TOM FLYNN: Yuval Harari Smears Humanism
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TOM FLYNN: Yuval Harari Smears Humanism CELEBRATING REASON AND HUMANITY June/July 2017 Vol. 37 No.4 “Blasphemy needs legal protection as a matter of equality before the law and as a precondition for citizens’ rights to exercise their freedom of expression and freedom of conscience.” — Flemming Rose EDWARD TABASH | OPHELIA BENSON RUSSELL BLACKFORD | SHADIA B. DRURY JOE NICKELL | LEAH MICKENS 80% 1.5 BWR PD J/J 08 07 Published by the Center for Inquiry in association with the Council for Secular Humanism 7725274 74957 IL ! Digital-Only Subscriptions to FREE IINQUIRY is now available for digital- only subscription. Digital subscribers can read the full contents of each new issue— and selected articles from issues back to 1996—online, without receiving physical magazines by mail. The content is viewable on desktop, laptop, tablet, or smartphone. Consider giving a gift subscription to a young person you know who might appreciate F REE IINQUIRY’s content but prefers to read on a digital device—or to a friend overseas who finds receiving the print edition cumbersome. Moving past print yourself? Plan now to switch when your current print subscription expires.* Best of all, FREE IINQUIRY’s digital subscription offers attractive savings: TERM PRINT RATE DIGITAL RATE 1 year $35.00 $18.95 2 years $58.00 $32.95 Use order form on page 60 3 years $84.00 $44.95 Ten to fifteen days after we receive your order, each recipient will receive an e-mail message announcing that a gift subscription has been entered in his or her name. You will be identified as the giver. If you prefer not to be named, check the “I wish to make this gift anonymously” box on page 60. The announcement message will contain a new account number that the recipient can use to log in to secularhumanism.org and create a username and password. Thereafter, the recipient will enjoy full subscriber-level access, including the full contents of each issue of FREE INQUIRY, for the duration of the digital subscription and will be able to access FREE INQUIRY content from any device. Each recipient will receive an e-mail reminder when a new issue is published. * Sorry—it is not possible to convert a current print subscription to digital only. JUNE | JULY 2017 Volume 37 No. 4 IL ! CELEBRATING REASON AND HUMANITY Digital-Only Subscriptions to BLASPHEMY: IN THE EYE OF THE BEHOLDER? 37 The Big Bang Enabled Evolution 22 Blasphemy: A Victimless Crime Joel Kirschbaum or a Crime in Search of a Victim? Flemming Rose 40 Calling All Wimpy Activists Karen Shragg 27 Religious Freedom and Blasphemy Law in a Global Context: The Concept 43 The Visions of Julian of Norwich of Religious Defamation Joe Nickell Mirjam van Schaik 33 The Catholic Church’s 46 One Smartphone, 100 Million Users, ‘Woman Priest’ Question and Privatizing Faith FREE IINQUIRY is now available for digital- Thomas Aquinas and Giving Thomas Larson only subscription. Digital subscribers can Every Woman Her Due read the full contents of each new issue— Leah Mickens and selected articles from issues back to 1996—online, without receiving physical magazines by mail. The content is viewable on desktop, laptop, tablet, or smartphone. EDITORIAL CFI NEWS 59 HUMANISM AT LARGE Jesus Is a Myth: A Rebuttal 4 Smearing Humanism 19 CFI Helps Welcome Consider giving a gift subscription to a to Bill Cooke Tom Flynn UN Special Rapporteur young person you know who might Mark Cagnetta appreciate F REE IINQUIRY’s content but LOOKING BACK REVIEWS prefers to read on a digital device—or to a OP-EDS 20 friend overseas who finds receiving 7 The Hadza: A People 61 The Rabbi’s Atheist Daughter: LETTERS the print edition cumbersome. without Religion Ernestine Rose, International Gregory Paul 21 Feminist Pioneer, Moving past print yourself? Plan now to by Bonnie S. Anderson switch when your current print subscription 8 Springtime for Bullies Reviewed by Wayne Trotta Ophelia Benson DEPARTMENTS expires.* 51 DOERR'S WAY 63 Star Map: A Journey of Faith, 9 Momentous Anniversaries Planetary Suicide in Slow Motion Doubt, and Meaning, Best of all, FREE IINQUIRY’s digital Russell Blackford Edd Doerr by Lewis Vaughn subscription offers attractive savings: TERM PRINT RATE DIGITAL RATE Reviewed by Tom Flynn 12 Conservatism and Calamity: 53 GREAT MINDS 1 year $35.00 $18.95 From Plato to Bannon The Wickedest Man in Shadia B. Drury San Francisco: Ambrose Bierce 64 Why I Left / Why I Stayed: 2 years $58.00 $32.95 and Cynicism’s Battling Prime Conversations on Christianity 14 God and Men Behaving Badly Dale DeBakcsy Between an Evangelical Father and Use order form on page 3 years $84.00 $44.95 Jane Roberts His Humanist Son, 55 GREAT MINDS EXCERPT by Tony Campolo and Bart Campolo 16 Purpose-Driven Lives The Devil’s Dictionary Reviewed by Tom Flynn James A. Haught Ambrose Bierce 17 Saving Speaker Ryan POEM Ten to fifteen days after we receive your order, each recipient will receive an e-mail message announcing that a gift subscription has been entered 57 THE HUMANIST SOAPBOX . and Unshackling the Bern 65 Truth in his or her name. You will be identified as the giver. If you prefer not to be named, check the “I wish to make this gift anonymously” Bogus Heartbeat Bill Logic Edward Tabash Ted Richer box on page 60. The announcement message will contain a new account number that the recipient can use to log in to secularhumanism.org and Stephen Ray Flora create a username and password. Thereafter, the recipient will enjoy full subscriber-level access, including the full contents of each issue of FREE INQUIRY, for the duration of the digital subscription and will be able to access FREE INQUIRY content from any device. Each recipient will receive an e-mail reminder when a new issue is published. * Sorry—it is not possible to convert a current print subscription to digital only. ty’s Polonsky Prize for Creativity and TOM FLYNN Originality and the National Library of Editor Thomas W. Flynn EDITORIAL China’s Best Book of the Year Award. Managing Editor Andrea Szalanski Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg Columnists Ophelia Benson, Russell made Sapiens a 2015 selection for his Blackford, Greta Christina, online book club, Bill Gates put it on Edd Doerr, Shadia B. Drury, his 2016 list of “Five Books to Read Faisal Saeed Al Mutar, Gregory Paul This Summer,” and more than one Senior Editors Bill Cooke, Richard Dawkins, hundred thousand people have taken Edd Doerr, James A. Haught, Smearing Harari’s free online course in English Jim Herrick, Ronald A. based on themes from the book. Lindsay, Taslima Nasrin Humanism In other words, Sapiens is a phe- Contributing Editors Levi Fragell, nomenon in intellectual publishing, Adolf Grünbaum, notwithstanding that an American- Marvin Kohl, Lee Nisbet Assistant Editors Julia Lavarnway market edition of its English trans- Nicole Scott lation did not appear until 2015. (A s it too soon for an editorial that Literary Editor Cheryl Quimba sequel, Homo Deus: A Brief History of steps back from the perpetual train Permissions Editor Julia Lavarnway Tomorrow, should reach the American wreck of Donald J. Trump’s presi- market before you read these words.) Art Director Christopher S. Fix dency to focus on one of human- Production Paul E. Loynes Sr. But back to Sapiens. It is nothing if Iism’s more, well, perennial discon- not sweeping. Its daunting subtitle, A Center for Inquiry Inc. tents? I call attention to someone in Brief History of Humankind, manages Chair Edward Tabash the public eye—someone who ought to understate the book’s sprawling Board of Directors David Cowan to know better—who denigrates hu- scope. Chapter 1 actually begins with Richard Dawkins Brian Engler manism in ways that are wildly un- the words: “About 13.5 billion years Kendrick Frazier true, yet appears not have made the ago, matter, energy, time and space Barry A. Kosmin slightest effort to ascertain the facts. Y. Sherry Sheng came into being in what is known as J. Anderson Thomson Jr. A reader might think that I’m still the Big Bang.” Leonard Tramiel discussing Trump. But truly, I’m not. I Harari’s goal is nothing less than Honorary: refer to Yuval Noah Harari, an Israeli Rebecca Newberger to explain how everything came to Goldstein history professor and best-selling au- be—the principles that underlie life; Susan Jacoby thor who has presented an extreme how language arose; why H. sapiens Lawrence Krauss and factually untethered critique of came to be the sole surviving repre- Chief Executive Officer humanism in a hugely high-profile sentative of the genus Homo; how and President Robyn E. Blumner book. we got the sciences, economics, and Senior Research Fellow Ronald A. Lindsay If you haven’t heard of Harari, politics—and where we’re headed Director, Campus and you need to. Think of him as Israel’s with them. When filling a canvas this Community Programs Debbie Goddard answer to Malcolm Gladwell, another large, there’s always the temptation Director of Public Engagement Stephanie Guttormson polymath who offers big answers to to spin “just-so stories.” Prominent Vice President for Philanthropy Martina Fern big questions in fast-flowing prose. among those is Harari’s treatment of Director, African Americans But while Gladwell is a journalist, humanism. for Humanism Debbie Goddard Harari is a tenured history professor In chapter 12, “The Law of Reli- Director of Libraries Timothy Binga at the Hebrew University of Jerusa- gion,” Harari devotes nine breathless Communications Director Paul Fidalgo lem. He has an enviable academic pages to humanism—or, as he calls it, Database Manager Jacalyn Mohr record, including four well-regarded “The Worship of Man.” (Yes, really.) Database Administrator Dave Churvis books of military history.