The Sword and the Covenant

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Sword and the Covenant ‘Covenants without the sword are just words’. Thomas Hobbes The Sword And The Covenant Defining Britain’s Ancient and Modern Military-Covenants for the Twenty-First Century By Lt Col. Mark Rynehart, RDG 1 Acknowledgements Friends and colleagues wonder why one would subject oneself to completing a PhD part time? My response has always been that it is a hobby that got out of hand. The curiosity of a certain generation of officers is not so easily dispelled and so to these I remark that I have taken my professional interest in the moral component to another level. At the heart of the military-covenant is the fair treatment of soldiers and their families in return for the sacrifices they make on behalf of the nation. This work is part of the endeavour to keep the bargain of the covenant a permanent feature of Defence policy so that our people are always looked after. In times of austerity, in the lull before the next major military campaign, this message is even more prescient. I would like to thank Maj. Gen Mike Riddell-Webster and Col. Nick Freeman whose support carried my initial rough and ready ideas over the start line at the Defence Academy. To Dr Jonathan Powell also thanks - his more recent trail blazing in the PhD stakes kept my enthusiasm levels up when the ‘day job’ prevented progress. My gratitude also goes to the senior officers who granted me the time necessary to complete the task. Without their goodwill the considerable time that it took to complete the work would have become practically glacial. These include: Maj. Gen Nick Pope, Air Cdre. Chris Jones and Col. John Matthews. For the firm handling that cavalry officers especially need for intellectual tasks, I doff my cap to Dr. Peter Caddick-Adams, Dr. Teri McConville, Mr. David Turns and Dr Matt Qvortrup who all displayed consummate patience as I got up to speed. An enormous thank you is due to Ms. Anne Harbour, without whom communication with my globetrotting supervisor would have been impossible. To the Members of Parliament, Charity Heads and journalists who gave me their valuable time my sincere thanks - their contributions to the research were invaluable. Finally to Dr. Laura Cleary my supervisor a great debt of gratitude is owed. She believed in the project from the start and offered me practical advice in bite size chunks which she knew I could cope with. Laura was also in the habit of buying lunch after my year on year assessments. After all these years that is a lot of lunch. Making the whole process bearable and human, even though her work kept her abroad for long periods, Laura kept me sane. Without such support defining the military-covenant would have been a distant dream. M.R. April 2015 2 List of contents Title Page Page 1. Acknowledgements Page 2. List of Contents Page 3. List of Abbreviations Page 4. Foreword Page 5. Chapter One Part 1 – Introduction & value Page 14. Chapter One Part 2 – Methodology Page 32. Chapter Two – Literature Review Page 55. Chapter Three – Origins & Evolution Page 88. Chapter Four – Defining the military-covenant Page 133. Chapter Five Part 1 – Analysis of themes, news articles 2002-2010 Page 157. Chapter Five Part 2 – Analysis of themes, interviews 2014 Page 238. Chapter Six – Analysis & Findings Page 278. Chapter Seven – Conclusion Page 291. Bibliography Page 300. 3 List of Abbreviations AFC Armed Forces Covenant AFF Army Families Federation ADP Army Doctrine Publication BBC British Broadcasting Corporation BFG British Forces Germany BMD British Military Doctrine CDS Chief of the Defence Staff C-IED Counter Improvised Explosive Device CGS Chief of the General Staff DCDC Development Concept & Doctrine Centre DGD&D Director General Doctrine & Development DSG Defence Strategic Guidance MoD Ministry of Defence Min AF Minister Armed Forces PSB Public Sector Bargaining PUS Permanent Under Secretary RBL Royal British Legion SDSR Strategic Defence & Security Review 4 Foreword If one takes the definition of a social contract to be: ‘an implicit agreement among the members of a society to cooperate for social benefits, for example by sacrificing some individual freedom for state protection,’ 1 then the military-covenant is distinctive on three counts. Firstly a military-covenant is explicit and exists not simply in an implied sense but is a legal artefact of public record.2 The creation of the Armed Forces Covenant in 2011 turned what had hitherto been an article of formal British military doctrine onto the statute books of Parliament. Secondly members of the Armed Forces which the military-covenant seeks to ‘protect’ do not only sacrifice ‘some individual freedoms’ in defence of the nation, they sacrifice (or are required to be prepared to sacrifice) the ultimate freedom: the right to life; along with several other significant freedoms such as freedom of speech and freedom of association. These are significant individual freedoms that arguably distinguish the social status of the military citizen from the civilian citizen. Social justice is at risk if the equities between the two realms of citizenship are allowed to become out of balance or the political framework to manage the civil-military gap (a term used to help explain the differences between the military and the civilian realms) collapses or becomes ineffective. The civil- military gap is also a term which is thought by many3 to show how the Armed Forces attempt to preserve military identity and military effectiveness,4 such that the ‘protection’ which civilians enjoy, is militarily attainable for the State to extend, at least from the military point of view. In Britain today the ‘implicit civil social contract’ which might otherwise have been thought to extend to military citizens but which has arguably in recent times seen decline, has in any case been augmented by ‘an explicit and military social compact’ designed to rebalance the perceived social inequity between military and civilian citizens. The ‘story’ of the rise of the modern military-covenant in recent years (2006-2011) is an important one but it is not the only one. For when one looks back into the earliest periods of British military endeavour a much older story of the covenant is surfaced, one in which explicit and formal 1 Oxford Dictionaries Online: ‘Social Contract’. http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/social-contract. 2 The Armed Forces Covenant, Statute Law 2011. 3 See for example Strachan, H. ‘The Civil-military ‘gap’ in Britian’. Journal of Strategic Studies, Vol 26, 2003. 4 See Hackett, General Sir John’.The Profession of Arms’. Sedgewick & Jackson. London, 1983. Pp 72,73. 5 social military compacts are found to be in existence and which played their part in British life, both in times of war and in times of peace. It is the author’s purpose to bring the more ancient story of the military-covenant’s rise to prominence to light. For if military practitioners, policy makers and academics fail to take a wider and deeper view of the origins of the military-covenant there is a risk that the principles underpinning it might be arbitrarily removed in the future, rejected without debate or added to without critical appreciation. As articles of military doctrine, if the modern versions of the military-covenants contain the received wisdom from all previous British conflicts then there is surely a wealth of material from the early modern and modern periods which contain important discussion on the origins of the modern covenant. Certainly some discussion on those key events in the seventeenth, through to nineteenth centuries is critical to the overall discussion on the origins of the covenant and these appear in the literature review of chapter two. Nevertheless discussion of the origins of the covenant covering the entire gambit of British military history is impractical and weighting has been given to the very ancient periods of history where practically nil consideration has been given before and where research is most wanting. Consideration has also been given to the modern story of the covenant at its point of inception, where discussion of the ancient context of covenants becomes critical to foundational understanding of the enduring and cultural aspects where current analyses of the subject is limited. Thus the historical dimension of the covenant becomes hugely important if a full and complete definition of the covenant is to be established. The word ‘covenant’ is derived from the Latin verb ‘convenir’ 5 meaning to convene, to come together. It has religious connotations being associated with the Biblical traditions concerning the Ark of the Covenant 6 and Christ’s new covenant.7 In the religious sense the term covenant pertains to the moral bargain between God and man. It is therefore not surprising and surely not a case of accident that the author of the modern ‘military-covenant’ Sebastian Roberts in 5 Oxford Dictionary of English Etymology. ‘Covenant: mutual agreement; divine contract with mankind , XIII century. Legal agreement, XIV century’. 2003. Pg 2. 6 i.e. as contained in The Bible Old Testament (Book of Exodus) in which the Ark contained God’s Ten Commandments written in stone. 7 i.e. as contained in The Bible of the New Testament (Gospel of Mathew) in which God’s New Covenant is written in blood. 6 2000 and Richard Dannatt, its chief advocate from 2006 are Christian. Indeed Roberts8 and Dannatt9 are cited for their moral and religious motivations. In this way, whilst the military- covenant is arguably another example of the more commonly termed and expressly modern ‘civil-military compact’10 it remains distinctive as a term and as a concept because its modern Christian influences as evidenced by its authorship and proponency over the period 2000- 2006 is importantly anticipated and underpinned by much earlier Christian11 and military doctrinal influences and artefacts.
Recommended publications
  • An Armed Forces Community Covenant
    AN ARMED FORCES COMMUNITY COVENANT Between Cheltenham Borough Council, Cotswold District Council, Forest of Dean District Council, Gloucester City Council, Gloucestershire County Council, Gloucestershire Police Authority, Stroud District Council, Tewkesbury Borough Council, NHS England, NHS Gloucestershire Clinical Commissioning Group, Department for Work and Pensions, Wessex Reserve Forces’ and Cadets’ Association, Gloucestershire Police and Crime Commissioner’s Office, Representatives of the Charitable and Voluntary Sectors, the Civilian Community of Gloucestershire and THE ARMED FORCES COMMUNITY IN GLOUCESTERSHIRE We, the undersigned, agree to work and act together to honour the Armed Forces Community Covenant. Armed Forces Community Covenant Signed: Signed: Brigadier Piers Hankinson, MBE. Commander, 43 (Wessex) Brigade Thomas Herman, OBE. Commander, Royal Navy, Deputy Naval Regional Commander (Wales and Western England) Brigadier General David Paterson, OBE. Allied Rapid Reaction Corps (ARRC) Signed on behalf of Royal Navy Signed on behalf of Army Date: 27.2.12 Date: 27.2.12 Signed: Signed: Rich Wylor-Owen. Squadron Leader, OC 501 Sqn RAuxAF Cllr Carol Topple. Cabinet Member for Housing and Communities, Cotswold District Council Signed on behalf of Royal Air Force Signed on behalf of Cotswold District Council Date: 27.2.12 Date: 27.2.12 Armed Forces Community Covenant Signed: Signed: Cllr Andy Lewis. Mayor, Gloucester City Council Cllr Barbara Driver. Mayor, Cheltenham Borough Council Cllr Steve Morgan. Deputy Leader, Gloucester City Council Cllr Steve Jordan. Leader, Cheltenham Borough Council Cllr Fred Wood. Gloucester City Council Signed on behalf of Gloucester City Council Signed on behalf of Cheltenham Borough Council Date: 27.2.12 Date: 27.2.12 Signed: Signed: Cllr Norman Stephens.
    [Show full text]
  • Dover District Civilian Military Partnership Board REPORT 2016- 2018
    Dover District Civilian Military Partnership Board REPORT 2016- 2018 “Recognise, Remember, Integrate and Support” Jan 2019 1 A. Introduction The Dover District Community Covenant1 is a voluntary pledge of mutual support between a civilian community and its local Armed Forces community. It is intended to complement, at a local level, the national Armed Forces Covenant2, which outlines the mutual obligations between the Nation, the Government and the Armed Forces. The Dover District Armed Forces Community involves many different client groups - regular and reservist serving personnel, veterans, service leavers, dependants and carers and its level of presence varies greatly across the country. Here in the Dover District, although official figures are difficult to come by, given the significant size of the military footprint in the area over the years, we believe that the Armed Forces community is likely to be large, with many veterans living and working in the area. The Dover District Community Covenant was launched on 4 June 2013 and updated by Cllr Keith Morris, leader of the council on 15 October 2018. ? The government has encouraged Local Authorities and the Armed Forces community to work together to establish a Community Covenant in their area to: Encourage local communities to support the Armed Forces community in their area; Nurture understanding and awareness amongst the public of issues affecting the Armed Forces community; Recognise the contribution made by the Armed Forces community; Remember the sacrifices faced by the Armed
    [Show full text]
  • NATO Airstrike Magnifies Political Divide Over the War in Afghanistan
    Nxxx,2009-09-05,A,009,Bs-BW,E3 THE NEW YORK TIMES INTERNATIONAL SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 5, 2009 ØØN A9 NATO Airstrike Magnifies Political Divide Over the War in Afghanistan governor of Ali Abad, Hajji Habi- From Page A1 bullah, said the area was con- with the Afghan people.” trolled by Taliban commanders. Two 14-year-old boys and one The Kunduz area was once 10-year-old boy were admitted to calm, but much of it has recently the regional hospital here in Kun- slipped under the control of in- duz, along with a 16-year-old who surgents at a time when the Oba- later died. Mahboubullah Sayedi, ma administration has sent thou- a spokesman for the Kunduz pro- sands of more troops to other vincial governor, said most of the parts of the country to combat an estimated 90 dead were militants, insurgency that continues to gain judging by the number of charred strength in many areas. pieces of Kalashnikov rifles The region is patrolled mainly found. But he said civilians were by NATO’s 4,000-member Ger- also killed. man force, which is barred by In explaining the civilian German leaders from operating deaths, military officials specu- in combat zones farther south. lated that local people were con- The United States has 68,000 scripted by the Taliban to unload troops in Afghanistan, more than the fuel from the tankers, which any other nation; other countries were stuck near a river several fighting under the NATO com- miles from the nearest villages. mand have a combined total of about 40,000 troops here.
    [Show full text]
  • Download PDF on Watching the Watchmen
    REPORT Watching the Watchmen The Growing Case for Recall Elections and Increased Accountability for MPs Sam Goodman About the Author Sam Goodman is the author of the Imperial Premiership: The Role of the Modern Prime Minister in Foreign Policy Making, 1964-2015 (Manchester University Press: 2015). He is currently working as a political adviser to Peter Dowd MP the current Shadow Chief Secretary to the Treasury and has previously worked for a variety of Labour Members of Parliament including: Julie Cooper MP, Sir Mark Hendrick MP, Michael Dugher MP, and Rt. Hon Jack Straw MP. Watching the Watchmen: The Growing Case for Recall Elections and Increased Accountability for MPs Members of the House of Commons have long flirted parliamentary conventions and much procedure with the idea of British exceptionalism—citing the is arcane, which makes it difficult even for the UK’s role as the ‘mother of all parliaments’, its most ardent politically engaged citizen to follow unwritten constitution, its unitary voting system, proceedings and debates in the House of Commons. and the principle of the sovereignty of Parliament This separation between the governors and over the people—as a bulwark against the instability governed is exacerbated further by the limited customarily found in other western democracies. avenues available to the public to hold those elected In modern times, this argument held water as to account, which is exemplified by recent political it delivered stable parliamentary majorities, scandals, including allegations of bullying and peaceful transfers of power between governments, sexual harassment in the House of Commons. At the and kept in check the ideological fringes of both time of writing this report, no MP has been forced major political parties.
    [Show full text]
  • Combined E-Mails Sent Between PRYCE and OAKESHOTT
    Exhibit: LJN/12a Combined E-mails sent between PRYCE and OAKESHOTT -----Original Message---- From: isabel oakeshott < Date: Tue, I Mar~201120:08:15 To: <viclcypryce Subject: my gran plan I've spent most of the afternoon thinking about your situation from every angle and have come to some conclusions, which I hope you'll have a think about First of all, i think your reputation would be really damaged by a 'tell all' book with Angela Levin/ the Mail on Sunday. The Mail on Sunday is -at the end of the day- a fairly downmarket publication and a lot of people would think it a bit tawdry for you to be co-operating with them. I know it's got a big readership, but so has the News of the World! Ifyou are seen to be helping the Mail on Sunday, it will look bad- no two ways about it. There will also be an assumption that you've made money from it, - because everyone rightly assumes that papers like that use their cheque books to get their stories. That would be bad for your reputation. At the moment it sounds like you have a really good chance ofjoining the MPC in the nearish future, and in the longer term, perhaps even the House of Lords. It is not worth jeapardising that if it can be avoided. Given that you clearly want to tell your story, (and at the same time see that Chris gets what he deserves) that leaves two options: 1) do the book, but give serialisation rights to a more respectable paper, ie, the Sunday Times.
    [Show full text]
  • Document: D-26817DDE 00001
    The Holme, Clay Lane, Headley, Surrey. KT18 6JS £1,500,000 Freehold • Living Room & Separate Family Room • Family Bathroom • Open Plan Kitchen/Dining Room • SW Facing flint wall Formal Garden • Rear Lobby/Boot Room & Utility Room • Oak Framed Carport & Adjoining Garage • Downstairs Bed 5/Study with e/s Shower Room • Equestrian Opportunity 1-3 Church Street, Leatherhead, • Master Bedroom with En Suite Bathroom • Three Paddocks extending to Approx. 3 Acres Surrey KT22 8DN • 3 Further Bedrooms • Scope to extend (subject to Planning) 01372 360078 [email protected] www.patrickgardner.com The Holme A charming detached Victorian House occupying a plot of just over 4.5 acres This property also benefits from mains drains and mains gas which is unusual in including three paddocks (of approximately 3 acres) on the edge of this sought Headley. after Surrey Village and offering a rare family equestrian opportunity. This attractive detached late Victorian house was built, we believe, in Council Tax Band H approximately 1890 and is well presented by its current owners. EPC Rating F The property enjoys attractive elevations and is approached via a long private driveway with electric remote controlled gates and is set on its plot in such a way that it enjoys a high degree of privacy. The total land holding comprises paddocks, a small wooded area and formal part flint wall enclosed gardens which enjoy a sunny south westerly aspect. The light and airy accommodation includes a wealth of original features including a Reception Hall, spacious double aspect Living Room, Family Room, Kitchen/Dining Room with adjoining Utility Room and large walk-in larder, rear Lobby/Boot Room and a Ground Floor 5th Bedroom/study with En Suite Shower Room.
    [Show full text]
  • 21 Bus Time Schedule & Line Route
    21 bus time schedule & line map 21 Crawley - Dorking - Leatherhead - Epsom View In Website Mode The 21 bus line (Crawley - Dorking - Leatherhead - Epsom) has 4 routes. For regular weekdays, their operation hours are: (1) Box Hill: 7:08 PM (2) Crawley: 6:51 AM - 5:15 PM (3) Epsom: 6:20 AM - 2:46 PM (4) Leatherhead: 5:30 PM Use the Moovit App to ƒnd the closest 21 bus station near you and ƒnd out when is the next 21 bus arriving. Direction: Box Hill 21 bus Time Schedule 19 stops Box Hill Route Timetable: VIEW LINE SCHEDULE Sunday Not Operational Monday 7:08 PM Leatherhead Railway Station (T) Station Approach, Leatherhead Tuesday 7:08 PM Leret Way, Leatherhead Wednesday 7:08 PM Leret Way, Leatherhead Thursday 7:08 PM The Crescent, Leatherhead Friday 7:08 PM Russell Court, Leatherhead Saturday Not Operational Highlands Road, Leatherhead Seeability, Leatherhead Lavender Close, Leatherhead 21 bus Info Clinton Road, Leatherhead Direction: Box Hill Stops: 19 Glenheadon Rise, Leatherhead Trip Duration: 27 min Line Summary: Leatherhead Railway Station (T), Tyrrells Wood, Leatherhead Leret Way, Leatherhead, The Crescent, Leatherhead, Highlands Road, Leatherhead, Seeability, Headley Court, Headley Leatherhead, Clinton Road, Leatherhead, Glenheadon Rise, Leatherhead, Tyrrells Wood, Hurst Lane, Headley Leatherhead, Headley Court, Headley, Hurst Lane, Headley, The Cock Inn, Headley, Broome Close, The Cock Inn, Headley Headley, Crossroads, Headley, Headley Common Road, Headley, Headley Common Road, Broome Close, Headley Pebblecombe, The Tree, Box Hill,
    [Show full text]
  • Why Sacrifices in the Millennium
    Scholars Crossing Article Archives Pre-Trib Research Center May 2009 Why Sacrifices in The Millennium Thomas D. Ice Liberty University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/pretrib_arch Recommended Citation Ice, Thomas D., "Why Sacrifices in The Millennium" (2009). Article Archives. 60. https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/pretrib_arch/60 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Pre-Trib Research Center at Scholars Crossing. It has been accepted for inclusion in Article Archives by an authorized administrator of Scholars Crossing. For more information, please contact [email protected]. WHY LITERAL SACRIFICES IN THE MILLENNIUM Tom's Perspectives by Thomas Ice A common objection to the consistent literal interpretation of Bible prophecy is found in Ezekiel’s Temple vision (Ezek. 40—48). Opponents argue that if this is a literal, future Temple, then it will require a return to the sacrificial system that Christ made obsolete since the prophet speaks of “atonement” (kiper) in Ezekiel 43:13, 27; 45:15, 17, 20. This is true! Critics believe this to be a blasphemous contradiction to the finished work of Christ as presented in Hebrews 10. Hank Hanegraaff says that I have “exacerbated the problem by stating that without animal sacrifices in the Millennium, Yahweh’s holiness would be defiled. That, for obvious reasons, is blasphemous.” He further says that such a view constitutes a return “to Old Covenant sacrifices.”1 “Is it heretical to believe that a Temple and sacrifices will once again exist,” ask John Schmitt and Carl Laney? “Ezekiel himself believed it was a reality and the future home of Messiah.
    [Show full text]
  • 2 South Pacific Aviation Safety Management Systems Symposium
    2nd South Pacific Aviation Safety Management Systems Symposium Queenstown, 17 th /18 th Feb 2010 Symposium Programme compiled, designed and sponsored by , , 2nd South Pacific Aviation `Safety Management Systems’ Symposium – Queenstown, 17 th /18 th Feb 2010 SMS Implementation and Metrics “How do you do it , and how do you measure it” DAY ONE (17 th Feb 2010) Times Activity / Presentation Speaker 10.00-10.30 Registrations and Morning Tea - Sponsored by Queenstown Airport 10.30-10.40 • Call together Capt Bryan Wyness • Welcome on behalf of AIA Irene King • Welcome on behalf of CAANZ Graeme Harris 10.40-11.05 • GAPAN welcome Capt Wyness • Summaries and Reflectives from the first Symposium (getting on the same page) • Symposium Themes and format SMS Progress Reports: our `systems of safety’ of `systems our our `systems of safety’ of `systems our our `systems of safety’ of safety’ `systems of our `systems our • SAC/IRM Committees Ashok Poduval • ACAG and PWG (Project Working Group) Qwilton Biel • CAANZ Simon Clegg 11.05-11.45 • “The challenges of SMS implementation Dr Rob Lee and integration - some practical guidance” 11.45-12.10 • “A look at the new AS/NZS31000 - Geraint Birmingham implications and insights for the development of SMS’s” 12.10-12.20 • Questions From Delegates 12.20-12.50 Lunch – Sponsored by Navigatus Risk Consulting 12.50-12.55 Brief on the first workshop – format and Neil Airey outcome, 12.55-13.25 Workshop #1 1. Identify Top 10 issues within each 1. Odd Numbered Groups Certificate (Airline, GA, Airport, Airways How are we integrating, operating and implementing implementing and operating integrating, we are How How are we integrating, operating and implementing implementing and operating integrating, we are How How are we integrating, operating and implementing implementing and operating integrating, we are How How are we integrating, operating and implementing implementing and operating integrating, we are How and Maintenance), 2.
    [Show full text]
  • House of Lords Official Report
    Vol. 759 Tuesday No. 106 24 February 2015 PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (HANSARD) HOUSE OF LORDS OFFICIAL REPORT ORDER OF BUSINESS Questions National Curriculum: Animal Welfare .............................................................................................................1529 Gurkhas ................................................................................................................................................................1531 Yarl’s Wood .........................................................................................................................................................1533 Armed Forces: Baltic Defence ..........................................................................................................................1536 Specialist Printing Equipment and Materials (Offences) Bill Order of Commitment Discharged .....................................................................................................................1538 Consumer Rights Bill Commons Reason .................................................................................................................................................1539 Human Fertilisation and Embryology (Mitochondrial Donation) Regulations 2015 Motion to Approve..............................................................................................................................................1569 Gambling: Fixed-odds Betting Machines Question for Short Debate.................................................................................................................................1627
    [Show full text]
  • Defence White Paper 2003
    House of Commons Defence Committee Defence White Paper 2003 Fifth Report of Session 2003–04 Volume I HC 465-I House of Commons Defence Committee Defence White Paper 2003 Fifth Report of Session 2003–04 Volume I Report, together with formal minutes Ordered by The House of Commons to be printed 23 June 2004 HC 465-I Published on 1 July 2004 by authority of the House of Commons London: The Stationery Office Limited £0.00 The Defence Committee The Defence Committee is appointed by the House of Commons to examine the expenditure, administration, and policy of the Ministry of Defence and its associated public bodies. Current membership Mr Bruce George MP (Labour, Walsall South) (Chairman) Mr Crispin Blunt MP (Conservative, Reigate) Mr James Cran MP (Conservative, Beverley and Holderness) Mr David Crausby MP (Labour, Bolton North East) Mike Gapes MP (Labour, Ilford South) Mr Mike Hancock CBE MP (Liberal Democrat, Portsmouth South) Dai Havard MP (Labour, Merthyr Tydfil and Rhymney) Mr Kevan Jones MP (Labour, North Durham) Mr Frank Roy MP (Labour, Motherwell and Wishaw) Rachel Squire MP (Labour, Dunfermline West) Mr Peter Viggers MP (Conservative, Gosport) Powers The committee is one of the departmental select committees, the powers of which are set out in House of Commons Standing Orders, principally in SO No 152. These are available on the Internet via www.parliament.uk. Publication The Reports and evidence of the Committee are published by The Stationery Office by Order of the House. All publications of the Committee (including press notices) are on the Internet at www.parliament.uk/parliamentary_committees/defence_committee.cfm A list of Reports of the Committee in the present Parliament is at the back of this volume.
    [Show full text]
  • The Gurkhas', 1857-2009
    "Bravest of the Brave": The making and re-making of 'the Gurkhas', 1857-2009 Gavin Rand University of Greenwich Thanks: Matthew, audience… Many of you, I am sure, will be familiar with the image of the ‘martial Gurkha’. The image dates from nineteenth century India, and though the suggestion that the Nepalese are inherently martial appears dubious, images of ‘warlike Gurkhas’ continue to circulate in contemporary discourse. Only last week, Dipprasad Pun, of the Royal Gurkha Rifles, was awarded the Conspicuous Gallantry Cross for single-handedly fighting off up to 30 Taliban insurgents. In 2010, reports surfaced that an (unnamed) Gurkha had been reprimanded for using his ‘traditional’ kukri knife to behead a Taliban insurgent, an act which prompted the Daily Mail to exclaim ‘Thank god they’re on our side!) Thus, the bravery and the brutality of the Gurkhas – two staple elements of nineteenth century representations – continue to be replayed. Such images have also been mobilised in other contexts. On 4 November 2008, Chief Superintendent Kevin Hurley, of the Metropolitan Police, told the Commons’ Home Affairs Select Committee, that Gurkhas would make excellent ‘recruits’ to the capital’s police service. Describing the British Army’s Nepalese veterans as loyal, disciplined, hardworking and brave, Hurley reported that the Met’s senior commanders believed that ex-Gurkhas could provide a valuable resource to London’s police. Many Gurkhas, it was noted, were multilingual (in subcontinental languages, useful for policing the capital’s diverse population), fearless (and therefore unlikely to be intimidated by the apparently rising tide of knife and gun crime) and, Hurley noted, the recruiting of these ‘loyal’, ‘brave’ and ‘disciplined’ Nepalese would also provide an excellent (and, one is tempted to add, convenient) means of diversifying the workforce.
    [Show full text]