Excerpted from James Gustav Speth, America, Rising to Its Dream (Forthcoming, Yale U.P., Fall 2012) * How Can We Gauge What
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
!"#$%&'$()*%+,)-.,$/)01/'.2)3&$'45))!"#$%&'()*%+%,-)./)01+)2$#'")34/$15&/"%,-()6'7#)89:9()4'77);<=;>)) 6) 7+8)#.9)8$):.1:$)84.')4./)4.&&$9$()'+)1/);9)'4$)&./')*$8)($#.($/).9() 84$%$)8$)/'.9()'+(.<=)>9$)8.<)'+).9/8$%)'4;/)?1$/';+9);/)'+)@++A).')4+8)8$) #+,&.%$)8;'4)+'4$%)#+19'%;$/);9)A$<).%$./B)3+)@$'C/)@++A).').):%+1&)+*).(2.9#$() ($,+#%.#;$/DD'4$)#+19'%;$/)+*)'4$)>%:.9;E.';+9)*+%)!#+9+,;#)F++&$%.';+9).9() G$2$@+&,$9'),;91/)'4$)*+%,$%)3+2;$')H@+#)#+19'%;$/5)I$";#+5)J1%A$<5)K+%$.5) L#[email protected](5)M1"$,H+1%:5).9()0%$$#$B)J4$)%$,.;9;9:)#+19'%;$/N9;9$'$$9)9+')#+19';9:) '4$)O9;'$()3'.'$/N#.9)H$)'4+1:4')+*)./)+1%)&$$%)#+19'%;$/B)P4.')8$)/$$)84$9)8$) @++A).')'4$/$)#+19'%;$/);/)'4.')'4$)O9;'$()3'.'$/);/)9+8).')+%)2$%<)9$.%)'4$)H+''+,);9) .)4+/')+*);,&+%'.9').%$./B)J+)+1%):%$.')/4.,$5)Q,$%;#.)9+8)4./RS) T)'4$)4;:4$/')&+2$%'<)%.'$5)H+'4):$9$%.@@<).9()*+%)#4;@(%$9U) T)'4$):%$.'$/');9$?1.@;'<)+*);9#+,$/U) T)'4$)@+8$/'):+2$%9,$9')/&$9(;9:)./).)&$%#$9'.:$)+*)0GV)+9)/+#;.@)&%+:%.,/) *+%)'4$)(;/.(2.9'.:$(U) T)'4$)@+8$/')/#+%$)+9)'4$)OWC/);9($")+*)X,.'$%;.@)8$@@DH$;9:)+*)#4;@(%$9YU) T)'4$)8+%/')/#+%$)+9)'4$)OWC/):$9($%);9$?1.@;'<);9($"U) T)'4$)@+8$/')/+#;.@),+H;@;'<U) T)'4$)4;:4$/')&1H@;#).9()&%;2.'$)$"&$9(;'1%$)+9)4$.@'4)#.%$)./).)&$%#$9'.:$)+*) 0GV5)<$').##+,&.9;$()H<)'4$)4;:4$/'R) D);9*.9'),+%'.@;'<)%.'$) D)&%$2.@$9#$)+*),$9'.@)4$.@'4)&%+H@$,/) D)+H$/;'<)%.'$) D)&$%#$9'.:$)+*)&$+&@$):+;9:)8;'4+1')4$.@'4)#.%$)(1$)'+)#+/') D)@+8)H;%'4)8$;:4')#4;@(%$9)&$%)#.&;'.)Z$"#$&')*+%)-.&.9[) !"#$%&'()*+$%"$,"-%*+!./)0/&&-%*&")/0"#-)+*-" ! -1$%2"3+*4"*4/"&4$0*/&*"1+,/"/5)/#*-%#6"-*"7+0*4"8/5#/)*",$0"9/%(-0:"-%." ;$0*'2-1<=" >"*4/"4+24/&*"#-07$%".+$5+./"/(+&&+$%&"-%."3-*/0"#$%&'()*+$%")/0"#-)+*-=" >"*4/"1$3/&*"&#$0/"$%"*4/"?$01."@#$%$(+#"A$0'(B&"@%C+0$%(/%*-1" ;/0,$0(-%#/"D%./5"8/5#/)*",$0"E/12+'(<F"-%."*4/"1-02/&*"@#$1$2+#-1"A$$*)0+%*" )/0"#-)+*-"8/5#/)*",$0"E/12+'("-%."9/%(-0:<=" >"*4/"4+24/&*"0-*/"$,",-+1+%2"*$"0-*+,6"+%*/0%-*+$%-1"-20//(/%*&=" >"*4/"1$3/&*"&)/%.+%2"$%"+%*/0%-*+$%-1"./C/1$)(/%*"-%."4'(-%+*-0+-%" -&&+&*-%#/"-&"-")/0#/%*-2/"$,"G9;=" >"*4/"4+24/&*"(+1+*-06"&)/%.+%2"+%"*$*-1"-%."-&"-")/0#/%*-2/"$,"G9;=" >"*4/"1-02/&*"+%*/0%-*+$%-1"-0(&"&-1/&=" >"*4/"($&*"%/2-*+C/"7-1-%#/"$,")-6(/%*&"8/5#/)*"H/3"I/-1-%.F"J)-+%"-%." ;$0*'2-1<=" >"*4/"1$3/&*"&#$0/&",$0"&*'./%*")/0,$0(-%#/"+%"(-*4"8/5#/)*",$0";$0*'2-1"-%." D*-16<"8-%.",-0".$3%",0$("*4/"*$)"+%"7$*4"&#+/%#/"-%."0/-.+%2<=" >"*4/"4+24/&*"4+24"$$1".0$)"$'*"0-*/"8/5#/)*",$0"J)-+%<=" >"*4/"4+24/&*"4$(+#+./"0-*/F"-%." >"*4/"1-02/&*")0+&$%")$)'1-*+$%")/0"#-)+*-K" L'0")$1+*+#+-%&"-0/"#$%&*-%*16"+%C$:+%2"M(/0+#-B&"&')/0+$0+*6"-%." /5#/)*+$%-1+&(K"N/*"*4/".-*-"-0/")+1+%2"')"*4-*"3/B0/"H'(7/0"O"+%"/5-#*16"*4/"3-6"3/" .$%B*"3-%*"*$"7/!!-*"*4/"7$**$(K"D*B&"-"2$$."+./-"*$"&/*"-&+./"*4/"04/*$0+#"$,"%-*+$%-1" 20/-*%/&&"-%."-&:"$'0&/1C/&"4$3"3/".0$))/."*$"*4/"7-&/(/%*"$%"&$"(-%6" +()$0*-%*"+&&'/&"-%."34-*"3/"&4$'1.".$"*$"#1+(7"$'*K" P4-%:,'116F"M(/0+#-"&#$0/&"3/11"$%"-"%'(7/0"$,")$&+*+C/"+%.+#-*$0&F"7'*"3/" !"#$!%&'$(!"$)'*+$,-#$"!+./+0&1$,-'20-$+',$34#,5$!,$,-#$6',,'71$'+$',-#"&$!%&'$+',$ %/&,#)$-#"#8$9'"$#:!7;%#1$,-#$<8=8$"!+.&$'+%4$>?,-$'+$@-#$AB'+'7/&,C&$D#7'B"!B4$ E+)#:1$"/0-,$6#%'*$,-#$FG#B-$H#;26%/B8$ $ " " #$%"&'%()*+)",-(-./0*1-2",/33*4*2*56"/7"-"8%'/1(-5*1"&1/+/'69" :6" ;-("<2=%(/>*5?" " " @/("5$%"'/35"=-(5"3%(*/A3"31$/2-(3"-+."-15*>*353"$->%"-..(%33%."5$%"=/33*4*2*56"/7"=(/)(%33*>%" 1$-+)%"*+"1-=*5-2*35"3635%'3"7(/'"/+%"/7"5B/"=%(3=%15*>%3C"#$%"D(%7/('E"5(-.*5*/+"-33A'%3"5$-5" 1/(=/(-5%"*+35*5A5*/+3"(%'-*+"1%+5(-2"5/"5$%".%3*)+"-+."35(A15A(%"/7"5$%"3635%'"-+."5$-5"D=/2*5*13E"*+" 3A==/(5"/7">-(*/A3"D=/2*1*%3E"F%G)G"5-0-5*/+H"3=%+.*+)H"*+1%+5*>%3H"(%)A2-5*/+I"B*22"1/+5-*+H"'/.*76"-+." 1/+5(/2"5$%"*+$%(%+5".6+-'*1"/7"-"1/(=/(-5%"./'*+-5%."3635%'G"J*4%(-2*3'"*+"5$%"K+*5%."L5-5%3"-+." 3/1*-2".%'/1(-16"*+"'-+6"1/A+5(*%3"-(%"(%=(%3%+5-5*>%"/7"5$*3"5(-.*5*/+G"#$%"D(%>/2A5*/+-(6E"5(-.*5*/+" -33A'%3"5$-5"1$-+)%"1-+"1/'%"-4/A5"/+26"*7"'-M/("1/(=/(-5%"*+35*5A5*/+3"-(%"2-()%26"%2*'*+-5%."/(" 5(-+31%+.%.H"A3A-226"4A5"+/5"-2B-63"46">*/2%+1%N-+."*+"'-+6"*'=/(5-+5"5$%/(*%3H"+/5-426"46"-"1(*3*3" 1/22-=3%"/7"5$%"3635%'H"2%-.*+)"5/"/+%"/("-+/5$%("7/('"/7"(%>/2A5*/+G" " :A5"B$-5"$-==%+3"*7"-"3635%'"+%*5$%("D(%7/('3E"+/("1/22-=3%3"*+"D1(*3*3EO" " P6"3A))%35*/+3"*+"5$*3"=(%3%+5-5*/+"-(%"5B/C"" " @*(35H"5$-5"*+"1/+5%053"/7"D+%*5$%("(%7/('"+/("1(*3*3"1/22-=3%E">%(6"*+5%(%35*+)"35(-5%)*1" =/33*4*2*5*%3"'-6"3/'%5*'%3"4%">*-42%"F%>%+"*+"3/'%"1-3%3"=(%.*15-42%IN-+."5$-5"3A1$"=/33*4*2*5*%3"-(%" 4%35"A+.%(35//."-3"+%*5$%("D(%7/('3E"F*G%G"=/2*1*%3"5/"'/.*76"-+."1/+5(/2H"4A5"+/5"5(-+31%+."1/(=/(-5%" *+35*5A5*/+3I"+/("D(%>/2A5*/+E"F*G%G"5$%"/>%(5$(/B*+)"/7"1/(=/(-5%"*+35*5A5*/+3IQ"" " L%1/+.H"5$-5"5$%"K+*5%."L5-5%3"*3"%+5%(*+)"-"=%(*/."*+"B$*1$"-"3*5A-5*/+-2"2/)*1"/7"5$*3"R*+."'-6" A+.%("1%(5-*+"1*(1A'35-+1%3"2%-."5/"2/+)%("5%('"=(/1%33%3"5$-5"-(%"4%35".%31(*4%."-3"D%>/2A5*/+-(6" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 9"#$*3"*3"-"(%>*3%.">%(3*/+"/7"-",2%+-(6"S%6+/5%"<..(%33"5/"5$%"<33/1*-5*/+"/7"L/1*-2"&1/+/'*13H"T-+A-(6"UH"VW!!H"-5" 8%+>%(H"X/2/(-./G" !" " #$%&'()#*%)+&',--.'/")0.)"1.2")0$($"1.2"0.3$"4.#-#$.%0+'5"/$1&%#.)+6+'5"+178+%.)+&'("/+44$#$')"4#&1" #$4".'/"#$3&8*)+&'9" :" ;3$#"#$%$')"/$%./$("(+'%$")0$"7&()<.#"$#.="+'"1.'2".#$.("&4")#*82"4*'/.1$').8"8+>$#.8"%&'%$#'" (%0&8.#("0.3$"/&%*1$')$/"8&'5")#$'/(")0.)"#$5+()$#"#$4?("/$%.2"&#"@&%%.(+&'.882A"().8$1.)+'5--<+)0" 8+1+)$/"7&(+)+3$"B.%0+$3$1$')(,">$()"*'/$#()&&/".("#$(+().'%$"$44&#)(".5.+'()")0$"1&#$"4*'/.1$').8" /$%.2+'5">.%C/#&79"D8)$#'.)+3$82"(*%0"5.+'("&4)$'"().'/".("+17&#).')">*)"*'*(*.8"0+()&#+%.8"&//+)+$(" $E78.+'.>8$"&'82">2"#$4$#$'%$")&"1*%0"$.#8+$#="$E)#$1$82"*'*(*.8"0+()&#+%.8"%+#%*1().'%$(9"D"%&11&'" $E7$#+$'%$"+'3&83$("5.+'(")0.)".#$"#$.8">*)"(+1782"/&"'&)".8)$#"/$%.2+'5")#$'/(F"G&#"+'().'%$="H'"!IIJ" 8+>$#.8("(*%%$$/$/"+'"7.((+'5"1*%0"0.+8$/"8$5+(8.)+&'")0.)"+'%#$.($/")0$"1+'+1*1"<.5$"4#&1"KL9ML".'" 0&*#")&"KJ9!L".'"0&*#"&3$#")0#$$"2$.#(9"N*)")0$"B#$.8,"@+'48.)+&'"./O*()$/A"1+'+1*1"<.5$"0./">$$'" 1&#$")0.'"K!"!"#!$%"@KMI9MI".'"0&*#"+'"!IMI"/&88.#(A"4&*#"/$%./$("$.#8+$#="+'"MPQR9"S3$'".("&3$#.88" '.)+&'.8"+'%&1$"T*./#*78$/=")0$"1+'+1*1"<.5$"0./">$%&1$"8&<$#"+'"#$.8")$#1("&'($%)(!$)*$+) ,$#"-,&(".*))0.'"+)"0./">$$'"<0$'"U&0'"G9"V$''$/2"<.("W#$(+/$')9" X0$"1&/$#'")#$'/("#$5+()$#+'5"#$4?("4.+8+'5"%.7.%+)2"+'"1.'2"C$2".#$.(".#$"'&)"+'"/+(7*)$F" X0&*50")0$#$"0.3$">$$'"(7$%+4+%"8$5+(8.)+3$".%0+$3$1$')("+'"/$4+'$/".#$.(="(+'%$")0$"0+507&+')"2$.#("&4" )0$">&&1"$#.=">&)0"+'%&1$".'/"<$.8)0")#$'/("0.3$">$%&1$"1&#$"%&'%$')#.)$/Y"$'%#&.%01$')("&'"%+3+8" 8+>$#)+$("0.3$"+'%#$.($/Y"$'3+#&'1$').8"/$5#./.)+&'"0.("%&')+'*$/".("1$.(*#$/">2"($3$#.8"C$2" +'/+%.)&#("@<+)0")#$'/".>.)$1$')"+'"."0.'/4*8"8.#5$82")#.%$.>8$")&"$.#8+$#"#$4(=".'/"$44&#)(")&"#$(+()" )0$"&3$#.#%0+'5"58&>.8"<.#1+'5")#.O$%)"1.#5+'.8".)">$()A9"D)">$()=")&&="8+>$#.8+(1".77$.#(".(".'".4)$#- )0$-4.%)"B#$(+().'%$"1&3$1$'),"+'"%&''$%)+&'"<+)0"<.#".'/"7$.%$F"H)"0.("'&)">$$'".>8$")&"7#$3$')" 1.O&#"<.#("+)"&77&($/Y"+'()$./"+)("8+1+)$/".%0+$3$1$')("0.3$"+'3&83$/"$44&#)(")&"(8&<"/&<'="%.88">.%C=" .'/"#$(+()"<.#("+'"V&#$.="Z+$)'.1="H#.T="@.#5*.>82A"D450.'+().'[.8<.2(".5&'+6+'582"(8&<"$3$'"+'"+)" (*%%$(($(9""\+>$#.8"$%&'&1+%"()#.)$52"0.(">$$'"+'%#$.(+'582"0.1()#*'5">2"&77&(+)+&'")&"7*>8+%"(7$'/+'5" !" " #$%"%&'#$%(")*+",#-"+&./&)01/,2"(,#3$#,/*$"*$.4"*$&"*)",2&"'*+&"*56/*7("#$%"8#/$)7."'*%&+$" *7,9*'&(:" " ;&+2#8("'*(,"/..7'/$#,/$3"*)",2&"7$%&+.4/$3"(4(,&'/9"+&.#,/*$(2/8("#+&"<&4")#9,("+&.#,&%",*" &9*$*'/9"8*1&+=">6&+",2&".#(,",2+&&"%&9#%&(",2&",*8"?"8&+9&$,"*)"@'&+/9#$("'*+&",2#$"%*75.&%",2&/+" (2#+&"*)",2&"$#,/*$A("/$9*'&B"/$9+&#(/$3"/,")+*'"?C"8&+9&$,"/$"?DEC",*"F!:G"8&+9&$,"/$"FCCH:"I2/92"/(",*" (#4",2&"5*,,*'"DD"8&+9&$,"*)"@'&+/9#$("(#1"/,("/$9*'&"(2#+&"+#%/9#..4B"$*,"'#+3/$#..4B"+&%79&%"/$" ,#$%&':"J#%",2&"K&%&+#."L*6&+$'&$,0/$(,&#%"*)",2&",*8"?"8&+9&$,MM",#-&%"#1#4",2/("'792"/$9*'&" N?!:G"8&+9&$,O")+*'",2&"5*,,*'"DD"8&+9&$,B"/,"1*7.%"2#6&"5&&$"%&&'&%"#$"&-,+#*+%/$#+4"*7,+#3&:"NP," 1*7.%"#.(*"2#6&"#'*7$,&%",*"$&#+.4"Q?",+/../*$"/$"#%%/,/*$#."#6#/.#5.&",#-"+&6&$7&("\"4&#+O:" R" " @"3+*1/$3"5*%4"*)"(*9/#.B"8*./,/9#."#$%"2/(,*+/9#."1*+<"2#("(733&(,&%"'#$4"*)",2&"7$%&+.4/$3" +&#(*$(")*+",2&"'*%&+$"(,#.&'#,/$3"*)"+&)*+':"@.,2*732"3.*5#./S#,/*$B"$&1",&92$*.*3/&(B",2&"+/(&"*)",2&" T/32,"#+&"#.."9*''*$.4"9/,&%B"'*(,"/'8*+,#$,"#.'*(,"9&+,#/$.4"/("12#,"2#("!"#$5&&$$8+&(&$,:"P,"/(" 8+*)*7$%.4"/$(,+79,/6&",*"$*,&",2#,"8+&6/*7("&+#("*)"'#U*+"8+*3+&((/6&"92#$3&"1&+&B"/$")#9,B"2/32.4" %&8&$%&$,"*$"'#((/6&B"3.*5#."(9#.&"9+/(&("N#$%",2&/+"#),&+M&))&9,(:O"V2&"'*(,"*56/*7("/(",2&"'#((/6&"9+/(/(" 1&"9#..",2&"L+&#,"W&8+&((/*$B"/$%/(87,#5.4",2&"8&+'/,,/$3"9*$%/,/*$"*)",2&"X&1"W&#.0#$%"*)".&3/(.#,/6&" #92/&6&'&$,(",2#,"2#%"5&&$"#.."57,"/$9*$9&/6#5.&"5&)*+&",2&"9+/(/("/,(&.)"'#((/6&.4"N57,",&'8*+#+/.4O" (2/),&%"8*./,/9(:"V2&"Y*7,9*'&("./(,Z"*)"W&8+&((/*$M&+#"8+*3+&((/6&"3#/$("/$9.7%&("[*9/#."[&97+/,4B" 9+&#,/*$"*)",2&"[&97+/,4"#$%"\-92#$3&"]*''/((/*$B",2&"L.#(("[,#.."@9,"N&:3:B"V2&"^#$</$3"@9,"*)"?D!!OB" ,2&"X#,/*$#."J*7(/$3"@9,"*)"?D!_B",2&"V&$$&((&&"`#..&4"@7,2*+/,4B"#$%B"9+/,/9#..4B",2&"I#3$&+"@9," )#9/./,#,/$3".#5*+"7$/*$"*+3#$/S/$3:"Na$/*$"'&'5&+(2/8"(,**%"#,"#"'&+&"?F"8&+9&$,"*)"$*$M)#+'"1*+<&+(" /$"?DFDb"/,"+*(&",*"Fc:D"8&+9&$,"54"?D_CO:P,"/("/'8*((/5.&",*"<$*1"12#,"'/32,",2&*+&,/9#..4"2#6&"*997++&%" 2#%"'#((/6&"&9*$*'/9"9+/(/("$*,"%/(+78,&%"@'&+/9#$"8*./,/9(B"57,"6&+4")&1"(&+/*7("2/(,*+/#$("5&./&6&" !" " #$%&'($)"*(+,"&'(-"*(-&"./"#0'(,1,2,$&-"3.4*5"'#1,"6,0.2,"7,#*(&%"(/"87(.7"0.$1,$&(.$#*"#$5"*#7),*%" 0.$-,71#&(1,"8.*(&(0#*"&7,$5-"'#5"-(28*%"0.$&($4,5"#*.$)",-*(-',5"*($,-9" :'#&"&',";8.-&3#7"6..2<"3#-"&',",--,$&(#*"8,72(&&($)"0.$&,=&"/.7"#"*.$)"*(-&"./"87.)7,--(1,"