View Which I Have Brought Before the Society Bofore, That Any Woll Educated Ojihbeway Indians Could Understand Eliot's Bible
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Oct. 1893.] Proceedings. PllOOEEDINGS. ANNl'AL MEETING, OCTOBER 21, 1S93, AT THE HALL OK TilE SOCIETY IN WOUCESTER. THE President, Hon. STEPHEN SALISIÏURY, in the chair. The followinir members were present : ' George E. Ellis, Edward E. Hale, George F. Hoar, Nathaniel Paine, Stephen Salisbury, P. Emory Aldrich, Samuel A. Green, Elijah n. Stoddiird, Edward L. Davis, William A. Smith, James F. Hunnewell, JohnD. Washburn, Edward G. Porter, Charles C. Smith, Edmund M. Barton, Franklin B. Dexter, George P. Fisher, Charles A. Chase, Samuel S. Green, Justin Winsor, Henry W. Haynes, Solomon Lincoln, Andrew McF. Davis, Cyrus Hamlin, J. Evarts Greene, Heury S. Nourse, William B. Weeden, Daniel Merriman, Reuben Colton, Robert N.Toppan, Henry H. Edes, Grindall Reynolds, Frank P. Goulding, Hamilton A. Hill, Johu F. .Jameson, Charles Francis Adams, Calviu Stebbins, Francis II. Dewey, Benjamin A. Gould. The minutes of the last meeting were read and approved. The Report of the Council was presented hy Mr. FRANK- LIN B. DEXTER of New Haveu, Conn., who also read a paper on "Some Social Distinctions at Harvard and Yale before the Revolution." At the close of the reading of the Report of the Council Rev. Dr. GEORCXE E. ELLIS said : "The baldest recognition of that distinction of rank is given in Sewall's Journal. He records that the minister of the Old South Church called a meeting of the members of the Church in connection with the choice of a colleague, and 1 Tlie ñamen follow the order of tloction to membersliip. 1 2 American Antiquarian Society. [Oct. very few attended the meeting so that in order to determine it they had to call another meeting. And the explanation was, and I think it was made by tlie father of Dr. Franklin, that Dr. Pendleton asked for a meeting of the gentlemen of the Church and Franklin's father said he did not claim to be a gentleman, and that was the reason that the infelicitous call of the Church led to such a small number being presnt. "I recall an incident which some of you may not remem- ber. When George Bancroft returned from Germany he made an effort in Harvard College to have the catalogue arranged not alphalietieally but according to scholarship. That was resisted by what was called a rebellion in those days. I have reason to remember it for I had an older brother then in college who was a very good scholar, as was also my younger brother. He would have had no reason to object to being ranged in the order of scholarship. But the class had what was called an illegal meeting, that is, a meeting without permission of the faculty, to resist the matter, and my brother was made moderator of that meet- ing. I distinctly recall in my boyhood President Kirkland, who had been my mother's clergyman before going to the college, coming to see her to reconcile her to my brother's l)eing sent off for that illegal moderatorship, and he found it difficult to do it. My brother, who was a very sensitive young man, said he would never return to the college." The Report of the Treasurer was then presented by NATHANIEL PAINE, Esq. The Report of the Librarian was presented by Mr. EDMUND M. BAUTON. On motion it was voted that the Report of the Council should be referred to the Committee on Publication for publication in the Proi-eedings. Prof". HKNRY W. HAYNES and Hon. EDWARD L. DAVIS were appointed to distribute and collect ballots for Presi- dent of the Society. During the collection of the ballots Dr. EDWARD E. HALE said: 1893.] Proceedings. 3 **I should like to ask what became of the supposed American edition of the Pilgrim's Progress which was sup- posed to l>e in the Brinley collection. In the second part of the Pilgrim's Progress Bunyan says in the poetical intro- duction tbat it was reprinted in America. It was announced, twenty or thirty years ago, that a copy was in the Brinley Library, and 1 suppose some of the gentlemen who attended that sale would know." The PRESIDENT referred to the fact that Mr. ANDREW McF. DAVTS at the meeting in April called attention to the question of the amount of property that the Society was allowed to hold ; wliether it had acquired a strength not authorized by the Act of Incorporation, and a committee was appointed by the Council to investigate the subject. The committee had attended to the duty, and a report was prepared by Senator HOAR which he would read. The fol- lowing report was then read : "The Committee who were directed by the Council to inquire how much real and jjersonal property the Society is authorized to hold, and whether it is desirable that further authority to hold property should be obtained from the Legislature, respectfully report : *'The Society was empowered by its eharter, approved October 24, 1812, to take and hold real and personal estate, »provided that the annual income of any real estate by said Society holden shall never exceed the sum of fifteen hundred dollars, and that the personal estate thereof, ex- clusive of books, papers and articles in the museum of said Society ahall never exceed the value of seven thousand dollars.' "By the statute approved March 26, 1852, the Society is authorized to hold real estate the annual income of which shall uot exceed the sum of five thousand <lollars, and per- sonal estate wbich exclusive of books, pspers and articles in its cabinet shall not exceed the sum of one hundred thou- sand dollars. 4 American Antiquarian Society. [Oct. " The Report of the Treasurer for the six month.s endincr April I, 1893, shows that the invested personal property of the Society ineluding cash on hand then amounted to $126,663.91, being more than twenty-six thousand dollars in excess ofthe amount allowed by law. " The Committee understand that no person can raise any lawful ol)jeotion to the holding of this amount by the Society, or to its acquiring and holding any further [¡rop- erty, real or personal, excej)t the Commonuealtb. But sueh holding and acquisition are in violation of law, and the Society can be compelled by proper process instilutc(î in behalf of the Commonwealth to keep within legal limits. This condition of things may deter some persons who might otherwise be disposed to make gifts to the Society. *'We therefore recommend that the Society petition the Legislature ¡it tho coming î^e.'jsion so to amend lhe churtor that the Society may hold property, real or personal, to an amount not exceeding five hundred thousand dollars. STEPHEN SALISBURY, GEO. F. HOAR, SAMUEL S. GREEN." The report was un¡ininiously adopted. The Comniittee on Election announced that Hon. STEPHEN SALISBUUY had been unanimously elected President. The PiiEsinE>!T: ''I express my thank.s for this renewed manifestation ofthe confidence ofthe Society." On motion of Dr. SAMUEL A. GHEEN, Dr. GRREN, Mr. RoBEitT N. TOPPAN and Mr. SOLOMON LINCOLN were appointed liy the President a committee to nominate the other officers. On motion of Senator HOAU it was voted that the Presi- dent and Recording Secretary should lie directed to peti- tion the Legislature, in accordance with the report pre- sented, for an increase of the authorized capital of tlie Society. Dr. HALE: "I had the honor of u conversation with 1893.] Proceedings, 5 Bishop Whipple at Lake Mohonk, and be confirmed the view which I have brought before the Society bofore, that any woll educated Ojihbeway Indians could understand Eliot's Bible. He has promised to send me some momo- randa on the mutter, and I should liko to have permission to present those memoranda to tbe Publication Committee, and if tbey should tbink them important enough to ask that they may be printed as a part of our Proceedings." It was so voted. Tbe chairman of the Committee on Nominations reported tbo list of officers for election. On motion tho Socrotary was instructed to cast a yea vote for tho officers aud the following persons were so elected : Vice-Presidents : Hon. GEOKOE FBISBIE HOAR, LL.D., of Worcester. Rev. EDWARD EVERETT HALE, D.D., of Roxbury. Secretary for Foreign Correspondence : Hon. JAMES HAMMOND TKUMBULL, LL.D., of Hartford, Connecticut. Secretary for Domestic Correspondence : Rev. GEOKGE EDWARD ELLIS, LL.D., of Boston. Recording Sea'etary : Hon. JOHN DAVIS WASHBURN, LL.B., of Woreestor. Treasuî'ei' : Mr. NATHANIEL PAINE, of Worcester. Councillors : Hon. SAMUEL ABBOTT GREEN, M.D., of Boston. Hon. PELEG EMORY ALDRICH, LL.D., of Worcester. Rev. EGBERT COFFIN SMYTH, D.D., of Andover. SAMUEL SWETT GREEN, A.M., of Worcester. CHARLES AUGUSTUS CHASE, A.M., of Worcester. Hon. EDWARD LIVINGSTON DAVIS, A.M., of Worcester. FRANKLIN BOWDITCH DEXTER, M.A., of New Haven, Ct. 6 Ameriean Antiquarian Soeiety. [Oct. JEREMIAH EVAKTS GREENE, A.B., of Worcester. GRANVILLE STANLEY HALL, LL.D., of Worcester. WILLIAM BABCOCK WEEDEN, A.M., of Providence, R. I. Committee of Publication : Rev. EDWARD E. HALE, D.D., of Boston. NATHANÍEL PAINE, Esq., of Worcester. CHARLES A. CHASE, A.M., of Worcester. CHARLES C. SMITH, A.M., of Boston. Auditors : WILLIAM A. SMITH, A.B., of Worcester. A. GEOROE BOLLOCK, A.M., of Worcester. The President announced that there were eleveu vacaneies in the list of Domestic Members. Foreign Members also were to be elected. The Council had prepared lists of names for the action of the Society. The Secretary read the following names presented for Foreigu Membership : Protap Chuuder Mozoomdar of India ; Rt. ßev. William Stubbs, Bishop of Oxford; Goldwin Smith of Canada; Sir John Lubbock of London.