Creating Literary Analysis

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Creating Literary Analysis Creating Literary Analysis v. 1.0 This is the book Creating Literary Analysis (v. 1.0). This book is licensed under a Creative Commons by-nc-sa 3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/ 3.0/) license. See the license for more details, but that basically means you can share this book as long as you credit the author (but see below), don't make money from it, and do make it available to everyone else under the same terms. This book was accessible as of December 29, 2012, and it was downloaded then by Andy Schmitz (http://lardbucket.org) in an effort to preserve the availability of this book. Normally, the author and publisher would be credited here. However, the publisher has asked for the customary Creative Commons attribution to the original publisher, authors, title, and book URI to be removed. Additionally, per the publisher's request, their name has been removed in some passages. More information is available on this project's attribution page (http://2012books.lardbucket.org/attribution.html?utm_source=header). For more information on the source of this book, or why it is available for free, please see the project's home page (http://2012books.lardbucket.org/). You can browse or download additional books there. ii Table of Contents About the Authors................................................................................................................. 1 Acknowledgments................................................................................................................. 2 Dedications............................................................................................................................. 4 Preface..................................................................................................................................... 5 Chapter 1: Introduction: What Is Literary Theory and Why Should I Care?............ 7 Literary Snapshot: Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland..............................................................................8 What Is Literary Theory? ............................................................................................................................ 12 Why Study Literary Theory?....................................................................................................................... 14 What Is the Writing Process?...................................................................................................................... 15 Why Commit to the Writing Process?........................................................................................................ 19 What Is Academic Argument? .................................................................................................................... 20 Introducing an Academic Argument.......................................................................................................... 24 Student Writer at Work: Monica Platten’s “‘The Legend of Sleepy Hollow’: An Allegory for a Young America” ....................................................................................................................................................... 29 Understanding the Body of Monica’s Argument ...................................................................................... 37 Conclusion to the Introduction .................................................................................................................. 42 End-of-Chapter Assessment........................................................................................................................ 43 Chapter 2: Writing about Form: Developing the Foundations of Close Reading... 46 Literary Snapshot: Through the Looking-Glass ........................................................................................ 47 The Foundations of New Criticism: An Overview ..................................................................................... 54 Close Reading Strategies: A Process Approach ......................................................................................... 61 Student Writer at Work: Kelly Ann Wolslegel’s Close Reading of Edna St. Vincent Millay’s “Love Is Not All”.......................................................................................................................................................... 63 Student Sample Papers: Todd Goodwin’s “Poe’s ‘Usher’: A Mirror of the Fall of the House of Humanity” and Amy Chisnell’s “Don’t Listen to the Egg!: A Close Reading of Lewis Carroll’s ‘Jabberwocky’”.............................................................................................................................................. 71 End-of-Chapter Assessment........................................................................................................................ 80 Suggestions for Further Reading................................................................................................................ 84 iii Chapter 3: Writing about Character and Motivation: Psychoanalytic Literary Criticism................................................................................................................................ 85 Literary Snapshot: Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking-Glass.....................86 Psychoanalytic Literary Criticism: An Overview ...................................................................................... 90 Focus on Sigmund Freud (1856–1939): Unconscious Repressed Desire..................................................94 Focus on Jacques Lacan (1901–81): Repressed Desire and the Limits of Language .............................101 Focus on Carl Jung (1875–1961): The Archetypal Collective Unconsciousness ...................................107 Reading Keats’s “Urn” through the Psychoanalytic Lens......................................................................112 Psychoanalytic Literary Criticism: A Process Approach........................................................................ 117 Student Writers at Work: Jenn Nemec’s Jungian Psychoanalytic Reading of “The Birthmark,” Susan Moore’s Freudian Reading of “The Birthmark,” and Sarah David’s Lacanian Reading of “The Birthmark”.................................................................................................................................................. 118 Student Sample Paper: Susan Moore’s “The Desire for Perfection in Hawthorne’s ‘The Birthmark’”................................................................................................................................................. 127 Student Sample Paper: Sarah David’s “A Lacanian Analysis of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s ‘The Birthmark’”................................................................................................................................................. 132 End-of-Chapter Assessment...................................................................................................................... 136 Suggestions for Further Reading.............................................................................................................. 139 Chapter 4: Writing about Gender and Sexuality: Applying Feminist and Gender Criticism.............................................................................................................................. 141 Literary Snapshot: Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland.......................................................................... 142 Feminist Theory: An Overview ................................................................................................................. 149 Gender Criticism and Queer Theory ........................................................................................................ 156 Gender Criticism: Masculinity Studies..................................................................................................... 161 Feminist and Gender Criticism: A Process Approach............................................................................. 163 Student Writer at Work: Gretchen Panzer’s Feminist Response to F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby.......................................................................................................................................................... 164 Student Sample Paper: Carrie Obry’s “Homoerotic Impulses in Willa Cather’s ‘Paul’s Case’” ..........176 Student Sample Paper: Duncan Raunio’s “The Tragedy of Performing Gender in Kate Chopin’s The Awakening” ................................................................................................................................................ 184 End-of-Chapter Assessment...................................................................................................................... 190 Suggestions for Further Reading.............................................................................................................. 201 iv Chapter 5: Writing about Racial, Ethnic, and Cultural Identity ............................. 204 Literary Snapshot: Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland.......................................................................... 205 Postcolonial, Racial, and Ethnic Theory: An Overview .......................................................................... 213 Writing about Race, Ethnic, and Cultural Identity: A Process Approach.............................................224 Student Writer at Work: Ashley Eckhardt’s Postcolonial Paper in Action ..........................................226
Recommended publications
  • How to Find Free, Reusable Content Online Rhode Island Library
    Open Everything: How to find free, reusable content online Rhode Island Library Association Conference 2016, “Color Outside the Lines” Andrée Rathemacher • Julia Lovett • Angel Ferria University of Rhode Island Open Culture General Resources: Sites, Portals & Guides Digital Public Library of America — http://dp.la/ Aims to be a national digital library for the​ USA. Harvests metadata and content in all formats from other digital libraries and databases (HathiTrust, Internet Archive, state/consortium repositories, govt repositories etc. ­ full partner list here http://dp.la/partners) Does not yet allow searching/filtering by rights information. ​ ​ Europeana — http://www.europeana.eu/portal/ Europe’s portal t​o cultural collections: “Explore 52,219,831 artworks, artefacts, books, videos and sounds from across Europe.” Can filter search results by reuse rights. Internet Archive — http://archive.org Founded in 1996. A “no​n­profit library of millions of free books, movies, software, music, and more.” Searchable by Creative Commons license or Public Domain: See https://archive.org/about/faqs.php#1069 ​ Open Culture — http://www.openculture.com/ Founded in 2006. B​rings together free/open resources from around the web. Geared for a popular audience, with frequent blog posts and active social media presence. OpenGLAM Open Collections — http://openglam.org/open­collections/ A searchable index of open cultural her​ itage collections with freely reusable content. Shared Shelf Commons — http://www.sscommons.org Freely available images and oth​ er digital content from libraries, archives, and museums participating in Shared Shelf by Artstor. Copyright restrictions vary. Creative Commons Search — https://search.creativecommons.org/ Search CC­licensed content from m​ultiple sites such as Flickr, Google, and YouTube.
    [Show full text]
  • Fairy Tales in Chapter Books
    Alexander, Lloyd. The Book of Three Codell, Esme. Diary of a Fairy Godmother Haskell, Merrie. The Princess Curse Taran, Assistant Pig-Keeper to a famous oracular Hunky Dory's interest in wishcraft over witchcraft gets Twelve princesses suffer from a puzzling curse, sow, sets out on a hazardous mission to save her kicked out of charm school. Now she's determined and anyone who ends it will win a reward. Reveka, Prydain from the forces of evil. to follow her heart and become a fairy godmother. But a sharp-witted apprentice herbalist, wants that re- how to go about doing it? ward. But her investigations lead to deeper myster- Bach, Shelby. Of Giants and Ice ies and a daunting choice - will she break the curse Eleven-year-old Rory, daughter to famous Dahl, Roald. James and the Giant Peach at the peril of her own soul? parents, finds herself becoming a celebrity in her A young boy escapes from two wicked aunts and em- own right as she participates in the magical after barks on a series of adventures with six giant insects Healey, Christopher. The Hero’s Guide to Saving school program, Ever After School. he meets inside a giant peach. the Kingdom The four princes erroneously dubbed Prince Baker, E.D. The Wide-Awake Princess Frederick, Heather. Once Upon a Toad Charming and rudely marginalized in their respec- Princess Annie is Sleeping Beauty’s younger sister. Cat is sent to live with her father and stepsister Olivia, tive fairy tales form an unlikely team when a witch When her sister pricks her finger and the whole but interference by her inept fairy godmother causes threatens the whole kingdom.
    [Show full text]
  • Joyce's Dubliners and Hemingway's in Our Time
    37q i 0 JOYCE'S DUBLINERS AND HEMINGWAY'S IN OUR TIME: A CORRELATION THESIS Presented to the Graduate Council of the North Texas State University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS By Kim Martin Mayo, B. A. Denton, Texas December, 1986 Mayo, Kim M., Joyze's Dubliners and Hemingway's In Our Time: A Correlation. Master of Arts (English), December, 1986. 109 pp., works cited, 50 titles. One rarely sees the names James Joyce and Ernest Hemingway together in the same sentence. Their obvious differences in writing styles, nationalities, and lifestyles prevent any automatic comparison from being made. But when one compares their early short story collections, Dubliners and In Our Time, many surprisingly similarities appear. Both are collections of short stories unified in some way, written by expatriates who knew each other in Paris. A mood of despair and hopelessness pervades the stories as the characters are trapped in the human condition. By examining the commonalities found in their methods of organization, handling of point of view, attitudes toward their subjects, stylistic techniques, and modes of writing, one is continually brought back to the differences between Joyce and Hemingway in each of these areas. For it is their differences that make these artists important; how each author chose to develop his craft gives him a significant place in literature. Copyright by Kim Martin Mayo 1986 TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter Page I. INTRODUCTION---ESTABLISHING THE SIMILARITIES . .1 II. ORGANIZATION AND UNITY.. ... 8 III. POINT OF VIEW . 0.v.. .......... .27 IV. SUBJECT, STRUCTURE, AND SYMBOLISM.
    [Show full text]
  • Download the Free STUDY GUIDE
    Dear Reader, We are so exited to share our comic series, The Light Princess, with you! This incredible fairy tale was originally written by scottish author, George MacDonald in 1864. The story is full of allegory and metaphors, and loved by many regardless of age and gender. While it was originally written for children, both C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkein loved this story, and considered MacDonald the inspiration for their well known works, Narnia and The Lord of the Rings. In light of this, this study guide has been designed to enrich the story for ages 6-16, and has been broken up into three levels of activities: beginner, in- termediate and advanced. We hope that this educational guide is something that your whole family can go through together, and help draw out just some of the richness that MacDonald infused throughout this beautiful story. How to Get the Comic Series If you do not already have the series, you can find it digitally on ComiXology, read it for free on Webtoon, or buy a physical series on Amazon. If you have younger children, you can download the edited version of Issue 1 that has removed pages 7-13 to make it more appropriate for children. The free webtoons version has also been edited, and the rest of the series is appropriate for all ages. About Cave Pictures Publishing Our projects include wholly original works by acclaimed artists in the comics industry as well as original adaptations of existing works. We work in many genres, including: supernatural fiction, historic fiction, fantasy, and science fiction.
    [Show full text]
  • Metaphor-II Metaphor-II Contents: 10.1 Dead Metaphors 10.2 Conceptual
    Metaphor-II Linguistic Stylistics Metaphor-II Figures of Speech Paper Coordinator Prof. Ravinder Gargesh Module ID & Name Lings_P-LS10 Metaphor-II Content Writer Dr. V.P. Sharma Email id [email protected] Phone 9312254857 Contents: 10.1 Dead Metaphors 10.2 Conceptual Metaphor Theory 10.3 Extended Metaphor 10.4 Mixed Metaphor 10.5 Metaphor in Literary and Non-literary discourse 10.1 Dead Metaphors We have noted that a metaphor is characterized by linguistic deviation. This characteristic allows metaphor, particularly poetic metaphors, to create novel and original combinations of ideas, objects and sensations. But as they come into common use, the novelty wears off and there is no perception of semantic deviation. More significantly, they lose their iconicity: in ‘root cause of the problem’ or ‘heated argument’, the original metaphor has lost its figurative ‘charge’; ‘root cause of a problem’ is simply the ‘fundamental reason for the occurrence of the problem’, and ‘heated argument ‘ is another expression for ‘angry exchange of words’. Such metaphors are dead metaphors. But metaphors never really die. The metaphors that ‘die’ in poetic language come to ‘live’ in ordinary language. The habit of words to extend their meaning by metaphor and then cease to be metaphorical is a fact of language. It further allows metaphors to be used to fill gaps in vocabulary: leg of a table, wings of a building, clock hands, World Wide Web, crashing or hanging (as in computer hangs), surf, crash course. In such cases of metaphorical extensions, there are no literal substitutes for these expressions. This is true of all languages.
    [Show full text]
  • "'A Complicated and Unpleasant Investigation': the Arden Shakespeare 1899-1924" by Gabriel Egan This Paper Arises From
    Egan, Gabriel. 2007d. "'''A complicated and unpleasant investigation': The Arden Shakespeare 1899-1924': A paper delivered on 12 July at the conference 'Open the Book, Open the Mind: The 2007 meeting of the Society for History of Authorship, Reading, and Publishing (SHARP)' at the University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, 11-15 July." "'A complicated and unpleasant investigation': The Arden Shakespeare 1899-1924" by Gabriel Egan This paper arises from a survey of Shakespeare play editions in the twentieth century. I'm particularly interested in what those who made editions thought they were doing, how confident they felt about their work, how they thought readers would respond to the textual problems that arise in editing old plays, and how editors' assumptions about their readers were manifested in the editions that they produced. My published title in the programme covers the whole century of editions, but I'm going largely to confine my remarks to just one editorial project. For those of you who like to see the big picture first, however, I can offer a brief overview of just one of those variables I mentioned: editorial confidence [SLIDE]. I see it going like this, from a low at the start of the twentieth-century, through to a peak in the 1970s, and back to a low now. From the detailed history behind this pattern, I have room on this chart to pull just a few keys moments. [SLIDE] First, A. W. Pollard's book Shakespeare Folios and Quartos (1909) distinguished the good from the bad quartos and gave editors reasons to suppose that the good ones are textually close to Shakespeare's own papers.
    [Show full text]
  • Epiphanies in Dubliners
    Epiphanies in Dubliners Epiphanies in Dubliners* Takashi Suzuki Epiphanies appear in Dubliners in various ways. Some stories present them directly. These epipha- nies are apparent to every reader. One of these is in “After the Race”. Jimmy Doyle is a son of the successful father who is called a merchant prince by the Dublin newspapers. Jimmy is a spoiled youth who has money and is popular but of no particular talent. He is very excited, sitting in a car that a wealthy Frenchman drives with his companions through the cheers of spectators. He has joined the Frenchman’s company without no reason. Jimmy takes this car race as the opportunity to deepen his relationship with the Frenchman from mere acquaintance to friendship. The Frenchman is reputed to own some of the biggest hotels in France, and is about to start motor business in Paris. Jimmy is going to “stake”(47)1 the greater part of his money on the Frenchman’s venture, and the Frenchman gives him the impression that the investment is made possible by a favour of friendship. The idea of this investment is initiated by his father’s suggestion. Therefore Jimmy and his father treat them in a very friendly and hospitable manner. But this design leads Jimmy to a fatal card game, and he loses more than he can afford: He knew that he would regret it in the morning, but at present he was glad of the rest, glad of the dark stupor that would cover up his folly. He leaned his elbows on the table and rested his head between his hands, counting the beats of his temples.
    [Show full text]
  • PRINCESS Books 11/2018
    PRINCESS Books 11/2018 PICTURE BOOKS: Princess Palooza jj Allen, J The Very Fairy Princess jj Andrews, J The Very Fairy Princess: Here Comes the Flower Girl! Jj Andrews, J The Very Fairy Princess Takes the Stage jj Andrews, J The Princess and the Pizza jj Auch, M Snoring Beauty jj Bardhan-Quallen, S The Princess and the Pony jj Beaton, K Marisol McDonald Doesn’t Match = Marisol McDonald No Combina jj Brown, Monica Babar and Zephir jj Brunhoff, J Princess Peepers Picks a Pet jj Calvert, P Puss in Boots jj Cauley, L The Frog Princess jj Cecil, L The Princess and the Pea in Miniature: After the Fairy Tale by Hans Christian Andersen jj Child, L Princess Smartypants jj Cole, B Do Princesses Scrape Their Knees? Jj Coyle, C A Hero’s Quest jj DiCamillo, K The Mouse and the Princess jj DiCamillo, K A Friend for Merida jj Disney The Prince Won’t Go to Bed! Jj Dodds, D A Gold Star for Zog jj Donaldson, J Zog and the Flying Doctors jj Donaldson, J Dora Saves the Snow Princess jj Dora How to Become a Perfect Princess In Five Days jj Dube, P Olivia and the Fairy Princesses jj Falconer, I Olivia: The Princess jj Falconer, I The Most Wonderful Thing in the World jj French, V The Princess Knight jj Funke, C The Snow Rabbit jj Garoche, C Spells jj Gravett, E Fitchburg Public Library 610 Main St, Fitchburg, MA 01420 978-829-1789 www.fitchburgpubliclibrary.org Princesses Save the World jj Guthrie, S Princesses Wear Pants jj Guthrie, S Snoring Beauty jj Hale, B Princess Academy jj Hale, S PA1 Princess Hyacinth: (The Surprising Tale of a Girl Who Floated)
    [Show full text]
  • Dubliners by JAMES JOYCE
    Dubliners BY JAMES JOYCE P RESTWICK H OUSE L ITERARY T OUC H STONE C L ASSICS TM P. O . B O X 6 5 8 • C LAY to N , D ELAWARE 1 9 9 3 8 SENIOR EDITOR: Paul Moliken EDITORS: James Scott and Lisa M. Miller COVER DESIGN: Kelly Valentine Vasami PRODUCTION: Jerry Clark P RESTWICK H OUSE L ITERARY T OUC H STONE C L ASSICS P. O . B O X 6 5 8 • C LAY to N , D ELAWARE 1 9 9 3 8 T EL : 1.800.932.4593 F AX : 1.888.718.9333 W E B : www.prestwickhouse.com Prestwick House Teaching UnitsTM, Activity PacksTM, and Response JournalsTM are the perfect complement for these editions. To purchase teaching resources for this book, visit www.prest- wickhouse.com/material This Prestwick House edition is an unabridged republication with slight emendations of Dubliners, published in 1914. ©2006 All new material is copyrighted by Prestwick House, Inc. All rights reserved. No portion may be reproduced without permission in writing from the publisher. Printed in the United States of America. ISBN-10 1-58049-165-0 ISBN-13 978-1-58049-165-5 Dubliners BY JAMES JOYCE C O N T EN T S NOTES ...........................................................................4 READING POINTERS FOR SHARPER INSIGHTS .....................6 THE SISTERS ..................................................................9 AN ENCOUNTER ...........................................................17 ARABY .........................................................................25 EVELINE ......................................................................31 AFTER THE RACE ..........................................................35
    [Show full text]
  • The Light Princess
    ADDDDDDDDDDD^DDDDDDDDDDDF H I H rag & bone puppet theatre I H I H The Light Princess I H I H I H ADDDDDDDDDDDDDDDF I H I H H I I H H I I H H I I H I H H I I H H I I H H I I H I H H I I H H I I H I H H I I H H I I H H I I H KMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMP I H I H teacher’s guide I H I H I H I H I H I H I H I H I H I H I H I H I H I H I KMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMP Contents Dear Teacher: ………………………………………4 The Company ……………………………………… 5 About the Production ……………………………… 7 The Characters ………………………………………8 The Story ………………………………………… 11 Word Search ……………………………………… 14 Where is the Baby? ……………………………… 16 A Rag & Bone Production ………………………… 18 Make a Puppet Show …………………………… 21 Scrap Wood Puppets ……………………………… 24 rag & bone puppet theatre The Light Princess f Based on the story by George MacDonald CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC Dear Teacher: We’re looking forward to performing The Light Princess at your school. This study guide has a synopsis of the show, a word search, a maze, and information about the production. Feel free to photocopy any of this guide for use with your class. Thank you for inviting us to your school. We hope your students and staff enjoy the show! Yours truly, Kathy MacLellan & John Nolan DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD The Company Founded in 1978 by John Nolan and Kathy MacLellan, Rag & Bone’s shows produced include The Snow Queen, The Nativity, The Cow Show, The Nightingale, Tug of War, A Bauchan in the Family, A Promise is a Promise, The Weaving of a Dream, The Story of Holly & Ivy, Felicity Falls, Macbeth, and The Light Princess and Zoom.
    [Show full text]
  • CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW 2.1 Theoretical Framework in This
    ADLN Perpustakaan Universitas Airlangga CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW 2.1 Theoretical Framework In this chapter, the writer will explain about the theory which is applied to analyze Rabbit Hole play as the chosen literary work in this study. Regarding the statement of the problem, the theory which is used in this study is New Criticism; which means the approach based only on the text itself. Besides explaining about New Criticism as the main theory and several formal elements such as characterization, plot, symbol, and also the theme which is the main idea of the story, this chapter also contains related studies with the similar issue that can support this study. There will be three related studies for this study that will be discussed in the end of this chapter. First, the writer will explain about the main theory; that is New Criticism. New Criticism is an approach which focuses on the text itself to find the meaning of a literary work. New Criticism refuses to pay attention to the external factors such as author’s background, reader’s response, and another factor which is not merely about the text of literary work. According to Tyson, the external factors such as author’s background cannot always be a guide to provide information to analyze a literary work (Tyson 136), because New Criticism focuses only on the text, Skripsi BECCA’S SURVIVAL ATTEMPT AFTER THE DEATH OF HER BELOVEDLUTFITA MAUDY PRASTIKASARI SON IN DAVID LINDSAY-ABAIRE’S RABBIT HOLE: A NEW CRITICISM STUDY ADLN Perpustakaan Universitas Airlangga the validity of the text meaning is reasonable.
    [Show full text]
  • Doing Wrong with Just Cause? a History of Julius Caesar 3.1.47-48 by M. L. Stapleton and Sarah K. Scott Relative to Some Of
    Doing Wrong with Just Cause? A History of Julius Caesar 3.1.47-48 by M. L. Stapleton and Sarah K. Scott Relative to some of its fellows in the First Folio, the text of Julius Caesar appears at first glance to present few problems for editors and commentators. There are no troublesome quartos with readings that diverge wildly from the copy text. There is no incomprehensible “I see that men make rope’s in such a scarre” (AWW 4.2.38 / 2063). Nor does the play provide a spectacular opportunity to illuminate a passage with the mere substitution of a few letters, such as Lewis Theobald’s extension of Mistress Quickly’s pastoral conceit as she describes Falstaff in extremis, his “’a babbl’d” for the Folio’s “a Table of greene fields” (H5 2.3.16-17 / 839). However, in our work on the New Variorum edition of the play—compiling a commentary, collating editions, and writing performance appendices—we have found that the 1623 text cannot be described as problem-free.1 Twenty-first century textual scholars tend to advise against emendation for sensible, if doctrinaire reasons. Surely no one would wish to violate a play’s textuality or deny her students the opportunity to purchase a multi-version Hamlet or Lear, a deprivation they would surely see as an impediment to their quest for knowledge. Yet many of our predecessors, even those of a fairly conservative bent such as Capell or Dr. Johnson, might well find such reasons for nonintervention ridiculous: or, as they spell one of their favorite euphemisms for strong disapproval, “surprizing.” Eighteenth and early nineteenth-century editors especially engage in somewhat ferocious combat about many passages in Julius Caesar.
    [Show full text]