Saving the Outer Banks – Lessons from the Life of Frank Stick Paul
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Saving the Outer Banks – Lessons from the Life of Frank Stick Paul Eugene Triulzi Faculty Advisor: Daniel Rittschof NSOE Marine Science and Conservation Division April 2017 This project was submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in the Graduate Liberal Studies Program in the Graduate School of Duke University. Copyright by Paul E. Triulzi 2017 Abstract The joy of finding unspoiled beaches on the island of Ocracoke led to inquiring how these areas escaped the rampant development prevalent in coastal North Carolina. This project’s primary purpose was to investigate a mostly unknown person, named Frank Stick, and to determine his role, if any, in helping to establish the Cape Hatteras National Seashore, and second, to investigate present-day threats to the seashore. The primary inquiry led to Roanoke Island, NC, and the Outer Banks History Center to research from primary sources the life of Frank Stick and the formation of the national seashore. I also interviewed residents of the Outer Banks and descendants of landowners that had contributed to the national seashore. To research current threats, I attended forums of the NC Coastal Federation, Duke’s Ocean Policy Working Group, and the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, and toured the entire seashore. My inquiry reveals that the formation of the Cape Hatteras National Seashore has a very long and complicated history in which Frank Stick played a major role, and which this paper examines through his life and times. I found that oil exploration and global warming are major threats to the seashore, and that coastal residents prefer tourism to an energy economy. This paper reveals who Frank Stick was and what we can learn from his activism, conservationism and methods in order to counteract current environmental threats to America’s first national seashore. iii Dedication TO THE OUTER BANKS’ FAMILIES THAT PARTED WITH LAND TO MAKE POSSIBLE A PRISTINE NATIONAL SEASHORE THAT RECREATES MORE THAN TWO MILLION VISITORS EACH YEAR. iv Contents Abstract ......................................................................................................................... iii List of Figures .................................................................................................................. x Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................ xi Introduction .................................................................................................................... 1 1. In Search of Frank Stick ............................................................................................... 5 1.1 Finding Treasure in Manteo ................................................................................. 5 1.2 Childhood and Family .......................................................................................... 6 1.3 Outdoorsman ...................................................................................................... 8 1.4 Budding Artist ...................................................................................................... 9 1.5 Call of the Wild .................................................................................................. 13 1.6 Career and Growing Family ................................................................................ 14 1.7 Environmentalist ............................................................................................... 16 1.8 Mid-Life Crisis .................................................................................................... 20 1.9 Conservationist .................................................................................................. 21 1.10 Builder, and Architect ...................................................................................... 23 1.11 Sunset Years .................................................................................................... 25 1.12 The Person....................................................................................................... 27 2. Early American Environmental Conservation ............................................................. 35 2.1 Early American Conservationists ........................................................................ 36 v 2.2 John Muir – Writer/Activist ............................................................................... 38 2.2.1 John Muir’s Writings ..................................................................................... 40 2.2.1.1 On Trekking Wilderness ......................................................................... 41 2.2.1.2 On the Need for Federal Intervention .................................................... 41 2.2.1.3 On the Beauty of Wild Spaces ................................................................ 41 2.2.1.4 On the Value of Wilderness Recreation .................................................. 42 2.3 Theodore Roosevelt – Naturalist/Politician ........................................................ 42 2.3.3 Naturalist and Conservationist ...................................................................... 43 2.3.3.1 On Environmental Stewardship .............................................................. 45 2.3.3.2 On The Value of Conservation ................................................................ 46 2.3.3.3 On the Greater Good and Generational Altruism ................................... 47 2.3.3.4 On the Grand Canyon and Its Conservation ............................................ 47 2.4 Aldo Leopold – Writer/Philosopher ................................................................... 48 2.4.1 Philosopher of Nature ................................................................................... 48 2.4.1.1 On Interdependence in Nature (from Round River) ................................ 50 2.4.1.2 On Conservation .................................................................................... 50 2.5 Conservation Consciousness ........................................................................... 50 3. Radical Career Change ............................................................................................... 53 3.1 Discovering the Outer Banks .............................................................................. 53 3.1.1 Outer Banks Promoter .................................................................................. 55 3.1.2 Fort Raleigh .................................................................................................. 57 vi 3.2 A New Home ..................................................................................................... 57 4. Grand Proposal or Grand Illusion ............................................................................... 61 4.1 The State of the Banks ....................................................................................... 61 4.2 A Perfect Confluence ......................................................................................... 64 4.3 A Proposal to Save the Outer Banks ................................................................... 65 4.4 Further Observations on Stick’s Proposal ........................................................... 71 5. Process and Politics of the National Seashore............................................................ 75 5.1 A Popular Start .................................................................................................. 75 5.2 Turning Vision into Reality – First Steps ............................................................. 76 5.2.1 Appointments ............................................................................................... 77 5.2.1 Correspondence ........................................................................................... 78 5.3 Beach and Land Reclamation ............................................................................. 80 5.4 Providing the Park’s Cornerstone – Making It Happen ....................................... 84 5.5 State and Federal Action .................................................................................... 90 5.6 Congressional Action ......................................................................................... 93 5.7 State Land Acquisition and War Years Hiatus ..................................................... 94 5.8 Sunset Clause .................................................................................................... 97 5.9 NC Backsliding and Delicate Interventions ......................................................... 98 5.10 Vision Becomes Reality .................................................................................. 105 5.11 Assessing Stick’s Contributions ...................................................................... 107 6. A Second National Park ........................................................................................... 111 vii 6.1 Plantation Improvements ................................................................................ 111 6.2 Promoting Another Park .................................................................................. 112 6.3 St. John Virgin Islands National Park ................................................................ 115 7. Lessons Learned from Frank Stick ............................................................................ 117 7.1 Dreams vs Pragmatism ...................................................................................