DOCSLIB.ORG

The Politics of Sectarianism in Iraq Omar Aziz

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Politics of Sectarianism in Iraq Omar Aziz Militia and Insurgency Violence: The Politics of Sectarianism in Iraq Omar Aziz 260212841 Institute of Islamic Studies McGill University Montreal, Quebec, Canada August 2018 A thesis submitted to McGill University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts © Omar Aziz Table of Contents Abstract .......................................................................................................................................... iv Acknowledgements ......................................................................................................................... v Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 1 Research Puzzle .......................................................................................................................... 1 Relevance of the Study: Transcending the Sunni-Shiite Dichotomy .......................................... 1 The Outline ................................................................................................................................. 3 Chapter 1 ......................................................................................................................................... 5 The Literature.............................................................................................................................. 5 The Iraqi Context Briefly ........................................................................................................ 5 Why do people rebel? ............................................................................................................. 6 The Causes of Sectarian Conflict .......................................................................................... 12 Peacebuilding in post conflict fragile societies ..................................................................... 16 What is violence and why do people use it? ......................................................................... 18 The Dominant Theory on Insurgency and Counterinsurgency Objectives and Tactics ....... 18 Methodology and its Weakness ................................................................................................ 27 The Methodology .................................................................................................................. 27 The Problem with the Methodology ..................................................................................... 29 Chapter 2 ....................................................................................................................................... 31 The Objectives of ISIS, PMF, and JRTN ................................................................................. 31 ISIS’ Objective...................................................................................................................... 31 PMF’s Objective ................................................................................................................... 32 JRTN’s Objective.................................................................................................................. 34 Where do the PMF, ISIS and JRTN operate and why is it important? ................................. 35 Analysis..................................................................................................................................... 36 Violence against civilians ..................................................................................................... 36 Remote Violence ................................................................................................................... 43 Battles which lead to gaining of territory ............................................................................. 47 Strategic Developments ........................................................................................................ 48 Headquarters or base established .......................................................................................... 50 Battles no change of territory ................................................................................................ 50 Non-violent transfer of territory ............................................................................................ 52 ii JRTN ..................................................................................................................................... 52 A note on the data ................................................................................................................. 53 A note of the appendices ....................................................................................................... 53 Chapter 3 ....................................................................................................................................... 54 Political Developments that Challenge the Sectarian Explanation of the Conflict .................. 54 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................... 60 Bibliography ................................................................................................................................. 63 Appendix A ................................................................................................................................... 83 Empirical findings of violence perpetrated ISIS ....................................................................... 83 Violence against civilians ..................................................................................................... 83 Remote Violence ................................................................................................................... 85 Battle ISIS overtakes territory .............................................................................................. 88 Headquarters or base established .......................................................................................... 88 Strategic Development .......................................................................................................... 89 Battle no change of territory ................................................................................................. 95 Non-Violent Transfer of Territory ........................................................................................ 98 Appendix B ................................................................................................................................... 99 Empirical findings of violence utilized by the PMF ................................................................. 99 Violence against Civilians .................................................................................................... 99 Remote Violence ................................................................................................................. 100 Battle PMF overtakes territory............................................................................................ 101 Headquarters or base established: ....................................................................................... 107 Strategic Developments ...................................................................................................... 108 Battle no change of territory ............................................................................................... 111 Non-Violent Transfer of Territory ...................................................................................... 113 Appendix C ................................................................................................................................. 116 The data on the violence by JRTN .......................................................................................... 116 iii Abstract The central research question this thesis addresses is the following: In cases where the state is weak, to what extent do sectarian identities explain the diverging and often converging objectives and strategies of various sectarian militant groups vying for political power and territorial control? In order to answer this question, this study focuses on the case of contemporary Iraq. The main argument of this thesis is that sectarian identities alone play little role in defining and determining the political objectives and military strategies pursued by various sectarian affiliated groups. I argue instead that it is the motivation of greed, which largely influences the behavior of many of the main actors in the Iraq conflict. However, I also argue throughout this study that while greed is a key motivation of the leaders of militant organizations, the rank and file members are largely driven by political, economic and social grievances. Consequently, as I demonstrate in this study sectarian politics is an outcome rather than the primary cause of the dynamics of violence in Iraq. More specifically, it is the presence of a state that is weak in political legitimacy as well as bureaucratic and military strength which has resulted in the politicization of sectarian identities in ways that have exacerbated forms of violence in the country.1 As such this thesis concludes that the ongoing conflict in Iraq is primarily a political struggle rather than a conflict over sectarian identity and culture and, moreover, differences in sectarian affiliation is not the most salient variable that explains
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Basra: Strategic Dilemmas and Force Options
    CASE STUDY NO. 8 COMPLEX OPERATIONS CASE STUDIES SERIES Basra: Strategic Dilemmas and Force Options John Hodgson The Pennsylvania State University KAREN GUTTIERI SERIES EDITOR Naval Postgraduate School COMPLEX OPERATIONS CASE STUDIES SERIES Complex operations encompass stability, security, transition and recon- struction, and counterinsurgency operations and operations consisting of irregular warfare (United States Public Law No 417, 2008). Stability opera- tions frameworks engage many disciplines to achieve their goals, including establishment of safe and secure environments, the rule of law, social well- being, stable governance, and sustainable economy. A comprehensive approach to complex operations involves many elements—governmental and nongovernmental, public and private—of the international community or a “whole of community” effort, as well as engagement by many different components of government agencies, or a “whole of government” approach. Taking note of these requirements, a number of studies called for incentives to grow the field of capable scholars and practitioners, and the development of resources for educators, students and practitioners. A 2008 United States Institute of Peace study titled “Sharing the Space” specifically noted the need for case studies and lessons. Gabriel Marcella and Stephen Fought argued for a case-based approach to teaching complex operations in the pages of Joint Forces Quarterly, noting “Case studies force students into the problem; they put a face on history and bring life to theory.” We developed
    [Show full text]
  • Security Council Issue: the Situation Regarding the Islamic State of Iraq
    Forum: Security Council Issue: The Situation Regarding the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria Student Officer: Ekaterina Kusaiko Introduction & Main Ideas The Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS), also known as the Islamic State of Iraq and Levant (ISIL) or the Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham, is a Salafi jihadist militant group that follows an Islamic fundamentalist, Wahhabi doctrine of Sunni Islam. The group has referred to itself as the Islamic State (IS) since it proclaimed a worldwide caliphate in June 2014 and named Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi as its caliph. As a caliphate, it claims religious, political, and military authority over all Muslims worldwide. As of December 2015, the group has control over vast landlocked territory in Iraq and Syria, with a population estimate ranging between 2.8 million and 8 million people and where it enforces its interpretation of sharia law. ISIL affiliates control over the small areas of Libya, Nigeria, and Afghanistan and operates in other parts of the world, including North Africa and South Asia. ISIL gained prominence, when in early 2014 it drove Iraqi government forces out of key cities in its Western Iraq offensive, followed by the capture of Mosul and the Sinjar massacre, almost causing a collapse of the Iraqi government and prompting a renewal of US military action in Iraq. In Syria, the group has conducted ground attacks on both government forces and rebel factions. The number of fighters the group commands in Iraq and Syria was estimated by the CIA at 31,000, with foreign fighters accounting for around two thirds, while ISIL leaders claim 40,000 fighters, with the majority being Iraqi and Syrian nationals.
    [Show full text]
  • Report on the Protection of Civilians in the Armed Conflict in Iraq
    HUMAN RIGHTS UNAMI Office of the United Nations United Nations Assistance Mission High Commissioner for for Iraq – Human Rights Office Human Rights Report on the Protection of Civilians in the Armed Conflict in Iraq: 11 December 2014 – 30 April 2015 “The United Nations has serious concerns about the thousands of civilians, including women and children, who remain captive by ISIL or remain in areas under the control of ISIL or where armed conflict is taking place. I am particularly concerned about the toll that acts of terrorism continue to take on ordinary Iraqi people. Iraq, and the international community must do more to ensure that the victims of these violations are given appropriate care and protection - and that any individual who has perpetrated crimes or violations is held accountable according to law.” − Mr. Ján Kubiš Special Representative of the United Nations Secretary-General in Iraq, 12 June 2015, Baghdad “Civilians continue to be the primary victims of the ongoing armed conflict in Iraq - and are being subjected to human rights violations and abuses on a daily basis, particularly at the hands of the so-called Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant. Ensuring accountability for these crimes and violations will be paramount if the Government is to ensure justice for the victims and is to restore trust between communities. It is also important to send a clear message that crimes such as these will not go unpunished’’ - Mr. Zeid Ra'ad Al Hussein United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, 12 June 2015, Geneva Contents Summary ...................................................................................................................................... i Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 1 Methodology ..............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Wash Needs in Schools Iraq
    COMPARATIVE OVERVIEW WASH NEEDS IN SCHOOLS OF KEY INDICATORS Note: Findings derived from WFP data are December 2019 IRAQ presented in turquoise boxes. Methodology Water Hygiene Sanitation 1 3 2 REACH Number of HH surveys conducted by Number of schools assessed by WFP Drinking water from a water source is available Drinking water from a water source is available Drinking water comes from an improved water source The water quality is perceived to be acceptable The main water source is at the school's premises Has access to handwashing facilities Has access to handwashing facilities of which is having water and soap available of which is functional of which is having soap Has access to improved sanitation facilities number of Average functional student toilets per school building number of toilets Average for students number of Average students per toilet Has access to student toilets separated by gender Has access to student toilets separated by gender Has unusable toilets Is having a good structural condition of student toilets Is having a good hygienic condition of student toilets Al-Falluja 115 88% 100% 78% 93% 100% 97% 100% 9,1 82% 0% Al-Ramadi 80 83% 98% 81% 98% 100% 100% 100% 8,6 93% 0% Al-Anbar Ana 74 31 44% 65% 87% 49% 72% 94% 94% 64% 66% 62% 94% 5,8 5,4 36 90% 90% 23% 100% 71% Heet 87 72% 100% 60% 100% 93% 97% 100% 9,0 88% 0% Shat Al-Arab 98 12% 92% 83% 11% 7,2 91 77% 56% 46% Al-Basrah Al-Khidhir 70 50% 66% 76% 11% 5,8 69 79% 74% 32% Al-Muthanna Al-Kufa 120 21% 46% 71% 99% 100% 23% 99% 6.5 71% 27% Al-Najaf Al-Najaf 94 2% 95% 98%
    [Show full text]
  • Kirkuk and Its Arabization: Historical Background and Ongoing Issues In
    Abstract The Arabization of the Kurdistan region in Iraq Since the establishment of the Iraqi state, the ruling Arab regimes forcibly displaced native Kurds and repopulated the area with Arab tribes. The change of demography,known as “Arabization,” existed in both Kurdish majority agriculture and urban lands. These policies were part of a larger Iraqi campaign to erase the Kurdish identity, occupy Kurdistan, and control its wealth. The Iraqi government’s campaign against the Kurds amounted to genocide and eventually destroyed Kurdish communities and the social fabric of Kurdistan. The areas affected by the Arabization stretch from eastern to northwestern Iraq , incorporating major cities,towns, and hundreds of villages. After the fall of Saddam Hussien’s dictatorship, these areas became referred to as “Disputed Territories'' in Iraq’s newly adopted constitution of 2005. Article 140 of Iraq’s constitution called for the normalization of the “Disputed Territories,” which was never implemented by the federal government of Iraq. 1 www.dckurd.org Kirkuk province, Khanagin city of Diyala province, Tuz Khurmatu District of Saladin Province, and Shingal (Sinjar) in Nineveh province are the main areas that continue to suffer from Arabization policies implemented in 1975. KIRKUK A key feature of Kirkuk is its diversity – Kurds, Arabs, Turkmens, Shiites, Sunnis, and Christians (Chaldeans and Assyrians) all co-exist in Kirkuk, and the province is even home to a small Armenian Christian population. GEOGRAPHY The province of Kirkuk has a population of more than 1.4 million, the overwhelming majority of whom live in Kirkuk city. Kirkuk city is 160 miles north of Baghdad and just 60 miles from Erbil, the capital of the Iraqi Kurdistan region.
    [Show full text]
  • The Tragedy of the Yezidis in Sinǧār Reflected in Four Iraqi Novels
    ROCZNIK ORIENTALISTYCZNY, T. LXXII, Z. 1, 2019, (s. 153–183) DOI 10.24425/ro.2019.129444 ADRIANNA MAŚKO (Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznań, Poland) Creating a Site of Memory: the Tragedy of the Yezidis in Sinǧār Reflected in Four Iraqi Novels Abstract In her reflections on cultural memory, which “is based on communication through media,” Astrid Erll uses the term “remediation” in order to “refer to the fact that memorable events are usually represented again and again, over decades and centuries, in different media: in newspaper articles, photography, diaries, historiography, novels, films, etc.” Some of these events may even become sites of memory. In my article, in relation to cultural memory studies, I contemplate the genocide of the Yezidis in the Sinǧār district, which was committed by ISIS militants in August 2014 and in the following months, as reflected in four Iraqi novels written in the Arabic language. They are: Raqṣat al-ǧadīla wa-an-nahr (“The Dance of the Braid and the River”, 2015) by Wafā’ ‘Abd ar-Razzāq, ‘Aḏrā’ Sinǧār (“Sinǧār’s Virgin”, 2016) by Wārid Badr as-Sālim, Šamdīn (“Šamdīn”, 2016) by Rāsim Qāsim, and Šaẓāyā Fayrūz (“The Shattered Fragments of Fayrūz”, 2017) by Nawzat Šamdīn. By analysing the ways in which these writers depict ISIS persecution of the Yezidis, I aim to answer, among others, the following questions: What are their reasons for a literary documentation of these events? Is the iconic image of the genocide which emerges in the four novels similar to that outlined in the West media coverage? Therefore, the first part of the article concentrates on attitudes of the above-mentioned Iraqi writers to the Sinǧār tragedy.
    [Show full text]
  • Return Dynamics in Ninewa Governorate Return Dynamics in Ninewa Governorate May 2021
    RETURNRETURN INDEX GOVERNORATE GOVERNORATE PROFILING: PROFILING RETURN DYNAMICS IN NINEWA GOVERNORATE RETURN DYNAMICS IN NINEWA GOVERNORATE MAY 2021 The Return Index is a tool designed to measure the severity of presents the overview of conditions across the governorate at the conditions in locations of return. The Return Index is based on 16 end of 2020 with a comparison of figures and the severity of living indicators divided into two scales: Scale 1, on livelihoods and basic conditions over the course of 2020 (from 31 December 2019 to 31 services, and Scale 2, centered around social cohesion and safety December 2020). This section also outlines the areas of no return perceptions. A regression model is used to assess the impact of each recorded by the IOM’s Rapid Assessment and Response Teams of the indicators in facilitating or preventing returns. The index ranges (RARTs) and newly assessed locations, the returnee population from 0 (all essential conditions for return are met) to 100 (no essen- living in critical shelters and the displaced population hosted in the tial conditions for return are met). Higher scores denote more severe governorate. The second section devoted to the mass arrivals from living conditions for returnees. The scores of the severity index are camps due to its closures which began in mid-October pointing out grouped into three categories: low, medium and high (which also the living conditions of new arrivals either they returned to villages includes very high). Refer to the report “Methodological Overview” and neighbourhoods of their origin or arrived in new displacement for more details on the methodology.
    [Show full text]
  • Weekly Explosive Incidents Flash News
    iMMAP - Humanitarian Access Response Weekly Explosive Hazard Incidents Flash News (26 Nov - 02 Dec 2020) 109 23 26 10 2 INCIDENTS PEOPLE KILLED PEOPLE INJURED EXPLOSIONS AIRSTRIKES BAGHDAD GOVERNORATE KIRKUK GOVERNORATE An Armed Group 26/NOV/2020 Popular Mobilization Forces 26/NOV/2020 Shot and injured a government employee in Taiji sub-district of Kadhimiya district. Repelled an ISIS attack in Al-Nakar area of Dibs district. An Armed Group 26/NOV/2020 An Armed Group 26/NOV/2020 Detonated an IED targeting a liquor store in Karada district. Detonated an IED targeting a military vehicle and injured four soldiers near Ali Saray Security Forces 26/NOV/2020 village of Daquq district. Found and cleared a cache of explosives containing 700kg of C4, west of the capital. Popular Mobilization Forces 28/NOV/2020 Security Forces 29/NOV/2020 Repelled an ISIS attack in Ataira village of Zab subdistrict. Found the corpse of a civilian showing a gunshot wound in Umm Al-Kabir area, east of the An Armed Group 30/NOV/2020 capital. Killed a major of the Federal Police Forces by detonating an IED striking their patrol An Armed Group 30/NOV/2020 vehicle in Hawija district. Detonated an IED targeting a liquor store in the Baghdad Al-Jdida area. Security Forces 02/DEC/2020 Security Forces 30/NOV/2020 Repelled an ISIS attack in Riyadh sub-district of Hawija district. Found the body of a civilian inside a car in Al-Sadr area, east of the capital. ANBAR GOVERNORATE An Armed Group 01/DEC/2020 Injured a civilian in a tribal conflict in Al-Mashtal area, east of the capital.
    [Show full text]
  • UM AL-IRAQ (THE DATE PALM TREE) the Life and Work of Dr
    UM AL-IRAQ (THE DATE PALM TREE) The Life and Work of Dr. Rashad Zaydan of Iraq By Nikki Lyn Pugh, Peace Writer Edited by Kaitlin Barker Davis 2011 Women PeaceMakers Program Made possible by the Fred J. Hansen Foundation *This material is copyrighted by the Joan B. Kroc Institute for Peace & Justice. For permission to cite, contact [email protected], with “Women PeaceMakers – Narrative Permissions” in the subject line. UM AL-IRAQ (THE DATE PALM TREE) ZAYDAN – IRAQ TABLE OF CONTENTS I. A Note to the Reader …………………………………………………………. 4 II. About the Women PeaceMakers Program …………………………………… 4 III. Biography of a Woman PeaceMaker — Dr. Rashad Zaydan ….……………… 5 IV. Conflict History — Iraq………………………………………………………… 7 V. Map — Iraq ……………………………………………………………………. 14 VI. Integrated Timeline — Political Developments and Personal History ………… 15 VII. Dedication …………………………………………………………………….. 22 VIII. Narrative Stories of the Life and Work of Dr. Rashad Zaydan 23 ُ UM AL-IRAQ 24 ُّ ُّ ُّ أمُّ ُّالعُّــ راق ُُُُُّّّّّ ُُُُُُُُُّّّّّّّّّ ّأولُّث ُّمَرَةُُُُُّّّّّ FIRST FRUIT 25 ُُُُّّّّالنُّ ـــشــأْة I. GROWING UP a. The Dawn’s Prayer …………………………………………………………. 26 b. Memories of Al Mansur ……………………………………………..……… II. MEHARAB AL NOOR/TEMPLES OF LIGHT 29 م ُحــرابُّالنّـــــور c. Beauty in Diversity …………………………………………………………. 31 d. The Day of Ashura ………………………………………………………… 32 e. Summer School ……………………………………………………………. 34 f. The First Spark …………………………………………………………….. 35 g. A Place for Prayer …………………………………………………………. 37 h. Postscript: The Most Advanced Degree ……………………………………. 39 ُُُُّّّّالحـــــربُّ والعقوباتُّ)الحصار(ُُُُّّّّ III. WAR AND SANCTIONS 42 َ ُ ُ ّ i. The Meaning of Marriage ………….………………………………………. 44 j. Baiji ………….……………………………………….……………………. 45 k. Wishing for Stability …………………….…………………………………. 46 l. Kuwait………………….………………………………………………….. 49 m. The Charity Clinic ………….……………………………………………… n. Postscript: The Empty House ………….………………………………….. 51 52 ا لُّحـــــــتـــــــﻻل IV.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 | Page Submission to the Senate Standing Committees on Foreign
    Submission to the Senate Standing Committees on Foreign Affairs Defence and Trade on the Issues facing diaspora communities in Australia by the Yazidi Australian Association Yazidi Australian Association welcomes the opportunity to provide a Submission to the Senate Standing Committees on Foreign Affairs Defence and Trade on the Issues facing diaspora communities in Australia. Yazidi Australian Association represents the needs and issues of the newly arrived Yazidi community members in Australia. We are one of the most recently arrived small and emerging refugee communities in Australia. Majority of our community members have settled in rural and regional Australia including Coffs Harbour, Wagga Wagga, Armidale and Toowoomba with a smaller cohort settling in Western Sydney. Below is a brief outline of the persecution faced by Yazidi community members. Further cultural information can be provided upon request. The Yazidi (or Ezidi) are a people who originate from Iraq, Syria and Turkey. The population is estimated to be between 800, 000 and 1000, 0001 globally, although their population is difficult to estimate considering their dwindling numbers over the last century due to constant persecution. The Yazidis are located primarily in the Nineveh province of northern Iraq, and in the Al-Jazira and Kurd- Dagh areas of Syria. The sacred valley of Lalish is the centre of pilgrimage for Yazidis. Some also live in Armenia and Georgia and many have migrated to parts of Europe. Sweden has had a significant Yazidi population since 20082 and Germany since the 1970s3 Yazidis almost all speak Kurmanji, with the exception of some villages in northern Iraq where Arabic is spoken.
    [Show full text]
  • Download the COI Focus
    OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER GENERAL FOR REFUGEES AND STATELESS PERSONS PERSONS COI Focus IRAQ Security Situation in Central and Southern Iraq 20 March 2020 (update) Cedoca Original language: Dutch DISCLAIMER: This COI-product has been written by Cedoca, the Documentation and Research Department of the CGRS, and it provides information for the processing of applications for international protection. The document does not contain policy guidelines or opinions and does not pass judgment on the merits of the application for international protection. It follows the Common EU Guidelines for processing country of origin information (April 2008) and is written in accordance with the statutory legal provisions. The author has based the text on a wide range of public information selected with care and with a permanent concern for crosschecking sources. Even though the document tries to cover all the relevant aspects of the subject, the text is not necessarily exhaustive. If certain events, people or organizations are not mentioned, this does not mean that they did not exist. All the sources used are briefly mentioned in a footnote and described in detail in a bibliography at the end of the document. Sources which have been consulted but which were not used are listed as consulted sources. In exceptional cases, sources are not mentioned by name. When specific information from this document is used, the user is asked to quote the source mentioned in the bibliography. This document can only be published or distributed with the written consent of the Office of the Commissioner General for Refugees and Stateless Persons. TO A MORE INTEGRATED MIGRATION POLICY, THANKS TO AMIF Rue Ernest Blerot 39, 1070 BRUSSELS T 02 205 51 11 F 02 205 50 01 [email protected] www.cgrs.be IRAQ.
    [Show full text]
  • Iraq CRISIS Situation Report No. 49 (17 June – 23 June 2015)
    Iraq CRISIS Situation Report No. 49 (17 June – 23 June 2015) This report is produced by OCHA Iraq in collaboration with humanitarian partners. It covers the period from 17 – 23 June. Due to the rapidly changing situation it is possible that the numbers and locations listed in this report may no longer be accurate. The next report will be issued on or around 3 July. Highlights More than 1,500 families return to Tikrit. Returnees need humanitarian assistance Close to 300,000 individuals displaced from Ramadi since 8 April NGOs respond to Sulaymaniyah checkpoint closures Concern over humanitarian conditions in Ameriyat al-Fallujah and Habbaniya Insufficient funding continues to limit humanitarian response capacity The boundaries and names shown and the designations used on this map do not imply official endorsement or acceptance by the United Nations. Map created 25 June 2015. Situation Overview More than 1,500 families (approximately 9,000 individuals) returned to Tikrit City and surrounding areas between 14 and 23 June, after the area was retaken by Iraqi Security Forces in April, according to the Displacement Tracking Matrix (DTM) of the International Organization for Migration (IOM). Most of those who returned were Government civil servants who were requested to return. Approximately 80 per cent of Government employees have gone back to the area, local authorities report. Returnees reportedly were required to submit to ID checks, body and vehicle searches before being allowed through manned checkpoints. Authorities have reportedly dismantled 1,700 improvised explosive devices (IEDs) and cleared more than 200 booby-trapped houses. The recent returns brings the estimated total number of returnees in Tikrit District to 16,384 families (over 98,000 individuals), according to a partner NGO.
    [Show full text]