DOCSLIB.ORG

The Garden Bridge Strategic Outline Business Case

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Garden Bridge Strategic Outline Business Case The Garden Bridge Strategic Outline Business Case May 2014 Contents 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................ 8 1.1 Description ................................................................................................................. 8 1.2 Five case model .......................................................................................................... 8 2 The Strategic Case ...................................................................................................... 9 Part A: The strategic context..................................................................................................... 9 2.1 National policy context ............................................................................................... 9 2.2 Regional policy context ............................................................................................. 12 2.3 Local policy context .................................................................................................. 23 Part B: The case for change ..................................................................................................... 25 2.4 Problem: Quality of the pedestrian environment on existing bridges in central London ..................................................................................................................... 25 2.5 Problem: Poor access onto Waterloo and Blackfriars bridges from the Thames Path 29 2.6 Problem: Missing link between Waterloo and Blackfriars bridges for pedestrians ...... 30 2.7 Problem: Underground access to the South Bank area .............................................. 32 2.8 Problem: Onward distribution of passengers from Waterloo station ......................... 33 2.9 Problem: Supporting economic activity and development on the north bank............ 36 2.10 Opportunity: maximising Waterloo Opportunity Area’s development potential ....... 38 2.11 Opportunity: Provide new park space in central London ............................................ 39 2.12 Opportunity: Supporting growth in the London economy by encouraging and protecting tourism revenues ..................................................................................... 25 2.13 Opportunity: Showcasing UK expertise and innovation in engineering, design and landscape .................................................................................................................. 40 2.14 Opportunity: Supporting the UK’s internationally renowned creative sector ............. 42 2.15 Objectives ................................................................................................................. 43 2.16 Options..................................................................................................................... 45 3 The Economic Case .................................................................................................. 59 3.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 59 3.2 Assessment of benefits ............................................................................................ 59 3.3 Journey time (walk time savings) ............................................................................... 60 2 3.4 Journey quality (ambience) ........................................................................................ 62 3.5 Severance ................................................................................................................. 65 3.6 Crowding .................................................................................................................. 69 3.7 Road safety ............................................................................................................... 71 3.8 Air quality: pedestrian exposure to pollution ............................................................. 73 3.9 Physical activity ......................................................................................................... 78 3.10 Business and property impacts.................................................................................. 80 3.11 Showcasing Britain .................................................................................................... 85 3.12 Job Impacts .............................................................................................................. 88 3.13 Tourism revenue ....................................................................................................... 91 3.14 Costs ........................................................................................................................ 93 3.15 Cost : Benefit ratio (BCR) ........................................................................................... 95 3.16 Appraisal summary table ........................................................................................... 96 3.17 Scope ........................................................................................................................ 98 3.18 Main risks .................................................................................................................. 98 3.19 Constraints ............................................................................................................... 99 3.20 Dependencies ........................................................................................................... 99 3.21 Stakeholders ............................................................................................................. 99 4 The Commercial Case ............................................................................................. 101 4.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 101 4.2 Required services and contractual arrangements ..................................................... 101 4.3 Procurement strategy .............................................................................................. 101 5 The Financial Case .................................................................................................. 103 5.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 103 5.2 Scheme cost ........................................................................................................... 103 5.3 Funding ................................................................................................................... 104 5.4 Impact on TfL ......................................................................................................... 105 6 The Management Case ............................................................................................ 106 6.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 106 3 6.2 Garden Bridge Trust ................................................................................................ 106 6.3 Transport for London’s role .................................................................................... 106 6.4 Trust Directors ........................................................................................................ 107 6.5 Responsibilities of the Garden bridge Trust ............................................................. 109 6.6 Garden Bridge Trust Management Team .................................................................. 110 6.7 Project management arrangements ......................................................................... 111 6.8 Governance and project Management arrangements ............................................... 112 6.9 Project plan ............................................................................................................. 116 6.10 Use of special advisors ........................................................................................... 117 Appendix A – Journey time saving calculations ..................................................................... 119 Appendix B – HEAT tool health benefit calculations ............................................................. 121 Appendix C – business/property benefit calculations ............................................................ 123 Appendix D – tourism benefit calculations ............................................................................ 132 Appendix E – benchmarking with the High Line, New York ................................................... 134 Appendix F – Further supporting information ........................................................................ 136 4 List of tables Table 1 London Plan policies ............................................................................................... 13 Table 2 Mayor's Transport Strategy policies ......................................................................... 18 Table 3 Mayor's Transport Strategy proposals ...................................................................... 21 Table 4 Project objectives mapped against identified problems and opportunites ................ 44 Table 5 Performance of Option 1 against objectives ............................................................ 46 Table 6 Performance of Option 2 against objectives ............................................................ 49 Table 7 Performance of Option 3 against
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 1905 PC London EC4
    www.acuitus.co.uk lot 5 Barclays Bank, 18-19 Fleet Street London EC4P 4DR Rent Freehold Bank Investment • Let to Barclays Bank plc on a new • Highly prominent location in Central £94,000 20 year lease from completion until London per annum 2030 (subject to option) • Nearby occupiers include HSBC, Royal exclusive Bank of Scotland and Coutts and Co On behalf of page 14 www.acuitus.co.uk lot 5 Rent £94,000 per annum exclusive Location Description Miles: 100 metres from Royal Courts of Justice The property comprises a GROUND FLOOR BANKING HALL with 1.0 mile east of Covent Garden BASEMENT STORAGE ACCOMMODATION. In addition there are Within City of London boundary SIX SELF-CONTAINED FLATS on first to fourth floors. Rail: Temple Tube Station, Blackfriars Railway Station Tenure Air: London City Airport Freehold. Situation VAT The property is prominently situated on Fleet Street near its VAT is not applicable to this lot. junction with Chancery Lane. Nearby occupiers include HSBC, Royal Bank of Scotland and Coutts and Co. Temple Underground Station is located approximately 400 metres from the property. Tenancy and accommodation Floor Use Floor Areas (Approx) Tenant Term Rent p.a.x. Reviews Ground Banking Hall 157.0 sq m (1,691 sq ft) BARCLAYS BANK 20 years from completion on a £94,000 5 yearly (3) Offices 127.8 sq m (1,376 sq ft) PLC (1) full repairing and insuring lease (2) Basement Storage 126.0 sq m (1,356 sq ft) First-Fourth Residential (5 Flats) Office Use (1 Flat) INDIVIDUALS 125 years from 29/09/1997 and Peppercorn N 25/12/2006 (4) Total Commercial Floor Area 410.8 sq m (4,423 sq ft) (1) For the year ending 31st December 2009, Barclays Bank plc reported a turnover of £40,800,000,000, pre-tax profits of £4,585,000,000 and a total net worth of £38,482,000,000.
    [Show full text]
  • Assets of Community Value Guide (6Th Edition)
    ASSETS OF COMMUNITY VALUE GUIDE (6TH EDITION) CONTENTS 1. INTRODUCTION 5 2. CONCERNS 9 3. OPERATION OF REGIME TO DATE 17 4. QUALIFYING ASSETS 23 5. QUALIFYING CRITERIA 26 5.1 Current Actual Use 27 (a) Conditions 27 (b) Local community 27 (c) Social wellbeing/social interest 31 (d) Further social welfare or social interest 43 (e) Realistic continuation of community use 45 (f) Ancillary 48 (g) Building 54 5.2 User in the recent past 56 (a) Conditions 56 (b) Recent past 57 (c) realistic prospect 62 (I) General 62 (II) role of planning 66 (III) not financially viable 74 (IV) earlier failure to acquire by community interest group 81 (V) condition of the asset 81 (VI) Summary 83 5.3 specific points from appeals 84 1 (1) small sites 84 (2) car parks 85 (3) sites awaiting construction 86 (4) Land comprised in single title 86 (5) Use by trespassers 87 (6) use of easement 91 (7) Owner’s ECHR rights 92 (8) Part of nominated property not in use 92 (9) visual amenity 92 (10) motive 94 (11) loss arising from listing 95 (12) compensation evidence 95 (13) local clubs 96 (14) planning matters 97 (15) absence of ability to waive or modify ACV regime 98 (16) possible subsequent disposal by cig 99 6. EXCLUDED LAND 100 (a) operational land 100 (b) residences 101 (1) buildings which are or are not residences 101 (II) unlawful use as a residence 102 (III) hotels and other multiple occupation buildings 106 (IV) land connected with a residence 110 (V) mixed residential and other use 111 (c) other forms of safeguard 114 7.
    [Show full text]
  • Directions to CEP from London Airports and Train Stations
    DIRECTIONS TO NEW ACADEMIC BUILDING, LSE CLICK ON STATION/AIRPORT FOR DIRECTIONS HOLBORN TUBE STATION TEMPLE TUBE STATION LONDON KINGS CROSS – EUROSTAR LONDON PADDINGTON – HEATHROW EXPRESS LONDON VICTORIA – GATWICK EXPRESS LONDON WATERLOO HEATHROW AIRPORT GATWICK AIRPORT STANSTED AIRPORT CITY AIRPORT CENTRAL LONDON MAP For more local information please visit the following websites Transport for London (tubes, buses, trains etc): www.tfl.gov.uk For street maps of London: www.streetmap.co.uk OR www.multimap.com London School of Economics: www.lse.ac.uk Nearest Tube Stations ► From HOLBORN tube station (Central and Piccadilly Lines): Turn LEFT out of the station onto Kingsway. Keep walking for 2-5 minutes and take the 2nd turning on left onto Sardinia Street. The NAB is the 1st building on your left, entrance on Lincolns in Fields (see map on page 2) ► From TEMPLE tube station (District & Circle line) see map on page 4: Turn LEFT out of the station, walk up the steps, then cross over the pelican crossing onto Arundel Street. Walk to the top of Arundel Street, then cross straight over to the far side of Aldwych. Walk around Aldwych to your left, then turn right onto Kingsway. Take 2nd right onto Sardinia Street and the NAB is the 1st building on your left, entrance on Lincolns in Fields (see map on page 2) From St Pancras/King’s Cross – Eurostar Option1: Take Piccadilly Line to Holborn station then walk down Kingsway and turn left on to Sardinia Street (see maps on pages 2 & 4). Option 2: cross over the road onto the south side of Euston Road and take bus (numbers 59 or 91) towards Streatham Hill or Trafalgar Square respectively and dismount at Holborn Station.
    [Show full text]
  • London WC2R 3HU a 4 0 a R
    N FARRINGDON A R A 2 Whitestone Chambers E 5 D 0 2 B A 1 L 0 1 Essex Street 5 4 I O 0 A 0 2 T N 1 S 4 E S Temple 2 S O U 0 T R H E 0 T London WC2R 3HU A 4 0 A R H C N H O L O R B O L B R O N H H H I G B CHANCERY 4 T Tel: 020 7760 7611 S 0 S LANE HOLBORN N S H O R T 0 L L E T B O E O A O W K R W V N www.whitestonechambers.com R N A N A I 0 P E A N V 4 E I N A N L A G S O S F A D D T E T D B R T S L U A T E R A I L R C E E H F U T D R W N E E 4 F I N N A G S C T W 2 ' LINCOLN'S R 4 N N A L S H O R W I C H T 0 O 0 L I C INN A S T E S I N N 0 L F H N R G HALL O C E E D E T O R T L Public Transport 0 8 LINCOLN'S INN E 2 N Y D G S A 4 ' S B L A FIELDS A M F B R E L S By Underground - Temple Station or Blackfriars Station K S A W D T I L S S N I E N E Temple Station is approximately a 3 to 4 minute walk.
    [Show full text]
  • Our Mutual Friends Dickens Walk #5: Lincoln's Inn and Temple
    Our Mutual Friends Dickens Walk #5: Lincoln’s Inn and Temple This walk should ideally be taken on a weekday, during office hours; at other times the Inns of Court are closed or have limited access. Alternatives for those times are given at the end of the relevant entries below. Start: Holborn Tube Station on the Central and Piccadilly Lines. Duration: Approximately 1.5 hours • At the top of the escalators turn right to exit the station onto High Holborn. Turn right, and second right at the end of the row of shops, back on yourself, into Little Turnstile. Follow this round and turn left then right at the end, into Gate Street. This leads straight ahead into Lincoln’s Inn Fields. • Stay on the right hand side to see No. 58 Lincoln’s Inn Fields. This was Mr. Tulkinghorn’s house in Bleak House, where he was murdered. (In real life it was the home of Dickens’s friend John Forster. Dickens is said to have based Mr Podsnap in Our Mutual Friend on John Forster – in a very unflattering portrait.) Betsey Trotwood’s lodgings in London, in David Copperfield, were described as being in “a kind of private hotel at Lincoln’s Inn Fields, where there was a stone staircase, and a convenient door in the roof; my aunt being firmly persuaded that every house in London was going to be burnt down every night.” • Cross the road opposite No. 58, into the park, and go straight ahead to the far end. The Gordon rioters gathered here in 1780, as described in Barnaby Rudge: “It was about six o'clock in the evening, when a vast mob poured into Lincoln's Inn Fields by every avenue, and divided-- evidently in pursuance of a previous design--into several parties.
    [Show full text]
  • SKYFALL Screenplay by Neal Purvis, Robert Wade and John Logan
    SKYFALL Screenplay by Neal Purvis, Robert Wade and John Logan 1 INT. HOTEL CORRIDOR - DAY We’re moving down a dark corridor. Then, emerging from the darkness. Ice blue eyes. BOND cautiously moves through the tight hallway. Gun ready. We have no idea where we are. We hear distant city noises outside. He rounds a corner. At the end of hall: open door. Dead body. Bond picks up his pace. Gets to the door. Nudges it open. Aiming. INT. HOTEL ROOM - DAY Bond enters. Eyes take it in. Scene of carnage. Another dead body. Euros scattered around. Empty metal briefcase. Laptop, backed ripped off, hard drive missing. Signs of struggle. And a dying MI-6 agent on the floor. Gasping for breath. Eyes pleading up at Bond. Bond moves to him quickly, checks his pulse: BOND (on earpiece) Ronson’s down. He needs a medical evac. A voice crackles through the darkness. It’s M: M (V.O.) Where is it? Is it there? Bond looks over to the laptop. BOND Hard drive’s gone. (CONTINUED) 2 CONTINUED: M (V.O.) Are you sure? BOND It’s gone -- give me a minute. Bond works urgently to staunch the bleeding. Ronson looks up at him. Eyes desperate. M (V.O.) They must have it -- get after them. BOND I’m stabilizing Ronson. M (V.O.) We don’t have the time. BOND I have to stop the bleeding. M (V.O.) Leave him. Ronson hears this too. Their eyes meet. Bond sets Ronson down. There’s another door out. He heads toward it.
    [Show full text]
  • Garden Bridge Consultation
    GARDEN BRIDGE CONSULTATION Analysis of Responses 'JOBM Report 'FCSVary 2014 Consultation Analysis CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...................................................................................... I Overview............................................................................................... i 1 INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................... 1 2 METHODOLOGY ..................................................................................... 3 Consultation & Promotional tools ................................................................. 3 Managing responses .................................................................................. 3 Consultation Questionnaire ........................................................................ 4 Quantifying support ................................................................................. 4 Coding .................................................................................................. 5 3 CONSULTATION FINDINGS ........................................................................ 7 Introduction ........................................................................................... 7 Degree of support for the Garden Bridge ........................................................ 7 4 ANALYSIS OF OPEN RESPONSES ................................................................ 11 Q1: What do you think of the proposals for the Garden Bridge? .......................... 11 Q2: How would you change
    [Show full text]
  • Special Offers with LP 09-10
    Special Offers with the London Pass - edition 2009/10 Normal Attractions/Venues Locations/opening Times Offers with The London Pass Adult Cost* SPECIAL OFFERS AT ATTRACTIONS (free entry) All Hallows by the Tower Tower Hill. Opens daily but might be closed when a service is in session. Free souvenir guide Tate Britain (Pimlico) Daily:10.00-17.50. Closed 24,25, 26/12 Free audio guide £3.50 Tate Modern (London Bridge) Sunday-Thursday:10.00-18.00, Friday-Saturday:10.00-22.00. Closed 24, 25, 26/12 Free audio guide £2.00 London Brass Rubbing Centre Trafalgar Square: Monday-Wed:10.00-18.00, Thursday-Saturday: 10.00-21.00, Sunday: 12.00-16.00 £4.50 worth of brass rubbing or £4.50 off your brass rubbing of a greater value £4.50 National Maritime Museum Open daily: 10.00-17.00.Closed 24/26 December Free souvenir guide £3.95 National Portrait Gallery Daily:10.00-18.00, Thursday-Friday:10.00-21.00. Closed 24/26, 1/01 and Good Friday Free entry to paying exhibition or free visitor's guide £10.00 Royal Air Force Museum Daily : 10.00-18.00. Closed 24/26, 1/01, 7-11/01 Free simulator ride. 10% discount in the shop for a minimum spend of £10 Shri Swaminarayan Mandir Daily:9.00-18.00. Neasden Station on Jubilee Line Free entry to the exhibition Southwark Cathedral London Bridge Station. Opens daily:08.00-18.00 Free souvenir guidebook. 10% discount off any food purchase in the Refectory Restaurant.
    [Show full text]
  • Spring 2012 Thejservingournal Professional Journalism Since 1912 Institute Salutes a Pioneer of Investigative Journalism
    Magazine of the Chartered Institute of Journalists Spring 2012 TheJServingournal professional journalism since 1912 Institute salutes a pioneer of investigative journalism s interest surrounding the sinking of the Titanic reaches Aa crescendo point for the April centenary of the disaster, the Chartered Institute of Journalists will conduct its own ceremony of remembrance for one of the greatest journalists of all time who perished when the “unsinkable” ship sank. William Thomas Stead, one-time editor of the Pall Mall Gazette, died as he sailed to answer a personal invitation from US President William Howard Taft to speak at a congress in New York’s Carnegie Hall on world peace and international arbitration. He decided to treat himself to a £26 11s (£25.55) first class ticket on the liner’s maiden voyage. He was 62 when he died. The Institute, led by President Norman Bartlett, will lay a wreath at the Stead memorial on London’s Victoria Embankment, directly opposite the Temple tube station’s Embankment exit, at 10am on Sunday, April 15. This will be followed by a special service at St Bride’s Church, Fleet Street, at 11am. Drinks will be served afterwards. Journalists responded in their droves to a “shilling and half-crown appeal” to erect a All members of the Institute who can memorial to W T Stead, on the Victoria Embankment, opposite the Temple tube station. attend are being urged to do so because A second casting was erected in New York’s Central Park. The inscription reads: “W. T. not only is this “our” event but the Stead, 1849 – 1912.
    [Show full text]
  • SOTA 12 6Pp Prog and Form 10/9/12 15:51 Page 3
    SOTA 12 6pp Prog and Form 10/9/12 15:51 Page 3 Free Conference for SOTA Members Surgical Oncology Trainee Association (SOTA) Conference 2012 18th November 2012 at The Royal College of Surgeons of England Programme and Registration form www.baso.org.uk/sota.aspx SOTA 12 6pp Prog and Form 10/9/12 15:51 Page 4 SOTA Conference 2012 - The Royal College of Surgeons, London Conference Programme Sunday 18th November 2012 at The Royal College of Surgeons of England 14:00 to 14:30 Registration with coffee Committee Room 3 14:30 to 14:35 Welcome from the President of BASO ~ ACS Mr Mike Hallissey Lecture 14:35 to 15:15 Radiation Therapy – why and how? Theatre 2 Dr Peter Jenkins 15:15 to 16:00 An introduction to cytotoxic chemotherapy Dr Jeremy Braybrooke 16:00 to 16:30 Break – tea and coffee Committee Room 3 16:30 to 17:15 Medico-legal aspects of cancer surgery Mr David Rew 17:15 to 17:40 Surgical Oncology training in Europe Lecture Prof Peter Naredi, President of ESSO Theatre 2 17:40 to 18:00 SOTA Annual General Meeting 18:00 Close Time - TBC Dinner for SOTA members venue to be confirmed SOTA SOTA 12 6pp Prog and Form 10/9/12 15:51 Page 5 SOTA Conference 2012 - The Royal College of Surgeons, London TERMS and CONDITIONS HOW TO GET TO THE VENUE LOCAL TUBE STATIONS Cancellations Holborn: (Piccadilly Line) AND (Central Line) If you are unable to attend the conference inform the Temple: (District Line) AND (Circle Line) conference organisers as soon as possible.
    [Show full text]
  • Has Eros Assentior In, Minimum Aliquando Definitiones Ei
    Planning and Environmental News from CPRE London Havering council has resolved to grant outline planning permission for a residential-led redevelopment of St George’s Hospital, Hornchurch. A previous scheme for the 29-acre brownfield site was rejected due to impact on the openness of the green belt. City Hall agreed that the new 279-home scheme would not affect the green belt. The scheme includes increased open space and a reduction in the footprint of buildings of 24% compared to current use. City planners said that proposed 15% affordable housing was too low and asked to examine the viability assessment before the mayor makes a decision on the scheme . Green Belt Developments Clark to decide. Sadiq Khan has refused plans for a football stadium for Cray Wanderers Football Club at Chislehurst, Bromley . The plans for Flamingo Park included community sports pitches and two four- storey residential blocks of 28 flats with the green belt and a conservation area . Mr Kahn said the plans would cause significant harm to an area of much needed open green space and failed to provide affordable housing: I am determined to oppose building on the green belt, which is now even more important than when it was created. Working with my planning team, I will Plans for St George’s Hospital continue to use my full range of planning powers to Redbridge council approved its draft local further strengthen protections for open and green development plan at a heated full council meeting. The spaces in the London Plan and ensure we are making plan outlines ambitions for 16,845 new dwellings in the the most of brownfield sites across the city, including period 2015 to 2030.
    [Show full text]
  • Supplementary Materials For
    Supplementary Materials for A vulnerability-based approach to human-mobility reduction for countering COVID-19 transmission in London while considering local air quality Manu Sasidharan, Ajit Singh, Mehran Eskandari Torbaghan, Ajith Kumar Parlikad Correspondence to: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] This PDF file includes: Materials and Methods Figs. S1 to S2 Tables S1 Materials and Methods The currently available data (as of 31 March 2020) on COVID-19 morbidity and mortality for different NHS Hospital Trusts in London were utilized in this study [23,18]. The Office of National Statistics (A Baker, personal communication, 2020) confirmed that they are unable to provide COVID-19 related fatality data categorized by each London borough or local authority. To this end, the deaths reported by individual NHS Hospital Trusts in London were employed to inform the reported deaths for each London borough. The fatality rate across each London borough was estimated by dividing the number of reported deaths by the number of reported positive COVID-19 cases. Due to the unavailability of data, this study does not include the number of people who are self-isolating due to COVID-19 within the analysis. The air pollution data associated with particulate matter (PM2.5) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2) for each London borough was collected from [24]. An ecologic analysis was conducted to explore the correlation between short-term air pollution (PM2.5 and NO2 levels) and COVID-19 cases and fatality rate in each London borough. To this end, a linear regression model was fitted to the data for regions with more than 100 reported cases and 10 COVID-19 related deaths.
    [Show full text]