1 Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

1 Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee

RURAL ECONOMY AND CONNECTIVITY COMMITTEE INQUIRY INTO CONSTRUCTION AND PROCUREMENT OF FERRY VESSELS IN SCOTLAND SUBMISISON FROM ANONYMOUS To Whom it Concerns, I would like to raise the matter regarding one of Calmac Ferries, MV Loch Seaforth, which operates between Stornoway & Ullapool. I believe that this ferry is not fit for the waters of the North Minch because the stern gunnel is very close to the water when the sea becomes rough. I personally had an experience which was frightening whilst travelling on the MV Sullivan. The ship was knocked over onto its side by a wave 40/50 foot high, this wave occurs in the North Atlantic every so often which has an effect in the Minch. In my view, if this was to happen with MV Loch Seaforth she would be swept? stern down into the waters, likely resulting in the ship sinking causing loss of lives. In my view, the design of the ship is poorly laid out. Also in my view: 1) Passengers are unable to get outside at the front of the ship on both port & starboard sides for fresh air/ viewing etc.. 2) To have the dog area next to the main restaurant is unpleasant & unhygienic, I’ve actually left my meal through no choice due to pet hair lying/ floating around the area. 3) It can be quite annoying to hear dogs barking while trying to enjoy a meal or watch TV. 4) The two unfinished projects in the Ferguson Yard Glasgow are unfit for purpose. 5) The design of ships should be similar to Norwegian Design and not an open stern for the North Minch Crossing. I personally have travelled this route many times and have had many different experiences on this crossing. My thanks go out to Captain John Angus & Captain Alex Morrison who always got us home safe. My family and I, like many others, are too familiar with the waters we cross, have awareness in of the dangers at sea and strongly feel MV Loch Seaforth is most unsuitable for the Stornoway-Ullapool crossing. 1 Many people are wondering what is the final cost for MV Loch Seaforth and the two ferries in the Ferguson Yard. What is actually going on and who is making all these decisions? 2 .

Copy Link

Recommended publications

Lewis Public Exhibition Boards FINAL
Outer Hebrides STAG Appraisal Lewis Public Exhibition 24 th May 2018, 16:00-20:00 Caladh Inn - Stornoway What is the study about? • A transport appraisal of the long-term options for the ferry routes to, from and within the Outer Hebrides, including the Sounds, was a commitment made in the Vessel Replacement & Deployment Plan (VRDP) annual report for 2015 • Peter Brett Associates LLP has been commissioned by Transport Scotland to carry out this appraisal. The study is being informed and guided by a Reference Group, which is being led by Transport Scotland and includes Comhairle nan Eilean Siar, HITRANS, CMAL and CalMac Ferries Ltd • The appraisal will identify and evaluate options for the long- term (i.e. for the next 30 years) 2 Scottish Transport Appraisal Guidance (STAG) • The appraisal is being undertaken using a Transport Scotland process referred to as ‘STAG’, the approved guidance for the appraisal of potential transport projects • The principle of STAG is that it is objective-led rather than solution-led , ensuring that the option(s) ultimately taken forward address the identified transport problems and are the most appropriate when judged against a range of criteria • The study is currently at the Initial Appraisal stage, which will consider problems & opportunities with the current and potential future service 3 How and when are we engaging with communities? • Stage: Initial Appraisal • Purpose: To collect views on current and future problems and opportunities associated with the current service(s) • What engagement will take
[Show full text]
Annex a Foi/19/00491 – Documents Request
Annex A FoI/19/00491 – Documents Request:– “correspondence relating to the MV Clipper Ranger from 25th September 2018 until 18th February 2019 including meetings, emails, letters and reports between Scottish Ministers, Transport Scotland, CMAL, CalMac Ferries Ltd, SercoNorthlink and Seatrucks.” Time frame : 25th September 2018 until 18th February 2019 Received: 18 February 2019 Due: 18 March 2019 From: Garrett, Stuart (UK & Europe) [Redacted] Sent: 25 September 2018 12:25 To: TS official Subject: Clipper Ranger Serco Business [Redacted], I’m sure you are sighted on the latest position ref above, but just to ensure all relevant parties are sighted following text message rec’d yesterday evening at 2120hrs. Message was unsolicited and is captured below in its entirety as received from Alistair Eagles, same message may have been sent to others, I’m unsighted in that regard. ‘By Wednesday evening the Ranger will no longer be an option as we will have lifted our board approval on an external charter. Scotland has 2 days left if they want the ship …..this is it.’ [Redacted]I haven’t replied. If you felt it appropriate then I’m happy to do so. Regards, Stuart Stuart Garrett Managing Director, NorthLink Ferries Serco UK & Europe [Redacted] www.serco.com On 25 Sep 2018, at 18:15, TS officials wrote: Alistair FoI_19_00491 - MV Clipper Ranger - Documents - Redacted Final version 21March 2019 Page 1 of 36 Thanks again for a final opportunity to intervene. As I indicated in my earlier response, Scottish Ministers are not going to pursue the MV Clipper Ranger at this time. Thanks again [Redacted] From: Alistair Eagles Sent: 26 September 2018 07:52 To: TS officials Cc: @cmassets.co.uk Subject: RE: Clipper Ranger On a purely practical issue we had a couple of press enquiries yesterday about the Ranger from the usual suspects in Scotland.
[Show full text]
PURPOSE of REPORT to Consider the Outcomes of a Study Commissioned Into the Socioeconomic Impact of Capacity Constrained Ferry Services to and from the Outer Hebrides
TRANSPORTATION AND INFRASTRUCTURE COMMITTEE 21 FEBRUARY 2018 OUTER HEBRIDES FERRY SERVICES – CAPACITY CONSTRAINTS Joint report by Directors of Technical Services and Development PURPOSE OF REPORT To consider the outcomes of a Study commissioned into the socioeconomic impact of capacity constrained ferry services to and from the Outer Hebrides. COMPETENCE 1.1 There are no legal, financial, equalities or other constraints to the recommendations being implemented. SUMMARY 2.1 The provision of lifeline ferry services to and from the Outer Hebrides is central to the sustainability and well being of island communities. The economic and social potential of the islands can only be fully realised when reliable and sufficient transport links are in place between the islands and the mainland. 2.2 While the Comhairle welcomes the support of the Scottish Government in terms of subsidised ferry services and the sustained availability of Road Equivalent Tariff, there are significant capacity issues during peak periods which are constraining socioeconomic development. These capacity issues have been reported by travellers, the local Tourism sector and hauliers and, while some carrying statistics are available from ferry operator, Caledonian MacBrayne, it has been difficult to prove the actual socioeconomic impact of a constrained ferry service. 2.3 In order to accurately review the current impact of a constrained ferry service and its growing impact going forward, an Economist was commissioned to carry out a study into ferry capacities across the Outer Hebrides. 2.4 The resultant Study indicates that, over the last four years, vehicle carryings have increased by 25% while summer passenger numbers have increased by 21%.
[Show full text]
Western Isles Ferry Services
TRANSPORTATION AND INFRASTRUCTURE COMMITTEE 16 APRIL 2014 WESTERN ISLES FERRY SERVICES Report by Director of Technical Services PURPOSE OF REPORT To provide the Comhairle with an update on matters associated with the delivery of ferry services to the Western Isles. COMPETENCE 1.1 There are no legal, financial, equalities or other constraints to the recommendations being implemented. SUMMARY 2.1 The inaugural meeting of the Outer Hebrides Ferries Task Group, facilitated by the Comhairle, was held on Tuesday 11 March 2014 at which it was agreed that the remit of the Group was to develop and implement a coordinated, structured, fully-informed and evidence-based strategy to engage with Scottish Ministers, Transport Scotland, Caledonian Macbrayne (CalMac), Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd (CMAL) and other relevant stakeholders seeking to improve the standard, the capacity, the scheduling and the affordability of ferry services to the Outer Hebrides ensuring the demands and aspirations of all sectors of the community are met. 2.2 The Draft Minute of the meeting and the proposed Action Plan are included at Appendix 1 and 2 respectively to the Report for the information of the Comhairle. 2.3 In addition to the meeting of the Task Group, a meeting of the Hebrides Ferry Users Group, facilitated by HITRANS, was held later that same morning and was attended by senior representatives from Transport Scotland, CalMac Ferries Ltd and Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd (CMAL). The recurring themes between the two meetings were: • The lack of information from and consultation by the ferry operator regarding services to be in place following the introduction of the MV Loch Seaforth on the Stornoway Ullapool route • A significant concern regarding the capacity of the new vessel, particularly in the context of the HITRANS/OHTIA study • The adequacy of the pilot trial of the Mallaig Lochboisdale service 2.4 The Scottish Government Ferries Plan, published in December 2012, gave an undertaking to carry out a comprehensive review of large commercial fares.
[Show full text]
D NORTH HARRIS UIG, MORSGAIL and ALINE in LEWIS
GEOLOGY of the OUTER HEBRIDES -d NORTH HARRIS and UIG, MORSGAIL and ALINE in LEWIS. by Robert M. Craig, iii.A., B.Sc. GEOLOGY of the OUTER HEBRIDES - NORTH HARRIS and UIG, 'MORSGAIL and ALINE in LEWIS. CONTENTS. I. Introduction. TI. Previous Literature. III. Summary of the Rock Formations. IV. Descriptions of the Rock Formations - 1. The Archaean Complex. (a). Biotite- Gneiss. b). Hornblende -biotite- gneiss. d).). Basic rocks associated with (a) and (b). Acid hornblende -gneiss intrusive into (a) and (b). e . Basic Rocks intrusive into (a) and (b). f Ultra -basic Rocks. g ? Paragneisses. h The Granite- Gneiss. i Pegmatites. ?. Zones of Crushing and Crushed Rocks. S. Later Dykes. V. Physical Features. VI. Glaciation and Glacial Deposits. VII. Recent Changes. VIII. Explanation of Illustrations. I. INTRODUCTION. The area of the Outer Hebrides described in this paper includes North Harris and the Uig, Morsgail and Aline districts in Lewis. In addition, a narrow strip of country is included, north of Loch Erisort and extending eastwards from Balallan as far as the river Laxay on the estate of Soval. North Harris and its adjacent islands such as Scarp and Fladday on the west, and Soay in West Loch Tarbert on the south, forms part of Inverness - shire; Uig, Morsgail and Aline are included in Ross- shire. North Harris, joined to South Harris by the narrow isthmus at Tarbert, is bounded on the south by East and West Loch Tarbert, on the east by Loch Seaforb and on the west by the Atlantic Ocean. Its northern limit is formed partly by Loch Resort and partly by a land boundary much disputed in the past, passing from the head of Loch Resort between Stulaval and Rapaire to Mullach Ruisk and thence to the Amhuin a Mhuil near Aline Lodge on Loch Seaforth.
[Show full text]
1 Ardvourlie, Isle of Harris, HS3 3AB Offers
1 Ardvourlie, Isle of Harris, HS3 3AB Offers over £210,000 are invited HOME REPORT AVAILABLE Substantial dwelling house Accommodation consists of four en-suite bedrooms, two reception rooms, two kitchens and toilet. Capable of providing guesthouse accommodation. Parking Area Superior property in rural village location overlooking Loch Seaforth. Situated adjacent to the main Stornoway to Tarbert roadway. Ten miles from Tarbert, the main village on the Isle of Harris. Twenty five miles from Stornoway, the main town on the Isle of Lewis. 1st Kitchen 2nd Kitchen Reception Room 1 Reception Room 2 Bedroom 1 Bedroom 2 Bedroom 2 En-suite Bedroom 4 Bedroom 4 En-suite DIRECTIONS ACCOMMODATION Take the A859 out of Stornoway to Harris. Crossing over the Kitchen: 6.34m x 2.23m Harris/Lewis Bridge number 1 Ardvourlie is on the left hand side UPVC Double glazed exterior door. Fully fitted floor and wall located just below the road after the left hand side bend. There units in Pine. Integrated hob and extractor hood. Stainless is a red phone box outside. Our For Sale board should be in view. steel sink unit with mixer tap. Rear aspect window. Washing machine, tumble dryer and dishwasher. Wall mounted DESCRIPTION extractor fan. Triple spot light fitting. Fitted storage cupboard. Also housing central heating boiler. Radiator. Fitted Linoleum. Substantial detached 4 en-suite bedroom dwelling house is offered to the market. Extensively renovated in 1998. Reception Room 1: 4.37m x 4.33m Dual front and side aspect windows with Roman blinds. Situated in the small and beautiful village of Ardvourlie on the Feature exposed stone wall with timber cladding.
[Show full text]
Place Names, Highlands & Islands of Scotland
4 r D PLACE NAMES HIGHLANDS AND ISLANDS OF SCOTLAND y-V~7'*'t^ z^--*^ Q HIGHLANDS & ISLANDS OF SCOTLAND ALEX. MacBAIN, M.A.,LL.D. WITH NOTE.S AND A FOREWORD BY WILLIAM J. WATSON, MA.,LL.D. - \^' ^'--fSSSSS^.-sll^^ ENEAS MACKAY 43 MURRAY PLACE, STIRLING 1922 INTROiJUCTION. Dr Alexander Macbain's work on Names of Places deals with the Cehic names of pre-Gaehc " " he calls Pictish with Gaehc origin which ; names, ancl with names of Norse origin which have been transmitted through Gaelic. The area from which he took his materials was chiefly Inverness-shire, Sutherland, and Lewis. His views on the language spoken by the Picts are " given in his paper on Ptolemy's Geography of Scotland" (published separately), in his edition of Skene's "Highlanders of Scotland," and in several papers contained in this volume, particu- " larly that on the Place-Names of Inverness- shire." His position is that the Picts spoke that the Celtic Early British or a dialect of it, and language of early Britain was practically homo- geneous from the English Channel to the very North. He agrees with Kuno Meyer in holding " that no Gael ever set his foot on British soil save from a vessel that had put out from Ire- larid." Further, assuming that the terms Cruthen (which is the Gaelic form of Briton) and Pict are co-extensive and mutually convertible, VI. INTKODUCTION. ' ' ' he includes under Picts ' the whole of the Celtic settlers in Britain prior to the Belgae, thus ignoring the facts that the Picts are not heard of till about 300 %^, and that all old authorities (Gildas, Nennius, Bede, &c.) state that their original seat in Scotland was in the far North.
[Show full text]
Page 1 of 7 DAVID MACBRAYNE LIMITED MINUTES of BOARD
Page 1 of 7 DAVID MACBRAYNE LIMITED MINUTES OF BOARD MEETING HELD AT THE FERRY TERMINAL, GOUROCK ON WEDNESDAY 18 JUNE 2014 AT 10AM ____________________________________________________________________________________ Present: Mr D C McGibbon, Chairman Mr M Easton Mr S Hagan Ms P J D Stark Mr J Stirling Mr A V Tait Mr M Dorchester Mr R L Drummond In attendance: Mr R Hadfield, Scottish Government (Assessor) Mr S A Ure, Technical Director, CalMac Ferries Ltd Ms C Roberts, HR Director, David MacBrayne HR (UK) Ltd Mrs C Craig, Commercial Director, CalMac Ferries Ltd Mr A Collier, Chief Risk Officer, CalMac Ferries Ltd Captain Dale-Smith, Head of Marine, CalMac Ferries Ltd (part-time) Ms P Morrison, Project Manager, CalMac Ferries Ltd (part-time) Mr C P Paterson, Board Administrator 1. PRELIMINARIES Welcome and Apologies for absence Mr McGibbon extended a welcome to Mr Hadfield, Mr Ure, Ms Roberts, Mrs Craig and Mr Collier. There were no apologies for absence. Declarations of interest There were no further declarations of interest, other than those previously made and known to all Directors. 2. MINUTES/MATTERS ARISING Approve Minutes of Special Board Meetings held on 14 March 2014 It was agreed that Minutes for the Special Board meetings held on 14 March 2014 should be amended to more accurately reflect the Project approval process. Mr Hadfield noted a point of procedure that as Scottish Government Assessor, he should have attended these meetings. Approve Minutes of Special Board Meeting held on 16 April 2014 The Minutes for the Board Meeting held on 16 April 2014 were approved.
[Show full text]
Msc in Environment and Development David Macpherson
School of GeoSciences Dissertation For the degree of MSc in Environment and Development David Macpherson August 2014 The Roots of the People: an Investigation of the Influence of Community Landownership in Scotland on Environmental Narratives. *All pictures taken by researcher. (l-r: Abandoned settlement at Loch Trolmamaraig, Land Reform Act displayed at the Reinigeadal Hostel, North Harris trust cairn Bogha Glas) i Statement of Originality: I hereby declare that this dissertation has been composed by me and is based on my own work. Signed: David Macpherson Word count: 18,674 ii ABSTRACT Scotland hosts the most concentrated pattern of private land ownership in Europe, with sporting estates covering 43% of rural land. In the last two decades a growing land reform movement, advocating greater power over land use and greater diversity of land ownership, has led to the rapid expansion of community landownership, with local people now owning approximately 500,000 acres of some of Scotland’s most iconic landscapes. This governance model is rooted in narratives of sustainability and has been embraced by the current Scottish Government, leading to the building of new political momentum. Research in the past has focused on the economic and social impacts of community landownership. Therefore, this study considers the third pillar of sustainability: environmental responsibility. Through consideration of three framing narratives finding common expression in land reform and land use debates, an investigation was made of four community landowning areas to establish the influence of this transformative change. Results showed that community landownership contains the potential to recast relations with the environment by introducing a new pluralistic narrative of interpretation.
[Show full text]
Outer Hebrides Local Development Plan
Comhairle nan Eilean Siar Outer Hebrides Local Development Plan STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT ENVIRONMENTAL REPORT FEBRUARY 2010 SEA ENVIRONMENTAL REPORT – COVER NOTE PART 1 To: [email protected] or SEA Gateway Scottish Executive Area 1 H (Bridge) Victoria Quay Edinburgh EH6 6QQ PART 2 An Environmental Report is attached for [name of PPS]: Outer Hebrides Local Development Plan The Responsible Authority is: Comhairle nan Eilean Siar PART 3 Contact name Diane McPherson Job Title Principal Policy Officer (Planning) Comhairle nan Eilean Siar Contact address Balivanich Isle of Benbecula HS7 5LA Contact tel no 01870 602425 [email protected] Contact email PART 4 Signature (electronic signature is acceptable) Date 25th February 2010 1 CONTENTS Page 1. NON TECHNICAL SUMMARY 4 Introduction and Purpose of Strategic Environmental Assessment 4 How to comment on the Environmental Report 4 Summary of SEA and Local Development Plan Stages 5 SEA Process 6 Likely Evolution of the Environment in the absence of the LDP 6 Summary of the Likely Significant Effects of the LDP 7 2. ENVIRONMENTAL REPORT - INTRODUCTION 8 Purpose of this Environmental Report 8 Local Development Plan Key Facts 9 SEA Activities to Date 10 3. OUTER HEBRIDES LOCAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN AND ITS CONTEXT 11 Outline of the Plan 11 Objectives of the Plan 11 Relationship with other Plans, Programmes and Environmental Objectives 11 Relevant Aspects of Current State of the Environment 12 Environmental Baseline 13 Gaps in Baseline Information 19 Significant Environmental Issues 19 Evolution of the Environment in the absence of the LDP 22 4. ASSESSMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS & PROPOSED MITIGATION 24 SEA Methodology 24 Alternatives Considered 27 Assessment Outcomes 27 Key Findings and Proposed Mitigation Measures 29 Conclusion 31 5.
[Show full text]
Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee
RURAL ECONOMY AND CONNECTIVITY COMMITTEE INQUIRY INTO CONSTRUCTION AND PROCUREMENT OF FERRY VESSELS IN SCOTLAND SUBMISSION FROM MULL & IONA FERRY COMMITTEE In our primary evidence to the RECC inquiry1, we suggested that sight of the ‘Specification of Operational and Technical Requirements (SOTR)’ in relation to hulls 801 and 802 would be important to your inquiry. This document is the primary descriptor of the key vessel specifications, and therefore dictated all subsequent design decisions. We have now obtained the SOTR from CalMac by FOI, and make it available to the Committee as an Annex to this submission. In addition to the SOTR, there is an ‘Initial High Level Requirements Specification’, which CalMac provided together with the SOTR, also annexed to this submission. CalMac have confirmed that they produced the SOTR, as has Scottish Government in their evidence. The ‘Initial High Level Requirements Specification’ (IHLRS) was also produced by CalMac “…to summarise the tri-partite meeting between us, TS and CMAL”. The SOTR is a long technical document, the IHLRS much less so. We have also received detailed carrying records for the entire CalMac fleet for a full calendar year (October ’18 to September ’19), and have analysed them in order to compare the ‘Operational Requirements’ laid out in the SOTR and IHLRS with the actual demands of the major vessel routes. After reading the SOTR and IHLRS together with the data analysis, there are three key conclusions: 1. PASSENGER CAPACITY FAR EXCEEDS DEMAND The 1000 passenger ‘requirement’ described in the SOTR appears to have no rigorous evidential or operational basis. It un-necessarily burdens the operator and tax payer with a high cost fleet, and results in extreme inflexibility of service for users.
[Show full text]
Western Isles Native Woodland Restoration Survey Report Restoration & Enhancement of Native Woodland Resources Sapling
Western Isles Native Woodland Restoration Survey Report restoration & enhancement of native woodland resources Sapling Native woodland, Bowglass, Isle of Harris Dog Rose Acknowledgements The author would like to thank Scottish Natural Heritage the many people who provided 32 Francis Street information, guidance and helped survey sites throughout the duration Stornoway of this project. They include Stewart Isle of Lewis Angus, Simon Fraser, Brendan Harty, Kevin Kennedy, Carol Knott, Mark T: 01851 705258 MacDonald, Iain MacIver, Kenny MacKay, Donald MacLeod, Duncan MacPherson and Paul Smith. Comhairle nan Eilean Siar This report has been part-funded by Sandwick Road Scottish Natural Heritage Stornoway Isle of Lewis HS1 2BW T: 01851 703773 F: 01851 709287 Western Isles Native Woodland Restoration Survey Report 2 Contents Summary .....................................................................................................................................5 Context .....................................................................................................................................5 the Western Background ...................................................................................................................................6 Methodology ...............................................................................................................................7 Isles once Key Sites .....................................................................................................................................8
[Show full text]