DOCSLIB.ORG

Multiple Perspective of Mobile Money System Development: Action Case of E-Masary Wallet

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Multiple Perspective of Mobile Money System Development: Action Case of E-Masary Wallet Multiple Perspective of Mobile Money System Development: Action Case of e-Masary Wallet A thesis submitted to The University of Manchester for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy In the Faculty of Humanities 2015 Mostafa Mohamad Manchester Business School University of Manchester 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS ...................................................................................................................... 2 LIST OF FIGURES .............................................................................................................................. 8 LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................................................. 11 ABBREVIATIONS ............................................................................................................................ 12 DECLARATION ............................................................................................................................... 16 COPYRIGHT STATEMENT ............................................................................................................... 17 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ................................................................................................................... 18 ABSTRACT ..................................................................................................................................... 16 CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION Area of concern ................................................................................................................................. 19 1.2. Research Background ................................................................................................................... 21 1.3. Research Objectives ..................................................................................................................... 26 1.4. Research Questions ...................................................................................................................... 27 1.5. Research Approaches .................................................................................................................... 28 1.6. Research Justification and Significance ............................................................................................ 29 1.7. Potential Contribution ................................................................................................................... 32 1.7.1. Theoretical Contribution .................................................................................................................................... 32 1.7.2. Methodological Contribution............................................................................................................................. 33 1.7.3. Practical Contribution ........................................................................................................................................ 34 1.8. Thesis Structure ........................................................................................................................... 34 CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 38 2. 1. What is Systems thinking? ............................................................................................................ 40 2.1.1. Inquiry Systems in Management ....................................................................................................................... 43 2.1.1. Why System Thinking? ..................................................................................................................................... 45 2.1.2. System Thinking Approaches ............................................................................................................................ 48 2.1.3. Hard and Soft Approaches Compared ............................................................................................................... 55 2.2. Information System Development ................................................................................................... 60 2.2.1. Human Activity Analysis (HAA) ...................................................................................................................... 62 2.2.2. The Socio-Technical Systems (STS) ................................................................................................................. 64 2.2.3. Structured System Analysis (SSA) .................................................................................................................... 65 2 2.2.4. Data Modelling and Analysis ............................................................................................................................ 68 2.2.5. Technical Specification (TS) ............................................................................................................................. 70 2.2.6. A comparative analysis of ISD approaches ....................................................................................................... 74 2.2.6.1. Ontological Assumptions ...................................................................................................................... 75 2.2.6.2. Epistemological Assumptions ............................................................................................................... 76 2.2.6.3. Assumptions about Information Situation ............................................................................................. 78 2.2.7. Contingency approaches .................................................................................................................................... 80 2.3.Information System Complexity ...................................................................................................... 82 2.4.The Multiperspectives Theory ......................................................................................................... 84 2.4.1.Why the Multiperspectives theory? .................................................................................................................... 87 2.5.Multiperspectives analysis of the Base of the Pyramid ................................................................................. 88 2.5.1.Technical perspective ......................................................................................................................................... 92 2.5.2.Organizational Perspective ................................................................................................................................. 93 2.5.3.Personal Perspective ........................................................................................................................................... 94 2.6.Information System Development @ BoP .......................................................................................... 96 2.6.1. Turbulent environment: ..................................................................................................................................... 96 2.6.2. Inter-organizational systems .............................................................................................................................. 96 2.6.3.Globalisation and Decentralization ..................................................................................................................... 98 2.6.4.Technological advances ...................................................................................................................................... 98 2.6.5.Big data ............................................................................................................................................................... 99 2.7. Mobile Money System at the BoP ................................................................................................ 100 2.7.1. Digital Financial Services ................................................................................................................................ 100 2.7.2. What is Mobile Money System? ...................................................................................................................... 109 2.7.3. Systematic Review of the Mobile Money Literature ....................................................................................... 118 2.7.3.1. Framing the Literature Review............................................................................................................ 119 2.7.3.2. Settings and Context ........................................................................................................................... 124 Lessons & Conclusions ..................................................................................................................... 126 CHAPTER THREE:THEORITICAL FRAMEWORK Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 127 3.1. IS & BS intimacy ....................................................................................................................... 128 3.1.1.Alternative Information System Theories ......................................................................................................... 130 3.1.1.1.Actor Network Theory (ANT) ............................................................................................................. 130 3.1.1.2. Innovation diffusion
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Toward a Common Language for Systems
    IFSR Conversation– April 2012 Sponsored by the International Federation for Systems Research (IFSR) Team 4: Towards a Common Language for Systems Praxis © 2012 IFSR unless otherwise indicated (reprinted with permission) James Martin (USA), [email protected] (Team Leader) Johan Bendz (SE), [email protected] Gerhard Chroust (AUT), [email protected] Duane Hybertson (USA), [email protected] Harold “Bud” Lawson (SE), [email protected] Richard Martin (USA), [email protected] Hillary Sillitto (UK), [email protected] Janet Singer (USA), [email protected] Michael Singer (USA), [email protected] Tatsumasa Takaku (JP), [email protected] Abstract: We explored developing “common language for systems praxis” to help systems theorists and systems practitioners deal with the major cross-discipline, cross-domain problems facing human society in the 21st Century. For the first three days, we explored a broad range of issues, from previous efforts at standardization; to the nature of language, culture, and praxis; to the relationship between systems science, systems thinking, and systems approaches to practice. On day 4, we used Checkland’s CATWOE approach to understand the usage, context, and constraints for any common language for systems praxis. On day 5, this checklist helped us develop a diagram showing how an integrated approach to Systems Praxis could put theories from Systems Science and Systems Thinking into action through technical Systems Engineering and social Systems Intervention. We learned that the best medium for communication across different ‘tribes’ is patterns, and that a common language for systems praxis could use system patterns and praxis patterns to relate core concepts, principles, and paradigms, allowing stakeholder ‘silos’ to more effectively work together.
    [Show full text]
  • IASCYS the International Academy for Systems & Cybernetic Sciences
    IASCYS The International Academy for Systems & CYbernetic Sciences 77 Academicians (2021/04/13) -alphabetic order- 1. Mary Catherine BATESON (USA) Cultural Anthropology & Cybernetics 2. Ockert J. H. BOSCH (New Zealand) Ecology Management 3. Paul BOURGINE (France) Cognitive Sciences and Artificial Intelligence 4. Pierre BRICAGE (France) Biologist, Secretary General 5. Søren BRIER (Denmark) Systems Cybersemiotics Philosopher 6. Pille BUNNELL (Canada) Systems Ecologist 7. Tom R. BURNS (Sweden) Sociologist 8. Xiaoqiang CAI (PR China, Hong Kong) Systems Engineering and Engineering Management, 9. Jinde CAO (PR China) Artificial Intelligence 10. Antonio CASELLES MONCHO (Spain) Applied Mathematician 11. Guangya CHEN (PR China) Operations Research & Systems Engineering 12. Hanfu CHEN (PR China) Automation & Systems Control Engineering 13. Jian CHEN (PR China) Systems Engineering & Management Science 14. C.L. Philip CHEN (PR China, Macao) Intelligent Systems Engineering 15. T.C. Edwin CHENG (PR China) Business Administration 16. Gerhard CHROUST (Austria) Systems Engineering & Automation 17. Gerard de ZEEUW (Netherlands) Architectural Design 18. Zengru DI (PR China) Socio-Economics Systems Engineering 19. Georgi M. DIMIROVSKI (R. Nth Macedonia) Computer & Control Sciences, Vice-President for membership 20. Gérard DONNADIEU (France) Systems Engineering & Management 21. Jean-Pierre DUPUY (France) Risk Management & Ethics 22. Raúl ESPEJO (UK) Systems Organization & Complexity Management, WOSC President 23. Helder Manuel FERREIRA COELHO (Portugal) Artificial Intelligence Engineering 24. Charles FRANÇOIS (Belgium) Cybernetics, Systems Theory & Systems Science 25. Ranulph GLANVILLE (UK) Cybernetics & Design 26. Jifa GU (PR China) Operations Research & Systems Engineering 27. Enrique HERRSCHER (Argentina) Economist & Systems Scientist 28. Wolfgang HOFKIRCHNER (Austria) Information Science, Internet & Society 29. Tingwen HUANG (Qatar) Systems Dynamics, Control & Optimization 30. Ray ISON (Australia) Systems Governance, IFSR President 31.
    [Show full text]
  • Program and Abstracts 2016
    Program and Abstracts 2016 Realizing Sustainable Futures in Socio-Ecological Systems University of Colorado Boulder, CO, USA July 24 – 30 John J. Kineman President Table of Contents Logos of Sponsors and Affiliated Organizations ............................................................................. 2 Welcome Message, Prof. John Kineman, ISSS President .............................................................. 3 Inaugural Message, Prof. Krupanidhi, Chair, Vignan ISSS Meeting ............................................... 5 Conference Schedule ...................................................................................................................... 7 Plenary Speakers .......................................................................................................................... 27 Explanation Associating Abstracts to Plenaries (Days and Topics) .............................................. 49 List of Abstracts ............................................................................................................................. 51 Plenary Speakers Abstracts .......................................................................................................... 63 Paper Session Abstracts ............................................................................................................... 69 Workshop Abstracts .................................................................................................................... 127 Poster Abstracts .........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 19, No
    IFSR Newsletter Official Newsletter of the International Federation for Systems Research Editor-in-Chief: Gerhard Chroust Volume 34, no. 1 (September 2017) Gary S. Metcalf, Gerhard Chroust, Stefan Blachfellner Gerhard Chroust, Nam Nguyen (photo: K. Rosencrans 2017) (photo: K. Rosencrans 2017) Dear Readers! During th first half of 2017 we carried on with the dynamic issues of 2016: We published the proceedings of the 2016 Conversation After the Conversation is before the Conversations: preparations for the Conversation are under way The IFSR Book Series – our flagship has a new Editor-in-chief and very ambitious plans We honored three of our past Executive Committee members We proudly present two books published by members of our Executive Committee As you can see, your IFSR is active and reaching out for new ISSN 1818-0809 (print) activities. With our best wishes ISSN 1818-0817 (electronic) I remain yours truly Gerhard Chroust Inhaltsverzeichnis MARY C. EDSON: PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE ........................................................................................................... 1 HONORING IFSR EC MEMBERS ............................................................................................................................ 2 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2016 IFSR CONVERSATION PUBLISHED: .......................................................................... 4 TWO NEW BOOKS ON SYSTEMS THEORY ............................................................................................................ 5 GARY S. METCALF (ED.) : .............................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Systems Thinking in Action Learning and Action Research
    Special issue: Systems Thinking in Action Learning and Action Research ALAR Journal Vol 21 No 1 August 2015 ALAR Journal is published by the Action Learning, Action Research Association Inc (ALARA) . Managing editor: Susan Goff Issue editor: Debora Hammond, Shankar Sankaran and Susan Goff Editorial team in alphabetical order, for this issue: Michael Dent, Susan Goff, Vasudha Kamat, Margaret O’Connell, Zada Pajalic, Rachel Perry, Riripeti Reedy, Steve Smith, Emmanuel Tetteh, Lesley Wood Editorial inquiries: The editor, ALAR Journal ALARA Inc PO Box 1748 Toowong, Qld 4066 Australia [email protected] ALAR Journal Volume 21 No 1 August 2015 ISSN 1326-964X CONTENTS Editorial 3 Debora Hammond, Shankar Sankaran and Susan Goff Application of the Structured Dialogic Design 11 Process to Examining Economic Integration and Free Trade in Cyprus Yiannis Laouris, Tatjana Taraszow, Mustafa Damdelen, Ilke Dağlı, Derya Beyatlı, Andros Karayiannis, Kevin Dye, & Alexander N. Christakis Systemic Pedagogy: A Design for Action 53 Researcher Collective Self Development Ross Colliver, Susan Goff, Riripeti Reedy and Vicki Vaartjes ALAR Journal Vol 21 No 1 August 2015 Page 1 ALARj 21 (1) (2015) 1-2 © 2015 Action Learning, Action Research Association Inc www.alarassociation.org All rights reserved. Developing Pictorial Conceptual Metaphors as a 77 means of understanding and changing the Australian Health System for Indigenous People Bronwyn Fredericks, Kathleen Clapham, Dawn Bessarab, Patricia Dudgeon, Roxanne Bainbridge, Rowena Ball, Marlene Thompson (Longbottom),
    [Show full text]
  • Team 3: Exploring the Relationship of Systems Research to Systems Literacy
    Open Research Online The Open University’s repository of research publications and other research outputs Team 3: Exploring the relationship of systems research to systems literacy Conference or Workshop Item How to cite: Edson, Mary; Buckle Henning, Pam; Ferris, Tim; Hieronymi, Andreas; Ison, Ray; Metcalf, Gary; Mobus, George; Nguyen, Nam; Rousseau, David; Sankaran, Shankar and Tuddenham, Peter (2017). Team 3: Exploring the relationship of systems research to systems literacy. In: Systems Literacy: Proceedings of the Eighteenth IFSR Conversation 2016 (Edson, Mary C.; Metcalf, Gary S.; Tuddenham, Peter and Chroust, Gerhard eds.), pp. 64–76. For guidance on citations see FAQs. c 2017 IFSR https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Version: Accepted Manuscript Copyright and Moral Rights for the articles on this site are retained by the individual authors and/or other copyright owners. For more information on Open Research Online’s data policy on reuse of materials please consult the policies page. oro.open.ac.uk Proceedings of the 2016 IFSR Conversation Team 3: Systems Research Team Systems Research: A Foundation for Systems Literacy Edson, M.1, Buckle, P.2, Ferris, T.3, Hieronymi, A.4, Ison, R.5, Metcalf, G.6, Mobus, G.7, Nguyen, N.8, Rousseau, D.9, Sankaran, S.10, Tuddenham, P.11 1 International Federation for Systems Research, Vienna, Austria and Adelphi University, Garden City, New York, USA 2 Adelphi University, Garden City, New York, USA 3 Centre for Systems Engineering, Cranfield University, Defence Academy of the United Kingdom Shrivenham, SN6 8LA, UK 4 University of St. Gallen, St. Gallen, Switzerland 5 The Open University, Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire, UK 6 Saybrook University, Oakland, California, USA 7 University of Washington, Tacoma, Washington, USA 8 Malik Institute, St.
    [Show full text]
  • Systems Thinking and Practice in Phd Research
    ISSS2016 Graduate Systemic Inquiry Co- Laboratory Systems Thinking in Practice (STiP) in PhD Research: Realizing Sustainable Futures in Socio-Ecological Systems 22nd July – 30th July 2016, Boulder, Colorado, USA Course programme See also: http://www.coexploration.org/systemicinquiry/ NB. We will generally have morning and afternoon coffee breaks of about 30 minutes and an hour for lunch. Pre-Course Familiarise yourself Read your pre-joining Establish on-line preparation with the program for instructions contacts 15 July – 27 July the systemic inquiry. Review Key References Write Personal Mission / Purpose Morning Afternoon Evening Friday 22nd July Introductions: STiP as the ‘Walking our talk’: sharing individual conservation of grounding what has 9am-8pm research and theoretical lineages been presented in systems and traditions your own context. trajectories Implications of these Practical exercise over working as a traditions for practice; dinner critical learning research as a practice systems (CLS) Modes of research community (the PFMS heuristic) reviewing STiP Introducing systemic experience & inquiry in context of taking an overview ISSS (SI session 1) of the course resources and program Emergent issues from your own experiences of Systems Saturday 23rd July Welcoming ISSS Introducing and using Berlin alumni; systems, tools, 9am - 5pm Contextualising techniques, methods you and your PhD and methodologies research combined with group Articulating your....PFMS work; ‘model’ Skills/enthusiasm Forming inquiry audit
    [Show full text]
  • The 2018 IASCYS Yearbook
    The International Academy for SYSTEMS and CYBERNETIC SCIENCES pictures by alphabetic order IASCYS 2018 yearbook The International Academy for SYSTEMS and CYBERNETIC SCIENCES pictures by alphabetic order IASCYS 2018 yearbook IASCYS The International Academy for Systems & CYbernetic Sciences 62 Academicians (2019/01/01) -alphabetic order- 1. Mary Catherine BATESON (USA) Cultural Anthropology & Cybernetics 2. Ockert J. H. BOSCH (Australia) Quantitative Ecology & Vegetation Management, Vice-President [email protected] 3. Pierre BRICAGE (France) Biologist, Secretary General [email protected] 4. Søren BRIER (Denmark) Systems Cybersemiotics Philosopher 5. Pille BUNNELL (Canada) Systems Ecologist 6. Tom R. BURNS (Sweden) Sociologist 7. Xiaoqiang CAI (PR China) Systems Engineering and Engineering Management 8. Antonio CASELLES MONCHO (Spain) Applied Mathematician 9. Guangya CHEN (PR China) Operations Research & Systems Engineering 10. Hanfu CHEN (PR China) Automation & Systems Control Engineering 11. Jian CHEN (PR China) Systems Engineering & Management Science 12. C.L. Philip CHEN (PR China) Intelligent Systems Engineering 13. T.C. Edwin CHENG (PR China) Business Administration 14. Gerhard CHROUST (Austria) Systems Engineering & Automation 15. Gerard de ZEEUW (Netherlands) Architectural Design 16. Georgi Marko DIMIROVSKI (Macedonia) Computer & Control Sciences 17. Jean-Pierre DUPUY (France) Risk Management & Ethics 18. Raúl ESPEJO (UK) Systems Organization & Complexity Management 19. Charles FRANÇOIS (Belgium) Cybernetics, Systems Theory & Systems Science 20. Ranulph GLANVILLE (UK) Cybernetics & Design 21. Jifa GU (PR China) Operations Research & Systems Engineering,Vice-President [email protected] 22. Enrique HERRSCHER (Argentina) Economist & Systems Scientist 23. Wolfgang HOFKIRCHNER (Austria) Information Science, Internet & Society 24. Ray ISON (Australia) Systems Governance 25. Michael C. JACKSON (UK) Management Systems Scientist 26.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Systems Thinking Courses in the Master's
    SYSTEMS THINKING COURSES IN THE MASTER'S PROGRAMME ON CREATIVE SUSTAINABILITY AT AALTO UNIVERSITY: REFLECTIONS ON DESIGN AND DELIVERY OF THE 2010-2011 SESSIONS David Ing Aalto University, School of Science and Technology, Department of Industrial Engineering and Management, Espoo, Finland; and IBM Canada Ltd, 3600 Steeles Avenue East, Station B4, Markham, Ontario, Canada, L3R 9Z7 [email protected] ABSTRACT In fall 2010 and winter 2011, two new courses in systems thinking were initiated as core curriculum in the master’s programme in Creative Sustainability at Aalto University in Finland. As intensive courses, each was to be conducted as three full days of lectures over eight days, with students fulfilling credit hour requirements both independently and in group activities over a two-to-three month period. To complement the teaching staff at the university, a researcher active in the systems science community was brought in from abroad as a subject matter expert for the two courses. In the summer preceding the first session, a reading list for the courses was drawn from current leading sources in the systems sciences, starting from 2010 and linking back to prior references of relevance. Lectures were prepared as minimal critical specifications, with concepts mapped into clusters of references, with the majority of sources available electronically over the Internet. On each set of the three lecture days, the courses were delivered in a face-to-face classroom setting, coupled with group activities designed in the style of Singerian inquiring systems. Coordinating artifacts from the instructors evolved and were incrementally updated on a publicly-accessible web site, and students followed the social media style of posting their reflections on publicly-visible weblogs linked with notifications on an activity stream at a systems community hub.
    [Show full text]
  • George Klir (See Inside)
    IFSR Newsletter Official Newsletter of the International Federation for Systems Research Editor-in-Chief: Gerhard Chroust Volume 33, no. 2 (December 2016) Janie Chroust 2011 Landhaus Linz Dear Readers! We are sad to have had said Good Bye to our founding president George Klir (see inside). 2016 has been was a very busy year for the newly elected IFSR Executive Committee (see IFSR Newsletter of July 2016). Key achievements have been: The acceptance of three new IFSR members Organising the IFSR Conversation 2016 in Linz, including publishing the proceedings the relaunch of the IFSR Book Series the relaunch of our web site As you can see, your IFSR is active and reaching out for new ISSN 1818-0809 (print) activities. With our best wishes for a peaceful Holiday Season ISSN 1818-0817 (electronic) I remain yours truly Gerhard Chroust Contents MARY C. EDSON: PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE ........................................................................................................... 1 GEORGE KLIR : THANK YOU AND GOOD BYE! ................................................................................................ 2 Founding the International Federation for Systems Research (IFSR) .................................................................... 2 Founding the IFSR International Book Series on Systems Science and Engineering ......................................... 4 MARY C. EDSON: THE IFSR CONVERSATION 2016 ............................................................................................... 6 SYSTEMS LITERACY ......................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Table of Contents
    Table of Contents Sponsors and Affiliated Organizations ............................................... Inside front cover Welcome Message, Professor Ockie Bosch, ISSS President ..................................... 3 Conference Schedule .................................................................................................. 5 List of Abstracts ......................................................................................................... 21 Plenary Abstracts ...................................................................................................... 31 Presentation/Paper Abstracts .................................................................................... 39 Poster Abstracts ........................................................................................................ 99 Workshop Abstracts ................................................................................................ 103 Author Index ........................................................................................................... 113 Keywords Index ....................................................................................................... 117 Sponsors Information .............................................................................................. 126 Conference Centre Map and Local Maps ................................................................ 128 ISBN: 978-1-906740-15-3 Copyright ISSS 2017 1 2 Welcome to ISSS 2017 Vienna is internationally recognized as the cradle of Systems Science
    [Show full text]
  • Download Download
    Program & Abstracts Making Liveable, Sustainable Systems Unremarkable 53rd Meeting of The International Society for the Systems Sciences July 12-17, 2009 The University of Queensland Brisbane, Australia Hosted by The School of Integrative Systems and ANZSYS Timothy FH Allen President Co-Sponsors & Affiliated Organizations The following organizations have provided various levels of support for the ISSS 2008 conference. All have agreed to publicize the conference through their institutional networks. In addition, those so designated have provided either financial or in-kind support through participation in conference planning and facilitation. ANZSYS Australian and New Zealand Systems Society Table of Contents List of Sponsors and Affiliated Organizations ...........................................Inner front cover Welcome Message, Professor T F H Allen, ISSS President............................................. 3 Conference Schedule ....................................................................................................... 7 Plenary Speakers Biographies........................................................................................ 21 Plenary Abstracts............................................................................................................ 31 Workshop Abstracts........................................................................................................ 39 Abstracts Index ............................................................................................................... 45 Paper
    [Show full text]