Messiah Lutheran Designation Study
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DRAFT Designation Study Messiah English Evangelical Lutheran Church 2501 Columbus Avenue South Heritage Preservation Commission City of Minneapolis Department of Economic Development-Planning Department Designation Study for Messiah English Evangelical Lutheran Church ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Mayor and City Council of the City of Minneapolis Betsy Hodges, Mayor Barbara Johnson, Council President Elizabeth Glidden, Council Vice President Kevin Reich Alondra Cano Cam Gordon Lisa Bender Jacob Frey John Quincy Blong Yang Andrew Johnson Abdi Warsame Lisa Palmisano Lisa Goodman Minneapolis Heritage Preservation Commission Laura Faucher, Chair Diana Dyste Laurel Fritz Barbara Howard Susan Hunter Weir Ginny Lackovic Linda Mack Dan Olson Ian Stade Madelyn Sundberg Minneapolis City Planning Commission Matthew Brown, President Alissa Luepke-Pier Council Member Lisa Bender Nick Magrino Sam Rockwell Rebecca Gagnon Amy Sweasy Ryan Kronzer Scott Vreeland Department of Community Planning and Economic Development (CPED) Craig Taylor, Executive Director Jack Byers, Manager, CPED-Long Range Planning Catherine Sandlund, Principal City Planner, CPED-Long Range Planning Susan Hunter Weir, Minneapolis Preservation Commissioner and Principal Researcher Nancy Powell, Photographer/Researcher 2 Heritage Preservation Commission City of Minneapolis Department of Economic Development-Planning Department Designation Study for Messiah English Evangelical Lutheran Church TABLE OF CONTENTS Designation Study Purpose and Background ............................................................ page 5 Part 1: Physical Description of Property .................................................................... page 7 • Parcel location, shape, and size • Description of building(s) on the property • Description of interior features • Description of landscape and landscape features Part 2: Historic Significance ...................................................................................... page 14 Part 3: Rationale for Local Historic Designation ....................................................... page 23 • Designation Criteria • Integrity of historic resource • Other Considerations Part 4: Registration and Classification Information ................................................. page 30 Part 5: Notes ............................................................................................................. page 34 • Bibliography Illustrations and Photos ........................................................................................... page 36 • Cover photo, Minnesota Historical Society Collection, MH5.9 MPS.1 p.1 • Figure 1. Map showing church’s location, Hennepin County Interactive Map • Figure 2. Harry Wild Jones’ drawing of church’s exterior and main floor from Harry Wild Jones Papers, Minnesota Historical Society Manuscript Collection (P1979) • Figure 3. North façade view of roofline, bell tower, east-end gable, and exterior of main floor windows, February 2017, photo by Nancy Luther Powell. • Figure 4. North façade view primary entrance and bell tower, February 2017, photo by Nancy Luther Powell. • Figure 5. West façade parapet gable wall, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 6. East facade, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 7. South facade, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 8. South façade east-end gable, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 9. Gabled entrance on south façade’s east end gable, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 10. Entrance to pastor’s study on south façade’s west end gable, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • February 11. Door and stairs on northwest corner of south façade, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 12. Central aisle in sanctuary, February 2017, photo by Nancy Luther Powell 3 Heritage Preservation Commission City of Minneapolis Department of Economic Development-Planning Department Designation Study for Messiah English Evangelical Lutheran Church • Figure 13. Sliding oak panels separating sanctuary and library, February 2017, photo by Nancy Luther Powell. • Figure 14. View of sanctuary from library through panel opening, February 2017, photo by Nancy Luther Powell • Figure 15. Stairwell • Figure 16. Interior arches and trusses, February 2017, photo by Nancy Luther Powell • Figure 17. Stained glass window, February 2017, photo by Nancy Luther Powell. • Figure 18. Art glass windows, hymn board and door to robing robe, February 2017, photo by Nancy Luther Powell • Figure 19. Altar, communion rail and choirs viewed from loft, February 2017, photo by Nancy Luther Powell • Figure 20. Dormer window and trusses, February 2017, photo by Nancy Luther Powell • Figure 21. View of trusses from the choir loft, February 2017, photo by Nancy Luther Powell • Figure 22. Oak pews, trusses, doors, panels and tracery. February 2017, photo by Nancy Luther Powell • Figure 23. Pulpit, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 24. Library on north side of main floor, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 25. Nursery at the west end of the library, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 26. Sunday School classroom at the east end of the library, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 27. Entrance to restrooms on main floor • Figure 28. Second floor hallway, January 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 29. Pastor’s office, January 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 30. Sunday School classroom on second floor, January 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 31. Basement fellowship hall, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 32. Basement performance platform, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 33. Entrance to kitchen, February 2017, photo by Susan Hunter Weir • Figure 34. Messiah’s interior, ca. 1950 Appendices ........................................................................................................................ 63 • Appendix A: First Board of Administrators • Appendix B: Current Status of Harry Wild Jones Churches • Appendix C: Harry Wild Jones’ marketing material • Appendix D: Harry Wild Jones’ marketing materials-- 4 Heritage Preservation Commission City of Minneapolis Department of Economic Development-Planning Department Designation Study for Messiah English Evangelical Lutheran Church DESIGNATION STUDY PURPOSE AND BACKGROUND: On June 21, 2016, the Heritage Preservation Commission approved Commissioner Hunter Weir’s nomination of Messiah Evangelical Lutheran Church located at 2501 Columbus Avenue South as a Landmark, established interim protection, and directed the Planning Director to prepare or cause to be prepared a designation study. This report is the designation study as defined in Section 599 of the Minneapolis Code of Ordinances. Included in this report is a description of the significance of the property, both individually and within the context of Minneapolis planning and heritage preservation goals. The report is based on a review of resources including historic building permits, unpublished church histories and documents, and archival materials from the Minneapolis Collection of the Hennepin County Library and Minnesota Historical Society. 5 Heritage Preservation Commission City of Minneapolis Department of Economic Development-Planning Department Designation Study for Messiah English Evangelical Lutheran Church BASIC PROPERTY INFORMATION Current name Messiah Evangelical Lutheran Church Historic Name Messiah English Evangelical Lutheran Church Current Address 2501 Columbus Avenue South Minneapolis, MN 55404 Historic Address 2501 Columbus Avenue South Minneapolis, MN 55404 Original Construction Date 1916 Original Contractor Unknown Original Architect, Master builder, Harry Wild Jones engineer, designer, artist, or craftsmen Historic Use Church Current Use Church Ward: 6 Neighborhood: Phillips West 6 Heritage Preservation Commission City of Minneapolis Department of Economic Development-Planning Department Designation Study for Messiah English Evangelical Lutheran Church PART 1: PHYSICAL DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY This section provides a description of the physical characteristics of the property, including both the parcel and features on the parcel, such as structures and landscaping. Parcel location, shape, and size The subject property is one building located on the southeast corner at the intersection of East 25th Street and Columbus Avenue South. It is located in the West Phillips neighborhood, which is located to the southeast of the core of Minneapolis. The parcel is rectangular in shape, measuring 100 by 129 feet, for a total of .27 acres or11,765 s.f (Figure 1). Messiah English Evangelical Lutheran Church sits on the northwest corner of a block that consists of newer contemporary construction. The church is adjacent to a brick parking structure and to the rear is a vacant lot. Across East 25th Street there is a mix of original and new neighborhood residential structures. Across Columbus Avenue is Messiah’s Parish Hall which was built in modernist style. Description of building(s) on the property Description of the primary structure Date(s) of construction: Harry Wild Jones, one of Minneapolis’ leading architects, was commissioned by Messiah’s congregation to design a new church for them. The building permit was issued on August 18, 1916. The cost of construction was $34,300. The groundbreaking ceremony took place on August 10, 1916, the cornerstone was laid on November 26, 1916, and the church’s formal dedication