Soldiers of Christ : Evangelicals and India, 1784-1833
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
This electronic thesis or dissertation has been downloaded from the King’s Research Portal at https://kclpure.kcl.ac.uk/portal/ Soldiers of Christ : evangelicals and India, 1784-1833. Carson, Penelope Susan Elizabeth The copyright of this thesis rests with the author and no quotation from it or information derived from it may be published without proper acknowledgement. END USER LICENCE AGREEMENT Unless another licence is stated on the immediately following page this work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International licence. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ You are free to copy, distribute and transmit the work Under the following conditions: Attribution: You must attribute the work in the manner specified by the author (but not in any way that suggests that they endorse you or your use of the work). Non Commercial: You may not use this work for commercial purposes. No Derivative Works - You may not alter, transform, or build upon this work. Any of these conditions can be waived if you receive permission from the author. Your fair dealings and other rights are in no way affected by the above. Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact [email protected] providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Download date: 04. Oct. 2021 1 SOLDIERS OF CHRIST: EVANGELICALS AND INDIA, 1784-1833 Thesis submitted for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in the University of London by PENELOPE SUSAN ELIZABETH CARSON King's College, London 1988. 2 ABSTRACT Much scholarship has been attracted to the history of missions, yet surprisingly scant attention has been paid to the early development of British policy towards missionary activity in India. This thesis provides the first detailed and systematic analysis of this policy, charting the changes that occurred from the early eighteenth century, when SPCK-sponsored missionaries were the only Protestant missionaries in India, to 1833, when there were twelve missionary societies at work. Central to this analysis is an examination of the Inclusion of a 'pious clause', affirming Britain's duty to provide for the moral and religious improvement of India, In the Company's 1813 charter. It will be argued that this inclusion was an ambiguous 'success' for the missionary lobby. The impact of 1813 can only be assessed by taking into account the two worlds in which decisions about India were made. The first was that of domestic politics in which Dissenters, Church Evangelicals, Government and the Company pursued complex aims which evolved into the compromise of 1813. The 1813 campaign was an episode In a long-running story of inter-Church and Church-Dissent politics. The second world was that of India. This was a world in which missionaries faced long years of toil and hostility. 3 Despite all efforts to the contrary, Christianity was increasingly resented by Indians as an arm of the colonial power and a threat to their religious, economic and social order. British officials were cautious in the face of this. Difficulties for the missionaries were compounded by the generally unhelpful attitudes of the new bishops, which reinforced High Church prejudices against evangelical missionaries. The 1813 political decision had little impact on the practicalities of the Indian situation and, far from being the resounding success that convention believes, was a circumscribed victory for the missionary lobby. 4 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I cannot commence my acknowledgements without a heart-felt thank-you to Peter Marshall, my supervisor. He has been generous with his time and advice and rigorous with his comments. These past four years have been a time of great learning and development for me. I particularly value Professor Marshall's enthusiasm and encouragement. I also owe a great debt to Doug Peers. We have had long conversations &bout 'militarism' and the influence of the 'Wellesley Kindergarten' . He has saved me time in the India Office by pointing me towards relevant references. Last, but not least, he has read my final draft and made valuable comments. I have also had many useful discussions with Barbara Schwegmann and am extremely grateful to her for reading and criticising my draft. John Dinwiddy has provided helpful advice and references, not to speak of encouraging me to embark on this PhD in the first place. I thank Teotonlo de Souza for directing me towards references on Catholic history, for his helpful comments on Chapter 8 and for many animated discussions on the 'imperial yoke and its aftermath'. Alan Scadding kindly proof-read my first four chapters. I am very grateful to the Irwin Fund of London University for a grant which enabled me to research in India for three 5 months. This has greatly enriched chapters 3,4, 5 and 8. The trip was invaluable for helping me understand the complexities of Indian society and the problems that were faced by the early missionaries In trying to propagate Christianity. I am also grateful to the British Academy for my three-year studentship, to the Historical Fund of the Institute of Historical Research for paying for the binding and copying of this thesis, and to Epsom College I or assisting me in Its final production. I should also like to thank the librarians and staff of the many archives and libraries in which I worked. I am also greatly indebted to many friends in India: to Bishop and Mrs Mani at Kottayani; to the Allenby's, Dr David and Fr Correia-Afonso in Bombay; to Fr Kathew and Rev Naidu and his family in Hyderabad; to Dr and Mrs John and Fr Kuriakose in Barigalore; to Rev Azariah in Madras; to Professor Ray, Dr John and Dinesh Dey in Calcutta and Dr Mukhopadhyay and Mr Chatterjee in Serampore. Last, and certainly not least, I thank Hugh, my husband, for his constant encouragement and support. He has found the time in a very busy work-schedule to read numerous drafts, to help me with my maps and photocopying the thesis. He must know nearly as much about missionaries as I do now. Finally, any errors that might remain are, of course, mine alone. 6 CONTENTS Abbrevi at loris 8 Introduction 10 1. The Wisdom of the Serpent and the Innocence of the Dove a. The Evangelical Army 15 b. The Early Years of British 19 Missionary Interest c. The Beginnings of Hostility: The Indian Situation 32 d. The Beginnings of Hostility: Changes in Britain 37 e. A Missionary Proposal for Bengal 39 2. T1e 1790s: A Time of Crisis a. The 1793 Renewal of the East India Company's Charter 51 b. The Impact of the French Revolution i In Britain 60 ii The Haldane Mission Proposal 63 iii On Evangelicals 68 iv On India 76 3 Missionary Activity in India 1793-1806 a. North India 91 b. South India 107 4. The Vellore Mutiny 117 5. The Troubled Years: 1807-12 a. The Persian Pamphlet Controversy 159 b. Missionaries and the Company, 1807-12 177 c. Church/Dissent Rivalry 187 6. The 1813 Renewal of the Company's Charter a. The Ground Laid 197 b. The Parliamentary Battle 213 c. The Battle Won: Whose Victory 238 7. Missions, Dissent and People: The Politics of Pressure a. The Popular Appeal of Missions 254 b. The Mobilisation of the People I Publicity 260 Ii The B&FBS: A society for All? 266 c. Missions, Dissent and Government 270 d. The Petitioning Campaign, April-June 1813 283 e. Trade and Christianity: An Alliance Against Monopoly? 297 7 f. Conclusion 301 8. The Walls of Jericho: Missionaries and India, 1813-1833. a. The Court of Directors 310 b. The Evangelical View 319 c. Bengal Presidency 322 d. Bombay Presidency 335 e. Madras Presidency i Tinnevelly 340 ii Travancore 346 iii Mysore 359 iv Tranquebar, Madras and the Northern Circars 364 Conclusion: Ezekiel's Dry Bones 387 Appendices 1. Map of Mission Stations 1813 400 2. Map of Mission Stations 1833 401 3. List of Missionaries 1706-1833 402 4. Chronology of Events 1812-13 409 5. Extracts from 53.GIII.c. 155 411 6. Petitions April-June 1813 412 Bibliography 413 8 ABBREVIATIONS a. General Add MSS Additional Manuscripts AL Angus Library B&FBS British and Foreign Bible Society BCL Bristol City Library BL British Library Bod Bodleian Library BNS Baptist Missionary Society CSBC College Street Baptist Church Commons Journals CMS Church Missionary Society CUL Cambridge University Library DRO Devon Record Office Eu r European EUL Edinburgh University Library DUL Durham Univeristy Library I DL India Office Library I OR India Office Records LNS [London] Missionary Society MS( S] Manuscript(s) NLS National Library of Scotland NLW National Library of Wales NRO Northants Record Office NUL Nottingham University Library Periodical Accounts The Parliamentary Debates from the Year 1803, Parliamentary Papers PSPRL Protestant Society for the Protection of Religious Liberty RTS Religious Tract Society SNS Scottish Missionary Society SPCK Society for the Promotion of Christian Knowledge SPG Society for the Propagation of the Gospel WMMS Wesleyan Methodist Missionary Society b. Abbreviations for India Office Records H/Misc Home Miscellaneous L/Parl Parliamentary L/PS Political and Secret BPC Bengal Public Consultations BSC Bengal Secret Consultations MPC Madras Public Consultations MSC Madras Secret Consultations Bo niP C Bombay Public Consultations BomSC Bombay Secret Consultations Eccies Ecclesiastical 9 c. Abbreviations for the [London] Missionary Society MSS The Missionary Society did not change its name to the London Missionary Society until 1818. Common usage is to refer to it as the London Missionary Society or the LMS regardless of date. In this thesis I shall use the term Missionary Society when that Is the correct name chronologically, and LMS as the abbreviation, despite the date.