Final Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Civil Society Monitoring of Security Sector Development (CSM-SSD) Final Report 13 September 2013 – 12 September 2017 Photo Above: Seminar in Viqueque Municipality on Conflict Prevention during the Parliamentary Election on June 07th 2017 (Photo credit: Municipal Coordinator Viqueque-Belun) Submission Details Date submitted: 15 December 2017 Prepared for: USAID Prepared by: NGO Belun Contact Person: Marilia Oliveira da Costa, Chief of Party Contact email: [email protected] 1 ACRONYMS USAID United States Agency for International Development UNDP United Nations Development Programme CSM-SSD Civil Society Monitoring of Security Sector Development EWER Early Warning, Early Response FM Fundasaun Mahein MEV Monitoring Electoral Violence IT Information Technologic CNE National Electoral Commission PNTL National Police Timor-Leste F-FDTL Timor Leste Defence Force BOP Public Order Battalion UEP Special Police Unit EU European Union CPRN Conflict Prevention and Response Network DAME Democracy and Development in Action through the Media and Empowerment RPO Research and Policy Officer CPD-RDTL Popular Council for the Defence of the Democratic Republic of East Timor FGD Focus Group Discussion MSS Ministry for Social Solidarity NDCCP National Directorate for Community Conflict Prevention NCCP National Community Conflict Prevention BNCTL The Timor Leste national Bank of Commerce STAE The Ministry of State Administration CNJTL The Timorense national Youth Council FONGTIL Civil Society Organizations RTTL Radio Television Timor Leste TVTL East Timor Television ETAN East Timor Action Network FB Facebook RAEOA Specials Administrative Region of Oe-Cusse Ambeno CT Conflict Transformation MC Municipal Coordinator MoI Minister of Interior UEP Commander of Special Police Unit PQA Program Quality Advisor SEPI Secretariat of State for the Promotion of Equality CNJTL National Youth Council DNTPSC National Directorate on Land and Property CNRT National Congress Reconstruction Timorense DAME Democracy and Development in Action through the Media and Empowerment SWG Security Working Group PMO Primer Minister Office UAS Assessorial Civil Society Unit HAK Human Right Associate AJAR Asia Justice and Right UNPAZ National University for Peace ILO International Labour Organization HIVOS Hivos & Humanism Organization TAF The Asian Foundation GIZ German Society for International Cooperation 2 FAO Food and Agriculture Organization WFP World Food Program CPRN Community Conflict Prevention and Response PRADET Psychosocial Recovery and Development in East Timor Alfela Legal Assistance to Women and Children NGO Non Government Organization MAG Martial Art Group CCTV Closed Circuit television IOM International Organization for Migration NDI National Democratic Institute OIPAS Observatorio da Igreja Paraos Assuntos Socials 3 Table of Contents: 1. Executive Summary .................................................................................................................................. 5 PROGRESS ACHIEVED ........................................................................................................................... 5 4. Problems Encountered and Lessons Learned ........................................................................................ 27 5. Cost Overruns ......................................................................................................................................... 28 6. Success Stories ...................................................................................................................................... 28 7. Conclusion and Way Forward ................................................................................................................. 34 4 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Belun’s Early Warning, Early Response (EWER) system continued monitoring for violent incidents and changes to human security indicators throughout the CSM-SSD program, which supports the operation of the EWER system in 5 municipalities (Ainaro, Baucau, Dili, Oekusi and Viqueque). Please note that these municipalities changed on 19 August 2014, as the first CSM-SSD contract amendment was approved by the Agreement Officer.. The Early Warning, Early Response (EWER) system uses a volunteer monitoring network to gather data and information about incidents of violence and situational change in all 13 municipalities of Timor-Leste. 86 monitors operating in 43 administrative posts collect the data, which is then transmitted to the Belun office for analysis by 5 members of the EWER Management team and entry into the EWER database by 13 Municipals Coordinators. This project’s first contract was from 13 September 2013-12 September 2016, with Belun awarded the USAID grant and Fundasaun Mahein as sub-grantee with Belun for 3 years. In 13 September 2016 the project was extended to monitoring electoral Violence for suku Election, 2017 Presidential Election and Parliament Election. For a total of four years Belun implemented this project from 13 September 2013 and end of the project 12 September 2017. PROGRESS ACHIEVED ER 1. 1: Civil Society monitoring results are published on a regular basis, providing timely and reliable informational and analytical reports on the security sector to the Secretariat of State for Security, Civil Society and Timorese public; Indicator 1 Due for reporting Annual Target Full program (Y1-Y3) result # of regular reports on Quarterly 12 37 Human Security and Threats to Public Safety and Progress towards Security Sector Development published Belun’s Crowdmap includes incidents from 36 months. Fundasaun Mahein (FM) also completed at least one blog post every month, but often many more, with a total of 114 blog posts from 36 months. In FY14, Fundasaun Mahein kept up to date, even surpassing the goals set out for it in this Indicator. Over the past three quarters of FY14 Fundasaun Mahein published 38 blog posts on its website with 12 blog posts being published in the last quarter. This is far in excess of the stated annual goal in the Performance Management Plan of 12.In Quarter 8 (Q8) FY15, FM continued to archive its research and publications in the database, and relies heavily on the research and archived accumulated within the database for its ongoing research and reporting. FM during Q8 FY14 also identified a method for improving the database, wherein the information and reports archived by FM within the database would directly link to the Fundasaun Mahein webpage, and thus provide access to FM's mission, ongoing operations, related reports, contact information, etc. Indicator 2 Due for reporting Annual target Full program (Y1-Y3) result 5 # of issue-based Quarterly 32 120 (FY14: 50; FY15: reports produced and 35; FY16: 35) disseminated to national stakeholders The target of 32 issue-based reports for FY14 was surpassed in Q3, and 50 reports were published by CSM-SSD in Y1 since it started in September 2013. This includes 2 Conflict Potential Analysis reports (1 in Q1 and 1 in Q4), 11 monthly situation reviews, and 7 alerts. Belun also released an updated and condensed version of a 2012 policy brief on the process for Veteran’s payments in Q4. FM published 27 Mahein Nia Lian reports and 2 Mahein’s Thoughts reports since the beginning of FY14. The target of 32 issue-based reports for Y2 was surpassed, and 35 reports were published by CSM-SSD in year 2. In year 2 Belun published 1 Conflict Potential Analysis reports, 12 monthly situation reviews over the four quarters, and 3 alerts over the 4 quarters. Belun also released one Policy brief about elderly pension in Q2 FY15. FM published 16 Mahein Nia Lian reports and 2 Mahein’s Thoughts reports in FY15. The target of 32 issue-based reports for Y3 was surpassed, and 35 reports were published by CSM-SSD in year 3. This includes 12 monthly situation reviews over the four quarters, and 4 alerts over the 4 quarters, 1 Conflict potential Analysis and 1 policy brief. FM published 13 Mahein Nia Lian reports and 4 Mahein’s Thoughts reports in FY16. A 1.2.1: Accurate Situation Reviews generated periodically; Thematic Policy Briefs and Conflict Potential Analysis Reports published annually and Alerts published when situation meets EWER criteria; Press Releases and Articles reflecting EWER reporting, analysis and data are circulated to the print media and radio; EWER Situation Reviews, EWER Alerts and EWER Conflict Potential Analysis report were published online in Tetun and English at http://belun.tl/en/publications/ and disseminated through Belun’s Mailchimp listserv. The publication of Situation Reviews is one of the two key ways (along with the presentation of monitoring data at the administrative post level, shares incident and situation data with the Timorese public to enable them to engage on security sector issues. List of Publications - EWER Monthly Situation Reviews (43 total) were published from September 2013-August 2017). In November and December 2014, the situation review was published in one report. - EWER Alerts totaled 18 during four years of project implementation for CSM-SSD/MEV - EWER Annual Conflict Potential Analysis (1) from October 2013-September 2014 and one Trimestral report from June 2013-September 2013. - EWER Policy Brief Reports (3 in total) were published during the 3 years of the CSM-SSD project: 1) The social Impact of the current Administrative processes for veterans payment, 2) Elderly Pensions and Conflict in Timor-Leste and 3) EWER Policy recommendation 2009-2015 Success and Challenges in Implementation. - EWER Press Release: Key project