Archaeologist
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Vol. 9 Number 4 ohi1 0 Archaeologist OCTOBER 1959 THE ARCHAEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF OHIO (Formerly Ohio Indian Relic Collectors Society) The Archacolological Society of Ohio Editorial Offices Business Offices 270 Orchard Lane, Columbus 14, Ohio 65 N. Foster Street, Norwalk, Ohio Tel. AMherst 2-9334 Tel. Norwalk 2-7285 Officers President - Ernest G. Good, 15 Civic Drive, Grove City, Ohio Vice-President - MacDonald Schumm, 146 W. Union St. , Circleville, Ohio Secretary-Treasurer - Arthur George Smith, 65 North Foster St. , Norwalk, Ohio Trustees Merton R. Mertz, 422 Third St. , Findlay, Ohio (Term expires May, I960) Robert W. Weick, 741 Greene St., Toledo 9, Ohio (Term expires May, I960) Gerald Brickman, 409 Locust St. , Findlay, Ohio (Term expires May, 1961) Harley W. Glenn, 2011 W. Devon Rd., Columbus 12, Ohio (Term expires May, 1961) Emmett W. Barnhart, Northridge Rd. , Circleville, Ohio (Term expires May, 1962) John W. Schatz, 80 South Franklin, Hilliards, Ohio (Term expires May, 1962) Editorial Staff Editor - Ed W. Atkinson, 270 Orchard Lane, Columbus 14, Ohio* Technical Editor - Raymond S. Baby, Ohio State Museum, N. High & 15th, Cols. 10, O. Associate Editors - Thyra Bevier Hicks, Ohio State University, Columbus 10, Ohio Assistant Editors - John C. Allman, 1336 Cory Drive, Dayton 6, Ohio > - Ralph J. Servey, 1726 Baird Avenue, Portsmouth, Ohio - Arthur George Smith, 65 North Foster St. , Norwalk, Ohio - Harley W. Glenn, 2001 W. Devon Rd., Columbus 12, Ohio - Harry H. Ball, 449 Spaulding Ave. , Newcomerstown, Ohio *address after Nov. 1, 420 Chatham Road, Columbus 14. Program Committee Chairman - Dr. Stanley G. Copeland, 1054 Lilley Ave., Columbus 6, Ohio Advisory - Raymond S. Baby, Ohio State Museum, N. High 8t 15th, Cols. 10, O. Members - Gerald Brickman, 409 Locust St. , Findlay, Ohio - Norman L. Dunn, 1025 S. West St., Findlay, Ohio - Bennett E. Kelley, 138 S. Fayette St., Washington C. H. , Ohio - Donald McBeth, R. R. #1, Kingston, Ohio - Merton R. Mertz, 422 Third St. , Findlay, Ohio - Thomas A. Minardi, 411 Cline St., Mansfield, Ohio - Arthur George Smith, 65 North Foster St. , Norwalk, Ohio Membership Committee National Dr. Stanley G. Copeland, 1054 Lilley Ave. Columbus 6, Ohio Lynn Munger, R. R. #3, Angola, Indiana Ohio Northwestern Arthur George Smith, 65 North Foster St. , Norwalk, Ohio North Central Merton R. Mertz, 422 Third St. , Findlay, Ohio Northeastern Thomas A. Minardi, 411 Cline St., Mansfield, Ohio South Central J. H. Barker, R R. #3, Lebanon, Ohio Southern Ralph Servey, 1726 Baird Ave. , Portsmouth, Ohio Table of Contents The President's Page 112 Guffey-Type Fake Bird, photo courtesy Donald E. Kohl 113 The William H. Davis Mound, by Ed W. Atkinson 114-116 The Zimmerman and Williams Sites, by Norman L. Dunn (in collaboration with Edward Galitza) 117-121 Glacial Kame Fund 121 Adena Points, photo courtesy Dr. Stanley G. Copeland 122 Adena Points, by Robert E. Bell 123 More Notes on the Transitional Period in the Shenango Valley, by Charles O. Fobes, Jr 124-127 Snyders Points, photo courtesy Dr. Stanley G. Copeland 128 Snyders Points, by Robert E. Bell 129 Cave Finds from Kentucky, by Ernest G. Good 130 Devola Workshop Site, by Richard P. Patterson 131 -1 34 That Basic Tool--the Hammerstone, by Thomas A. Minardi . 135-136 Birdstone Find in Fayette County 1 37 More on Obsidian in Ohio, by Robert E. Bell 137 Scioto Gravel Burials, by Richard McClish 1 38-1 39 A Peculiar Knife Type, by Arthur George Smith 140 Last of the Ohio Elm Tree Markers ? by Claude Britt, Jr 141 Book Reviews, by Arthur George Smith, Editor 142-143 Membership List Now Ready 144 Errata 144 Necrology , 144 Notes and Personals 145 Chapter Notes 146 New Members 146 The Trading Post third cover Object of the Society ***** The Archaeological Society of Ohio is organized to discover and conserve archaeological sites and material within the State of Ohio; to seek and promote a better understanding among stu dents and collectors of archaeological material, professional and non-professional, including individuals, museums and institutions of learning; and to disseminate knowledge on the subject of archaeology. Membership is open to all persons of suitable character and interest. The annual dues are payable either the first of January or the first of July each year. Adult dues are $3. 50 and juniors up to 18 are $1. 75 per year. Funds obtained are used for publishing the "OHIO ARCHAEOLOGIST" (all articles and pictures are furnished by the members) and for office supplies and postage. The Society is an incorporated non-profit organization, and has no paid officers or employees. ***** The Ohio Archaeologist is published quarterly in January, April, July, October. Price per issue $1. 00. Subscription included in the Society's annual membership dues. Address all articles, personal news, queries and comments. Trading Post copy and payment, etc. , to the Editor. Address all communications concerning application for membership, change of address, pur chase of back numbers, and other business matters to the Secretary-Treasurer. - Ill - The President's Page by Ernest G. Good As with every year, 1959 can be called a year of change. Archaeol- ogically speaking, changes in the landscape that involve the disturbance of the earth are the significant ones. Here in Ohio, as in every state, these activities are everywhere. For example, the North-South superhighway is cutting across the state from Conneaut to Cincinnati, slicing through some of Ohio's richest prehistoric Indian sites. Right here in Franklin County, I know of 5 such sites disturbed or completely destroyed by construction of this highway and connecting roads. Commercial buildings and residential developments are taking over farmland at an alarming rate. Within the past 12 months at least two important sites have been destroyed here in Franklin County. In many areas, as we saw in western Kentucky just a few weeks ago, the damming up of rivers is flooding thousands of acres of archaeologi- cally rich land. It is the obligation of every ASO member, I think, to be alert to such changes as these in his own area. And to act quickly, when each pro ject is first announced, to salvage whatever archaeological sites are threatened. Get your fellow ASO members to help you conduct the best possible salvage operation before construction or flooding becomes an immediate threat. The earlier you start, the more scientific and painstaking your "dig" can be planned and carried out. Lost sites, unexplored, can have another effect on our interests as archaeologists and collectors. Every unexplored site can mean the loss of fine artifacts, thus causing the supply available to collectors to diminish each year. This is the situation already, and it encourages the maker of fakes to take advantage of the scarcity. Remember--a man who wants to trade or sell a genuine artifact is never afraid to have other competent collectors examine it and judge its genuineness. Only the faker after the "fast buck" will hesitate. Examine carefully any piece you are thinking of acquiring — seek out other opinion if you and the owner have any doubts. While on our vacation in September, my wife Dorothy and I--along with Ed Atkinson--spent a most enjoyable afternoon and evening with Dr. and Mrs. T. Hugh Young at their home in Nashville, Tennessee. We never tire of studying their wonderful collection and visiting with these two fine people. They always welcome a visit from any of our members. Found a number of interesting artifacts on our "dig" this year. Come and see them whenever you can--you're always welcome. - 112 - CM r— •••• iff <J Guffey-type fake bird in the collection of Donald E. Kohl, Newcom- erstown, Ohio. Brown banded slate (Kentucky? ). Wrong material, tail too square and too thick, Guffey-type rib on tail. And just too perfect all over! - 113 - The William H. David Mound By Ed W. Atkinson, 270 Orchard Lane, Columbus 14, Ohio The discovery of Archaic burials beneath an early Adena burial mound has established for the first time that the one culture directly followed the other. This is the one most significant observation recently announced by Raymond S. Baby, Curator of the Ohio Historical Society's Archaeo logical Department, following many weeks' excavation of the William H. Davis Mound just north of East Main Street and a few hundred yards east of Noe-Bixby Road, Columbus. The excavation was scheduled as a salvage operation, since the mound had been greatly reduced by bulldozing from a height of 1 8 feet to 4-1/2 feet in advance of a commercial and housing development. Working to the base of the Adena mound, Ray Baby and his as sistants Asa Mays, Jr. and Robert M. Goslin directed a team of Ohio State students in removing 27 Adena burials. Fig. 1 shows a general view of the work, and gives some idea of the extent of the 80-foot di ameter mound. The investigation of two Adena sub-floor burial pits led to the dis covery of numerous Archaic burials made in circular pits measuring about 2-1/2 feet by 3 feet. Figs. 2 and 3 record some of the burials, and Fig. 4 shows one of the artifact associations. Location of the Adena mound burials directly above the Archaic bur ials was probably accidental, Baby believes. But this association is of great significance in providing the first evidence of the time relation ship between the two prehistoric cultures. Ohio Archaeologist plans a much more complete report in a later issue of both the Adena and the Archaic finds and their interpretation. Fig. 1 (Baby)--General view of the floor of the Adena mound. - 114 - Fig. 2 (Baby)--Ray Baby and student Martha Potter record data on an Archaic burial.