Everyday Life and the Politics of Urgency in Kathmandu

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Everyday Life and the Politics of Urgency in Kathmandu Mutable Aspirations and Uncertain Futures: Everyday life and The Politics of Urgency in Kathmandu by Sabin Ninglekhu A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor in Philosophy in Geography Department of Geography and Program in Planning University of Toronto © Copyright by Sabin Ninglekhu, 2016 Mutable Aspirations and Uncertain Futures: Everyday life and the Politics of Urgency in Kathmandu Sabin Ninglekhu Doctor in Philosophy in Geography Department of Geography and Program in Planning University of Toronto 2016 Abstract This dissertation interrogates the right to the city as a category of analysis with recourse to an account of extreme marginality. As a starting premise, it seeks inspiration from Kristin Ross’ (1987) take on everyday life as a site of dominant relations of power on the one hand, and an incubator of utopian possibilities on the other. To this end, the dissertation probes three key questions. The first question asks: what are the conditions of possibility enabling the “slum dwellers” (sukumbasi in Nepali) in Kathmandu, Nepal, to make claims for the right to the city? I document the rituals of everyday life and the capacity to make claims that are organized through a metaphorical framework of a “house with three pillars." The second question broaches the issue of how claims for a right to the city come up against governmental programs seeking to secure norms of private property, environmental sustainability, and elite aesthetics. It asks: How does the threat of violence forge sukumbasi ii political subjectivity and inform renewed strategies of inhabitance? The third question investigates what implications these strategies have for diminishing, or modifying, the right to the city project? The last two questions prompt us to locate the practices of the poor within the context of a “politics of urgency” – an ad hoc creative and counterintuitive “non- movement” forged in the crucible of crisis, in which the organized ritual of everyday life is disrupted and stretched in new and uncertain directions. It is under these conditions that the demand for the right to the city loses its aspirational spirit on the one hand, while ushering in an evolving politics of possibility, on the other. In considering the politics and contingencies of the right to the city, we are presented with a stark understanding of the possibilities and limits of the political aspirations of the poor. The dissertation draws on ethnographic research of “the slum” in Kathmandu, and aims to combine Postcolonial Urbanism, Planning Theory and Critical Urban Studies to constructively probe the role of urban everyday life in troubling the political contours of the right to the city project. iii Acknowledgement This dissertation is an outcome of countless moments of feeling empowered and disempowered; these experiences have been interspersed over years of reading, researching, writing, and rewriting, and procrastinating, that have been both inspiring and excruciating in equal measure. I am pleased that the dissertation has finally seen the light of the day. A heartfelt note of thank you, therefore, should go to my supervisor, comrade, and colleague, Dr. Katharine N. Rankin, for relentlessly and passionately pushing me over and over again as if she was never prepared to give up on me. Enormous gratitude goes to my partner, Sirjana Pant, whose notes of encouragement conveyed through a perfect balance of patience and urgency always served as an everyday source of motivation and focus. Dr. Kanishka Goonewardena, Dr. Rachel Silvey and Dr. Anderson Sorensen are my dissertation committee members who have together provided constructive criticism, incisive feedback, and much- needed empathy in constantly re-invigorating the intellectual self that was necessary to inject energy into the dissertation time and again. Dr. Mark Hunter, the internal dissertation examiner, provided insightful comments during the final exam that has pushed the dissertation in a new direction. I owe a special thank you to my external examiner and the appraiser during the final exam, Dr. AbdouMaliq Simone, for a meticulous reading of my work and a very thoughtful set of encouraging comments that have helped me take ownership of the future direction of this project with renewed vigor and confidence. Without Yogendra Shakya, friend and mentor, this journey would not even have begun. Likewise, it would have been impossible to end this journey without Smita Acharya, Raju Lama and Moti lama, the fellow inhabitants of the city that I come from, Kathmandu, with whom I continue to collaborate in activism and planning for the right to the city. To my mom and dad, I dedicate this work for their dignified silence towards the latter stages of the PhD, which could have meant anything, but I mostly decided to take it as a source of inspiration. Few names remain unnamed because I have already thanked them in the hearts of my heart. iv Table of Contents Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 1 1. Prologue .............................................................................................................................................. 1 2. Misplaced Dreams? .......................................................................................................................... 8 2.1 The Conjuncture of Naya Nepal (or New Nepal) ............................................................................ 8 2.2 Dreams Devoid of a Base ....................................................................................................................... 12 3. The Rise of Neoliberal Governance and Planning .............................................................. 17 4. Everyday Life and The Right to the City: Framing the Sukumbasi Demand .............. 25 5. Methodological Orientation ...................................................................................................... 30 5.1 Research Site ............................................................................................................................................... 31 5.1.1 The Site of Citizenship ...................................................................................................................................... 32 5.1.2 The Site of Governance ..................................................................................................................................... 33 5.2 Research Design and Strategy ............................................................................................................. 36 5.3 Research Sampling ................................................................................................................................... 38 5.3.1 Random Sampling and Sampling Size ......................................................................................................... 38 5.3.2 Snowballing ........................................................................................................................................................... 40 5.4 Research Methods .................................................................................................................................... 41 5.4.1 Interviews ............................................................................................................................................................... 41 5.4.2 Participant Observation ..................................................................................................................................... 42 5.4.3 Oral History ........................................................................................................................................................... 43 5.5 Positionality and Ethics .......................................................................................................................... 46 6. Dissertation Outline ..................................................................................................................... 48 Chapter 1 Right to the City, Everyday Life and Urban Revolution .............................. 51 1. Right to The City and Urban Revolution ............................................................................... 53 2. Everyday Life in Postcolonial Urbanism: The Organized and The Unanticipated .. 59 3. Concluding Thoughts ................................................................................................................... 65 Chapter 2 “House With Three Pillars”: The Politics of Patience .................................. 68 1. Condition of Compulsion: Transgression and Subversion .............................................. 69 2. Condition of Possibility: Space and Subjectivities ............................................................. 74 3. “House With three pillars” .......................................................................................................... 77 3.1 Savings: Enacting entrepreneurial subjectivities ....................................................................... 84 3.2 Sharing: A “Cosmopolitanism from below” ................................................................................... 91 4. Entangled Everyday Life and Alternative Imaginations .................................................. 96 Chapter 3 The Politics of Urgency ....................................................................................... 101 1.
Recommended publications
  • FOREIGN COOPERATION BRANCH Nepal India Regional Trade and Transport Project
    Terms of Reference GOVERNMENT OF NEPAL MINISTRY OF PHYSICAL INFRASTRUCTURE AND TRANSPORT DEPARTMENT OF ROADS FOREIGN COOPERATION BRANCH Nepal India Regional Trade and Transport Project TERMS OF REFERENCE of Bridge Engineer (Resident Engineer) For CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISION OF Construction of Khani Khola, Mauri Khola , Dasdhunga Khola and Jalbire Khola Bridge on Narayanghat – Mugling Road Road January, 2018 Jwagal, Lalitpur Page 1 of 9 Terms of Reference TERMS OF REFERENCE of Bridge Engineer (Resident Engineer) For CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISION OF Construction of Khani Khola, Mauri Khola , Dasdhunga Khola and Jalbire Khola Bridge on Narayanghat – Mugling Road Road 1. INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND The Government of Nepal has received financing from the World Bank toward the cost of the Nepal India Regional Trade and Transport Project for the improvement of Naryanghat – Mugling Road. Under the project it has started to construct the new bridges in following rivers: a) Khani Khola b) Mauri Khola c) Dasdhunga Khola and d) Jalbire Khola Nepal India Regional Trade and Transport Project has procured contracts of ”Construction of Bridges over Khani, Mauri, Dasdhunga and Jalbire River” in two following contracts which are in construction stage. Contract ID No. Name of Contractor Bridge Name Lama Construction Company Construction of RCC Bridges over NIRTTP-DOR-W-NCB- Pvt Ltd, Maharajgunj, Khani, Mauri and Dasdhunga River 4 Kathmandu along Narayanghat – Mugling Road Rautaha Construction Pvt Ltd, Construction of Prestressed Concrete NIRTTP-DOR-W-NCB- Triyuga municipality, Udaypur Bridge over Jalbire River along 5 Narayanghat – Mugling Road Nepal India Regional Trade and Transport Project, Foreign Cooperation Branch, Department of Roads under the Ministry of Physical Infrastructure and Transport intends to apply part of the proceeds for consulting service of the Bridge Engineer (Resident Engineer).
    [Show full text]
  • Preparation of GPS Based Digital Profile of Godawari Municipality
    Godawari Municipality Godawari, Lalitpur Final Report Preparation of GPS based Digital Profile of Godawari Municipality Submitted to Godawari Municipality Bajrabarahi, Lalitpur, Nepal Submitted by ArchieSoft Technology Lalitpur Metropolitan City 21, Lalitpur, Nepal Phone: +977 -1-5553000 Email: [email protected] Web: www.archiesoft.com.np 1 Table of Contents Chapter 1: Project Description ............................................................................................................... 4 1.1 Background ......................................................................................................................................... 4 1.2 Objective of the assignment ............................................................................................................... 4 1.3 Key Deliverables ................................................................................................................................. 5 1.4 Methodology/ process ....................................................................................................................... 5 1.5 Project Location .................................................................................................................................. 6 1.6 Time line of assignment/ study .......................................................................................................... 7 Chapter 2: Godawari Municipality an Introduction ............................................................................... 9 2.1 Background: .......................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Sustainable Development Goals Baseline Report of Province No
    Sustainable Development Goals Baseline Report of Province No. Five Province Planning Commission, Government of Province, Province No. Five 2 Sustainable Development Goals Baseline Report Province Planning Commission, Government of Province, Province No. Five This report was prepared and published in 2019 by the Province Planning Commission, Government of Province, Province No. Five, with the support from United Nations Development Programme. Photo Credit: UNDP Nepal, Laxmi Prasad Ngakhusi, CP Khanal Preface The government of Province No. 5 has been forward for achieving the goals so that formulating first five-year plan (2019/20 - no one will be left behind. This report has 2023/24) of the province with a vision of helped us to set the targets to be achieved 'prosperous province, happy people'. The in our five-year plan. Local governments, goals and priorities of the plan match with civil society organizations, private sector of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) this province and interested development agreed by the global community for the partners will also benefit from this report period of 2016-2030. As the Government to identify the areas where they need to of Nepal has shown its commitment on the focus to help the provincial government in realization of SDGs at the international level, achieving the SDGs. this province intends to localize the SDGs to the provincial context to contribute in The Province Planning Commission would the fulfillment of the national commitment. like to thank the UNDP for helping us to This SDG baseline report is produced under prepare this milestone report and also to technical and financial support from UNDP the team of experts Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Evaluation of the Commission of the European Union's
    Evaluation of the Commission of the European Union’s Co-operation with Nepal – Country Level Evaluation Final Report Volume 2 – Annexes March 2012 Evaluation for the Commission of the European Union Framework contract for Multi-country thematic and regional/country- level strategy evaluation studies and synthesis in the area of external co- operation Italy LOT 4: Evaluation of EC geographic co-operation strategies for countries/regions in Asia, Latin America, the Aide à la Décision Economique Southern Mediterranean and Eastern Europe (the Belgium area of the New Neighbourhood Policy) PARTICIP GmbH Ref.: EuropeAid/122888/C/SER/Multi Germany Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik Evaluation of the Commission of the Germany European Union’s co-operation with Nepal Overseas Development Institute (Country Level Evaluation) United Kingdom European Institute for Asian Studies Final Report Belgium Volume II Instituto Complutense de Estudios Internacionales Spain This evaluation is being carried out by A consortium of DRN, ADE, PARTICIP, DIE, ODI, EIAS & ICEI c/o DRN, leading company: Headquarters Via Ippolito Nievo 62 00153 Rome, Italy Tel:+39-06-581-6074 Fax: +39-06-581-6390 mail@drn•network.com March 2012 Belgium office Square Eugène Plasky, 92 1030 Brussels, Belgium Tel:+32-2-732-4607 Fax: +32-2-706-5442 [email protected] This report has been prepared by the consortium led by DRN, with Particip, ADE, ODI, ICEI, EIAS and DIE. The core evaluation team comprised of: Jan Douwe Meindertsma (Team leader), Malcolm Mercer, Chhaya Jha and Jonas Lovkrona. The core team has been supported by: Georg Ladj (QA expert); Tino Smail (evaluation coordinator); Sarah Seus and Claus-Peter Hager (junior consultants).
    [Show full text]
  • In the Name of 'Empowerment': Women and Development in Urban Nepal
    In the name of ‘empowerment’: women and development in urban Nepal Margaret Becker Thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor in Philosophy Department of Anthropology School of Social Sciences, Faculty of Arts The University of Adelaide December 2016 Contents Abstract ...................................................................................................................... v Thesis declaration ...................................................................................................... vi Acknowledgements .................................................................................................. vii Transliteration ........................................................................................................... ix List of acronyms and abbreviations ........................................................................... x Introduction ...................................................................................................... 1 Ethnographic locations and methodology .................................................................. 3 Situating the organisations ......................................................................................... 5 Critical perspectives on development ........................................................................ 8 Critical perspectives on empowerment .................................................................... 12 Reflections on empowerment ................................................................................... 18 The structure
    [Show full text]
  • Federalism Is Debated in Nepal More As an ‘Ism’ Than a System
    The FEDERALISM Debate in Nepal Post Peace Agreement Constitution Making in Nepal Volume II Post Peace Agreement Constitution Making in Nepal Volume II The FEDERALISM Debate in Nepal Edited by Budhi Karki Rohan Edrisinha Published by United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) Support to Participatory Constitution Building in Nepal (SPCBN) 2014 United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) Support to Participatory Constitution Building in Nepal (SPCBN) UNDP is the UN’s global development network, advocating for change and connecting countries to knowledge, experience and resources to help people build a better life. United Nations Development Programme UN House, Pulchowk, GPO Box: 107 Kathmandu, Nepal Phone: +977 1 5523200 Fax: +977 1 5523991, 5523986 ISBN : 978 9937 8942 1 0 © UNDP, Nepal 2014 Book Cover: The painting on the cover page art is taken from ‘A Federal Life’, a joint publication of UNDP/ SPCBN and Kathmandu University, School of Art. The publication was the culmination of an initiative in which 22 artists came together for a workshop on the concept of and debate on federalism in Nepal and then were invited to depict their perspective on the subject through art. The painting on the cover art titled ‘’Emblem” is created by Supriya Manandhar. DISCLAIMER: The views expressed in the book are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of UNDP/ SPCBN. PREFACE A new Constitution for a new Nepal drafted and adopted by an elected and inclusive Constituent Assembly (CA) is a key element of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA) of November 2006 that ended a decade long Maoist insurgency.
    [Show full text]
  • Training Report on Conflict Resolution & Mediation
    Training Report on Conflict Resolution & Mediation Hotel Durbar Himalaya, Bandipur Date: 19th – 27th August, 2019 Submitted on: 10th September, 2019 LIST OF ABBREVIATION & OTHER JC : Judicial Committees NVC : Nonviolent Communication RTI : Right to Information CIAA : Commission of Investigation of Abuse of Authority Group I Participants who attended the training from 19th to 22nd August, 2019 Group II : Participants who attended the training from 24th to 27th August, 2019 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The four day high level refresher training on ‘Conflict Resolution and Mediation’ was aimed at providing tools, information and knowledge to the participants within the Nepalese context of legal protocols primarily involving mediation & negotiations, and also other scope of work of local leaders. Supported by Mott Macdonald Ltd, and organized by Pro Public, the training took place from 19th to 27th August, 2019 at The Durbar Himalaya, Bandipur. The participants included judicial committee coordinators/ members, ward chair, community mediators, local government officials such as asst. women dev officer, legal facilitator etc, and coordinators/advisors of Purnima project within Mott Macdonald. The training reached out to 60 participants in total, among which 25 were female and 35 male. The participants were further divided in two groups for the first and second round of the training. The first, with the total outreach of 31 participants, covered Rural Municipalities of Dhanding & Gorkha, and the second round, with total outreach of 29 participants, covered Rural Municipalities of Rasuwa, Dhading, and Nuwakot. This training was a continuation of the phase I training, which took place for the same participants from 7th to 15th January, in Gaindakot.
    [Show full text]
  • Nepali Times, but Only About the Kathmandu District Are You Writing an Article
    #217 8-14 October 2004 20 pages Rs 25 Weekly Internet Poll # 157 Q. Should the government announce a unilateral ceasefire before Dasain? Peace by peace Total votes:1,001 ANALYSIS by KUNDA DIXIT Hope is strongest Weekly Internet Poll # 158. To vote go to: www.nepalitimes.com Q. Do you think the human rights situation in s Dasain approaches there are indications that both sides will Nepal has improved or deteriorated in the when things seem most hopeless past one year? observe an unofficial festival truce, but prospects of peace A talks to resolve the conflict are more remote than ever. A purported statement from the Maoists declaring a Dasain-Tihar ceasefire on Tuesday turned out to be a hoax. Rebel spokesman Krishna Bahadur Mahara set the record straight by dashing off an e- statement, but that was followed on Wednesday by another release purportedly signed by Prachanda saying the original statement was correct and action would be taken against Mahara. Analysts do not rule out the possibility of army disinformation at work, and see signs of a rift in the Maoist hierarchy following the groups plenum in Dang last month which reportedly rejected peace talks for now. The meeting was followed by strident anti-Indian rhetoric and an intriguing silence on the part of Baburam Bhattarai, who is said to have favoured a softer line on India. The contradictions between central-level statements about links to fraternal parties and recent attacks on the leftist United Peoples Front in the mid-west hint at a breakdown in control. While the leadership calls on UN mediation, grassroots militia defy international condemnation of forced recruitment of school students, abduction of a Unicef staffer and looting of WFP aid.
    [Show full text]
  • Nepal National Association of Rural Municipality Association of District Coordination (Muan) in Nepal (NARMIN) Committees of Nepal (ADCCN)
    Study Organized by Municipality Association of Nepal National Association of Rural Municipality Association of District Coordination (MuAN) in Nepal (NARMIN) Committees of Nepal (ADCCN) Supported by Sweden European Sverige Union "This document has been financed by the Swedish "This publication was produced with the financial support of International Development Cooperation Agency, Sida. Sida the European Union. Its contents are the sole responsibility of does not necessarily share the views expressed in this MuAN, NARMIN, ADCCN and UCLG and do not necessarily material. Responsibility for its content rests entirely with the reflect the views of the European Union'; author." Publication Date June 2020 Study Organized by Municipality Association of Nepal (MuAN) National Association of Rural Municipality in Nepal (NARMIN) Association of District Coordination Committees of Nepal (ADCCN) Supported by Sweden Sverige European Union Expert Services Dr. Dileep K. Adhikary Editing service for the publication was contributed by; Mr Kalanidhi Devkota, Executive Director, MuAN Mr Bimal Pokheral, Executive Director, NARMIN Mr Krishna Chandra Neupane, Executive Secretary General, ADCCN Layout Designed and Supported by Edgardo Bilsky, UCLG world Dinesh Shrestha, IT Officer, ADCCN Table of Contents Acronyms ....................................................................................................................................... 3 Forewords .....................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Silence Breaking the Silence
    www.fridayweekly.com.np Every Thursday | ISSUE 194 | RS. 20 SUBSCRIBER COPY | ISSN 2091-1092 13 NOVEMBER 2013 @& sflt{s @)&) 9 772091 109009 www.facebook.com/fridayweekly Silence Breaking the Silence 9/11 will experience the country’s loudest musical explosion this year in the form of Silence Festival, allowing fans an opportunity to witness great acts right here in the city. Continued on page 2 Model: Ashma Singh Model: 2007 record “The Apostasy” At a glance was inspired by his trip here. getstarted What Silence Festival start off with our picks Hailed for the last two decades as one of the few metal bands Who Silence Entertainment getting better with each album, When Behemoth could be the ultimate 9 November (Saturday) Silence Breaking the Silence treat for fans here. Time 12:00 pm onwards Samyam Shrestha Opening for the Polish Where Bhrikuti Mandap Fun Park juggernauts are six killer eavy metal has come here has steadily grown. It was bands from Nepal, India and Ticket Price Rs. 700 a long way in Nepal as if the Michael Jacksons of Switzerland - UgraKarma, Hsince its introduction in metal were playing here one Underside, Newaz, Jugaa, to promote our music and bring While the previous editions late 80s-early 90s. But until after the other, while the people Zygnema, Derrick and And it to an international standard. I of the festival were held at a few years ago, no major beyond the metal circle were We Came. The festival has believe it’s getting better every Jawlakhel Football Ground, international metal band had totally oblivious to it all.
    [Show full text]
  • Branch Account Name
    List of Accounts without Debit Transaction For More Than 10 year as of Ashad End 2076 BRANCH ACCOUNT NAME BAUDHA BRANCH 4322524134056018 GOPAL RAJ SILWAL BAUDHA BRANCH 4322524134231017 MAHAMAD ASLAM BAUDHA BRANCH 4322524134298014 BIMALA DHUNGEL BENI BRANCH 2940524083918012 KAMALA KUMARI MALLA BENI BRANCH 2940524083381019 MIN ROKAYA BENI BRANCH 2940524083932015 DHAN BAHADUR CHHANTYAL BENI BRANCH 2940524083402016 BALARAM KHATRI BENI BRANCH 2922524083654016 SURYA BAHADUR PYAKUREL (KHATRI) BENI BRANCH 2940524083176016 KAMAL PRASAD POUDEL BENI BRANCH 2940524083897015 MUMTAJ BEGAM BENI BRANCH 2936524083886017 SHUSHIL KUMAR KARKI BENI BRANCH 2940524083124016 MINA KUMARI SHARMA BENI BRANCH 2923524083016013 HASULI KUMARI SHRESTHA BENI BRANCH 2940524083507012 NABIN THAPA BENI BRANCH 2940524083288019 DIPENDRA GHALE BENI BRANCH 2940524083489014 PRADIP SHAHI BENI BRANCH 2936524083368016 TIL KUMARI PUN BENI BRANCH 2940524083230018 YAM BAHADUR B.K. BENI BRANCH 2940524083604018 DHAN BAHADUR K.C BENI BRANCH 2940524140157015 PRAMIL RAJ NEUPANE BENI BRANCH 2940524140115018 RAJ KUMAR PARIYAR BENI BRANCH 2940524083022019 BHABINDRA CHHANTYAL BENI BRANCH 2940524083532017 SHANTA CHAND BENI BRANCH 2940524083475013 DAL BAHADUR PUN BENI BRANCH 2940524083896019 AASI DIN MIYA BENI BRANCH 2940524083675012 ARJUN B.K. BENI BRANCH 2940524083684011 BALKRISHNA KARKI BENI BRANCH 2940524083578017 TEK MAYA PURJA BENI BRANCH 2940524083460016 RAM MAYA SHRESTHA BENI BRANCH 2940524083974017 BHADRA BAHADUR KHATRI BENI BRANCH 2940524083237015 SHANTI PAUDEL BENI BRANCH 2940524140186015
    [Show full text]
  • Evolution of Municipalities in Nepal
    EVOLUTION OF MUNICIPALITIES IN NEPAL: CHALLENGES AND PLANNING Gopi Krishna Pandey INTRODUCTION Urban center is an index of transformation from traditional rural economics to modern industrial unit. It is a long term process. It is progressive concentration of population in urban unit. Kingsley Davis has explained urbanization as a process of switch from spread out pattern of human settlements to one of concentration in urban centers. It is a finite process of cycle through which all nations pass as they evolve from agrarian to industrial society (Davis and Golden, 1954). In a more rigorous sense, urban center is such a place where exchange of services and ideas; a place for agro processing mills or small scale industries; a place for community and production services; a place for fair or hat (periodic market) or social gatherings; and place for transport service or break of bulk service. All these activities act as complement to each other, and are considered as a total strength of market force. Urban center is the foci of development activities for the rural development. Historical accounts show that some of the urban centers are in increasing trend and decreasing the number of commercial units. The urban centers which is located at the transportation node have chance to rapidly grow. Nepal is undergoing a significant spatial transition. It is both the least urbanized country in South Asia with about 17 percent of its population living in urban areas (based on 2011census data, CBS, 2011) and the fastest unbanning country with an average population growth rate of about 6 percent per year since the 1976s.
    [Show full text]