INSTITUTE PROCEEDINGS A Vietnam minefield experience

an address1 to the Institute on 30 August 2011 by Dr Tony White, AM, RFD2

Tony White describes treating casualties in a minefield during his deployment to in 1966-67 as regimental medical officer of the 5th , Royal Australian . Key words: ; minefield casualties; medical officer; Australian infantry battalion. During the Vietnam War in the 1960s, I served in 1st Australian Task Force Operations South Vietnam as the regimental medical officer (RMO) in Phouc Tuy Province of an Australian infantry battalion, the 5th Battalion of In April 1966, HMAS Sydney transported one the Royal Australian Regiment (5RAR), for a year in of 5RAR plus stores and vehicles to Vung Tau, 1966-67. Let me start by placing that year in some a port on the Vietnamese coast south-east of Saigon, chronological and geographical context. the capital of South Vietnam. The rest of the battalion ’s direct involvement in the war in Vietnam was transported from RAAF Richmond (an airbase began in 1962 with the posting to South Vietnam of 30 near Sydney) to Saigon in a series of Qantas members of the Training Team (Australian civilian airline) night flights over two weeks. (AATTV). In 1964, six Caribou aircraft of No. 35 The task force, under the command of Transport , Royal Australian Air Force David Jackson, was allotted an area in the centre of (RAAF), were deployed. Later that year, conscription for Phuoc Tuy (now Baria-Vung Tau) Province for its base. military service was introduced in Australia. The area was an abandoned rubber plantation close to March 1965 saw the arrival in Vietnam of the first a small hill called . The base was 30 kilometres American combat . In May 1965, the 1st Battalion inland from the Australian Logistic Support Group of the Royal Australian Regiment (1RAR) was sent to (ALSG), which had been set up on the sand dunes the Bien Hoa airbase to operate as part of the United outside Vung Tau. The ALSG included stores, work- States (US) . Later that year, shops and 2nd Field Ambulance, which contained both a they were joined by an Australian artillery battery, casualty treatment and a casualty evacuation engineers and army aviation. section. 1966 was a turbulent year. In January, the Minister The province had a population of about 104,000. It for Defence, Senator Shane Paltridge, died in office. He measured 60 x 40 kilometres and faced onto the South was replaced by Allen Fairhall. One week later, the China Sea. Its western border was 40 kilometres east of Prime Minister, Sir Robert Menzies, resigned and was succeeded by Harold Holt. On the same day, Malcolm Fraser replaced A. J. Forbes as Minister for the Army. On 2 March 1966, cabinet decided to increase Australia’s commitment to a self-contained task force of two infantry , a Special Air Service squadron3, combat and logistic support troops and eight Iroquois helicopters of No. 9 Squadron, RAAF. The task force was to be operational within two months. This decision has to be taken in the context of cabinet’s veto of any preparation for just such a force six months previously. Preparations for deployment were therefore rushed and chaotic, accounting for many of the logistic problems later experienced in Vietnam. Both battalions were brand new, having been raised only 12 months previously. Roughly half the personnel were national servicemen (conscripts).

1 This address is based on an incident recorded in Dr White’s 2011 book, Phuoc Tuy Province, South Vietnam, 1966 – the Australian Task Starlight: An Australian Army Doctor in Vietnam (Copyright Publishing: Force base was located north of the village of Hoa Long; the Brisbane), which is reviewed on page 35. Australian Logistic Support Group is indicated by the black box 2E-mail: [email protected] 3Essentially, highly-trained infantry that specialise in intelligence gathering east of the port city of Vung Tau and surveillance behind enemy lines. [Map: Australian War Memorial, Wartime Issue 55, p. 26, July 2011]

United Service 62 (4) December 2011 Page 13 Saigon. The main industries were fishing, rice-growing, metres, they were riddled with caves containing rubber plantations and charcoal. The only areas under extensive Viet Cong facilities. government control before arrival of the Australian task Earlier in the month during Tet, the Lunar New Year force were the provincial capital, Baria, and the corridor festival, a Viet Cong flag, spot-lit at night, flew defiantly from Baria to the port of Vung Tau. There were from a flagpole at the southern end of the hills. Eight government outposts in towns around the province, but months previously, the US 173rd Airborne Brigade had these were isolated and effectively under siege by the done a sweep through the area, suffering heavy National Liberation Front (NLF), a communist political casualties. organisation which sought the overthrow of the Most of the cordon-and-searches had been single southern government and the re-unification of south battalion operations. Phuoc Hai would need both and . Its military arm was the Viet Cong, Australian battalions. 6RAR would be helicoptered in at the communist guerrilla forces of South Vietnam. The first light from Nui Dat to block the eastern side of the NLF and the Viet Cong were strongly supported by village. 5RAR, approaching by land, would be North Vietnam. responsible for the western side. After three weeks of preparation on the beach at As with all these cordon-and-search operations, a Vung Tau, 5RAR was ferried up to the Nui Dat area in deception plan was required to get the battalion into four waves of 30 Iroquois helicopters of the US 68th position without arousing suspicion. The plan was for Aviation Company. It was an unopposed insertion – the 5RAR to carry out a search-and-destroy operation over US 173rd Airborne Brigade, at some cost, had cleared the eastern approaches and side of the Long Hai hills. the area prior to our arrival. One month later we were Moving from north to south over a week, the battalion joined by 6RAR. The next 12 months saw an unending would end up at the south-eastern corner of the hills the programme of patrolling and operations from one end of afternoon before the Phuoc Hai operation and only two the province to the other. The Nui Dat base was slowly kilometres to the west of the village. We could then be transformed from a muddy rubber plantation into a in place on the edge of the village by first light. small town. The most notable event of 1966, indeed of Operation Bribie Australia’s 10-year involvement in Vietnam, was D Events turned out very differently from the way they Company 6RAR’s on 18 August were planned. As mentioned earlier, this one week in 1966. February 1967, however, was the worst month for mid February 1967 proved a very expensive one for the task force casualties up to that point and that record Australian Task Force. The Long Hai operation itself stood for some time. 5RAR fell victim to two mine was preceded by a cordon-and-search of the village of incidents a week apart with a total of nine killed-in- An Nhut on 14 February. Shortly after the An Nhut action and 24 wounded. In the days between these two search got under way, the headquarters of 5RAR’s C incidents, 6RAR was mauled in Operation Bribie with Company was gathered on the fence line when an eight killed-in-action and 27 wounded. explosive device detonated, killing three officers and wounding five soldiers. Those killed included the Cordon-and-Search Operations company commander, Don Bourne, his second- The two 5RAR mine incidents were linked with in-command, Captain Bob Milligan and Captain Peter cordon-and-search operations. In these operations, the Williams, the New Zealand artillery forward observer. battalion would creep up on a village overnight so as to Major Bourne had just taken over command of the have a cordon in place before first light to prevent company and this was his first operation. He was the villagers leaving. The village would then be searched, father of four young children and it was his 35th birthday. house to house, usually by Vietnamese government Captain Milligan was due to return to Australia shortly troops. 5RAR carried out nine such operations during and this was to be his last operation. He was a popular the year and they proved very useful in terms of the officer who had been dux of his year at the Officer numbers of Viet Cong suspects captured, and the Cadet School and had won the Governor General’s quantity of weapons and documents seized. Medal. The nature of the An Nhut explosion was never The village of Phuoc Hai, just east of the Long Hai clarified. hills, was chosen for the next cordon-and-search. This Three days later (the day before the planned start of had a population of 8000 and was a very productive the Long Hai operation), the enemy attacked the fishing fishing village, supplying the Saigon market as well as village of Phuoc Hai, the object of our next cordon-and- the province. The Viet Cong had infiltrated a large cadre search. 6RAR responded and their ensuing engage - into the village and undertook a lot of recruiting there. ment, Operation Bribie, turned into a ferocious 5-hour The Long Hai hills had been a guerrilla haven since fire-fight, with numerous casualties. Disaster was only French colonial times. They were the centrepiece of a narrowly averted. 30 square kilometre area named after two Viet Minh4 martyrs as the Minh Dam Secret Zone. Rising to 330 Operation Renmark A B52 strike had been arranged for early on the

4The communist guerrillas of North Vietnam morning of 18 February to coincide with the start of

Page 14 United Service 62 (4) December 2011 5RAR’s next phase, Operation Renmark, searching the Soldiers and equipment lay scattered over an area the foothills of the Long Hai hills. Because of Operation size of a tennis court. Bribie, the start was delayed and the element of a After landing, I found that one of the stretcher- surprise strike was lost. Nevertheless, the search got bearers had been killed. All the others, and the under way and the first two days were relatively company medical assistant, Corporal Ron Nichols, uneventful. were wounded. Most of the troops, even those not On the third day, the companies moved south to physically injured, were stunned. position themselves for the next phase of the operation. The first group of casualties I encountered was the At 1330 hours on 21 February, 5RAR’s B Company, B Company headquarters group. The company mounted on armoured personnel carriers (APCs), set commander, Major Bruce McQualter, had a head forth towards the Long Hai hills. Battalion headquarters wound. He was conscious, struggling to get up on his was to follow after half an hour. Shortly after 1400 feet, but unable to respond to questions or commands. hours, there was the sound of a large explosion from Stretched out next to him, also with a head wound and their line of travel and the sight of a black mushroom unconscious was the 4th commander, rising above the tree line. Four minutes later there was Lieutenant Jack Carruthers. The Platoon Sergeant, a second smaller explosion and a cloud of dust. After a Tassie Wass, was the most urgent casualty with both delay, there was a radio call notifying headquarters of elbows shattered and wounds to the back. After casualties, but with no details. dressing his wounds and giving morphine, I moved on We in battalion headquarters were only two or three towards the upended APC. kilometres away. There happened to be an army Near the rear of the APC there was a pyramid of aviation reconnaissance helicopter parked with us at what at first glance appeared to be discarded that time and I was soon on my way to the site of the equipment and uniforms. It was a dark grey colour. On explosions. Circling to find a spot to land, we were closer inspection, it proved to be a pile of dead and astonished by the sight of an APC lying on its side. wounded soldiers blown out of the back of the vehicle. It was not until 30 years later that I discovered the cause of the blackened skin and uniforms. As protection against mines, two layers of sandbags had been laid on the floor of the APCs. The sand used was very fine and black; the boys had literally been sand-blasted by the explosion. Many of the wounded were suffering from the effects of the explosive blast and were peppered with shrapnel. They required little treatment apart from dressings. On the other hand, there were some horrific sights, including an arm with the attached hand grasping a rifle. This arm was protruding from under the APC, which had crushed the soldier to death. There was also the torso of another soldier separated by some distance from the lower half of his body. To huge relief, four sappers5 with mine detectors were choppered in within half an hour of the explosions. They got to work, laying white tape to indicate clear pathways. Soon dust-off helicopters6 started to arrive. It was a busy time, trying to get casualties away in order of need. The last casualties were evacuated within about 90 minutes of the explosions. Mercifully this proceeded without enemy interference. 4 Platoon B Company bore the brunt of the casualties. Their platoon commander, Lieutenant Jack Carruthers, died of head wounds in hospital three days later. Three others were killed and 13 wounded. One of the wounded was Private Ted Lloyd. He was back in the platoon after three weeks, but was killed in a second mine incident three weeks later. In that same incident, Lieutenant Kerry Rinkin, who had replaced Jack

5RAR’s search pattern over the eastern approaches to Long Hai hills on Operation Renmark, February 1967 5Army engineers [Diagram: O’Neill 1968, 219] 6Casualty evacuation helicopters

United Service 62 (4) December 2011 Page 15 Carruthers as platoon commander, was also killed. later they were still perfectly serviceable. Triage was the Major Bruce McQualter died of his head wounds in other important function. This is the process of ranking hospital after twelve days. casualties in order for evacuation to ensure that the The engineers did a good forensic job of working out severely wounded but salvageable soldiers were what had caused this disaster. The lead APC was hit by evacuated ahead of the mortally wounded or those with what is now described as an improvised explosive non-life threatening wounds. device. This was a buried, recycled, 5-inch US naval shell. It was rigged up with a detonator and battery. Conclusion Pressure from the passing vehicle closed the wire Mine incidents continued to plague the Australian circuit, detonating the explosion. The force was forces throughout the Vietnam War and at times considerable, throwing the 11-tonne APC three metres accounted for over half the casualties. To compound the off to one side and leaving a 2 metre by 1 metre crater. grief, most of the mines had been lifted skilfully by the As Major McQualter and the medics went forward to enemy from allied minefields and re-laid to the enemy’s assist the wounded, one of them stepped on an M16 advantage. The controversy over the use of mines mine. This “jumping jack”, with its half kilogram of TNT continues to this day. and a killing range of 25 metres, caused most of the casualties. Two more M16 mines were detected by the The Author: Australian born but brought up in Kenya, sappers in the immediate area as they carried out their Dr White graduated in medicine from the University of search. Sydney and served as a doctor in the Australian Army At that time, there were no clear instructions as to for five years. This included a year in Vietnam where he how to respond when it becomes evident that a party is was mentioned-in-despatches. Subsequently, he stalled in a minefield. Logic declares that there should practised privately as a dermatologist in Sydney for 32 be no movement until sappers have cleared paths. One years before retiring in 2010. During this time, he was a soldier, a corporal section commander, swears to this visiting medical officer at Royal Prince Alfred Hospital day that he said he would shoot me if I walked any and a clinical senior lecturer at the University of Sydney. further after stepping out of the helicopter that had He also served as an Army Reservist in the Royal dropped me off. I have no recollection of this, but Australian Army Medical Corps, attaining the rank of fortunately he did not follow through with his threat. colonel and being awarded the Reserve Force After this incident, when personnel found them - Decoration. In 2009, he was appointed a member in the selves in a minefield, it became standard procedure for General Division of the Order of Australia for all personnel to freeze until the area had been cleared contributions to remote area dermatological practice by sappers. This must have presented some agonising and education. [Photo of Dr White: Colonel J. M. Hutcheson, MC] dilemmas, preventing soldiers from going to the aid of wounded comrades. Reference My role as RMO was simple first aid, albeit in a very O’Neill, Robert J. (1968). Vietnam Task: The 5th trying situation. Our shell dressings were made in Battalion, The Royal Australian Regiment, 1966/67 England and date-stamped April 1915. Half-a-century (Cassell Australia: Melbourne).

Page 16 United Service 62 (4) December 2011