12182 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS June 15, 1989 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS AN ANALYSIS OF THE CURRENT China's Communist government, and that Communist Party and a member of the Po CRISIS IN THE PEOPLE'S RE the progress of the Chinese reform move litburo during most of this period. PUBLIC OF CHINA ment toward "liberalism" was irreversible. If And then, there was the famous Great nothing else good comes out of this tragedy Proletarian Cultural Revolution <1966- it will perhaps have a heuristic value, re 1976), the details of which we need not be HON. FLOYD SPENCE minding us that nothing in politics is irre labor here. The "wounded" literature of the OF SOUTH CAROLINA versible, especially the march toward West survivors of China's holocaust is well IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ern liberal democracy in a political system known, some of the personal accounts of like that of the People's Republic of China. this period having become best sellers in the Thursday, June 15, 1989 In fact, the spectacle of the Chinese gov United States. Deng himself became a Mr. SPENCE. Mr. Speaker, in the wake of ernment engaging in the "wanton slaugh victim of the Cultural revolution, purged the tragic and suppressive actions taken by ter" of its own people, to quote a distin and branded a "capitalist roader." His son the Government of China, I would like to guished member of the U.S. Congress in de was thrown out of a window at Beijing Uni share with my colleagues an editorial written scribing the use of the Army against the versity and paralyzed for life. by a noted professor of government and inter students, is really nothing new. Over the years, then, the record of gov If we look back to 1951, for example, the ernment violence against the Chinese national studies at the University of South first year in which the new Communist gov people is a rather substantial one. Carolina, an exceptional institution located in ernment had consolidated complete control During this time the factional strife my congressional district. Prof. James T. over the Mainland, Hainan Island and within the Communist leadership has not Myers has been a professor of East Asian af Tibet, the government launched what can been between "liberals" and "conservatives" fairs at the university for the past 20 years. In only fairly be described as a year-long reign in the Western sense, or between "hard this piece, entitled "Whither China?" Dr. of revolutionary terror. The campaign was liners" and those who advocated "human Myers illustrates the realities of the Beijing called "Suppression of Counterrevolutionar rights," but between those more willing to crisis by bringing the student riots into histori ies." The precise human toll of this cam take risks to make the inefficient Marxist paign is impossible to calculate, but respon system work more efficiently and those cal perspective. He reminds his readers that sible scholars estimate the numbers of more comfortable with the security of the "democracy" was not on the verge of becom deaths in the hundreds of thousands, and inefficient status quo. Deng has been among ing the new ideological basis for the Govern perhaps in the millions. The Land Reform the risk takers, but it has been a mistake to ment in China; nor was it the principal catalyst Movement was taking place at the same regard him as a "liberal" in the Western for the turmoil. Dr. Myers reascertains that time with the bloody and violent e This "bullet" symbol identifies statements or insertions which are not spoken by a Member of the Senate on the floor. Matter set in this typeface indicates words inserted or appended, rather than spoken, by a Member of the House on the floor. June 15, 1989 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 12183 fluid and volitile as that which exists in former general counsel of the Senate Appro of our country. Instead, I saw myself as a China today. Several points, however, are priations Committee, so that it may be shared schoolboy again-a student to a teacher who worth remembering. with the other Members of this body. had the marvelous ability of being able to There is no effective opposition to com consider the problems of the present within munist rule in China. There is, to be sure, THE LAST SCHOOLBOY the context of the solutions of the past. The widespread popular discontent, unease, mal Many years ago when I first read James critical problem this year of adequate ap aise, call it what you will, but such "opposi Hilton's classic, "Goodbye, Mr. Chips," I propriations for a future manned space sta tion" is atomized. There is no focus, no lead could not know that one day I would find tion reminded him of President Kennedy's ership, no structure, no institutional sup myself in the role of that novel's last school request to him many years ago for assist port for the opposition. Suppose the "hard boy. Perhaps this is because when life imi ance in getting sufficient funds from the liners" Deng Xiaoping and Li Peng should tates art, it often does so in subtle ways. For committee to support the new president's be ousted, who would replace them? Deng me, this will happen at year's end with the announced goal of putting a man on the and Li, after all, are last year's "reformers," departure of the senior senator from Missis moon before the end of that decade. Simi and Deng was cited as Time Magazine's sippi-John C. Stennis-chairman of the larly, President Reagan's recent visit to the "Man of the Year" for leading his country Appropriations Committee and President Soviet Union to conclude the INF Treaty toward capitalism. There are no philosopher Pro Tempore of the Senate. When he final ly does leave this institution which he so with representatives of that "evil empire" kings waiting in the wings, only Communist reminded John Stennis of when President Party bureaucrats who have spent a lifetime loves and where he is in turn revered by all, he will undoubtedly do so in the same Nixon first sought his advice on a secret maneuvering their way to the top of the plan to visit China and the repercussions Party hierarchy. steady way he has served it for almost 42 years and under eight presidents: with quite which might result if Nixon were to try and In addition, the P.L.A. has an enormous open relations with a country which he had stake in seeing that China does not frag grace, unflinching modesty and serene gen tility. so bitterly denounced over the years. When ment and drift into anarchy. It is not entire Senator Stennis informed the president ly unlikely that the army will bury its dif John Stennis was born when the century was new-in 1901- and as our nation now that he supported the secret overture, ferences as they did during the Cultural Nixon asked: "But will you support me on Revolution and restore order and at least stands on the threshold of the last decade the appearance of a normally functioning of this long century, he will return to his be the Senate floor if I fail?" John Stennis re society. The current situation cannot persist loved Mississippi from where he was first plied, "Yes I will, Mr. President." There is for much longer with public tranfportation sent to the Senate in 1947. He will leave in Senator John Stennis a deep reverence paralyzed, food deliveries to many cities in behind a legacy which is almost unique: a for the office of the presidency surpassed terrupted or stopped, and essential services senatorial career that spans one-fifth of the only by his love for the Constitution. Presi shut down because no one is going to work. republic's history, including our country's dents come and go, but the office, like the It is, of course, also possible that civil war emergency after World War II as a super Constitution, remains and must be protect will break out in China, though this seems power. In this respect, and as it was once re ed. Perhaps because he never aspired to the the less likely outcome of what is essentially marked of Dean Acheson, it may be said of office, but memorized every word of the doc an intra-Party power struggle at the John Stennis that he, too, was "present at ument, that the Constitution remains para moment. Indeed, we should probably not be the creation." mount. surprised if, a year from today, the govern I came to know this great and gentle man I once raised the notion of his writing a ment of China looks much like it did before in the twilight of his career when he chose book about all that he had seen, learned, the student demonstrations, with a Central me to serve as general counsel to the Senate and been privy to over the course of his Committee and a Politburo run by most of Appropriations Committee. At 85, he had career-of his first meeting with President the same people, and Chairman Mao's por just assumed the chairmanship of one of Harry Truman, of his long friendship with trait still in its place over the Gate of Heav the most powerful committees in the Lyndon Johnson, of his relationships with enly Peace. Senate, and at 42 I was being offered a job the 400 senators with whom he had served. The problems symbolized by the student that most lawyers could only dream about. "No," he said, "I don't think there would be demonstrations in Beijing are long-term The Chairman counseled me that first much interest in such a book." And when I morning on the duties and responsibilties persisted over the course of several weeks, problems which are not susceptible to short that would be mine and then spoke in rever term solutions. It is true that we are wit even giving him a short chronology of the ent fashion of the great men he had known major events of the past 40 years, explain nessing history in the making, that China and served with over the course of his 40 will never be the same, even that this may ing that there would indeed be a large audi years in the Senate. None occupied a higher ence of scholars, historians, politicians and be the end of Communist rule in China, but place in his pantheon of heroes than Dick the culmination of these events is not likely others who would benefit from his perspec Russell-the legendary senator from Geor tive on these events, he would smile, sitting to be sudden and dramatic. The May 4, 1919 gia who many years before had also been Movement may have marked the birth of there in his wheelchair, blue eyes twinkling, chairman of the Appropriations Committee and reply again and again, "No, I have no modern China, but it was a decade before and who had taken under his wing the the impact of this movement was seen in young John Stennis. Whenever he spoke of lessons to teach." the political life of the nation. Russell, who died in 1973, it was as if his Of course, he was wrong. Or perhaps he Many of the problems which the students mentor were still present and he, John understood better than I that what I hoped and intellectuals of 1919 were responding to Stennis, still had so much to learn. he would spell out were the traits he has had been around since the 1890s. They Over the following weeks and months as come to embody for his colleagues and sought the appropriate political formula for we came to know each other, and our daily which cannot really be taught except by ex China's successful entry into the modern conversations ranged over the numerous ample. Senator J. Bennett Johnston of Lou world. Those who believed that Communist and varied issues before the committee, a isiana has said that John Stennis is a man rule provided this formula have been proven bridge was slowly built between the years who "defines the word integrity." Senator wrong. For the Chinese students and intel that separated us. In discussing military Ted Stevens of Alaska has called him "an lectuals of the 1990s, like their counterparts matters, if I strayed into remembering my inspiration to new senators for four dec of a century ago, their quest will be neither own wartime experience as a young naval ades." Senator John Warner has likened quick nor easy. officer in Vietnam or my father's service in him to a "second father." Senator Sam World War II, he remembered and spoke of Nunn has declared that "no higher honor his uncle who fought and died at Gettys has come my way than serving in the THE LAST SCHOOLBOY burg. If our conversation turned to politics United States Senate with John Stennis." where my earliest recollections were of the Senator Mark Hatfield, the ranking Repub HON. IKE SKELTON Kennedy-Nixon debates, he remembered lican on the Appropriations Committee and OF MISSOURI with clarity his first presidential election one of the Chairman's closest friends, will IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES which involved Woodrow Wilson. He always show you that on the wall of his inner office considered himself a Woodrow Wilson Dem are only family pictures, except for one Thursday, June 15, 1989 ocrat, and so informed President Reagan that of John Stennis. Perhaps for all of Mr. SKELTON. Mr. Speaker, recently I had when first they met in 1981. The new Presi these qualities and so much more, President the opportunity to read a short item about the dent's reply was immediate: "That's what I Reagan has announced that as an expres am!" And so the bond was forged with yet sion of the nation's gratitude for his years now-retired Senator from Mississippi, John C. another chief executive. of public service, the Navy's next aircraft Stennis. He was in many ways an inspiration I cannot remember when it first dawned carrier would be named in his honor and to us all. I submit this writing to the CONGRES on me that I was slowly becoming the privi christened the USS John C. Stennis 29-059 0 -90- 19 (Pt. 9) 12212 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS June 15, 1989 "of the people, by the people, and for the My amendments defeated at the Banking SECRETARY OF STATE BAKER'S people" to ignore the people-that is, until we Committee gave the Treasury an incentive to MIDEAST POLICY SPEECH: have to find someone to pay the bill. The sell the bonds to the U.S. public first by limit "EMINENTLY FAIR" American taxpayer did not cause the savings ing to 10 percent the amount foreign creditors and loan crisis. Yet the Bush administration could purchase in the first 18 months of the HON. HOWARD WOLPE legislation will cost the taxpayer a minimum of bond offering. I also proposed a report back $150 billion over the next 30 years to fund an to Congress on which foreign creditors buy OF MICHIGAN "off budget" bond financing scheme to re these bonds and to whom Americans thus IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES solve troubled thrifts. Some estimate the cost owe principal and interest. Americans have a Thursday, June 15, 1989 to the taxpayers could rise as high as $300 right to know to whom our financial system is billion depending on what happens to interest indebted. Mr. WOLPE. Mr. Speaker, Israel and the rates and the health of savings and loan insti Finally, in any acceptable solution to the Palestinians have been engulfed for over 18 tutions in the future. S&L crisis, reinvestment must take place in months in the turmoil and challenges posed In fact, the Bush administration bond pro communities which have faced lending dis by the uprising, known as the intifada, in the posal is the biggest tax increase in recent crimination. It is a pathetic commentary on occupied territories. These are events of his memory that will begin kicking in in 1991, at a those who steered the S&L industry down this torical significance and great human anguish. rate of $4 billion per year for 30 years to pay dead-end path that deposits flowed out of The intifada reflects the truth that the status the interest costs on the new bonds issued. communities that were red-lined in order to quo in the West Bank and Gaza that has pre Where will the annual $4 billion come from to pay for risky investments made far from home vailed since 1967 can no longer endure pay the interest on the bonds? Where will the by institutions that manipulated small deposi even though these territories were thrust upon $120 billion in interest over 30 years come tors' funds. It is sad public policy that the Israel, against her will, in a war of aggression from? Whose taxes will be raised to make Banking Committee did not pass the Gonza initiated by the combined military might of th these payments? Which budget accounts will lez/Kennedy amendments to strengthen the Arab world. The intifada demonstrates that the be short changed as a result-education, Community Reinvestment Act and the Home legitimate political aspirations of the Palestin health care, veterans, defense? No one in the Mortgage Disclosure Act to make restitution to ians must be accommodated. But just as executive branch wants to answer these ques those who have been discriminated against. clearly it shows there is only one road to tions. I believe that the enforcement provisions of peace: through a cessation of the violence; Incredibly, this bond scheme-which is ac this legislation go a long way to assure that direct, face-to-face negotiations, without con tually a hidden tax-is being done in the name this thrift debacle will never occur again. But ditions, between Palestinian representatives of fiscal responsibility-that is to meet in solving the present crisis, I believe this leg and Israel; and the forging together of a future Gramm-Rudman-Hollings budget targets. Yet islation failed miserably in proposing a fair fi that will let Israelis and Palestinians live with if Congress would put the bailout on-budget nancing mechanism to give American taxpay each other in peace. and pay for it over the next 3 years, it would ers something for their money-namely, fair In the wake of these momentous develop be three times less expensive than the Bush ness. That is why I must vote against this leg ments, two important and positive initiatives plan and the cost to the taxpayer would be islation. have emerged. First, the PLO has met the cut by 300 percent. This is why I support both conditions established by successive Presi the Ways and Means Committee amendment dents regarding the recognition of Israel and to place the bailout on-budget and the La SRI LANKA GOVERNMENT the renunciation of terrorism-and on that Falce amendment to force the Congress to basis, a dialog has begun between the United pay for the bailout annually on a pay-as-you States and the PLO. It is imperative, at each go basis. HON. BOB CARR and every session with the PLO, that we test If the bailout is placed on-budget, Congress OF MICHIGAN the intentions of the PLO's leadership, mem and the President should negotiate and use a IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES bers and supporters, and hold the PLO strictly process similar to what was done on the accountable for both its rhetoric and actions. recent budget agreement to make those re Thursday, June 15, 1989 The dialog that has begun can just as easily sponsible for this debacle pay for it. The aver Mr. CARR. Mr. Speaker, as you know, the be suspended, and the PLO should not doubt age taxpayer is not guilty. States in certain re Government of Sri Lanka is fighting a guerrilla for a moment our resolve that terrorism gions of our Nation that permitted their State movement of Tamil nationalists. The war is against Israel, its people, and its armed forces chartered institutions to engage in excessively producing human rights violations that are of will not be tolerated. Indeed, I have joined in risky activities must be made to pay their fair great concern worldwide. The case of George sponsoring legislation that requires the Secre share. The financial services industry, financial Alexis is one such violation. tary of State to regularly ascertain PLO com intermediaries and certain individuals that took On September 8, 1988, George Alexis, a pliance with the policies and conditions gov advantage of high interest rate, brokered de 30-year-old carpenter, was arrested in Sri erning the dialog with the PLO. posits also should pay their fair share of the Lanka by officials of the Indian Peace Keeping Second, the Government of Israel has bailout. Special taxes could be assessed on Force. He was taken to the Pandeteruppu come forward with a far-reaching and just pro these groups for a limited time period to help camp. Camp officials at first refused Alexis' posal for elections to be held in the territories fund the bailout. relatives entry, then told them that Alexis had to select bona fide representatives of the Pal If the Bush administration off-budget tax been released. The camp commander showed estinians to enter negotiations with Israel over scheme must be used, the interest payments the family Alexis' thumb-print on the release their future. Many details of this proposal need on the bonds should at least be structured to document. The family pointed out that Alexis to be resolved. But this courageous initiative is benefit the American taxpayer. The operative can read and would have signed his name, a necessary first step if any progress is to be question should be: How can the bond offer and that a curfew was in effect at the time of made. The issues are too difficult, and the po ing be structured to benefit the American Alexis' supposed release. He has not been litical gulf too broad, for the tabling of sweep public which will pay the tab for this "debacle seen since. ing proposals by either side. But beginning a of deregulation with lax examination?" My George Alexis is one of 700 civilians who framework in which all issues can be dis amendment adopted in the Banking Commit have been disappeared in recent years by the cussed is essential. The Palestinians have a tee to lower the face value of bonds sold to security forces in Sri Lanka. Even though the choice: riots or ballots. They have been $1,000 (from the Bush proposal of minimum Government is fighting the Tamil insurgent heard-in Israel and around the world. It is face value $1 0,000) is one step to make the movement, the disappearance of civilians is time to talk. bond offering more available to our citizens. wrong. I call on the Sri Lankan Government to Until diplomacy is underway, however, the But why should U.S. taxpayers pay billions of find Alexis and the others who have disap violence of the intifada, and Israel's response dollars in interest payments over 30 years to peared. They should be either charged and to it, continues. So many children-far too foreign investors-who are the most likely given fair trials or unconditionally released. Sri many children-have been killed by the appli buyers of these bonds-when the American Lanka must end this violation of human rights cation of lethal force by the Israeli Army. This taxpayer is being asked to fund the bailout? now. is an offense to moral sensibility, and it must June 15, 1989 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 12213 be stopped. The violence has also hardened of existing U.S. policy with respect to the and need a settlement that will make it pos Israeli attitudes generally, with Israeli settlers territories and which continues to value Is sible for Israel, its neighbors and the Pales taking the law into their own hands, and im raeli security as among its highest priorities. tinians to live in peace and security, with posing cruel vigilante justice, often on inno Some observers have overlooked the fact human rights secured for all. that the demands Secretary Baker has The American Jewish Committee protects cents. Controls on the movement of Palestini made on the Palestinians are considerably the rights and freedoms of Jews the world an workers, and the issuance of identification more rigorous than those made on Israel. over; combats bigotry and anti-Semitism; cards, have been imposed-practices that He called on the Palestinians to end the in promotes human rights for all; works for smack of the reprehensible policies of other tifade violence, to "renounce the policy of the security of Israel and deepened under regimes. phases," to amend the covenant, to accept standing between Americans and Israelis; At the same time, over 40 Palestinians have the current Israeli peace initiative, to enter defends democratic values and seeks their been murdered as "collaborationists" with direct, face-to-face negotiations with Israel, realization in American public policy; en and to accept a transitional period of auton hances the creative vitality of the Jewish Israel-a chilling message of intimidation and omy prior to a final settlement, which will fear that undercuts the hopes of moderate Is people. Founded in 1906, it is the pioneer "mean full recognition of Israel as a neigh human-relations agency in the U.S. raelis and Palestinians alike. bor and partner in trade and in human con More and more, the territories are taking on tact." He also urged the Arabs to end the the raw character of Palestine in the 1920's economic boycott, to "stop the challenges to COMMENT BY RABBI ALEXANDER M. and 1930's-venues of ethnic warfare and Israel's standing in international organiza SCHINDLER, PRESIDENT, UNION OF AMERICAN strife. tions," and to "repudiate the odious line HEBREW CONGREGATIONS
<<