Georgian Art in the Context of European and Asian Cultures JUNE 21-29, 2008, GEORGIA
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
VAKHTANG BERIDZE 1st INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM OF GEORGIAN CULTURE Georgian Art in the Context of European and Asian Cultures JUNE 21-29, 2008, GEORGIA PROCEEDINGS TBILISI 2009 UDC(uak)7(479.22)+008.1(479.22:100) q-279 PUBLISHED BY: GEORGIAN ARTS & CULTURE CENTER through INTERNATIONAL INITIATIVE FOR GEORGIAN CULTURAL STUDIES 7, N.Nikoldaze str., Tbilisi, 0108, Georgia e-mail: [email protected] www.gaccgeorgia.org PROJECT LEADER Maka Dvalishvili Georgian Arts & Culture Center EDITORS: Peter Skinner Dimiti Tumanishvili G. Chubunashvili National Center of Georgian Art History and Monuments Protection, Tbilisi State Academy of Arts Anna Shanshiashvili Georgian Arts & Culture Center CATALOGUE COORDINATION: Anna Shanshiashvili Georgian Arts & Culture Center DESIGN AND TYPESETTING: Gega Paksashvili Photography on the cover: David Garedji Monastery. Bertubani 13th c Printed in: PETITE Ltd ISBN 978-9941-0-2005-6 ISSN 1987-829X © Georgian Arts & Culture Center 2009 © Authors 2009 Vakhtang Beridze The Proceedings of the International Symposium “Georgian Art in the Context of European and Asian Cultures” are dedicated with great respect to the memory of Vakhtang Beridze, one of the most distinguished Georgian scholars, Director of the Giorgi Chubinashvili Institute of Georgian Art History, and founder and organizer of the International Symposiums on Georgian Art, 1974 to 1989. Contents PREFACE Maka Dvalishvili. Project Leader. GACC International Initiative for Georgian Cultural Studies. President, Georgian Arts and Culture Center ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------6 Nikoloz Vacheishvili. Director General. National Agency for Cultural Heritage Preservation of Georgia -------------7 SYMPOSIUM BODIES --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------8 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------9 FOREWORD Dimitri Tumanishvili. Chairmen of Symposium Scientific Council. G. Chubinashvili National Center of Georgian Art History and Monuments Protection ---------------------------------10 Teimuraz Sakvarelidze. G. Chubinashvili National Center of Georgian Art History and Monuments Protection -----11 ANCIENT GEORGIA Nino Shanshashvili, George Narimanishvili. Cultural Interactions of Mesopotamia and the South Caucasus in the Early Bronze Age -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------13 Karen Rubinson. Revisiting the Silver Vessels from Trialeti -----------------------------------------------------------------18 Ana Kldiashvili. Semantics of Images and Model of the Universe in Pre-Christian Georgian Culture (On Kvatskheli Diadem Example) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------21 Goderdzi Narimanishvili, Kakha Khimshiashvili. The Bronze Age Settlements from Trialeti -----------------------28 Ketevan Ramishvili. Images of Horses in Ancient Georgia -------------------------------------------------------------------------33 Nino Gomelauri. Georgia and Eurasia in the 2nd and 1st Millennia, B.C.– Evidence of Bronze Plastics ------------39 Manana Tsereteli. Colchian Ritual Axe ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------45 Ori Z. Soltes. Defining “Georgianness” in Antiquity: Artifacts and Concepts --------------------------------------------51 Tamaz Sanikidze. General Aspects of the History and Architecture of Uplistsikhe -------------------------------------58 Mariam Gvelesiani. Toward Interpretation of the Anthropomorphic Figure from Katlanikhevi ----------------------64 Teimuraz Bibiluri. The Apollo Temple in Didi Mtskheta. “Apollo-Sun” (Sulkhan-Saba Orbeliani, “Sitkvis Kona”) ------71 Michael Vickers, Amiran Kakhidze. Trade and Economic Relations between Athens and Colchis in the Classical Period: The Evidence from the Joint British-Georgian Archaeological Expedition to Pichvnari --------------76 Nino Dzneladze. Athenian Painted Pottery from Pichvnari ----------------------------------------------------------------80 Tamar Shalikadze, Tariel Ebralidze. Gonio-Apsaros: Trade, Economic and Cultural Relations with the Western Mediterranean Coast -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------84 Irine Varshalomidze. Roman Period Coins from Gonio-Apsaros ----------------------------------------------------------86 Shota Mamuladze, Emzar Kakhidze. Apsarus: The Roman Acculturation Center in the Eastern Black Sea Area -------89 MEDIEVAL GEORGIA Christopher Haas. Ioane Zedazneli: A Georgian Saint in the Syrian Ascetical Tradition --------------------------------95 Alexei Lidov. Eastern Christian ‘Image-Paradigms’: A Hierotopic Dimension of Medieval Art History ---------------101 Ekaterine Gedevanishvili, Marine Kenia. On the Interrelation of the Word and Image in Medieval Georgian Mural Painting ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------108 Ori Z. Soltes. Rustaveli as Epic and Lyric Poet and His Diverse Illuminators and Illustrators ------------------------114 Mariam Didebulidze. Secular Trends in the Georgian Culture from the Period of Queen Tamar and the Contemporary Wall Painting -------------------------------------------------------------------------121 Aleksandra Davidov Temerinski. Eschatology, Ideology, Contextualisation: The Last Judgement in Timotesubani, Akhtala and Dečani -----------------------------------------------------------------127 Ida Sinkević. Freso Icons in Monumental Art of Georgia and Byzantium: Meaning and Significance ---------------135 Irine Mamaiashvili. Post-Byzantine Tendencies in 16th-Century Georgian Mural Painting --------------------------140 Beatrice Tolidjian. Inspirations from Georgia?: Observations on the External Wall Decoration of two Pakourianos Monastic Foundations in the Bachkovo-Asenovgrad Region of Bulgaria ----------------------------145 Tamar Khundadze. Images of Historical Persons in Georgian Architectural Sculpture of the Middle Ages (6th through 11th century) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------152 Ekaterine Kvatchatadze. Main Trends in the Early Medieval Georgian Façade Sculpture of the 12th-18th Centuries -----159 Peter Grossmann. Roman and Late Roman Elements in the Early Christian Architecture in Egypt in Comparison with the Case of Georgia -------------------------------------------------------------------------------164 John Wilkinson. Where Did Georgia’s Churches Start? ---------------------------------------------------------------------170 Irene Giviashvili. Georgian Polyapsidal Church Architecture --------------------------------------------------------------173 Bruno Baumgartner. Unknown and less Known Georgian Monuments in Northeast Turkey ------------------------183 Markus Bogisch. Some Remarks on Georgian art History and the Cross-in-square Church at Oshki in the Historic Province of Tao in North-eastern Turkey --------------------------------------------------------------188 Nato Gengiuri. Georgian Churches Porches: Early Christian Period to High Middle Ages -----------------------------196 Irma Berdzenishvili. The Ecclesiastical Architecture of Abkhazia in The Early Middle Ages --------------------------201 Edith Neubauer. Georgian Medieval Architecture and Sculpture and the Central European Romanesque Period ---------205 Veronica Kalas, Yavuz Özkaya. The Georgian Aspects of Medieval Architecture at Ani in the Thirteenth Century: The Church of Tigran Honents and the Mosque of Minuchir -----------------------------------211 Rozmeri Basic. Georgia and Croatia: A Case of Common Source ---------------------------------------------------------217 Contents Leila Khuskivadze. An Ornament in Medieval Georgian Repoussé Art -------------------------------------------------222 Maria Lidova. Creating a Liturgical Space: the Sinai Complex of Icons by Ioannes Tohabi ---------------------------226 Nina Burtchuladze. Georgian Icons at St. Catherine’s Monastery on Mount Sinai (On Georgian-Byzantine cultural interrelations) --------------------------------------------------------------234 Alexander Saminsky. The Miniatures and Origin of the Berta Gospels -------------------------------------------------241 Lali Osepashvili. Characteristics of the Artistic Decoration of Georgian Liturgical Scrolls, (12th to 16th centuries) --------248 POSTERS George Gagoshidze. Georgian Monastery in Gialia (Cyprus) -------------------------------------------------------------254 George Patashuri. Reconstruction of the 11th-Century Exterior Decoration System of Svetitskhoveli Cathedral in Mtskheta ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------256 Dea Gunia. Sapara: The Church of the Assumption of The Virgin Mary. The Arrangement of the Inner Space as a Means of Determining Construction Dates ----------------------------------------------------------258 Eter Edisherashvili. Façade Sculpture of Nadarbazevi “Triple-church Basilica” (Reconstruction of the program) ---------260 Eka Berelashvili. The Mitre of Archbishop Mitrophan ----------------------------------------------------------------------263 Elene Kavlelashvili. The Wall Paintings of Mkheri Church, Svaneti ------------------------------------------------------265 Vera Shanidze. The 16th - 18th Centuries Secular Architecture in the Georgia Influence of Persian Stylistic or Georgian Authenticity?