Neo-Ottoman Perspectives: Turkish Identity and Culinary Culture in a Sociopolitical Context
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AN ABSTRACT OF THE THESIS OF Sera D. Kinoğlu for the degree of Master of Arts in Applied Anthropology presented on May 22, 2014. Title: Neo-Ottoman Perspectives: Turkish Identity and Culinary Culture in a Sociopolitical Context Abstract approved: ____________________________________________________________ David A. McMurray As Turkey’s cultural and economic climate has experienced dramatic shifts in accordance with its changing role in global society, a neo-Ottoman movement has taken root in recent years which can offer insight into the new Turkish identity. This sociopolitical movement captures a diverse set of cultural attributes through a contemporary perspective of the historical Ottoman Period. This thesis will explore the spectrum of Ottoman representations as well as the meanings ascribed to them by Turks. By focusing largely on culinary culture as it is manifested in neo-Ottomanism, I will address socioeconomic and religious distinctions in terms of their participation in and perception of this phenomenon. Situating these concepts in the context of a cultural and ideological transition, I hope to offer some initial conclusions as to neo-Ottomanism’s broader implications for Turkey. ©Copyright by Sera D. Kinoğlu May 22, 2014 All Rights Reserved Neo-Ottoman Perspectives: Turkish Identity and Culinary Culture in a Sociopolitical Context by Sera D. Kinoğlu A THESIS submitted to Oregon State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Presented May 22, 2014 Commencement June 2014 Master of Arts thesis of Sera D. Kinoğlu presented on May 22, 2014. APPROVED: _________________________________________________________________ Major Professor, representing Applied Anthropology _________________________________________________________________ Director of the School of Language, Culture, and Society _________________________________________________________________ Dean of the Graduate School I understand that my thesis will become part of the permanent collection of Oregon State University libraries. My signature below authorizes release of my thesis to any reader upon request. _________________________________________________________________ Sera D. Kinoğlu, Author ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to express sincere appreciation to those who helped make this research possible. Thank you to my advisor, Dr. David McMurray, for his encouragement and guidance, particularly during the writing process. Thank you also to my committee member, Dr. Joan Gross, for her speedy assistance and guidance with my IRB preparation. And to committee member Dr. Nancy Rosenberger, for inspiring a new perspective on my research through her own work on cuisine and national identity. I owe special thanks to those in my cohort with whom many hours were spent discussing class, our theses, and grad life in general; and to the cohort that came before us, for your guidance throughout our first – sometimes terrifying – first year. Thank you to my supportive partner Garrett, for making dinner while I worked away and for helping me remain sane during fieldwork. Finally, and most importantly, to my parents, who were unwavering in their support and encouragement from day one. TABLE OF CONTENTS Page 1 Introduction......................................................................................................................1 1.1 Significance.......................................................................................................1 1.2 Organization of the Thesis ................................................................................3 2 Background and Context..................................................................................................5 2.1 Geographical Significance ................................................................................5 2.1.1 Istanbul as a Site of Research.................................................................5 2.1.2 Interview Venues....................................................................................7 2.2 Positionality: Family Dynamics and Personal Significance ......................7 2.3 Timing of Fieldwork .......................................................................................10 2.3.1 Gezi Park Protests ................................................................................10 2.3.2 Ramadan ...............................................................................................11 2.4 What is Neo-Ottomanism? ..............................................................................12 2.5 Conditions Contributing to Neo-Ottomanism .................................................14 2.5.1 Globalization ........................................................................................14 2.5.2 Changing Politics and Religiosity ........................................................15 2.5.3 Economic Success as a Nation and Rise of the Middle Class ..............16 2.5.4 Distance from the Ottoman Empire ......................................................17 2.5.5 Summation of Influences......................................................................17 2.6 Methodology...................................................................................................18 3 Literature Review...........................................................................................................21 3.1 Introduction.....................................................................................................21 3.2 Food and Consumer Culture ...........................................................................22 TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued) Page 3.3 Nationalism.....................................................................................................31 3.4 Ottomanism and its Legacy ............................................................................34 3.5 Conclusion ......................................................................................................40 4 Findings and Discussion: Identity and Politics in Istanbul ............................................41 4.1 Introduction.....................................................................................................41 4.2 Religiosity.......................................................................................................42 4.3 Class and Cosmopolitanism ............................................................................46 4.4 Nationalism and Politics .................................................................................49 4.5 Conclusion ......................................................................................................53 5 Findings and Discussion: Representations of the Ottoman ...........................................54 5.1 Introduction.....................................................................................................54 5.2 Popular Culture ...............................................................................................55 5.3 Culinary Culture..............................................................................................57 5.4 Exoticization of the Ottoman ..........................................................................63 5.5 Discourse Analysis of Ottoman Representations ............................................66 5.5.1 Review of Discourse Analysis Literature and the Turkish context ......66 5.5.2 Methodology ........................................................................................70 5.5.3 Analysis and Discussion.......................................................................71 5.6 Conclusion ......................................................................................................76 6 Findings and Discussion: Authenticity Through Historicism ........................................78 6.1 Introduction.....................................................................................................78 TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued) Page 6.2 Authentication of the Ottoman ........................................................................79 6.3 Reimagination Versus Reconstruction ............................................................84 6.4 Discourse of Authenticity ...............................................................................88 6.5 Conclusion ......................................................................................................89 7 Conclusion .....................................................................................................................91 7.1 Introduction.....................................................................................................91 7.2 The Ottoman Brand .........................................................................................91 7.3 What this Means for Turkey ...........................................................................93 7.4 Implications and Final Inferences ...................................................................93 Bibliography ....................................................................................................................99 LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page Figure 1: Blue Mosque (Sultan Ahmet Camii), built during the height of the Ottoman Empire ..................................................................................................................................6 Figure 2: Gas mask-adorned mannequins .........................................................................10 Figure