Su Renshan and the Politics of Painting in Early 19Th-Century Guangdong
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Defi ant Brush Su Renshan and the Politics of Painting in Early 19th-Century Guangdong Yeewan Koon University of Hawai‘i Press Honolulu Koon_00a_fm.indd iii 25/03/2014 9:50 AM Th is publication has been generously supported by the Hsu Long-sing Research Fund at the University of Hong Kong. For distribution in Asia, Australia and New Zealand: Hong Kong University Press Th e University of Hong Kong Pokfulam Road Hong Kong www.hkupress.org ISBN 978-988-8139-61-3 For distribution outside Asia, Australia and New Zealand: University of Hawai‘i Press 2840 Kolowalu Street Honolulu, Hawai‘i 96822 USA www.uhpress.hawaii.edu ISBN 978-0-8248-4103-4 © Hong Kong University Press 2014 All rights reserved. No portion of this publication may be reproduced or transmitt ed in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage or retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Koon, Yeewan, author. A defi ant brush : Su Renshan and the politics of painting in early 19th-century Guangdong / Yeewan Koon. pages cm Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-8248-4103-4 (cloth : alk. paper) 1. Su, Renshan, 1813–1849?—Criticism and interpretation. I. Title. ND1049.S894K66 2014 759.951—dc23 2014005774 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed and bound by Paramount Printing Co., Ltd. in Hong Kong, China Koon_00a_fm.indd iv 25/03/2014 9:50 AM Contents List of Illustrations ix List of Maps and Charts xvii Acknowledgments xix An Introduction 1 Chapter One 21 Art and Trade in Guangzhou Chapter Two 69 Su Renshan: Art in the Delta Hinterlands Chapter Th ree 109 Art and War in Guangzhou Chapter Four 139 Su Renshan: Politicizing the Vernacular Chapter Five 164 Su Renshan: In the Company of Women Notes 191 Bibliography 211 Index 221 Koon_00a_fm.indd vii 25/03/2014 9:50 AM Illustrations Introduction 8. Att ributed to Su Renshan, Autumn Landscape. Hanging scroll, dated 1842, ink on paper, 1. Su Renshan, A Celebration of Myriad Birds. 142.5 × 55.5 cm. Guangdong Museum. 19 Hanging scroll, undated, ink on paper, 243 × 123 9. Att ributed to Su Renshan, Landscape. Hanging cm. Kyoto National Museum. 2 scroll, undated, ink on paper, 120.3 × 59.7 cm. 2. Su Renshan, Riding Dragons. Hanging Guangdong Museum. 19 scroll, undated, ink on paper, 254 × 118 cm. Reproduced by permission of the Art Museum Chapter One of the Chinese University of Hong Kong from the collection of the Art Museum. 14 10. Li Tang, Gathering Herbs. Handscroll, undated, 3. Su Renshan, Leading the Phoenixes by Playing ink and colors on silk, 27.2 × 90.5 cm. Palace the Flute. Hanging scroll, dated 1848, ink on Museum, Beijing. 28 paper, 278 × 120 cm. Reproduced by permission 11. Shitao, Wilderness Cott age. Leaf G from of the Art Museum of the Chinese University Wilderness Colors album of 12 leaves, dated c. of Hong Kong from the collection of the Art 1700s, ink and color on paper, 26.7 × 21.6 cm. Museum. 14 Th e Metropolitan Museum of Art, Th e Sackler 4. Su Renshan, Landscape. Hanging scroll, dated Fund, 1972 (1972.122a-1). Image © Th e 1844, ink on paper, 147.9 × 76 cm. Guangdong Metropolitan Museum of Art . 31 Museum (廣東省博物館). 15 12. (a-h) Li Jian, Album of Landscapes and Figures. 5. Su Renshan, Liezi in a Landscape. Hanging Album of eight leaves, dated 1789, ink or ink scroll, dated 1843, ink on paper, 192 × 46.5 cm. and color on paper, each leaf 35.5 × 25.5 cm. Reproduced by permission of the Art Museum Reproduced by permission of the Art Museum of the Chinese University of Hong Kong from of the Chinese University of Hong Kong from the collection of the Art Museum. 16 the collection of the Art Museum. 34–37 6. Su Renshan, Landscape aft er Wang Wei. Hanging 13. (a–d) Li Jian, Landscapes: (a) Cliff with Old scroll, dated 1847, ink on paper, dimensions Trees, (b) Furong Bay, (c) Hamlet in Autumn, unknown. Guangdong Museum. 18 and (d) Searching for Plum Blossoms in Morning 7. Su Renshan, Leaf 2 from Album of Paintings Snow. Set of four hanging scrolls, dated 1797, and Calligraphy. 20 leaves (14 calligraphy, ink and color on paper, 99 × 45 cm. Guangdong 6 paintings), one leaf is dated 1847, ink on Museum. 38–39 paper, 121 × 35 cm each. Kyoto National 14. Shitao, Mount Luofu, Calligraphy and Painting. Museum. 18 From an album of eight leaves, undated, Koon_00a_fm.indd ix 27/03/2014 8:08 AM x Illustrations ink and color on paper, 28.2 × 19.8 cm. 22. Zhang Bao, Guangzhou. From Images of A Princeton University Art Museum/Art Floating Raft, vol. 3, 1833. Reprinted by Beijing Resource, NY. 40 guji chubanshe, 1988. 51 15. Li Jian, Green Mountains with Kapok Trees 23. Pu Qua Workshop, Butcher. From a set of in Album of Landscapes aft er Great Masters 100 sheets, dated ca. 1790, watercolor on Dedicated to Juhu. From an album of twelve paper, 34.1 × 41.5 cm. Victoria and Albert leaves, dated 1782, ink and color on silk, 25 × 32 Museum. 55 cm. Guangzhou Art Gallery, Guangzhou Art 24. Pu Qua, Vegetable Seller. From a set of 100 sheets, Museum. Aft er Kao Mayching, ed. (1993), Th e dated ca. 1790, watercolor on paper, 34.1 × 41.5 Art of Li Jian and Xie Lansheng. Hong Kong cm. Victoria and Albert Museum. 55 and Guangzhou: Art Gallery, Th e Chinese 25. Pu Qua, Barrel Maker. From a set of 100 sheets, University of Hong Kong and Guangzhou Art dated ca. 1790, watercolor on paper, 34.1 × 41.5 Gallery, 60.. 40 cm. Victoria and Albert Museum. 56 16. (a–h) Xie Lansheng, Landscapes. Album of 8 26. Pu Qua, Metal Worker. From a set of 100 sheets, leaves, 1823, ink and color on silk or ink on dated ca. 1790, watercolor on paper, 34.1 × 41.5 gold-sprinkled paper, 35.2 × 34.5 cm (4 leaves); cm. Victoria and Albert Museum. 56 31.6 × 29.8 cm (4 leaves). Hong Kong Museum 27. Pu Qua, Feather Dusters Hawker. From a set of Art Collection. 42–45 of 100 sheets, dated ca. 1790, watercolor on 17. Xie Lansheng, Lychee Tree. Hanging scroll, paper, 34.1 × 41.5 cm. Victoria and Albert dated 1791, ink and color on silk, 166 × 75 cm. Museum. 57 Reproduced by permission of the Art Museum 28. Pu Qua, Street Entertainer with a Snake Tracing. of the Chinese University of Hong Kong from ca. 1790, paper, 34.1 × 41.5 cm. Victoria and the collection of the Art Museum. 46 Albert Museum.. 57 18. Xie Lansheng, Lychee Grove. Hanging scroll, 29. Ju Chao, Operatic Comic Actor. One from a dated 1820, ink and color on paper, 58 × 31.5 set of 4 hanging scrolls, ca. 1840s, ink and cm. Guangzhou Art Gallery, Guangzhou Art color on paper. Reproduced by permission of Museum. Aft er Kao Mayching, ed. (1993), Th e the Art Museum of the Chinese University Art of Li Jian and Xie Lansheng. Hong Kong of Hong Kong from the collection of the Art and Guangzhou: Art Gallery, Th e Chinese Museum. 58 University of Hong Kong and Guangzhou Art 30. Su Liupeng, Tan San from Album of Street Gallery, 191. 47 Characters. Album of four double leaves, ca. 19. Xie Lansheng, Landscapes. One leaf from 1843, ink and color on paper, 24.5 × 18.5 album of 12 leaves, 1830, ink and color on cm. Guangzhou Art Gallery, Guangzhou Art paper, 35 × 30 cm. Hong Kong Museum of Art Museum. Aft er Kao Mayching, ed., Th e Art of Collection. 47 Su Liupeng and Su Renshan, Hong Kong and 20. Xie Lansheng, Waterfall in Mount Cha. Hanging Guangzhou: Art Gallery, Th e Chinese University scroll, 1821, ink and color on silk, 116 × 43.5 cm. of Hong Kong and Guangzhou Art Gallery, Guangdong Museum. 50 1990, 35. 59 21. Wen Zhengming, Pine Forest and Waterfall. 31. Su Liupeng, Monkey Trainer from Album of Hanging scroll, 1527–31, ink and color on paper, Street Characters. Album of four double leaves, 108.1 × 37.8 cm. National Palace Museum, ca. 1843, ink and color on paper, 24.5 × 18.5 Taipei.. 50 cm. Guangzhou Art Gallery, Guangzhou Art Koon_00a_fm.indd x 27/03/2014 8:08 AM Illustrations xi Museum. Aft er Kao Mayching, ed., Th e Art of edited by Xu Zhihao. Shanghai: Xuelin chuban- Su Liupeng and Su Renshan, Hong Kong and she, 2003, 18. 65 Guangzhou: Art Gallery, Th e Chinese University 39. Zhou Kun, Street Entertainers from Album of Hong Kong and Guangzhou Art Gallery, of Paintings of Life in a Village Town. Palace 1990, 35. 60 Museum, Beijing. 65 32. Su Liupeng, Bamboo Bed Peddler from Album of 40. Zhou Kun, Metal Worker from Album of Paintings Street Characters. Album of four double leaves, of Life in a Village Town. Palace Museum, ca. 1843, ink and color on paper, 24.5 × 18.5 Beijing. 66 cm. Guangzhou Art Gallery, Guangzhou Art 41. Reprint of lithograph aft er Dong Qi, Barrel Museum. Aft er Kao Mayching, ed., Th e Art of Maker from Taiping huanle tu, pictures by Dong Su Liupeng and Su Renshan, Hong Kong and Qi, text edited by Xu Zhihao. Shanghai: Xuelin Guangzhou: Art Gallery, Th e Chinese University chubanshe, 2003, 108. 66 of Hong Kong and Guangzhou Art Gallery, 42.