Results Page
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
2011 Ultimate Wine Challenge Results ULTIMATE WINE CHALLENGE 2011 May 26, 2011 ASTOR CENTER, NEW YORK CITY All wines were evaluated by a select group of judges under ideal tasting conditions, at the proper service temperature, in manageable flights of no more than eight wines; and in high-quality glassware specific for wine type and varietal. Wines were poured into numbered glasses in a separate room, served blind in small flights based upon wine type, origin, varietal and price, and evaluated and scored by panels of judges who used a unique variation of the 100-point scale. Products that scored 90 points or higher were then evaluated blind once again, in newly-created groupings by a different panel of judges. Top scoring products were then reviewed again to determine a select group of finalists with the categorys highest-scorer being awarded a Chairmans Trophy accolade. For 2011, there are 17 Chairmans Trophies awarded, representing the best of the best; Finalists in each section are also identified. In addition to the score, wines are distinguished with the following Accolades, as a guide to consumers: 95-100 Extraordinary, Ultimate Recommendation 90-94 Excellent, Highly Recommended 85-89 Very Good, Strong Recommendation 80-84 Good, Recommended A note on the icons: Tasting Note: tasting notes for Chairman's Trophy winners and Finalists have been provided by Judging Chairman, F. Paul Pacult and Assistant Judging Chairman, Sean Ludford based upon their and the judges' impressions. Roll over icon to view. Great Value: indicates products with a favorable relationship between their price and final score. Product Image: to assist you with visual identification, we've included an image for each product evaluated. (Please note that age statements, vintages or label may vary slightly from the specific product evaluated but it represents a helpful portrayal of the brand.) Click icon to view. Entered products that were scored below 80 points have not been included; Ultimate Beverage Challenge is dedicated to recognizing the best of the best, and that, in our opinion, begins with a score of 80 as being indicative of products of commendation and consumer worthiness. CHAMPAGNE/SPARKLING Sparkling - World Award Score Product Accolade Chairman's Trophy 95 Piper Sonoma Blanc de Blancs Sonoma County Extraordinary, NV (United States), $19.99, 750 ml Ultimate Recommendation Finalist 93 Gloria Ferrer Sonoma Brut Sonoma County NV Excellent, (United States), $20.00, 750 ml Highly Recommended Finalist 92 Domaine Carneros Le Reve Blanc de Blancs Excellent, Chardonnay Carneros, Napa 2005 (United Highly Recommended States), $95.00, 750 ml Finalist 91 Astoria 9.5 Cold Wine Brut Sparkling White Wine Excellent, Veneto, IGT NV (Italy), $16.99, 750 ml Highly Recommended Finalist 91 Domaine Carneros Brut Rosé de la Pompadour Excellent, Carneros, Napa NV (United States), $36.00, 750 Highly Recommended ml Finalist 91 Gloria Ferrer VA de VI Sonoma County NV Excellent, (United States), $22.00, 750 ml Highly Recommended 90 Astoria Spumante Extra Dry Prosecco Prosecco Excellent, di Conegliano-Valdobbiadene 2010 (Italy), $21.99, Highly Recommended 750 ml 89 Vilarnau Brut Nature Cava - Catalonia NV (Spain), Very Good, $17.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 88 Barefoot Bubbly Extra Dry Champagne California Very Good, NV (United States), $9.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 88 Martini & Rossi Prosecco Italy NV (Italy), $14.99, Very Good, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 88 Maschio Cadoro Moscato IGT, Puglia NV (Italy), Very Good, $14.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 88 Segura Viudas Brut Reserva Cava - Catalonia NV Very Good, (Spain), $10.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 87 Banfi Rosa Regale Estate Bottled Brachetto Very Good, d'Acqui (DOCG) 2009 (Italy), $23.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 87 Barefoot Bubbly Rose Cuvée Champagne Very Good, California NV (United States), $10.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 87 Domaine Carneros Brut Cuvée Carneros, Napa Very Good, 2007 (United States), $26.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 87 Greendance Sparkling Vidal Blanc Pennsylania Very Good, Central Delaware Valley 2010 (United States), Strong Recommendation $20.00, 750 ml 87 Scharffenberger Brut Rosé Sparkling Wine Very Good, Mendocino NV (United States), $23.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 86 Barefoot Bubbly Pinot Grigio Champagne Very Good, California NV (United States), $10.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 86 Martini & Rossi Asti Italy NV (Italy), $12.99, 750 Very Good, ml Strong Recommendation 85 Barefoot Bubbly Brut Cuvée Champagne Very Good, California NV (United States), $9.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 85 Martini & Rossi Sparkling Rosé Italy NV (Italy), Very Good, $12.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 85 Maschio Brut Prosecco Italy NV (Italy), $13.00, Very Good, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 85 Moletto Prosecco Treviso Veneto, IGT NV (Italy), Very Good, $17.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 85 Riunite Movendo Moscato IGT, Puglia NV (Italy), Very Good, $9.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 84 Piper Sonoma Brut Sonoma County NV (United Good, States), $19.99, 750 ml Recommended 83 Monluc Brut Methode Traditionelle Sparkling Good, Wine France NV (France), $16.00, 750 ml Recommended 83 Scharffenberger Brut Sparkling Wine Mendocino Good, NV (United States), $19.00, 750 ml Recommended 82 Barefoot Bubbly Moscato Spumante Champagne Good, California NV (United States), $10.99, 750 ml Recommended WHITE WINES Chardonnay - World Award Score Product Accolade Chairman's Trophy 94 Glen Carlou Chardonnay Paarl 2009 (South Excellent, Africa), $11.00, 750 ml Highly Recommended Finalist 91 Rodney Strong Chalk Hill Estate Vineyards Excellent, Chardonnay Chalk Hill 2009 (United States), Highly Recommended $20.00, 750 ml Finalist 90 Wakefield Estate Chardonnay Clare Valley 2009 Excellent, (Australia), $16.99, 750 ml Highly Recommended 90 Clos du Bois Chardonnay North Coast 2009 Excellent, (United States), $11.99, 750 ml Highly Recommended 90 Fog Head Highland Series Reserve Chardonnay Excellent, Monterey 2009 (United States), $13.99, 750 ml Highly Recommended 88 Big House Unchained Naked Chardonnay Very Good, California 2009 (United States), $10.00, 3L Box Strong Recommendation 88 Blackstone Sonoma Reserve Chardonnay Very Good, Sonoma County 2007 (United States), $16.99, Strong Recommendation 750 ml 88 Chamisal Vineyards Stainless Chardonnay San Very Good, Luis Obispo 2010 (United States), $18.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 88 Clos du Bois Calcaire Chardonnay Russian River Very Good, Valley 2009 (United States), $24.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 88 Clos du Val Reserve Chardonnay Carneros, Napa Very Good, 2008 (United States), $45.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 88 Davis Bynum Chardonnay Russian River Valley Very Good, 2008 (United States), $25.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 88 Scheid Vineyards Estate Chardonnay Monterey Very Good, 2008 (United States), $22.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 87 Bouchaine Estate Chardonnay Carneros, Napa Very Good, 2009 (United States), $28.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 87 Charles Krug-Peter Mondavi Family Chardonnay Very Good, Napa Valley 2009 (United States), $20.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 87 Clos du Val Chardonnay Carneros, Napa 2009 Very Good, (United States), $25.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 87 Hess Collection Chardonnay Napa Valley 2009 Very Good, (United States), $22.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 87 McWilliam's Hanwood Estate Chardonnay South Very Good, Eastern Australia 2009 (Australia), $12.00, 750 Strong Recommendation ml 87 Rex Goliath Chardonnay California NV (United Very Good, States), $7.49, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 87 Simi Chardonnay Sonoma County 2009 (United Very Good, States), $17.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 87 Toasted Head Chardonnay California 2009 Very Good, (United States), $12.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 87 Woodbridge Chardonnay California 2010 (United Very Good, States), $7.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 86 Dragon's Hollow Unoaked Chardonnay Helan Very Good, Mountains Region in Ningxia Province 2008 Strong Recommendation (China), $9.99, 750 ml 86 Estancia Pinnacles Ranches Chardonnay Very Good, Monterey County 2009 (United States), $11.99, Strong Recommendation 750 ml 86 Gnarly Head Chardonnay California 2010 (United Very Good, States), $10.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 86 Jordan Chardonnay Russian River Valley 2009 Very Good, (United States), $29.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 86 Mercer Estates Chardonnay Columbia Valley Very Good, 2009 (United States), $14.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 86 Robert Mondavi Winery Private Selection Very Good, Chardonnay California 2009 (United States), Strong Recommendation $10.99, 750 ml 86 Sanford Chardonnay Santa Barbara County 2009 Very Good, (United States), $25.00, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 86 Santa Carolina Reserva, Casablanca Chardonnay Very Good, Chile 2010 (Chile), $12.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 86 Simply Naked Unoaked Chardonnay California Very Good, 2010 (United States), $9.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 86 The Naked Grape Chardonnay California NV Very Good, (United States), $7.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 85 Robert Oatley Chardonnay Australia 2008 Very Good, (Australia), $14.99, 750 ml Strong Recommendation 85 Rodney Strong Sonoma County Chardonnay Very Good, Sonoma County 2009 (United States), $13.50, Strong Recommendation 750 ml 84 Barefoot Chardonnay California NV (United Good, States), $6.99, 750 ml Recommended 84 Black Box Chardonnay Monterey County 2010 Good, (United States), $24.99, 3L Box Recommended 84 Deep Sea Bien Nacido