 342 8. The Last Consul 364 Epilogue 385 List of Roman Emperors 395 Notes 397 Further Reading 409 Credits and Permissions 411 Index 413 About the Author Other Books by James J. O’ Donnell Credits Cover Copyright About the Publisher preface An American soldier posted in Anbar province during the twilight war over the remains of Saddam’s Mesopotamian kingdom might have been surprised to learn he was defending the westernmost frontiers of the an- cient Persian empire against raiders, smugglers, and worse coming from the eastern reaches of the ancient Roman empire. This painful recycling of history should make him—and us—want to know what unhealable wound, what recurrent pathology, what cause too deep for journalists and politicians to discern draws men and women to their deaths again and again in such a place. The history of Rome, as has often been true in the past, has much to teach us.
    [Show full text]
  • The Discourse of Herrschaft As the Practice of Herrschaft in the Fifth Century 1 Patrick J
    The Discourse of Herrschaft as the Practice of Herrschaft in the Fifth Century 1 Patrick J. Geary* This essay examines the spectrum of political action and dominance from Constantinople to the frontiers of Noricum and Gaul at the end of the fifth century by comparing the lives of Zeno the Isurian, Theoderic the Great, Severinus of Noricum and Genovefa of Paris. Keywords: Herrschaft, ethnicity, Zeno, Theoderic, Severinus, Genovefa Max Weber famously defined Herrschaft as »die Möglichkeit, den eigenen Willen dem Ver- halten anderer aufzuzwingen,« and further distinguished on the one hand »die Herrschaft kraft Interessenkonstellation,« and on the other »die Herrschaft kraft Autorität.«2 One way to compare the nature of power from the center of the late Roman Empire to its periphery in the last half of the fifth century is to take Weber’s two »ideal types« of Herrschaft as a point of departure, even if, as he recognized, boundaries between the two are fluid. They are, after all, only models, but as George Box famously observed, »essentially, all models are wrong, but some are useful.«3 Moreover, the discourses within which the practice of Herrschaft is presented and grounded is anything but transparent: tropes and genres both provide a way into understanding the exercise of power but can also obscure, for cultural reasons, this exercise. Europe in the fifth century experiences a spectrum of formal and informal modes of Herrschaft, from long-established imperial authority to ad-hoc moments of what seem to correspond to Weberian charismatic Herrschaft. Weber’s models are wrong when conside- ring Herrschaft in its myriad manifestations in the fifth century, but they are indeed useful.
    [Show full text]
  • The Uses of Comparative History in Macrosocial Inquiry THEDA SKOCPOL and MARGARET SOMERS
    The Uses of Comparative History in Macrosocial Inquiry THEDA SKOCPOL AND MARGARET SOMERS Harvard University Comparative history is not new. As long as people have investigated social life, there has been recurrent fascination with juxtaposing historical pat- terns from two or more times or places. Part of the appeal comes from the general usefulness of looking at historical trajectories in order to study social change. Indeed, practitioners of comparative history from Alexis de Tocqueville and Max Weber to Marc Bloch, Reinhard Bendix, and Bar- rington Moore, Jr. have typically been concerned with understanding societal dynamics and epochal transformations of cultures and social structures. Attention to historical sequences is indispensable to such under- standing. Obviously, though, not all investigations of social change use explicit juxtapositions of distinct histories. We may wonder, therefore: What motivates the use of comparisons as opposed to focussing on single historical trajectories? What purposes are pursued—and how—through the specific modalities of comparative history? Certain areas of scholarly endeavor in contemporary social science have given rise to methodological reflection even more sophisticated than the substantive applications of the methods in question, but this has certainly not been the case for comparative history. Despite the steady application of variants of this approach to macrosocial topics such as revolutions, re- ligious evolution, political development, economic "modernization," pat- terns of collective violence, and the rise and fall of empires, there have been remarkably few efforts to explore the methodological aspects of compara- tive history as such in any systematic fashion.' What is more, the most An earlier version of this paper was presented at the Session on "Methods of Historical Sociology" at the Annual Meeting of the American Sociological Association, Boston, Massa- chusetts, August 1979.
    [Show full text]