DOCSLIB.ORG

Download Date 28/09/2021 19:08:59

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Download Date 28/09/2021 19:08:59 Ghana: From fragility to resilience? Understanding the formation of a new political settlement from a critical political economy perspective Item Type Thesis Authors Ruppel, Julia Franziska Rights <a rel="license" href="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/ by-nc-nd/3.0/"><img alt="Creative Commons License" style="border-width:0" src="http://i.creativecommons.org/l/by- nc-nd/3.0/88x31.png" /></a><br />The University of Bradford theses are licenced under a <a rel="license" href="http:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/">Creative Commons Licence</a>. Download date 28/09/2021 19:08:59 Link to Item http://hdl.handle.net/10454/15062 University of Bradford eThesis This thesis is hosted in Bradford Scholars – The University of Bradford Open Access repository. Visit the repository for full metadata or to contact the repository team © University of Bradford. This work is licenced for reuse under a Creative Commons Licence. GHANA: FROM FRAGILITY TO RESILIENCE? J.F. RUPPEL PHD 2015 Ghana: From fragility to resilience? Understanding the formation of a new political settlement from a critical political economy perspective Julia Franziska RUPPEL Submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities University of Bradford 2015 GHANA: FROM FRAGILITY TO RESILIENCE? UNDERSTANDING THE FORMATION OF A NEW POLITICAL SETTLEMENT FROM A CRITICAL POLITICAL ECONOMY PERSPECTIVE Julia Franziska RUPPEL ABSTRACT Keywords: Critical political economy; electoral politics; Ghana; political settle- ment; power relations; social change; statebuilding and state formation During the late 1970s Ghana was described as a collapsed and failed state. In contrast, today it is hailed internationally as beacon of democracy and stability in West Africa. In light of Ghana’s drastic image change from a fragile and even collapsed polity to a resilient state, this thesis contributes to the statebuilding debate by analysing the social change that occurred. Grounded in a critical theory approach the thesis applies a political settlement analysis to explore how power is distributed and changed over time between contending social groups; exploring the extent to which this is embedded in formal and informal institutional arrangements. Ghana’s 2012 elections serve as an empirical basis and lens to observe the country’s current settlement. This approach enables a fine grained within-case comparison with Ghana’s collapsed post-independent settlement. The analysis illustrates that while there has been no transformation of the Ghanaian state, however, continuous incremental structural change has occurred within it, as demonstrated by a structurally altered constellation of power. While internationally propagated (neo-)liberal economic and political reforms had a vital impact on the reconstruction process of state-society relations, Ghana’s labelling as “success story” evokes the distorted idea of a resilient liberal state. The sustainability of Ghana’s current settlement characterised by electoral competitive clientelism depends on a continued inflow of foreign capi- tal. So far the mutually beneficial interest of portraying Ghana as a resilient state by its elites and donors ensures the flow of needed financial assistance to preserve the settlement. i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC), as well as the European Commission with its Marie Curie Pre-doctoral Fellowship programme, for their financial support. Together these awards enabled me to carry out the research for my thesis. I am deeply grateful to my supervisor, Dr David Harris, who took me on blindly as a PhD student half way through the process. Without his guidance, invalua- ble feedback and constant sympathetic ear and support, the thesis would not have been completed. Thank you so much David for being such an outstanding supervisor. I could have sincerely not been any luckier. I am also indebted to Professor Nana Poku for starting me out on my PhD. His endless patience and perpetual belief in in me as well as general idea for my project provided a solid basis for embarking my doctoral journey. Furthermore, I would like to thank Professor Arnim Langer for kindly hosting me at the Centre for Research on Peace and Development (CRPD) at the KU Leuven during parts of my research. A massive thank you as well to my former colleagues at CRPD in Leuven and and current ones at JEFCAS/Peace Studies at Bradford. The Peace Studies PhD community in Bradford is something so rare and unique existing independ- ent of, and dispite institutional quarrels. This community and its members have made the process of writing this thesis with all its accompanying challenges an experience I would have under no account wanted to have missed. In this con- text I am in particular grateful to Sarah Njeri and Pamela Nzabampema. Our endless fruitful discussions about African politics have shaped my perception and academic thinking lastingly which is reflected in this work. Moreover, your friendship and care have brought me to the longed for finishing line. A very warm thank you must go to Michele Mozley who has been the central and con- stant pillar of our PhD programme. Thank you Michele for always having been there to lean on when needed throughout this sometimes rocky journey. I also would like to thank the many Ghanaians who have hosted me in Accra and answered patiently my endless questions about Ghanaian politics and so- ii ciety: especially, Sarah, Daniel and their twins Manuella and Emanuella; Mawu- tor Alifo and Max Kolbe Domapielle. Of course I cannot thank enough my Bradford-family: Laura O’Connor, Nadia Fer- rer-Sanz and Julia Smith. Thank you for always being there for me and having shared all my ups and downs of life over the last few years. A special thanks as well to Torie Cochrane, Gwyneth Sutherlin, Manuel Amarilla Mena, Mark O’Shea, Ronak Olfati, Ulli Immler, Niall Hynes and everybody at Cecil who provided me with a lovely and supportive home over the last few years and kept me – more or less – sane throughout the writing up process. Der gröβte Dank geht an meine Familie: meine Oma, meine Tanten und Onkel im Saarland, aber vor allem an meine Eltern, denen ich diese Arbeit widme. Ihr habt mich bei jedem meiner bisherigen Abenteur, wo auch immer sie mich hingeführt haben, in jeder erdenklichen Weise unterstützt. Ohne euch wäre dies alles nicht möglich gewesen. DANKE! iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract .......................................................................................................... i Acknowledgements ........................................................................................ ii Table of Contents ........................................................................................... iv List of Figures ................................................................................................ vii List of Tables .................................................................................................. ix Abbreviations ................................................................................................. xi I. INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................... 1 II. THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK, CONTEXTUALIZATION AND METHOD- OLOGICAL APPROACH ........................................................................ 7 2.1 Theoretical framework ..................................................................... 7 2.1.1 Engaging Gramsci in the field of statebuilding .................... 7 2.1.2 Gramsci: On forms of states, power and social transformation ..................................................................... 10 2.1.3 A political settlement approach – a derivation from Gramsci’s thought ................................................................ 16 2.2 Contextualization: African states’ historical trajectories ................... 24 2.2.1 Structures and institutions .................................................. 25 2.2.2 Norms and ideas ................................................................ 28 2.2.3 Actors ................................................................................. 34 2.3 Methodological approach ................................................................. 37 2.3.1 Analysing social change in Ghana through a political settle- ment framework .................................................................. 37 2.3.2 What type of data has been used for the analysis and which techniques have been applied to gather it? ........................ 40 2.3.3 Data access and documentation of collected primary data .... 42 2.3.4 Data analysis ...................................................................... 44 2.3.5 Reasoning for applied approaches and their limitations ..... 45 2.3.6 Reflections on the process of data collection and analysis .... 47 2.4 Chapter summary ............................................................................. 49 III. GHANAIAN POLITICAL SETTLEMENTS IN HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE ... 50 3.1 Social dynamics and historical roots of elite conflict ......................... 50 3.1.1 Impact of colonialism ........................................................... 51 3.1.2 Manifestation of societal factions ......................................... 53 3.1.3 National power struggle and flaring up of regional-ethnic factions ............................................................................... 55 iv 3.2 Ghana’s post-independent settlement ............................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Communication Deficit and Monetization of Political Contests at the Electoral Commission of Ghana
    Available Online at https://journal.unismuh.ac.id/index.php/otoritas Otoritas : Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan, 9 (1), April 2019, 73-88 Communication Deficit and Monetization of Political Contests at the Electoral Commission of Ghana Shadrack Bentil1*), Edmund Poku Adu2 1Department Institute for Intercultural and International Studies – InIIS, University of Bremen, Mary-Somerville-Straße 7 D - 28359 Bremen, Germany. Department of Public Administration and Health Management Sciences, University of Ghana, P. O. Box LG 64, Legon-Accra, Ghana. Received: 13 June 2018; Revised: 4 November 2018; Accepted: 25 Desember 2018 Abstract The current state of the office of the Electoral Commission (EC) of Ghana can be couched as a bleed- ing pillar in Ghana’s electoral democracy pending crisis. In spite of the numerous reform measures undertaken by the EC to improve the quality delivery of its constitutional mandate, communication deficit and the increasing monetization of parliamentary and presidential contestation poses a seri- ous threat to broader participation and competition in Ghana's future electoral fortune. Thus, the objective of the paper was to interrogate the issues of communication inefficiencies and monetiza- tion of political contestations by the Electoral Commission of Ghana and proffer pragmatic solutions that can be taken into consideration in years ahead due to the past and recent experiences of neigh- bouring countries within the sub-region. The study employed the qualitative research methodology to elicit responses from 12 experts in the field of elections. Apart from the primary data generated from the field, secondary sources were consulted to situate the discussion in the existing debate in the literature.
    [Show full text]
  • The Regional Balance of Presidential Tickets in Ghanaian Elections: Analysis of the 2008 General Elections
    3 The Regional Balance of Presidential Tickets in Ghanaian Elections: Analysis of the 2008 General Elections Ziblim Iddi Introduction Ghana’s Fourth Republican Constitution prescribed a hybrid of the presidential and parliamentary systems of government to be practiced in a multi-party democracy. This is a clear departure from the country’s previous attempt at constitutional government in the first three republics. The country experimented with the presidential system of government in the first and third republics, and practiced the parliamentary system under the second republic. It is reported that the constitutional experts assembled by the Provisional National Defense Council (PNDC) government to produce a draft constitution for the fourth republic were guided by the lessons learned under the first three republican constitutions. For example, the requirement that the majority of ministers of state shall be appointed from among members of Parliament as prescribed by Article 78 of the 1992 constitution was recommended because of lessons learned under the third republican constitution. The president, under the third republic, failed to get his budget passed by parliament in 1981. This was largely blamed on the fact that no member of parliament was a minister of state under the 1979 constitution. The framers of the 1992 constitution, therefore, recommended hybridization to cure the mischief of members of parliament of the ruling party sabotaging the president’s agenda. Nonetheless, Ghana’s current hybrid system of government could easily pass for a presidential system (Ninsin 2008). 64 Issues in Ghana’s Electoral Politics The institutional arrangement and power dynamics between the executive and the legislature sanctioned by the 1992 constitution has inadvertently created what is gradually becoming an ‘imperial presidency’ in Ghana.
    [Show full text]
  • CODEO's Pre-Election Environment Observation Statement
    Coalition of Domestic Election Observers (CODEO) CONTACT Mr. Albert Arhin, CODEO National Coordinator +233 (0) 24 474 6791 / (0) 20 822 1068 Secretariat: +233 (0)244 350 266/ 0277 744 777 Email:[email protected]: Website: www.codeoghana.org CODEO’s Pre-election Environment Observation Statement-September Introduction STATEMENT ON THE VOTER REGISTER The Coalition of Domestic Election Observers (CODEO) is pleased to release the second of its pre-election environment observation findings covering August 31st to September 28, 2016. The findings in this report are based on bi-weekly field reports submitted by CODEO’s Long Term Observers (CODEO LTOs) deployed in 134 out of the 138 constituencies randomly selected from the 10 regions of Ghana. Guided by a checklist, CODEO’s LTOs observe the general political environment, including election-related preparatory activities by state and non-state actors, civic/voter education programs as well as political party campaign activities. The LTOs also observe the conduct of the security agencies, electoral irregularities and pre-election disputes adjudication. Summary of Findings: The Electoral Commission (EC) is undertaking key preparatory activities ahead of the elections across the constituencies. Radio continues to remain the main medium for civic/voter education in the constituencies. The National Democratic Congress (NDC) and the New Patriotic Party (NPP) continue to remain the most visible parties with regard to election campaigning activities across the constituencies under observation. Four key policy priority issues: education, unemployment, health and corruption dominated political party campaigns in the constituencies. The National Democratic Congress (NDC) leads as the party that featured women and Persons with Disability (PWDs) as the leading speakers on their campaign platform followed by the New Patriotic Party (NPP), the Convention People’s Party (CPP) and Progressive People’s Party (PPP).
    [Show full text]
  • Coalition of Domestic Election Observers (CODEO) CONTACT Mr
    Coalition of Domestic Election Observers (CODEO) CONTACT Mr. Albert Arhin, CODEO National Coordinator +233 (0) 24 474 6791 / (0) 20 822 1068 Secretariat: +233 (0)244 350 266/ 0277 744 777 Email:[email protected]: Website: www.codeoghana.org CODEO’s Pre-election Environment Observation Statement ( 15th July- 31st August, 2016) STATEMENT ON THE VOTER REGISTER Introduction The Coalition of Domestic Election Observers (CODEO) is pleased to release its findings on the pre-election environment for the period mid July to 31st August, 2016. This report is the first in the series of CODEO’s pre-election environment observations for the 2016 presidential and parliamentary elections, and captures bi-weekly reports filed by CODEO’s Long Term Observers (LTOs) deployed across the country. The findings in this report are based on bi-weekly field reports submitted in the month of July and August from 134 out of the 138 constituencies randomly selected from the 10 regions of Ghana. Guided by a checklist, CODEO’s LTOs observe the general political environment, including election-related preparatory activities by state and non-state actors, civic/voter education programs as well as political party campaign activities. The LTOs also observe the conduct of the security agencies, electoral irregularities and pre-election disputes adjudication. Summary of Findings: The National Commission on Civic Education (NCCE) and the Electoral Commission (EC) have stepped-up civic/voter education across the country using radio as the main medium for educating the public. There is low visibility of Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) working in the areas of election violence monitoring, and peace promotion activities.
    [Show full text]
  • Second CODEO Pre-Election Observation Report
    Coalition of Domestic Election Observers (CODEO) CONTACT Secretariat: +233 (0) 244 350 266/ 0277 744 777 Email: [email protected]: Website: www.codeoghana.org SECOND PRE-ELECTION ENVIRONMENT OBSERVATION STATEMENT STATEMENT ON THE VOTER REGISTER Introduction The Coalition of Domestic Election Observers (CODEO) is pleased to release its second pre- election observation report, which captures key observations of the pre-election environment during the month of October 2020, ahead of the December 7, 2020 presidential and parliamentary elections of Ghana. The report is based on weekly reports filed by 65 Long-Term Observers (LTOs) deployed across 65 selected constituencies throughout the country. The observers have been monitoring the general electoral and political environment including the activities of key election stakeholders such as the Electoral Commission (EC), the National Commission for Civic Education (NCCE), political parties, the security agencies, Civil Society Organizations (CSOs), and religious and traditional leaders. Below are key findings from CODEO’s observation during the period. Summary of Findings: • Similar to CODEO’s observations in the month of September 2020, civic and voter education activities were generally low across the various constituencies. • There continues to be generally low visibility of election support activities by CSOs, particularly those aimed at peace promotion. • COVID-19 health and safety protocols were not adhered to during some political party activities. • The National Democratic Congress (NDC) and the New Patriotic Party (NPP) remain the most visible political parties in the constituencies observed as far as political and campaign- related activities are concerned. Main Findings Preparatory Activities by the Electoral Commission Observer reports showed intensified preparatory activities by the EC towards the December 7, 2020 elections.
    [Show full text]
  • Ghana Poverty Mapping Report
    ii Copyright © 2015 Ghana Statistical Service iii PREFACE AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The Ghana Statistical Service wishes to acknowledge the contribution of the Government of Ghana, the UK Department for International Development (UK-DFID) and the World Bank through the provision of both technical and financial support towards the successful implementation of the Poverty Mapping Project using the Small Area Estimation Method. The Service also acknowledges the invaluable contributions of Dhiraj Sharma, Vasco Molini and Nobuo Yoshida (all consultants from the World Bank), Baah Wadieh, Anthony Amuzu, Sylvester Gyamfi, Abena Osei-Akoto, Jacqueline Anum, Samilia Mintah, Yaw Misefa, Appiah Kusi-Boateng, Anthony Krakah, Rosalind Quartey, Francis Bright Mensah, Omar Seidu, Ernest Enyan, Augusta Okantey and Hanna Frempong Konadu, all of the Statistical Service who worked tirelessly with the consultants to produce this report under the overall guidance and supervision of Dr. Philomena Nyarko, the Government Statistician. Dr. Philomena Nyarko Government Statistician iv TABLE OF CONTENTS PREFACE AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ............................................................................. iv LIST OF TABLES ....................................................................................................................... vi LIST OF FIGURES .................................................................................................................... vii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • AFRICA RISK CONSULTING Ghana Monthly Briefing December 2020
    AFRICA RISK CONSULTING Ghana Monthly Briefing December 2020 Ghana Summary 17 December 2020 President Nana Addo Akufo-Addo (2017-present) secures a second four-year term in a tight presidential election but without a majority in parliament and his opponent, former President John Mahama (2012-2017), refusing to concede defeat. Economists are divided in opinion on how the current uncertain political environment will impact economic activity and local and foreign investment in the country. The election was largely peaceful but marred by patches of violence during counting and collation of results, with six recorded election-related deaths. Akufo Addo wins re-election, opposition claims fraud Ghana’s Electoral Commission (EC) announced on 9 December that President Nana Akufo-Addo (2017-present) of the New Patriotic Party (NPP) had secured 51.59% of the valid votes cast in presidential polls held on 7 December, beating his opponent and predecessor, former President John Mahama (2012-2017) of the National Democratic Congress (NDC) who obtained 47.366%.1 Mahama has rejected the election results, describing them as “fraudulent”, and has vowed to take up a legal battle. ARC’s sources in Ghana say there is a tense atmosphere in the country as the nation awaits the next move by the opposition NDC – although the election was largely peaceful. The two major parties failed to gain an absolute majority in the country’s 275-seat parliament, with the NDC wiping out of the NPP’s 63-seat majority. The ECC announced on 17 December that the NDC won the remaining seat to be counted in the legislative elections, Sene West, matching the ruling party’s tally and creating a hung parliament.
    [Show full text]
  • Akufo-Addo Delivers 2Nd Annual Aliu Mahama Lecture
    SPEECH BY NANA AKUFO-ADDO, 2016 PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE OF THE NEW PATRIOTIC PARTY, AT THE 2ND ALIU MAHAMA MEMORIAL LECTURES AT THE BANQUET HALL, STATE HOUSE, ACCRA, ON 9TH DECEMBER, 2014 ON “ONE GHANA: SECURING OUR FUTURE”. It was with great pleasure, tinged with considerable sadness, that I accepted the invitation from my good friend, Kwasi Abeasi, the Chairman of the Board of Trustees of the Aliu Mahama Foundation, to be the second speaker in the series of the Foundation’s Annual Memorial Lectures. Pleasure, because, having missed last year’s inaugural lecture delivered, according to my information, with panache and verve by Mahamudu Bawumia, I would be able, today, to bear testimony to the distinguished statesman in whose honour the Foundation and these Memorial Lectures have been instituted. Shakespeare’s inimitable language, in the mouth of Mark Anthony, during his celebrated funeral oration for Julius Ceasar, captures it best: “He was my friend, faithful and just to me.” Dependable friend, faithful colleague, just leader – the attributes of Aliu Mahama. The first of his faith in our history to occupy the high office of Vice President of the Republic, his conduct in that office was a credit to all Moslems, and, indeed, to all Ghanaians. Proud Dagomba, he personified the best traits of the Ghanaian character – patriotic, responsible, tolerant. I remember the first speech he made to the gathered ranks of the NPP at our Congress in Ho in 2000, soon after his nomination as running mate to then candidate J.A. Kufuor, with whom he partnered to give the Fourth Republic its best government so far.
    [Show full text]
  • MOBA Newsletter 1 Jan-Dec 2019 1 260420 1 Bitmap.Cdr
    Ebusuapanyin Dentist Poku Goes ‘Home’ ews of the demise of Dr. Fancis Yaw Apiagyei Poku, immediate past Ebusuapanyin of MOBA Nappeared on the various MOBA Year Group WhatsApp plaorms by mid-day on Saturday 26th January 2019. For those who knew he was sick, it was not too much of a surprise. However, for the majority of 'Old Boys' the news came as a big shock! In line with Ghanaian tradion, the current Ebusuapanyin, Capt. Paul Forjoe led a delegaon to visit the family to commiserate with them. MOBA was also well represented at the one-week celebraon at his residence at Abelenkpe, Accra. To crown it, MOBA organised a Special Remembrance Service in his honour at the Calvary Methodist Church in Adabraka, Accra. A host of 'Old Boys' thronged the grounds of the Christ Church Anglican Church at the University of Ghana, Legon on Saturday 24th April 2019 for the Burial Service and more importantly to pay their last respects to the man who had done so much for Mfantsipim and MOBA. The tribute of the MOBA Class of 1955, read by Dr. Andrew Arkutu, described him as a very humble and kindhearted person who stood firmly by his principles but always exhibited a composed demeanor. ...connued on page 8 The MOBA Newsletter is Registered with the National Media Commision - ISSN 2637 - 3599 Inside this Issue... Comments 5 Editorial: ‘Old Boys’ - Let’s Up Our Game 6 From Ebusuapanyin’s Desk Cover Story 8. Dr. Poku Goes Home 9 MOBA Honours Dentist Poku From the School 10 - 13 News from the Hill MOBA Matters 15 MOBA Elections 16 - 17 Facelift Campaign Contributors 18 - 23 2019 MOBA Events th 144 Anniversary 24 - 27 Mfantsipim Celebrates 144th Anniversary 28 2019 SYGs Project - Staff Apartments Articles 30 - 31 Reading, O Reading! Were Art Thou Gone? 32 - 33 2019 Which Growth? Lifestyle Advertising Space Available 34 - 36 Journey from Anumle to Kotokuraba Advertising Space available for Reminiscences businesses, products, etc.
    [Show full text]
  • African Agenda 20.1
    ISSUE Vol. 20 No.1 2017 US$5.00 GB£3.00 €5.00 • HOW LONG WILL BARROW’S HONEYMOON LAST? Find out what's on the African Agenda To subscribe, please fill in the form and post it to the address shown ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTION RATES (INDIVIDUALS) Africa & Global South $35.00 North America & Australia $55.00 Europe €55.00 The African continent is mostly reported as a land of poverty, civil strife and end- U.K £35.00 less lines of begging hands. Problems facing the continent are portrayed and communicated mostly by foreign eyes through the monopoly-controlled news Ghana GH¢9.00 media. Rarely are Africans themselves given a forum to highlight what they see as press- INSTITUTIONAL/ CORPORATE ing problems, and offer analyses and solutions to tackle the challenges. By pub- lishing African Agenda, Third World Network Africa aims to provide exactly that Africa & Global South $45.00 forum. Open your eyes and ears to an African perspective on critical issues such as trade, the environment, gender and sustainable development. North America & Australia $70.00 I wish to subscribe to AFRICAN AGENDA and I enclose Europe €70.00 A cheque/bank draft payable to Third World Network U.K £45.00 AMOUNT ………………………............................................................................................................................................………..............................................………............................................. NAME: ...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................………..............................................………..
    [Show full text]
  • Logistics Capacity Assessment Ghana Country Name Ghana Official Name Ghana
    LCA - Ghana Version 1.05 Logistics Capacity Assessment Ghana Country Name Ghana Official Name Ghana Assessment Assessment Dates: From To 11th February 2011 Name of Assessor Izzeldin Abdalla Title & Position Logistics Officer Email contact [email protected] 1/72 LCA - Ghana Version 1.05 Table of Contents………………………………………………………………… ……………….. 1. Country Profile ......................................................................................................................... 3 1.1. Introduction & Background ................................................................................................ 3 1.2. Humanitarian Background ................................................................................................ 4 1.3. National Regulatory Departments ..................................................................................... 7 1.4. Customs Information ......................................................................................................... 8 2. Logistics Infrastructure ........................................................................................................... 13 2.1. Port Assessment............................................................................................................. 13 2.2. Airport Assessment ......................................................................................................... 25 2.3. Road Assessment ........................................................................................................... 31 2.4. Railway Assessment
    [Show full text]
  • Extra-Parliamentary Strategies and Their Effects on the Development of Good Governance in New Democracies
    THINKING OUTSIDE THE BOX: EXTRA-PARLIAMENTARY STRATEGIES AND THEIR EFFECTS ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF GOOD GOVERNANCE IN NEW DEMOCRACIES BY AMANDA E. BURKE DISSERTATION Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science in the Graduate College of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2019 Urbana, Illinois Doctoral Committee: Associate Professor Carol Skalnik Leff, Chair Professor Brian J. Gaines Associate Professor Gisela Sin Associate Professor Matthew S. Winters Abstract The literature on transitions and democratization overwhelmingly supports the idea that opposition parties should pursue tactics akin to those used in Westminster and other Western democracies, and those the choice to pursue extra-parliamentary opposition tactics is ultimately anti-democratic. In particular, there is a popular consensus that opposition participation in boycotts prevents the development of democracy. This dissertation takes a critical look at this conjecture, evaluating its plausibility in the first dedicated mixed-methods study of parliamentary and electoral boycotts as extra-parliamentary opposition tactics. I argue that the choice to condemn the use of boycotts takes too narrow a view of the utility of extra-parliamentary tactics in new democracies. I support this claim through the use of case study analysis and dynamic panel data analysis, for which I constructed, using event data, the most extensive dataset on electoral boycotts and the first dataset on legislative boycotts. My findings in both parts show that there is indeed no difference between the likelihood that a country that experiences a boycott and a country which does not will experience good or improved democratic governance, refuting the literature’s current consensus.
    [Show full text]