Raiding Sovereignty in Central African Borderlands

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Raiding Sovereignty in Central African Borderlands Raiding Sovereignty in Central African Borderlands by Louisa Nicolaysen Lombard Department of Cultural Anthropology Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Charles Piot, Supervisor ___________________________ Orin Starn ___________________________ William O’Barr ___________________________ Peter Redfield ___________________________ Janet Roitman Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Cultural Anthropology in the Graduate School of Duke University 2012 ABSTRACT Raiding Sovereignty in Central African Borderlands by Louisa Nicolaysen Lombard Department of Cultural Anthropology Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Charles Piot, Supervisor ___________________________ Orin Starn ___________________________ William O’Barr ___________________________ Peter Redfield ___________________________ Janet Roitman An abstract of a dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Cultural Anthropology in the Graduate School of Duke University 2012 Copyright by Louisa Nicolaysen Lombard 2012 Abstract This dissertation focuses on raiding and sovereignty in the Central African Republic’s (CAR) northeastern borderlands, on the margins of Darfur. A vast literature on social evolution has assumed the inevitability of political centralization. But these borderlands show centralization does not always occur. Never claimed by any centralizing forces, the area has instead long been used as a reservoir of resources by neighboring areas’ militarized entrepreneurs, who seek the savanna’s goods. The raiders seize resources but also govern. The dynamics of this zone, much of it a place anthropologists used to refer to as “stateless,” suggest a re-thinking of the modalities of sovereignty. The dissertation proposes conceptualizing sovereignty not as a totalizing, territorialized political order, but through its constituent governing capabilities, which may centralize or not and can combine to create hybrid political systems. The dissertation develops this framework through analysis of three categories of men-in-arms—road blockers, anti-poaching militiamen, and members of rebel groups— and their relationships with international peacebuilding initiatives. It compares roadblocks and “road cutting” (robbery) to show how these men stop traffic and create flexible, personalized entitlements to profit for those who operate them. The dissertation also probes the politics of militarized conservation: in a low-level war that has lasted for 25 years, European Union-funded militiamen fight deadly battles against herders and hunters. Though ostensibly fought to protect CAR’s “national patrimony” (its animals and plants), this war bolsters the sovereign capabilities of non-state actors and has iv resulted in hundreds of deaths in the last few years alone, many of them hidden in the bush. The dissertation then shows how CAR’s recent cycle of rebellion has changed governance in rural areas. Though mobile armed groups have long operated in CAR, they used to work as road cutters and local defense forces and only recently started calling themselves “rebels”—a move that has landed in them in new roles as “governors” of populations. Throughout these various raiders’ projects, the idea of the all-powerful state serves as a reference they use to qualify themselves with sovereign authorities. But their actions as rulers undermine the creation of the unitary political authority they desire and invoke. Failure to appreciate these non-centralized micropolitical processes is a main reason peacebuilding efforts (such as disarmament, demobilization, and reintegration) have failed. v Contents Abstract .................................................................................................................................... iv List of Figures ........................................................................................................................... x Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................ xi Preface .................................................................................................................................... xiv Ambivalent multisitedness ..........................................................................................xviii The independent researcher who needs a team ........................................................... xxi The archives .................................................................................................................. xxiii Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... xxv 1. Introduction: Sovereignty in the buffer zone ..................................................................... 1 1.1 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 1 1.2 The return to sovereignty ............................................................................................ 6 1.2.1 Colonialism and Divisible Sovereignty ........................................................... 13 1.3 Marks of sovereignty ................................................................................................. 22 1.3.1 A typology of marks of sovereignty ................................................................ 30 1.3.1.1 Jurisdiction, as differentiated from dominion ....................................... 30 1.3.1.2 Extraction.................................................................................................. 34 1.3.1.3 Violent coercion ....................................................................................... 35 1.3.1.4 Protection.................................................................................................. 37 1.3.1.5 Diplomacy ................................................................................................ 40 1.3.1.6 Mobility .................................................................................................... 41 1.3.1.7 Invisibility................................................................................................. 42 1.3.1.8 Flexibility .................................................................................................. 44 1.3.2 Chapter overview ............................................................................................. 46 vi 1.4 Why sovereignty? ...................................................................................................... 51 1.5 Conclusion .................................................................................................................. 55 2. Mapping the space: An historical geography .................................................................. 57 2.1 Introduction ................................................................................................................ 57 2.2 Mapping this space .................................................................................................... 64 2.3 Not the next frontier? ................................................................................................. 70 2.4 Raiding comes to Central Africa ............................................................................... 76 2.5 Raiding in the buffer zone ......................................................................................... 83 2.6 Colonialism ................................................................................................................. 97 2.6.1 Sous-divisions autonomes .................................................................................... 99 2.6.2 Conservation ................................................................................................... 107 2.7 Conclusion ................................................................................................................ 120 3. The state of the buffer zone: Non-centralization and brokered/vicarious autonomy amid dreams of welfare..................................................................................... 123 3.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 123 3.2 Independence for the trash-can colony .................................................................. 128 3.3 Flexibility: “As an African, I must be flexible...” ................................................... 143 3.4 Negotiating mining rights: Laws as hurdles or levers .......................................... 155 3.5 Social atomization .................................................................................................... 164 3.6 Conclusion ................................................................................................................ 172 4. Capabilities of dispossession: Road blockers and road cutters .................................... 176 4.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 176 4.2 Part one: Navigational tools for Central African roadblocks ............................... 177 4.2.1 Introducing roadblocks .................................................................................. 177 4.2.2 Situating roadblocks
Recommended publications
  • Central African Republic Humanitarian Situation Report
    Central African Republic Humanitarian Situation Report © UNICEFCAR/2018/Matous February 2019 SITUATION IN NUMBERS Highlights 28 February 2019 1.5 million - On 6 February the Central African Republic (CAR) government and # of children in need of humanitarian assistance 14 of the country’s armed groups signed a new peace agreement in 2.9 million Khartoum (Sudan). The security and humanitarian situation still # of people in need remained volatile, with the Rapid Response Mechanism recording 11 (OCHA, December 2018) new conflict-related alerts; 640,969 # of Internally displaced persons - In February, UNICEF and partners ensured provision of quality (CMP, December 2018) primary education to 52,987 new crisis-affected children (47% girls) Outside CAR admitted into 95 temporary learning spaces across the country; - 576,926 - In a complex emergency context, from 28 January to 16 February, # of registered CAR refugees UNICEF carried out a needs assessment and provided first response (UNHCR, December 2018) in WASH and child protection on the Bangassou-Bakouma and Bangassou-Rafaï axes in the remote Southeast 2018 UNICEF Appeal US$ 59 million - In Kaga-Bandoro, three accidental fires broke out in three IDP sites, Funding status* ($US) leaving 4,620 people homeless and 31 injured. UNICEF responded to the WASH and Education needs UNICEF’s Response with Partners Funds received: Sector/Cluster UNICEF $2,503,596 Key Programme Indicators Cluster Cumulative UNICEF Cumulative Target results (#) Target results (#) Carry-Over: $11,958,985 WASH: Crisis-affected people with access to safe water for drinking, 800,000 188,705 400,000 85,855 cooking and personal hygiene Education: Children (boys and girls 3-17yrs) attending school in a class 600,000 42,360 442,500 42,360 Funding Gap: led by a teacher trained in 44,537,419 psychosocial support $ Health: People and children under 5 in IDP sites and enclaves with access N/A 82,068 7,806 to essential health services and medicines.
    [Show full text]
  • En Republique Centrafricaine L'experience De La Zone Pilote De Sangba
    LES CAHIERS FORESTIERS DE GEMBLOUX LE "PROGRAMME DE DEVELOPPEMENT DE LA REGION NORD" EN REPUBLIQUE CENTRAFRICAINE L'EXPERIENCE DE LA ZONE PILOTE DE SANGBA N° 9 T. d'ESPINEY, J. TELLO, W. DELVINGT ISSN : 0777-9992 D/2002/6026/09 2 LES CAHIERS FORESTIERS DE GEMBLOUX visent à faire connaître les travaux (documents techniques, rapports de recherche, publications, articles de vulga- risation) émanant des Unités des Eaux et Forêts de la Faculté Universitaire des Sciences Agronomiques de Gem- bloux et de ses groupes de recherche, financés par des organismes internationaux, nationaux ou régionaux. Adresse de contact : Unité de Gestion et Economie forestières Faculté des Sciences Agronomiques de Gembloux B - 5030 Gembloux – Belgique Tél : 32 (81) 62 23 20 Fax : 32 (81) 62 23 01 E-MAIL : [email protected] http://www.fsagx.ac.be/gf 3 LE "PROGRAMME DE DEVELOPPEMENT DE LA REGION NORD" EN REPUBLIQUE CENTRAFRICAINE L'EXPERIENCE DE LA ZONE PILOTE DE SANGBA T. d'ESPINEY(1), J. TELLO(2), W. DELVINGT(3) Résumé En vue d'établir une barrière contre l'avancée du Sahel, le Gouvernement Centrafricain et la Commission des Communautés Européennes financent, dans le cadre du 6ème Fonds Européen de Développement, un "Programme de Développement de la Région Nord" en Centrafrique. Les ressources naturelles, et particulièrement la grande faune, constituent les facteurs clés en vue d'une mise en valeur de cette région, s'étendant sur plus de 105.000 km2 en zone médio- soudanienne. Les recherches pour une utilisation de la faune se sont concentrées sur la zone pilote de Sangba (8.500 km2) et en particulier sur la zone de chasse coutumière (750 km2) du village d'Idongo (300 habitants).
    [Show full text]
  • Starving Tigray
    Starving Tigray How Armed Conflict and Mass Atrocities Have Destroyed an Ethiopian Region’s Economy and Food System and Are Threatening Famine Foreword by Helen Clark April 6, 2021 ABOUT The World Peace Foundation, an operating foundation affiliated solely with the Fletcher School at Tufts University, aims to provide intellectual leadership on issues of peace, justice and security. We believe that innovative research and teaching are critical to the challenges of making peace around the world, and should go hand-in- hand with advocacy and practical engagement with the toughest issues. To respond to organized violence today, we not only need new instruments and tools—we need a new vision of peace. Our challenge is to reinvent peace. This report has benefited from the research, analysis and review of a number of individuals, most of whom preferred to remain anonymous. For that reason, we are attributing authorship solely to the World Peace Foundation. World Peace Foundation at the Fletcher School Tufts University 169 Holland Street, Suite 209 Somerville, MA 02144 ph: (617) 627-2255 worldpeacefoundation.org © 2021 by the World Peace Foundation. All rights reserved. Cover photo: A Tigrayan child at the refugee registration center near Kassala, Sudan Starving Tigray | I FOREWORD The calamitous humanitarian dimensions of the conflict in Tigray are becoming painfully clear. The international community must respond quickly and effectively now to save many hundreds of thou- sands of lives. The human tragedy which has unfolded in Tigray is a man-made disaster. Reports of mass atrocities there are heart breaking, as are those of starvation crimes.
    [Show full text]
  • Republique Centrafricaine Autorite Nationale Des Elections
    21.1.11.3code VillageQu 21 REPUBLIQUE CENTRAFRICAINE Code Préfecture 2021-01-02 AUTORITE NATIONALE DES ELECTIONS Code 21/03/2021 12:38:27 Date et Heure Impression : 21/03/2021 12:38:27 Sous Pref21.1 2021/03/19 ELECTIONS LEGISLATIVES DU 14 MARS 2021 - RESULTATS PROVISOIRES code 21.1.11 Préfecture : BAMINGUI BANGORAN Nbre inscrits : 210 commune Sous Préfecture : NDELE Nbre votant : 83 code 3954 centre Code BV 3954-01 Circonscription : 1ere Circonscription Nbre Blancs Nuls : 7 7 Commune : DAR-EL-KOUTI Taux de participation : 39,52% TOTAL : photo 0 0% Village Quartier : KOUBOU Suffrages Exprimés : 76 centre vote : ECOLE KOUBOU BV : BV01 1/74 Ordre Candidat Parti Politique voix Taux% 1 ALIME AZIZA SOUMAINE MCU 35 46,05% 46,05% 2 AROUN-ASSANE TIGANA P.G.D 41 53,95% 53,95% 100% 1 / 74 21.1.11.3code VillageQu 21 REPUBLIQUE CENTRAFRICAINE Code Préfecture 2021-01-02 AUTORITE NATIONALE DES ELECTIONS Code 21/03/2021 12:38:27 Date et Heure Impression : 21/03/2021 12:38:27 Sous Pref21.1 2021/03/19 ELECTIONS LEGISLATIVES DU 14 MARS 2021 - RESULTATS PROVISOIRES code 21.1.11 Préfecture : BAMINGUI BANGORAN Nbre inscrits : 397 commune Sous Préfecture : NDELE Nbre votant : 164 code 3948 centre Code BV 3948-01 Circonscription : 1ere Circonscription Nbre Blancs Nuls : 39 39 Commune : DAR-EL-KOUTI Taux de participation : 41,31% TOTAL : photo 76 54% Village Quartier : DJALABA Suffrages Exprimés : 125 centre vote : MAIRIE DE NDELE BV : BV01 2/74 Ordre Candidat Parti Politique voix Taux% 1 ALIME AZIZA SOUMAINE MCU 108 86,40% 86,40% 2 AROUN-ASSANE TIGANA P.G.D
    [Show full text]
  • Central African Republic Giraffe Conservation Status Report February 2020
    Country Profile Central African Republic Giraffe Conservation Status Report February 2020 General statistics Size of country: 622,984 km² Size of protected areas / percentage protected area coverage: 13% Species and subspecies In 2016 the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) completed the first detailed assessment of the conservation status of giraffe, revealing that their numbers are in peril. This was further emphasised when the majority of the IUCN recognised subspecies where assessed in 2018 – some as Critically Endangered. While this update further confirms the real threat to one of Africa’s most charismatic megafauna, it also highlights a rather confusing aspect of giraffe conservation: how many species/subspecies of giraffe are there? The IUCN currently recognises one species (Giraffa camelopardalis) and nine subspecies of giraffe (Muller et al. 2016) historically based on outdated assessments of their morphological features and geographic ranges. The subspecies are thus divided: Angolan giraffe (G. c. angolensis), Kordofan giraffe (G. c. antiquorum), Masai giraffe (G. c. tippleskirchi), Nubian giraffe (G. c. camelopardalis), reticulated giraffe (G. c. reticulata), Rothschild’s giraffe (G. c. rothschildi), South African giraffe (G. c. giraffa), Thornicroft’s giraffe (G. c. thornicrofti) and West African giraffe (G. c. peralta). However, over the past decade GCF together with their partner Senckenberg Biodiversity and Climate Research Centre (BiK-F) have performed the first-ever comprehensive DNA sampling and analysis (genomic, nuclear and mitochondrial) from all major natural populations of giraffe throughout their range in Africa. As a result, an update to the traditional taxonomy now exists. This study revealed that there are four distinct species of giraffe and likely five subspecies (Fennessy et al.
    [Show full text]
  • Zon Nes C Cyné Égét Tique Es V Villag Geois
    Répub lique centrafricain e C ommission E uropée nne F o nds E u ropéen de D évelop pemen t Zones Cynégétiques Villageoises SCHÉMA D'ORIENTATION POST ECOFAC IV Informations générales Evaluation interne Prospectives à 10 ans VERSION PROVISOIRE Août 2010 GROUPEMENT BRL Ingénierie -SECA / GFA GmbH / DFS ZCV, Evaluation interne et perspectives post ECOFAC IV – Version provisoire 2 TABLE DE MATIERES Préambule _____________________________________________________________________ 5 Synthèse du complexe écologique de la zone Nord‐est de la RCA (zone d'intervention de la composante ZCV du programme ECOFAC) ____________________________________________ 6 Informations générales _________________________________________________________________ 6 Valeur pour la conservation _____________________________________________________________ 9 Politique nationale en matière de gestion des Aires Protégées _________________________________ 9 Cadre juridique ______________________________________________________________________ 11 Cadre réglementaire du tourisme cynégétique en RCA ______________________________________________ 11 Cadre institutionnel __________________________________________________________________ 11 Evolution de la structure de gestion des ZCV ______________________________________________________ 12 Contexte territorial ___________________________________________________________________ 14 Population humaine __________________________________________________________________ 14 Héritage culturel _____________________________________________________________________
    [Show full text]
  • The Making and Unmaking of Ethnic Boundaries: a Multilevel Process Theory1
    The Making and Unmaking of Ethnic Boundaries: A Multilevel Process Theory1 Andreas Wimmer University of California, Los Angeles Primordialist and constructivist authors have debated the nature of ethnicity “as such” and therefore failed to explain why its charac- teristics vary so dramatically across cases, displaying different de- grees of social closure, political salience, cultural distinctiveness, and historical stability. The author introduces a multilevel process theory to understand how these characteristics are generated and trans- formed over time. The theory assumes that ethnic boundaries are the outcome of the classificatory struggles and negotiations between actors situated in a social field. Three characteristics of a field—the institutional order, distribution of power, and political networks— determine which actors will adopt which strategy of ethnic boundary making. The author then discusses the conditions under which these negotiations will lead to a shared understanding of the location and meaning of boundaries. The nature of this consensus explains the particular characteristics of an ethnic boundary. A final section iden- tifies endogenous and exogenous mechanisms of change. TOWARD A COMPARATIVE SOCIOLOGY OF ETHNIC BOUNDARIES Beyond Constructivism The comparative study of ethnicity rests firmly on the ground established by Fredrik Barth (1969b) in his well-known introduction to a collection 1 Various versions of this article were presented at UCLA’s Department of Sociology, the Institute for Migration Research and Intercultural Studies of the University of Osnabru¨ ck, Harvard’s Center for European Studies, the Center for Comparative Re- search of Yale University, the Association for the Study of Ethnicity at the London School of Economics, the Center for Ethnicity and Citizenship of the University of Bristol, the Department of Political Science and International Relations of University College Dublin, and the Department of Sociology of the University of Go¨ttingen.
    [Show full text]
  • OCHA CAR Snapshot Incident
    CENTRAL AFRICAN REPUBLIC Overview of incidents affecting humanitarian workers January - May 2021 CONTEXT Incidents from The Central African Republic is one of the most dangerous places for humanitarian personnel with 229 1 January to 31 May 2021 incidents affecting humanitarian workers in the first five months of 2021 compared to 154 during the same period in 2020. The civilian population bears the brunt of the prolonged tensions and increased armed violence in several parts of the country. 229 BiBiraorao 124 As for the month of May 2021, the number of incidents affecting humanitarian workers has decreased (27 incidents against 34 in April and 53 in March). However, high levels of insecurity continue to hinder NdéléNdélé humanitarian access in several prefectures such as Nana-Mambéré, Ouham-Pendé, Basse-Kotto and 13 Ouaka. The prefectures of Haute-Kotto (6 incidents), Bangui (4 incidents), and Mbomou (4 incidents) Markounda Kabo Bamingui were the most affected this month. Bamingui 31 5 Kaga-Kaga- 2 Batangafo Bandoro 3 Paoua Batangafo Bandoro Theft, robbery, looting, threats, and assaults accounted for almost 60% of the incidents (16 out of 27), 2 7 1 8 1 2950 BriaBria Bocaranga 5Mbrès Djéma while the 40% were interferences and restrictions. Two humanitarian vehicles were stolen in May in 3 Bakala Ippy 38 2 Bossangoa Bouca 13 Bozoum Bouca Ippy 3 Bozoum Dekoa 1 1 Ndélé and Bangui, while four health structures were targeted for looting or theft. 1 31 2 BabouaBouarBouar 2 4 1 Bossangoa11 2 42 Sibut Grimari Bambari 2 BakoumaBakouma Bambouti
    [Show full text]
  • The Central African Republic Diamond Database—A Geodatabase of Archival Diamond Occurrences and Areas of Recent Artisanal and Small-Scale Diamond Mining
    Prepared in cooperation with the U.S. Agency for International Development under the auspices of the U.S. Department of State The Central African Republic Diamond Database—A Geodatabase of Archival Diamond Occurrences and Areas of Recent Artisanal and Small-Scale Diamond Mining Open-File Report 2018–1088 U.S. Department of the Interior U.S. Geological Survey Cover. The main road west of Bambari toward Bria and the Mouka-Ouadda plateau, Central African Republic, 2006. Photograph by Peter Chirico, U.S. Geological Survey. The Central African Republic Diamond Database—A Geodatabase of Archival Diamond Occurrences and Areas of Recent Artisanal and Small-Scale Diamond Mining By Jessica D. DeWitt, Peter G. Chirico, Sarah E. Bergstresser, and Inga E. Clark Prepared in cooperation with the U.S. Agency for International Development under the auspices of the U.S. Department of State Open-File Report 2018–1088 U.S. Department of the Interior U.S. Geological Survey U.S. Department of the Interior RYAN K. ZINKE, Secretary U.S. Geological Survey James F. Reilly II, Director U.S. Geological Survey, Reston, Virginia: 2018 For more information on the USGS—the Federal source for science about the Earth, its natural and living resources, natural hazards, and the environment—visit https://www.usgs.gov or call 1–888–ASK–USGS. For an overview of USGS information products, including maps, imagery, and publications, visit https://store.usgs.gov. Any use of trade, firm, or product names is for descriptive purposes only and does not imply endorsement by the U.S. Government. Although this information product, for the most part, is in the public domain, it also may contain copyrighted materials as noted in the text.
    [Show full text]
  • Central African Republic Country Report BTI 2006
    Central African Republic Status Index Management Index (Democracy: 3.22 / Market economy: 3.14) 3.18 3.91 HDI 0.355 Population 3.9 mn GDP per capita ($, PPP) 1.089 Population growth1 2.3 % Unemployment rate - Women in Parliament - UN Education Index 0.43 Poverty2 66.6 % Gini Index 61.3 (1993) Source: UNDP: Human Development Report 2005. Figures for 2003 unless otherwise indicated. 1 Annual growth between 1975 and 2003. 2 People living below $ 1 a day (1990- 2003). A. Executive summary Following a constitutional referendum in late 2004, CAR conducted the first round of presidential elections in March 2005 and completed the second round on May 6, 2005 when voters cast their votes for legislative elections.1 These elections mark the end of a transitional period after a military takeover by General François Bozizé. Bozizé stood as a presidential candidate in the first round and succeeded to gain an absolute majority in the second round, despite declaring earlier that he would step down after the transition phase. Initially, most competitors were barred from running and only after mediation by Gabon’s President Bongo and the re-admittance of most candidate hopefuls were fair elections given a chance. The Central African Republic (CAR) is a poor country according to all traditional, albeit rather unreliable indicators, yet it is rich in natural resources such as diamonds, timber and unconfirmed recent oil discoveries. However, the sparsely populated and only marginally accessible interior suffers from extremely poor governance. After a series of unsuccessful mutinies, coup attempts and rebellions, Ange-Félix Patassé was overthrown in March 2003.
    [Show full text]
  • Biogeography of the Reptiles of the Central African Republic
    African Journal of Herpetology, 2006 55(1): 23-59. ©Herpetological Association of Africa Original article Biogeography of the Reptiles of the Central African Republic LAURENT CHIRIO AND IVAN INEICH Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle Département de Systématique et Evolution (Reptiles) – USM 602, Case Postale 30, 25, rue Cuvier, F-75005 Paris, France This work is dedicated to the memory of our friend and colleague Jens B. Rasmussen, Curator of Reptiles at the Zoological Museum of Copenhagen, Denmark Abstract.—A large number of reptiles from the Central African Republic (CAR) were collected during recent surveys conducted over six years (October 1990 to June 1996) and deposited at the Paris Natural History Museum (MNHN). This large collection of 4873 specimens comprises 86 terrapins and tortois- es, five crocodiles, 1814 lizards, 38 amphisbaenids and 2930 snakes, totalling 183 species from 78 local- ities within the CAR. A total of 62 taxa were recorded for the first time in the CAR, the occurrence of numerous others was confirmed, and the known distribution of several taxa is greatly extended. Based on this material and an additional six species known to occur in, or immediately adjacent to, the coun- try from other sources, we present a biogeographical analysis of the 189 species of reptiles in the CAR. Key words.—Central African Republic, reptile fauna, biogeography, distribution. he majority of African countries have been improved; known distributions of many species Tthe subject of several reptile studies (see are greatly expanded and distributions of some for example LeBreton 1999 for Cameroon). species are questioned in light of our results.
    [Show full text]
  • NOTES on ANTHROPOLOGICAL METHOD, Mainly in the Key of E
    NOTES ON ANTHROPOLOGICAL METHOD, mainly in the key of e John Comaroff There is only one method in social anthropology, the comparative method – and that is impossible. Sir Edward Evans-Pritchard1 PROLEGOMENON It is exceptionally difficult to address questions of method for anthropology at large un- less one reduces the field to a caricature of itself. To wit, the discipline – if anything so obviously polythetic, anything so unruly in its expansiveness, can be called a discipline at all – extends from the “hard” biological sciences and archaeological forensics through “comparative sociology” in the British tradition, technical linguistics of the various Ameri- can schools, and ethno-everything in the formalist mode, to the “soft” hermeneutics of interpretive and historical ethnography. And this barely begins to exhaust the field. Even if we take Clifford Geertz’s (1973) fashionable saw for the seventies, that anthropolo- gists “do ethnography,” it is difficult to pin down what this might mean in general, replic- able terms; after all, Geertz’s often imitated, widely-cited methodological approach – which was fleshed out only illustratively, never rigorously – was itself directed toward ideographic particularity and away from anything that might present itself as nomothetic, general, theoreticist. Since then, moreover, the discipline has become much more diverse, much less coherent; having departed the village, the reservation, the island, both its ends and its means are more contested than ever before.2 Indeed, if, for David Lodge (1999:52), writing a novel is “like playing chess in three dimensions,” doing anth- ropology nowadays is like playing it in four; the fourth being the terrain of the virtual, the electronic commons that ties even fairly remote social worlds into an expansive, if often exclusionary, global ecumene.
    [Show full text]