Multi-Layered Historicity of the Present
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Publications of the Department of Political and Economic Studies 8 (2013) Political History his book celebrates Professor Pauli Multi-layered Kettunen on his sixtieth birthday. Historicity of Multi-layered Historicity T In Pauli Kettunen’s scholarship as the Present well as in this collection, history meets of the Present social sciences in a manner that render distinctions between the two unnecessary. Approaches to social science history This book challenges simplistic views to HAGGRÉN, history as ‘a background’ or ‘development’, RAINIO-NIEMI, VAUHKONEN opening up sophisticated perspectives to (EDS.) many up-to-date debates on, for instance, nationalism and globalization or the Nordic welfare models. HEIDI HAGGRÉN, JOHANNA RAINIO-NIEMI, JUSSI VAUHKONEN (EDS.) Multi-layered Historicity of the Present Approaches to social science history Multi-layered Historicity of the Present Approaches to social science history Edited by Heidi Haggrén, Johanna Rainio-Niemi, and Jussi Vauhkonen HELSINKI 2013 Publications of the Department of Political and Economic Studies 8 (2013) Political History © Editors and Authors Cover: Riikka Hyypiä Distribution and Sales: Unigrafia Bookstore http://kirjakauppa.unigrafia.fi/ [email protected] PL 4 (Vuorikatu 3 A) 00014 Helsingin yliopisto ISSN-L 2243-3635 ISSN 2243-3635 (Print) ISSN 2243-3643 (Online) ISBN 978-952-10-8909-1 (paperback) ISBN 978-952-10-8910-7 (PDF) Unigrafia, Helsinki 2013 CONTENTS 7 List of contributors 8 Tabula gratulatoria 10 Acknowledgements 11 To Pauli! 13 Towards historical social science / The making of Pauli Kettunen’s dissertation Poliittinen liike ja sosiaalinen kollektiivisuus (1986) / SEPPO HENTILÄ 33 The Nordic and gendering dimensions of labour history in Finland / PIRJO MARKKola 47 Pauli Kettunen, history, and sociology / RISTO Alapuro 61 Raoul Palmgren and the East and West of the Finnish Left / ILKKA LIIKANEN 75 Notes on the theory of nationalism / Jussi PAKKasvirTA 93 A Nordic conceptual universe / HENRIK STENIUS 105 The Danish social reform of 1933 / Social rights as a new paradigm by an accidental reform? / Klaus PETERSEN, NIELS FINN CHRISTIANSEN AND JØRN HENRIK PETERSEN 125 The primacy of welfare politics. / Notes on the language of the Swedish Social Democrats and their adversaries in the 1930s / NILS EDLING 151 So many roads and nowhere to go. / How the Swedish Social Democrats are losing the battle about the Nordic model. / Urban LUNDBERG AND Klas ÅMARK 171 A manager and his professionals. / Planning and constructing the modern firm in Finland, 1920s–1940s / Susanna FELLMAN 189 Private entrepreneurship and the state. / Discursive power struggles during the regulated economy 1939–1949 / Kari TERÄS 215 Knowledge and skills as national capital / Industrial modernization, nationalism and the failure of Asea-Strömberg 1962–64 / JUHANA Aunesluoma 233 Work and welfare. / A comparison of Swedish and British shipbuilding industry in the context of economic downturn / STEVEN GascoiGNE AND NOEL WHITESIDE 247 The 1890–1910 crisis of Australian capitalism and the social democratic response / Was the Australian model a pioneering regime of Social Democratic Welfare Capitalist regulation? / CHRISTOPHER LloYD 271 Narratives and numbers. / Politics in the making of sickness insurance in Finland / OLLI KanGas, MIKKO NIEMELÄ AND SAMPO VARJONEN 297 Comparison, measurement, and economization. / The origin of the retirement age of 65 in Finland / MATTI HANNIKAINEN 313 Decline of civil servant privilege. / A new look at the historical development of Finnish social policy / Tapio BERGHOLM 327 Basic income and democracy / JORMA Kalela 345 Finnish central government administration views on welfare service reform / Advancing the social investment paradigm? / HELENA BlomberG-KROLL 361 Economizing the reluctant welfare state / New rationales for child care in the United States in the 21st century / SONYA MICHEL 6 LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS RisTO Alapuro, professor emeritus of sociology, University of Helsinki Juhana Aunesluoma, D.Phil., director for the University of Helsinki Network for European Studies, University of Helsinki Tapio BerGholm, PhD, senior researcher, Central Organisation of Finnish Trade Unions – SAK Helena BlomberG-Kroll, professor of social policy, Swedish School of Social Science, University of Helsinki Niels Finn ChrisTiansen, associate professor emeritus, University of Copenhagen, adjunct professor at Centre for Welfare State Research, University of Southern Denmark Nils EdlinG, PhD, senior lecturer, Stockholm University Susanna Fellman, professor of business history, University of Gothenburg STeven GascoiGne, PhD, University of Warwick Heidi HAGGRÉN, M.Soc.Sc., coordinator of the Nordic Centre of Excellence NordWel, University of Helsinki MATTI HanniKainen, D.Soc.Sc., senior research fellow, University of Tampere Seppo HenTilÄ, professor of political history, University of Helsinki Jorma Kalela, professor emeritus of political history, University of Turku Olli KanGas, research professor and head of the research department, Social Security Institution of Finland KELA ILKKA LIIKanen, professor, University of Eastern Finland ChrisTopher LloYD, emeritus professor of economic history, University of New England, Australia, guest professor, Tampere and Jyväskylä Universities Urban LundberG, PhD, researcher, Stockholm University PirJO MARKKola, professor of Finnish history, University of Jyväskylä SonYA Michel, professor of history, University of Maryland, College Park, USA MIKKO NiemelÄ, D.Soc.Sc., senior researcher, Social Security Institution of Finland KELA Jussi PAKKasvirTA, professor, head of the Department of Political and Economic Studies, University of Helsinki Klaus PETersen, professor in Welfare State History and director of Centre for Welfare State, University of Southern Denmark JØRN HenriK PETersen, professor of social policy, University of Southern Denmark. Johanna Rainio-Niemi, D.Soc.Sc., post-doctoral research fellow, University of Helsinki HenriK STenius, PhD, research director at the Centre for Nordic Studies, University of Helsinki Kari TerÄS, professor of Finnish history, University of Tampere Sampo VARJonen, M.Soc.Sc., MP’s personal assistant, Parliament of Finland Jussi VauhKonen, M.Soc.Sc., doctoral candidate in political history, University of Helsinki Noel WhiTeside, professor of comparative public policy, University of Warwick. Klas ÅMARK, professor emeritus of history, Stockholm University 7 TABULA GRATULATORIA Pertti Ahonen Markku Hyrkkänen Heikki Länsisalo Kirsi Ahonen Matti Hyvärinen Jani Marjanen Sirkka Ahonen Sakari Hänninen Pirjo Markkola Martti Ahti Kari Immonen Tuomas Martikainen Anna Alanko Marja Jalava Harri Melin Risto Alapuro Gudmundur Jønsson Sonya Michel Ari Antikainen Raija Julkunen Heikki Mikkeli Anu-Hanna Anttila Jorma Kalela Päivi Mäkelä Juhana Aunesluoma Kristiina Kalleinen Arto Nevala Otto Aura Johannes Kananen Mikko Niemelä Jaakko Autio Olli Kangas Hannu Niemi Tapio Bergholm Suvi Kansikas Jussi Nuorteva Erkki Berndtson Kari Kantasalmi Jari Ojala Helena Blomberg-Kroll Petri Karonen Sami Outinen Paolo Borioni Elina Katainen Tapani Paavonen Niklas Bruun Pirkko ja Yrjö Kaukiainen Jussi Pakkasvirta Niels Finn Christiansen Nanna Kildal Kari Palonen Christoph Conrad Ville Kivimäki Emilia Palonen Nils Edling Jussi Koivuniemi Heikki Patomäki Laura Ekholm Markku Koivusalo Saara Pellander Risto Eräsaari Juhani Koponen Matti Peltonen Susanna Fellman Jukka Kortti Pentti Peltoniemi Katja Forssén Päivi Korvajärvi Jørn Henrik Petersen Steven Gascoigne Joni Krekola Klaus Petersen Leo Granberg Christian Kroll Anna-Maija Pirttilä-Backman Norbert Götz Stein Kuhnle Tuija Pulkkinen Pertti Haapala Jussi Kurunmäki Panu Pulma Heikki Haara Hanna Kuusi Marjatta Rahikainen Per Haave Aappo Kähönen Keijo Rahkonen Heidi Haggrén Matti La Mela Johanna Rainio-Niemi Juha Hannikainen Liisa Laakso Marketta Rajavaara Matti Hannikainen Anu Lahtinen Jukka Rantala Sakari Heikkinen Jaana Laine Pirkko-Liisa Rauhala Harri M. J. Heinilä Tuija ja Esko M. Laine Kimmo Rentola Anu Heiskanen Marko Lamberg Risto Rinne Liisa Myyry ja Klaus Helkama Lars-Folke Landgren Ohto Rintala Helena Helve Tuomo Lappalainen Veli-Matti Ritakallio Seppo ja Marjaliisa Hentilä Pauliina Latvala Leena Riska-Campbell Meri E. Herrala Turo-Kimmo Lehtonen Bente Rosenbeck Marjatta Hietala Arnlaug Leira Tauno Saarela Mary Hilson Pia Letto-Vanamo Juho Saari Riitta ja Reino Hjerppe Ilkka Liikanen Hannes Saarinen Ilkka Huhta Klaus Lindgren Sakari Saaritsa Janne I. Hukkinen Chris Lloyd Kari Saastamoinen Tiina Huokuna Urban Lundberg Kirsti Salmi-Niklander Katja Huumo Åsa Lundqvist Antti Saloniemi 8 Åsmund Arup Seip Miika Tervonen Sirpa Wrede Juha Siltala Kari Teräs Marja Vuorinen Hannu Simola Pilvi Torsti Klas Åmark Anneli Anttonen ja Jorma Sipilä Erkki Tuomioja Mirja Österberg Timo Soikkanen Ilkka Turunen Ann-Catrin Östman Eija Stark Tero Vahtola Henrik Stenius Heli Valtonen Johan Strang Janne Varjo Bo Stråth Sampo Varjonen Irma Sulkunen Erkki Vasara Anu Suoranta Jussi Vauhkonen Riikka Taavetti Noel Whiteside Historian ja etnologian laitos, Jyväskylän yliopisto Kulttuurihistorian oppiaine, Turun yliopisto Politiikan ja talouden tutkimuksen laitos, Helsingin yliopisto Poliittisen historian opiskelijat ry Sosiaalipolitiikan ja sosiaalityön oppiaineet, Turun yliopisto Suomalaisen Kirjallisuuden Seura Suomen Historiallinen Seura Suomen kielen, suomalais-ugrilaisten ja pohjoismaisten kielten ja kirjallisuuksien laitos, Helsingin yliopisto Uni Rokkan Centre 9 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We gratefully acknowledge the generous