Metals in Mandara Mountains Society and Culture Dokwaza Kawa of Lum-Ziver Near Mokolo (1989)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Metals in Mandara Mountains Society and Culture Dokwaza Kawa of Lum-Ziver near Mokolo (1989). A Mafa master smelter, blacksmith, diviner and healer, he is seen here assembling a variety of seeds and other plant parts to place in a bracelet of smelted iron made for Nicholas David. Metals in Mandara Mountains Society and Culture Edited by Nicholas David AFRICA WORLD PRESS Trenton | London | Cape Town | Nairobi | Addis Ababa | Asmara | Ibadan | New Delhi AFRICA WORLD PRESS 541 West Ingham Avenue | Suite B Trenton, New Jersey 08638 Copyright © 2012 Nicholas David First Printing 2012 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechani- cal, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher. Book and cover design: Saverance Publishing Services Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Metals in Mandara Mountains society and culture / edited by Nicholas David. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-59221-889-9 (hard cover) -- ISBN 978-1-59221-890-5 (pbk.) 1. Iron industry and trade--Social aspects--Mandara Mountains (Cameroon and Nigeria) 2. Blacksmiths--Mandara Mountains (Cameroon and Nigeria) 3. Mandara Mountains (Cameroon and Nigeria)--Social life and customs. I. David, Nicholas, 1937- HD9527.C173M356 2012 682.4096--dc23 2011046719 Contents List of Figures vii List of Tables xi A Note on Transcription xiii PART I SETTING THE STAGE 1. Introduction 3 Nicholas David 2. The prehistory and early history of the northern Mandara Mountains and surrounding plains 27 Scott MacEachern 3. My father René Gardi & Co.: Truadak and Rabash, Hans Eichenberger and Paul Hinderling 69 Bernhard Gardi PART II SOCIETY AND ECONOMY 4. Smith and society: patterns of articulation in the northern Mandara Mountains 87 Nicholas David and Judy Sterner 5. Ricardo in the Mandara Mountains: iron, comparative advantage, and specialization 115 Nicholas David 6. Competition and change in two traditional African iron industries 171 Nicholas David and Ian G. Robertson 7. Form, style, and ethnicity: iron hoes and knives in the Mandara region, Northern Cameroon 185 Ian G. Robertson vi PART III HISTORY AND IDEOLOGY 8. The development of endogamy among smiths of the Mandara mountains eastern piedmont: myths, history and material evidence 225 Olivier Langlois 9. The wife of the village: understanding caste in the Mandara Mountains 257 James H. Wade 10. The iron bride: blacksmith, iron, and femininity among the Kapsiki/Higi 285 Walter van Beek 11. A touch of wildness: brass and brass casting in Kapsiki 303 Walter van Beek PART IV AFTERWORD 12. Afterword 327 Jean-Pierre Warnier List of contributors 343 Index 347 Metals in Mandara Mountains Society and Culture List of Figures Larger color versions of the figures marked with an asterisk can be found on Nich- olas David’s web site at http://people.ucalgary.ca/~ndavid/Homepage/#MMF *1.1 Map of the northern Mandara Mountains and surrounding plains: ethno-linguistic groups, towns and villages. 4 *1.2 The furnace built by the Mafa iron-master Dokwaza. 10 *1.3 The Sukurian furnace built by Plata smelter Ajokfa in use in 1989. Photo: David Killick. 11 1.4 Front and side views of examples of Teleki-Banan furnaces. 12 *1.5 Dokwaza Kawa’s forge, 1986. 14 *2.1 The study area in regional context, with archaeological sites. 28 *2.2 The northern Mandara Mountains, with numbered archaeological sites. 41 * 2.3 The northern Mandara Mountains, with selected named sites. 43 3.1 René Gardi at Ldamszay with a young Mafa woman. Photo: Paul Hinderling. 72 *3.2 A moment early in the smelt by Truadak at Ldamszay in February 1953. Photo: René Gardi. 74 3.3 Towards the end of the smelt at Sulede in March 1953. 76 3.4 The end of the smelt at Sulede in March 1953. 77 *4.1 Patterns of articulation of ironworkers and society in the Northern Mandara region. 100 *5.1 A selection of Sukur blooms, iron bars and bloomery iron frag- ments. 116 viii *5.2 Map showing Nigerian districts and Cameroonian administrative boundaries. 118 5.3 Villages of the Mokolo cantons and selected other settlements. 119 5.4 Dokwaza Kawa’s Shebe clan line. 128 *5.5 Map of Sukur and its region. 139 *5.6 Sukur furnaces. 140 *5.7 Sukur blooms and iron bars. 141 6.1 At work in a Mafa forge. 175 6.2 At work in an Uldeme forge. 176 6.3 Smith and bellowsman/striker beat out a hoe in a Manaouatchi (Wandala) forge. 177 *6.4 Three named Wandala hoe types and their common template. 178 *6.5 A Mafa smith using a bar hammer on a hoe. 181 7.1 The Mandara region, northern Cameroon. 187 *7.2 Ridged-boulder forging hammers. 191 7.3 Hoes made by Plata and Wandala smiths. 192 7.4 Wandala-made hoes. 195 7.5 Two examples of Wandala hoe templates. 199 7.6 Decision tree flow chart showing the main steps in forging three key hoe types. 200 *7.7 Mandara region sheath knife, resting on its leather sheath. 203 7.8 Field sketches showing knife handles. 205 7.9 Metric recording scheme for knife handles. 209 7.10 The first two principal components based on metric observations of knives. 211 8.1 Part of Central Africa, showing selected ethno-linguistic groups, kingdoms and sites. 227 8.2 The northern Mandara Mountains: ethno-linguistic groups, his- toric and archaeological sites and the Mandara (Wandala) kingdom. 229 9.1 The centrality of the marginal: a view of the Fali cosmos. 265 9.2 Fali society: structured in terms of gender and caste. 266 10.1 A selection of Kapsiki iron artifacts. 287 *10.2 The bride clothed in her iron skirt, accompanied by female relatives 289 *10.3 The sister of an initiated boy clothed in her iron skirt and carrying his cowrie shell girdle. 291 Metals in Mandara Mountains Society and Culture ix *10.4 Chief smith Gwarda wears the smiths’ traditional coiled basketry cap. 298 11.1 Cross-section of a Kapsiki brass casting furnace and a selection of brass artifacts. 305 11.2 Brass casters Teri Kwafashé and his wife Masi at work. 306 *11.3 A selection of Kapsiki/Higi brasses. 307 *11.4 Kapsiki/Higi brasses: a goblet and a calabash. 308 *11.5 A selection of small Kapsiki/Higi brasses. 309 11.6 The 1973 male initiates of Mogode, four with paya ornaments on their foreheads. 311 11.7 A fully decorated initiate wearing a headdress with rooster feathers gets his blessing. 312 11.8 The chief smith performing a burial rite. 315 11.9 Coins stuck on his forehead reward an iron smith for his praise singing. 316 *11.10 Tourists shopping for brasses at Teri’s compound in 2005; brasses by Masi. 317 *11.11 Masi shows the mold of a brass goblet, a brass miniature cooking pot and the wax model of a miniature pot. 319 List of Figures List of Tables 2.1 Radiocarbon dates from Mandara research 1984 – 2008. 36 4.1 Craft and professional activities of some Mandara montagnard smith-potters. 89 4.2 Classifications of Chadic languages spoken in and around the Mandara Mountains. 101 5.1 Census data and population densities for the Department of Mayo Tsanaga and the Matakam-Sud and Mokolo-Fulbe cantons. 124 5.2 Population of the Mokolo cantons according to the 1963, 1982 and 1987 censuses. 126 5.3 Furnace masters working in a sample of circum-Mokolo villages in the 1930s and 40s. 131 5.4 Census made in 1986 of iron objects in the house of an elderly Mafa couple. 134 5.5 Calculation of bloomery iron production in relation to require- ments for replacements. 137 5.6 Estimates of production of blooms and small bar equivalents per annum at Sukur. 147 5.7 Calculations of estimated annual production of small bars by Sukur in the1930s and 1940s. 150 5.8 Calculation of iron production of the Hide of Tourou and the Mabas in the period 1930-49. 153 5.9 Calculation of iron balance in the Mokolo cantons. 154 5.10 Best estimate of population of Madagali District in 1942-3. 157 xii 5.11 The iron balance in Madagali District (1930s-40s) by community cluster. 158 7.1 Knives included in study, broken down by maker ethnicity and location. 208 7.2 Regression analysis of location and ethnicity effects on knife shape. 213 8.1 Recorded montagnard myths relating to the origins of endogamy by theme and group. 233 11.1 Craft and other associations of the three groups of Kapsiki smiths. 314 Metals in Mandara Mountains Society and Culture A Note on Transcription To the best of my knowledge there are published lexicons, dictionaries or gram- mars for only five of the over forty Biu-Mandara Chadic languages1 still spoken in the northern Mandara Mountains region. Lacking such resources, fieldwork- ers’ transcriptions of native words tend to be ad hoc and erratic, often failing to note tones. Furthermore, somewhat different conventions have been adopted by linguists on either side of the Nigeria-Cameroon border. Readers of this volume should therefore not expect consistency in the reproduction of native terms. While Wade (chapter 9) and van Beek (chapter 10) specify their transcriptions in more detail, and others use the transcriptions of the authors they cite, the following special characters are commonly used: º voiced bilabial implosive Þ, ë voiced alveolar implosive ©, í schwa ½, Á voiced velar nasal (English – sing) tl/sl unvoiced alveolar lateral fricative (Nigerian versus Cameroonian orthography) dl/zl voiced alveolar lateral fricative (as above).