NEW DIRECTIONS Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT three types of transportation: three types requires convenience andchoice maximum VROXWLRQ system andbalanced offers that A complete PRELOLW\ RQHVL]H¿WVDOO QR LV 7KHUH residents, investmentandaskilledworkforce. DQ regions aretheonesthatsucceedinattracting ,Q ORFDWH increasingly competitiveworld,highlymobile EXVLQHVVHV ZKHUH LQÀXHQFHV people choosetoliveandwork.Inturn,this and environmentalprosperity. Itaffects where Mobility isoneofthekeystoeconomic,social We could notagreemore! OVERVIEW OVERVIEW ‡ ‡ ‡

MUNITY transit)and local (rail,Public air, buses inter-community (cars,Private roadsandhighways) (walkingActive andcycling) -COM TER RVICE E 2014 17, April Moving to build a seamless transportation network across the province. weIf wantto boostproductivity andgrow our economy, weneed Ontario Forward IN US S M B ULT I-M O DA L TRANSPORTATION T E

R

G M O PARTNERSHIP I

N

T A

R L

A S

N PUBLIC Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities

S

I

T

U

R

B

A

N

T

R

G A

H N S

- I P T E R R F A OR IL M AN

AIL HIGH-SPEED R NEW DIRECTIONS  stakeholders. levels of government someprivate andincludes amongall isscattered which individual pieces, of istheownership the theprocess Complicating arestillabsent. Others but theyplace, requireinnovative development. arealreadyin puzzle publictransportation the In Southwestern Ontario, some of the pieces aseamlesspicture. toand allmust form interlock of must shaped beprecisely puzzle. piece Each like agiant jigsaw somewhat assembling is that thissituation isacomplex process correct can system that and integrated publictransportation buildinganddelivering acomplete Designing, alternatives of lack a is travel.to car result The potential. full its systemtransportation has not beendeveloped to public the because orbalanced complete neither is regions–mobility American other North In Southwestern Ontario today – as in many April 2016 PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT Other regions throughout North America are America regionsthroughoutNorth Other largeas thisjobwillbe,As beavoided. itcannot sustainability. andlong-term competitiveness ZLOOFRQWULEXWHVLJQL¿FDQWO\WRWKLVUHJLRQ¶V system that of publictransportation the type systems. Itisintended asaguideto building andprovincial ofournational transportation future the concerning policy andfunding decisions presented by public upcoming opportunities inseizingseveralSouthwestern Ontarians hasbeenpreparedtoThis tool kit assist Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities investment. we ensure we receive not to –andhow do but whether afford we can the task, this undertake to most afford can we whether value fromFor Southwestern isnot Ontario, thechoice our to live,places andinvest. work to remakechallenges themselves aspreferred now addressingtheir own publictransportation oxfordcounty.ca PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT for theothers. developed largelyinisolation andwithout regard hasbeen andfunding, legislation, ownership system. mode, Each operating under scattered Southwestern publictransportation Ontario played akey roleintheevolution of thecurrent has A failureto develop partnerships andnurture of modeisimpossible. each systemseamless that makes use themaximum and aneffective delivery. partnerships, Without toapproach policy, planning, funding and service isapartnership piece the others. Thispuzzle thedevelopment andmust precede concept of that to iscentral thewhole piece is onepuzzle initself, there isimportant puzzle transportation of thecomplete public piece each While PARTNERSHIPS Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities NEW DIRECTIONS IRUSXEOLFWUDQVSRUWDWLRQ¶VJHQHUDOO\ORZVKDUH accounts partially America North across regions providers in and funding of numerous service plans policies, the failuretolink The Ontario. This situation isnot uniqueto Southwestern andinter-regional intra- for their trips. for thosetravellers whousepublic transportation privately-funded operators overlap andcompete result and hasbeenasituation wherepublicly- The theircoordinating services. and connecting potential thefull from by that isattainable WKHLURZQSLHFHRIWKHSX]]OHEXWQRQHEHQH¿WVprovider –publicorprivate –strives to maximize legislatively orinstitutionally. service Each operationally, connect rarely pieces individual the The result hasbeenadisjointed system where April 2016 PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT WKH3DFL¿F1RUWKZHVW Carolinaand New England, North as Northern asdiverse inregions corridors rail-based to other models have beenapplied Alternative partnership services. busandtransit rail,the inter-community governments,and municipal providers andthe of federal, the state, between regional partnerships as jointly funded, managedandoperated have beenrecast approach, thesecorridors Usingajoint authority powers in California. be theoneemployed onthreerailcorridors system, transportation auseful modelcould ,QUHHQYLVLRQLQJ6RXWKZHVWHUQ2QWDULR¶VSXEOLF results.revenue andcost-recovery –andwithimpressivethis challenge ridership, some progressive U.S. regionsarenow meeting However, continent-wide. market travel the of Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities inter-community busesand local transit in many California communities. Photo courtesy of Amtrak. The partnership approach provides travellers with direct connections between intercity trains, Others arestillabsent. Others place, but they require innovative development. arealreadyin puzzle publictransportation the In Southwestern Ontario, some of the pieces public its own multi-modal of required to thepieces create andconnect craft the freight railways) Southwestern can Ontario providers (including andthe service agencies, governments, and public Crown corporations federal, the provincial andmunicipal include that andpartnerships leadership with Only of thepast. andmodalboundaries jurisdictional techniques that have cut across the self-imposed delivery governance, management andservice innovative the produced otherin ofthe partners andthebuy- was Thisleadership not acceptable. governments approach as usual” that a“business byrealization oneormoreof theaffected was driven by the partnerships multi-modal In each case, thecreation of theseinnovative transportation puzzle. transportation oxfordcounty.ca PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT high activity levels makehigh activity can them generators of metres, approximatelya distance their 800 appropriate zoning landwithin forthesurrounding by areaccompanied terminals multi-modal When andbeverages. asfood appealing, such journey more public transportation multi-modal that make goods purchase a can passengers they retail outlets where shouldalso contain Ideally, facilities. andpick-up drop-off passenger and their journey by ampleparking including of those whomake foraportion useof thecar provide terminals for well,As multi-modal andfast. barrier-free simple, modes the between transfers passenger andintegrates by others allthe connects making that physically puzzle public transportation provide terminals of the the piece Multi-modal MULTIMODAL TERMINALS Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities NEW DIRECTIONS GO Transit andprivately-operated busservices. transit line transitroutes, withother urban VIA, UDLO OLJKW 5HJLRQ¶V :DWHUORR FRQQHFW WR WHUPLQDO development of thenew multi-modal Kitchener isbeingtakenA similarapproach inthe *XHOSK¶VGRZQWRZQUHYLWDOL]DWLRQSODQ of part integral an is station, railway historic 7KLVPLOOLRQIDFLOLW\ZKLFKLQFOXGHVWKHFLW\¶V andGreyhound. Rail, railandbusservice, GO TransitGuelph VIA routes, italsoaccommodates interchange timed asthe point forseveralServing Station. Central Guelph municipally-owned hub is the that isnow emergingasamobility terminal example multi-modal An of aneffective LQWRZKDWLVGH¿QHGDVDPRELOLW\KXE development. theseterminals Thistransforms residential andcommercial of transit-oriented Guelph Central Station April 2016 PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT inter-governmental cooperation. By acquiring and inter-governmental Byacquiring cooperation. development for intermodal and beacatalyst can planningand terminal of how multi-modal inmanyprojects regions of theU.S. areexamples development corridor rail-based The successful usage. publictransportation discourage integration. impediments Such is noservice other,each they donot andthere sharefacilities with contact inclose various public modescome therearemanyWhile wherethe locations eventually hubs. could into mobility blossom providers to that terminals develop multi-modal haveattempts beenmade by any of theservice Elsewhere in Southwestern few Ontario, Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities of it. of development component isa major andearly terminal potentialrealize full its ifmulti-modal only will Ontario Southwestern for strategy integrated, public transportation An multi-modal initiated projects. these that haveoperators publicagencies andthe WKH SDVVHQJHUV WR ÀRZHG KDYH EHQH¿WV 7KH of facilities. providing theirown stand-alone to consolidate operations to eliminate thecost providers have service beenableto encourage andstate agencies municipalities terminals, UH¿WWLQJH[LVWLQJUDLOZD\VWDWLRQVDVPXOWLPRGDO oxfordcounty.ca Amtrak PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT VDOVWDHSFDHHFPRGH¶V HDFK SDFNDJH WUDYHO VHDPOHVV D of aspart transit adequate urban Without with theother publicmodes. geographiccoverage andconnectivity access, KLQJHRQXUEDQWUDQVLW¶VIUHTXHQF\HDVHRI journey fortheirfull XVH may public transportation RU GULYH WR GHFLVLRQ WUDYHOOHU¶V $ MRXUQH\V andinter-regional ofcar-freecomponent intercity PLOH´ ODVW ³¿UVW DQG WKH VXSSOLHV ,W SOD\ WR UROH hasanequallyimportant transit urban puzzle, of theregionalpublictransportation apiece As to invest. andwherebusinesses choose work, people make aboutwherethey want to live and decisions inthe asfactors areincreasing quality isobvious.dependent and onthecar quantity Its less communities needsandmaking mobility transit inaddressinglocal The roleof urban URBAN TRANSIT Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities NEW DIRECTIONS WRWKHLQWHUFLW\PRGHVKDVEHHQGLI¿FXOWWRMXVWLI\ improvements to urban transit to act as a feeder aresult, investing As worse. situation made the in have only operated busservices inter-community RailCanadaandprivately- toVIA Reductions inSouthwestern Ontario. service of intercity thisisth Compounding marginally. to transithave, to date, eased thisproblem contributions federal andprovincial funding have Recentand operating costs been barriers. coverage andfrequency, capital theincreased the needto increase their transit service many recognize challenge. While municipalities However, isa transit urban delivering enhanced iscompromised. car inproviding analternative effectiveness tothe Woodstock Transit. BruceChessell, Woodstock SentinelReview e generalinfrequency April 2016 PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT downtown Kitchener. with theintercity modes ina direct connection 5HJLRQ¶V :DWHUORR provide linewill light transit rail high-frequency  LQ FRPSOHWHG :KHQ and private busservices. withGO, provideswhich direct connections VIA Station, Central Guelph the municipally-owned emphasisheavy of on the“hubbing” itsroutes at The 2012 revamping Transit of Guelph a placed system onaregionalbasis. public transportation ERRVWXUEDQWUDQVLW¶VUROHDVDFRPSRQHQWRIWKH that will areengagedinprojects cities Ontario Despite these challenges, someSouthwestern Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities of government. , s VLJQL¿FDQW¿QDQFLDOVXSSRUWIURPWKHXSSHUOHYHOV n o i g e r . S require will providers transit municipal Ontario, . U l a r e v e system. To s inSouthwestern make areality this n i d e t a r multi-modal a successful t s n o m e d n of transitisan indispensable component urban e e b s a h s A for London. new transitvisionandimplementation strategy WKHVHLVWKH6KLIWLQLWLDWLYHZKLFKZLOOGH¿QHD system.a seamless, region-wide among Notable to consider how it can better improvements transit provide moreopportunities perform as part ofIn other studies current communities, of urban public transportation public transportation oxfordcounty.ca City of London: Shift. City ofLondon: PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT of the industry itself, these include a lack of of itself, alack include these industry of the RSLQLRQ WKH ,Q  PDQ\ DUH VHUYLFH EXV 2QWDULR¶V of SouthwesternThe reasonsforthecontraction many smaller communities. option for provided theonlypublictransportation subsidized by themainroutes often andwhich the light-density feeder servicespoints Highway alongthe 401 corridor. are Gone that were cross- travel main between no-frills provides low-cost, Today, to onethat hasdeclined largely thisnetwork 100more than largeandsmallcommunities. of privately-operated busroutes that connected by aweb was served Southwestern once Ontario INTERCOMMUNITY BUS SERVICE INTERCOMMUNITY Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities NEW DIRECTIONS more than100 km. of trips passenger trainsforintercity comfortable travel of istheattractiveness and morespacious appealofbus declining inthe factor Another inexpensive, convenient andcomfortable. subsidies, travel car isstill perceived by many as car. Even though itishighlydependent onpublic byone experienced railandtransitoperators: the $WLWVURRWWKHEXVLQGXVWU\¶VSUREOHPLVWKHVDPH that prevents innovation costs. andincreases and GOTransit, system andaprovincial regulatory RailCanada asVIA such carriers publicly-funded to theotherconnections modes, from competition April 2016 PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT routes have operating direct included grants, initiatives existing new to launch orsustain bus andprivateagencies operators. Low-cost public between resulted frompartnerships have The U.S. busservices inter-community buses serve. the thecommunities only journeying between who arenot travelling onward by trainandare forthose They mobility alsoprovide stand-alone areas. deliversinurban transit last mile” service URXWHVSURYLGHDUXUDOYHUVLRQRIWKH³¿UVWDQG thesebus services, railpassenger intercity networks regionalpublictransportation several successful inpart of a multi-model system is demonstrated the by as busservice The usefulness of inter-community U.S. As feedersor therearenolongertracks to onwhich operate. would exceed therequirements where railservice to theis well suited routes andrural forinter-community core system. It play inaregionalpublictransportation However, roleto busdoeshave the animportant Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities piece of thepuzzle. piece VHUYLFHLVDPDMRU±DQGFXUUHQWO\GH¿FLHQW±system bus istobecomplete, inter-community WUDQVSRUWDWLRQ SXEOLF 2QWDULR¶V 6RXWKZHVWHUQ ,I province. the throughout ofcounties inahandful launched mobility. Test have projects previously been programs to improve andinter-community rural funding to governments assist local withpilot provincial government hassaiditwillprovide Southwestern Ontario may be at hand. The in anapproach totest such opportunity The transit services. railand with may passengers where connect terminals, intermodal provision ofpublicly-funded interest grants fornew loansor andthe buses falls,low- short guarantees againstoperating Photo courtesy of the Ontario Motor Coach Association oxfordcounty.ca PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT weekday inandoutofToronto. peaktrips am/pm system by vary route, someoperating onlyfor (GTHA). levels onthisexpanded Theservice blanketing theGreater Toronto andHamilton Area Toronto-centred, railandbusnetwork multi-route Lakeshore Linein1967, hasgrowninto GO a onthe railservice asaone-line Started RI*2¶VVHUYLFHWHUULWRU\ system, areaswest the including transportation 0HWUROLQ[KDYHDQLPSDFWRQWKHUHJLRQ¶VSXEOLF provided by provincially-owned bus services east Southwestern itonlyserves Ontario Although of Kitchener, the GO Transit rail and GO TRANSIT Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities NEW DIRECTIONS XUQOSRLHWH DJVEQ¿WWR EHQH¿WV ODUJHVW WKH SURYLGHV FXUUHQWO\ GOroutes, theLakeshore thesetwo LineOf frequent service. the Lakeshore Line willprovide faster andmore GLUHFWLRQVGDLO\(OHFWUL¿FDWLRQDQGXSJUDGLQJRI eventually will inboth frequently operate service program. Theweekday-only rail Kitchener Forward Moving Ontario under the$29-billion are likely to beexpanded over decade thenext All to Aldershot. Lakeshore railservice all-day to Kitchener, andthe services andBarrie, Guelph have railandbus arethe greatest the impact For Southwestern theGOroutes Ontarians, that April 2016 PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT KO*¶SDQG [DVRZOLPSURYH ZLOO of H[SDQVLRQ section easternmost inthe mobility SODQQHG *2¶V :KLOH SUR¿WDEOHURXWHVRQZKLFK*2LVQRZFRPSHWLQJ routes, by were which cross-subsidized the 2QWDULR XQSUR¿WDEOH 6RXWKZHVWHUQ RI RSHUDWRUV to thetermination bybeen acontributor thebus to Ithas London also andSarnia. Kitchener through service resulted intheVIA inareduction and private busoperators. has Thiscompetition operated to andpoints Kitchener west by VIA These routes compete with thosetraditionally on someSouthwestern communities. Ontario have alsohada negative effect and busservices However, rail of Kitchener theintroduction GO bus routes at Toronto Union Station. withother may GOrailand Ontario alsoconnect Southwestern from points. passengers VIA intermediate toreach touseGO passengers stations allows andOakville the sharedAldershot 5DLO&DQDGD¶V:LQGVRU/RQGRQ7RURQWRWUDLQVDW As well, made thedirect connections with VIA theirjourney by andcompleting Aldershot GO. RIWKH*7+$¶VKLJKZD\FRQJHVWLRQE\SDUNLQJDW drove to Toronto andfrom now avoid can some Southwestern Many Ontarians. whopreviously Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities

QXLJ 2 [DVREQ¿WPQDQG PDQ\ EHQH¿WV none.harms H[SDQVLRQ *2 HQVXULQJ existing with andcoordination consultation mandatory Revising toinclude legislation the 2006. Act, is through thecurrent review of theMetrolinx carriers to safeguard theseservices The opportunity Kitchener. is of their routes thaton theportions extend west of one provided by other operators, particularly services possible the andreduce destabilize will a mannerthat Southwestern Ontario, means it should not be done in of oxfordcounty.ca PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT performing up to their full potential, although both both although anduseful service. do provide anecessary potential, full their to up performing QRW DUH URXWHV 2QWDULR 6RXWKZHVWHUQ WZR 9,$¶V Theresult levels isthat comparable of service. DQG todeliver Canada hasnever opportunity hadthe LQVWLWXWLRQDO ¿QDQFLDO RI Rail VIA operational federally-operated factors, YDULHW\ D )RU world. aroundthe regions operating inthriving systems now integrated publictransportation of themany isat thecore service passenger rail intercity Fast, andaffordable frequent HIGHPERFORMANCE RAIL Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities NEW DIRECTIONS

to passengerservice. KLJKHURQQHZHOHFWUL¿HGOLQHVGHGLFDWHGVROHO\ operateswhich at or speedsof 240 km/hour (HSR), rail and high-speed trains, freight with itshares ontracks speeds upto160 km/hour 9,$¶VFXUUHQWVHUYLFHZKLFKODUJHO\RSHUDWHVDW system. Itisaproven middlegroundbetween publictransportation of amulti-modal as part (HPR) option foroptimizing isaneffective rail rail ashigh-performance known an approach hasdemonstrated that experience Worldwide April 2016 PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT service inthefuture. service demand that willleadto amoreintensive HSR optionterm beusedto that build can themarket near- asanaffordable described isoften HPR There are currently sixhigh-performance rail corridors inthe U.S. andmore than adozen are underdevelopment. Photo courtes More and better local and regional andregional local andbetter More transit stations Improved, fully-accessible connections and performance on-time Better all-weather and comfort Enhanced reliability onboard travel Reduced door-to-door times amenities Increased HPR offers: frequency locomotives androllingwith modern stock, km/hour atit. Operating speedsupto 200 previouslyon thepublicfunds invested in andbuilds of aconventional railservice HPR incrementally improves incrementally allaspects Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities Ontario. forSouthwestern andconsidered to beanalyzed exists HSRline,Windsor forHPR theopportunity Toronto-London- potential a studying government provincial options, andthe railpassenger its thefederalWith government now reviewing the other modesof publictransportation. improvements with to incoordination especially to provide analternative travel, toservice car that demonstrate of amodernized theability rail improvements recovery andcost been ridership 9,$¶V6RXWKZHVWHUQ2QWDULRURXWHV7KHUHVXOWKDV foundon similartothose operating conditions and demographics distances, with U.S. corridors isbeingtaken approach The HPR onseveral propulsion. fromdiesel alsobeconverted to electric can warrant it,HPR theconditions Where service. pathwayaffordable to faster andmorefrequent improvements at step each alongaphasedand A majoradvantage of isthat HPR itdelivers oxfordcounty.ca y of Amtrak PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT centres that are 300-1,000 km apart, with few with apart, km that are300-1,000 centres top speedsof major at between least 240 km/h Transportation with asafrequent express service + 6 5 L V G Hworldwide. ¿  or being planned are now under construction Q H GEuropean Several countries. more HSRroutes E \ W in13 and other Asian corridors on high-volume K H 8 beenimplementedJapan in1964, HSRhassince  6  in Introduced limits. speedandcapacity their ' H S raillineshave Dgenerally whenoriginal reached U W P undertaken service, railpassenger of intercity H Q W rail(HSR)High-speed istheultimate evolution R I  HIGHSPEED RAIL Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities NEW DIRECTIONS demand. other modes,aswell as the from of passengers largenumbers attract It must, therefore, to bepredicated onitsability construction. andinfrastructure way acquisition right-of- involves andtime-consuming costly lines,HSR original onthe alignments than of theneedfornewBecause andstraighter areas. terminal urban constrained VKDUHWUDFNZLWKRWKHUW\SHVRIUDLOWUDI¿FLQdedicated rights-of-way, althoughthey often grade-separated, powered onfully andoperate areelectrically trains stops. HSR intermediate German 280-km/hInter-City Express high-speed train inducing additional travel additional inducing April 2016 PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION TOOL KIT described as high-performance rail, not HSR. rail, not HSR. ashigh-performance described wouldlower-speed moreaccurately be services alternatives These hasbeencommissioned. diesel and electric that 200-km/h includes In addition to the EA, a business case province inlate tothe 2016.recommendations analysis of Transport David Collenette, whowillprovide Minister hasbeenentrusted to former project Kitchener, LondonAirport, andWindsor. The HSR linelinkingToronto, Pearson International environment assessment (EA) fora300-km/h LQ SRWHQWLDO andinitiatedSouthwestern apreliminary Ontario +65¶V UHH[DPLQH WR LQWHQWLRQ LWV In 2014, announced theGovernment of Ontario investment.only limited private-sector substantial publicfunding andwould likely attract FRXOG\LHOGPRELOLW\EHQH¿WVEXWLWZRXOGUHTXLUH feasibleand study determined itwas technically Corridor. of theQuebec-Windsor Each portions the 1970s to allor forpossibleapplication HSR hasbeenstudied numerous timessince Advancing Southwestern Ontario’s Public Transportation Opportunities Bombardier’s 240-km/h Acela Express on Amtrak’s Northeast Corridor. Ontario. system forSouthwesternpublic transportation UHTXLUHPHQWVDQGWKHEHQH¿WVRIDPXOWLPRGDO the address co-operatively to government of foralllevelsof HSRprovide anopportunity analysis case andbusiness EA current The HSR service. communities that would be bypassed by thenew forthose the existing rail passenger services would betheretention andimprovement of to beconsidered as high-volume Also feeders. systems transit toact busandurban community improvements rail, inter- tosupport connecting wouldHSR inSouthwestern require and Ontario hasbeendemonstratedAs inother regions, route. anewsegments, Kitchener-London including FRUULGRUVDQGWKHFRQVWUXFWLRQRI³JUHHQ¿HOG´OLQH of theexistingthe upgrading rail of portions threeoptions beingstudiedAll would involve Photo courtesy of Amtrak oxfordcounty.ca © Oxford County, 2016 For questions or permission to reproduce contact: 519-539-9800 | 1-800-755-0394 [email protected] oxfordcounty.ca

Developed in partnership with Greg Gormick, On Track Strategies Design by Rhonda Franks, Baseline Creative