The Effects of Participation in Ayahuasca Rituals
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
______________________________________________________________________________________________www.neip.info THE EFFECTS OF PARTICIPATION IN AYAHUASCA RITUALS ON GAYS’ AND LESBIANS’ SELF PERCEPTION A Dissertation presented to the Faculty of John F. Kennedy Graduate School of Professional Psychology in Pleasant Hill, California in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree Doctor of Psychology By Clancy Cavnar MAY 1, 2011 ______________________________________________________________________________________________www.neip.info THE EFFECTS OF PARTICIPATION IN AYAHUASCA RITUALS ON GAYS’ AND LESBIANS’ SELF PERCEPTION This dissertation by Clancy Cavnar has been approved by the committee members, who recommend that it be accepted by the faculty of John F. Kennedy University, Pleasant Hill, California, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PSYCHOLOGY ________________________________________________________ Peter Van Oot, PhD, Chair ________________________________________________________ Stephen Trichter, PsyD, Reader ________________________________________________________ Date ii ______________________________________________________________________________________________www.neip.info © 2011 by Clancy Cavnar All Rights Reserved iii ______________________________________________________________________________________________www.neip.info ABSTRACT THE EFFECTS OF PARTICIPATION IN AYAHUASCA RITUALS ON GAYS’ AND LESBIANS’ SELF PERCEPTION CLANCY CAVNAR John F. Kennedy University College of Graduate and Professional Studies Pleasant Hill, CA The practice of drinking the psychoactive drink ayahuasca has been shown in several studies to have positive long-term effects on mental states, and several studies have suggested it has a particularly strong positive effect on perceptions of identity. This research sought to discover if and in what way, these previous findings would be seen in gay people, who are often taught by their culture and religion that their lifestyles, values and sexual orientation are unacceptable. This qualitative study examined the interview responses of 17 gay and lesbian- identified participants who had used ayahuasca in a group in the past three years regarding their self-perceptions. The results indicated that all participants reported positive effects on their lives from ayahuasca rituals, including affirmation of their sexual orientation, and no participants reported negative effects on perception of identity. KEYWORDS: Identity, Hallucinogenic drugs, Homosexuality, Religious practices iv ______________________________________________________________________________________________www.neip.info DEDICATION This dissertation is dedicated to Randy Barbato and Bia Labate. v ______________________________________________________________________________________________www.neip.info ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to thank Randy Barbato, Fenton Bailey, World of Wonder, and Chris Wereski for their help with this project. Thanks to my friends for their support, especially Anne Veraldi, Raffaele Trudu, Ralph Trueblood, and Suzanne Manley. Thanks to the Santo Daime church, and thanks to all the participants in this research who responded and kindly allowed me to take their time with the interview. Thanks to Dr. Beatriz Labate, and my reader Dr. Stephen Trichter for their perspectives and advice. vi ______________________________________________________________________________________________www.neip.info Table of Contents Page Dedication........................................................................................................... v Acknowledgments.............................................................................................. vi I. Introduction.................................................................................................... 1 II. Review of the Literature................................................................................ 7 New Research on Psychedelics .................................................................. 7 The “Discovery” of Ayahuasca................................................................ 10 Research on the Chemistry and Effects of Ayahuasca .............................. 13 Ayahuasca, Entheogens, Spirituality and Religion ................................... 19 Empirical Investigation on Entheogens and Spirituality ........................... 21 Speculation on Entheogens and the Origin of Religion............................. 23 Neurochemistry and Psychedelic Spirituality ........................................... 24 Ayahuasca Religious Practices Today...................................................... 26 Shamanistic Use of Ayahuasca ................................................................ 30 Psychedelics and Sexual Minorities ......................................................... 35 Personal Narratives.................................................................................. 39 Homosexuality and Religion.................................................................... 41 III. Method....................................................................................................... 48 Content Analysis ..................................................................................... 48 Assumptions, Limitations and Considerations.......................................... 49 The Process of Analysis........................................................................... 50 vii ______________________________________________________________________________________________www.neip.info Participants.............................................................................................. 50 Recruitment............................................................................................. 54 Data Collection and Analysis................................................................... 54 Timeline to Completion ........................................................................... 55 IV. Results ........................................................................................................ 56 Responses A: Effect on Identity in General.............................................. 56 Responses B: Effect on Identity Regarding Sexual Orientation ................ 57 Responses C: Effect on Sexuality in General............................................ 59 Responses D: Comfort with Group Members........................................... 61 Responses E: Comfort with Beliefs about Homosexuality........................ 62 Responses F: Effect on Spirituality .......................................................... 65 Responses G: Effect of Ayahuasca Ritual on “Life”................................. 66 Responses H: Aspects Causing Discomfort.............................................. 68 Responses I: Perception of Externally Appreciable Change ..................... 70 Responses J: Changes in Future Use ........................................................ 70 Summary of Results................................................................................. 72 V. Discussion ................................................................................................... 74 Clinical Implications................................................................................ 81 Implications for Public Policy.................................................................. 87 Suggestions for Future Research.............................................................. 88 References......................................................................................................... 90 Appendix A: Consent to Participate................................................................. 110 Appendix B: Demographic Questionnaire........................................................ 113 viii ______________________________________________________________________________________________www.neip.info Appendix C: Participant Recruitment .............................................................. 116 Appendix E: Demographics Chart ................................................................... 122 ix ______________________________________________________________________________________________www.neip.info 1 Chapter I Introduction The use of ayahuasca (eye-ah-WAS-ka) for personal exploration, physical and emotional healing, and religious practice has grown recently both in the United States and worldwide, expanding from its traditional roots in South America to become a global phenomenon (Luna, 2003). Currently, thousands of people drink ayahuasca throughout the world, either as ayahuasca tourists in South America, as adherents of the two international ayahuasca churches, Santo Daime and União de Vegetal, or their numerous local offshoots and variations. People also drink the beverage in more esoteric groups and smaller circles interested in self-knowledge and personal exploration, or as practitioners in who work with shamans who travel to their countries (Metzner, 1999). The name “ayahuasca” is a Quechua term for “vine of the soul.” It has many other names, including “yage,” “hoasca,” “caapi” and “pinde” (Shultes, 1992). It is said to provide “telepathy” to its users, to heal physical and psychological wounds, and to grant religious visions. The experiences of people who drink ayahuasca are often life changing, and have been said to include cures for drug addiction (Mabit, 1996; Labate, Guimarães dos Santos, Anderson, Mercante, & Barbosa, 2010) and