DOCSLIB.ORG

The Search for the Lost Tribes

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Search for the Lost Tribes chapter 4 The Search for the Lost Tribes Kabbalah beyond the Sambatyon By creating a national narrative that integrates elements of Jewish mysticism, Shimon Zvi Horowitz, the co-founder of the Sha’ar haShamayim Yeshiva, sought to reach a wider audience than the majority of Jerusalem’s Sharabian kabbalists. In certain respects, he was indeed successful. A case in point is his efforts to find the Ten Tribes – an idea that is part and parcel of his kabbal- istic approach. Horowitz tried to get Jerusalem’s Sephardic kabbalists on the bandwagon, but came up empty-handed. Moreover, his efforts to turn Sha’ar haShamayim into a center for expeditions of this sort drew mixed results. At any rate, this episode sheds light on Horowitz’s unusual eclectic worldview. In 1908, Shimon Menachem Lazar of Drohobycz (1864–1932), an editor and Hebrew scholar, came out with a thick tome on Ḥidot haHagadot haNiflaot al Dvar Aseret haShvatim vePitronam (The Riddles of the Wonderful Myths on the Ten Tribes and their Solution). The journal HaSchiloah had published an earlier, serial version of this work in installments between 1902 and 1903. At the end of the book’s introduction is a summary of Lazar’s approach to these same myths: And this belief [in the Lost Tribes], which filled the hearts of our nation for some two thousand years, has been suspended in our time, the days of the Jewish Enlightenment, to the point that they have even ceased to think about the Ten Tribes, as though they never existed and were never created. Today, a misguided [sense of] embarrassment will cover the face of a Jew, even from the Orthodox party, on anything regarding the Ten Tribes. Like a nighttime vision in a dream, the memory of the Tribes has abruptly vanished from the congregation of Israel and has become the realm of the Christian English, some of whom are endeavoring to prove that they, of all people, are the Lost Tribes of Israel.1 1 Lazar, Ḥidot haHagadot, 5. The HaSchiloah version of this book does not contain the passage “a misguided [sense of] embarrassment will cover the face of a Jew, even from the Orthodox party, on anything regarding the Ten Tribes.” Lazar, “Aseret haShvatim,” 47. Important mate- rial on the book’s publication and its ideology is preserved in Lazar’s correspondence with Ahad Ha’am (Asher Zvi Hirsch Ginsberg); Lazar, Letters to Ahad Ha’am, 1902 (ms). © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, ���6 | doi �0.��63/97890043��649_005 <UN> The Search For The Lost Tribes 97 As an aside, Lazar noted “that also in our time in the year 1898 a band of Ye- menite Jews from Jerusalem went to the deserts of Arabia, to seek out the Sambatyon. One of them indeed boasted that upon travelling from South- ern Arabia to Eretz Yisrael its [i.e., the river’s] traces were revealed to him.” That said, Lazar was apparently unaware of two contemporaneous develop- ments: the distribution of the mythical literature on the Tribes in East Europe; and the intensive activity within the heart of the Old Yishuv in Jerusalem to find the lost Israelites. His book falls under the heading of the far-ranging re- search literature on this topic whose main conclusion was that the Tribes had assimilated and disappeared, so that it is no longer possible to find any remnant of this exile. Moreover, the authors of this corpus posited that these myths lack a solid foundation. As a result, any initiative to find the lost Jews is bound to be a wild goose chase.2 This literature put an emphasis on documents that are tied to past efforts to locate the Tribes as well as the outlook of the explorers. Furthermore, they toiled to reconstruct the Israelites’ history in the Diaspora until their extinction. The most prominent and influential of these writers was the Orientalist Adolf (Abraham) Neubauer. In 1888, he published an exhaus- tive Hebrew anthology on issues pertaining to the Ten Tribes and the Sons of Moses. Soon after, he released an English survey on the various explorers who placed their sights on this elusive prize.3 The Awakening of Explorers in Jerusalem In stark contradistinction to these firm conclusions, new ideologically-driven explorers surfaced during this period who employed the research literature in 2 Mendel Wohlman also reached this conclusion in his 1907 study; idem, “The Sambatyon and the Ten Tribes,” 279–305. Countervailing this trend was Shmuel Ze’ev Goldman, Sefer Nidḥei Yisrael (1941). In the introduction (v), he wrote that “the reason that stirred me on to formu- late this book: that most of the books that were written on this topic were infiltrated by the spirit of the Enlightenment, and they built a stubborn and treacherous case. Moreover, the occupation with these books has produced a sad result, namely a couple of Torah scholars are talking about the above-mentioned topics as though they were a popular fable that is intertwined in the air.” At any rate, Goldman endeavored to verify the story of the Ten Tribes and the existence of the Sambatyon, not to actually find or support those who were searching for them. In the early 1900s, a couple of booklets focused on tracking the Israelites’ assimila- tion into various nations; see, for example, Israel Balkind, Where are the Ten Tribes? (1928). 3 See Neubauer, “Qvutṣim ’al ’Inyanei ’Aseret haShvatim;” idem, “Where Are the Ten Tribes,” 14–28, 95–114, 185–201, 408–423. Later on, the emphasis shifted to describing the worldview of groups that claimed to descend from the Lost Tribes. For a scholarly disquisition on the roots of this myth and its various incarnations, see Ben-Dor Benite, The Ten Lost Tribes: A World History. See also Veltri, “The East in the Story of the Lost Tribes,” 246–266. <UN>.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • We Arrived in Manipur Unannounced, to Get a Bona Fide Glimpse Into How
    ESENT I PR AR D N A To see our subscription options, I R please click on the Mishpacha tab A e knocked and waited nervously mesor ah because we hadn’t notified them ahead — yet we weren’t disappointed. Quest As the door opened to the little hut, a kippah-clad man smiled broadly and Wsaid, “Baruch haba!” He led us through a courtyard to a small, well-kept synagogue. We were not in Monsey, but in a far-fl ung corner of India on the northeastern border state of Manipur, preparing the ground in advance of our curious delegation — a party of 35 Western Jews and one of the rare groups to visit this little-known Indian com- munity known as the Bnei Menashe. We were both excited and relieved by the warm wel- come, as their story is exotic and spans thousands of years of Jewish history. It is a direct link with our Biblical past and raises interesting halachic and philosophic conun- drums about our future. Welcome to our search for part of the Ten Lost Tribes. It all started with a call from the OU Israel Center in- viting us to lead a “Halachic Adventure” tour. We asked the organizers where they would like to go, and they re- plied, “Where would you like to lead us?” The answer for us was simple: to return to India where the richness and diversity of Jewish history is largely unknown to much of the Jewish world. Our goal was to give our fellow adventurers a unique, exciting, and o -the-beaten-track experience.
    [Show full text]
  • The Hebrew Revolution and the Revolution of the Hebrew Language Between the 1880S and the 1930S
    The Hebrew Revolution and the Revolution of the Hebrew Language between the 1880s and the 1930s Judith Winther Copenhagen The new Hebrew culture which began to crys- Eliezer Ben Yehudah was born in 1858, tallize in the land of Israel from the end of the Ben Gurion in 1886, and Berl Kazenelson in last century, is a successful event of "cultural 1887. planning". During a relatively short period of As a man who was not active in the so- time a little group of"culture planners" succee- cialist Jewish movement Ben Yehudah's dedi- ded in creating a system which in a significant cation to Hebrew is probably comprehensible. way was adapted to the requested Zionist ide- But why should a prominent socialist like Berl ology. The fact that the means by which the Kazenelson stick to the spoken Hebrew langu- "cultural planning" was realized implicated a age? A man, who prior to his immigration to heroic presentation of the happenings that led Palestine was an anti-Zionist, ridiculed Hebrew to a pathetical view of the development. It and was an enthusiastic devotee of Yiddish? presented the new historical ocurrences in Pa- The explanation is to be found in the vi- lestine as a renaissance and not as a continu- tal necessity which was felt by the pioneers ation of Jewish history, as a break and not as of the second Aliyah to achieve at all costs a continuity of the past. break from the past, from the large world of the The decision to create a political and a Russian revolutionary movements, from Rus- Hebrew cultural renaissance was laid down by sian culture, and Jewish Russian culture.
    [Show full text]
  • Six Lessons to Unlocking the Truth to God's Holy Land
    Photo: ASHERNET Six Lessons to Unlocking the Truth to God’s Holy Land LESSON 4 I.S.R.A.E.L. — Aliyah (Immigration to Israel) Introduction Key Verse: Today’s lesson comes from the letter “A” Even if you have been banished to the in “ISRAEL.” most distant land under the heavens, from there the LORD your God Aliyah (al-EE-yah) is a Hebrew word will gather you and bring you back. meaning to immigrate to Israel, or return to the Jewish people’s ancestral homeland. — Deuteronomy 30:4 Main teaching point Think about a time you’ve returned to a place that has special meaning for you — perhaps a high God always intended for His people school reunion, or maybe returning to your hometown to return home to Israel, the land after many years. What prompted your return? He promised to Abraham. What emotions did it evoke? How did going back Throughaliyah , hundreds of thousands to this place impact you? of Jews have been able to return to Now think of the history of Israel, including their promised homeland, fulfilling how it was given to the Israelites as an inheritance from biblical prophecy. God, and how they were expelled from their land, not once, but twice. What emotions do you think going to Israel would evoke for a Jewish person? If you’ve been to Israel, what emotions did it evoke for you? ©2018 International Fellowship of Christians and Jews ifcj.ca | page 32 Keys to I.S.R.A.E.L. Lesson 4: I.S.R.A.E.L.
    [Show full text]
  • On Saints, Sinners, and Sex in the Apocalypse of Saint John and the Sefer Zerubbabel
    The University of San Francisco USF Scholarship: a digital repository @ Gleeson Library | Geschke Center Theology & Religious Studies College of Arts and Sciences 12-30-2016 On Saints, Sinners, and Sex in the Apocalypse of Saint John and the Sefer Zerubbabel Natalie Latteri Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.usfca.edu/thrs Part of the Christianity Commons, History of Religion Commons, Jewish Studies Commons, and the Social History Commons Apocalypse of St. John and the Sefer Zerubbabel On Saints, Sinners, and Sex in the Apocalypse of St. John and the Sefer Zerubbabel Natalie E. Latteri, University of New Mexico, NM, USA Abstract The Apocalypse of St. John and the Sefer Zerubbabel [a.k.a Apocalypse of Zerubbabel] are among the most popular apocalypses of the Common Era. While the Johannine Apocalypse was written by a first-century Jewish-Christian author and would later be refracted through a decidedly Christian lens, and the Sefer Zerubbabel was probably composed by a seventh-century Jewish author for a predominantly Jewish audience, the two share much in the way of plot, narrative motifs, and archetypal characters. An examination of these commonalities and, in particular, how they intersect with gender and sexuality, suggests that these texts also may have functioned similarly as a call to reform within the generations that originally received them and, perhaps, among later medieval generations in which the texts remained important. The Apocalypse of St. John and the Sefer Zerubbabel, or Book of Zerubbabel, are among the most popular apocalypses of the Common Era.1 While the Johannine Apocalypse was written by a first-century Jewish-Christian author and would later be refracted through a decidedly Christian lens, and the Sefer Zerubbabel was probably composed by a seventh-century Jewish author for a predominantly Jewish audience, the two share much in the way of plot, narrative motifs, and archetypal characters.
    [Show full text]
  • Ten Lost Tribes Or Two?
    Ten Lost Tribes or Two? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_Identity Ten Lost Tribes - Wikipedia Christian Identity asserts that the white people of Europe or Caucasians in general are God's servant people, according to the promises that were given to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. It further asserts that the early European tribes were really the Ten Lost Tribes of Israel and therefore the rightful heirs to God's promises, and God's chosen people. Colin Kidd wrote that in America, Christian Identity exploited "the puzzle of the Ten Lost Tribes to justify an openly anti- Semitic and virulently racist agenda." Identity teaches that "Israel" was the name given to Jacob after he wrestled with the angel at Peniel as described in Genesis 32:26–32. "Israel" then had twelve sons, which began the Twelve Tribes of Israel.[45]:101 In 975 BC the ten northern tribes revolted, seceded from the south, and became the Kingdom of Israel.[45]:101 After they were subsequently conquered by Assyria at approximately 721 BC, the ten tribes disappeared from the Biblical record and became known as the Lost Tribes of Israel.[45]:101 According to Identity doctrine, 2 Esdras 13:39–46 then records the history of the nation of Israel journeying over the Caucasus mountains, along the Black Sea, to the Ar Sereth tributary of the Danube in Romania ("But they formed this plan for themselves, that they would leave the multitude of the nations and go to a more distant region, where no human beings had ever lived. … Through that region there was a long way to go, a journey of a year and a half; and that country is called Arzareth").[45]:101 The tribes prospered, and eventually colonized other European countries.
    [Show full text]
  • Apples from the Desert”: Form and Content
    Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal – Vol.4, No.6 Publication Date: March 25, 2017 DoI:10.14738/assrj.46.2908. Kizel, T. (2017). Image of the Religious Jewish Woman in Savyon Liebrecht’s Story “Apples from the Desert”: Form and Content. Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal, 4(6) 60-72 Image of the Religious Jewish Woman in Savyon Liebrecht’s Story “Apples from the Desert”: Form and Content Dr. Thaier Kizel Head of the Department of Hebrew Language and Hebrew Literature Arab Academic College of Education, Haif INTRODUCTION Divine missions have always been associated with men. Men were entrusted by God to worship Him and women were men’s helpers in the dissemination of the message, although usually their role was restricted to hearth and home. In modern times women began to share men’s roles in every aspect of life, in religion, in politics and in society. In fact, women in some cases have pushed men out of some of the latter’s former roles in life. The afore-mentioned facts are also applicable to Judaism, whose founding prophet Moses was a man. Jewish women obeyed the ritual law because of the men. However, as just noted, their role was purely domestic. However, they began to rebel in every domain, including that of religion, even after they immigrated to Israel. The Jewish religion played an important role in defining the place of women in every aspect of Jewish life, whether in politics, society, religion or any other. Their role at first was marginal, in fact practically non-existent, at the birth of modern Hebrew literature and the emergence of the Zionist movement.
    [Show full text]
  • Jews and the Search for the Ten Lost Tribes
    chapter 7 Jews and the Search for the Ten Lost Tribes Latin Christians in the West were not the only polities inventing mythologies of distant coreligionists. Jewish knowledge and belief in unexplored regions was, likewise, based on a combination of scholarship, myth and religious text, but, like Christians, there was a strong belief among European Jewish commu- nities in the existence of unseen coreligionists. Often, Jews envisioned these coreligionists as members of the so-called Lost or Ten Tribes, who had not re- turned to Israel following the Babylonian exile.1 Their return, as the Prophets claimed, would herald the coming the Messiah.2 In this way, the search or de- sire to make contact with these hidden Jews always held a special significance for Jewish commentators that went beyond the hunger for political liberation from Christian or Muslim oppressors. Comparing Jewish with Christian de- signs regarding distant coreligionists will allow us to garner a fuller picture of the European mythological landscape. Jewish claims of the existence of powerful coreligionists dwelling in some unknown and distant place, hold particular importance in the ongoing polem- ical debate between Jews and Christians in medieval and early modern Eu- rope. Christian, anti-Jewish polemic had long maintained that the Jews were a stateless people. That their lack of a king or army was proof of their doctrinal errors in light of Jesus’ assumption of David messiahship.3 For Jews, on the other hand, the belief in the existence of a distant and pow- erful Jewish state gave lie to Christian polemic. It also allowed for the Jewish assumption of a type of power Christians claimed as exclusively their own.
    [Show full text]
  • The Ten Lost Tribes: a World History
    BYU Studies Quarterly Volume 53 | Issue 1 Article 15 1-1-2014 The eT n Lost Tribes: A World History Zvi Ben-Dor Benite Jeffrey R. Chadwick Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq Recommended Citation Benite, Zvi Ben-Dor and Chadwick, Jeffrey R. (2014) "The eT n Lost Tribes: A World History," BYU Studies Quarterly: Vol. 53 : Iss. 1 , Article 15. Available at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol53/iss1/15 This Book Review is brought to you for free and open access by the All Journals at BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in BYU Studies Quarterly by an authorized editor of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. Benite and Chadwick: The Ten Lost Tribes: A World History Zvi Ben-Dor Benite. The Ten Lost Tribes: A World History. New York: Oxford University Press, 2009. Reviewed by Jeffrey R. Chadwick he Ten Lost Tribes: A World History is an ambitious treatment by Zvi TBen-Dor Benite, an associate professor of history and Middle Eastern and Islamic studies at New York University. The subject is a departure from the focus of his book The Dao of Muhammad: A Cultural History of Muslims in Late China, but the story of the Ten Lost Tribes is intrigu- ing, and the assembled tales of how people throughout the world and throughout history have related to the loss of the Israelite tribes make for a fascinating read. The reader should be aware that The Ten Lost Tribes does not, in my opinion, adequately or accurately address the eighth- century BC deportations and subsequent assimilation of hundreds of thousands of people from the kingdoms of Israel and Judah.
    [Show full text]
  • Uva-DARE (Digital Academic Repository)
    UvA-DARE (Digital Academic Repository) Links in a chain: Early modern Yiddish historiography in the northern Netherlands (1743-1812) Wallet, B.T. Publication date 2012 Document Version Final published version Link to publication Citation for published version (APA): Wallet, B. T. (2012). Links in a chain: Early modern Yiddish historiography in the northern Netherlands (1743-1812). General rights It is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), other than for strictly personal, individual use, unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons). Disclaimer/Complaints regulations If you believe that digital publication of certain material infringes any of your rights or (privacy) interests, please let the Library know, stating your reasons. In case of a legitimate complaint, the Library will make the material inaccessible and/or remove it from the website. Please Ask the Library: https://uba.uva.nl/en/contact, or a letter to: Library of the University of Amsterdam, Secretariat, Singel 425, 1012 WP Amsterdam, The Netherlands. You will be contacted as soon as possible. UvA-DARE is a service provided by the library of the University of Amsterdam (https://dare.uva.nl) Download date:29 Sep 2021 LINKS IN A CHAIN A IN LINKS UITNODIGING tot het bijwonen van de LINKS IN A CHAIN publieke verdediging van mijn proefschrift Early modern Yiddish historiography from the northern Netherlands, 1743-1812 LINKS IN A CHAIN Early modern Yiddish historiography from the northern the northern Yiddish historiography from Early modern Early modern Yiddish historiography in the northern Netherlands, 1743-1812 op vrijdag 2 maart 2012 om 11.00 uur in de Aula van de Universiteit van Amsterdam, Singel 411.
    [Show full text]
  • The Hebrew Language Council from 1904 to 1914*
    Bulletin of the SOAS, 73, 1 (2010), 45–64. © School of Oriental and African Studies, 2010. doi:10.1017/S0041977X09990346 Revisiting the language factor in Zionism: The Hebrew Language Council from 1904 to 1914* İlker Aytürk Bilkent University, Turkey [email protected] Abstract The role of language and linguistic-philological studies in the nationalist movements of the nineteenth century received much attention. The aim of this article is to focus on the language factor in Zionism and the revival of Hebrew as a spoken language in the Yishuv between 1904 and 1914. Founded in 1904, the Hebrew Language Council was expected to enhance the process of revival and, from the very beginning, an unmistakably nationalist attitude to its subject matter marked the Council’s agenda. However, the authority of the Council to make binding decisions on lin- guistic matters was contested by a number of other Zionist institutions, a development which ruined the prestige and effectiveness of the Council. The controversy resulted less from a turf war or quarrels over scarce resources than a deeper question of which institution represented the “true” Hebraic spirit. The World Zionist Organization’s decision to de- align from cultural matters, including the revival of Hebrew, worsened the conditions under which the Council operated. From a comparative per- spective, thus, the Hebrew case provides an unusual case of linguistic nationalism, which should be of interest to students of both nationalism and sociolinguistics. The majority of the scholars in the field of nationalism studies today agree on the modernity of nations and believe nations to be “constructs”, “artefacts” or “ima- gined communities”, invented by a host of nationalist ideologues since the late eighteenth century.
    [Show full text]
  • Tangled Roots
    TANGLED ROOTS BJS Program in Judaic Studies Brown University Box 1826 Providence, RI 02912 BROWN JUDAIC STUDIES Edited by Mary Gluck David C. Jacobson Saul M. Olyan Rachel Rojanski Michael L. Satlow Adam Teller Number 365 TANGLED ROOTS BJSby Israel Bartal TANGLED ROOTS THE EMERGENCE OF ISRAELI CULTURE Israel Bartal BJS Brown Judaic Studies Providence, Rhode Island © 2020 Brown University. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying and recording, or by means of any information storage or retrieval system, except as may be expressly permitted by the 1976 Copyright Act or in writing from the publisher. Requests for permission should be addressed in writing to the Rights and Permissions Office, Program in Judaic Studies, Brown University, Box 1826, Providence, RI 02912, USA. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Barṭal, Yiśra’el, author. Title: Tangled roots : the emergence of Israeli culture / Israel Bartal. Other titles: Brown Judaic studies ; no. 365. Description: Providence, Rhode Island : Brown University, 2020. | Series: Brown Judaic studies; 365 | Includes bibliographical references and index. | Summary: "In this new book Israel Bartal traces the history of modern Hebrew culture prior to the emergence of political Zionism. Bartal examines how traditional and modernist ideals and Western and non-European cultures merged in an unprecedented encounter between an ancient land (Israel) and a multigenerational people (the Jews). As this new Hebrew culture was taking shape, the memory of the recent European past played a highly influential role in shaping the image of the New Hebrew, that mythological hero who was meant to supplant the East European exilic Jew"—Provided by publisher.
    [Show full text]
  • Ten Lost Tribes - Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia
    Ten Lost Tribes - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ten_Lost_Tribes Ten Lost Tribes From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia The phrase Ten Lost Tribes of Israel refers to the ancient Tribes of Israel that disappeared from the Biblical account after the Kingdom of Israel was destroyed, enslaved and exiled by ancient Assyria.[1] Many groups of Jews have doctrines concerning the continued hidden existence or future public return of these tribes. This is a subject that is Tribes of Israel partially based upon authenticated and documented historical fact, partially upon written religious tradition and partially The Tribes upon speculation. There is a vast amount of literature on the Lost Tribes and no specific source can be relied upon for a complete answer. Reuben Simeon Levi Judah Dan Naphtali Contents Gad Asher 1 Twelve Tribes Issachar 2 Which tribes were lost Zebulun Joseph 2.1 Religious beliefs Menasheh 2.2 Historical background Ephraim 2.2.1 17th- to mid-20th-century theories Benjamin 2.3 Groups claiming descent from specific Lost Tribes Related topics 2.3.1 Bene Israel of South Asia 2.3.2 Bnei Menashe of India Israelites 2.3.3 Beta Israel of Ethiopia Ten Lost Tribes 2.3.4 Persian Jews 2.3.5 Igbo Jews of Africa 2.3.6 Samaritans 2.4 Groups claiming descent from a non-specific Lost Tribe 2.4.1 Lemba people of Africa 2.4.2 Pashtuns of the Afghan region 2.4.2.1 Origin theories 2.4.3 Chiang Min people of China 2.4.4 The Jews of Kaifeng, China 2.4.5 Bedul, Petra 2.5 Speculation regarding other ethnic groups 2.5.1 Scythian / Cimmerian Theories 2.5.1.1 British Israelism variant 2.5.1.2 Brit-Am variant 2.5.1.3 Other variants 2.5.2 The Kurds 2.5.3 The Japanese 2.5.4 The Irish 2.5.5 Native Americans 2.5.6 General dispersions, via Media region 2.5.7 Nathan Ausubel's list 2.6 In other religions 2.6.1 Latter-day Saints 3 See also 4 References and notes 5 External links Twelve Tribes According to the Hebrew Bible, Jacob (progenitor of Israel) had 12 sons and at least one daughter by two wives and two concubines.
    [Show full text]